On August 14, 2020 a
Trial Materials
was filed
involving a dispute between
Stephens, Donnetta,
and
Crown Ace Hardware,
Does 1 Through 100 Inclusive,
Monsato Company,
Wilbur-Ellis Company, Llc,
Wilbur-Ellis Nutrition, Llc,
for Product Liability Unlimited
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
F I L E D
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
CASE # cnv332104ao1 CASE NAME: DONNETTA STEPHENS -v- MONSANTo cgk’fig‘égfifififéfifiéfigo
MAR 01 2022
SUPERIOR COURT 0F CALIFORNIA, COUNTY 0F SAN BERNAngo
Case; Clvsez1o4eo1 Judge:
Clerk:
EXHIBIT LIST
GILBERT OCHOA
JMEDINA A. HERNANDEZ / s. PRATT / w. BLANCHARD
/
BY
m3»
3%gm
SQHQQ
EPUTY
Year: Reporter: S.AUSTIN/R.ALLENIK.MORRow
Plaintiff Counsel: TRAMMEL / KIESEL / SHAPIRO / PALMER
Dept: DefendantCounseI: WILLIAMSIPOPKIN/CACHAN/LEDINGHAM
Case Tine: [DONETTA STEPHENS -v- MONSANTO
N0. n A c J ID Data Evid.oate EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION
'
Verified
22 D D D NOT USED UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
(MEMORANDUM 09/29/1982)
\/
D D D
32 8/31/2021 EPATOXICOLOGY BRANCH/ROUNDUP(02/22/1985)
/
35 D D D NOTUSED UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
(MEMORANDUM 03/04/1985)) \/
37 D D D Nowseo B:0/DYNAMICSINC.-LETTER DATED 04/03/1985
DEPT. 0F MEDICINE
/
38 D D D NOTUSED 8. ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH
(04/03/1985) \/
D D
42 El NOTUSED ROUNDUP s.A.P.MEETING,DATE08/20/1985
/
D D D
44 9/22/2021 USEPAMEMORANDUM(12/04/1985)
/
D D D REDACTED LETTER FROM MARVIN KUSCHNER.
-
5° NOT USED M.D.,
DATED 02/15/1986 /
52 D D D NOT USED GLYPHOSATE REREGISTRATION STANDARmoe/ze/wes) /
D D D
71 9/1/2021 us EPAARCHIVE DOCUMENT(10/30/1991)
GLYPHOSATE CENTRIFUGE FEED (DATE PREPARED
/
83 D D D NOTUSED
01/16/1995) \/
87 D D 1:] Nowseo EMAIL FROM DONNAFARMER DATED12/29/1998 V-
89 D D D NOTUSED "OFFICIAL REQUEST BY ITALIAN GOVERNMENT" (
(M0NGLY01312107)(EX.89) V
D D "OFFICIAL REQUEST BY ITALIAN GOVERNMENT“ '
9° E] NOT USED
(M0NGLY01312107)(EX.90) /
91 D E] D 10/6/2021 MONSANTo TELEFAx TRANSMITrAL SHEET(15/oz/1999)
/
94 D El D NOTUSED REVIEW 0FzHARDELL L.ERIKSSON M.(o4/14/1999)
\/
95 D El D 9/21/2021 EMAIL FROM MARKA.MARTENS(04/19/1999)
/
101 D D D 9/22/2021 EMAIL FROM THOMAS B.KLEv0RN(06/o1/1999)
\/
107 D Cl D NOTUSED EMAILFROM WILLIAM HEYDENS(os/21/99)
\/
Page 1 or 26
I *u
CA E Clvséz104ao1 CASE NAME: DONNETTA STEPHENs-v-MONSANTO
7fA a 5
D El D
111
D U
9/22/2021 EMAIL FROM WILLIAM HEYDENS(o7/30/1999)
/
1‘15
El 9/22/2021 EMAIL FROMALANWILSON(09/02/1999)
/
D D
119 El 9/22/2021 EMAIL FROMWILLIAM HEYDENS(09/15/1999)
/
D D
120 E] 9/22/2021 EMAIL FROM HEYDENS(09/16/1999)
/
D D D
123 NOTUSED EMAIL FROMJOHN F.ACQUALVELLA(11/03/1999)
/
142 El D D NOTUSED EMAILFROM LISA DRAKE(05/26/2000)
/
158 D D D 10/5/2021 EMAILFROMWILLIAMHEYDENS(02/19/2001)
‘/
173 D El D 9/22/2021 EMAILFROM DONNAFARMER(11/29/2oo1)
\/
181 D D D 9/22/2021 EMAIL FROM RICHARD GARNETr(04/05/2002) \/'(
a a a Examsasmgross'DEMWW f
189 E] D D NOTUSED ngglggggNAND FOODRESEARCH FAXMESSAGE V,
195 D D D 10/14/2021 EMAIL FROM RICHARDGARNETT(02/10/2003) /
200 D D E] NOTUSED TNo REPORTV4478<04IOQI2003) v/
209 D D D NOTUSED EMAIL FROMJOHN F.ACQUAVELLA(09/02/2oos)
\/
212 D [Z] E] 9/22/2021 EMAILFROM DONNAFARMER(11/24/2ooa)
/
262 D D D NOT USED
EggnazafiofifigggéooFF-fcfigzolSC/ESTIGATI0N3 x/
272 D D [j 9/22/2021 EMAIL FROM DANIELGOLDSTEIN(05/22/2008)
/
281 D D D NOTUSED EMAIL FROM CHARLES HEALY(08/19/2008)
/
286 D D D NOT USED EMAIL FROM DAVID SALTMIRAS(09/12/2008) /
287 D [:1 E] 9/22/2021 REDACTED EMAIL FROM DONNAFARMERmmM/zoos)
\/
325 D D D 9/22/2021 EMAILFROM DAVID SALTMIRAsme/m/zooe)
J
327 D D D 9/22/2021 EMAILFROM DONNAFARMER(09/21/2009)
/
DONNA FARMERWITH ATTACHMENT
362 D D D 10/4/2021 EngfilsL/foiom
/
CONFIDENTIAL-PRODUCEDSUBJECTTO PROTECTION
459 D D D NOTUSED
ORDER (REDACTED) (MONGLY03293245-R) \/
Page 2 of 28
Document Filed Date
March 01, 2022
Case Filing Date
August 14, 2020
Category
Product Liability Unlimited
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
F I L E D SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA CASE # cnv332104ao1 CASE NAME: DONNETTA STEPHENS -v- MONSANTo cgk’fig‘égfifififéfifiéfigo MAR 01 2022 SUPERIOR COURT 0F CALIFORNIA, COUNTY 0F SAN BERNAngo Case; Clvsez1o4eo1 Judge: Clerk: EXHIBIT LIST GILBERT OCHOA JMEDINA A. HERNANDEZ / s. PRATT / w. BLANCHARD / BY m3» 3%gm SQHQQ EPUTY Year: Reporter: S.AUSTIN/R.ALLENIK.MORRow Plaintiff Counsel: TRAMMEL / KIESEL / SHAPIRO / PALMER Dept: DefendantCounseI: WILLIAMSIPOPKIN/CACHAN/LEDINGHAM Case Tine: [DONETTA STEPHENS -v- MONSANTO N0. n A c J ID Data Evid.oate EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION ' Verified 22 D D D NOT USED UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION (MEMORANDUM 09/29/1982) \/ D D D 32 8/31/2021 EPATOXICOLOGY BRANCH/ROUNDUP(02/22/1985) / 35 D D D NOTUSED UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION (MEMORANDUM 03/04/1985)) \/ 37 D D D Nowseo B:0/DYNAMICSINC.-LETTER DATED 04/03/1985 DEPT. 0F MEDICINE / 38 D D D NOTUSED 8. ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH (04/03/1985) \/ D D 42 El NOTUSED ROUNDUP s.A.P.MEETING,DATE08/20/1985 / D D D 44 9/22/2021 USEPAMEMORANDUM(12/04/1985) / D D D REDACTED LETTER FROM MARVIN KUSCHNER. - 5° NOT USED M.D., DATED 02/15/1986 / 52 D D D NOT USED GLYPHOSATE REREGISTRATION STANDARmoe/ze/wes) / D D D 71 9/1/2021 us EPAARCHIVE DOCUMENT(10/30/1991) GLYPHOSATE CENTRIFUGE FEED (DATE PREPARED / 83 D D D NOTUSED 01/16/1995) \/ 87 D D 1:] Nowseo EMAIL FROM DONNAFARMER DATED12/29/1998 V- 89 D D D NOTUSED "OFFICIAL REQUEST BY ITALIAN GOVERNMENT" ( (M0NGLY01312107)(EX.89) V D D "OFFICIAL REQUEST BY ITALIAN GOVERNMENT“ ' 9° E] NOT USED (M0NGLY01312107)(EX.90) / 91 D E] D 10/6/2021 MONSANTo TELEFAx TRANSMITrAL SHEET(15/oz/1999) / 94 D El D NOTUSED REVIEW 0FzHARDELL L.ERIKSSON M.(o4/14/1999) \/ 95 D El D 9/21/2021 EMAIL FROM MARKA.MARTENS(04/19/1999) / 101 D D D 9/22/2021 EMAIL FROM THOMAS B.KLEv0RN(06/o1/1999) \/ 107 D Cl D NOTUSED EMAILFROM WILLIAM HEYDENS(os/21/99) \/ Page 1 or 26 I *u CA E Clvséz104ao1 CASE NAME: DONNETTA STEPHENs-v-MONSANTO 7fA a 5 D El D 111 D U 9/22/2021 EMAIL FROM WILLIAM HEYDENS(o7/30/1999) / 1‘15 El 9/22/2021 EMAIL FROMALANWILSON(09/02/1999) / D D 119 El 9/22/2021 EMAIL FROMWILLIAM HEYDENS(09/15/1999) / D D 120 E] 9/22/2021 EMAIL FROM HEYDENS(09/16/1999) / D D D 123 NOTUSED EMAIL FROMJOHN F.ACQUALVELLA(11/03/1999) / 142 El D D NOTUSED EMAILFROM LISA DRAKE(05/26/2000) / 158 D D D 10/5/2021 EMAILFROMWILLIAMHEYDENS(02/19/2001) ‘/ 173 D El D 9/22/2021 EMAILFROM DONNAFARMER(11/29/2oo1) \/ 181 D D D 9/22/2021 EMAIL FROM RICHARD GARNETr(04/05/2002) \/'( a a a Examsasmgross'DEMWW f 189 E] D D NOTUSED ngglggggNAND FOODRESEARCH FAXMESSAGE V, 195 D D D 10/14/2021 EMAIL FROM RICHARDGARNETT(02/10/2003) / 200 D D E] NOTUSED TNo REPORTV4478<04IOQI2003) v/ 209 D D D NOTUSED EMAIL FROMJOHN F.ACQUAVELLA(09/02/2oos) \/ 212 D [Z] E] 9/22/2021 EMAILFROM DONNAFARMER(11/24/2ooa) / 262 D D D NOT USED EggnazafiofifigggéooFF-fcfigzolSC/ESTIGATI0N3 x/ 272 D D [j 9/22/2021 EMAIL FROM DANIELGOLDSTEIN(05/22/2008) / 281 D D D NOTUSED EMAIL FROM CHARLES HEALY(08/19/2008) / 286 D D D NOT USED EMAIL FROM DAVID SALTMIRAS(09/12/2008) / 287 D [:1 E] 9/22/2021 REDACTED EMAIL FROM DONNAFARMERmmM/zoos) \/ 325 D D D 9/22/2021 EMAILFROM DAVID SALTMIRAsme/m/zooe) J 327 D D D 9/22/2021 EMAILFROM DONNAFARMER(09/21/2009) / DONNA FARMERWITH ATTACHMENT 362 D D D 10/4/2021 EngfilsL/foiom / CONFIDENTIAL-PRODUCEDSUBJECTTO PROTECTION 459 D D D NOTUSED ORDER (REDACTED) (MONGLY03293245-R) \/ Page 2 of 28