Motion-Secondary: Andrea Spears vs. Health Net of California Inc

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                TIMOTHY J. LONG (STATE BAR NO. 137591)
     tjlong@orrick.com
2    NICHOLAS J. HORTON (STATE BAR NO. 289417)                                JAN 3 0 2019
     nhorton@orrick.com
3    AVALON JOHNSON FITZGERALD (STATE BAR NO. 2881^'^y:
     afitzgerald@orrick.com
4    ORRICK, HERRINGTON & SUTCLIFFE LLP
     400 Capitol Mall. Suite 3000
5    Sacramento, CA 95814-4497
     Telephone:     +1916 447 8299
6    Facsimile:     +1 916 329 4900
7    Attorneys for Defendant
     HEALTH NET OF CALIFORNIA. INC.
 8
                            SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
9
                                         COUNTY OF SACRAMENTO
10
     ANDREA SPEARS, an individual, on behalf             Consolidated Case No. 34-2017-00210560-
11   of herself and on behalf of all persons similarly   CU-OE-GDS
     situated.
12                      Plaintiff,                       DECLARATION OF NICHOLAS J .
                                                         HORTON IN SUPPORT OF
13            V.                                         DEFENDANT HEALTH NET OF
                                                         CALIFORNIA, INC.'S REPLY TO
14   HEALTH NET OF CALIFORNIA, INC., a                   RENEWED MOTION FOR SUMMARY
     California Corporation; and Does I through 50,      ADJUDICATION
15   inclusive.
                                                         Date:       February 4, 2019
16                         Defendants.                   Time:       9:00 a.m.
                                                         Dept:       54
17
                                                         Reservation No.:   2380178
18
                                                         Complaint Filed:  April 5, 2017
19                                                       FAC Filed:        June 29, 2017
                                                         Consolidated Complaint Filed: Dec. 21, 2017
20
                                                         Complaint Filed:   August I , 2017
21   TOMAS R. ARANA, on behalf of himself, all
     others similarly situated.
22
                           Plaintiff,
23
              V.
24
     HEALTH NET OF CALIFORNIA, INC., a
25   California corporation; and DOES 1-50,
     inclusive,
26
                           Defendant.
27

28


                   DECLARATION OF NICHOLAS J. HORTON IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT'S REPLY TO
                               RENEWED MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION
     4158-3090-7162
 1          1, Nicholas J. Horton, declare as follows:

2           1.      I am an attorney duly admitted to practice before the courts ofthe State of

3    California and an associate in the law firm of Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, attorneys of

4    record for Defendant Health Net of California, Inc. ("HNCA"). I make this declaration on

5    personal knowledge and, if sworn as a witness, could competently testify to the following facts

6    except where otherwise indicated.

7           2.      On December 19, 2018, Plaintiff Andrea Spears deposed Diane Rodes in her
8    individual capacity in this matter. Ms. Rodes was separately deposed on May 2, 2018 as the
9    person most knowledgeable regarding 36 topics related to various policies. She was not
10   designated as the person most knowledgeable on the benefits plan at issue, nor have Plaintiffs
11   sought to depose such a witness. A true and correct copy of relevant portions ofthe transcript of
12   Ms. Rodes' December 19, 2018, deposition is attached hereto as Exhibit A.
13          3.      On January 9, 2019, Spears deposed Debbie Colia in this matter. A true and
14   correct copy of relevant portions of the transcript of Ms. Colia's deposition is attached hereto as
15   Exhibit B.
16          4.      On January 8, 2019, Spears deposed Kelly Sarabia in this matter. A true and
17   correct copy of the relevant portions of the transcript of Ms. Sarabia's deposition is attached
18   hereto as Exhibit C.
19          I declare under the penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California and that the
20   foregoing is true and correct. Executed this 30"^ day of January, 2019, at Sacramento, Califomia.
21
22
                                                                                     .FTDRTON
23
24
25
26
27
28


                DECLARATION OF NICHOLAS J. HORTON IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT'S REPLY TO
                            RENEWED MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION
     4158-3090-7162
EXHIBIT A
                   'jitjB>: tcoj4 .-Titc. oousflnr ojT' i;i%cujf««wra;'



                                               I




      P>4




                .vicjjo.cjLrt,




I • t.''    I




           ^1




                                                                          EXHIBIT A
       a ' i m f^LCes-Qman\Ut»' I^>i'l!U;i6

        outlines Uie c&£«^t^ia'^e'tyle b«iie£i%'j^an .
 .2.
  3
  4 17 .of, ssii>ii^^-t              .         J ysyt ^ o ^ p t ^ o n .af:. r^s^;




 .8


10 i ka -pax^gmpp 17 •4i--i^i5Tiiir- #ai¥re.M'^A' "j^fiit^^ V:is?s''*x^, ^yii^gi



U.



              Mil WHBRjBBif
u



li':




Mi'


                                         Et^SS:cf^ Solutions Bg8IS5106m
                                                                                    EXHIBIT A
      •CfSdS Recess.UeMHilkf.iaj    Ap,\D


       03£etQt^»''gtvl9              bensfi-fe-pl^-.      3C' i-f t;;tea-teJ''£-'-(wtt-a-t your


 3 be B&ioiblo for bhs yiex Oolla^^ and the iia£^kj&rlu'^k,'vi&




       y^a-vlBt„ iii ,that: ;oprgtect?;




10             ,^1       ^&dd! t^jiiial:. miiit.sipijm       clg'iug,. laafc. that:, lai
        jbhjft,;.^'digax.                                        ^. 0<:»tzsmx:f'
12
l\
t€     aBpeictg.




is-

       '•th6-.Be'dii^3. ^E^ag£••Doli•^^^;, £G£-^i.'»a»,.- rr» 'bxrife'-:-. ha .xei^liia




       •liage ,ta                  ai:?toa,:r"i% jpaoeaiigriibaiiaC'ima*-atm^&~ t3a&. nJaaif"
                                                                                                EXHIBIT A
       ! V043 litave ifctfi be ^an s>in>aloveg.               yaau         bach tec the way


 •1     deained ifcbaa               aamafcalnty y?iafe->& lyol part af fche plsa .

 4                      , ts^ jgQvit your .--           your iniig.s.tioo ftxrgug^ag-.
 5.' 'IMfc'N^d 'Kleic 'W4a.|yi^' -a^ -pars' -or^ tK'sfe- pl;aji> "ofe aoa .yog




.8'                      3--'itfc^actiialiy^-ii-^.ezi3y       ifc'-as--related't^.- fcfa'fe
       y>£fkrt,,'''^jti'"WygM,ta&ai.,,'fcc..::,.^^      .^^I..^a".j1!3fi8^,,a3i»^idh:gr:^^^^^   •
10,
11.
12
1|                        MR^^-, aQia!'cR9.ii...        loaeg-,.. aafit^ ..and -^^m>tireieLi\ •
14
.P,            *Q - - --yQU-carf -reapcottiiA
16


18;'

 : I
It-
               'f^\ Jz^ftttaj'iiM>ftOi^<^j:z^


•2i



                                                                                                EXHIBIT A
 3
 4:
 -5
          5X ISS. ^imHSBJEE:
      I

 4    i




10

ii.',
1^'




     •1

ir
18
1#


21-^


23




                               EXHIBIT A
 :2
 •3    o£ the plan thrpngli itesl^th Hah i tnc*^


-.5           ..Qi     GJsaiy-i    'And 3o •fhafc ,,;jpas. T— »»e" ictnds fjbni-
       ^e,aTtb .'l|eife-,af .'GflJXfara           aod, IHaaltto'^lfsk ? It^c ••fiaAi>.%ait^ ^,
 'l'
               A.      i 4ii»it 'it. kn^wi


m
it
1£

il:;
                                                                                  I




w
•is            ft'.        d o j i ' u £ B e L x y '%,uuw.'-

18     ^     /fit'.   -WJtsy-       3et^s-^1*% ^ge''2»lri»;lt?^                       -liafd.


mi



       '•teffljpitfvaefi-'af -atpal't^- Ifefe        -CaiJtfpjrihia ^''ilr.MX ^alw^ufe




                                                                                                EXHIBIT A
        CfMtta R£n ainil                    fc^th.,     Ik
 2: ^
 3'
                              ^loul/'fei .jto. p-royie .thft .yotj. L>^ere., fa.;,tii;lpajy?a<3i'

 I
         Hfel^ghii Wa.teb^cs^»_ a)r -vb&.fc^^r,              .vps»



 •7'



10 i


Hi:                A-         Ye».

It.;

 - -i


18 '
L9
StO .


f f•
23




                                            E^iS^f^ Solutions 8$ffiSSTC5Q5
                                                                                                    EXHIBIT A
 i. ' docuniartte      Misa^tes the g^qoj;^.              Mlsabat^^ ;pgl


                    ffHS   WITHSSST       X plan psrl^icip^riib i s i n the
      c&fBt^^A^ plait-. ^Tfb.afci' i - urbj^!^-          pl3,a.Sfliep.fts - -
 5. ,caffefcerl.-a.-'styi^bensg-ife i plan ^•


 7,




m
      ;      A;. ,jhjft .,..va4.,.a^3ilga^3'^tia^pai?x J-tt:..,ifehfef-.
12


14    caefa bisnMf i:t oif ^jf>j tftiiith elsawg .op -ag Kea ^Icoe .Walaa.




      ^feltj|fi*fcaa-'^nibid-v --'aca'-igijg'^i^'aa'^e-.abl'&'^t ttfesii'cialt
                               * ^ «ba,t iit —^^ nc^j^ ioJE art aXaTgiMe
'It


23.




                               B:^^iSfi^ Sc^Utlans Bg8IS5T05Q5
                                                                                 EXHIBIT A
      >.HD>F»£iiK=^F'EABSv« H E A L T H NETQF*^«UFOBl^^(A
      \2ianii tRwmOmanlUinf A^','2iy.\6

 I                                 r.PJ'.TTIPrrA'I'E: n r   RRPflRTJJfl

 2



 i     de^PcxcioA,          DJlftlE.             w*ue' «2Uly -afwrh < J%.-fne- iJt zm^tJtZif
^5



 T     .t£p titiaet .ajsfl ^}jL€ie-^hBr€^                                        ^,i   >• 'i -• j-'a-r. r;;,s

                                            r/' V---/!
                                    Ih         F O K T S K C3Utnr3f OV SU^i^CPAtOeOTQ




                I r e s e t s iP. K .i]H^PMW4^..,,^»l»;.it»«i^i£: !i?i ''bittSM»l-i
                [>1 JL'io,thHra.„jp±By.a^^^




                                                   'aBBajcz. 'anna-, cSjXiai,




I ' ,"-'rii
[ .v, ::v>v.|




••                                                                                      EXHIBIT B
        «1li>^>£^-'3PEABev»<,MeALT>^-NEJKOF%^rtklFC.^^

                        Mai l MOKMRS^JEi: .          Ko , I ,appA*aiafce tbac; C«agui©©l,
         sn<3 4<© wiil)        I ' l l 6€. §©t:tiy>g, to tjj*.t ooameat^ily.                    i
         joeb vant tfi BS^ a Cewmt^re sepa^t^^est^Dds^ iiz^fc amd
        "the5:.,:m''il           jba, i t .      But :!thA«3k'.YC:ii..


         a&pgy to Haaltb. a>et3Pc^ -to aind^tba tmtmtl ts I o£ tte
         •|J.Bn ip^t3i.e3.partta' ,TcSD,.jace..,'eiiqp3;g:yiBe^, .of' 5e^'t2i''„'ISe.i:'„t,o-
  •a. i 'Otit'l i£aritl''A u*'jatrv?




12       benef £t:at^o£ i h « pltan ipaiiiilsLipanJbfif?
                 iA... ' .CaD;',y|>'u. .^i^Jl^aiC fee, Mea'sioE,, 'pojiw'^m^oje,,?:


;l"5



ifi      :R^itb     'mt^'ci: C^Xiiorafslj^ ^Tn^'. • ^t^SiM^^^^"'




         lanioyiniftnfe Jtduc tite 'i?ait|ifiii£ ,ol!aiiB-.


         ilil€i V iHtfal..     tc- f;,r" i t ~      i^cHi^t bi'riq: - ©ajie ?


.2.5.


                                   &^S0riti^ Solutions SM'fiST OfiOS
                                                                                                    EXHIBIT B
 •3:   emtollmenb period.
 4




 '7
       '±n,a-i ^tB^loyBaft*?'''
                  •' tilllMi^\:        t»b3-«wjtl«ri'.,„ ' Vatf&ie' -^rciil^ • m^.i^<0'\^*
                    .THE' iftftgw • am. €rjDgugiiioii3 *
16                  TRS .WITflESS;- 3 ^ f»pjp«Pvai' a]f\tb'e'^aa^n^^^^


M      dmitoi^lll i*nci:SajBd't2lfe",xJtyee. fo^^'^Stae' vaxioas-'^iart*-^-a:*.!:
1-0
       BY MS, mumB^^r
              Q,.^ He'll .ofifcaM''^M^.¥e!3iMtb/%eE




                                  EcoScribe Solutions 888.651.0505
                                                                                             EXHIBIT B
  2    uXay:,,   Dia tb« i::o(isp6m,a'ti<)ti -and- Banefiitss


  4
  5.
  fi




•If,


i'i

14.


 .AbflL-liAd:: to.- be,, -kfipt: .tfmL.'ptim. -Ebr-tiifc.
        porpcBe fcbafc bbe accponfe yaa tat op £o>r'.                             a
        conuni^uallDg cief f ucds vQ?il3 r>ot                  ageygre^ la. a^y
        ojpaLnaqn'' yatb -.btb'ek-.- ^poj^g^ntgt      She -pacppbp- JP£' ^ccoc'Ptig-: ss'^
 fi     -tP•• foap accctiates- separate '•^roa^.-gthgtar vsejyiititjs.••^i^- to


 5




iii                                                      iaci^..-;,.ii?!8flcm..



14     : &nd, yqs.




ifi;                 'MR'.           ''O^ect£oa:.                   ^bc£: ^rabi^P^s.
15      Jtbd. ovelJsrpadL




        By MS. iitmR£t«^^




                                EcoScribe Solutions    888.651.0505
                                                                                         EXHIBIT B
        'Anc>Re»^''3PEAR8^v».)^A^ITH1JEjIi•OF•»•^H•ulf50F»l^llA•..




                           THS MlTN&SSi              Sm^lcyca preoauine Dvsa de^lcchad
 4        on an iSe't^^tjB;.-£teB^                                   tai'-•
         ."Wa le^gflsd-^By' .ib:tt--^pl'cyefe^ -Pg -Ae^t£'^ lliat M Ofljl'l^rtn rt'-


          ibfl,iitpana,a!ti'op.^ ^tiB.ajp "laqaJP- ^ ^ t ^ ^aa"^ ^:fe.eBpg'aj£.i1^g ^be-



                      ,   !.MB^ i ^ ^ ^ r      ObjectiibDir           ^^^ipj^^-aeila^i^^j




                                         EcoScribe Solutions           888.651.0505
                                                                                                                     EXHIBIT B
                                                                                        ..Iub'.2.9?i2»i'


 J.



  •a • tbB individoal         nnsckad in^
  4    BY HS. MPKHRRJE^k
 5            ''Q.. "Dpgg: Bs4lt&'--Jtetl,P^-g'illcfoCTi1a't .Iji'oi. jft'^Vb -its'-
  6

 7.»

 fit




iii


                    ;?>Kyi ac<»s- ;isai|b .gt*^ pt4(^i|,crfeji^,: '^rrtci.'.-iia*^.
14
15
16     iAtt^ta;pla;'; .Qpff't^' Cenoeri; Co' track'-yA-jMPiigL^' tsacpsinsWs' '^niJ -
^'T    xeveuuea^:'assocsQCBti , OLD/ a r • " ^ l . . ^ ^ |N»!|t.'B§^.pj|,%^^bs. i k cg«x^P.c,t




,ii,-             tA... 'ttitk


                         Okay.      Andfiarayi^qo^sManis.^i^                                     .

n
           C^i^Di^ia^ "Inc.. en^layte ^cr <^£t.-partipulax':|3a<^,
W
                         MR. LOSa-        Oli»flB(;tl.ttn%    Eh^uJcs £Pandation.         .^aifuP
-IT
is                       THE 'IfXTifJBSS^ -^eol'tJte^siPr.-, „, %»oXa^Be3' -arfe i^ai^i ^:vi)E
•'1!|.-    acuQatmtd'.-;tlsa.t         set'up''3!2i-''<'|>e£N3dB3-es .'esi^'Ileba^ «tji^.-
           tba £y siLik tsy^tm&tfn MJifit^. l<^$al «|]Ut4t;i4Mi f i i              'iiim.
;ij,i     I'lioapjaji'^: :-ir ;b£*' kh.e(ik' sn^iloyegp-.
.ft.'
.73^              -;.Q'-. • W»)Qn»',^c,^^ajtliesaii.'intlj^^                lib--jriSUK ffiean?^.,
                 »Ai.-.-'Ife-ag- aQt%Ttiyjcirri4ijiA •
           aepaga^.,liBgaii -aasi-sy^ tccur, 'lte,ai]tiHi:BQt.i,., 3^iig=

                                    EcoScribe Solutions      888.651.0505
                                                                                                      EXHIBIT B
        ^^|[>t^' 3PBABS VB.H£ALT?H NrrOF c«».iFOe-nH^..                              -iub-.E9!i2«




  2               Q< -So lbaa^,'Orr,*(ft^c..yop a t e 9>3eiipg li.#5a|£or tJia
  3       am@.ufit €if | l i 5 § i } . 1 3     yau fiave arj loaderstaodinloi


  -5     . d i e p P s i ' t P 4 ' ' B w ^ a ^ T ^ * ' cdaec}u.n9 .Pcc<]iin|:^




  9                    -'•THE-trrm^i: .ml^i^.-
10:                     .JWid...;'t.p!. | ^ c . l i ? j ,yoa kD:m:ii.MMmsm&Zi coapooanfea
li      ^, il&tpd' .oj&..,sli>a;:. .,^<«gia       •Mit^u^^.Mtfyismtm. . g!Li>.a


24 ' ^ platt. 3jdsELniarjDra.fcPis..Heal''ifh.-l>te^             -jfag xagp'cgngiiajE- fo'r--


^Ife \i -cPm|3e'Pis^ta.P'rt:'l.:tspagf'pa ^ f e .


                                     EcoScribe Solutions 888.651.0505
                                                                                              EXHIBIT B
           lifeubie Cij|iu«)anuary..6'5>r5Wit.

  1          bcttotn- taobt. EAS .iSafeAC 4Llfe. ADJD>.                         ThcMEs. aare pa^r
  I         -felMfe>.(::Aj6fti^ia:L'^lJttr>.,lJbg..J^                                   ..,.,jyfc,..»i»elJL.j3ta tft-Qi:
     m "
             e6Er»iaaa^ blve ai^diitral                        yaiTe and fehe dienfeai Iflegx

  4         i'i'eg't-. .tbp,g#" -agg,F»-EA'-3F:'EAB&.V«,HEM_TH -.NEJOF   crttiFopiiiiA,                                   Jub-,Ee52*i'


  J.               A. 't maarv thongs j<»tfldS^b« aubaoPouiat^. Cbc Uve
           dlfferaot bBcr^iit j^labs Mithin an AwflJbb^U^ iooomt foe
  ."3:     Uhe plan>         Mf ^poaltla:; l i clear Ibal:' bfTie fuPda ^of? the
  4'      ^ 6 4 . 1 A s i v j i p t f l ^ ^Jip               Mftij^^l.t^ by « © ^ t b Ne:t..
  5       1-nc-,
  B                • Q.    QM:^- lig^ii;*-' op*» X":**- •3,)'^^*' •                            ta jm.d0VSitMS)i^-
           the f low' of .th^ oBoaeyi
 Mi                       'So      i t yo.uT^r^-teskiMpiay •%i£a.fcfcSfe-.ata^lxiypx
  U        benetlfeS" irr '«Gr3«blalt: 4^'                  ^^sne^-'iie^eac^ifenOe       -3E5,r ..-^aadc,,
                    .'ADAB:-land                     :^lt./sSiaa ^^nc« b^^vKp*                       ^J^a%Uft, tba BA^^iinc; bba Daaie
          •:^£tk' '^ti|: : ^ \ b x ^               p '?)^e?ce^d:,%| ')jtofci^|ajj,dl |adb.^
          'ib«ii6«ld|^^j^lah-sfi^^                                                   .
,'23;
•24'.            iblgQr£piMittekfe£l-^



                                      EcoScribe Solutions          888.6510505
                                                                                                             EXHIBIT B
               ^PBAB-S v« HEALTH, HETOF CAtlfOBi-ilA.^                                    iub:£S52ii'


 1^     Jtpq . ^account 1ftto              gpaars'• cbacfclx^ ^ao4>!ix>c1


 •3--   ambiqUooa•

 4                    But- alts wee i t I E you can.
 'Sr

 fi     .bad^-'diriECt -•depogif.;:": * Sa- the • pX-aa • gcfataaror aotr^
 •7i'   adM.nigfeTg^acr ,:^'^ ,'Real^.:Jtfet:»^^                   :§fie i^feajdicji-Tect":
 5^     deposit:.-jtb" is^hfe liatpaaais^ij'tHaj.''ti^^
 a
.'II

ii             - Q;, pkijr* -^IP                to ci9:nfiani4 ,,i^
li      'Dx^ratandlng! ^b6ai^u-lhe''.>liii''£^',i'a.iSiiliiibii                  «!iplJiy«3i-,
        ••pAi'^ %fi#ilt«, irai :|^id,, 5«jpaJ3.teii'*^                  ''';|5#(a«B^.^'^<3{j^ liBt^.
14      r«g^-at\.3bd pve'TlfciifiB'' je^ti]^ias:6at4-.p^                                   -that
i5
16'                   MR. lk»I«:        Ok^PctiPn.       iktt.gytratJi3= tba ^wi^t^JBBcra


Ifi                   •THE'r»a'Ta'SS'St-     Rlt^rit^^. -^P-lgi-'giaair. -^-^tft -Sfet..,^
19             'vaa.;. .cegpopa'iJbiiti' fPi>''Lbia^..£:^fete*^    .Etmft'lit- i^flb'.


        'PlJUBi 'Ifiib,: .i§o'miii||tba^' -ili.db*                 'Jlj^s^ajrjBi?.* .^arjcg^Lkatr


        'qpafliPbafi'%£ PC' BV M9.i iTOTlliBBi^^



                                   EcoScribe Solutions   888.651.0505
                                                                                                    EXHIBIT B
          ••^ICff^"3PBi»B©-v«.teM-T>1:NFrOF»"A'tiFv^


  X          me i f                             Was t i » ^ 1 2 . S 3 l^ruw fciil^ paycheck:.

  Z          Bxhibifc A, dfipocit^^^                                                         Ihc,
  •3?




  4
  5          tesLiisdny.         .j.'^cki £bbnd;4^bii"i           Va'gc^. '^4; anyb4gu6b| ;

  fi                         TtlE ' W I T l ? E ^ ;    JM? piBi*t: pC tba ajBOupt P?

  7-
             b.iifnP£'i,kt «afi-,pM4:d ••ijntfjti^s S^«iir$i'-•.b,atMc-"'p.p«Qbiife pier Jhw-
  r          InitJ^pfelon'S S » ;Mj«P^-'d!a©pa-it--,




i4
14



•4fi'                 •|A:.-. . H&Ai.tti fi&bt a^ip;.. ;-,^Ai5 .v£'^gp.'gb^:jubit'.^ £,9g: -HhP.' •

             mmiiisyfvc: -paid' ,b«ane£i:fes^ '^S^xstt^-^- c c "'^bi^^_ .aqifexcjg:,

is                           MR.-'-.'XifgCg.-     .^•d...xs ydtofc..2ifecste3^ '^'fe^-Uterb%i&ri':

19



:;^i ^ ^bape'E;itSi^luid^'•tfaijE•^ta^e: "%aama.4tirg,'*-|aa                .tjBaRDn*.A^#

-:|St';                                    idpgjatit      .a^l-i*:!         .^nj±ek-.

             By ^3. IptRERJIS '
        -*




                                          EcoScribe Solutions         888.651.0505
                                                                                                      EXHIBIT B
      - ^ } i > f ^ ^P,Bi^mym .HEALTH, NeiIT.OF»"^rttlFWi'ilA..
      tlfejblt Calm ,Janu«i'^i,Arif2L«1-y

 1

 I                        .iaB;.....uOfl6':..' ,£»fe^a^g,fciQ^l.... VAqiig .--.abd. ,aaaBblitubt£a...
                          TBE HI YHg3B:           H m * that' s my tinde eg t^bdi^p.                    1
 4'
 5                        MS. MDREEBJEEt             I'TO sbrry*
 B                        THE iRITIilESyS,.--     I!,bat;-E ®fc<=^:-      Wai,*:'«

 1-   i-andejrataading'»
        B3? Hs.              mm^^-
                %-        AM wbat.. Id -yoisft- //,wd&a£asai(\-alttf;- b«s'©ii • tm?
                Ji'st:          ijc^JbiL ,ad]ni< NE^OF i'ftiiFQRi'ilAi




   2.-                   'Si^'Kitifa ^t>aSfp6,ot to-ith^:, —%*>i©i^.r€fp9pc to ti&.e.
            regpilat' nbnoiteinpc cpnsp^saatiao that ia in tba aafariat pf
   4       ii' r 250: .•,00"I • i * tbat .pot:T,pctf,
   •3:
   fi              ,<3^ Ofcey> Axh3-1 bfellityB-^you^tastti^eA^is^
   7/
   fi I     xi*qttlair noptbteflBpt^ .e<^^                            ^tbb amount: of


•it
;il
ill-                     :-'QkaLV'£.J:iS,b,-_,:Jfehten';.:si%   -'tebttr aa'deofg^iam^iab-htt^^ ab.


 14


          j Ki^naifetafed .'tbfete,,..«'8plEgl.r&r>"felmcteAnW^ricPPbnt^/ibtigblatj^.
"^7
.,.3:2»
 19
            yout-. — I -4Pb! t kiWW JuT tbaaa                        b^L, aini£>jiftJL*, ^Gjsrjioiadii,,
 ;2i rpc 'ifcbaa^' ,ai»p^mtiBl


                    .Q'. ^k. .ai}«o"abt^,»«|b*sa> ^-^JO^'^. ^l*^bl'rtf«^a .;anli^ -'




                                         EcoScribe Solutions       888.651.0505
                                                                                                           EXHIBIT B
        .^'.>.v^BFl©^'"3eEi»B8^v«.HeMi^l^j*lEE^                                                                                     J«ii:2852*i'


                ^y^-.;4ij«>il-•, '•.3)cft;'-ikfVs^^^^                                                                       -



3'




•:7.3
        1


-S-i




                                    iA^-i.



            f    iji..-*...,--..^            '            .-.    -    .J.',   ,   ^....-..'..-.,...1'   ••f.


                                                 •:DP,^ybb?.-£'BS'


                                ,'^'ig.,. ^^Ok,lyi              ISD *tbis--l^ a^?'ab'd^.'««P>i.iBS»rWtnP0* -^ibttKabW.^ bZ'-
            i     :i:




                                                 1 flt^^ii?t '^yoTj^'^SbM

                                    .A..         ,<«a,
                                     0^          ' Okay i ^ &iid' Cobagdlfiq- Ad                               l i f e . »Snaaj^a



                                                 0^ ^ 0         s^-^lliAif.




                                                                EcoScribe Solutions                888i65 f.0'505'
                                                                                                                                             EXHIBIT B
           '.^1|(>F^A';SPEAB8^v«e H ^ T H J i i E ^ U F »:«».lfvUfli'ilA-.
            ULHibVe Cij|iu.ijaiiu«i'v.iD'i,,^CjTiy




                       A-      ibfejJttealth t^^. iac:.- piatL acoobufr.
                               Wag bhc mobey foTr deofeal fleUe b l g t i >tept in a


  5                    A •- tl -ajyanniB' .tSaxa ^Vigpa. ^efpacata, ^,gPbac»=pHb:'ts^^•^;i^^
  fi         op^sc t:o> tgecJi;- tbam aepgcat^iy                              Hoitb r^iaPafubts tbyol^
             baffg''' ,l>eea, .paxb P^., t^&;'geal:€H jfletv. In'g'i:£:pl'iMi''' 'accDoint;. fog
             tbti ejetfetgria^pdiatOi
                      *g;, „ -p^ay,*:.,.: 'g.6/'!tibjalijerye,,ypfc-p^




             m-fl^tibl^i 'z^cj^ajt'iaiag.. ^ye^,-bPif,,'.wItat                   t.ajcW, jfe^^aigM^^
             BUbaeaaauntati.. it-, fjc^si' ^•Eifept..,,p£:; aia.-ApaiL-r^- -:'«lnc'..'iqAiai"ftl^
       ;

ifi • 'tmft3.ty -Bpjfeith' ffp,fc.-. Xnc--. •1»Pff--'xPatpqtfsi:^ate....Sb^^                      na.'ajt:
19            af«f«'^.y...A£^*^'&^ tbeAi^"»aa.'.ab--'#cx3pub;fe.tb:^gg^.-
              XbAdar         Abd>X IM14«V]^. ibaid^ iVBra ^rtittaacpimJLA Xu fiir^t^£::.^.tiiiL
:?fi


'23;


•2S:         •^^t' -i^m, tia^iisensod'ipt Aagii5,e,pf'-2''pi'3'-'in|^EA-3PEABJ6-v«.HEALT>i-NE^iOF t'AciFOS'.i*!!^^^^                                    Ajiilc952a
       p\iob)B •CWiu.-.)anudi'j<4%'SQ'?r*'                                                           \fi»;0 % I.




         f»lf ,setyic# .i^ycih«.a3f ftUt- fbr:lt3'i $g>®axs.
                  Q, ,     ^ d d6«c rJ)o t inake tha dli^j^b-le i^ploy8« a ,p>lan
 4       padfjfcipipont?
                  -A'.,   ^eS'i in i^bp'lidv'a^tagps ^plaii.                    3ctt psi.
 fi.. ^niec.e5ff.aJPlXy;^-M? a,iX;./0-f-:^^^^ paifbt^sri^,--p.JA^a"^ *^r^- .-tb.a.
         Adi^bta9is4..:plbn pbdvi-dbb^ for;,
 lit             ,-ff. •.•.Dkay,'Sr" ^^P, ^i:itf«i-itt^-s..!po,B3ifel.(a.-.-tq»^^^       .plm.;.
         .pay:fcs:.aipgbt Tg»Xtb.».i5papE,gt j tP.'-=tjte,,.:A^                      .pj^.^bi£t;.,.fipjE:.


i4       pia«ii?,'
rl'             • A'^ tlQi ,,it!iafc V3!ti-acQfc£ecit-.''6
if'
14 : >*hat 'V0r«. ypu.,,.s«j)'iBg.-pac^ip:Dsif, thtp- *rifcb -fbscffBist td„, tB«-
iB
<16                       •MR. -iOJJ(3T..                 't^i --^i .;4:bttna;al-.. .Wb^r-'*

        ;'.dpn.*|i. y^u, .;ai^k'' '.tl^e,, iffxtziie^sSo -a: -^vua.s.zxuf*,;'

Ifi     |:Bf'MS:. ITOXkE'RJEE'.t--
                          il-JjBTVja'ii^afc. aiflM!bt"'3'^                         what yob •-•aid'
        i j|ali!eM4puaXy Jb^^^^i^'-^^Pii^^ §d<^ ^&bi>m% tlua,, ea£;6La£Aa>
;^x     I .|)l'ap,s


        f '^^ie.;;ii -'t^ptt'gadLp4-'..^Pit«.stat©                  ; '^tbe- .sepord'i; ^.ealfc*. - ' • - '
:f4-     '.i*fc»^l'f.• tt:"-^^''^v^- .A'*s<5pa«^^©rt ' sB^'.jfi^.'ia ^ ^ t ^ - |
         ',?a'sa5e:.

                                       EcoScribe Solutions          888.651.0505
                                                                                                             EXHIBIT B
      «Hi>»EA' SPEAB&vn.MEALTH.NET'OF »-^rt-tiFOribJIA-!                                             Jub.£952»i



 X
                     IS ats-€11^*^1® •9flip.lpy^,awTOtabai3^^^^
       participnnb oace rbe^ sse ppvssed by tbf P^s:a benefits:
 4             A-.. I , dLeacnPfe. '**4tb,                  ea-be.iaBb t.
 5             Q.    ^bat dc you disag^wk. Mi.tS^'^""
              lA., X€ ai:i.ew|».Loy^. j^ej^,,.tbs pX%,g^iJb^X5>"'lt^
 7,    .'ir€iqt>i'i'€msntt 4% defibedl.ib tbe''^ll^n , dc^sSznabb-undec
 S     stligibillty .-ii^.y ^«p.»j^tPiiii.*^t^?ikily•«^ver4ijl'.i^^^^
       J&p«e£4fei.                        ffife fdiaft'.. .otb^x Xierraiib& tf^-&^»-ijaw-
1^      la. {i.trp^iXyaiy" fttiap't: 'QS y(s^^kivi^j.'^mit bo.l ^                          ask i^ss-.
       I- .waiys' M tHm% ibi4n-s.
li                        -abc« •somabne nitset^i. feheLeii(gdib£lit-|^'&
i^     ^:3ffe^is'sfiiftbt^' .pj|*        -il^tfl' 4oKweK ^ i ^ ,               '€fe-fiiT»A M "ch**
14,    plais, fbe^ .-a.ce c^ovbcad ~ls^ #C»M8 ',e)ra3^1by,s.t- ,jp,ai(^.' 'b8(H€,:ra.l:# at-
15     •HP coa,tj^t;*>- 'tlijim,. ,dO'.«?oft ,t,p 'tl^'t*'C^icaii?at M^^^
16     ..ara' parlicup^ntA • ib-^Kha .Adyantjfffas{pi*P;.                        'Tbsryr ;:;st£li#^


ifi     feto 'tife' Ptoeb ^febP£x'ls^^ ^ X .aje'axi;,.sjoAitisti'^l 'bfenfffl ts,- - ii>Se
19     madic^- afid .dbbt^i P«-.opt -i&is€:                      iR«?dlb41 ''and' aant&l" asd.
       .viaiob;,     febfi-A*        f f A f « i £ » j a ; » . ..a|:'.iDrp^ti.pJiA^*»,bebfiiiJi*^,
       :Bbfc -,iMiployaea bBMf' paLD,kicii^tb,-l£i-. &f ,np|..'iijai: ,po,f2:lL3Qa.f,.


       Mis f,ipf "|iJ^,»a,,,basic-li-j^/ii^                                             tS' ap
                     -as&i'i&jl^itd^ {.^drogpt^



                                    EcoScribe Solutions 888.651.0505
                                                                                                             EXHIBIT B
                                i*« :j .;->.,£fAi.



              '>iiie«'ts




              pajttl&lpa'bt'?"

  1      '}




              (sraiciS'lPipak'i:. • •
  .   ., j

                                                                            |Hb^;l|ttp||^




              ^^;take*JJ.^; ..l^fj|tot^i:Vj^v.




:,i-4':


"^6 I


 ifi'-                                                                     Prt the




 Ji            paxtinlpatloo '.wltb easoecc ta ^che -BiaaJ^t^^WBK.^,.:.




 ^4'|
                           4.   2


                                                     EcoScribe Solutions     888:651.0505
                                                                                            EXHIBIT B
        =Ai4l>I^EA'^i*PEABS-v(?.HEALTH NFFOF i^^rtwlFOni'HA.                                   -k:li;2852*<'


             BV       »i1}Xk&St?£S.

  Z               --0^ JiX%-^.^ 'ja5.^£,.jffi^„aipployHi£v
          elxqibiHtv ^pua^gamentji ae sgt fortb i c tba JieaXtb Hfet.
  4-' I n c , l^*/abt4qp9 pjfb pleiefiied to j'eceilve                           optlpoal
  s

  fi     \ye^iaanto.gbd-..€tebtal :£l^.b ..yaava jgatyjgsag^tj; :^ X


  Bi


         :paycDab'ta-~.'lpir' .^'e^tlitj?? kb-bpb< rBcedt?e^,.<:i|ptipbaI- bscal^.^sT:'
li                       tte'.             iD|>|«^£Jtl#-.- "yb^-e-.^cftl ani]Ql^


il        .BT- Hsj, .'Ijifiiifli^;:.
14
         i--pp'king; af'iiite.'«rjg^ f^t«6»eiift:.. ,!iijtb|b;i^^^^                   i^iv -.^l^ie^i

          'ttpit .tbe.\ •c4i»'d-^^:5La iwa'i'vsa i'p^yiii^|i..:<:^ijiis>, •ditfeit^jtl:^ ^^rara a

ii*
1>9''             %A.. '''teia

                         tikpy- ^' -Sap- ^.I-oyee^ -i^thP .*ei2fcivea'-.tb'^ dbifcttt-
             jClbx fiax^<» j^nmni- laujciJigi tijs t4»aw' j^pipa,                   A»*i9p41 0!f
          ;s.pi|-.bb,tii.' .arpxyrfif- i|a|'r'\ib,arf-,iiid! tbp,.''paypBbfe'B'-^e

         !        'i^i. *ito-5^»'-!fe*i^'i#fi^                                                       ^

<25 :


                                     EcoScribe Solutions 888.651.0505
                                                                                                         EXHIBIT B
        «U£>F»EA- SPEABe-vK. HEALTH NETOF CrtLiFOBi^iJA-
        Ubublt t;wliu..iaMUdrv,fli'?i'2i:"J*.^"

 1

                        MR xiOifla : and »^at 9?
                        I^B , >tU)6:^J&S v Tb«y wbiild bb tfie Advabitager£
 4'- .plan ••§ocammat •iftcA^udibfl .a 14-                             mepdpe^b?,,, :S.ucioairy pip.b
 •5      de'fpripti'Q^s- .abele^-' th§. 'p.l^^ i.                       . eBn,dknG& .of, co^ilecage
  B     ;d
  IS
  9
m        dlild^Qg; - ^^&i,;i:d(4PA^i^^^^.°'''--i>!3l:'                     pbtiCBCt .'pa' .i£t.',l'''iii.r'
ii       VKPJSg,
12
if-
14       ba cPtfgldfecad' a.tfcn'^'PlkaTs^airtacLpabfa                                   PPM                 aPt a
• 15
•"16            < A..    Mpt ,a "pl^a- ^paJEfcljipXfianfe'aIl» tbg-                            • ng'A-.
                "j^.    tlk^.;.:   'Jflu|u " i ' X ' s u < e l X a l l £ L e , e g p i p y e ^ ; "

IS
19       ' t b # l f b ^ " t b " ' N % - / i'a'P- ' M v a n t ^ a ^§Lim£'«wsri.vet i ^                    tr'oy^rage

 its      abdax: t b a ^j^CJu^AJuL bianafAtft la^^

:21      Vpiib 'ide'cXayr,atlfla' .tba^t 'l2idlvidb^.'^'''«ia|iiti::be; "'«3kbXb-X,&; -.CP.'




                i^z     L^t*^, .a^ai.abbad ,andsiactb,alij''3JS-."yp.'^^^

                                     EcoScribe Solutions               888.651.0505
                                                                                                                       EXHIBIT B
        .!AfJDH^:"3P5ABa^v*.HEALTH NE^OF »"rAtiFOFSi>JlA.                                  ,iuh:E.g52fi'
         fejuife G)|iu;.)a«uafM.j!»;-^-r:2Cili.«-"

        Tor    dfeiifeAX f leK (waive p£»yinanka
  X- \

                  Qi     — STB" tliiieipe any r^pilsititioas placed by H»sJtb
 4        K©t,.,,P\c:- PC-'Ite^IStfe'-.K^f: 'pS Ji^iifpapoiat IpjC, Ipn %H?'.:^tha.t:.
 -•5      money can be apenb by, the ernPloyee*^
  B                     MB- UOfyj^: pf^.e •it;*s p:aid' i^m- "tfP tbaip -aib. tfc^r-

  7
  •Si                   fclS, t^WKfiES^ipBs. jC!prrapt>
  9                    .iPHE, ''Wiiefeasr -•i^p,?*; 'H't(»tti^'|bm-,_.                           ^pmmk^tiQ, x% m-
14        bpnfla othjBt; fdra rf cppyany bsbttfit.j ytni kbraii^fenE-TSlab
         ! ,
1^6                    'Sb .Cni'A Xx,t^t^e'--^^PnSr)'s1>d^.bsP


ifi'      of ppupab it|#'aibtjrs.nia::ew.' ' ^ i W a ^ I ^ i l - i^^;WSc- jtbt
!19       .e>*eatioil\ -ye^-.- -^^Jiej^ 'fedfl'•^•'•wbateve* -tbey'-ft^aa't •'ffilti*'''.ifc€
M                      . MS v MDlUijE^t4EB:. OAay.           Xaab . xneLL j^ 4«bai, X waf




                       ''Okayi • Witiiy tBspiacs.t'td tbja :taa^^
*
.4^^


                                   EcoScribe Solutions      8887651.0505
                                                                                                     EXHIBIT B
       '•^l,!«IETOF-CfttiFOni'ilA-.                                         .iuh*2&52ti


 X       liBPkad.at Mg. <3pea.s&wa^qe ---^ we looJcad'..a:t. the ^Ifew^elf
         a^±yi33R, pavcicack Afe Bitbibitil -iafpd .bfef mBriliial ilfeK..wA%m
         Hs, Kpear^ nece^pecj ^gO .                   kv spia&tica I B KPW arc the
 4" afflp.pntjg fot." th&£& 3«aiyg^' .p^yogots '^^Btfaisecl^.
 5:

 fi      vPuXtl coXXect xoaslQet data on. ocacpoti txtm beoaftt
         ipyaP.tlPegi';and'loofc..^a^fc frti^t....oth"Pr !-bamPgtS^1:xy,e.^di:p.gec
 •Bi

 9      - -gtjS'di.b, iJrbr:.--ept^ op:,. ..aqt..j>^,..fflaacdaaeal, .iiTi^r''daat-ai.-iisdaiiB^^^


;ii

         peaiiitee. t t r ira±ygd.-- ea^, Ba^n'efit^. ibE ;3^icl3giab.t-,,
14               '^. ^'tokaV- - .Si0..^I.^t.bifflc^g'.--kaPy:tb.b...a'^


16                      Ifc. 'tbW^ .aanbpnrB .tb^te--'-^s ,;psMi9'kgiCd^..t^b\^^"iaii^lb^'geB wbcc--


12
19
                 A.^ .;itaab....^tt^taXblg-^roxL^Lba^,|r^^                                              .
I'it
                        ' Aftd-      'Bfe jcla&M:j .,.M^.-:,:TOe^diiC^,fii.g^^^^^^          ifeiailgflt^;-.
         4-0 a ;diffsfeQpfe -aa'cunt i^aif^ tha ^a^b^^l* •Maa£babe^^,,.-^td*'
'|4-     •KiiL3iyibii-s.ilife'!^                ibib._^5-                    .-gai!e- ajb'.S

                                      EcoScribe Solutions       888. 651.0505
                                                                                                              EXHIBIT B
       .:-i«flD#&*r3PBABeW»>. HEALTH NEPOF Crttif^OW^llA •                                    ..iur';29^>2ti
        fe(b)fe Cid)itj,:jantdi',v..&"^aWy •

         s^aoall... .you .-kaow,... for: -a -.^aw Viia3t£& -bow"fcbPs^.ratee ^bave
         'bjeaaL...lb.            .. x -:dcflCL'JE;.rBmiember-_,,vb'cb:jMei-^^irtQd[^ ..tbaae.
         Tatco bbb tbey have bees hhe iaire rgfcea abri their bays
 4       -beets .jgp.nsigte.'yb.-.-oyqii'.Ctb.e. -las-C-iey. y^gg.
 5

  fi     4bQ>:t, dndV.^t,Ty dtajade.xid t^^pts ..dUscunifp^ v^jere £bese..
         bbmkx:!^, wcmld                  Jticvai^tm: .iditei^Tidnibg; "the. -aradont'.-of >
 a. 'thaja.ap*ia;^Pl|aV'i€lM^               '^*|:ay imsrebb           ,b)as%:p.^jd|Mipa .kasl,-
        ";bigtli3[' f i i f p p ^ f - c s c j i ^ ^         •-••|llwri-Jii^.(^'';6?^!p©^&l
        'pta©|,LbalD' lthiEt^\,h&&e                   ..^'l^ i f jbistj/^c^tit     :5be{ gibgbikig;
        . piPppeiibaB ;fcp ^1»IErKO'F^


 i''




                        •THip)r^pb,:' - •




 9
                 /Q:'...- ''i!SB..-|^,Ms- --.QgllaLt ^^bn^^
                       ' ^^:At& tJaasa "ttossa 3ecatatjs''bpn!aib^es3
        :          ^    ,,7"" '          I ,    H   ,




is,

.19s
                  Q. - What 1.6 tba¥'^'ta!iiBrti£xse?
;21


23

            t b O i S ' c a a e t s i & o ^ t e tJas ^tsaxsjse. atoriuniatragxag aaa:
25
                                  EcSScrlbe Solutions   888.651.0505
                                                                                        EXHIBIT B
 -\>- -: '




       .:J^IC«EAr.3£Bma\v,»,.'HS4aiH>NEjfc'OF*"^^^^

  X-f:! I,,plj^-:^ap&nsiiifc^£ijdi^Cth^                        ,Jlet^Advantacoe^^^t^a:!ataxXa'^


                   .•<^k:.:;lMt>tt;.        'S®-'-.wa2''.'d;jby^
                            is;;;pj.an'f,




                   ^iSw'IgP^efeam:^ tt^ aioao^ib^ ^Qjelu^a a^bpJS^ aa, igfl^nfflt t.j^.'
>:!2,i ; ;i]fe^.;Iibi;^fepaitiiio7
             f^'
                    QV^W^Qli'r^tiii and^ ^ciuna^ M^Ejr& zaDcin^^ about xbatt                      Si




              iisdpdtttfiliott^Kfld alio x©f«t«nt»d swbAcoo^iKti; optog x
t'25r, 1


                                            EcoScribe Solutions        888:651.0505
                                                                                                       EXHIBIT B
        ^ll>f^.5P,BfrBfiW«^H^LTH,NETOF»"^AtlCt!^i'ltA-?                                                .iuli-2.952w


  X'                     In u&xng tho«« phiriaees we£^ yot^ ;&lvaye
         r€^€cr„ibg t~c •iabpey thtSit -.tfiau^ ^ f ibtJO-. G&E .^•oPbEyc^
         Tefcs^'nced in patagcafH) ^ of ycm; d«»claratxon:
  4'
 .5;

  B      ii»ttbac.co,uat3' -ox:, -auydXjig^Pf -tapsa .-oaxusgr
  7.1           .-'A'..,.., "'-The:' •plan.-,.'do'cPmecit.t
                .'Cf-    -Pkay^.^: JiJa.d--i^'*3d|liaS't^^               •IJfer..plaj;!f-dpPtiriH>f»t?..



                         :,Mp«4,...'^t:fai'3''':i3.«5^^       liitjfe.t,. ati-lia» 11?"-aby^'^ ...pg
         Tfel€tipbia)lifeJ(itg..,^Qie^


         bad.icpieatibp.
14-                      l.g ••Hdal.ftt '".^^v. l^"L^.wagg^.,tP..aPDgafe.'fcflc aaggoy
         ^xp -tbaa. apepmffe ..a^tbf^as'^^ai'"by^.. Safe ^Caimp^ aaMi Bfecftefit^ •
1,6'     dbtroia: ttbb. '-fbe.i Wg-...TiXanC.|lb3L.te:..,v i 0 aa-ynbabb-,., :«^-puid' H'^litb


Ifi              -A>. iRbtpixrig.
*X9-^                   - MfeiOa^ yeb..,pa'i£as'e^^»^ldib-^ t^at-...
                 A.Tba,iPlJUfc. ctecajBfcgpt,,^»agbfe:.Ujtp> jUuMlaa,Jjofe^ ttoa
:5?i ' '|fXato <,ap'df1febb|jgiBa:^                                                     .dP'ciiBiae,# 'ki.-
Mi



                                       EcoScribe Solutions        888.651.0505
                                                                                                                EXHIBIT B
       -«Ui>REA-aF:EAB&v« HEALTH.I^^ETtOF »":rtki6C?R-r)lA-'


 •1,            ^A'. Mo.


 3               A.     tb'a my tmdBratandinq bow .tha iplab i s qaVgxDeid.
 4       vou.feHP'4^y.¥iiiL ihsi %.4y-".fet^ .Pl'ij3...,dpcun^i.,'ll •^£i^ma.'-^d'
 •5"            ^lilg/i arid rtherr a^quigemsbfag ifcliafc;                 ibrlbriiBtL In
 6
         admlni^tsre'd-.         „5CJ.   the' fcndgjabei aldjP,oateil^: for the ,..p,i.an
 •Bi     atid^:Jt»iULg.t-be .^-wtrtid.. fptr, .€bfe»^dv&btiil,pftBK plami
 9              .'Q,. "Ab:^'^ti«: 'Ufe^^-X ^l«tP->«WI9^^iM                             :pl^t.
la      ypp ui}ii^..;|^di^,ii«x•:..l±^^ B ^ l l : ^            Ifl^^.; Mifkui^usgs'?laii
        '.apttpuflc., ta 'that,                   -litov       «i*,.®c«^bf>tp'jtti"t -
       t-ai^'aui^'b ...^at:,:ypd' ajre '3:«.£b^rrlb#           lfi».-|^'iirk^^|^h^'£     -you'r%.
         d^p,i^«eltx©K7
14             A- Tha f/ a ^Prr«e'&. Abi9-rtfPb'tksai^
         ^i)--^'«np,ubt '.wit|>'-_|c|iarc b»»--ipt,:'I .wa? tfi^itttlmt-Jto an
a6       appotenb*'tft'at .woiiltt- ,l]'Pld^~tbe>--£hbd^ '^Eofc -^ta&'-plaii-;,'




1?       ,(Sos>ceebly ., .-but •rdtt^Pt-Jise -iS •r'J*s--«*o'ogi ••ab^ .Vfas-'yipi1k t£>




/23              •A,. ^'2B'^C



        "pfe .th&jpiao? :i-3t:.it..^,-3gpargiJte-ijjaqai .."Epkl'ty.^

                                    EcoScribe Solutions 888.651.0505
                                                                                                    EXHIBIT B
   .jXi.




           •as ..'-a-.                                                                  as                                                            Uaki



                     A     I'm :^Qt ^cie h0«->to daecxibe                                                                                    seijdT'^tenaei:. „c
           bejt»e»an tlae t»oi                   -So tbs TOap^xg sgpfatate^tfrca'BatLltB^;'
           '•tm.^,,Ipg... .,.-';!ibc-^plimr:^dtKis3isat:,::'jptegaagg3'-:-^^ certai.g'"'.'-
    it; ppyegnanpti tha?b Bealtb. f8et. Ipt^-'tHd. lafot hiring'^ abi

                             . •\.    ' .-'1    .,'•.-.:.»•"(> I • - . • . . • » > • i . : ' • : . " • . " > . . Ar-   ,>   ••'.•.•.•,.•,'       .



                     'g-   Baaedi upca yooc teniigfe a& tha VAgg SpeBi^ao^'bg:,
 .,aa,';   d'igcrabiJ^tifiafcaai gi€eetiysri>sf&s yptirj/agrk t^ttlt the
 Tir,


                    .,Ai,.- ..WM>i3^^g^|-m^Jthteigp^                                                                   - •


•'*li6,_



.12.,'


                                     tt2«aaia^a>i<^                                                                                                       -
 ax i S R t S o               tbfc plan. ibtJudea iofbrrwatioi: abouc tbfe
           taqiifcb,.

                                                                        snil^^c^l^' :{a^f'i^


                                                           b->i£np£ab >!-a'f*.-i!iy2ri!ajry



' '•'-M>^6 ,-f,1

 •m
   15*"



   id
   31'i'                                                                                             -J. s




                                     EcoScribe Solutions   888:651. 0505
                                                                                                         EXHIBIT B
           • ; ^ l > t ^ " i PEAI^W*. H E A L M J                    ^^i^f^'^'^-f
                                              1 ^ . ;        —




                      • j.;:;jCoMtf Id[ypbfeJllrl^^':^lia^i'tfi^iMe,ttM^                                                          •'•i':xv~Y'-7TT,-:f^-'^i^TJ--^-'
                                                                                                                                                                     ..




   fi ,                jA;j;^^


                        dlnMMIIIMMMMMMMMMIM



                       '-




3?i'



             j                - >i.«>*»K-.'.'^-.iW';i,!'.' .|;<>iST^V',-.-?#?;^..- :*fe£.=.^a'r,£..^ii^5-"'^^                                                             v..-!


             r



:2.5„} i



                                                        EcoScribe        Solutions            888. 651. 0505

                                                                                                                                                                             EXHIBIT B
             ;4||i>ft&i"3PEARQW?>.HEALTH {JFFOF      I'^ALIFOBNIA".                                   Ju[»:2.952>i'


 X             SC^XP      -uao tl^t money , yc«a -arc not tai)ci.xg about tl:a^t.
               ire yout


 •4'                  .Q.. Mfillj tjbs,. Coli^t,'P«Mi: ypuj ,pptdLlj3^.tb.i^t, opcp./UuE.
              inbbb^.- 4ii ^aid' opt', -Pnca -jaed4oal' fXpA- uraiyB' acid d^.b&i <
     B       rjf J i^'.vap.V€.e4J»^ey rss ^psaX,d .o>it/ t|«e. .rp,ei3i^at''r..teia4J^
              'ES^ployee- f^hPi,-.wagt7ed the -sort 9f cPfs^a^e'p^vXd.spe'bd thia
              niPQ'b'y.         .the -Pr ali,b el'pM»s^ 'Vrtijafi
^7 I

ifi..                           JHg iWt'gHBSS^ -^Sie^.,:i_sgyPnt>.'Pc.:. apweth^bg-:
%9 '          'ibit luncaoiaJPcbablfs?: .Mith: .those                 wihd^..


              cfchflr ",eariiinX.ttBe--'aggp                  tbfe 5pia.'ii^ .c(i!acji£niapi|.:,' 'gfabdE
              .•|tQlu:dbl;t:lB^I^iejg.,aESg^




                                            EcoScribe Solutions       888.651.0505
                                                                                                                EXHIBIT B
             •-^ID^R^i'3F'E*>R6^v^>.H£ALTH;.t.lE^•OF fWClf^CfWi'ilA-.                                 ,iulr2952w
             iJfetiWfe C4i)m.;janiJdrv.t&t*-:atjri1

  X            knPw, tbjjce. ^g^* inacbaiiXog.                   Bat ttao^i f uode viacg
  I            »6atmat)o&d .-ai jii^msdiMt ±.bi&iiLdVAbeacr^..-]pl^                                     for
               fcba plan babesfitg anly.
 4             BV MS. ITOi^jE£.r
 a.                    '••B'.' ^"They...|gex;g.ebipfe''gke^d^^          be —->:;tafe- 'PiBdiPaX: •fllwr-
  fi:.         •graxirs' ana;-*dantaX-, fXgx,;¥aive ^iitnajsay itias,,.e.aragrtoad.«tP:--i3et


             j »fhP iffitxVad^cQyt»yair^^




li '
1^ '

i f - . !h'bt?..-a^atfl.tdqp'^--,Fiag- •ifa^\.,aAii»i|bisfc§Lffe^aXve-
 1?            "and, .dfental- -'f'igi^ waive PPvaetLti 7
                        A.^ ^TbcAfe wpiaLdjiaA                                  .to jljafe.^;eiig>lgiyaj&


                               'ajkl-jf^    |P|.-iM^fX^''i|&^^




«2a-" ^

                                            EcoScribe Solutions         888.651.0505
                                                                                                              EXHIBIT B
         ^Ali[>f^-3f?E^R6^v*!i,-HEAi5M;Nll^                                                            Ju^fi2e.52«;.

                                                                                                                 1


 J-
                                    :1 -^^bartaty-'p«x^tri'i^^




                                    ,-''.•;(:•;[-••+,.•.• •ft.'"

•"IR'



              . -. V •   -.^^y-                                    ^.'•^^•'^•'''^••-••;''J?/''''"'^^      '




'if'




:5»:i-




••^.rj


                                     EcdScribe Solutions           888.651.0505
                                                                                                                 EXHIBIT B
        1^              v ...   i




                        m
                        ^•'' i
                                                   .Vl?i-iC!;tij^^


                   an




                                                                     'I
                                                                     .-y.
                                    •Mj««ilsl;>'iiid:-t"oiS3lEjfilQ




• a.                A.
                                                               1"^-   '"l-'.'&Vi.



                  Qi.       :Oki¥-i r:iMas^^-.VbkKJs^^
          *t^icaX .^^WB*':^leM-^:P#^
 6               •Ai       •ye^.-
                  Q,        okay,      hnd -what *s^3^dlpal Ftejr Slect^"
                  A.        X!b tmuld bb.my ubdPtBk63i^^i^ that, xt s^dr^ tot
          bfl« S'i^^TJtflL^u^ ' ^ t . P«i^^x:fTi^e4l fep efi!e'~;i:*!?« luae
15

      1
          xiaoa X2L,ap«,Sas'"aPE^iRa-vf!-.HEAt^Hil,>lEjR^-F'C»l1|0




    "3 i|
                                                                •Sr

   f •:4-v                                           '^'•"6^1"




        1
             -iSorte-i5p..i:M».                                                          Jcy^-ffe gb.i'
   12:


   IC



             I   -       --^fe.      i • ....                   v.--•.Jp^';i.f;^^^if'•




   18


             B!^ MS. MOKHBBOiBBi
IS. tt',
                                                                                                          .. I




                                            EcoScribe Solutions 888:651.0505
                                                                                                            EXHIBIT C
     ,.,.*Al4D:ReA"3PE«Ba\w,.H£^T-Hit>lFl!;'OF'C^
     -vK6llj',^mMia:iJ^ni)Bi5vsafej^

               '•g.    ..'Dkay.i^ • siAna':;vi^!CT»-;.-. 3Sk^1abF;:..jrti6an#''                                    ••^*"""'-;'      •'                        ••. I


        ,      iQ., . ^Okfly;, ;Abd'::|#»b4t.                 ^tli&.;.b^4i*;;i<^-                 ....      I
air-




        :ixMPSis:^ti.'pjcp .t^i-th'i;?,tbjs|bpp^                                    .' •:


                                     EcoScribe Solutions           888: 651.0505
                                                                                                            EXHIBIT C
         • X- b«pef ,i tsr;. Xsifeh



         3 ip'pai^..cPn:ol^
         4                                .i;;^"'jap3^M!©rB,

        -^5                        3!tiiS'.iWITMSSSl^.. -'illifc joq=!;faiail4i^_;iw^


                  ?t^p|^ tfanridti^f^^*tJi' '-.t^
        .*0-; •iilf M^»•>bd.t•,imy^:aw|^4,#^




                               '              .•   '        'j*;'^.-?.'/'^fit^iif ;i*e"^r".       .                   ;   'v. ' •   •"

        Ml

       •i<.i                                                                      ^ .5.--. . ' . ' ) - - '   •-' «t

     ."'-.-r« *


-;     ii"- A-




        f-l^^^' «     "   "'              "            '

                          ''^t. ^••1;ibidi^-yPo|lc^^


                  ^       :-A^     ,fclp.. •                                                                                             , _ -J


      "Ml

                                                       •f



11

                                                       EcoScribe Solutions                                   888.651:0505
                                                                                                                                            EXHIBIT C
                  £Al4&na^''3PE^Ra"vii.HEAL^H-!,JEiEQF«rtd