Exhibit,Appendix: JOYCE JUELCH, ET AL VS. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B/P)AS REFLECTED ON EXHIBITS et al

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                wo oN DBD GF FF WO N

oa

11

BRYDON
Tuco & PARKER
185 MAIN STREET
20" FLOOR
San Francisco, CA 94105,

John R. Brydon [Bar No. 083365]
Robert C. Crane [Bar No. 197667]
Thomas J. Moses [Bar No. 116002]
BRYDON HUGO & PARKER

135 Main Street, 20th Floor

San Francisco, CA 94105
Telephone: (415) 808-0300
Facsimile: (415) 808-0333

Attorneys for Defendant
UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION

ELECTRONICALLY
FILED

Superior Court of California,
County of San Francisco

MAR 03 2010

Clerk of the Court.
BY: CHRISTLE ARRIOLA
Deputy Clerk

SUPERIOR COURT - STATE OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO - UNLIMITED JURISDICTION

JOYCE JUELCH and NORMAN JUELCH,

7

Plaintif{(s),
vs.

ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B*P),

Defendants.

(ASBESTOS)
Case No. CGC-09-275212

EXHIBITS A THROUGH E -
DECLARATION OF THOMAS J. MOSES IN
SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT UNION
CARBIDE CORPORATIONS MOTION FOR
SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR, IN THE
ALTERNATIVE, SUMMARY
ADJUDICATION

{Filed With Notice of Motion; Memorandum
of Points and Authorities; Compendium of
Out of State and Federal Authorities; and
Separate Statement of Undisputed Material
Facts]

Date: March 18, 2010
Time: 9:30 a.m.

Dept.: 220

Judge: Hon. Harold E. Kahn

Complaint Filed: May 20, 2009
Trial Date: April 5, 2010

DECLARATION OF THOMAS J. MOSES IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE
CORPORATIONS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, SUMMARY

ADJUDICATIONEXHIBIT A83/21/2005 aa a2 831-386-4468

oe JOHN L MYERS PAGE 92
oay2iv2dos 1d: BAX L21z50p9641 “oopptce =f @ovarond
INTHE CIRCUIT COURT OF ASHLEY COUNTY, ARKANSAS °
DON LEB HART
. Plaintifi,
yw . Case No. CIV-2000-203-3
AN. CHESTERTON CO. st al.,
“Defendants.
A: 1. MYERS

STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
: )
COUNTY OF MONTEREY }

John L. Myers, being Sst duly sworn, states on oath as follows:

1 Tama resident of the State of California, over 18 years of age and competetit to
sive this Affidavit. The thets contained in this Affidavit are based upon my personal knowledge,
jnformation and belief, The fuots set firth inthis Affidavit are true und correct to the best of my
knowledge. ‘Wéswom as a witness, 1 could testify competently to the.facts contained herein,

2. was.employed by Union Carbide Corporation (“Union Catbide") from 1951 to.
1985, During ny career working for Union Carbide, 1 served in several different capacities, 1
became involved In Union Carbide’s asbestos group in Niagara Falls, New York in 1966. From -
1967 to 1970, 1 was technical superintendent at the King City wiine and mill in King City,
Colifornia at which Union Carbide’s Calida ashestos ‘wis mined and processed, respectively.
From 1970 to 1981, T served a3 Marketing Manager for the Union Carbide Calidria asbestos
‘business. In 1984, 1 was promoted to Product ani Production Manager for tho King City-aa/2L/2008 19:42 ‘831-385-4458 SOHN 1, MYERS PAGE 83

“93/21/2008 14:01, FAK 12128083682 : ORRICK . - fonavoo4

asbestos opértions, 1 served in thls eapacity unl Union Carbide sold its asbestos business it

1985. As a result of my years. of experience with Union Carbide’s asbestos business, T am

famfliar swith the various applications and uses of Union Cathide’s Calidria ashestos, By virtue

of my position with Union Carbide, [ bed siestings with Union Carbide’s customers and

repulatly reviewed reporis vaitten by Calidvia satesrnen that sumamarized meetings with Union
: Carbide customezs.

4, Union Carbide began mining and milling ‘its nique, shortfiber chrysotile
asbestos near King City, California in 1963. The King City mine was the only asbestos mine
operated by Union Carbide, Union Carbide sold the raw asbestos first under the name “Union
Carbide Asbestos,” and then under the ttade name “Colidtia.” ‘The asbestos was mined-by Union
Cotbide and sold in bulk form to various purchasers who incomponsted and used it in
mannfaoturing various products, Union Carbide did not sell Calidria to the generat public.
Throughout the time that Union Carbide was in the Calidria asbestos business, It remained a
yelotively small player in the ashestos business due to the limited applications in which its unique
Calidrin fiber could be used, In fact, to the bestof my knowledge, from the time Union Carbide
‘began operating fis mine through the 1970s, Union Catbide never supplied more than 5% of the
asbestos used in the United States. "

5. Union Carbide did not market of sell its Calica asbestos for use in gant,
valves, pamps, packing mateciale, pipes or pipe covering, pipe insulation, blork insulation, spray
insulation, boiler Insulation, farnace insulation, compressor insulation, pump insulation, turbine
jnsulotion, seftactory products, acoustical plaster, lathe material, cloth, roofing or siding shingles,
boilers, furnanes, spray on fireproofing, wallboard, dry wall, firebricks, or brakes,

in fact, due to its unique chirestetistics, Calideia asbestos was not suitable for09/21/2805 13:42 831-385-4468 JOHN L MVERS PAGE
12085 1 64

93/2172005 14701 FAX 12425083641. ORRICK Boose

‘

applications associated with pipe tovering, insulation or other high-temperature products, To the
best of my knowledge, shere ate no end usets who used Union Carbide’s Calidria asbestos in
geskets, valves, pumps, packing materials, pipes or pipe sovering, pipe insulation, block
insulation, spray insulation, boiler insulation, fornace ‘insulation, compressor insulation, ‘pump
insulation, turbine insulation, reffactory products, acoustical plaster, Jathe material, cloth, roofing ©
or siding shingles, boilers, furnaces, spray on fireproofing, svallboard, Arywall, firebricks, or
“trees,

6. As Union Carbide -was a Jate comer to the asbestos business, many of its
customers had been using other types and supplies of asbestos for many years prior to purchasing
Calidria fim Union Carbide. . ,

1 Union Carbide did supply Calidtia for use in mastics. However, I.do-not recall
the names of the manufacturers t0 whom Union Carbide sold Calldria for this particular use.
Union Carbide did sell Calidria to Mensento, but Ido not recall the use Monsanto intended to
make, of did make, of the Calidria. In any event, Union Carbide would not have sold Calidria to
manufacturers, Monsanto or otherwise, for use in any product prior to late 1963, the first year
Uaion Cube mined md sold Calida. The 1963 produetion of Calla asbestos wag limited to
an.amount wvolued at apptosimately $9,000.00.

FURTHER ARFIANT SAYETHNOT:

wat at yp

GANTHIA HAVER.

* common # 1477887
Notary Putas Califomia %
Monistey County
B” My Cornyn tepies Mar 20, 2008

SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before
me this G1 day of March, 2005,

“tyeEXHIBIT B07/29/2008 18:03 FAK 12125083")

ORRICK . sy _ , 0027005

JOHN L. MYERS, of full age, being duly sworn scoording to law, upon bis oath &
/ 1. Tam a resident of the State of California, over eighteen years of age and”:
: completo gv he fait The facts contained in this affidavit are base upon tay personal 2
towed crn dunn hat have eviews ad ae re and comet th bet fy
2, T was employed by Union Carbide Cerpomtion ("UCC") from 1951 ntl 1985, I°
served in several capacities as a UCC employes. In 1966, 1 began wosking for UCC’ asbesins :
group 2s a reseatch engineer, From 1967 until 1970, I was the technical superistendent of UCC's .
asbestos plant in King City, Califomia. As technical superintendent, mysresponsibilities: « .-.
included making sre the raw asbestos met proceasng standard From 1970 intil 1981, Twas
the marketing manager for asbestos. in 1981, 1 becaie the product and production: manager ot a
UOC's plant in King City, California, Theld that position until 1985. Because of my dutiés while. .
employed by UCC, 1 have personal knowledge about UCC’s Cafidria raw asbestos’ and about
UUCCs supply of Calidea raw asbestos to various manufacturers, oe
3. "ave reviewed CC's reeords reganting the sale of ls raw chrysotile asbesiog .
(kxowa as “Calidtia” asbestos) to Hanailton' Materials (“Hamilton”). Hamilton manufactured .
tape joint compound, a2 well a3 ofter products, I have also reviewed certain documents :
produced by Hamilson relating to its purchase of Calidria. :27/20/2008 15:03 FAX 42525087" "5 ORRICK Toos/o0s

4.

4 UCC sold iis Calidhia raw asbestos in very small amounis 10 thind-party
manufacturers beginning in late 1963. UCC did not sel any significant quantities of Calidria to
tps ont comp mnt fo ef te ola compo sl pony ht
to late-1960s, UCC gol its Calida busines nts entirety in 1985. , - 4

8 UCC sald tet gies of ibn incon $010 ed $6210 (60

_ Calida asbestos grade SG-210. While it was possible to use Calidtia asbestos grade SG-130 in
tape joint compounds; tothe best of my knowiedge, 1 do not recall any tape jeint compound
"maratpe ho wed 86-90 fri pom UCC also sold Calideia asbestos in grades RG-
"144 (RG meant “resin grade”) and HPO (HPO meant “high purty open’ fiber);:however these.

" grades were not marketed for use, andto my knowlédge not used, in tapejointeompoundss ° =. :

6. Generally as a matter of business practice, tape joint compound manufticturers
_ would purchase the raw ingredients necesjary to make their prndcts ftom sever] row mtd
: suppliers, fie topo jolt compound manuitunrs pucased abe tom UCC, most of
- them were already manufacturing asbesos-containing tape jojnt compound using asbestor from
‘Suppliers other than UCC, and had best doing 90 for years, UCC generally servedias an
“stsmate asbestos sppier for these manufhtares, who had besa wing sbexos sup by
compenies, including Jobns Manville, Atlas and Philip Carey. As most of these manufacturers
already lsd established relationships with other asbestos suppliers, to my knowiedge, UOC was
never the exclusive supplier of asbestos to its tape jolit compound manufhctorer-cistomers,
With the exception of a few small sample quantity shipments, UCC never sold a
its Calideia asbestos direcly to Hamilton, All asbestos sales to Hamilton were made through
UCC's distibutors specifically, Wester Chemical & Mannfactating Company and Harrisons07/20/2005 15:04 FAX 12125063) ORRICK 004/005

& Crosfield (Pacific) Inc.
8 Ta addition to distributing Calidria, Harrisons & Croafield also distributed
various other products mamsfactined by UCC that did not contzin asbestos.
“9, _ Prior to 1974, -UCC only sent samples or isolated quantities of HPO, §G-130 ae.
and RG-144 io Hamilton, Ini my experieace and tothe best of my recollection, these types of ,
: ‘asbestos werd not geietlly used in thé maintain of ape joint compounds. (See Exhibits-A,

'B, and ©). Moreover, even if any Of these Calidria grades were somehiow used! in Hamilton's on
‘imamate ‘of tape joint compound (pict to 1974, these purchases sry not consiant wid
"mounts iat would needed in an exclusive supplier ratomhip

10. “Thave soviowed my notes regarding siberian lcs from. this tie period and
‘hey ae consistent with my recolecton thet, as Inte 26 August 1972, Hamilton still had not
tte UCC's 86-210 for oe in ts tae joint compounds (Sce Exhibits D and 5) ! Bos

i.” In fume 1974, "UCC hepan applying Hamiton with $6-210, an asbestos grade
ht was se or wen pe joi compos
- 2. "ive reviewed letter deed Iemary 6, 1975, sent by me to'our Hasiition =
distributor, Hasisons & Crosfield (Pacific) Inc. ‘This leer is consistent withmhy récolecion- =
tat up until cis point, Hamilton had not been purchasing significant amouits of Celica i

| asbestos, , (See Exhibit F) =:

3 vce el tems pe ta, ngs ue 1
dated Fébruary 25,,1983 from Gene Haiz to Linda Wayne (Exhibit G), a document entitied
“Hamilton Materials Asbestos Fiber Purchases,” (Exhibit H) and various pages that appear to
be taken from Hanilton’s “Accouating Raw Materials Ledger.” (Exhibit 1) All of dese.
documents show that during te time period wherein. Hamilton was purchasing asbestos

A
a : 307/20/2005 16:05 FAX 1212506" > ORRICK ey oos/oos
} ' o

supplied by UCC, it was also purchasing asbestos fromi E.S, Browning Company, Pacific

Asbestos, Jaoquays, Asbestos, Als Asbestos and John K, Bice. These docamesis are

consistent with my recollection that UCC was not Hamilton's exclusive asbestos suppiier. 5
FURTHER AFFIANT SAITH NOT mt

Commission #° 1477537

Notary Public - Catitomia ge
Monisrey County

My Comm. Expires Mat 20, 2008}EXHIBIT Aro . Joe oo

: Ueaseoorases
i .EXHIBIT B- SEE . Voese Ivy I NH od U ea aA
PSSSSSOCOHOO TSH DFIFOFGSOOOESESOSOOHOO

- UCASB00072264EXHIBIT C% oy,
)
jNION GARSIDE CORPORATION westE§ ACCOUNTING COPY

1 Bie !
if
° ea AMONING AND METALS DIVISION

Tea

om te ay bres te
Fr oe APOE noun AND AACS WSO

Pale Bon, tt Blog reid
T_[otenpteoes ad andes tha 4, ey

aaa EE EE Ag
a °

. a 1
Vs ea UNION CARBIDECORPORATION + SALES ACCOUNTING .copy ‘J
MINING AND METALS DuvISION
° .
swe1o

"Honddton atarinla, Tate
Heahs
Orange, California

inVOIKE Ta

‘SORSLFCNHER ADOLES teow nie Winvekatin T1903, ‘than ang long fo
TO] vroan crus eosrorstion, astern ano astais onoss UNIGH CARMOE CORPORATION, MINING AND DAETALS BIVISION
Balls Hox "1, Bg 0 ati Gaastorasa goon | Pols Dox 2045 Gaston Haves Post Otten
Wa bareby a

apie oa ppb geen ot ath & Pica WE Ube Fa Led Bala RAW BO OO

UCASB00857998EXHIBIT D| _ Shorthand °

: No. 182
Notebook GREGG RULED

4
GEORGE ‘H. COURTER CO... INC.

316 WTRE FOURTH STREET
NIAGARA FALS, NEW Vor 14303

UCASB02791622UCASB02791702EXHIBIT £ET,

Pannen

©

FT

! .
|
{
v .
t oo 2
| . Shorthand
i: j o /
: Notebook
No. 210 6C
HOELSCHER'S INC. 1
. 3905 Geneseo Stroot
' . Buffalo 25,N. Ye
fo “TEL. 634-1090"
.
| _ , -
NAME t ‘ Nv ers
te pate nu Weft fo) pbypo- pre
RUBBER EDGES
poe “ tee ee

UCASB02791194KO Maris "96

: UCASB02791214EXHIBIT F3 ay

. bec: -G, L. Vessels
- Me CL Thurber:

y UEDPHOCARAEDE CORPORATION AAINING A METALS DISION

FL BORSTO~ WOMARAAUS, Ys B02 >“ WELSTUERIOOTE

January 6, 1975

Hr, Wharton Jackson. :

Harrisons & Crosfield {Pacific} Inc. -

4000 Birch Street : .
Newport. Beach, CA 92660 “ .

Qear Wharton:

“My apologies for not answering your Jetter. more promptly. "It had slipped
40 the middie of 3 very Targe pile. . -

If you originate business and a customer inadvertently places an order
directly with us, we certainly intend to make an appropriate adjustment.
T.do not think Supro is a good example since I started: working on
Bi Labud before he went to Florida; and the final OX to use SG-210 was
the direct result ef our efforts in Florida. 1 amnot belittting your

* efforts but E don't agree -that you "priginated* this business.

Ve vere anticipating sizeable business from customers with thom We have .
had Tittle success, such as Hamilton, Xalser, and Paco, because of your
_ Yapport with them. You can be assured.of proper credit. for this type
_ business, and from the paper accounts which you service. ©

Since our.distributor agreement is not exclusive, we cannot establish a
system with King City for automatic credit, Again, if a customer you
develop or have serviced regularly places an order direct, xe Wi) make
‘an 2djustment. We are looking for new business frow you und wi? wake
the appropriate “reward” for it.

Siice we do not warehouse tn the Los Angeles or San Francisgo areas, we
- would prefer customers order from you and will suggest, that ‘to then -
as We have always done. However, we will not ‘nsist that they dp this. -

Untess I am mistaken or misinformed we have "turned over” a majority
of the customers you sow service and we ere Jess than fully satisfied
with the ‘amount of new or Increased business, you have generated. J
should be out during the first quarter of this year and would Vike to
discuss the overall picture in more detail With you, The main emphasis

RECEIVED
dhe 7 G75

UCASB01412B89 °Mp. Wharton Jackson” Be danuary'6, 1975 -

. Should be on what We can both do to generate more sales of talidria.

“Very truly yours,

set Mr. RE, Byrne oe .
Te PB. Norris .
_ fds
; .
ho.

“UCASBO1412800EXHIBIT G+

Os-a-04 ° 058A From - - Tor pays F702

8 hamilton's
/ 345 Wedt bouts Avarse * Orange, Cobforfs * Fhobe (714) BH-i71b

Feuruary 35, 583°

Additional information bas been brugkt to ny acténtion sinos my resp
to Interrogatory dared February 18, 198%, This infomation would

2 my oe eee Se Ee Corrected reply should be md
| ated th read: —— oe

(8) Four types of asbestos were purchased fnem two scares.

A. Cansdiew asbestos sel thre i
Broming Cg Dy Was fhe CayayeConudianEXHIBIT H—  @ Be
tani Materiate e.... . . : . 2590
jnmanufachingaabiestoscontaling crywel products? . .
( wy _ Cae ttsiparl) rou 177

“pare UNION HARRISONA ATLAB—_JAQUAYS JOHNS JOHN
: canoe cpoepe.n ASBESTOS ASBESTOS MANVILLE iC BICE

“BrobTs .
2075 «BEAD
‘22-0875 : 636.00
29-00-75 9503.40 .
; 467208 :
o> 2703.00
40719.09 o ”
ao o 497982 : .
2148.50 *
2113.78
3021.00
8620.00
.16134,30 . ’
. 7800.00"
1058.00
1880.09
048,25
1431.00
5004.12
1985.75
6121450 wale
10460.00
. + 4989.60
. 16BQ 0
6385.75 .
2021.00 .
3018.00
- 3224.00 %
02.Feb-76 oo. 080,18
11-Feb-76 2 $4888.00
42-Feb-76 . . . 4004.64
VaFob-78 © ' 2, : 30170.72
16-Feb-76 » : a “5085.28 .
19-Feb-78 ~ 95480.18
2OF eb 76 290.00 :
27-Feb-78 40568.80 -
27-Feb-76 5019.50 . . .
O2-Mar76 . ~ + 17824.28 . tok
KAINSUREDW7061UNIONG-HARRIS, +
Net -oo

arama ran rec .

For use in manufschising. asbestos containing drywall products”
Period 878\partial rough 1977 oe

DATE HARRISON & anlas JAQUAYS JOHNS

JOHN

pape SROs ASBESTOS ASBESTOS MANVILLE, BICE

16568.68

1875.00 .

8414.04: Hamilton Matatals Asbestos Fiber Purchases
Cee For use in manufactuting sbestns containing drywal products?
mo pertod 1978tpartial) through 1877
DATE UNION HARRISON & ATLAS JAQUAYS. «JOHNS» = JOHN

‘CARBIDE, SROSFRS ASBESTOS ASBESTOS MANVILLE kK BICE

1OMarT7. . $804.00

10-Mar-77 2000.00
18-MieT? 4044740
JCUNJUREOQTESEWUNIONC- HARRIS

atab.00

6819.70 .

1568,00

(6031,68Hamilton Materials Asbestos Fiber Purchases :
Foruse in manulachtiing asbestos containing drywall products” : . . . .
Period 1978(partial) through 1977 : :

pate - UNION HARRISON ATLAS JAQUAYS JOHNS JOHN
. CARGIDE CROSFIELO ASBESTOS ASBESTOS MANVILLE K.BICE
ERD

4800.00 :
2004.60 °
1407.10
5677.18
. * 85254,78
654,00."
, * g50p-9a
: . $800:00. oe
22876:60
yen48.00 . ;
24925.00 ‘
22562.50° .
8507.20
1812.50
| 22752.00
78400,00 ot
28087.60
1258.25
_ . $60.50 :
. cunen 2150.00
- 42 - 71954860 -
. 2887.50
15241,38 o :
277 : : 1770.00
> OUT 14258.00 . ny
< OtJURTT | 4407.10 :
19 0UL7T > “es008.b0
14duLTT 1817.50
2u-TT 2400.00 :
281-77 10512.60
29uK77 7880.50
D1-Aug-77 : : TE.
C2-AugT? et 19140,90 .
O5-Aug-77 22000,00°~ :
10-Aug-77 2876.00
12-Aug-77 aa2eRaD
18-Aug-77 91448.00
22-Aug-77 8562.60
2o-Augt7 2072.50
08-Sep-77 10819.60
13-Sepa77 . 7885.00
18.Sep-77 47189.60
‘23-Sep-77 335,00ot

‘Hamilton Materials Asbestos Fiber Purnhases,
For use in marmsfactoting asbestos containing drywall products"
. Period 1975{partial} through 1977

pare UNION HARRISON ATLAS JAQUAYS JOHNS JOHN
CARBIDE_CROSFIELD ASBESTOS ASBESTOS MANVILLE iC BICE

“Gai —OCOS:C~*« BAD
1608
21-00-77 TITAN :
g1-On-77 254849
DaNowT7 : . - 4240.00
OENoW7 61646.00
18-NOTF . . 9628.00
ieNGTT . 18449705”
“qyowTT °° $0701.00 .
2BNOeTT 2400.00
BONGTT * fe906.42
a0-Nov7? 24451.00
‘Total Fiber from each vender? . . .
: 31g80 (2239839 18097 12240 1568 22025

‘Total Fibar Purchases from All Vendors:
2.51448 -

Pércentage of Total Purchased from each vendor :
420% = BEED% 0, 70% O47% 0.00% . 10.93%.

. snlony Carbide and Harsison Crossfield combined purchased:
Lon BBBsaB 8 aTEae

Source: From the deposition of Mr. Edward Eugene Hatz, person most knowledgeable for
Haniiltlon Materials, taken Jn the matter of Strawn ¥. Fiberboard Corp,, USDC WD,
of WA at Tacoma, WA, Case No, C85-539T, dated December 8, 1988, andthe

- altached Exbibit 4 to that deposition, the Accounting Raw Material Ledger Cards. .

wEXHIBIT Ioo oO

MF

: ® Acco RAW MATERIALS
€ . to -  Lepoer

Meru Dew Materiale eee ast

seeeae ae
ATLAS Nene

sf + TUNAisoNy cagarTED
oo BE tygH? Aino:

TB3883}

SUCUI LABS, Tan3369:
COSA OFANOAL THAISNA:
, OW CHEMICAL TIDWION >:

BIq9NAGE
§3Z979.9
aTAseeD -
eonss1s
amasla:
920,087A
2229946

* MARRISONS & CASSFIELD

+ AIRS BIE

J ani Bice , 997,9393°

£ BASF WeAMOOTTE pagenen:
conml CHEMICAL a

i AE 3 AIRS S | T7HSIOS,

+ MUONEST SOLVERTS INES £002,272%-

pox. 724omy,

9
z038 | 9
ee | REST iuze
DARL UND AD 0D SA 21 314239 SS173.85
HARRISOND& CROSFJELO [NS , wRibOBS
ATLAS ASBESTOS 49,16089 | s2.6at
copa OMENGAL szaazay| 67.9928"
BASF WT, 67.99189 | THEIL. |
contpios: ° 83,783.6¢
MCKESSON CHOMICAL OR7723°
EXIM BORDEN | 223,839.76
= CATANIA PQeUENT Tat,239.94
: ateO ROLIMERS Za'| Z29.973.9¢
_ ONAL K BIGE 220.313"
GEXTAAL SOLVENTS 9 | 273,057"
CRNERAL SOLVENTS 223.7833
WARNISONS B CAOSFIELD| ane 2530828 |
BIAIKD SAMICK ” 2570393 -
£ SAS BYMOOTTE ya) 26%Dto3
ANGELES CHEMICAL 21b739
| OW CHEMICAL 286,999
BOADEN CHEM CAL 304.1 99.1:

309,709.15PeIZER
PFIZER.

oueaa eReoucrs ©

wiTER

DOW CHEMICAL
CARLING ND

“PFIZER |

WARADSONS BCROSFIELD| WHO 2083)

eB CHRON,
MOELES CHEGICAL

DARLING: MIO: CD

oo

92766 R
maIeTE == 02.618 |
236,988 f

{sea

| Saeed

ZOLS 9S

PIAS

3963292

‘So6,0ha75
377,0h84-
Sonoewa-

| aszee22

265,618

y | 242ATIS
J 291,8035

2645105
‘ZMSNZT
2902922
2630922

43370043,

3470995
Beodsse

fsanenee

392.6402
nph3ZOn
41,8900
8219508
HOLT
WOLI3AS

BAL FWD.ARISONS & CAOST FELD
TAT SHBATERT.
FUND AK BO. |
NIN, SAVONTS
LAS ASBESTOS
HH BICE”
“RESSON, CHEMICAL
Lunes
ALG ND CO
SPER CHEMICAL
GELES DHE CAR,

TAU PIOUENT
CARA CAR,
wR .
DEL CAEICAL
4AN GHOMICAL
S908 ChEULOAL

20 POLYMERS
VELHAAD MINT ERALS-
ATA SOLVENTS,
NK BICE .
TIBAEYS AECOND
ADEH CHEMICAL
A CHEUDAL,ASF WYAMDETTE
YS CHBUOAL
iZER

ZER .
sARESONS J CANSFIELD

163,797 S 7
3 82,039.93.

YUERS
SESSON CHEMICAL
aA, SOLVENTS:
IDEN SHEWACAL
WZER

CHEMICAL
ER

aoewcL | *
eB . ‘ 33,09048 2
uN KR SICE . 54922.7 4°,
BRISONS bb CROOF LEGO 4792.7 wf
AON TRODIAS
SAN CHEMICAL, 26,098,98
A CHEICAL 10309894 ,
B1OSSEHT .
a 77w. a72Ke| agiaas
Boe7 | WeahhD,

a :
H*EDION CHEMGAL, -
AQTN CIEL ICAL
TAM PLOMENT,
AAISONG & CROBFIELD
toh AAO
ACEH CHEMICAT,
Leip .
ANISONS & CROSFIELD
ITER ao
no 30N GHUICAL

“+ apen"guedioay ~

ANSON & CROSFIDO
eas.

132067028
3Saqs5e20 °
| S48 90209
33q08010 °
DELS TNS IOAS |
STONERS
Bazsoass
G1 I947 7000
<) SOI EELS
§] ObbSIAT
b36,93207
wZEStae2

" ANSN267 *

fon ASD

NTWAL SOLVENTS
ARIIONS & CASSFSELD
ADER CHEMICAL

WEA 4
AISONS & CROSFIELD
WER

ALING MD CO

“BOEN CHEMICAL, 4009287
7 HOA CO 3008287
(co POLYMERS - 227,00287
AQELHAAD UN NERALS +] 3208287me CADEICAL
SCH CHEMICAL
ins te CAOSFIELO [ARTO
Tz [ar 5 Te.

7 SHEMSCAL Rae

IRISONS Be GROSFIELGI NNN %

APART [wae

ANTRAL SOLVINTS. ay

TOHMGAL ir bw
ESTAEY = - [WARS

TERIATINAL, OMSEIN ‘|p
“SAN -CHOEIBAL

wa”
MIRAL DUYENTS:

aye”

ANISOAS & CACOFELO [PATIOS
A0EN Chea

HOA,
Vien .

AVSONS b CROSFIELO
TAN SHDAIGAL,
ai X SICE

"ARIS ONS & CROSFIELO
ATER :
LING AND 60

SELES ibuoAL
+ CHDAICAL +
TRA, SOLVENTS

+ 95.65
e8bsb

292381 6
3363

3073.00
781 03.3 9,
bRObt Bethae
e8bus | 855.00)
T4366 Altona

524,444

Leinapse
boney
su 9052

enneanz
ATRABASZ +
ataetzas =

agezers2 |
35uzago2:
a scend.sz
n3204122
deantiesa
RbZOBTS:
57099978 -
208,78
87.3 64-78
07228
AeAONTZO -
AVLBITZ
Sokaesas
336.5133.
[oass7LLS *
{25876145
| ssncezes ~we

ves gp

DALING & CO
OATLING RID CO
CENTRE SOLVENTS
WHER BICE

THT aeM ProMDi"

eras
Ee bs
ae
eho

z
BEE

123,023.09"
22006109

"CORN CHEAICAL 4113203940.
RIZER 2aRFIO92-
HARRISON b OROST JELD 1 1089097
BORDEN CHEBIICAL 231762
HARAIBONS b GROSFIEDL {ul 2207242
‘HARRIS OHS” b’ CROW ELD. 293,69612
BOAODA CHEMICAL 2) 242,665.22
CENTRAL. SOLVENTS * 2 | 265.717.98
D8 2NSOLER

COSAT CHEMICAL 2909928.

5: 344.12327
FAZER

337.45056
ares
que

3 thease. oY
s9z5010 7}
S9NTISST
SON O088T
24,219.92)bar9200 Vanaeasa | atesan a:
© SCOLANOND SHAGRG OO 8 | 323750 ginss3a [> 9as90g.
3 PXARUUIRO MLsERALS i onesaet
1. BORDEN CHeMroat, 92454424
Dow cleMoA, + [35889773
U ontan. sven. [J 29879573
4 HAARYSONS 4 SROSFIELD| 202872.73
; sie MD oi
“GENERAL MILLS.

; HAAASONS &, CROSFFELO.
ENGELHAAD WONERALS
WARRISONS & cROSTI ELD |

5 Soe fae

{. parting “Mpoe - - *
© GENERAL MILLS -
2 LARD POLYUERS

AE SRALEY. ©

sade ++ BORDEN

Teer erie

ANT EPA AT ONAL: OASELN,

aan onic |
325,900 baesaz0

ps0 1209 *
262.344.9 9 -
26538318
3ob05300

CAL

6  a1039.08 |

2136 |
AL, 525.930 b2669.90

. * WAR, EWo.
es .

40,9707 8Samsere.
SREY

DARL AND 0D

COSAN CHEMICAL
CEMAM, IOLEENTS
HARRISONS & GRO

S2757| 6002779
SIGSTIO:
$002 7651
6032 473:
Ra 92,0359°
T12535a

DAU AD, oo
HODNDER CO
BORDEN CHERIGAL -
_ SROELES CHEMICAL
CENTRAL SOLVENTS

PRIZER

wansoNE G cACSFIELD |un1s 4033, AZ99SH3 | 7336972,
‘DON CHEMICAL R b O | T39h 781
BAS WHMOUTTE TWHNI B01

“HARRISONS b CASOFHELD 28281 7641622

CENTRAL SOLVENTS

1 SBM Stas iateszs

t owt 26 co 167.4528
1933608

2522430

| 234.0328 "—|. 39 « * © FY & 8

scooury “Bow Materigis acer. we 950
- . . . . tomar nt. ,
er
's RPgPT Oe con ewriwened "paunege |, eM ep matbeee’

Tames s cara

2 PRUER :
* PeHIER
BOROEN OHEMECAL
WOVEST SOLVENTS
DUAMOND SHARDCK

2e78a701
Fomasia
31RhIe2-

BORDEN 32207101
‘Hee Soearsat
* saw S7R0IS44

aes ‘378093.72 ©

COLLOIDS | -BOZ0b12¢

+ DMMLIND

cine

30K3h822
4012202"

> “uo KEsson :
PFIZEA S2ANb3TE
7 DUMOND STE ABZ1037:
wee COST CHMAIDAL A2KOITSE
DARLING AND CO ss Paue f., waee233:

T aqutna, souvent a
1 HARRISONS b CROSFIELO:
+ BOAOey cHOUICAL

BOLG23S:
whtThI3;
AS NITS:

99,900 | 320000

, * Pow CHEMICAL | 9928033;
: 1 COSAN GHERIOAL ]poxse0r~
; PFOTER . |. 5032997. -
~ enw Bice » | 929,793.7
WORESSOH CHEMI GAL. p7ae032:
‘BORDEN CHWICAL 938273 ~
F wanascets w onosr ety Sekes74
; SoLLorDs 9936784

a8 3,085] s05an

5358728
49382

{MIDWEST soLveNs
* SPRARER seaesa7

“ WER

Neg

of 3 97ny S28

ORSTED |‘cosa One
THTAUUE PISO

“_MIDWeST SOLVENTS 73438397

PrIZEAS 433950.
BORDEN CHEMIOAL 3809208
- BoM 5 sasane2
HARRISONS & CROs HELD , BIRR? | 12770332
INTERNAT JOH, CASEIN | [20073 pe 393,999.52
eo PoLruts b 23830532
CGNIRK sounors 29325982
GENERAL MILLS zoaoon82
BYOEUHARD wiNTERALS .*| a3 (21 zexa7007
“pO oneal GAT 3sHO02e2
» DSA CHEM CA, 330,80082
+ COSY. CHEMICAL. 3H3.90802:
‘3 37272192
377.30982
2 | soLeTeae
41750302
52630382
HWTALT Sb
451,109.46
‘bbP SOR d
HOKOTIAG
82421277"

Ff aes
3 [941,722.73
S7TbIOID

OBR, SOLVENTS
* wv croacat |
DOALIG MO CO

une
Vo pce i et
= ; SST SS

$79] 399876794PRAZER

}

BORDEN “CHEMICAL

PFIZER

“DADE ewobrre

938363.7 6

SSRI8NS9

ohS03726

#4852023
e358 a?
bTRAbLA?
69993647
702398.97
FIRIIGD 7
TaD 7II I
TNA A
pouzeba2
DoD d73.7 2
76492732
76361780
T7LASBL0
79627210

#0321230
S3hils.0

1 R774 080

97212590

912,745.06ORTEERS © LI2g48
COSAN CHOEICAL

2485904)

COLL OS. 2555964:

2 DARLING JNO CO | 2023865:

CENTRK SOLVENTS 230,5003°

‘CDS/4 CHOAICAL 22b5328°

GENERAL ULL : BO | 2326928-

ENGELHAAD MINERALS. 9] 2387328
Us YICA CO

ZAG 3 Ze
| 253,0765-
2904393
3483003

WATERTON CASEIN
MIDWEST SOLVENTS au
_ HAS OHS & ‘ones VED

a ee | 3107 33E9NOR

‘ A 3 ZKEBT | SaTNIN
: N373089 .
848,779.0
BORDEN ChEMICAL 489,323.9
AMQELES CHEINGAL 446959.3-

couLor3"

V| S7RS713
CENTAAL SOLVENTS

bh) won7B9K

sem nets

SOROEH GHB OAL,

STBLONS
a cas Ore CAL

63,0036

329.3332"

DMT OICE ‘wohnooa ~
‘fore penrane
» PFIZER .] 9.039573
CENTRAL SOLVENTS Sn380r0
} cow cfEMoaL ° 6965990
F DMA m0 oo bobtorsMae

TYR PIGMENTS
GENERAL WILL
DALING AND CO
Ad LYNCH

TITANIUM PIGMENTS
PFIZER

DANA SHIROGH ©
DARLING AND CO

“4 RE STALEY

1 OHM K.RICE

___-MtSD POLYMERS.

t MELES. CHWOAL
DLLOLS

* DIQELHMD MINERALS
SOU HOUCAL ©
‘CRATRAL SOLYENTS

4 BORDEN CHANICAL
1 PFIZER

* paOELEs CHEMICAL,
* BORDEN CHEMICAL
“Tyas Peace

reir

20%
- 3%

ny 4

14322
o3te5

ABO

foes: 928983

W936

p3500D0

‘323298
475700

“RBI370

* 2876 97.86

$29,.373.9"
ayges00-
s30230.9-
A7R,73006
872079

44,069.58

S3A77.92
135427791
2389157
PAASSLT
255405
167.8147.
2723062
2780862
2305864
250,207.58
2Sea0e
263,2973
207,697.8

Tasiss
BATFWD.oy

87.782

DAES jrvsa® = 526202
Ad LYNCH WIN =——-13.254 §572b047
TITANIUM PIGHENT HIPS 20,204 HA2BGON:
R00" POLYMERS: * pores L273 bb
JGHN K 'BICE KY 3% | 89.558

, SENTRA, SOLVENTS; [HYRO% 4.708 Bo

COLL DIDS . faraye 69,374
VARISONS b CROSFIELD [HN29% 5.008 395,733"
WEST QHEMCAL WA | IRATE 3958003"
MCKESSON CHEMICAL «= VIN GAT. S97 SHOR"
PRUZER WNT (BTL0BE oneaes

{COSA GHEMICAL Wve «27.520 19.2585

. US MICA Hr 9% 4.970 b1RebeD”
BORDEN CHEMICAL HAIR §— 525,690 57.) h7,7503~
DOW CHONCAL vie «276326 #939323"

HARISNS Db CROSFIELD
INTERNATIONAL CASEIN
+ CENTRAL SOLVENTS
T ORUNG MD O08 -
CENTRAL SOLVENTS
* MONK BICE
WOKESSON CHEMI CAL
COSAN CHEMI CAL

Ac 957.2102 °

7339671"oe

seAnISONN & GHOST) ELD

MIDWEST SOLYENTS © | Se21070

ENGELHARD MINERALS 5A9.247.0
Gaol SOCK Be07A70
BORDEN Gufuaca * 896.148.0
FEXTER : 920.2703
FAZER . VIESTES
~ SENTRAL-SOLVENTS ‘p46-200.4
cOSMd OIBIIOR. on2380D

ENGELHAND MINERALS
ANGELES CHEMICAL

‘9542106
PBAUROS

US$ MICA 942,9403"
PEIZER o7hai7s
MEXESSON CHOAICAL IIGII7D

. JOHN K BICE PORATED
TITANIA PIOMENT OLOI5K9
COUN CHEM CAL 099.9102
ARRIECHS b -CROSFIEWD | 220,299.7

s coLLNIOS | 4 a0: 213,095.27

1 JOHN rok f 2320973

in > 18:
i GeuTea AES TETLRZO

US MICA

vo tm ae,B  SZ773
aaa UMA
reise 326.KN9 |
a3 23,087
se gt AE STALEY oe

+ TW GEOL

+ HANASSONS A CADSFLELD }¥

“OORDEN ° oe
PRYZER

BORDEN CHEMNDAL - ..

» MG RESSON CHEMICAL , .|

*_SNTERAATIONAL CASEIN”

20,650.79
57,976.00

f Prizes 12,258"

. to TRONS

j FRAZER” AAT | 1Z079 191-65.0
S GOSAN CHDUICAL SU | 27,869 ROSNTAS
SENERAL SOLVENTS Hee GHOL | KUDOS | 8739.9

“2.038 57,578.00 822119.

~s pe-

GLAMOND SHMRDEK

WADKEST SOLVENTS

ROO POLYMERS
‘BORDEN CHEMICAL,
BORDEN SHEWC K
pew CHOICE
PRIZER

UsuIcA |
AESAY

* MARRESONS & GROSF ELD!

“POM CIE CR,
BORDEH CHEROR,
ARCO POLYMES
OARLIIO NO 00.

"+ uunois aueseo
HARRISONB & CROSFIELD

CENTRAL SOLVENTS

PrIZI

HARRISON & CAQSF IELD

+ MCKESSON GHEAICAL
FIR

°° PRATER

A_E STALEY.

37:

saw 326,049 |
ween 3R9E9
SIT 14,682:

5.020
L375
5.357

2.393

SANS 5.28050

‘168

wats 221.846 Ti

602
5.436

- 6.828
INET 18.236 |

7.348
1.8

19,213 |
wHIe TW -21.969

$479
7.584

2s 22.293
22.285

642

$88.00
7732.0 0
Rabaze

22,615.70
“2250.00

LTe099

17,325.90
1L9.5B9.48
8.66356

2003.40
462000

VIBIEZOE

PRs %e201

FA72058 t,
256,025.81

291.64 19
296.1410
FOB3S40:°
3074420
D44g SS

3933082

FNL
390.5827
390,867,7
NOS3777
427.9934
4 29223~
WIOFOS
‘882003

| aeza7as

4663408
wORbDNZ™
A9G NAD
SUID
$08.3935
3191383

275 1281AE STALEY |-
BORDW CHEMCAL-
BXGELHAAD MINERALS +
BORDEM CHEMICAL
IOWEST BOLVENTS
,MARSSES & cROSIELO

rae At «328,087 bs

ai anasteot
ons?

se T353e8t

* wri & HCE

- US MICA
ANGELES CHEMICAL
COSAN CHANICAL

} CARLSNG' AND 60 : 222234

] Aiea POLYMERS SVT | LITZ

© av EDOW-GrBUICAL 20RD
ET HORN 186
BRADGO OD jaws mt aK ONa |

j GOnDEN CHENOA rma 9% 928320 5
2 Ott 108, eave | (78368
_ OMe OHOMICAL FONT "20.007
+ ome 81k bnase f
3
i

. fawes8
HAUISONS 8 cAOSTTELD [OWN 3,982 B
HOLTOO
32353,init

PROEUIAD WINEHALS.
“COLLOIDS
ANGELES CHEM CAL
HN K BICE
DORSETT AID UACKSOF

BORDEN CHASCAL 34229040
i KESSON CHEMICAL, Sadeses:
AE stuge

DARLING ai on *
MIONEST sotvENTs
“WIARISOWS & CROSFSELD
COSAN CREMIGAL ©”
PRITIEN

“"RARRIS ONS & CAOSF ELD
7 US WGA ?
_ POMIDT OFIIOAL,
4 DARLING MD OO.

Faw 222500 4
7 COSAN CHEAOAL

review 26,092

wizek FOS | -389AT f FaN077

7 PFIZER FBI. «= 396NO 7266910
ean GIST | kOATS 7388209-

+ COSY GHOMIOA, => (romtue | 20.223 f 7543202

| SOF CHES AL SHI «393,992 TARHSS.

7 OF BORDEN CHEMICAL FOTN 32K202 6 #242093
| RESTAEY AS | BST 8IK3193,
GrAMOND ShancoK rezk Th ase | 538.9095.

+ WORESSON OIBNICL fae 7D3 | 840,849"
CONTNA, SOLVENTS ras 75 | 4 890,2740,

3780 § 902.1430

em. . ‘BAL FWD.33,967 fon
3760 | pA
G75
3704
30008
03,733

22,398 4

AE sTMtY, _ a
& BARRISONS & cRooraELbAe le TI oqn2397
“DARLING MID 90 WAN 222,703 bo 104,603.97
09 MIA wae TL | 3,063 f Likic19s
COSA) OLAIICAL ave 29924947
Fetus PrOMENT Zig2s585
AE STARY 2IROD8ts
DOY cHECAL - 2%) 908,272 5
JOH K BIGE PLS | 319,303.86.
‘ROO PORYWERS = “] 93160052
QUEER RramHEICL - p¥39099.3F
: 1 | HQNSISI
EROELHARD UINERALS HORNTISE

MIDWEST SOLVENTS

7 INTERNATIONAL CASEIN
HUDIMIE R
CENTRAL -SOLVETHS
MEXESSDN. CHEMICAL

HOT 2R3O
3] BORAT Fae
"| saghipt
x"] 330.201

536,050.93

Une 3AL FWD.ost

3 ‘
ns ~
oo —- y
. > se 8 oe
: B
Raw Materials aera 380

MATION, STMIGH
HAARISONS & CAOSFATLD

JREQ. POLYMERS FAS RIOBS
CNTRAL SOLY 8TS: 7907182:
ANGELES: CHU DAL 754,339.85
rite

DARLING AND 99 -
MOREASON GHEMOAL.

1,300] 139200
* 4032 Rneebo
60,067 PRI 1A be
20313 s2A608s

8340993
eanerpa
-$O00717 ©
ban0298
4) 90n30o8
91,0088
V1b2079
920,007.9
Pa3.647.9
95368 TAt
POLb07%:

yaogon-
‘$3,9808>
renznde
sehiess.
208131.7°

“HAWLASON8 ROSE DEOL
MEWEST SOL

263,699.58 -*

accounr Raw Menriela ‘. aserna 350

“Dow CremoaL *

AGO. POLYMERS "3.12.b.
INTERRATIONAL CASEIN" [R15 Tt 9S0.697.5 -
BOCLES Gipaicat, 54,7059
PFIZER “ . Opnae72:
TITANIA PIGMENTS IPLIATZ
FARR ISOS & CADSFIEDE (ans 904.4032

BORDEN GHEMOAL,.”

. SLOSS ¢
PFIZER

ADA 25+

FRIZEN . 65,402.0° -

HARRISONS he CAOSFIELD 87.8364
COSAN GH BAIGAL, 112,853.0
COW CHEMIGN, 147.7675 -
: AE STALEY 1733779
CENTRAL SOLVENTS 1846345
HIDDIDER . 2IL23b4
WIWEST SOLVENTS 225,095.6
BASE WYANDOTTE . 230b834
_ $NO> PoLrwens . WLS
DARLING AO OD, [2780 85.0
1 pa Lenanp wimenays VT 82032 2816254
MOCESSON GHEUSORL, tT 249 f2ssecee
3ORO200

_ SOROEN OMEMOAL «= furizt saneee &

, SAARISOIS & CROSFIELD ase. |
"R088

328,068.0
376,972.0

on _, BAL FWD.me
PrYZER
BOMEN omaen,

DASE wIAOOTTE |

36720732
wi 397,793.23 &
PPUZER, . ge HLRLORTZ
usuitas' 422,603.72
THT RN PrGUENTS 2378 42> Pee 0322
NOREISON CHEHCAL 7 ; ITZ, |oaneersz

HAARISONS & CAOSFIELD 47999732
J CHOELHARO MINERALS +f

‘ E pea 89907732
2 or 7 TDOWSCHEM SAL: . : panis7az
ORDO AD 6O $44,16702

HARRISOS & cRDSTIEWD fe

CENTRAL SOLVENTS SaReStse

coLLo}ns, prorTas

CDSAN DIEMLCAL nees98a68
“ARCO POLYHERS * P 4 oseensae
= OORDEN CHDUICAL . . j B3223276

dOHN'K BICE * bv

CENTRAL SOLYENTS  ~

DARLING HDC”

DANG SHAMORT
i SORDEN CHEMICAL

+ MPELES | SAERICAL
i PRIZER

PFIZER

ene eoBORODY DIEM OAL
JAGD FOLIVERS rc
OAAUM) AD-CO AER 22LEe
CENTRAL SOLVENTS FET. | REZ
POLLOIDS. hari Th 7RGSS
BASF WYANDOTTE . PRIVAT 258060
HAARISONS & CROSFIELD &ap2 |
DOW CHIMIDAL, FRLWL BT.
FRIZER . , 3 bbe
coprizeR s**t oat3 ht
PFIZER so aT «99,599
BORG CHENICAL ir2k 929.953 6
JOW,# BIGE oom 92,022
U3 MICA - . WT ADS

4) TITAN PIGUENTS

VE (23,052
"ARISING & CAOSF ELD

zh &bb7 FB
. 260 9393 B
DU AMOND SHMROKK Par he Th 30,052
¢ wre SABIE

SP ANTERMATIOWE BASEN [wT 2.892 f
= ENGELHARD MINERALS u 27,367
J HARMISONSS CROSFIEDL 6,409 2
E HAMAIESONS & CADSF ELD

CENTRAL SOLVENTS

HF TERoe

DOH CHEMIOAL:
bow CHONOAL

PRATER

CONTRA, SOLVENTS:

CODA CHERICAL

ROWEST. SOLVENTS
EMELHAND MINERALS”

no " 08 MICA
” Om K BICE

-FZER
FER

DARLING: AD :tO*
HARRISON 6 CROSFIELD ff
7. HARRIS ONG b CADSF EEL

BORDEN CHEM OAL
A€ STREY
A 8 STREY

PFAZER

THTANGUM PEOUEMT

U SMIOA

MIDWEST SOUVINTS
LGKESSON OMEMOAL

ANC POL)

OAALING AID 0D
* pow CHEMICAL

+ BORDEN

CHEMCA.

DALING JNO 0D

aH

BICE

~ CENTRAL SOLVENTS

He ome ee

“hake

YHERS .
HARATS ONS fe CACSFIELD [ANC T

_ Daze fe
Dees = 9822e b
AIT F7S3IS_
ARV = 22KS7O-
Paton 92.527 1:
* am507 B

STO ELITSLO

. | rasayes
q2ea7as | suscn0s
‘\abonps | SRe3776—
AR ASTIG | ESS7TTS
oRb379& | Tqz2z77
7022776 | AsO
oxezoz6
3 20677.728

SO73T LT Z

wget“Baw otewica, "°°

aa

“SUB IN CHEMICAL

COLLOIDS © jeusr9385
BASF WrANOOOTE [EA2S23.9 £
4M poral 445,040.99
OH) K BICE 64ND
“CAVEOON CHEMICAL, SA82bL0t
PRIZER 6 60.220:28
wun sayo2289

GENTRAL SOLVENTS
PFIZER

PEIZER :
HARRISONS b CROSFIELD
ZER ,

CENTRA. SCLENTS
YORN K BICE
SORDEN CHEMICAL = * BY 407
BAS WLANDOTTE 82002703
+ BAGO POLYHERS 95276722
HARRISONS kb CROSFIELD |B oe,035.25
WOM ROTAL shsboa3
Ad LYNCH 870,900.83
PITER y fezazssss
AE sTatey 2 - 25.610,00
2 PFIZER {rstase Taatese
7 PFIZER ANB 29.609 $2015.77 Bag 2932
cu 3 RICA 29) -$,173 119,000.00 A253
~ PWIDWEST SOLVENTS: ARTA Ty, 9.097 Pesd.186 93,33225,
473200" 23208026 |
J 500 256,500.19
ONE Bice aMt9T 92653 2.77000 2d690N29 15835ea5
: tansih

BAL EWD.

ee meee 7 ee weesoo

* MIDWEST SOLVENTS

COS M2 OIEMNEAL
cow GeMom |
ARCO POLYMERS
POUR

JDRDEN CHEM CAL

} BORDECHEMiC A.

HARAISONS be CROSPTEDL
ENGELIARD MINERALS
DARLING ND oD
CENTRAL SOLVDNS

DARLING’ 40.60
BASE 5Y ANOGTEE

» CENTRAL SOLVGITS

Wa >

yn 2

BuO

WAST 224.733 b

07,237 |

4955
39,058
2hb ae
13,358

2083
Baan

oes

TALIS
TARTS
TWABAIID:

[750770

7ax23b6
795.4055

woreres
eee

BAL FWD,eee we te

9238 [SOK TIS
. salve ,

BST AZIAS
/ i , Tas | STATED?
WH K BIE Bee 92053 }351750 hz [97227852
| PFIREA
’ PERE
WARTSOND & CAQSFLELD
Us UICAReope

“pilRsons a ontSF ELD
WFIRER .

WAARISOGN & ChOSFIELO bo

JBSO POLYMERS
aa K BICE
COLLOIDS

cro W SIMANOAL
CONTRA, SOT

UU. :
HAARISONS & CROSFIELD
ima
AW WEST SOLVENTS
CEHTRML SOLVENTS
WMD CHO

COOMN CHANICAL =”
OgROEN

“PERZER

“"WAMLISOHS &® CROSFIELD

US ICA

ORR BEAEX,

ER
| UNTERUNT ORAL GASELH

 APAaNR
" WAARIGONS & cHOSr TELS

* MMRISDDS & CROSFIELD
12R Tas

3 [72909509 -erent Evers

ARGO POLYMERS
‘AACO POLYMERS
Inf DHEA
BORDEN CHEM.CAL
PFERER |
PFIZER
HAARISCHS & CROSFIELD
ENGELHCRD MINERALS
OOY CHEGAL
GHTRA, SOLVENTS
CENTRA, SOUVENTS,
BOPOEN CHDUICAL
U3 MICA
MIDWEST. SOLVENTS

+ PFIZER > *

B15 s

SRI
323,323.87

BOROES

7 US MICA 29,626.00

_ > AB STAY 29,b26.00 | 66,399.00

1 AFIZER ob35900.' “Bh AT

* . FLAS ES Ree

* JOM K BICE 75.011.90 | 82,896.06

JRO POLYMERS 82,894.90 122063000

BORDEN CHEMI 20,534.00 |234122.62
de remeneee +EMGEUHAAD IMHERALS
. HARLISONS & ENON) ELD

MIDWEST SOLYDITS
AR STNY
FRAZER
OSM: CHBCAL
CENTRK SOLVENTS,

+, AVOO POLYMERS

BOROEM QHEMICAL "”

CALGIM GANBOWAT E
PFI
PRATER
‘tOW CHEMICAL,
ITER

i pr iee
Prva
HARRISEHS & CRORE

* TiTenue Puts.
3 PER ue

ch SERIES AE ee See TT ee Cee
7 2 3 8 OF

a

. 7 es fo

90243 fagoes7
7599 BRIG150

LOROORL
raasaose
LARZORSE
AGA0ITSE
TAROT
ZONESATE
2318262

T3pBl £254222
PIR | -7E,4O2 [NEI T
CTV —G8K2 | 5,95615

WA 27,997 br00000
pruen -sreseiqrerss |“DSMI ORBRICAL
WS YICA

AE STAR
Pree
PRIZE
FPHER ©
FFIZDR

Prt
Us YICA

+7 HANRISOSH & CROSFLELD PF

DAALIND ND OD
DARLING HD OD
LLOIDS

‘DI aN SHAMIDOS

SIN CIBC,

5 DOW CHEMICAL,
AE STALEY
CENTRAL, SOLVENTS
MOWEST SOLVENTS

SDARLEND ND

i CALCIUM GARSOH ATE

+ DOROEN.
ARM POLYMERS
BORDEN

CALCIUM CARBOUIT E

ENGELHMAD MINERALS © PTO

93.399
TARR

110,380 |
123598 |

01,259.97

S3zasc

| 3422020

RI 9880
‘LIGbOITE
BINS IST

32740252
B43eO2S

| 331.2035
[3420775

SORL77Se

y {eg.0395e

599,5555€
SETA OSE
|b 31,276.99
GowozsI16

SILOT31«
SRE

yt 8087299 %

BaDLOITCENTAM, SELVEHTS
rim mot, cs
HAARISONS & CROSFIELD 9
TW CHEMICON:
BASE WYANDOTTE.
PIR
PFIZER

SUNT ERNAT 66808, CASE
THT RU PreMENT

7 333,00022
HARRISONS & CAOSFIELO je

‘BORDEN (1 255.44632
+US MICA 2TRPSES 3

+ 1 NGO POLYMERS * 30298832
OHA BICE 307,29632
TNTERNATIONAL CASELH | 347,.23632

TITAN PRGMENT 37393837

“OLLIDS, 9780032
[Datu AO mM raze 224344 39720032
+MOWEST SOLVENTS . ) | eIOS TEL

ots LSD
WN 74.279

‘ow CHEMICAL

wore oe BED

V9SSHI72 ©

ADKeGZLT:sO

RA Set
seu BCE

BORDEN : 327109 bzoveso
HARRISGHS & CROSFIELO 0222 }o70100
ANC POLIMENE

SM OMA,

DENTAAL SULRENTS

} DARLING mo

AARON b CHOSFIELO
HOELHAAD MINERALS ©
CENTRAL SOLVONTS:
Loanono suman |
| DMLO AID o>
¥ DOW. CHENSAL
} cosMt O1BNIEAL
{ cprmax sctverts
BOROEN SHOMEOAL
PrTtR
FAZER :
ae 99 er ARTS

sar |2s0000 5 y
. 9990-] 3 0aD09 OF Fs] €39,060.97
{1 867,054.88
BbT, 26484

0,416.90
ant? RISDTRTANEMAE PIGMENT
DD ANONO SHAMIOK
Dow CHEMICAL

Ad LYNCH

BASF WYANDOTTE
US TICA

HAARIS OS & hos? pELD fo

WACO POLYMERS

GOLLOIDS ”
o PRIREAS. .~ EXHIBIT Cpage

SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA : |

1

2 FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES

3 DEPARTMENT 96 HON. VICTOR E, CH.
4 ROBERT L. BOWEN, . )

5 : )

6 Plaintiff, )

7 )

8 VS. ) No. BC372150

9 )

10 A.W. CHESTERTON COMPANY, etal.,  )

i )

RR Defendants. )

13: _ )

14 REPORTER'S DAILY TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
15 TUESDAY, MAY 13, 2008

16 APPEARANCES OF COUNSEL:

17 (Please see next page) .
18 NAREN JANSEN, CSR NO. 3827, RMR, CRR
19 OFFICIAL REPORTER

pagePage

1 APPEARANCES OF COUNSEL:
2 FOR PLAINTIFFS: PAUL & HANLEY, LLP
3 BY: STEPHEN J. HEALY
4 CAMPBELL EILMER
5 1608 4th Street
6 Suite 300
7 Berkeley, California 94710
8 (510) 559-9980
9 FOR DEFENDANT McKENNA LONG & ALDRIDGE, LLP
10 METALCLAD BY: SUSAN WEISENBERG GILEFSKY
11 CORPORATION: BRADFORD J. DeJARDIN
12 . 444 South Flower Street
13 Suite 800
14 Los Angeles, California 90071
18 (213) 243-6167
16 FOR DEFENDANT NIBCO: BRYDON, HUGO & PARKER
17 BY: GREGORY S. ROSSE
18 135 Main Street
19 : 20th Floor
20 San Francisco, California 94105
21 (415) 808-0300
22 FOR DEFENDANT UNION — LINER YANKELEVITZ SUNSHINE &
23 CARBIDE: ~ REGENSTREIF LLP
24 BY: KEVIN C. MAYER
25 RAUL PEREZ
26 1100 Glendon Avenue
27 14th Floor
28 Los Angeles, California 90024
29 (810) 500-3500
30 ORRICK, HERRINGTON & SUTCLIFFE, LLP
31 BY: SIOBHAN A, HANDLEY
32 666 Fifth Avenue
33° New York, New York 10103-0001

34 (212) 506-3757page 2513

“Ep OoN DOR WN

Pee Pe Pee
SNATA ANE

19

CASE NUMBER: BC327150

CASE NAME: BOWEN V. A‘W. CHESTERTON
COMPANY, ET AL.

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA TUESDAY, MAY 13, 2008
DEPARTMENT 96 HON. VICTOR E. CH
APPEARANCES: ° (AS HERETOFORE NOTED)
REPORTER: NAREN JANSEN, CSR NO. 3827
TIME: 841 AM.

(The following proceedings were
held in open court outside the
presence of the jury.)

THE COURT: Union Carbide is asking that we limit
some testimony. So let's hear anything that you want to
add.

MR. MAYER: Yes. Good morning, Your Honor. This
is an issue that Your Honor has considered previously on
several occasions, and you have consistently ruled that
evidence conceming the Union Carbide worker health issues
should not be admitted into evidence.

By the way, before we begin, Your Honor, Td
like to introduce to the court Ms. Siobhan Handley, my
colleague, who Your Honor has graciously admitted pro hac
vice. We appreciate that. She willbehandling
Mr. Myers' testimony today, and can also amplify if you
need amplification on the issues of the Union Carbide

page 25131
2 A. Yes. -
3 Q. And there came a time in 1970 where you were
4 the plant supervisor of a mine located near Fresno,
5 California.
6 A. Iwas never called a superintendent of the
7 mine. And it was not near Fresno. Or at least not any
8 closer than anyplace else.
9 Q. Then you became a marketing sales manager
10 about 1970, for Union Carbide's asbestos business?
li A. Marketing manager, yes.
12 Q. And the mine closed in 1985?
13 A. No.
4 Q._ Union Carbide sold off the mine in what
15_year?
16 A. They sold off the mine and milling, the
AA7 entire asbestos operation in 1985.
18 Q. Allright. If this jury were interested in .
19 finding out what Union Carbide lnew about the toxicologic
20 effects of asbestos and when they knew it, do you have
21 some special knowledge in your capacity as running the
22. mining operations for Carbide? Have I got that right?
23 MS. HANDLEY: Objection, Your Honor.
24 THE COURT: Legal ground, Counsel,
25 MS, HANDLEY: Vague, ambiguous.
26 ° THE COURT: Overruled.
27 Q. BYMR.HEALY: Allright.
28 A. Would you repeat it, please.

page 2520page 2608

1 A. Yes, itis.

2 Q. What's the date of that letter?

3 A. November 3rd, 1976,

4 Q. Are you advising of all the different

5 warning labels placed on the Carbide asbestos during
6 different periods of time in that letter?

7 A. Two. Two of them.

8 Q. Okay. ,

9 MR: HEALY: Move to admit 10744,

10 MS, HANDLEY: No objection, Your Honor.
11 THE COURT: Received.

12

13 - (Received in Evidence - Exhibit 10744)
14

15 Q. BY MR, HEALY: The earliest warning label
16 _was 1968, Before 1968, there were no warning labels on_.
17 Carbide asbestos bags, right?
18 A. That's correct.
19 -Q, And in '68, the warning said, "Warning,

20 Breathing Dust May Be Harmful, Do Not Breathe dust."
21 A. Yes. :

22. __Q. Then the warning got revised in 1972 to

23 read, "Caution: Contains Asbestos Fibers, Breathing Dust
24 May Cause Serious Bodily Harm"?
25 THE COURT: Doesn't it say "breathing asbestos,

26 dust"?
22Z MR, HEALY; Thank you, Your Honor.
28 Q.__ "Breathing Asbestos Dust May Cause Serious

page 2608page 2609

1

17

Bodily Harm."
+ 3.

Q. Moving forward to Exhibit 10659. Did you
write this document? :

A. Yes. Basically, I did. 1 probably had
input from others, But I have my name on it.

MS. HANDLEY: Your Honor, may we approach about
this document, please.

THE COURT: Certainly.

(The following proceedings
were held at sidebar:)

THE COURT: Yes, Counsel.

MS, HANDLEY: Good afternoon, Your Honor.

_ This document is a presentation entitled
"Preventing on-the-Job Cancer," Your Honor. And in light
of the court's previous rulings limiting the case to
asbestosis, | just see some real danger here on opening
the door, and I'm not sure what the relevance is at this
point.

MR. HEALY: I have no intention of getting into the
cancer. The highlighted portion is about the
appropriateness of controls of dusts.

THE COURT; Do you see what he's looking at?

You're going to stay away from the reference
to cancer?

MR. HEALY: Yes.

page 2609page 2617

1 MS. HANDLEY: I thought, Your Honor -

2 THE COURT: Okay. Let's hear what Counsel is
3_saying.

4 MR. HEALY: Yes, Your Honor. The representation.
5 Jhas been made that Mr. Myers is unfamiliar with medical
6 terminology. This is foundation to show that he actively
7__sought to change a death certificate and has intimate

8_ familiarity with medical terminology relating to
9_pneumoconiosis and asbestosis.

10 Lf this is something I have to do outside

11_the presence, then I'll move on to a different area, but ]
12_do have some material on this.

13°, THE COURT: TH certainly sustain the objection.

14 I'm not sure that just becatise someone writes something.

15 How many of us went to school and wrote
16 things that we weren't quite sure of?
17 MS. HANDLEY; Your Honor, I'll add for the record

18 thathe’s actually quoting the death certificate,
19 THE COURT: Okay, We don't have to get into that.

20 Objection sustained.

21

22 (The following proceedings
23 =. ° were held in open court in
24 thie presence of the jury:)

25

26 OQ. BY MR. HEALY: Did there come a time when

27 ide sold off the King City mining operations?
28 A... The mining and milling and marketing

page 2617page 2618

1 operations, yes,

2 Q.._ What year? :

3 A, 1985, I think it was effective July ist,

4 _1985. .

5 Q. And they sold the mine?

6 A, Well, they didn't own the mine, But, you

7 know, as we discussed earlier, we had claims. These were
8 transferred to the new owner.

9 ,.Q. ‘They transferred claims.

10 A. Wedid own some property where the roads

11 were putin, We had to buy that property. But we didn't
12 _gwn any of the asbestos ore deposit.

13° | .Q. By this time, was Union Carbide out of the

14 raw fiber and -- to joint compound manufacturers business?
15 A. They sold the asbestos business.

16 Q. Did there come a point in time before 1985

17 in which the government banned asbestos from joint

18 compounds?

19 A, Part of them, yes.

20 Q. Allright. And what year was that?

21 A. [think it was 1978 or in that neighborhood.

22 Q. You've testified in other litigation than

23 thisone. Havel got that right? ‘ ,

24 A. Yes,

25 MR. HEALY: A moment, Your Honor.

26 :

27 (Pause in proceedings.)

28

page 2618page 2527

1 part that Union Carbide had claims to.

2 Q. So the deposit was 40 to 50 miles, 40 to 50
3 square miles.

4 A. Again, as I recall, that sounds about right.

5 Union Carbide probably had maybe two or three miles of the

6 area,

7 Q, At this -- this land where this deposit --

8 the deposit was an asbestos deposit, right?

9 AL Yes. ,

10 Q. The largest in North America?

WAL Yes. ,

12 Q. And the asbestos here was ¢alled Calidria?
A
Q

13 Later, that trade name was adopted.

14 , _Calidria was a trade name?
15 A, Yes.
16 Q. And that comes from California, and Idria,

17 from the name of the mine, the New Idria mine?

As A. Yes, it was the New Idria mining area,

19 Q. Now, this Calidria asbestos was unique in
20 terms of the fiber of asbestos found anywhere in the

-21 world. Is that true?

22 A, It was similar to others, but it had -- it
23 was all short-fiber asbestos, short-fiber chrysotile

24 asbestos.

25 Q. You wrote in 1979 a document describing it
26 asbeing highly sheared and pulverized by nature?
27 A. Yes.

28 Q. And it didn't have the cross-fiber look that

page 2527page 2624

NWR WON HR

8
a

We've got Union Carbide here, We're going
to call that UCC?

A. Allright.
Q._ And you are selling asbestos. Right?
A, Right.

Q. Okay. Who are you selling that to?
A. To companies that mix the asbestos with
other materials to make a finished product that they then

sold to another -- their customers.

10 Q.” Okay. So let's take it one step at a time.

li
12
13
14
15
16
17
18

19°

20
21
22
23

Because as you can tell already, I'm not very good with
this thing. So we're going to have to go a little slowly.
So were one of their customers that you just
referred to tape joint compound manufacturers?
A. Yes,
Q So you sell your product to tape joint
compound manufacturers, correct?
A. Yes.
Q. Among other, correct?
A. Many others. ‘
Q. Okay. And what do they do with it, to your
knowledge?
A. They use to it make tape joint compounds.
Q. Okay. They use it to make tape joint
compound.
And the jury has heard already what tape
joint compound is used for, so we're not going to go into
that.

page 2624EXHIBIT D2 ON AH BW DN

PURCELL LLP

{415) BUBISSS
a

16

NOVATO, CALIFORNIA Y4U48-U109

BRA’
3

DAVID R. DONADIO, ESQ., S.B. #154436

ERIC C. SOLOMON, ESQ., §.B. #L19131 ENDORSED
BRAYTON*PURCELL LLP sent S ich ein 2 coon

Attorneys at Law
222 Rush Landing Road

P.Q. Box 6169 CONFERENCE SET MAY 20 2009
Novato, California 94948. QAa§}ANAGEMENT ‘

(415) 898-1555 . . GORDON PARK-LI, Ciork
Attorneys for Plaintitfs APR 15 2010 -18PM Deoua Clek

DEPARTMENT 206
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

JOYCE JUELCH and } ASBESTOS
NORMAN JUELCH, SR., ) No.
) Cac-09-275212
Plaintiffs, ) - : ~
) COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY
vs. ) AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM -
. ) ASBESTOS
ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (BP) )
As Reflected on Exhibits B, B-1, C; )
and DOES 1-8500; and SEE ATTACHED =)
LIST. )
1 Plainuff J