On November 27, 2019 a
Exhibit,Appendix
was filed
involving a dispute between
Joseph Hertz,
and
Samuel Hertz
Individually, And As The Nominated Executor Of The Purported Last Will & Testament Of Mira Hertz, Dated November 26, 2008, And As Trustee Of The Mira Hertz Purported Revocable Trust Agreement, Dated November 26, 2008, Et Al.,
for Other Matters - Contract - Other
in the District Court of Kings County.
Preview
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023
EXHIBIT B
TO NIMETZ AFFIRMATION IN
SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR
SANCTIONS
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023
From: Angelica Barcsansky
Sent: Tuesday, January 24, 2023 3:00 PM
To: KSCCVCCP@nycourts.gov
Cc: Justin M. Piccione; Irma K. Nimetz
Subject: FW: Joseph Hertz v. Samuel Hertz - Index No. 526061/2019 - Privilege Log
Attachments: Hertz - Privilege log & cover ltr.pdf
Good afternoon:
We were advised by Judge Knipel’s assistant law clerk that Judge Knipel is no longer overseeing CCP and to reach out to
this email address directly.
Please see below and the attached documents.
Respectfully submitted,
Angelica
11YR1vK1NRADtER
(J
Angelica Barcsansky
Associate
926 RXR Plaza, Uniondale, NY 11556-0926
D 516.357.3359 T 516.357.3000 F 516.357.3333
Angelica.Barcsansky@rivkin.com
www.rivkinradler.com
From: Angelica Barcsansky
Sent: Tuesday, January 24, 2023 2:20 PM
To: SMONTESA@nycourts.gov
Cc: Justin M. Piccione ; inimetz@MccarthyFingar.com
Subject: Joseph Hertz v. Samuel Hertz - Index No. 526061/2019 - Privilege Log
Dear Judge Knipel:
This firm represents the defendant, Samuel Hertz, in connection with the above-referenced matter. Pursuant to court
order dated July 13, 2022, attached is defendant’s privilege log.
The privileged documents themselves will be sent via separate email to this court for in camera inspection.
Opposing counsel is copied on this email.
Respectfully submitted,
Angelica
1
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023
ilYR1vK1 N RADLER
'
Angelica Barcsansky
Associate
926 RXR Plaza, Uniondale, NY 11556-0926
D 516.357.3359 T 516.357.3000 F 516.357.3333
Angelica.Barcsansky@rivkin.com
www.rivkinradler.com
NOTICE: This message may contain information that is confidential or privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, please advise the sender
immediately and delete this message. See: http://www.rivkinradler.com/disclaimer-electronic-communications/ for further information on confidentiality.
2
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF KINGS
-------------------------------------------------------------X
JOSEPH HERTZ,
Plaintiff, Index No. 526061/2019
-against-
SAMUEL HERTZ, Individually, and as the
Nominated Executor of the Purported Last Will &
Testament of Mira Hertz, dated November 26, 2008,
and as Trustee of the Purported Mira Hertz Revocable
Trust Agreement, dated November 26, 2008, and as
Trustee of the Purported Mira Hertz Family Trust
Agreement, dated November 26, 2008,
Defendant.
-------------------------------------------------------------X
PRIVILEGE LOG OF DEFENDANT SAMUEL HERTZ
SUBMITTED FOR IN CAMERA INSPECTION PURSUANT TO
COURT ORDER1
1
Although Defendant has withheld the documents contained in this log based on privilege, this should not
be construed as an admission that, but for the claim of privilege, such documents are otherwise discoverable.
Nor should this log and in camera production be deemed a waiver by Defendant of any objections
whatsoever concerning these documents and their production. Separate and apart from his privilege
assertion, Defendant maintains his strong objection to the production of these documents because, among
other things, the documents are not material and necessary to the prosecution or defense of this action.
6158941.v1
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023
BATES NO. DOC TYPE DATE AUTHOR ADDRESSEE(S) OTHER RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION BASIS(ES)/PRIVILEGE
SH_00000676 Email 7/23/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00000677 Email 7/23/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00000678 Email 7/23/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00000679 Email 7/23/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00000732 Email 7/23/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00000881 Email 8/9/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00000882 Email 8/8/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00000889 Email 8/8/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00000890 Email 8/8/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00000891 Email 8/8/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: Decedent Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00001055 Email 8/12/2021 Samuel Hertz Justin M. Piccione; Scott Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege
Eisenmesser
SH_00001142 Email 7/19/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00001143 Email 7/19/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00001647 Email 7/7/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00001648 PDF Client's personal and confidential tax communication Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00001656 Email 7/12/2021 Scott Eisenmesser David Lobl; Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00001814 Email 7/7/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00001815 Email 7/7/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00002004 Email 8/11/2021 Justin M. Piccione Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00002005 Email 8/6/2021 Justin M. Piccione Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00002006 Email 8/6/2021 Samuel Hertz Justin M. Piccione Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00002007 Email 8/6/2021 Justin M. Piccione Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00003409 Email 6/1/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Jeffrey P. Gorak; Justin M. Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege
Piccione
SH_00003410 Email 6/1/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz; Jeffrey P. Justin M. Piccione Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege
Gorak
SH_00003414 Email 5/27/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00004266 Email 6/29/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00004267 PDF Client's personal and confidential tax document Attorney-Client Privilege/Confidential
SH_00004268 PDF 6/29/2021 Client's personal and confidential tax document Attorney-Client Privilege/Confidential
SH_00005836 Email 3/26/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00005849 Email 3/25/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00005935 Email 3/11/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak; Justin M. Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
Piccione
SH_00005936 PDF Draft settlement proposal Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00006098 Email 3/31/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Justin M. Piccione; Jeffrey P. Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
Gorak
SH_00006119 Email 3/15/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00006120 PDF Draft settlement proposal Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00006149 Email 3/15/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: Israel legal proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00006332 Email 3/15/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: legal services Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00006621 Email 2/24/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00006622 Email 2/24/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00006761 Email 4/7/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Sperberlaw; Justin M. Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
Piccione; Jeffrey P. Gorak
SH_00007112 Email 2/24/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00007113 PDF Client's personal and confidential tax communication Attorney-Client Privilege/Confidential
SH_00007668 Email 1/20/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: status and next steps Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00008458 Email 2/9/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: status and next steps Attorney-Client Privilege
Page 1 of 9
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023
BATES NO. DOC TYPE DATE AUTHOR ADDRESSEE(S) OTHER RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION BASIS(ES)/PRIVILEGE
SH_00008459 Email 2/9/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: status and next steps Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00008460 Email 2/9/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: status and next steps Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00008461 Email 2/9/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00008586 Email 12/17/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00008587 Email 12/17/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00008930 Email 12/7/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00009536 Email 2/26/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Justin M. Piccione; Jeffrey P. Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
Gorak
SH_00011338 Email 1/18/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: status and next steps Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00011497 Email 9/4/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: retainer & potential representation re: Attorney-Client Privilege / Attorney Work
immigration matter Product / Privileged & Confidential
SH_00011498 DOC Draft Retainer Agreement re: immigration matter Attorney-Client Privilege / Attorney Work
Product / Privileged & Confidential
SH_00011499 Email 8/28/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: retainer & potential representation re: Attorney-Client Privilege / Attorney Work
immigration matter Product / Privileged & Confidential
SH_00011500 DOC Draft Retainer Agreement re: immigration matter Attorney-Client Privilege / Attorney Work
Product / Privileged & Confidential
SH_00011634 Email 9/4/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00011641 Email 9/3/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00011642 Email 9/3/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00011646 Email 9/3/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00011647 Email 9/3/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00011651 Email 9/3/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00011652 Email 9/3/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012055 Email 8/17/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012062 Email 8/17/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012063 Email 8/14/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012068 Email 8/14/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012075 Email 8/14/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012076 Email 8/14/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/Client email re: real estate matter regarding 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012077 PDF Proprietary Lease re: 35 PPW Privileged & Confidential
SH_00012078 Email 8/14/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012079 PDF Proprietary Lease re: 35 PPW Privileged & Confidential
SH_00012081 PDF By-Laws re: 35 PPW Privileged & Confidential
SH_00012083 PDF Certificate of Incorporation re: 35 PPW Privileged & Confidential
SH_00012167 Email 8/14/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012400 Email 8/13/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012415 Email 8/13/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012549 Email 7/27/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012574 Email 8/5/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012575 Email 8/5/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012625 Email 7/23/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser; Hagit Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
Hertz
SH_00012702 Email 7/7/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012703 PDF Draft of Proprietary Lease re: 35 PPW Privileged & Confidential
SH_00012957 Email 7/7/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012959 PDF Client's personal and confidential tax document Privileged & Confidential
SH_00012963 Email 8/13/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012968 Email 8/12/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
Page 2 of 9
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023
BATES NO. DOC TYPE DATE AUTHOR ADDRESSEE(S) OTHER RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION BASIS(ES)/PRIVILEGE
SH_00012972 Email 8/11/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00012973 Email 8/11/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00013000 Email 7/20/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00013546 Email 7/9/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00013547 Email 7/9/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00013836 Email 5/12/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz; Henry Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege
Mascia
SH_00014244 Email 5/12/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00014245 Email 5/12/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00014300 Email 3/26/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00014388 Email 4/30/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00014389 Email 4/29/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00014531 Email 3/26/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00014532 PDF Client's personal and confidential tax document Privileged & Confidential
SH_00015598 Email 1/21/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00015661 Email 6/8/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00016006 Email 7/13/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00016013 Email 7/13/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00016014 Email 7/13/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00017454 Email 1/7/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: legal proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00017455 DOC Draft pleading in present litigation Work Product Doctrine
SH_00017619 Email 2/18/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00017623 Email 2/18/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00017626 Email 2/5/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00018014 Email 12/9/2019 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00018226 Email 7/18/2019 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00020104 Email 4/24/2019 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00020388 Email 4/24/2019 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00020392 Email 4/24/2019 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00020393 Email 4/24/2019 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00020711 Email 3/15/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00020712 Email 3/14/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00021838 Email 2/11/2019 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00024118 Email 1/16/2019 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: Israel legal proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00024119 Email 1/16/2019 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: Israel legal proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00024673 Email 5/31/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00024678 Email 5/31/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00024679 Email 5/31/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00024707 Email 6/4/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00024709 PDF Client's personal and confidential tax document Privileged & Confidential
SH_00025128 Email 9/6/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00025129 Email 9/6/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00025961 Email 3/27/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00025962 Email 3/27/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00025963 PDF Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00026064 Email 3/8/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00026065 Email 3/8/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: Israel related matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00026066 Email 3/8/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: Israel related matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00026460 Email 3/2/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00026461 Email 2/28/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00026462 Email 2/27/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00026464 Email 2/5/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00026652 Email 4/23/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00026836 Email 3/27/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege
Page 3 of 9
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023
BATES NO. DOC TYPE DATE AUTHOR ADDRESSEE(S) OTHER RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION BASIS(ES)/PRIVILEGE
SH_00026839 Email 3/27/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00027583 Email 3/28/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00027584 Email 3/27/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00027585 Email 3/27/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00027588 Email 3/27/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00027589 Email 3/27/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00027664 Email 1/10/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00027683 Email 2/1/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00027684 Email 2/1/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00027685 Email 2/1/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00027686 Email 2/1/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00027983 Email 1/16/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00027984 Email 1/16/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00027985 Email 1/16/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00028357 Email 1/22/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00028358 Email 1/22/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00028617 Email 1/10/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00028618 Email 1/9/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00028920 Email 11/30/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: subpoenas Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00028921 PDF Atty/Client email re: subpoenas Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00029485 Email 11/21/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: corporate dissolution/settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00029486 Email 11/21/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: corporate dissolution/settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00029487 Email 11/21/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: corporate dissolution/settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00029488 Email 11/21/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: corporate dissolution/settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00029489 Email 11/21/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Benjamin Frenkel Atty/Client email re: corporate dissolution/settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00029490 DOC Draft petition Attorney-Client Privilege; Work Product
Doctrine
SH_00029859 Email 1/10/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00029892 Email 1/2/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00030261 Email 10/30/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00030263 Email 11/21/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00030264 Email 11/21/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00030678 Email 6/10/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00030805 Email 11/30/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: subpoenas Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00030986 Email 10/4/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00030987 Email 10/4/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00030988 Email 10/4/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00030992 Email 10/31/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00031043 Email 9/27/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Benjamin Frenkel Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00031084 Email 9/28/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00031133 Email 11/13/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00031207 Email 9/11/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00031836 Email 3/27/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: Israel related matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00031839 Email 3/27/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: Israel related matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00033684 Email 8/7/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: Frankel escrow issue Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00033990 Email 7/25/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00034163 Email 7/19/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00034164 Email 7/19/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00034165 Email 7/19/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00034166 Email 9/26/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00034348 Email 7/27/2017 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00034384 Email 7/11/2017 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00034385 Email 7/11/2017 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege
SH_00034386 Email 7/18/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege
Page 4 of 9
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227
Document Filed Date
February 17, 2023
Case Filing Date
November 27, 2019
Category
Other Matters - Contract - Other
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023 EXHIBIT B TO NIMETZ AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SANCTIONS FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023 From: Angelica Barcsansky Sent: Tuesday, January 24, 2023 3:00 PM To: KSCCVCCP@nycourts.gov Cc: Justin M. Piccione; Irma K. Nimetz Subject: FW: Joseph Hertz v. Samuel Hertz - Index No. 526061/2019 - Privilege Log Attachments: Hertz - Privilege log & cover ltr.pdf Good afternoon: We were advised by Judge Knipel’s assistant law clerk that Judge Knipel is no longer overseeing CCP and to reach out to this email address directly. Please see below and the attached documents. Respectfully submitted, Angelica 11YR1vK1NRADtER (J Angelica Barcsansky Associate 926 RXR Plaza, Uniondale, NY 11556-0926 D 516.357.3359 T 516.357.3000 F 516.357.3333 Angelica.Barcsansky@rivkin.com www.rivkinradler.com From: Angelica Barcsansky Sent: Tuesday, January 24, 2023 2:20 PM To: SMONTESA@nycourts.gov Cc: Justin M. Piccione ; inimetz@MccarthyFingar.com Subject: Joseph Hertz v. Samuel Hertz - Index No. 526061/2019 - Privilege Log Dear Judge Knipel: This firm represents the defendant, Samuel Hertz, in connection with the above-referenced matter. Pursuant to court order dated July 13, 2022, attached is defendant’s privilege log. The privileged documents themselves will be sent via separate email to this court for in camera inspection. Opposing counsel is copied on this email. Respectfully submitted, Angelica 1 FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023 ilYR1vK1 N RADLER ' Angelica Barcsansky Associate 926 RXR Plaza, Uniondale, NY 11556-0926 D 516.357.3359 T 516.357.3000 F 516.357.3333 Angelica.Barcsansky@rivkin.com www.rivkinradler.com NOTICE: This message may contain information that is confidential or privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, please advise the sender immediately and delete this message. See: http://www.rivkinradler.com/disclaimer-electronic-communications/ for further information on confidentiality. 2 FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF KINGS -------------------------------------------------------------X JOSEPH HERTZ, Plaintiff, Index No. 526061/2019 -against- SAMUEL HERTZ, Individually, and as the Nominated Executor of the Purported Last Will & Testament of Mira Hertz, dated November 26, 2008, and as Trustee of the Purported Mira Hertz Revocable Trust Agreement, dated November 26, 2008, and as Trustee of the Purported Mira Hertz Family Trust Agreement, dated November 26, 2008, Defendant. -------------------------------------------------------------X PRIVILEGE LOG OF DEFENDANT SAMUEL HERTZ SUBMITTED FOR IN CAMERA INSPECTION PURSUANT TO COURT ORDER1 1 Although Defendant has withheld the documents contained in this log based on privilege, this should not be construed as an admission that, but for the claim of privilege, such documents are otherwise discoverable. Nor should this log and in camera production be deemed a waiver by Defendant of any objections whatsoever concerning these documents and their production. Separate and apart from his privilege assertion, Defendant maintains his strong objection to the production of these documents because, among other things, the documents are not material and necessary to the prosecution or defense of this action. 6158941.v1 FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023 BATES NO. DOC TYPE DATE AUTHOR ADDRESSEE(S) OTHER RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION BASIS(ES)/PRIVILEGE SH_00000676 Email 7/23/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00000677 Email 7/23/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00000678 Email 7/23/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00000679 Email 7/23/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00000732 Email 7/23/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00000881 Email 8/9/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00000882 Email 8/8/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00000889 Email 8/8/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00000890 Email 8/8/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00000891 Email 8/8/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: Decedent Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00001055 Email 8/12/2021 Samuel Hertz Justin M. Piccione; Scott Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege Eisenmesser SH_00001142 Email 7/19/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00001143 Email 7/19/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00001647 Email 7/7/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00001648 PDF Client's personal and confidential tax communication Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00001656 Email 7/12/2021 Scott Eisenmesser David Lobl; Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00001814 Email 7/7/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00001815 Email 7/7/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00002004 Email 8/11/2021 Justin M. Piccione Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00002005 Email 8/6/2021 Justin M. Piccione Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00002006 Email 8/6/2021 Samuel Hertz Justin M. Piccione Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00002007 Email 8/6/2021 Justin M. Piccione Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: discovery Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00003409 Email 6/1/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Jeffrey P. Gorak; Justin M. Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege Piccione SH_00003410 Email 6/1/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz; Jeffrey P. Justin M. Piccione Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege Gorak SH_00003414 Email 5/27/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/client email re: probate proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00004266 Email 6/29/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00004267 PDF Client's personal and confidential tax document Attorney-Client Privilege/Confidential SH_00004268 PDF 6/29/2021 Client's personal and confidential tax document Attorney-Client Privilege/Confidential SH_00005836 Email 3/26/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00005849 Email 3/25/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00005935 Email 3/11/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak; Justin M. Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege Piccione SH_00005936 PDF Draft settlement proposal Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00006098 Email 3/31/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Justin M. Piccione; Jeffrey P. Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege Gorak SH_00006119 Email 3/15/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00006120 PDF Draft settlement proposal Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00006149 Email 3/15/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: Israel legal proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00006332 Email 3/15/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: legal services Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00006621 Email 2/24/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00006622 Email 2/24/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00006761 Email 4/7/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Sperberlaw; Justin M. Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege Piccione; Jeffrey P. Gorak SH_00007112 Email 2/24/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00007113 PDF Client's personal and confidential tax communication Attorney-Client Privilege/Confidential SH_00007668 Email 1/20/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: status and next steps Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00008458 Email 2/9/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: status and next steps Attorney-Client Privilege Page 1 of 9 FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023 BATES NO. DOC TYPE DATE AUTHOR ADDRESSEE(S) OTHER RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION BASIS(ES)/PRIVILEGE SH_00008459 Email 2/9/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: status and next steps Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00008460 Email 2/9/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: status and next steps Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00008461 Email 2/9/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00008586 Email 12/17/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00008587 Email 12/17/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00008930 Email 12/7/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00009536 Email 2/26/2021 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Justin M. Piccione; Jeffrey P. Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege Gorak SH_00011338 Email 1/18/2021 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: status and next steps Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00011497 Email 9/4/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: retainer & potential representation re: Attorney-Client Privilege / Attorney Work immigration matter Product / Privileged & Confidential SH_00011498 DOC Draft Retainer Agreement re: immigration matter Attorney-Client Privilege / Attorney Work Product / Privileged & Confidential SH_00011499 Email 8/28/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: retainer & potential representation re: Attorney-Client Privilege / Attorney Work immigration matter Product / Privileged & Confidential SH_00011500 DOC Draft Retainer Agreement re: immigration matter Attorney-Client Privilege / Attorney Work Product / Privileged & Confidential SH_00011634 Email 9/4/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00011641 Email 9/3/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00011642 Email 9/3/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00011646 Email 9/3/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00011647 Email 9/3/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00011651 Email 9/3/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00011652 Email 9/3/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012055 Email 8/17/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012062 Email 8/17/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012063 Email 8/14/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012068 Email 8/14/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012075 Email 8/14/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012076 Email 8/14/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/Client email re: real estate matter regarding 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012077 PDF Proprietary Lease re: 35 PPW Privileged & Confidential SH_00012078 Email 8/14/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012079 PDF Proprietary Lease re: 35 PPW Privileged & Confidential SH_00012081 PDF By-Laws re: 35 PPW Privileged & Confidential SH_00012083 PDF Certificate of Incorporation re: 35 PPW Privileged & Confidential SH_00012167 Email 8/14/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012400 Email 8/13/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012415 Email 8/13/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012549 Email 7/27/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012574 Email 8/5/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012575 Email 8/5/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012625 Email 7/23/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser; Hagit Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege Hertz SH_00012702 Email 7/7/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012703 PDF Draft of Proprietary Lease re: 35 PPW Privileged & Confidential SH_00012957 Email 7/7/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012959 PDF Client's personal and confidential tax document Privileged & Confidential SH_00012963 Email 8/13/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012968 Email 8/12/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege Page 2 of 9 FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023 BATES NO. DOC TYPE DATE AUTHOR ADDRESSEE(S) OTHER RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION BASIS(ES)/PRIVILEGE SH_00012972 Email 8/11/2020 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00012973 Email 8/11/2020 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Hagit Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00013000 Email 7/20/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00013546 Email 7/9/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00013547 Email 7/9/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00013836 Email 5/12/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz; Henry Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege Mascia SH_00014244 Email 5/12/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Jeffrey P. Gorak Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00014245 Email 5/12/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00014300 Email 3/26/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00014388 Email 4/30/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00014389 Email 4/29/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00014531 Email 3/26/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00014532 PDF Client's personal and confidential tax document Privileged & Confidential SH_00015598 Email 1/21/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00015661 Email 6/8/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00016006 Email 7/13/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00016013 Email 7/13/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00016014 Email 7/13/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00017454 Email 1/7/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: legal proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00017455 DOC Draft pleading in present litigation Work Product Doctrine SH_00017619 Email 2/18/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00017623 Email 2/18/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00017626 Email 2/5/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00018014 Email 12/9/2019 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00018226 Email 7/18/2019 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00020104 Email 4/24/2019 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00020388 Email 4/24/2019 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00020392 Email 4/24/2019 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00020393 Email 4/24/2019 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00020711 Email 3/15/2020 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00020712 Email 3/14/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00021838 Email 2/11/2019 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00024118 Email 1/16/2019 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: Israel legal proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00024119 Email 1/16/2019 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: Israel legal proceeding Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00024673 Email 5/31/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00024678 Email 5/31/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00024679 Email 5/31/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: tax and other matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00024707 Email 6/4/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00024709 PDF Client's personal and confidential tax document Privileged & Confidential SH_00025128 Email 9/6/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00025129 Email 9/6/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00025961 Email 3/27/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00025962 Email 3/27/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00025963 PDF Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00026064 Email 3/8/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00026065 Email 3/8/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: Israel related matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00026066 Email 3/8/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: Israel related matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00026460 Email 3/2/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00026461 Email 2/28/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00026462 Email 2/27/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00026464 Email 2/5/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00026652 Email 4/23/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00026836 Email 3/27/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege Page 3 of 9 FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/17/2023 BATES NO. DOC TYPE DATE AUTHOR ADDRESSEE(S) OTHER RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION BASIS(ES)/PRIVILEGE SH_00026839 Email 3/27/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00027583 Email 3/28/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00027584 Email 3/27/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00027585 Email 3/27/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00027588 Email 3/27/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00027589 Email 3/27/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: real estate matters for 35 PPW Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00027664 Email 1/10/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00027683 Email 2/1/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00027684 Email 2/1/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00027685 Email 2/1/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00027686 Email 2/1/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00027983 Email 1/16/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00027984 Email 1/16/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00027985 Email 1/16/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00028357 Email 1/22/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00028358 Email 1/22/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00028617 Email 1/10/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00028618 Email 1/9/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00028920 Email 11/30/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: subpoenas Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00028921 PDF Atty/Client email re: subpoenas Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00029485 Email 11/21/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: corporate dissolution/settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00029486 Email 11/21/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: corporate dissolution/settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00029487 Email 11/21/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: corporate dissolution/settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00029488 Email 11/21/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: corporate dissolution/settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00029489 Email 11/21/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Benjamin Frenkel Atty/Client email re: corporate dissolution/settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00029490 DOC Draft petition Attorney-Client Privilege; Work Product Doctrine SH_00029859 Email 1/10/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00029892 Email 1/2/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00030261 Email 10/30/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00030263 Email 11/21/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00030264 Email 11/21/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00030678 Email 6/10/2020 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00030805 Email 11/30/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: subpoenas Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00030986 Email 10/4/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00030987 Email 10/4/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00030988 Email 10/4/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00030992 Email 10/31/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00031043 Email 9/27/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Benjamin Frenkel Atty/client email re: tax matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00031084 Email 9/28/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00031133 Email 11/13/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00031207 Email 9/11/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: case status/legal strategy Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00031836 Email 3/27/2018 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: Israel related matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00031839 Email 3/27/2018 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: Israel related matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00033684 Email 8/7/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: Frankel escrow issue Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00033990 Email 7/25/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00034163 Email 7/19/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00034164 Email 7/19/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00034165 Email 7/19/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00034166 Email 9/26/2017 Samuel Hertz Scott Eisenmesser Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00034348 Email 7/27/2017 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00034384 Email 7/11/2017 Yaron Kornblum Samuel Hertz Atty/client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00034385 Email 7/11/2017 Samuel Hertz Yaron Kornblum Atty/client email re: real estate matters Attorney-Client Privilege SH_00034386 Email 7/18/2017 Scott Eisenmesser Samuel Hertz Atty/Client email re: settlement Attorney-Client Privilege Page 4 of 9 FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 02/17/2023 06:02 PM INDEX NO. 526061/2019 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 227