Party Discovery: LORI BUSH -V- ST BERNADINE MEDICAL CENTER Print

• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                J




        1
                MICHAEL J LIBMAN SBN 222353
                THE LAW OFFICES OF 1VIICHAEL J LIBMAN
        2
                18321 Ventura Boulevard Suite 700

        s       Tarzana Califomia 91356
                Telephone           81 8 995 7300                                                       F I L E D
                                                                                                SUPERIOR COURT OF CRLIFORNIA
        4
                Facsimile        866       644 6764                                              coutvn oF saN s RNARoitvo
                                                                                                  SAN BERNARDINO DISTRICT
                7 111   IiblYfpYlICtl tt   COJYt
        y
                                                                                                        SEP 2 9 2017
                GARY       BERKQVICH                 SBN 1 92731
        6
                A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATiON
                                                                                           sY
                14900 Ventura Boulevard Suite 220
                                                                                                         ANNE PERRY    EPUTY
                Sherman   aks Galifornia 91403

        8
                Telephonec          818 465 9505
                Facsimile        818 358 2829
        y
                Attorneys for Plaintiff LORI BUSH
    io



    11                                      SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALCFORNIA

    i 2                 IOR T IE COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO                                 SAN BE RIVARDINO DISTRICT

    i

                LORI BUSH            an    individual                             GAS     NO    CIVllS 1 F 13161
    i


                                      Plaintiff                                   Judge   Hon John M Pacheco
        5
                          vs                                                      Dept    S31


                                                                                  SEPARATE STATEMENT OF ITEM5 IN
                ST BERNARDINE MEDICAL CENTER                              a
                                                                                  DISPUTE WITH REASON TqR
                business entity form               uriknown     DIGNITX
    ls                                                                            FURTI IER RESPnNSES TO DEMAND
                FiEALTl I       a   California Corporation         and            FOIt P1Z ODUCTION OF DOGUMENTS               i
        9       DOES 1 through 200                  inclusive
                                                                                  SET TWO
    20
                                      Defendants

    21



    22



    23
                                                                                  DATE     November 7 2017
    z4                                                                            T ME      8 30 a m
                                                                                  DEPT      S3l
    25



    26



    21



    I8




                                                                              1
                    SF PARATE STATEIVTEN7 QT ITEMS IN DISPUTE WITH REASON I O1Z I UR CHER RESPO NSE
            i                                        R FPD SET TWO
                                                                                                                                           i
        1
                 TO DEFENDANT ANI I1 S COUNSEL OF RECOIzll
     2
                          Plaintiff LORI BUSFI hereby submits her Separate Statement of Items in Dispute a
     3
                follows

     4
                L         DEMANDS F OR PRODUCTYON OE D4C MENTS IN DISP UTE RESpOSNES
     5
                          AND REASONS FOIt JLTSTIFYING A FURTHER VERII IED RESPONSE
     6
                DEMAND EOR P120DiICTION N0 47


                          All photographs of the hathroom where Plaintiff fell as identified in your response t
            r



            F Form Interrogatory No 12 4
     9
                RESPONSE TO DEMAND EOR PRODUCTION NO 47

    lo                    Objection      attorney    client and oi work pi           duct   privilege pursuant to    CCP     2018 O10 e
    11
                seq Objection         this request   is   or   tnay be   violative of   Evidence Code
                                                                                                            1157 Specifically withou
1 2
                waiving said objections and in the spirit of cooperation defendant responds defendant wil
1 3
                comply       by   producing unprivileged documents             not   immune from       discovery    See response to iio
i
                49

    s
                REASON FURTHE R RESPONSE IS REOUIRED
1h
                         Plairitiff deinanded all phot s of the bathrooin where ilaintiff fell photos of her knee an

                all non privileged documents identified iii response to respcinses to the Special Interrogatoi ies
18
                Set Two       Defendant asserted attorney client privilege and work product to shield photos ari
l               videos of     the   bathroom from         discovery   Under Suezaki         v   Superios Cour t    1993   58 Cal 2d 16 6

                photos and videos are physical objects that are not subject to the work product or attorney clien
21
                protection absent showing that they show Defendant s trial strategy or mental impressions


73
                D EM AND 1 OR PRODUCTfON NO 48

                        All photographs of Plaintilf s knee as identified in your response to Forin Iiiterrogato
2               No    12 4


2               RESPONSE TO DElVIAND FO1t P ROID UCTION NO 48

27
                        Objection                   cl ient and or work product privilege pursuant to CCP                   2018 0 O e
                                        attorney

28              seq Objectiarr this      request     is   or   may be violative of      vidence     Code   1 157 Specifically withou


                                                                               2
                     SEPARATE STATEMENT OF ITEIVIS 1N llISPUTE WITH REASON FOR FURTHER RESPONSE
                                                                      RFPD    SI T TWO