Preview
LAW OFFICES OF
COOLEY MANION JONES HAKE KurOWSKILLP
wwe NY DH WS
William M. Hake, Esq. (State Bar No. 110956)
Melissa E. Macfarlane, Esq. (State Bar No. 239811)
Rachael A, Buckman, Esq. (State Bar No, 263224) ELECTRONICALLY
COOLEY MANION JONES HAKE KUROWSKI LLP FILED
201 Spear Street, 18th Floor Super oe
: iperior Court of California,
= ress A sete County of San Francisco
Fax: (415) 512-6791 FEB 03 2011
Clerk of the Court
Attorneys for Defendant BY: WILLIAM v Nepal Clerk
TEMPORARY PLANT CLEANERS, INC. f/k/a
PLANT MAINTENANCE, INC. OF CALIFORNIA
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
ROBERT ROSS and JEAN ROSS, Case No. CGC-10-275731
Plaintiffs, DECLARATION OF RACHAEL A.
BUCKMAN IN SUPPORT OF
v. DEFENDANT TEMPORARY PLANT
CLEANERS, INC. f/k/a PLANT
C.C. MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS; MAINTENANCE, INC. OF
Defendants as Reflected on Exhibit 1 attached | CALIFORNIA’S DEMURRER TO
to the Summary Complaint herein; and DOES PLAINTIFFS’ COMPLAINT
1-$500.
Hearing Date: March 3, 2011
Time: 9:30 a.m.
Dept.: 220
Complaint: December 17, 2010
Trial Date: TBD
I, Rachael A. Buckman, declare as follows:
1, Iam an attorney licensed to practice law in the State of California and an
associate of the law firm Cooley Manion Jones Hake Kurowski LLP, attorneys of record for
Defendant Temporary Plant Cleaners, Inc. f/k/a Plant Maintenance, Inc. of California (“TPC”). I
have personal knowledge of each fact stated in this declaration and, if called upon to testify,
could and would competently testify thereto.
Mt
-Le
DECLARATION OF RACHAEL A. BUCKMAN IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT TEMPORARY PLANT CLEANERS, INC. t/k/a PLANT
MAINTENANCE, INC, OF CALIFORNIA’S DEMURRER TO PLAINTIFFS’ COMPLAINTLaw OFFICES OF
COOLEY MANION JONES HAKE KuROWSKI LLP
RW eM MW MN RP NR KY BR Be Se Be Be eB Se eB ewe ee
eo VW A RA KF 8 SS = SF Swe BAH BO YP SB STS
‘|| for Personal Injury and Loss af Consortium ~ Asbestos, filed December 17, 2010.
oO ON A ROR YH LD
2. Attached hereto as Exhibit A is a true and correct copy of Plaintiff's Complaint
3. Attached hereto as Exhibit B is a true and correct copy of the Brayton Purcell
Master Complaint for Personal Injury [and Loss of Consortium] - Asbestos, filed January 2,
2003, in In re; Asbestos Cases of Brayton Purcell, San Francisco County Superior Court, Case
No. 828684.
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the
foregoing is true and correct. Executed on February 3, 2011 at San Francisco, California.
»
Rachael A. Buckman
-2-
DECLARATION OF RACHAEL A, BUCKMAN IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT TEMPORARY PLANT CLEANERS, INC. ia PLAN) T
MAINTENANCE, INC. OF CALIFORNIA’S DEMURRER TO PLAINTIFFS’ COMPLAINTEXHIBIT ABRAYTON@PURCELL LLP
ATFORNEYS AT LAW
222 RUSH LANDING ROAD
POBOX G69
NOVATO, CALIFORNIA 9388-6169
{AES 981555
DAVID R. DONADIO, ESQ., 3.B. #154436
BRAYTON*PURCELL LL ENDORSED
Altorneys at Law ,
222 Rush Landing Road : soatd ED on
Novato, Cal forni 94948-6169 ‘0S 0
lovato, California T 1
(415) 898-1553 CASE MAN ARETENT GONFERENCE DEC 47 2010
wo COURT
Attorneys for Plaintiffs DEC 15 7011 {2PM ERC GF THE
DEPARTMENT 220
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
ASBESTOS
Defendants as Reflected on Exhibit 1
attached 1o the Summary Complaint
herein; and DOES 1-8500.
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
ROBERT ROSS and JEAN ROSS, y ASBESTOS
) jo.
Plaintiffs,
; C-10-275731.
vs. ) COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY
. ) ANDLOSS OF CONSORTIUM -
C.C, MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS; )
)
1. Plaintiff ROBERT ROSS was born September 9, 1935.
2. The @Brayton%Purcell Master Complaint for Personal Injury [and Loss of
Consortium]- Asbestos (hereinafter "Master Complaint") was filed January 2, 2003, in San
Francisco Superior Court. A copy of the Master Complaint and General Order No. 55 may be
obtained upon request from Brayton?Purcell, and designated portions of the Master Complaint
are incorporated by reference herein pursuant to the authority conferred by General Order No. 55.
Plaintiffs’ claims are as set forth in said Master Complaint against defendants herein as follows:
ue
ue
Mt THIS CASE IS SUBJECT TO
MANDATORY ELECTRONIC FILING
PURSUANT TO AMENDED G.0. 158:
TqUyNy Aue Uo to yUrEsdUtOD Jaisepy otf] UT Gop las Se SANUS ABUATPe MOY! PUL,
(Geneg [IAID)
Doo ob Ob oO ob ob ob be me lhe puooag-Aitian |
& (gr Te - Geneg Bulnsqy Surpiy) Ie g-itomL
O Quay - wevaq/pnerg) panuant |
: (uonejasaidaisipy jeuotuaiuy
: Quatuyeaque yu
EaSQIdaus py
tg “yaa aaag
(uQHdy JO H9IHED) GUAIINIS
gq (Surpuyp 2oyg ayeag)
qiuaayly ‘yueayneg
oO {saoiaag Ayayes
Arorestdsay) yaannpy “type
a LV TAs) ieenayg "yiuay
(IVOMH TOW vonesuadieD
o SISO Ay LOQIEH PUB aI04STUOF) YIN
(ang pur soueuayy [oy sauor]
aouatifeay ‘ssauitpiomessun)
yiydig ‘gusaag ‘yas
(Anpiqery sorsetu0g
#BUMO Sastuard) yyty
(wniuosti0D
Jo sso7y) yunoy
(uonentasaiday
sje) PAWL
(CQiiqer7 to1ig) pitooag
(2ousdy Fang) ssary
Tony jo SsteD:
Oo w&
20
aoa
4o0
al K&ROo 2 YN A HW &
3. Plaintiff's asbestos-related injury, date of diagnosis, employment status, and
history of exposure lo asbestos are as stated on Exhibit A.
4, Plaintiffs were married on December 15, 1975.
5. Plaintitf hereby amends the Master Complaint on file berein, to incorporate a
new Twenty-First Cause of Action, set forth below, specially plead against the defendant listed
on Exhibit N, namely METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY. (Plaintiffs are in
the process of amending the Master Complaint herein and will include this new Cause of Action
in said amendment.)
“TWENTY-FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION
Aiding and Abetting Battery
[Against Metropolitan Life Insurance Company
and Does 7501-7900, Inclusive)
AS AND FOR A FURTHER, TWENTY-FIRST, SEPARATE AND DISTINCT
-CAUSE OF ACTION FOR AIDING AND ABETTING BATTERY, PLAINTIFF
COMPLAINS OF DEFENDANTS METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY,
DEFENDANTS ON EXHIBIT N, DOES 7501-7900, THEIR ALTERNATE ENTITIES AND
EACH OF THEM, AND ALLEGES AS FOLLOWS:
225. Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference, as though fully set forth hereat, each
and every allegation of the First through Third and Sixteenth, Seventeenth, Bighteenth and
Nineteenth Causes of Action as though fully set forth herein, (AS used throughout this cause of
action, ‘plaintiff refers to all named plaintiffs and/or all named decedents from whom the
named plaintiff's injuries may derive.) .
226. This cause of action is for the aiding and abetting of battery by METROPOLITAN
LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY (MET LIFE”), primarily through its assistant medical
director Anthony Lanza, M.D., of a breach of duty committed by Jobns-Manville Corporation
(“J-M”).
227. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and thereon alleges, that at al times herein
mentioned defendant MET LIFE was and is a corporation organized and existing under and by
virtue of the laws of the State of New York or the laws of some other state or foreign
9 4a. 3
‘AINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY Al RTIUM- ASBESTOSom YD DH BF wD
10
jurisdiction, and that this defendant was and is authorized to do and/or was and is doing
business in the State of California, and regularly conducled or conducts business in the County
of San Francisco, State of Califomia. At times relevant to this cause of action, MET LIFE was
an insurer of J-M,
228. Plaintiff. was exposed to asbestos-containing dust created by the use of the
asbestos products manufactured, distributed and/or supplied by J-M. This exposure to the
asbestos or asbestos-related products supplied by |-M caused Plaintiff's asbestos-related disease
and injuries.
229. Starting in 1928, MET LIFE sponsored studies of asbestos dust and asbestos-
related disease in Canadian mines and mills, including those of J-M. Those studies revealed
that miners and mill workers were contracting asbestosis at relatively low levels of dust.
McGill University, which conducted the studies, sought permission from MET LIFE to publish
the results but they were never published. MET LIFE prepared ils own report of these studies.
230. Between 1929 and 1931, MET LIFE studied dust levels and disease at five U.S.
plants manufacturing asbestos-containing products. including a J-M plant. Those studies
showed that workers in substantial numbers were contracting asbestosis, at levels less than what
became the Threshold Limit Value (TLV”) of Smppef. The MET LIFE report was never
published or disseminated except to plant owners. including J-M.
231. tn 1932, MET LIFE studied dust levels and disease at the J-M plant at Manville,
New Jersey. Results were consistent with those of the Canadiafi and previous U.S. plant
studies. They were never published. :
232. In 1934, J-M and others whose plants MET LIFE had studied agreed with MET
LIFE that it should issue a report of its studies.
233. MET LIFE submitted a draft of its report to J-M. I-M requested, for legal and
business reasons, that certain critical parts of the draft be changed. MET LIFE’s official in
charge was Lanza. MET LIFE through Lanza did make changes that J-M requested, including:
(a) Deletion of MET LIFE’s conclusion that the permissible dust Jevel for asbestos
should be less than that for silica;
KSajuresna4 hte 4
COMPLAINT FOR PERSONA THIGRY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOS(b) Addition of the phrase that asbestosis clinically appeared to be milder than
silicosis.
The report, thus allered, was published in 1935. It was misleading, and intentionally so,
because il conveyed the incorrect propositions thal asbestosis was a less serious disease process
than silicosis and that higher tevels of ashestos dust could be tolerated without contracting
diseases than was the case for silica dust.
234. MET LIFE had a close relationship with J-M. It invested money in J-M. It
provided group health and life insurance to J-M. MET LIFE IN 1934 agreed ta supply
industrial hygiene services to J-M, including dust counts, training employees to monitor dust
levels, examining employees, and recommending protective equipment. MET LIFE and Lanza
were viewed as experts on industrial dusts.
233. In 1933, MET LIFE through Lanza issued the following advices to J-M:
{a) Disagreeing with the reconmmendation of a J-M plant physician, MET LIFE
advised against waming workers of the fact that asbestos dust is hazardous to
their health, basing its advice in view of the extraordinary legal situation;
(b} When the plant physician judged the best disposition ofan employee with
asbestosis was to remove him from the dust, MET LIFE advised instead that
disposition should depend on his age, nature of work and other factors and to
leave him alone if he is old and showing no disability, for, MET LIFE stated,
economic and production factors must be balanced against medical factors.
236. J-M followed the MET LIFE advices and did not warn its workers, including
plaintiff, of the hazards of asbestos dust, and J-M also intentionally refrained from notifying
workers of their disease.
237. In $936, MET LIFE, J-M and others founded the Air Hygiene Foundation
(“AHF”). One of the AHF purposes was to develop standards for dust levels that would serve
as a defense in lawsuits and workers’ compensation claims.
238. MET LIFE funded partially another study that tentatively recommended in 1938 a
TLV fox asbestos dust of Smpeef, the-same as for silica dust. MET LIFE was aware of data10
27
28]
we NW DH B&B YN
| from its own, unpublished reports that showed that level was too high for asbestos dust. MET
LIFE nonetheless promoted that TLV as proper.
239. In June 1947, the Industrial Hygiene Foundation (“1HP") which succeeded to the
| AHF, issued a report of studies by Dr. Hemeon of U.S. asbestos plants, including a J-M plant.
That report showed that workers exposed (o less than the recommended maximum levels of ~
dust were developing disease. MET LIFE was a member of the If1F and Lanza was on its
medical committee. The Hemeon report, which was supplied to J-M and other owners, never
was published.
240. In 1936, J-M and other ‘asbestos companies agreed with a leading medical research
facility, Saranac Laboratories. that Saranac would research asbestos disease, but J-M and the
Saranac’s critique of existing dust standards. Lanza directed Saranac to delete the offending
| materiats. Saranac did so, and the altered report was published in 1951 by Saranac’s Dr.
Vorwald, in the AMA Archives of Indusirial Hygiene.
242. Lanza lefi MET LIFE at the end of 1948, and took a position al New York
University, funded by MET LIFE. He continued to misrepresent that asbestos does not cause
cancer into the 1950s.
243. The IHF (formerly AHF), of which MET LIFE was a member and MET LIFE
|| official was on its medical committee, through Drs. Braun and Truan conducted a study of
|| Canadian miners. The original report, in 1957, found an increased incidence of lung cancer in
persons exposed to asbestos. The sponsors, including J-M, caused those findings to be stricken,
and the report published in 1958 contained the false conclusion that asbestos exposure alone did
not increase the risk of lung cancer.
KArivsess one itepblet.
6
NAL TNIORY AND LOSS OF RTM: ASBESTOS26
244. The false and misleading reports that a link between asbestos exposure and cancer
was not proven influenced the TLV. for if a substance causes cancer the TLV must be very low
OF 210.
243, J-M not later than 1933 was inflicting asbestos dust on its workers in its plants
knowing that the dust was hazardous and was causing workers to contract disease thal could
and would disable and kill them. As MET LIFE advised, J-M did aot warn ils workers of the
hazard. J-M committed battery on workers in its plants, including plaintiff, by that conduct.
246. MET LIFE knew that J-M’s conduct constituted a breach of its duties to its
workers. MET LIFE gave substantial assistance to J-M in commilting batteries 6n its workers,
including plaintiff, through MET LIFE’s conduct described above, including by:
(a) Affirmatively urging J-M not to warn workers of the hazards of asbestos dust. in
view of the extraordinary legal situation, such that J-M did not warn its workers,
including plaintiff;
{b) Deleting the findings of its own drafi report that the allowable limits for asbestos
dust should be less than those for silica dust, and promoting a false and unsafe
TLV which specified maximum levels of silica dust, and promoting a false and
unsafe TLV which specified maximum levels of dust for workers, including
- plaintiff, which MET LIFE knew was wrong through its own studies; :
(c) Advising J-M to keep certain workers continuing to work at dusty areas in the
plant even after J-M was aware that their lungs showed asbestos-induced
changes, lest other workers including plaintiff be alerted to the dangers of
working in the dust.
WHEREFORE, plaintiff prays judgment as is hereinafter set forth.”
6. Plaintiff's do not make claim for either false representative or punitive damages
against any named defendant herein.
Dated: Ab} BRAYTON*PURCELL LLP
By: ~
David R. Dona: .
Attorneys for PlaintiffsEXHIBIT 1EXHIBIT. 1- LISY OF DEFENDANTS
C.C. MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS
ASSOCIATED INSULATION OF CALIFORNIA
FLUOR CORPORATION :
HANSON PERMANENTE CEMENT, INC, FORMERLY KNOWN AS KAISER CEMENT CORPORATION
METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
OAKFABCO, INC.
SLAKEY BROTHERS, INC.
BAYER CROPSCIENCE INC.
} GRAYBAR ELECTRIC COMPANY, INC.
s|
CSK AUTO, INC.
THE GOODYEBAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY
JOHNSON CONTROLS, INC.
PHARMACIA CORPORATION, WHICH WiLL DO QUSINESS IN CALIFORNIA AS PHARMACIA PHARMACEUTICAL CORPORATION
H&C INVESTMENT ASSOCIATES, INC. .
FOLEY ELECTRIC CO.
} CINCINNATI VALVE COMPANY
C&R PLASTERING, INC,
| TUTTLE AND BAILEY CORP
| LAUB SHEET METAL WORKS
| WILLARD ELECTRIC
WESTBURNE SUPPLY, INC.
COMMAIR MECHANICAL SERVICES
ACCO ENGINEERED SYSTEMS, INC.
IMPERIAL PLASTERING & DRYWALL,
GENERAL MILLS, INC.
KENTILE FLOORS, INC,
DOMCO PRODUCTS TEXAS, LP.
FULLER FLOORS
ROBERT MAGEE
MARSHCO AUTO PARTS, INC.
EMIL J. WEBER ELECTRIC CO.
THE W.W. HENRY COMPANY
TEMPORARY PLANT CLEANERS, INC.
D, ZELINSKY & SONS, INC.
ALBAY CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
PACIFIC MECHANICAL CORPORATION
WALNUT CREEK SHEET METAL, FURNACE & AIR CONDITIONING, INC.
| PARKER INSULATION CONTRACTING & SUPPLY CO. INC,
| EX- PME, INC. (FKA FISCHBACH AND MOORE ELECTRIC, INC.)
} GIAMPOLINI & CO.
WEBCOR BUILDERS, INC.
JONES PLASTERING COMPANY
J.W. MCCLENAHAN COMPANY, INC,
SCOTT CO. OF CALIFORNIA
|| BARNES CONSTRUCTION Co.
BALLIET BROS. CONSTRUCTION CORPORATION
| CLAUSEN-PATTEN, INC.
A. TEICHERT & SON, INC.
CRITCHFIELD MECHANICAL, INC.
JOSEPH BRUNO SHEET METAL CO., INC.ow eI DA HH
BELL PRODUCTS INC.
ALLEN-SIMMONS HEATING & SHEET METAL COMPANY INC,
ROLLIE R. FRENCH, INC.
HEWRY C. BECK COMPANY
INSULATION SPECIALTIES, INC.
TEMPER INSULATION
RED TOP ELECTRIC CO. EMERYVILLE, INC,
SFL, INC.
ALLSBERRY MECHANICAL CORPORATION
MIDSTATE MECHANICAL, INC,
ROUNTREE PLUMBING & HEATING INC.
COLLINS ELECTRICAL COMPANY. INC.
HAROLD BEASLEY PLUMBING AND HEATING, INC.
SUGIDEN ENGINEERING CO.
JAMES A. NELSON CO., INC.
MICHAEL BROTHERS
MACK CONSTRUCTION CO.
MITCHELL BROS. TRUCK LINES, INC,
AIR SYSTEMS MECHANICAL CONTRACTOR
A&K HEATING COMPANY, INC,
ADVANCED MECHANICAI.
PACIFIC FIREPROOFING
MATTOCK CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
HARRY LEE PLUMBING & HEATING
W.C. THOMASON
CLIMATE AIR, INC.
ALLIED SPRINKLER COMPANY, INC.
DELUCCHI SHEET METAL WORKS
MCCLURE ELECTRIC, INC.
DPR CONSTRUCTION
CJR PLASTERING
COSCO SPRINKLER
ROLLINS CONSTRUCTION
BANNER DRYWALL & PAINTING CO, INC.
ORTHO-CRAFT
DONOVAN CONSTRUCTION
BETA MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS, LIMITED
PRIBUSS ENGINEERING
DILLAND SEDERBERG PLUMBING
ERWIN MECHANICAL INC.
CLIMATE CONTROL. CO., INC.
DORN REFRIGERATION
CASTRO CONSTRUCTION, INC.
VAN MULDER SHEETMETAL
W.C. THOMPSON
CALIFORNIA DRYWALL CO.
BRAGG INVESTMENT COMPANY, INC.
FAIRMONT HOTEL COMPANY
D.W. NICHOLSON CORPORATION
SWINERTON BUILDERS
and DOES 1-8500,
Defendants.
aojureg 994 a
Pl [AL TNJORY AN! IS
10
7 ASBESTOSEXHIBIT AOo @ VA DH Rw
10
EXHIBIT A
Plaintiff's exposure to asbestos and asbestos-containing products occurred at various
locations both inside and outside the State of California, including but not limited to:
Employer :
Philip Carey
Cinefnnati, OH
Coast Insulating Products
Los Angeles, CA
Universal Insulation
520 6" Avenue
Menlo Park, CA
Universal Insulation
520 6" Avenue
Menlo Park, CA
ACES
Lancaster, PA
Western Asbestos
Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA
Heat, Frost & Asbestos
Workers Union
Local 16
Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA
Mt
Klis 194 Men
IN IR
Location of
Exposure
Warehouse
10] Williams
San Francisco, CA
Jack Tar Hotel
(aka Cathedral Hill Hotel)
1101 Van Ness
San Francisco, CA
Fertilizer Plant
Helm, CA
Mare Istand Naval
Shipyard
Valigjo, CA
Hewlett Packard
Menlo Park, CA
"UC Berkeley (Central
Steam Plant),
Berkeley, CA
Tidewater Associated Oil
Avon, CA
PG&E Powerhouse
Pittsburg, CA
Queen of the Vailey
Hospital
Napa, CA
Maritime Union
Mission Street
San Francisco, CA
McKinleyville High School Insulator
McKinleyville, CA
12
Exposure
Job Title Dates
Warehouseman 2/1959-8/1959;
12/1959-1/1960
(1 week)
Insulator 8/1959-9/1959
(Apprentice) (approx. 5 wks)
Insulator 1959 (on and off
(Apprentice) for 3 months)
Insulator 1959 (1-2 weeks)
(Apprentice)
insulator 1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966"
(1 week)
Insulator 1959-1965
(3 weeks)
Insulator 1/1960-7/1960
Insulator 7/960 (3 weeks)
Insulator Approx. 1960
(i day)
7/1961-L 0/1961;
7/1962-5/1965
GB% weeks, | on
and off)
EXHIBIT A
RTIUM - ASBESTOSEmplover
Western Asbestos
3150 3 Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3° Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3” Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
31503” Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3” Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3° Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3 Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3” Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3” Street
San Francisco, CA
“
EXHIBIT A (cont'd.)
Location of
Exposure
Calaveras Cement Plant
Redding, CA
Tidewater Oil Company
Avon, CA
Monsanto Chemical
Avon, CA
PG&E Powerhouse
Pittsburg, CA.
Colgate Palmolive
Berkeley, CA
Gerber Foods
Oakland, CA
Ampex Systems Corp.
Redwood City, CA
Pacific Bell Telephone
San Francisco, CA
PG&E
Antioch, CA
Hercules Powder
Hercules, CA
Georgia Pacific
Arcata, CA
Job Title
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insujator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Exposure
Dates
1961-1965
(1 month)
1961-1962
(Approx 1 month)
1961-65 (Approx
1 month)
1961-1965
(3 months)
FAIGI-1O/1961;
711962-5/1965
(5 weeks, on and
off)
7/1961-10/196);
TA962-SN965
(3 weeks, on and
off)
1961-1962 (2-3
weeks, on and off)
196 f-1965
(3 months)
1961-1965
. (5-6 months)
7/1961-LO/1 961;
7/1962-S/1965
(1 month, on and
off)
7/1961-10/1961;
711962-5/1965
(2-3 months, on
and off)
EXHIBIT A
{
i
|
|
'
|
|Enloyer
Wester Asbestos
3150 3° Street
San Francisco, CA
oo me NA He we OR
EXHIBIT A (cont'd.
Location of .
Exposure Job Title
Bethlehem Stee! Insulator
Shipbuilding
San Francisco, CA
Triple A Machine Shop
(Pier 64)
an Francisco, CA
Willamette Shipyard
Richmond, CA
Pacific Ship Repair
(Pier 36) *
‘an Francisco, CA
Todd Shipyard
Oakland, CA
Matson Navigation
Pier 30)
an Francisco, CA
Naval Air Station
Alameda, CA
JOSEPH P. KENNEDY
IR,
(DD-850)
ea
~AG-174)
HAWAHAN PL
(1945)
AFEL
(AF-29
MATHEWS
{AKA-96)
MERRICK
(AKA-97)
WANIN
BD-340)
Exposure
Dates
7/1961-10/1961;
7N962-5/1965
(on and off for
approx. 1 week
each time)
EXHIBIT ASwe yw aw Bw PD
12
Employer
Western Asbestos
3150 3” Street
San Francisco, CA (cont’d.)
Wester Asbestos
3150.3" Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3° Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA
Mt
jure 938 15
SGMPLAINT TOR PERSONAL INJURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM. ASBESTOS
EXHIBIT A
Location of
Exposure Job Title
Bethichem Steel Insulator
Shipbuilding
San Francisco, CA
_M
(AP-112)
MONTEREY (1952)
BLAND (APA-134)
PONTCHARTRAIN
(WPG-70)
» i846)
AMERICAN ROBIN
(1943)
noes eNO
HAWAIIAN
(1946)
Grace Cathedral Insulator
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos Pad Insulator
Shop, 3 Avenue and
Army, San Francisco, CA
PG&E Nuclear Powerhouse Insulator
Hambolde County
Eureka, CA .
PG&E Insulator
San Francisco, CA
(Potrero Station)
Exposure
Dates
TA9G1-1 0/1961;
TAN962-5/1965
1963 - 1963 -
74196) -10/1961;
711962-5/1965
(2 weeks, on and
off)
711961-10/1961;
» 7/1962-5/1 965
{2 -3 days, on and
off)
7/1961-10/1961;
711 962-12/1962
(5 months, on and
or
7/1961-1 0/1961;
TN962-12/1962
(2 weeks) :
7/196 1-10/1961;
71962-51965
(2 to 3 weeks, on
and off)
EXHIBIT ADO we MY DH A FW Nm
Row NON RS ew em eB ewe me ee ee
BRRRERRUPESESCREAUARBDE BSCS
Employer
Western Asbestos
3150 3™ Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150.3" Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3” Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3% Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
31503" Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3” Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA
Western Asbestos
3150 3” Street
San Francisco, CA.
“
EXHIBIT A (cont'd.
Location of
Exposure
Dow Chemical
Pittsburg, CA
Shell Oit
Martinez, CA.
PG&E
Oakland, CA
Vallecitos Atomic
Laboratory
Pleasanton, CA
Missile Base
Live Oak, CA.
University of California
Berkeley, CA
(Boiler Plant)
Shell Oil
Martinez, CA
Standard Oil
Richmond, CA
Shell Oil
Martinez, CA.
.
Hills Brothers Coffee
San Francisco, CA
Job Title
Insulator
Insulator
insulator
Insulator
insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Exposure
Dates
7/1961~-10/1961;
711962-5/1965
(1 month, on and
8
7HN96)-10/1961;
711962-5/1965
(6 weeks, on and
off}
711961-10/1961; -
7HN962- 12/1962
(2 weeks, on and
off)
7/1961-10/1961;
7962-51965
(2 weeks, on and
a!
7/196 1~10/1961;
111962-5/1965
CL month, on and
off)
FA9G61-10/1968;
711962-5/1965
(3 weeks)
7/1961-10/1961;
7/1962-5/1965
(2. weeks, on and
al
7/1961-10/1961;
7/1962-5/1965
G weeks, on and
off)
711961-10/1961;
FA9G62- 12/1962
(3 weeks, on and
off)
711961 ~10/1961;
711 962-5/1 965
(2 weeks, on and
off)
EXHIBIT AEmployer
AC&8 Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
|} Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
We
‘ks 17
SGSBERINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIOM - ASBESTOS
EXHIBIT A (cont'd)
Location of
oOsure
US Department of
Agriculture
Albany, CA
Steinhart Aquarium
San Francisca, CA
Union Oi
Rodeo/Oleum, CA
Sonoma State University
Rohnert Park, CA
(Science Building Boiler
Room)
Oakland Coliseum
Oakland, CA
Firestone Tire & Rubber
Salinas, CA
‘Golden Gateway
Apartments
San Francisco, CA
Oakland Museum
Oaktand, CA
California State University
Humboldt, CA
(Science Building)
Job Title
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
(Foreman)
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
(Foreman)
Insulator
Exposure
Dates
8/1960-7/1961;
10/196 1-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
(2 months, on and
off)
1961-1963”
(20 days)
8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
(3 weeks, on and
off)
8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961 -6/1962;
5/1965- 12/1966
(1 month, on and
off)
8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961-6/1962;
3/1965-12/1966
(5 weeks)
8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
(3-4 weeks)
8/1960-7/1961,;
10/1961-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
(1 month)
8/1960-7/1961;
10/196 1-6/1962;
3/1965-12/1966
{1 month, on and
off)
8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961 -6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
(2 to 3 months, on
and off)
EXHIBIT AEn plover
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O, Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA.
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
u“
EXHIBIT A (cont'd.)
Location of
Exposure Job Title
AEC-Lawrence Livermore Insulator
Laboratory (Foreman)
Livermore, CA
Bank of America Insulator
San Francisco, CA (Foreman)
(1 South Van Ness Avenue)
Georgia Pacific Insulator
Samoa, CA (Foreman)
University of California Insulator
Berkeley, CA
San Francisco International Insulator
Airport
San Francisco, CA
UCSF Medical Center Insulator
Parnassus Ave. .
San Francisco, CA
San Francisco State Insulator
University
San Prancisco, CA
Fairmont Hotel Insulator
San Francisco, CA
Chabot College Insulator
Hayward, CA
San Francisco General Insulator
Hospital
San Francisco, CA
Lockheed Insulator
Sumnyvale, CA
Exposure
Dates
8/3960-7/1961;-
10/1961-6/1962;
(month, on and
off)
8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961-6/1962;
5/1965- 12/1966
(3 months, on and
off)
8/1960-7/1961;
10/196 1-6/1962;
5/1965- 12/1966
(1 month, on and
off)
8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
8/1960-6/1962;
541965-12/1966
8/1960-6/1962;
5/1965- 12/1966
8/1960-6/1962,
5/1965~12/1966
8/1960-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
{100 days)
8/1960-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966
EXHIBIT ACO MN AH
Employer
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
120 North Lime St.
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
120 North Lime St.
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
120 North Lime St.
Lancaster, PA
ACS Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O, Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
ut
Pi
EXHIBI t'd.
Location of
in
Stanford Medical Center
Palo Alto, CA
Stanford University
Engineering Bldg.;
School Business;
other buildings
Palo Alto, CA.
Golden Gateway Center
Apartments
San Francisco, CA
. Children’s Hospital
California Street
San Francisco, CA
Kaiser Hospital
Geary Street
San Francisco, CA
Hillcrest Elementary
- School
Rodeo, CA
Hall of Justice
Oakland, CA
Georgia Pacific
Arcata, CA
Bechtel Building
50 Beale Street
San Francisco, CA
NASA-AMES Research
Center
Moffett Field
Sunnyvale, CA
Veterans Administration
Hospital
Palo Alto, CA
AL INJURY Al
LOSS OF COl RT
Job Title
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Tusulator
insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
~ ASB
Exposure,
Dates
1960 - 1962;
1965 ~ 1966
8/1960-6/1962;
5/1 965-12/1966
1960-1962,
1965-1966
1960-1962;
1965-1966
1960-1962;
1963-1966
1961 - 1962
(1 month, on and
off)
1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966
(Lweek, on and
0}
1960 ~ 1962;
1965 - 1966
(2 weeks)
1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966
(J week)
1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966
1960 ~ 1962;
1965 - 1966
EXHIBIT AEmployer
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
we
4
|
|
61 AC&S insulation
| P.O. Box 1268
7 | Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA.
AC&S Insulation
) P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
} AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
| Lancaster, PA
| AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA.
| AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA
27
28
EXHIBIT td.)
Location of
Berkeley High School
Berkeley, C.
Shell Oil
Martinez, CA
“Naval Hospital
Oakland, CA
Emerson Elementary
School
Berkeley, CA
1BM
Cottle Road
San Jose, CA
Hewlett Packard
Palo Alto, CA
General Motors
Fremont, CA
Washington Hospital
Fremont, CA
St. Luke’s Hospital
San Francisco, CA
Chiron Building
Berkeley, CA
K-Mart
Vallejo, CA
Job Title
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Exposure
Dates
8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
(3 days)
8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961-6/1962;
5/1963-12/1 966
(2 weeks, on and
o
1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966
(3 weeks, on and
off)
1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966
2 weeks
{on and off)
1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966
1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966
1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966
1960 ~ 1962;
1965 - 1966
1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966
1960 ~ 1962;
1965 - 1966
© 1967 - 1972
EXHIBIT AEmployer
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
Consolidated insulation
Consolidated Insulation
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
51?-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA.
Consolidated Insulation
317-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA.
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
We
Wt
VA it'd,
Location of
x: H
State Compensation
Building, 1275 Market St,
San Francisco, CA
Alameda Count:
Administration Building,
Oak Street,
Oakland, CA
Children’s Hospital,
San Francisco, CA
Community College,
Mission Street,
San Francisco, CA
Stanford University
Encina Hall
Palo Alto, CA
Ghirardelli Square
Northpoint Street
San Francisco, CA
Mount Zion Hospital &
Medical Center
San Francisco, CA
Naval Supply
Center Annex
Alameda, CA
Hilton Hotel
Union Square
San Francisco, CA
Fisherman's Wharf
San Francisco, CA
Pier 39
San Francisco, CA
dob Tie
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
(Foreman)
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
insulator
Insulator
Exposure
Dates
1967 - 1972,
1977 - 1979
(6 weeks, on and
off)
1967 - 1972;
1977 - 1979
(2 weeks)
1967 - 1972;
1977-1981 (on
and off)
1967 - 1972;
1977 - 1981
(G weeks, on and
off}
1967 - 1972
(1-2 weeks)
1967 - 1972
(2 weeks)
1967 - 1972
(6 weeks off & on)
1967 - 1972
(3 weeks)
1967 - 1972
(1 month, on and
off)
1966-1973
CL month, on and
off); 1977-1980
- 1967-1970
EXHIBIT A2 Oe BW A hh Fw NM =
= 5
12
Employer
Consolidated insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA.
Consolidated Insulation
317-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
317-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
317-D Marine View Ave.
Beimont, CA.
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA’
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
537-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA.
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
MW
XHIBM ‘cont'd,
Location of
Exposure
Ghiradelli Square
San Francisco, CA
Bechtel Building
30 Beale Street
San Francisco, CA
Golden Gateway Center
Apartment Towers
San Francisco, CA
Hewlett Packard
Palo Alto, CA
General Motors
Fremont, CA
Oakland Coliseum
Oakland, CA
Chabot College
Hayward, CA
St. Luke’s Hospitai
San Francisco, CA
Chiron Building
Berkeley, CA
Stanford University
Palo Alto, CA
San Francisco General
Hospital
San Francisco, CA
Atomic Energy
Commission
Lawrence Livermore
Laboratory
Livermore, CA
Vg stepnteunp 2
ESSIEN PGI PERSONAL INIURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM ASBESTOS-——-—————
Job Title
Insulator
Insulator
insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Exposure
te
1967-1970
1967-1970
‘sage
1967-1972
1967-1972
1967-1972
1967-1972
1967-1972
1967-1972
1/1967-3/1972
1/1967-3/1972
1/1967-3/1972
EXHIBIT AEmplover
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Losulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
EXHIBIT A (cont'd.)
Location of
Exposure
San Francisco Stare
University
San Francisco, CA
Fairmont Hotel
San Francisco, CA
Cafiada College
Woodside, CA
UCSF Medical Center
Parnassus Ave.
San Francisco, CA
University of California
Berkeley, CA
San Francisco International
Airport
San Francisco, CA
NASA-Ames Research |
Center
Moffett Field
Sunnyvale, CA
Washington Hospital
Fremont, CA
Stanford Medical Center
Palo Alto, CA.
St. Patrick's High School
Benicia Road
Vallejo, CA
U.S. Air Force--Travis
FB
A
Fairfield, CA
(Commissary)
Job Title
Insulator
Insulator
insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
{nsutator
insulator
(Foreman)
Insulator
Exposure
” Dates
1/1967-3/1972
1/1967-3/1972
1/1967-3/1972
1/1967-3/1972
Angry 39a
1/1967-3/1972
1967-1970
1967-1970
4967-1970
1/1967-3/1972
(1 month, on and
off)
1/1967-3/1972
(2 months, on and
off)
EXHIBIT AEmp! Over
Consolidated Inswlation
317-D Marine View Ave,
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
317-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA.
Consolidated Insulation
317-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA.
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA.
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave,
Belmont, CA
MW
Mu“
EXHIBIT A (cont'd)
Location of
Alameda Hospital
Alameda, CA
US Post Office
Vallejo, CA
Ice House |
San Francisco, CA
Langley Porter Clinic
San Francisco, CA
PG&E
The Geysers, CA
Fairmont Hotel
San Francisco, CA
Civic Center Auditorium
San Francisco, CA
Marin Civie Center,
San Rafael, CA
Standard Oil Building
225 Bush St. -
San Francisco, CA
China Basin Building
185 Berry St.
San Francisco, CA
Jack Tar Hote)
(aka Cathedral Hill Hotel)
1101 Van Ness
San Francisco, CA
Job Title
Insulator
Insulator
(Foreman)
Insulator
(Foreman)
Insulator
(Foreman)
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
(Foreman) °
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Exposure
Dates
11967-31972
(1 week, on and
°
1/1967-3/1972
C1 month, on and
a
1/1967-3/1972
(2 months, on and
o
1/1967-3/1972
(1 week, on and
off)
1/1967-3/1972
(6 weeks, on and
off)
1967-1972
(9 days)
11967-31972
{2 to 3 weeks, on
and off)
1967 --1972;
1977 - 1981
(1 month, on and
off)
1/1967-3/1972
(1 week, on and
off}
1/1967-3/1972
(3 weeks)
[/1967-3/1972
(2 weeks, on and
off)
EXHIBIT Atp OD PW NR RH BR wR
~ See eee ee ee
BeRRRPSRUXE RSS SGA EGR ER
lover
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave,
Belmont, CA
Consolidated insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated insulation
517-D Marine View Ave,
Bebnont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
317-D Marine View Ave.
Beimont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation.
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA.
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
i
KAtnpupedt 93 inp ens
AHIBIT A (cont'd,
Location of
& KPOSULE
Embarcadero Center
#1, #2, #3
San Francisco, CA
San Francisco War
Memorial Opera House
San Francisco, CA
S.P.C.A.
San Francisca, CA
Safeway Bakery
Richmond, CA
Kilpatrick Bakery
Oakland, CA
Sandia National Laboratory
Livermore, CA
Napa State Hospital
Napa, CA
US Department of
Agriculture
Albany, CA
Kaiser Hospital
2425 Geary Blvd.
San Francisco, CA
California Pacific Medical
Center
San Francisco, CA
(California Street)
Coast Guard Facility
Monterey, CA
Veterans Administration
Hospital
Yountville, CA
Job Title
Insulator
Insulator
(Foreman)
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
(Foreman)
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Exposure
Dates
1/1967-3/1972
(] month, on and
off)
1/1967- 1970
(1 week, on and
oft
1/1967-3/1972
(3 weeks, on and
off)
1/1967-3/1972
(2 weeks, on and
off)
1967-1968
(2 months, on and
off)
1/1967-3/1972
(i month, on &
off)
1/1967-3/1970
(L month, on and
off)
1/1967-3/1972
(3 weeks, on and
off)
1967-1972
1/1967-3/1972
(2. weeks, on and
offy
1/1 967-3/1972
(1 week, on and
off}
1/1967-3/1972
(week, on and
off)
EXHIBIT A
Y ul
25
F CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOSoU BN KR RYN
po
tll vt
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
317-12 Marine View Ave,
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation.
317-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave,
Belmont, CA.
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
ut
at
Kates 3 siege.
COMPLAINT FOR PE]
EXHIBIT A (cont'd.
Location of
Exposure
Unknown Meat Packing
Plant .
Sacramento, CA
Stonestown Shopping
Center
San Francisco, CA
Napa County Hall of
Justice
Napa, CA
Kaiser Hospital
Vallejo, CA
Alta Bates Hospital
Oakland, CA
Mills Building:
(Bush/Montgomery)
San Francisco, CA
pity Administration
Building
Cutting Boulevard
Richmond, CA
690 Market Street
San Francisco, CA
50 California Street
San Francisco, CA
St. Mary’s Church
San Francisco, CA
Hi land Hospital
land, CA
Job Title
Insulator
insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
insulator
Insulator
Exposure,
Dates
1/1967-3/1972
(2 weeks, on and
off)
1/1967-3/11972
(1 month, on and
off)
11967-31972
(3 days, on and
off) .
1/1967-3/1972
(3 weeks, on and
off)
1/1967 - 1972;
1977 ~ 3/1980
G to 4 weeks, on
and off)
1/1.967-3/1972
(on and off)
1/4967-3/1972
(2. months, on and
off}
1967-3/1972
{1 week, on and
9:
1/1967-3/1972
(2 weeks, on and
off)
1/1967-3/1972
(6 weeks, on and
off)
1/1967-3/1972
(1 month, on and
o!
EXHIBIT A
INAL INJURY AND res HPCORSCRTTR ~ ASBESTOSEmployer
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave,
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
5}7-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Siefert and Rossi
1501 North C Street
Sacramento, CA.
ut
EXHIBIT. A (contd.)
Location of
Exposure
American Can Company
San Leandro, CA
| Bush Street
San Francisco, CA
Hong Kong Bank
San Francisca, CA
(Headquarters) 60
ansome Street) =“
111 Pine Street
San Francisco, CA
333 Bush Street
San Francisco, CA
Naval Station Treasure
Island
San Francisco, CA
{BM
San Jose, CA
Lockheed
Sunnyvale, CA
Lucky Deli Plant
San Leandro, CA
101 California Street,
San Francisco, CA
Aerojet-General
Rancho Cordova, CA
Job Title
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator.
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Exposure
Dates
11967-3/1972
(4 days, on and
off)
1/1967-3/1972
(2 weeks, on and
01
1/1967-3/1972
(1 week)
1/1967-3/1972;
SITT-1181
(3 weeks, on and
off)
1/1967-3/1972;
S/TT-UBL*
CL month, on and
off) .
1/1967-3/1972;
S/77-U183
(L month, on and
off)
1967-1972;
1977-1981
1967-1972;
1977-1981
1969 (1 week, on
and off)
1970 - 1972;
1977 ~ 1979
(on and off)
41972-91973
(18 working days)
EXHIBIT A
i
:
:
:
q
:
:
/
iEmployer
Siefert and Rossi
1501 North C Street
Sacramento, CA
Siefert and Rossi
4501 North C Street
Sacramento, CA
Siefert and Rossi
1501 North C Street
Sacramento, CA
Siefert and Rossi
1501 North C Street
Sacramento, CA.
Plant Insulation
227) California Street
San Francisco, CA
Plant Insulation
2271 California Street
San Francisco, CA
Plant Insulation
2271 California Street
San Francisco, CA
Plant insulation Co.
2271 California Street
San Francisco, CA
Plant insulation
2271 Califomia Street
San Francisco, CA
Plant Insulation
2271 Califomia Street
San Francisco, CA
uw
EXHIBIT_A (cont'd)
Location of
Exposu ec
General Mills,
Lodi, CA
Kaiser Hospital
Sacramento, CA
Sacramento Convention
Center
Sacramento, CA
(16" St)
Truckee High School,
Truckee, CA
Westin Saint Francis
(Powell Street)
San Francisco, CA
Leiterman Hospital
& Medical Center
San Francisco, CA
Standard Oil
Richmond, CA
Shell Oil Refinery
Martinez, CA
PG&E Powerhouse
Pittsburg, CA
Union Oil,
Rodeo/ Oleum, CA
Job Title
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator ~
Insulator
Exposure
Dates
1972-1973
4f1972-9/1973
(3 weeks, on and
off)
411972-9/1 973
(3 months, on and
off)
411 972-9N9T3
{2 weeks, on and
off}
10/1973-12/1973;
3/1974-3/1976;
10/1976-2/1977
(21 to 26 days)
10/1973-12/1973;
3/1974-3/1976;
10/1976-2/1977
(Lmonth, on and
off)
10/1973- 12/1973;
3/1974-3/1976;
10/1976-2/1977
(4 months, on and
off)
1973-1977
10/1973-12/1973:
3/1974-3/1976;
10/1976-2/1977
(3-4 months, on
and off)
1973-1977
(on and off for
approx. 2 months)
EXHIBIT A~
we Ow WDA KH A WN
Employer
Plant Insulation
227) Califomia Street
San Francisco, CA
Plant Insulation
2271 California Street
San Francisca, CA
Plant Insulation
2271 Califomia Street
San Francisco, CA
Plant Insulation
2271 California Street
San Francisco, CA
Plant Insulation
227) California Street
§an Francisco, CA
Plant Insulation
2271 California Street
San Francisco, CA
Plant Insulation .
2271 California Street
San Francisco, CA
Plant Insulation
2271 California Street
San Francisco, CA
Western MacArthur
2855 Mandela Parkway
Oakland, CA
Wt
EXHIBI nit'd.
Location of
Exposure:
Fireman’s Fund
Novato, CA
Colgate-Palmolive
Berkeley, CA
Phillips Petroleum
Gompany! Lion Oi!
mpany
Avon, CA
Mare Island Naval
Shipyard
Vallejo, CA
TROUT (88-566)
GUDGEON (SS-567)
General America Soda Ash
Plant .
Green River, Wyoming,
Queen of the Valley
Hospital .
Napa, CA
Standard Oil Building
San Francisco, CA
(555 Market Street)
Standard Oil
Richmond, CA
Louisiana Pacific’
Samoa, CA.
Job Tile
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Exposure
10/1973- 12/1973;
3/1974-3/1976;
10/1976-2/1977
(1 month, on and
off}
40/1973-12/1973;
3/1974-3/1976;
10/1976-2/1977
(L month, on and
off)
10/1973-12/1973;
3/1974-3/1976;
10/1976-2/1977
(1 month, on and
off}
10/1973-12/1973;
3/1974-3/1976;
VON976-2/1977
(1 month, on and
off)
10/1973-12/1973;
3/1974-3/1976;
10/1976-2/1977
(2 months)
10/1973-12/1973;
3/1974-3/1976;
10/1976-2/11977
(4 months, on and
off)
311974-3/5976
C1 year)
1974 - 1977
1/1974-3/1974
(3-4 weeks)
EXHIBIT A
SORTIUM - ASBESTOSEmployer
} Western MacArthur
2855 Mandela Parkway
Oakland, CA
2855 Mandela Parkway
Oakland, CA
Wester MacArthur
2855 Mandela Parkway
Oakland, CA
Owens-Coming Fiberglas
10] 1 Owens Coming Parkway
Toledo, OH
Owens-Corning Fiberglas
! Owens Coming Parkway
Toledo, OH
| Plant Insulation
14} 2271 California Street
| San Francisco, CA
i]
| Plant Insulation
} 2271 California Street
|] San Francisco, CA
Combustion Engineering
18 || 1119 Riverfront Parkway
Chatfanaoga, TN
Combustion Engineering
H 1119 Riverfront Parkway
| Chattanooga, TN
Douglass Insulation
3990 Ralston Avenue
Hillsborough, CA
Douglass Insulation
3990 Ralston Avenue
| Hillsborough, CA
Douglass Insulation
26 || 3990 Ralston Avenue
Hillsborough, CA
cont'd.
Location of
Exposure Job Title
Union Oil
Rodeo/Oleum, CA
Insulator
Chevron Chemical
(aka Ortho Plant)
Richmond, CA
Todd Shipyard
Alameda! CA
insulator
Insulator
Anheuser Busch Insulator
(Budweiser) Brewery
‘airfield, CA
Modules-Alaska
Sacramento, CA
Insulator
Anheuser Busch Insulator
(Bud weiser} Brewery
‘airfield, CA
Union Oil
: Insulator
Roded/Oleum, CA
PG&E Powerhouse
Pittsburg, CA
Insulator
Mojave Powerhouse (SCE) Insulator
Laughlin, NV
Laguna Honda Hospital and Insulator
Rehabilitation Center
San Francisco, CA
UCSF Medicat Center Insulator
San Francisco, CA
Standard Oil Building Insulator
555 Market Street
San Francisco, CA
Exposure
Dates
1/1974-3/1974
G weeks, on and
of)
. W974 3/1974
(2 weeks, on and
off)
V/1974-3/1974
(3 weeks, on and
off)
4/1976-10/1976
(3 to 4 months)
4/1976-10/1976
@ months)
10/1976-2/1977
(3 months, on and
oO
11977-21977
(2 months)
2/1977-3/11977
(3 weeks)
2/1977-3/1977 -
(1 month)
AN977-S11977
(2 weeks)
MA9TT-SI9TT
(9 days)
4/1977-5/1977
(1-2 weeks)
EXHIBIT Awwe TD DAH RB WN
=— = me
A Bw NN = So
Employe:
Douglass Insulation
3990 Ralston Avenue
Hillsborough, CA
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA.
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insvlation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA.
Consolidated insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA.
Consolidated Insulation
517-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation
$17-D) Marine View Ave.
Belmont, CA
W
EXHIBIT nt'd.
Location of
Ex posure
Douglass Insulation Shop
Yosemite Street
San Francisco, CA
Sun Valley Shopping
Center
Concord, CA
Kaiser Hospital
(Broadway Street)
Oakland, CA
Vallejo City Hall
Vallejo, CA
500 Howard St.
San Francisco, CA
Veterans Administration
Hospital
Palo Alto, CA
Louise M. Davies
Symphony Hall
San Francisco, CA
459 Post St.
San Francisco, CA
Mare Island Naval
Shipvard
Vallejo, CA
US Aic Force
Travis Ar Force Base
Fairfield, CA
Sonoma State Hospital
Eldridge, CA
Santa Rosa Junior College
Santa Rosa, CA
Job Title
Insulator
insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
Insulator
I insulator
Insulator
Exposure
Dates
4NN9T7-SIN9TT
(7-9 days, 4 or S
times)
S/77-1980
(2 weeks, on and
off}
S/1977-1/1 981
(4 weeks, on and
off)
1977 (3 weeks, on
and off,
1977 (4 week, on.
and off}
t 977 )
approx.
months)
1977-1980
(3 weeks, on and
off} :
1977-1980
(1 week, on and
off)
1977 Gto
4 weeks, on and
off)
1977 (3 weeks, on
and off}
19
Preview
LAW OFFICES OF COOLEY MANION JONES HAKE KurOWSKILLP wwe NY DH WS William M. Hake, Esq. (State Bar No. 110956) Melissa E. Macfarlane, Esq. (State Bar No. 239811) Rachael A, Buckman, Esq. (State Bar No, 263224) ELECTRONICALLY COOLEY MANION JONES HAKE KUROWSKI LLP FILED 201 Spear Street, 18th Floor Super oe : iperior Court of California, = ress A sete County of San Francisco Fax: (415) 512-6791 FEB 03 2011 Clerk of the Court Attorneys for Defendant BY: WILLIAM v Nepal Clerk TEMPORARY PLANT CLEANERS, INC. f/k/a PLANT MAINTENANCE, INC. OF CALIFORNIA IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO ROBERT ROSS and JEAN ROSS, Case No. CGC-10-275731 Plaintiffs, DECLARATION OF RACHAEL A. BUCKMAN IN SUPPORT OF v. DEFENDANT TEMPORARY PLANT CLEANERS, INC. f/k/a PLANT C.C. MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS; MAINTENANCE, INC. OF Defendants as Reflected on Exhibit 1 attached | CALIFORNIA’S DEMURRER TO to the Summary Complaint herein; and DOES PLAINTIFFS’ COMPLAINT 1-$500. Hearing Date: March 3, 2011 Time: 9:30 a.m. Dept.: 220 Complaint: December 17, 2010 Trial Date: TBD I, Rachael A. Buckman, declare as follows: 1, Iam an attorney licensed to practice law in the State of California and an associate of the law firm Cooley Manion Jones Hake Kurowski LLP, attorneys of record for Defendant Temporary Plant Cleaners, Inc. f/k/a Plant Maintenance, Inc. of California (“TPC”). I have personal knowledge of each fact stated in this declaration and, if called upon to testify, could and would competently testify thereto. Mt -Le DECLARATION OF RACHAEL A. BUCKMAN IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT TEMPORARY PLANT CLEANERS, INC. t/k/a PLANT MAINTENANCE, INC, OF CALIFORNIA’S DEMURRER TO PLAINTIFFS’ COMPLAINTLaw OFFICES OF COOLEY MANION JONES HAKE KuROWSKI LLP RW eM MW MN RP NR KY BR Be Se Be Be eB Se eB ewe ee eo VW A RA KF 8 SS = SF Swe BAH BO YP SB STS ‘|| for Personal Injury and Loss af Consortium ~ Asbestos, filed December 17, 2010. oO ON A ROR YH LD 2. Attached hereto as Exhibit A is a true and correct copy of Plaintiff's Complaint 3. Attached hereto as Exhibit B is a true and correct copy of the Brayton Purcell Master Complaint for Personal Injury [and Loss of Consortium] - Asbestos, filed January 2, 2003, in In re; Asbestos Cases of Brayton Purcell, San Francisco County Superior Court, Case No. 828684. I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on February 3, 2011 at San Francisco, California. » Rachael A. Buckman -2- DECLARATION OF RACHAEL A, BUCKMAN IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT TEMPORARY PLANT CLEANERS, INC. ia PLAN) T MAINTENANCE, INC. OF CALIFORNIA’S DEMURRER TO PLAINTIFFS’ COMPLAINTEXHIBIT ABRAYTON@PURCELL LLP ATFORNEYS AT LAW 222 RUSH LANDING ROAD POBOX G69 NOVATO, CALIFORNIA 9388-6169 {AES 981555 DAVID R. DONADIO, ESQ., 3.B. #154436 BRAYTON*PURCELL LL ENDORSED Altorneys at Law , 222 Rush Landing Road : soatd ED on Novato, Cal forni 94948-6169 ‘0S 0 lovato, California T 1 (415) 898-1553 CASE MAN ARETENT GONFERENCE DEC 47 2010 wo COURT Attorneys for Plaintiffs DEC 15 7011 {2PM ERC GF THE DEPARTMENT 220 SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA ASBESTOS Defendants as Reflected on Exhibit 1 attached 1o the Summary Complaint herein; and DOES 1-8500. COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO ROBERT ROSS and JEAN ROSS, y ASBESTOS ) jo. Plaintiffs, ; C-10-275731. vs. ) COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY . ) ANDLOSS OF CONSORTIUM - C.C, MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS; ) ) 1. Plaintiff ROBERT ROSS was born September 9, 1935. 2. The @Brayton%Purcell Master Complaint for Personal Injury [and Loss of Consortium]- Asbestos (hereinafter "Master Complaint") was filed January 2, 2003, in San Francisco Superior Court. A copy of the Master Complaint and General Order No. 55 may be obtained upon request from Brayton?Purcell, and designated portions of the Master Complaint are incorporated by reference herein pursuant to the authority conferred by General Order No. 55. Plaintiffs’ claims are as set forth in said Master Complaint against defendants herein as follows: ue ue Mt THIS CASE IS SUBJECT TO MANDATORY ELECTRONIC FILING PURSUANT TO AMENDED G.0. 158: TqUyNy Aue Uo to yUrEsdUtOD Jaisepy otf] UT Gop las Se SANUS ABUATPe MOY! PUL, (Geneg [IAID) Doo ob Ob oO ob ob ob be me lhe puooag-Aitian | & (gr Te - Geneg Bulnsqy Surpiy) Ie g-itomL O Quay - wevaq/pnerg) panuant | : (uonejasaidaisipy jeuotuaiuy : Quatuyeaque yu EaSQIdaus py tg “yaa aaag (uQHdy JO H9IHED) GUAIINIS gq (Surpuyp 2oyg ayeag) qiuaayly ‘yueayneg oO {saoiaag Ayayes Arorestdsay) yaannpy “type a LV TAs) ieenayg "yiuay (IVOMH TOW vonesuadieD o SISO Ay LOQIEH PUB aI04STUOF) YIN (ang pur soueuayy [oy sauor] aouatifeay ‘ssauitpiomessun) yiydig ‘gusaag ‘yas (Anpiqery sorsetu0g #BUMO Sastuard) yyty (wniuosti0D Jo sso7y) yunoy (uonentasaiday sje) PAWL (CQiiqer7 to1ig) pitooag (2ousdy Fang) ssary Tony jo SsteD: Oo w& 20 aoa 4o0 al K&ROo 2 YN A HW & 3. Plaintiff's asbestos-related injury, date of diagnosis, employment status, and history of exposure lo asbestos are as stated on Exhibit A. 4, Plaintiffs were married on December 15, 1975. 5. Plaintitf hereby amends the Master Complaint on file berein, to incorporate a new Twenty-First Cause of Action, set forth below, specially plead against the defendant listed on Exhibit N, namely METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY. (Plaintiffs are in the process of amending the Master Complaint herein and will include this new Cause of Action in said amendment.) “TWENTY-FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION Aiding and Abetting Battery [Against Metropolitan Life Insurance Company and Does 7501-7900, Inclusive) AS AND FOR A FURTHER, TWENTY-FIRST, SEPARATE AND DISTINCT -CAUSE OF ACTION FOR AIDING AND ABETTING BATTERY, PLAINTIFF COMPLAINS OF DEFENDANTS METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, DEFENDANTS ON EXHIBIT N, DOES 7501-7900, THEIR ALTERNATE ENTITIES AND EACH OF THEM, AND ALLEGES AS FOLLOWS: 225. Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference, as though fully set forth hereat, each and every allegation of the First through Third and Sixteenth, Seventeenth, Bighteenth and Nineteenth Causes of Action as though fully set forth herein, (AS used throughout this cause of action, ‘plaintiff refers to all named plaintiffs and/or all named decedents from whom the named plaintiff's injuries may derive.) . 226. This cause of action is for the aiding and abetting of battery by METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY (MET LIFE”), primarily through its assistant medical director Anthony Lanza, M.D., of a breach of duty committed by Jobns-Manville Corporation (“J-M”). 227. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and thereon alleges, that at al times herein mentioned defendant MET LIFE was and is a corporation organized and existing under and by virtue of the laws of the State of New York or the laws of some other state or foreign 9 4a. 3 ‘AINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY Al RTIUM- ASBESTOSom YD DH BF wD 10 jurisdiction, and that this defendant was and is authorized to do and/or was and is doing business in the State of California, and regularly conducled or conducts business in the County of San Francisco, State of Califomia. At times relevant to this cause of action, MET LIFE was an insurer of J-M, 228. Plaintiff. was exposed to asbestos-containing dust created by the use of the asbestos products manufactured, distributed and/or supplied by J-M. This exposure to the asbestos or asbestos-related products supplied by |-M caused Plaintiff's asbestos-related disease and injuries. 229. Starting in 1928, MET LIFE sponsored studies of asbestos dust and asbestos- related disease in Canadian mines and mills, including those of J-M. Those studies revealed that miners and mill workers were contracting asbestosis at relatively low levels of dust. McGill University, which conducted the studies, sought permission from MET LIFE to publish the results but they were never published. MET LIFE prepared ils own report of these studies. 230. Between 1929 and 1931, MET LIFE studied dust levels and disease at five U.S. plants manufacturing asbestos-containing products. including a J-M plant. Those studies showed that workers in substantial numbers were contracting asbestosis, at levels less than what became the Threshold Limit Value (TLV”) of Smppef. The MET LIFE report was never published or disseminated except to plant owners. including J-M. 231. tn 1932, MET LIFE studied dust levels and disease at the J-M plant at Manville, New Jersey. Results were consistent with those of the Canadiafi and previous U.S. plant studies. They were never published. : 232. In 1934, J-M and others whose plants MET LIFE had studied agreed with MET LIFE that it should issue a report of its studies. 233. MET LIFE submitted a draft of its report to J-M. I-M requested, for legal and business reasons, that certain critical parts of the draft be changed. MET LIFE’s official in charge was Lanza. MET LIFE through Lanza did make changes that J-M requested, including: (a) Deletion of MET LIFE’s conclusion that the permissible dust Jevel for asbestos should be less than that for silica; KSajuresna4 hte 4 COMPLAINT FOR PERSONA THIGRY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOS(b) Addition of the phrase that asbestosis clinically appeared to be milder than silicosis. The report, thus allered, was published in 1935. It was misleading, and intentionally so, because il conveyed the incorrect propositions thal asbestosis was a less serious disease process than silicosis and that higher tevels of ashestos dust could be tolerated without contracting diseases than was the case for silica dust. 234. MET LIFE had a close relationship with J-M. It invested money in J-M. It provided group health and life insurance to J-M. MET LIFE IN 1934 agreed ta supply industrial hygiene services to J-M, including dust counts, training employees to monitor dust levels, examining employees, and recommending protective equipment. MET LIFE and Lanza were viewed as experts on industrial dusts. 233. In 1933, MET LIFE through Lanza issued the following advices to J-M: {a) Disagreeing with the reconmmendation of a J-M plant physician, MET LIFE advised against waming workers of the fact that asbestos dust is hazardous to their health, basing its advice in view of the extraordinary legal situation; (b} When the plant physician judged the best disposition ofan employee with asbestosis was to remove him from the dust, MET LIFE advised instead that disposition should depend on his age, nature of work and other factors and to leave him alone if he is old and showing no disability, for, MET LIFE stated, economic and production factors must be balanced against medical factors. 236. J-M followed the MET LIFE advices and did not warn its workers, including plaintiff, of the hazards of asbestos dust, and J-M also intentionally refrained from notifying workers of their disease. 237. In $936, MET LIFE, J-M and others founded the Air Hygiene Foundation (“AHF”). One of the AHF purposes was to develop standards for dust levels that would serve as a defense in lawsuits and workers’ compensation claims. 238. MET LIFE funded partially another study that tentatively recommended in 1938 a TLV fox asbestos dust of Smpeef, the-same as for silica dust. MET LIFE was aware of data10 27 28] we NW DH B&B YN | from its own, unpublished reports that showed that level was too high for asbestos dust. MET LIFE nonetheless promoted that TLV as proper. 239. In June 1947, the Industrial Hygiene Foundation (“1HP") which succeeded to the | AHF, issued a report of studies by Dr. Hemeon of U.S. asbestos plants, including a J-M plant. That report showed that workers exposed (o less than the recommended maximum levels of ~ dust were developing disease. MET LIFE was a member of the If1F and Lanza was on its medical committee. The Hemeon report, which was supplied to J-M and other owners, never was published. 240. In 1936, J-M and other ‘asbestos companies agreed with a leading medical research facility, Saranac Laboratories. that Saranac would research asbestos disease, but J-M and the Saranac’s critique of existing dust standards. Lanza directed Saranac to delete the offending | materiats. Saranac did so, and the altered report was published in 1951 by Saranac’s Dr. Vorwald, in the AMA Archives of Indusirial Hygiene. 242. Lanza lefi MET LIFE at the end of 1948, and took a position al New York University, funded by MET LIFE. He continued to misrepresent that asbestos does not cause cancer into the 1950s. 243. The IHF (formerly AHF), of which MET LIFE was a member and MET LIFE || official was on its medical committee, through Drs. Braun and Truan conducted a study of || Canadian miners. The original report, in 1957, found an increased incidence of lung cancer in persons exposed to asbestos. The sponsors, including J-M, caused those findings to be stricken, and the report published in 1958 contained the false conclusion that asbestos exposure alone did not increase the risk of lung cancer. KArivsess one itepblet. 6 NAL TNIORY AND LOSS OF RTM: ASBESTOS26 244. The false and misleading reports that a link between asbestos exposure and cancer was not proven influenced the TLV. for if a substance causes cancer the TLV must be very low OF 210. 243, J-M not later than 1933 was inflicting asbestos dust on its workers in its plants knowing that the dust was hazardous and was causing workers to contract disease thal could and would disable and kill them. As MET LIFE advised, J-M did aot warn ils workers of the hazard. J-M committed battery on workers in its plants, including plaintiff, by that conduct. 246. MET LIFE knew that J-M’s conduct constituted a breach of its duties to its workers. MET LIFE gave substantial assistance to J-M in commilting batteries 6n its workers, including plaintiff, through MET LIFE’s conduct described above, including by: (a) Affirmatively urging J-M not to warn workers of the hazards of asbestos dust. in view of the extraordinary legal situation, such that J-M did not warn its workers, including plaintiff; {b) Deleting the findings of its own drafi report that the allowable limits for asbestos dust should be less than those for silica dust, and promoting a false and unsafe TLV which specified maximum levels of silica dust, and promoting a false and unsafe TLV which specified maximum levels of dust for workers, including - plaintiff, which MET LIFE knew was wrong through its own studies; : (c) Advising J-M to keep certain workers continuing to work at dusty areas in the plant even after J-M was aware that their lungs showed asbestos-induced changes, lest other workers including plaintiff be alerted to the dangers of working in the dust. WHEREFORE, plaintiff prays judgment as is hereinafter set forth.” 6. Plaintiff's do not make claim for either false representative or punitive damages against any named defendant herein. Dated: Ab} BRAYTON*PURCELL LLP By: ~ David R. Dona: . Attorneys for PlaintiffsEXHIBIT 1EXHIBIT. 1- LISY OF DEFENDANTS C.C. MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS ASSOCIATED INSULATION OF CALIFORNIA FLUOR CORPORATION : HANSON PERMANENTE CEMENT, INC, FORMERLY KNOWN AS KAISER CEMENT CORPORATION METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY OAKFABCO, INC. SLAKEY BROTHERS, INC. BAYER CROPSCIENCE INC. } GRAYBAR ELECTRIC COMPANY, INC. s| CSK AUTO, INC. THE GOODYEBAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY JOHNSON CONTROLS, INC. PHARMACIA CORPORATION, WHICH WiLL DO QUSINESS IN CALIFORNIA AS PHARMACIA PHARMACEUTICAL CORPORATION H&C INVESTMENT ASSOCIATES, INC. . FOLEY ELECTRIC CO. } CINCINNATI VALVE COMPANY C&R PLASTERING, INC, | TUTTLE AND BAILEY CORP | LAUB SHEET METAL WORKS | WILLARD ELECTRIC WESTBURNE SUPPLY, INC. COMMAIR MECHANICAL SERVICES ACCO ENGINEERED SYSTEMS, INC. IMPERIAL PLASTERING & DRYWALL, GENERAL MILLS, INC. KENTILE FLOORS, INC, DOMCO PRODUCTS TEXAS, LP. FULLER FLOORS ROBERT MAGEE MARSHCO AUTO PARTS, INC. EMIL J. WEBER ELECTRIC CO. THE W.W. HENRY COMPANY TEMPORARY PLANT CLEANERS, INC. D, ZELINSKY & SONS, INC. ALBAY CONSTRUCTION COMPANY PACIFIC MECHANICAL CORPORATION WALNUT CREEK SHEET METAL, FURNACE & AIR CONDITIONING, INC. | PARKER INSULATION CONTRACTING & SUPPLY CO. INC, | EX- PME, INC. (FKA FISCHBACH AND MOORE ELECTRIC, INC.) } GIAMPOLINI & CO. WEBCOR BUILDERS, INC. JONES PLASTERING COMPANY J.W. MCCLENAHAN COMPANY, INC, SCOTT CO. OF CALIFORNIA || BARNES CONSTRUCTION Co. BALLIET BROS. CONSTRUCTION CORPORATION | CLAUSEN-PATTEN, INC. A. TEICHERT & SON, INC. CRITCHFIELD MECHANICAL, INC. JOSEPH BRUNO SHEET METAL CO., INC.ow eI DA HH BELL PRODUCTS INC. ALLEN-SIMMONS HEATING & SHEET METAL COMPANY INC, ROLLIE R. FRENCH, INC. HEWRY C. BECK COMPANY INSULATION SPECIALTIES, INC. TEMPER INSULATION RED TOP ELECTRIC CO. EMERYVILLE, INC, SFL, INC. ALLSBERRY MECHANICAL CORPORATION MIDSTATE MECHANICAL, INC, ROUNTREE PLUMBING & HEATING INC. COLLINS ELECTRICAL COMPANY. INC. HAROLD BEASLEY PLUMBING AND HEATING, INC. SUGIDEN ENGINEERING CO. JAMES A. NELSON CO., INC. MICHAEL BROTHERS MACK CONSTRUCTION CO. MITCHELL BROS. TRUCK LINES, INC, AIR SYSTEMS MECHANICAL CONTRACTOR A&K HEATING COMPANY, INC, ADVANCED MECHANICAI. PACIFIC FIREPROOFING MATTOCK CONSTRUCTION COMPANY HARRY LEE PLUMBING & HEATING W.C. THOMASON CLIMATE AIR, INC. ALLIED SPRINKLER COMPANY, INC. DELUCCHI SHEET METAL WORKS MCCLURE ELECTRIC, INC. DPR CONSTRUCTION CJR PLASTERING COSCO SPRINKLER ROLLINS CONSTRUCTION BANNER DRYWALL & PAINTING CO, INC. ORTHO-CRAFT DONOVAN CONSTRUCTION BETA MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS, LIMITED PRIBUSS ENGINEERING DILLAND SEDERBERG PLUMBING ERWIN MECHANICAL INC. CLIMATE CONTROL. CO., INC. DORN REFRIGERATION CASTRO CONSTRUCTION, INC. VAN MULDER SHEETMETAL W.C. THOMPSON CALIFORNIA DRYWALL CO. BRAGG INVESTMENT COMPANY, INC. FAIRMONT HOTEL COMPANY D.W. NICHOLSON CORPORATION SWINERTON BUILDERS and DOES 1-8500, Defendants. aojureg 994 a Pl [AL TNJORY AN! IS 10 7 ASBESTOSEXHIBIT AOo @ VA DH Rw 10 EXHIBIT A Plaintiff's exposure to asbestos and asbestos-containing products occurred at various locations both inside and outside the State of California, including but not limited to: Employer : Philip Carey Cinefnnati, OH Coast Insulating Products Los Angeles, CA Universal Insulation 520 6" Avenue Menlo Park, CA Universal Insulation 520 6" Avenue Menlo Park, CA ACES Lancaster, PA Western Asbestos Western Asbestos 3150 3" Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3" Street San Francisco, CA Heat, Frost & Asbestos Workers Union Local 16 Western Asbestos 3150 3" Street San Francisco, CA Mt Klis 194 Men IN IR Location of Exposure Warehouse 10] Williams San Francisco, CA Jack Tar Hotel (aka Cathedral Hill Hotel) 1101 Van Ness San Francisco, CA Fertilizer Plant Helm, CA Mare Istand Naval Shipyard Valigjo, CA Hewlett Packard Menlo Park, CA "UC Berkeley (Central Steam Plant), Berkeley, CA Tidewater Associated Oil Avon, CA PG&E Powerhouse Pittsburg, CA Queen of the Vailey Hospital Napa, CA Maritime Union Mission Street San Francisco, CA McKinleyville High School Insulator McKinleyville, CA 12 Exposure Job Title Dates Warehouseman 2/1959-8/1959; 12/1959-1/1960 (1 week) Insulator 8/1959-9/1959 (Apprentice) (approx. 5 wks) Insulator 1959 (on and off (Apprentice) for 3 months) Insulator 1959 (1-2 weeks) (Apprentice) insulator 1960 - 1962; 1965 - 1966" (1 week) Insulator 1959-1965 (3 weeks) Insulator 1/1960-7/1960 Insulator 7/960 (3 weeks) Insulator Approx. 1960 (i day) 7/1961-L 0/1961; 7/1962-5/1965 GB% weeks, | on and off) EXHIBIT A RTIUM - ASBESTOSEmplover Western Asbestos 3150 3 Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3° Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3” Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3" Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 31503” Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3” Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3° Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3 Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3” Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3" Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3” Street San Francisco, CA “ EXHIBIT A (cont'd.) Location of Exposure Calaveras Cement Plant Redding, CA Tidewater Oil Company Avon, CA Monsanto Chemical Avon, CA PG&E Powerhouse Pittsburg, CA. Colgate Palmolive Berkeley, CA Gerber Foods Oakland, CA Ampex Systems Corp. Redwood City, CA Pacific Bell Telephone San Francisco, CA PG&E Antioch, CA Hercules Powder Hercules, CA Georgia Pacific Arcata, CA Job Title Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insujator Insulator Insulator Insulator Exposure Dates 1961-1965 (1 month) 1961-1962 (Approx 1 month) 1961-65 (Approx 1 month) 1961-1965 (3 months) FAIGI-1O/1961; 711962-5/1965 (5 weeks, on and off) 7/1961-10/196); TA962-SN965 (3 weeks, on and off) 1961-1962 (2-3 weeks, on and off) 196 f-1965 (3 months) 1961-1965 . (5-6 months) 7/1961-LO/1 961; 7/1962-S/1965 (1 month, on and off) 7/1961-10/1961; 711962-5/1965 (2-3 months, on and off) EXHIBIT A { i | | ' | |Enloyer Wester Asbestos 3150 3° Street San Francisco, CA oo me NA He we OR EXHIBIT A (cont'd. Location of . Exposure Job Title Bethlehem Stee! Insulator Shipbuilding San Francisco, CA Triple A Machine Shop (Pier 64) an Francisco, CA Willamette Shipyard Richmond, CA Pacific Ship Repair (Pier 36) * ‘an Francisco, CA Todd Shipyard Oakland, CA Matson Navigation Pier 30) an Francisco, CA Naval Air Station Alameda, CA JOSEPH P. KENNEDY IR, (DD-850) ea ~AG-174) HAWAHAN PL (1945) AFEL (AF-29 MATHEWS {AKA-96) MERRICK (AKA-97) WANIN BD-340) Exposure Dates 7/1961-10/1961; 7N962-5/1965 (on and off for approx. 1 week each time) EXHIBIT ASwe yw aw Bw PD 12 Employer Western Asbestos 3150 3” Street San Francisco, CA (cont’d.) Wester Asbestos 3150.3" Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3° Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3" Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3" Street San Francisco, CA Mt jure 938 15 SGMPLAINT TOR PERSONAL INJURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM. ASBESTOS EXHIBIT A Location of Exposure Job Title Bethichem Steel Insulator Shipbuilding San Francisco, CA _M (AP-112) MONTEREY (1952) BLAND (APA-134) PONTCHARTRAIN (WPG-70) » i846) AMERICAN ROBIN (1943) noes eNO HAWAIIAN (1946) Grace Cathedral Insulator San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos Pad Insulator Shop, 3 Avenue and Army, San Francisco, CA PG&E Nuclear Powerhouse Insulator Hambolde County Eureka, CA . PG&E Insulator San Francisco, CA (Potrero Station) Exposure Dates TA9G1-1 0/1961; TAN962-5/1965 1963 - 1963 - 74196) -10/1961; 711962-5/1965 (2 weeks, on and off) 711961-10/1961; » 7/1962-5/1 965 {2 -3 days, on and off) 7/1961-10/1961; 711 962-12/1962 (5 months, on and or 7/1961-1 0/1961; TN962-12/1962 (2 weeks) : 7/196 1-10/1961; 71962-51965 (2 to 3 weeks, on and off) EXHIBIT ADO we MY DH A FW Nm Row NON RS ew em eB ewe me ee ee BRRRERRUPESESCREAUARBDE BSCS Employer Western Asbestos 3150 3™ Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150.3" Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3" Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3” Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3% Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3" Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 31503" Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3” Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3" Street San Francisco, CA Western Asbestos 3150 3” Street San Francisco, CA. “ EXHIBIT A (cont'd. Location of Exposure Dow Chemical Pittsburg, CA Shell Oit Martinez, CA. PG&E Oakland, CA Vallecitos Atomic Laboratory Pleasanton, CA Missile Base Live Oak, CA. University of California Berkeley, CA (Boiler Plant) Shell Oil Martinez, CA Standard Oil Richmond, CA Shell Oil Martinez, CA. . Hills Brothers Coffee San Francisco, CA Job Title Insulator Insulator insulator Insulator insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Exposure Dates 7/1961~-10/1961; 711962-5/1965 (1 month, on and 8 7HN96)-10/1961; 711962-5/1965 (6 weeks, on and off} 711961-10/1961; - 7HN962- 12/1962 (2 weeks, on and off) 7/1961-10/1961; 7962-51965 (2 weeks, on and a! 7/196 1~10/1961; 111962-5/1965 CL month, on and off) FA9G61-10/1968; 711962-5/1965 (3 weeks) 7/1961-10/1961; 7/1962-5/1965 (2. weeks, on and al 7/1961-10/1961; 7/1962-5/1965 G weeks, on and off) 711961-10/1961; FA9G62- 12/1962 (3 weeks, on and off) 711961 ~10/1961; 711 962-5/1 965 (2 weeks, on and off) EXHIBIT AEmployer AC&8 Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 |} Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA We ‘ks 17 SGSBERINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIOM - ASBESTOS EXHIBIT A (cont'd) Location of oOsure US Department of Agriculture Albany, CA Steinhart Aquarium San Francisca, CA Union Oi Rodeo/Oleum, CA Sonoma State University Rohnert Park, CA (Science Building Boiler Room) Oakland Coliseum Oakland, CA Firestone Tire & Rubber Salinas, CA ‘Golden Gateway Apartments San Francisco, CA Oakland Museum Oaktand, CA California State University Humboldt, CA (Science Building) Job Title Insulator Insulator Insulator (Foreman) Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator (Foreman) Insulator Exposure Dates 8/1960-7/1961; 10/196 1-6/1962; 5/1965-12/1966 (2 months, on and off) 1961-1963” (20 days) 8/1960-7/1961; 10/1961-6/1962; 5/1965-12/1966 (3 weeks, on and off) 8/1960-7/1961; 10/1961 -6/1962; 5/1965- 12/1966 (1 month, on and off) 8/1960-7/1961; 10/1961-6/1962; 3/1965-12/1966 (5 weeks) 8/1960-7/1961; 10/1961-6/1962; 5/1965-12/1966 (3-4 weeks) 8/1960-7/1961,; 10/1961-6/1962; 5/1965-12/1966 (1 month) 8/1960-7/1961; 10/196 1-6/1962; 3/1965-12/1966 {1 month, on and off) 8/1960-7/1961; 10/1961 -6/1962; 5/1965-12/1966 (2 to 3 months, on and off) EXHIBIT AEn plover AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O, Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA. AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA u“ EXHIBIT A (cont'd.) Location of Exposure Job Title AEC-Lawrence Livermore Insulator Laboratory (Foreman) Livermore, CA Bank of America Insulator San Francisco, CA (Foreman) (1 South Van Ness Avenue) Georgia Pacific Insulator Samoa, CA (Foreman) University of California Insulator Berkeley, CA San Francisco International Insulator Airport San Francisco, CA UCSF Medical Center Insulator Parnassus Ave. . San Francisco, CA San Francisco State Insulator University San Prancisco, CA Fairmont Hotel Insulator San Francisco, CA Chabot College Insulator Hayward, CA San Francisco General Insulator Hospital San Francisco, CA Lockheed Insulator Sumnyvale, CA Exposure Dates 8/3960-7/1961;- 10/1961-6/1962; (month, on and off) 8/1960-7/1961; 10/1961-6/1962; 5/1965- 12/1966 (3 months, on and off) 8/1960-7/1961; 10/196 1-6/1962; 5/1965- 12/1966 (1 month, on and off) 8/1960-7/1961; 10/1961-6/1962; 5/1965-12/1966 8/1960-7/1961; 10/1961-6/1962; 5/1965-12/1966 8/1960-6/1962; 541965-12/1966 8/1960-6/1962; 5/1965- 12/1966 8/1960-6/1962, 5/1965~12/1966 8/1960-6/1962; 5/1965-12/1966 {100 days) 8/1960-6/1962; 5/1965-12/1966 1960 - 1962; 1965 - 1966 EXHIBIT ACO MN AH Employer AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation 120 North Lime St. Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation 120 North Lime St. Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation 120 North Lime St. Lancaster, PA ACS Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O, Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA ut Pi EXHIBI t'd. Location of in Stanford Medical Center Palo Alto, CA Stanford University Engineering Bldg.; School Business; other buildings Palo Alto, CA. Golden Gateway Center Apartments San Francisco, CA . Children’s Hospital California Street San Francisco, CA Kaiser Hospital Geary Street San Francisco, CA Hillcrest Elementary - School Rodeo, CA Hall of Justice Oakland, CA Georgia Pacific Arcata, CA Bechtel Building 50 Beale Street San Francisco, CA NASA-AMES Research Center Moffett Field Sunnyvale, CA Veterans Administration Hospital Palo Alto, CA AL INJURY Al LOSS OF COl RT Job Title Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Tusulator insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator ~ ASB Exposure, Dates 1960 - 1962; 1965 ~ 1966 8/1960-6/1962; 5/1 965-12/1966 1960-1962, 1965-1966 1960-1962; 1965-1966 1960-1962; 1963-1966 1961 - 1962 (1 month, on and off) 1960 - 1962; 1965 - 1966 (Lweek, on and 0} 1960 ~ 1962; 1965 - 1966 (2 weeks) 1960 - 1962; 1965 - 1966 (J week) 1960 - 1962; 1965 - 1966 1960 ~ 1962; 1965 - 1966 EXHIBIT AEmployer AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA we 4 | | 61 AC&S insulation | P.O. Box 1268 7 | Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA. AC&S Insulation ) P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA } AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 | Lancaster, PA | AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA. | AC&S Insulation P.O. Box 1268 Lancaster, PA 27 28 EXHIBIT td.) Location of Berkeley High School Berkeley, C. Shell Oil Martinez, CA “Naval Hospital Oakland, CA Emerson Elementary School Berkeley, CA 1BM Cottle Road San Jose, CA Hewlett Packard Palo Alto, CA General Motors Fremont, CA Washington Hospital Fremont, CA St. Luke’s Hospital San Francisco, CA Chiron Building Berkeley, CA K-Mart Vallejo, CA Job Title Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Exposure Dates 8/1960-7/1961; 10/1961-6/1962; 5/1965-12/1966 (3 days) 8/1960-7/1961; 10/1961-6/1962; 5/1963-12/1 966 (2 weeks, on and o 1960 - 1962; 1965 - 1966 (3 weeks, on and off) 1960 - 1962; 1965 - 1966 2 weeks {on and off) 1960 - 1962; 1965 - 1966 1960 - 1962; 1965 - 1966 1960 - 1962; 1965 - 1966 1960 ~ 1962; 1965 - 1966 1960 - 1962; 1965 - 1966 1960 ~ 1962; 1965 - 1966 © 1967 - 1972 EXHIBIT AEmployer Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation Consolidated insulation Consolidated Insulation Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 51?-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA. Consolidated Insulation 317-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA. Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA We Wt VA it'd, Location of x: H State Compensation Building, 1275 Market St, San Francisco, CA Alameda Count: Administration Building, Oak Street, Oakland, CA Children’s Hospital, San Francisco, CA Community College, Mission Street, San Francisco, CA Stanford University Encina Hall Palo Alto, CA Ghirardelli Square Northpoint Street San Francisco, CA Mount Zion Hospital & Medical Center San Francisco, CA Naval Supply Center Annex Alameda, CA Hilton Hotel Union Square San Francisco, CA Fisherman's Wharf San Francisco, CA Pier 39 San Francisco, CA dob Tie Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator (Foreman) Insulator Insulator Insulator insulator Insulator Exposure Dates 1967 - 1972, 1977 - 1979 (6 weeks, on and off) 1967 - 1972; 1977 - 1979 (2 weeks) 1967 - 1972; 1977-1981 (on and off) 1967 - 1972; 1977 - 1981 (G weeks, on and off} 1967 - 1972 (1-2 weeks) 1967 - 1972 (2 weeks) 1967 - 1972 (6 weeks off & on) 1967 - 1972 (3 weeks) 1967 - 1972 (1 month, on and off) 1966-1973 CL month, on and off); 1977-1980 - 1967-1970 EXHIBIT A2 Oe BW A hh Fw NM = = 5 12 Employer Consolidated insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA. Consolidated Insulation 317-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 317-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 317-D Marine View Ave. Beimont, CA. Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA’ Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 537-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA. Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA MW XHIBM ‘cont'd, Location of Exposure Ghiradelli Square San Francisco, CA Bechtel Building 30 Beale Street San Francisco, CA Golden Gateway Center Apartment Towers San Francisco, CA Hewlett Packard Palo Alto, CA General Motors Fremont, CA Oakland Coliseum Oakland, CA Chabot College Hayward, CA St. Luke’s Hospitai San Francisco, CA Chiron Building Berkeley, CA Stanford University Palo Alto, CA San Francisco General Hospital San Francisco, CA Atomic Energy Commission Lawrence Livermore Laboratory Livermore, CA Vg stepnteunp 2 ESSIEN PGI PERSONAL INIURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM ASBESTOS-——-————— Job Title Insulator Insulator insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Exposure te 1967-1970 1967-1970 ‘sage 1967-1972 1967-1972 1967-1972 1967-1972 1967-1972 1967-1972 1/1967-3/1972 1/1967-3/1972 1/1967-3/1972 EXHIBIT AEmplover Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Losulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA EXHIBIT A (cont'd.) Location of Exposure San Francisco Stare University San Francisco, CA Fairmont Hotel San Francisco, CA Cafiada College Woodside, CA UCSF Medical Center Parnassus Ave. San Francisco, CA University of California Berkeley, CA San Francisco International Airport San Francisco, CA NASA-Ames Research | Center Moffett Field Sunnyvale, CA Washington Hospital Fremont, CA Stanford Medical Center Palo Alto, CA. St. Patrick's High School Benicia Road Vallejo, CA U.S. Air Force--Travis FB A Fairfield, CA (Commissary) Job Title Insulator Insulator insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator {nsutator insulator (Foreman) Insulator Exposure ” Dates 1/1967-3/1972 1/1967-3/1972 1/1967-3/1972 1/1967-3/1972 Angry 39a 1/1967-3/1972 1967-1970 1967-1970 4967-1970 1/1967-3/1972 (1 month, on and off) 1/1967-3/1972 (2 months, on and off) EXHIBIT AEmp! Over Consolidated Inswlation 317-D Marine View Ave, Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 317-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA. Consolidated Insulation 317-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA. Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA. Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave, Belmont, CA MW Mu“ EXHIBIT A (cont'd) Location of Alameda Hospital Alameda, CA US Post Office Vallejo, CA Ice House | San Francisco, CA Langley Porter Clinic San Francisco, CA PG&E The Geysers, CA Fairmont Hotel San Francisco, CA Civic Center Auditorium San Francisco, CA Marin Civie Center, San Rafael, CA Standard Oil Building 225 Bush St. - San Francisco, CA China Basin Building 185 Berry St. San Francisco, CA Jack Tar Hote) (aka Cathedral Hill Hotel) 1101 Van Ness San Francisco, CA Job Title Insulator Insulator (Foreman) Insulator (Foreman) Insulator (Foreman) Insulator Insulator Insulator (Foreman) ° Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Exposure Dates 11967-31972 (1 week, on and ° 1/1967-3/1972 C1 month, on and a 1/1967-3/1972 (2 months, on and o 1/1967-3/1972 (1 week, on and off) 1/1967-3/1972 (6 weeks, on and off) 1967-1972 (9 days) 11967-31972 {2 to 3 weeks, on and off) 1967 --1972; 1977 - 1981 (1 month, on and off) 1/1967-3/1972 (1 week, on and off} 1/1967-3/1972 (3 weeks) [/1967-3/1972 (2 weeks, on and off) EXHIBIT Atp OD PW NR RH BR wR ~ See eee ee ee BeRRRPSRUXE RSS SGA EGR ER lover Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave, Belmont, CA Consolidated insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated insulation 517-D Marine View Ave, Bebnont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 317-D Marine View Ave. Beimont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation. 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA. Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA i KAtnpupedt 93 inp ens AHIBIT A (cont'd, Location of & KPOSULE Embarcadero Center #1, #2, #3 San Francisco, CA San Francisco War Memorial Opera House San Francisco, CA S.P.C.A. San Francisca, CA Safeway Bakery Richmond, CA Kilpatrick Bakery Oakland, CA Sandia National Laboratory Livermore, CA Napa State Hospital Napa, CA US Department of Agriculture Albany, CA Kaiser Hospital 2425 Geary Blvd. San Francisco, CA California Pacific Medical Center San Francisco, CA (California Street) Coast Guard Facility Monterey, CA Veterans Administration Hospital Yountville, CA Job Title Insulator Insulator (Foreman) Insulator Insulator Insulator (Foreman) Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Exposure Dates 1/1967-3/1972 (] month, on and off) 1/1967- 1970 (1 week, on and oft 1/1967-3/1972 (3 weeks, on and off) 1/1967-3/1972 (2 weeks, on and off) 1967-1968 (2 months, on and off) 1/1967-3/1972 (i month, on & off) 1/1967-3/1970 (L month, on and off) 1/1967-3/1972 (3 weeks, on and off) 1967-1972 1/1967-3/1972 (2. weeks, on and offy 1/1 967-3/1972 (1 week, on and off} 1/1967-3/1972 (week, on and off) EXHIBIT A Y ul 25 F CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOSoU BN KR RYN po tll vt Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 317-12 Marine View Ave, Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation. 317-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave, Belmont, CA. Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA ut at Kates 3 siege. COMPLAINT FOR PE] EXHIBIT A (cont'd. Location of Exposure Unknown Meat Packing Plant . Sacramento, CA Stonestown Shopping Center San Francisco, CA Napa County Hall of Justice Napa, CA Kaiser Hospital Vallejo, CA Alta Bates Hospital Oakland, CA Mills Building: (Bush/Montgomery) San Francisco, CA pity Administration Building Cutting Boulevard Richmond, CA 690 Market Street San Francisco, CA 50 California Street San Francisco, CA St. Mary’s Church San Francisco, CA Hi land Hospital land, CA Job Title Insulator insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator insulator Insulator Exposure, Dates 1/1967-3/1972 (2 weeks, on and off) 1/1967-3/11972 (1 month, on and off) 11967-31972 (3 days, on and off) . 1/1967-3/1972 (3 weeks, on and off) 1/1967 - 1972; 1977 ~ 3/1980 G to 4 weeks, on and off) 1/1.967-3/1972 (on and off) 1/4967-3/1972 (2. months, on and off} 1967-3/1972 {1 week, on and 9: 1/1967-3/1972 (2 weeks, on and off) 1/1967-3/1972 (6 weeks, on and off) 1/1967-3/1972 (1 month, on and o! EXHIBIT A INAL INJURY AND res HPCORSCRTTR ~ ASBESTOSEmployer Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave, Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 5}7-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Siefert and Rossi 1501 North C Street Sacramento, CA. ut EXHIBIT. A (contd.) Location of Exposure American Can Company San Leandro, CA | Bush Street San Francisco, CA Hong Kong Bank San Francisca, CA (Headquarters) 60 ansome Street) =“ 111 Pine Street San Francisco, CA 333 Bush Street San Francisco, CA Naval Station Treasure Island San Francisco, CA {BM San Jose, CA Lockheed Sunnyvale, CA Lucky Deli Plant San Leandro, CA 101 California Street, San Francisco, CA Aerojet-General Rancho Cordova, CA Job Title Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator. Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Exposure Dates 11967-3/1972 (4 days, on and off) 1/1967-3/1972 (2 weeks, on and 01 1/1967-3/1972 (1 week) 1/1967-3/1972; SITT-1181 (3 weeks, on and off) 1/1967-3/1972; S/TT-UBL* CL month, on and off) . 1/1967-3/1972; S/77-U183 (L month, on and off) 1967-1972; 1977-1981 1967-1972; 1977-1981 1969 (1 week, on and off) 1970 - 1972; 1977 ~ 1979 (on and off) 41972-91973 (18 working days) EXHIBIT A i : : : q : : / iEmployer Siefert and Rossi 1501 North C Street Sacramento, CA Siefert and Rossi 4501 North C Street Sacramento, CA Siefert and Rossi 1501 North C Street Sacramento, CA Siefert and Rossi 1501 North C Street Sacramento, CA. Plant Insulation 227) California Street San Francisco, CA Plant Insulation 2271 California Street San Francisco, CA Plant Insulation 2271 California Street San Francisco, CA Plant insulation Co. 2271 California Street San Francisco, CA Plant insulation 2271 Califomia Street San Francisco, CA Plant Insulation 2271 Califomia Street San Francisco, CA uw EXHIBIT_A (cont'd) Location of Exposu ec General Mills, Lodi, CA Kaiser Hospital Sacramento, CA Sacramento Convention Center Sacramento, CA (16" St) Truckee High School, Truckee, CA Westin Saint Francis (Powell Street) San Francisco, CA Leiterman Hospital & Medical Center San Francisco, CA Standard Oil Richmond, CA Shell Oil Refinery Martinez, CA PG&E Powerhouse Pittsburg, CA Union Oil, Rodeo/ Oleum, CA Job Title Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator ~ Insulator Exposure Dates 1972-1973 4f1972-9/1973 (3 weeks, on and off) 411972-9/1 973 (3 months, on and off) 411 972-9N9T3 {2 weeks, on and off} 10/1973-12/1973; 3/1974-3/1976; 10/1976-2/1977 (21 to 26 days) 10/1973-12/1973; 3/1974-3/1976; 10/1976-2/1977 (Lmonth, on and off) 10/1973- 12/1973; 3/1974-3/1976; 10/1976-2/1977 (4 months, on and off) 1973-1977 10/1973-12/1973: 3/1974-3/1976; 10/1976-2/1977 (3-4 months, on and off) 1973-1977 (on and off for approx. 2 months) EXHIBIT A~ we Ow WDA KH A WN Employer Plant Insulation 227) Califomia Street San Francisco, CA Plant Insulation 2271 California Street San Francisca, CA Plant Insulation 2271 Califomia Street San Francisco, CA Plant Insulation 2271 California Street San Francisco, CA Plant Insulation 227) California Street §an Francisco, CA Plant Insulation 2271 California Street San Francisco, CA Plant Insulation . 2271 California Street San Francisco, CA Plant Insulation 2271 California Street San Francisco, CA Western MacArthur 2855 Mandela Parkway Oakland, CA Wt EXHIBI nit'd. Location of Exposure: Fireman’s Fund Novato, CA Colgate-Palmolive Berkeley, CA Phillips Petroleum Gompany! Lion Oi! mpany Avon, CA Mare Island Naval Shipyard Vallejo, CA TROUT (88-566) GUDGEON (SS-567) General America Soda Ash Plant . Green River, Wyoming, Queen of the Valley Hospital . Napa, CA Standard Oil Building San Francisco, CA (555 Market Street) Standard Oil Richmond, CA Louisiana Pacific’ Samoa, CA. Job Tile Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Exposure 10/1973- 12/1973; 3/1974-3/1976; 10/1976-2/1977 (1 month, on and off} 40/1973-12/1973; 3/1974-3/1976; 10/1976-2/1977 (L month, on and off) 10/1973-12/1973; 3/1974-3/1976; 10/1976-2/1977 (1 month, on and off} 10/1973-12/1973; 3/1974-3/1976; VON976-2/1977 (1 month, on and off) 10/1973-12/1973; 3/1974-3/1976; 10/1976-2/1977 (2 months) 10/1973-12/1973; 3/1974-3/1976; 10/1976-2/11977 (4 months, on and off) 311974-3/5976 C1 year) 1974 - 1977 1/1974-3/1974 (3-4 weeks) EXHIBIT A SORTIUM - ASBESTOSEmployer } Western MacArthur 2855 Mandela Parkway Oakland, CA 2855 Mandela Parkway Oakland, CA Wester MacArthur 2855 Mandela Parkway Oakland, CA Owens-Coming Fiberglas 10] 1 Owens Coming Parkway Toledo, OH Owens-Corning Fiberglas ! Owens Coming Parkway Toledo, OH | Plant Insulation 14} 2271 California Street | San Francisco, CA i] | Plant Insulation } 2271 California Street |] San Francisco, CA Combustion Engineering 18 || 1119 Riverfront Parkway Chatfanaoga, TN Combustion Engineering H 1119 Riverfront Parkway | Chattanooga, TN Douglass Insulation 3990 Ralston Avenue Hillsborough, CA Douglass Insulation 3990 Ralston Avenue | Hillsborough, CA Douglass Insulation 26 || 3990 Ralston Avenue Hillsborough, CA cont'd. Location of Exposure Job Title Union Oil Rodeo/Oleum, CA Insulator Chevron Chemical (aka Ortho Plant) Richmond, CA Todd Shipyard Alameda! CA insulator Insulator Anheuser Busch Insulator (Budweiser) Brewery ‘airfield, CA Modules-Alaska Sacramento, CA Insulator Anheuser Busch Insulator (Bud weiser} Brewery ‘airfield, CA Union Oil : Insulator Roded/Oleum, CA PG&E Powerhouse Pittsburg, CA Insulator Mojave Powerhouse (SCE) Insulator Laughlin, NV Laguna Honda Hospital and Insulator Rehabilitation Center San Francisco, CA UCSF Medicat Center Insulator San Francisco, CA Standard Oil Building Insulator 555 Market Street San Francisco, CA Exposure Dates 1/1974-3/1974 G weeks, on and of) . W974 3/1974 (2 weeks, on and off) V/1974-3/1974 (3 weeks, on and off) 4/1976-10/1976 (3 to 4 months) 4/1976-10/1976 @ months) 10/1976-2/1977 (3 months, on and oO 11977-21977 (2 months) 2/1977-3/11977 (3 weeks) 2/1977-3/1977 - (1 month) AN977-S11977 (2 weeks) MA9TT-SI9TT (9 days) 4/1977-5/1977 (1-2 weeks) EXHIBIT Awwe TD DAH RB WN =— = me A Bw NN = So Employe: Douglass Insulation 3990 Ralston Avenue Hillsborough, CA Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA. Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insvlation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA. Consolidated insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA. Consolidated Insulation 517-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation $17-D Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA Consolidated Insulation $17-D) Marine View Ave. Belmont, CA W EXHIBIT nt'd. Location of Ex posure Douglass Insulation Shop Yosemite Street San Francisco, CA Sun Valley Shopping Center Concord, CA Kaiser Hospital (Broadway Street) Oakland, CA Vallejo City Hall Vallejo, CA 500 Howard St. San Francisco, CA Veterans Administration Hospital Palo Alto, CA Louise M. Davies Symphony Hall San Francisco, CA 459 Post St. San Francisco, CA Mare Island Naval Shipvard Vallejo, CA US Aic Force Travis Ar Force Base Fairfield, CA Sonoma State Hospital Eldridge, CA Santa Rosa Junior College Santa Rosa, CA Job Title Insulator insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator Insulator I insulator Insulator Exposure Dates 4NN9T7-SIN9TT (7-9 days, 4 or S times) S/77-1980 (2 weeks, on and off} S/1977-1/1 981 (4 weeks, on and off) 1977 (3 weeks, on and off, 1977 (4 week, on. and off} t 977 ) approx. months) 1977-1980 (3 weeks, on and off} : 1977-1980 (1 week, on and off) 1977 Gto 4 weeks, on and off) 1977 (3 weeks, on and off} 19