Exhibit,Appendix: Barbara U. Collyer, Frank F. And Barbara U. Collyer, Iii Revocable Inter Vivos Trust v. Danielle M. Lavigne, New York Centraul Mutual Fire Insurance Company, Cfcu Community Credit Union, Town Of Lansing

• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                FILED:         TOMPKINS           COUNTY        CLERK        10/07/2020             03:51        PM                 INDEX    NO.   EF2020-0162
   NYSCEF     DOC.   NO.   35                                                                                 RECEIVED      NYSCEF:     10/07/2020
     CI2020-14163                                                                                                        Index # : EF2020-0162
   FILED:         TOMPKINS           COUNTY        CLERK        10/07/2020             03:51        PM                 INDEX    NO.   EF2020-0162
   NYSCEF     DOC.   NO.   35                                                                                 RECEIVED      NYSCEF:     10/07/2020
                                                                                                                         Index  #: EF2020-0162
    CI2020-14163



          Peter  J. Walsh


          From:                               Peter J. Walsh  
         Sent:                                Friday, June  12, 2020 12:51
         To:                                  'Byms,  Shawn  P
          Cc:                                 SallyT. True  (stt@truewalshlaw.com)
          Subject                             RE: Collyer vs.Danielle  LaVigne  et at




          Dear Shawn,


         Of course.   The  two cases  I mêñticñêd  - and            not        to make  an inclusive list-were:
                                                          certainly     trying


         Scarola  v. Insurance Campany    of North America,   31 NY2d  411, and
                                      Clizens'
          National Filtering Oil Co. v        Ins. Co.,of Mo.,  106  NY 535.


          From  the ccñversation,  itsounds  to me  likeJustice  McBride  has a reasonab!e   handle  on the matter,  even  at thisearly
         stage.


          I lookforward               your  document              on      175  or        as we  discussed.
                         to receiving                   response     the          before,


         Sincerely  yours,
          Peter J. Walsh



          From:  Byrns, Shawn   P. 
          Sent: Friday, June  12,2020  12:20
              'pjw@truewelsh!aw.com'
         To:                             
          Subject: Collyer vs. Danielle LaVigne  et al


          Peter,


          I hope  allis well. Just  wanted   to touch   base  quick  regarding   some   cases   you  meñticñad    during  the conference
          with the  court yesterday.    You  had  read  off the  cites forthe  judge,  but I was  unable   to correctly  write them
          down   I believe.  Ifpõssible,  can  you  send   me  those  case  cites  so that  I may  ascertain  your  contenticñ   raised  in
          the ccñference    and  so  thatI may   properly  inform  my   clientof the  basis  of your  position.  In linewith  Judge
          McBride's   direction, I believe  this willassist  in an expedited    resolution  to this matter.  Thank   you  in advance    for
          you  clarification.


          Best,
          Shawn




          Sha wn   P.9 y ms
          AWOCiate




                                                                          1