Preview
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 12/10/2021 03:47 PM INDEX NO. 805265/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 30 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/10/2021
STATE OF
STATE OF NEW
NEW YORKYORK
SUPREME COURT:
SUPREME COURT! COUNTY
COUNTY OF OF ERIE.
ERIE
.....---_.....-..-.....-.-.....-.._-----.-..-_.........---.-...._._-_-._)(
------ Our
OurFIle
FileNo.
No.18011 DZSEB
18011DZSIB
N.J.S,
N.J.S, anan infant,
infant, by
by and
andthrough
through her
lier
. Parent and Natural Guardian,
Parent and Natural Guardian,
MICHELE SARDO,
MICHELE SARDO, and and
M§CHELESARDO,
MICHELE SARDO,Individually
Individually
Plaintiffs,
Plaintiffs, THIRD-PARTYSUMMONS
THIRD-PARTY summons
-V3-
- VS - index No.:
Index No.: 805255/2020
805265/2020
WEST SENECA
WET SENECA CENTRAL
CENTRAL SCHOOL
SCHOOL DISTRICT,
DISTRIQT,
WEST SENECA CENTRAL SCHOOL SCHOOLU1STR1CT
DISTRICT
BOARD
BOARD OF OF EDUCATION
EDUCATION AND AND
WEST SENIOR
WEST SENICR HIGHHIGH SCHOOL,
SCHOOL,
Defendants.
Defendants.
- t! _...X
X
WEST SENECA
WEST SENECA CENTRAL
CENTRAL SCHOOLSCHOOL DISTRICT,
DISTRICT,
WEST SENECA
WEST SENECA CENTRAL
CENTRAL SCHOOLSCHOOL DISTRICT
DISTRICT
EDUCATION AND
BOARD OF EDUCATION AND
SENEORHIGH
WEST SENIOR HIGHSCHOOL,
SCHCOL,
Potters Road
675 Potters Road
Seneca,New
West Seneca, NewYork
York 14224
14224
Titird-party Ptalntlffs
Third-Party Plaintiffs
VS
VS
CHRYSTLER LEE STORTZ STORTZ
Bamsdale Avenue
24 Bamsdale Avenue
Seneca, New
West Seneca, NewYorkYork 14224,
14224,
MECHAELJAMES
MICHAEL JAMESSTORTZ
STORTZ
Bamsdale Avenue
24 Bamsdale Avenue
Seneca, New
West Seneca, NewYorkYork 14224,
14224,
BARBARA
BARBARA ANNE ANNE STORTZ
STORTZ
Barneda!e Avenue
24 Barnsdale Avenue
West Seneca,
West Seneca,New NewYork
york 14224, and and
EXHIBIT
090;;;9¢ab4891ao
0901119cab4891d0 I usAAConfidentW—
UsAA
I
tbtgfidgntiaf"
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 12/10/2021 03:47 PM INDEX NO. 805265/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 30 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/10/2021
HEATHER THIBEAULT
HEATHER THIBEAULT a/k/a a/kfa HEATHER
HEATHERA. STORTZ,
A. STORTZ,
56 Sterxzit
56 Street
Stenzil Street
Tonawanda, New
North Tonawanda, New York
York 14120
14126
Defendants
Third-Party Defendants
. l l l i I l l * m- n4o_¢¢ln»
a¢ » u» » --
- -w..- Q U- - - 4 , p¢pX
--X
TO THE ABOVE
TO THE ABOVE NAMED
NAMED THIRD-PARTY
THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANTS:
DEFENDANTSI
YOU AREARE HEREBY
HEREBY SUMMONED
SUMMONED and and required
required toto serve
serve upon
upon the
the Defendants
Defendants //
Third~Parly Plaintiffs' attorneys,
Third-Party Plaintiffs' altorneys, an
an Answer to thethe annexed
annexed Thlrd~Par1y Complaint,which
Third-Party Complaint, which
Is herewith served upon you with
herewith served with pleadings in
all relevant pleadings in the
the action
action within
within twenty
twenty (20)
(20)
days
days after the service
after the service thereof,
thereof, exclusive
exclusive ofof the
the day
day of
of service,
service, or
or within
within thirty
thirty(30)
(30) days
days
after service
after is complete
service Is complete ifif service
service isis made
made by by any
any method
method other
other than
than personal
personal! delivery
delivery
to you
to you within the State
within the State of
of New
New York.
York.
in case
In case ofof your failure to
your failure to answer,
answer, judgment
judgment willwill be
be taken
taken against
against you
you byby default
default
for the relief demanded in the Third-Party Complaint.
Venue is
Venue is based
based upon
upon the
the addresses
addresses of of all
all parties
parties named
named in this
this litigation.
litigation.
Dated; West
Dated: West Seneca, New York York
January 19, 2021
BAXTER SMITH
BAXTER SMITH & & SHAPRRO,
SHAPIRO, P.C. P.C.
Ey:
By:
LOUIS B. 8.
49
DINGELDEY
.IV
J
J
Defendants/ Third-Pérty
Attorneys for Defendants/ Third-Pariy Plaintiffs
4
Iaintiffs
WEST SENECA
WEST SENECA CENTRAL
CENTRAL SCHOOL
SCHOOL
DISTRICT, WEST SENECA SENECA CENTRAL
CENTRAL
D1STR1CTBOARD
SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDOF OFEDUCATION
EDUCA TfON
AND WEST SENIORSENIOR NIGH HIGH SCHOOL
SCHOOL
Dwyer Street
182 Dwyer Street
West Seneca,
West Seneca,New NewYorkYork 14224
14224
(718) 854-6140
(716) 854-6140
. 1--
9D_1119,cab4891d0
09.§J_1118c ah4 891d0 I Ug-CD¥1f8
USAA e*niial
Confidential )
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 12/10/2021 03:47 PM INDEX NO. 805265/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 30 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/10/2021
TO:
TO: CHRYSTLER LEE LEE STORTZ
STORTZ
24 Barnsdale
24 BarnsdaieAvenue
Avenue
West Seneca,
West Seneca,NewNewYorkYork 14224,
14224,
NHCHAELJAMES
MICHAEL JAMESSTORTZ
STQRTZ
24 BarnsdaieAvenue
24 Bamsdale Avenue
WestSeneca,
West Seneca,New NewYork
York 14224,
14224,
BARBARA ANNE
BARBARA ANNE STORTZ
STORTZ
24 Bernsdale
24 BamsdaleAve Ave
West Seneca,
West Seneca,NewNewYorkYork 14224,
14224, and
and
HEATHER THIBEAULT
HEATHER THIBEAULT a/k/A a/I(/AHEATHER
HEATHERA. A,STORTZ
STORTZ
66
56 Stenzil
Stenzi!Street
Street
North Tonawanda,
North Tonawanda, New New York
York 14120
14120
PLEASE GIVE THESE THESEPAPERS
PAPERSTO TOYOUR
YOURINSURANCE
INSURANCECOMPANY COMPANYIMMEDIATELY.
IMMEDIATELY.
FAILURE TO DO DO SO MAY RESULT IN LOSSOF
SO MAY RESULT IN LOSS OFYOUR
YOURINSURANCE
INSURANCECOVERAGE.
COVERAGE.
CC:
CC: Joseph
Joseph L. L. Nicastro,
Nicastro,Esq.
Esq.
Cantor Wolff
Cantor WolffNicastro
Nicastro&&HallHall
Attorneys
Attorneys forfor Plaintiffs
Plaintiffs
Main Place
Main Place Tower
Tower
350 Main Street,
350 Main Street,Suite
Suite 2140
2140
Buffalo,
Buftafo, New York 14202
New York 14202
(716)
(716) 848-8000
848-8000
USAA Confidential
_09 0 1119_c ab 4 8 91d_0_ I l}sAACcxafider\tial
119.0111 &cab489.1d9 - -
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 12/10/2021 03:47 PM INDEX NO. 805265/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 30 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/10/2021
STATE OF DF NEW
NEW YORKYORK
SUPREME COURT;
SUPREME GOURT; COUNTY
COUNTY OF OFERIE
ERIE
.....---...--.-....--_..-_--__-_---_.--._...--...-._-..-.._...__._.X
OurFile
X Our FifeNo.
No.18011DZSIB
18011 Dzsss
N.J.S, an
N.J.S, an infant,
infant, by
by and
and through
through her
her
Natural Guardian,
Parent and Natural Guardian,
SARDO, and
MICHELE SARDO, and
Individually
MICHELE SARDO, Individually
Plaintiffs,
Plaintiffs, THIRD-PARTYCOMPLAINT
THIRD-PARTY COMPLAINT
-V5.-
-vs- IndexNo.:
Index No.: 805265/2020
805265/2020
SENECA CENTRAL
WEST SENECA CENTRAL SCHOOLSCHOOL DISTRICT,
DISTRICT,
WEST SENECA
WEST SENECA CENTRAL
CENTRAL SCHOOLSCHOOL DISTRICT
DlSTRiCT
BOARD OF EDUCATION AND AND
WEST SENIOR
WEST SENlOR HIGHHIGH SCHOOL,
SCHOOL,
Defendants.
Defendants.
SENECA CENTRAL
WEST SENECA CENTRAL SCHOOLSC-HCOLDISTRICT,
l;)isTRlcT,
SENECA CENTRAL
WEST SENECA CENTRAL SCHOOLSCHOOLDISTRICT
DISTRICT
EDUCATION AND
BOARD OF EDUCATION AND
WEST SENIOR
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL,
HIGH SCHOOL,
Third-Party
Third-Palfy Plaintiffs
Plaintiffs
VS
VS
CHRYSTLER LEE LEE STORTZ,
STORTZ,
MICHAEL
MICHAEL JAMESJAMES STORTZ,
STORTZ,
BARBARA
BARBARA ANNE ANNE STORTZ
STORTZ and and
HEATHER
HEATHER A. THIBEAULT a/k/a
A. THIBEAULT a/k/a HEATHER
HEATHERA. A.STORTZ
STORTZ
Third-Party
Thlrd-'partyDefendants
Defendants
-X
Defendants,
Defendants, WESTWEST SENECA
SENECA CENTRAL
CENTRAL SCHOOL
SCHOOL DISTRICT,
DISTRICT, WEST WESTSENECA
SENECA
CENTRALSCHOOL
CENTRAL SCHOOLDISTRICT
DISTRICTBOARDBOARDOF OFEDUCATION
EDUCATIONAND ANDWESTWESTSENIOR
SENIORHIGH HIGH
09 Q_1119cab4891d0
.0.9_Ql119c.ab4891do
USAA Confidential
USAA Confidential I
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 12/10/2021 03:47 PM INDEX NO. 805265/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 30 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/10/2021
SCHOOL (the
SCHOOL (the latter
latter of
of which
which'\isisnot
nota alegal
legalentity),
entity),bybytheir
theirattorneys,
atiomeys,BAXTER
BAXTERSMITH SMITH
SHAPIRO, P.C.,
SHAPIRO, P.C.,for
forIts
ItsThird-Party
Third~PartyComplaint,
Complaint,allege
allegethe
tlwe followingupon
following uponinformation
informationandand
belief:
belief:
1.
1. The Defendants
The Defendants f/ Third~Party
Third-Party Plaintiffs,
Plaintiffs, W EST SENECA
WEST SENECA CENTRAL
CENTRAL
SCHOOL DISTRICT,
SCHOOL DISTRICT,WEST WESTSENECA
SENECACENTRALCENTRALSCHOOL SCHOOLDISTRICT
DlSTR:CTBOARD BOARDOF OF
EDUCATIONAND
EDUCATION AND WEST
WEST SENIOR
SENIORHIGH HIGH SCHOOL
SCHOOL(hereinafter
(hereinafter "WEST
"WEST SENECA
SENECA
CSD") was
CSD") was and still
steel!
is is
aa publiceducation
public educationcorporation
corporationduly
cicily formed
formed andexisting
and existingpursuant
pursuant
and subject
and subject toto the
the laws
laws ofof New
New York
York State
State with
with offices
officeslocated
locatedatat 675
675Potters
PottersRoad,
Road,
West Seneca,
West Seneca, Newnew York,
York, 14224,
14224, andandisis still
still doing
doing and
and transacting
transactingbusiness
businesswithin
withinthethe
State of
State of New
New York.
York.
2.
2, Upon information
Upon information and
and belief,
boiief, at
at all
all times
timeshereinafter
hereinafter mentioned,
mentioned, the theThird-
Third~
Defendant, CHRYSTLER
Party Defendant, CHRYSTLERLEE LEESTORTZ,
STORTZ,was wasandandstill
stillIsisa aresident
residentofofthe
theCounty
County
Erie and
of Erie and State
Stateof of New
New York.
York.
3. Upon information
Upon information and
and belief,
belief,at
at all
all times
timeshereinafter
hereinaftermentioned,
mentioned,the theThird-
Third-
Party Defendant,
Party Defendant, MICHAEL
MICHAEL JAMESJAMESSTORTZ,
STORTZ,was wasand
andstill
stillisisa aresident
residentofofthe
theCounty
County
of Erie
of Erie and
and State
Stateof of New
New York.
York.
4. Upon information
Upon information and
and belief,
belief, at
at all
all times
times hereinafter
hereinafter mentioned,
mentioned, the theThird-
Third~
PartyDefendant,
Party BARBARA ANNE
flefendant, BARBARA ANNE STORTZ,
STORTZ,was wasand
andstill
stillisisaaresident
residentofofthe
theCounty
Countyofof
Erie
Erie and
and State
state of New York.
of New York.
5.
5. Upon information
Upon and belief,
information and belief, at
at all
all times
times hereinafter
hereinafter mentioned,
mentioned. the theThird-
Third»
Party Defendant,
Party HEATHER A.
Uefeodant, HEATHER THIBEAULTa/k/a
A. THIBEAULT a/kia HEATHER
HEATHERA. A.STORTZ
STORTZ(hereinafter
(hereinafter
"H EATHERA.A.THIBEAULT"),
"HEATHER Tl-IIBEAULT"), was
was andstill
and is is
stillaa resident
residentofofthe
theCounty
CountyofofErie
Erieand
andState
State
of
of New
New York.
York.
0_9_0113.9cala4891d0
.0.9-0111.99 a.b.4, 89 ld()
W USAA Confidential)
l
usAA C9l'\fid6l\\i8l
FILED: ERIE COUNTY CLERK 12/10/2021 03:47 PM INDEX NO. 805265/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 30 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/10/2021
6.
6. N.J,S,an
N.J.S, an infant,
infant, byby and
and through
through her Parent