Exhibit,Appendix: ROBERT ROSS et al VS. C.C. MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                co ON DBD Uo FF BW N

N N oN NON NoB eB BP eB SB eB eB BP eB
NPP RP BBS B&F RR RFR BRE S

28

BRYDON
HUGO & PARKER
135 MAIN STREET
207" FLOOR.

San Franciseo, CA 94105

Edward R. Hugo [Bar No. 124839]
P.M. Bessette (Bar No. 127588]
Josette D. Johnson [Bar No. 195977]
BRYDON HUGO & PARKER

135 Main Street, 20th Floor

San Francisco, CA 94105
Telephone: (415) 808-0300
Facsimile: (415) 808-0333

Email; service@bhplaw.com

Attorneys for Defendant
A. TEICHERT & SON, INC.

ELECTRONICALLY
FILED

Superior Court of California,
County of San Francisco

FEB 20 2013

Clerk of the Court
BY: JUANITA MURPHY
Deputy Clerk

SUPERIOR COURT - STATE OF CALIFORNIA

COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO - UNLIMITED JURISDICTION

ROBERT ROSS and JEAN ROSS,

Plaintiffs,
vs.

C.C, MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS, et al.,

Defendants.

(ASBESTOS)
Case No. CGC-10-275731

EXHIBIT H (Part 1 of 4) TO THE
DECLARATION OF JOSETTE D.
JOHNSON IN SUPPORT OF

‘A. TEICHERT & SON, INC’s MOTION
FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

1

EXHIBIT H (Part 1 of 4) TO THE DECLARATION OF JOSETTE D. JOHNSON IN SUPPORT OF A.
TEICHERT & SON, INC.’s MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENTEXHIBIT HStephen J. Squillario (Bar No. 257781)
HAIGHT BROWN & BONESTEBL LLP
7} Stevenson Street, 20th Floor

San Francisco, CA 94105-2981
Telephone: 415.546.7500

Facsimile: 415.546.7505

Attomeys for Defendant ROBERTSHAW CONTROLS
COMPANY

SUPERIOR, COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
UNLIMITED CTVIL JURISDICTION
Case No. CGC-09-275091

EUGENE MILLARD,

Plaintiffs, DECLARATION OF HOWARD B.

SPIELMAN IN SUPPORT OF

1B ¥. DEFENDANT ROBERTSHAW /
CONTROLS COMPANY’S MOTION FOR :

14 ] ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (BP), et al, SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR, i
ALTERNATIVELY, SUMMARY :

15 Defendants. ADJUDICATION |

et eee Ne te a el a

1, Howard B. Spielman, declare as follows:
1. Since 1974 | have been President of Health Science Associates, a full service i
occupational and environmental health and safety consultation firm located in Los Alamitos,
[catifornia. {received a Bachelor of Science degree from the University of California in Los
Angeles, California in 1956, and a Master's degree in Health & Safety Science from California
State University at Los Angeles in 1967. The American Board of Industrial Hygiene has certified
me in the Coraprehensive Practice of Industrial Hygiene since 1970 (CIH #653). I have been
certified as a Safety Professional since 1971 (#1097) by the Board of Certified Safety

i
|
'
|
|

Professionals. [ am a Registered Professional Enginecr (Safety} in the State of California, and
have been since 1978 (#2845). Tam registered as afi Environmental Health Specialist in the State

of California (#2065). Tam certified by the State of California as an Asbestos Consultant (#92-

LAW OFFICES: 1
HAIGHT, DROWN & povasooms4 SPIELMAN DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF ROBERTSHAW'S MOTION FOR
BONE | sesenos.] SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR, ALTERNATIVELY, SUMMARY ADJUDICATIONAAIGHT, BROWN &
PSTEEL, LP,

0830). Uhave received my Community College Instructor Credential from the State of California
(#89575). | am certified by the State of California as a Lead Inspecton‘Assessor, Lead Project
Designer, and Lead Project Monitor (#1611, D6L1, M611). f have served as President of the
California industrial Hygiene Council (CHC) from 1990 to 1996, and am a current Board
member. Ihave served as Director of the American Board of Industri al Hygione (ABIH) from
1990-1996. Since 1994, Ihave been a Fellow member of the American Industrial Hygiene
Association (ATHA), as well as past chair of the Audit Committee and Public Affairs Committce,

and past membet of various technical committees, the Emerging Issues Committec, and Awards

oom WA FW ON

Committee. My additional professional memberships include: AIHA, Souther California
10 | Section and Orange County Section. Other professional activities include: Ca/VOSHA Mold
Advisory Committee (2001-2002), California Department of Health Services Lead Workshaps
(1996-1998); and various California advisory committees established by the CaYOSHA Standards
Board (member 1973-1984) for development of occupational health and safety standards,
including the asbestos, airborne contaminants, noise, confined space and coke missions
standards. From 1980 through 1994, T was a member of the California Safety Council Board of
Directors, and served as President from 1983 to 1985. Thave served on the California
Manufacturers Association Workers Compensation and Occupational Safety & Health Committee,
and was a member of the Steering Committee (1968-1974) and Chainnan (1971-1973).
Additionally, | have organized, developed and/or presented health, safety environmental seminars,
workshops, programs for AIHA, American Medical Association, California Safety Council, L.A.
Chapter of National Safety Council, California Manufacturers Assn., Merchants & Manufacturers
Assn., University of Southem California, Society of Manufacturing Engineers, Public Agency
Safety Mgmt. Assn., and CaVOSHA. As reflected in my Curriculum Vitae, attached hereto, J have
over forty years experience in the practice of industrial hygiene. have taught for the Los Angeles
City Schools and Long Beach Community College and have taught segments of ATHA and
Southern California Section’s Industrial Hygiene review course.

2. Throughout my career, | ave become aware of and reviewed numerous

publications by various entities and organizations that are relevant to my area of work, including,

2
mavaona7s4 SPIELMAN DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF ROBERTSHAW’S MOTION FOR
BRRCO.( SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR, ALTERNATIVELY, SUMMARY ADJUDICATION1
1
i
1
1
1
1
1
1

1 | but not limited to, The International Association of Heat & Frost Insulators and Asbestos Workers
2} Union’s official journal, The Asbestos Worker.

3 3. Lam very familiar with the International Association of Heat & Frost Jasulators and
4 | Asbestos Workers Union and its official journal, The Asbestos Worker.

5 4. Over the past several decades, | have obtained numerons volumes of The Asbesins
6 | Worker, dating as far back as the 1950s. These volumes are retained at my office in Los Alamitos,
7 | California.

8 5 Thave reviewed the deposition transcripts of Steve Steele, and the numerous

9 {exhibits attached thereto, in the matters of Spivia Currier, et al. y, Asbestos Defendants (BP), San
Q | Francisco County Superior Court Case Nos. CGC-06-454323, CGC-06-451849, CGC-08-274823,
1 }CGC-09-275161, CGC-08-274946, and CGC-07-274099, Volumes I-Il, dated August 21, 2009

2, | and October 6, 2009.

3 6. Steve Stecle testificd that he is the Business Manager for Local No. 16 ofthe

4 | International Association of Heat & Frost Insulators and Allied Workers Union, which, until a few
5 Lycars earlier, was previously known as the International Association of Heat & Frest Insulators

6 and Asbestos Workers Union. (See Deposition of Steve Steele, Vol. I, 15:5-25, 19: 4-19.)

7 7. Steve Steele testified that he is the Custodian of Records for Local No. 16, and the

3 | Custodian of Records for all categories of documents requested per his deposition notice, except

19 | for the joumals from his Union (i.¢., the International Association of Heat & Frost Insulators and

20 | Asbestos Workers). Mr. Steele testified that he believes that the Jnternational Association of Heat

21 | & Frost Insulators and Asbestos Workers Union has copies of The Asbestos Worker journals from

22 jae beginning of its publication, tut be did not attempt to obtain “old” copies of The Asbestos

23 | Worker journals in response oF in preparation for his deposition. (See id. at 3 1:22-32:16.)

25

24 8. Steve Steele testified that The Asbestos Worker is the official journal of the
Tntem:

ational Association of Heat & Frosi Insulators and Asbestos Workers Union, of which Local

26 |No. 16 is apart, and that The Asbestos Worker is published by the Intemational Association of

27 | Heat & Frost Insulators and Asbestos Workers Union and is sent out several times per year. Mr.

28 | Stecle also believes that the journals are sept on or about ihe date indicated on the journals to cach

LAW OFFICES:
BAGGHT. BROWN &
BONESTEEL LLP.

‘San Framisen

3
meve-ounuase SPIELMAN DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF ROBERTSHAW'S MOTION FOR
3B88000,1 SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR, ALTERNATIVELY, SUMMARY ADJUDICATION‘LaW OFFICES

HAIGHT, BROWN,
"BONBSTEEL. LF

San Braco

1 fand every member of the International Association of Heat & Frost {nsulators and Asbestos

2 | Workers Union. (See id, at 37:12-38:25.}

3 9. In response to the request for documents, Steve Steele looked through his office,
4 | filing cabinets, and off-site storage for responsive documents, Mr. Stecle found and produced at

5 [his deposition various documents, including eleven (11) editions of The Asbestos Worker that he

6 [had located in his office. These journals were jdentified, marked and attached to Mr. Stecle’s

77 | deposition as Exhibits EE1 through EE11:

8 El. The Asbestos Worker , August 1970

g E2. The Asbestos Worker, November 1973
10 E3, The Asbestos Worker, August 1974
iE EA, The Asbestos Worker, August 1976
12 ES The Asbestos Worker, November 1976
3 E6 The Asbestos Worker, February 1978
14k E]? ‘The Asbestos Worker, August 1979
15 \ E& The Ashestos Worker, November 1979
16 F9 ‘The Asbestos Worker, February 1989
7 E1G The Asbestos Worker, May 1980
18 Bll The Asbestos Worker, November 1980

49} See id, at 32:1 8-33:17, 46:15-37:11, 42:143:6.}

20 10. During his deposition, Mr. Steele was shown and asked about cleven Qa)

21 | additional issues of The Asbestos Worker that were preceded the ones he had produced. These
22 | earlier issues of The Asbestos Worker were amarked and attached to Mr. Steele’s transcript as
93 | exhibits F through P:

24 RF The Asbestos Worker, Noventber 1969
25 G. The Asbestos Worker, October 1957
26 EL The Asbestos Worker, November 1961
27 L The Asbestos Worker, February 1963
28 iL The Asbestos Worker, February 1964
4
& Tl pneonoerse SPIELMAN DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF ROBERTSHAW'S MOTION FOR
SRR. SUMMARY FUDGMENT OR, ALTERNATIVELY, SUMMARY ADJUDICATIONHh kK The Asbestos Worker, November 1964
21 L The Asbestos Worker, May 1987
3 M. The Asbestos Worker, April 1957

The Asbestos Worker, May 1959
The Asbestos Worker, August 1965

=o 2

| The Ashestos Worker, April 1958

7 | Mr. Steele consistently testified that these earlier editions of The Asbestos Worker appear to have

& | the same format as The Asbestos Worker journals he bad produced, and/or simply appear fo be The
Asbestos Worker journals. (See id. at 95:20-132:8.)

41. Fhavereviewed the above twenty-two (22) issues of The Asbestos Worker that

11 [were produced at the deposition of Mr- Steele, and have compared them to my retained set of The

| Asbestos Worker journals from the International Association of Heat & Frost Insulators and

I ashestos Workers Union. All of the issues of The Asbestos Worker that were produced at Mr.

14 Stecle’s depasition have the same format and categories as The Ashestos Worker journals from the
15 | knternational Association of Heat & Frost Insulators and Asbestos Workers Union that I possess.
Based on the appearance aud contents of the journals produced at Mr. Steele’s deposition, and

: W7 | when compared to my set of Journals, there is no reason to doubt that the twenty-two (22) issues
of The Asbestos Worker journals produced at Mr. Steele's deposition are true and correct copies of
19 | The Asbestos Worker, the official journal of ‘the International Association of Heat & Frost

29 | nsulators and Asbestos Workers Union.

12. It is, therefore, my opinion, absent evidence fo the contrary, and based on my

22) training, experience, review and comparison of the aforementioned, that all ewenty-twa (22) issues
of The Asbestos Worker journals produced and attached as Exhibits B1-B11 and F-P to the
deposition of Sieve Steel, Volume 1, on August 21, 2009, are trae and correct copies of the official
25 |joumal of the Intemational Association of Heat & Frost Insulators and Asbestos Workers Union,
26 | The Asbestos Worker.

13. It is further my opinion, absent evidence to the contrary, and based on my training,

28 i experience, review and comparison of the aforementioned, that, specifically:

5
ryve-cooo2s4 SPIELMAN DECLARATION JN SUPPORT OF ROBERTSHAW'S MOTION FOR
3BE800".) SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR, "ALTERNATIVELY, SUMMARY ADJUDICATIONLAW OFFICES
HAIGHT, BROWN &
BONESTEEL, LA

{A)

®)

(«cy

@)

©

INV 0900254

aRRER.|

The Asbestos Worker, Aprif 1957 produced at the deposition of Steve Steele on
August 21, 2009 and attached thereto as Exhibit M, is a true and correct copy of the
April 1957 official journal of the Jutemational Association of Heat & Frost
Insulators and Asbestos Workers Union, The Asbestos Worker {attached hereto as
Exhibit 1):

The Asbestos Worker, October 1957 produced at the deposition of Steve Steele on
Acgust 21, 2009 and attached thereto as Exhibit G, is a true and correct copy of the
October 1957 official journal of the International Association of Heat & Frost
Ingulators and Asbestos Workers Union, The Asbestos Worker (attached hereto as
Exhibit 2);

The Asbestos Worker, April 1958 produced at the deposition of Steve Steele on
August 21, 2009 and attached thereto as Exhibit P, isa tme and correct copy of the
April 1958 official journal of the International Association of Heat & Frost
Ynsulatars and Asbestos Workers Union, The Asbestos Worker (attached hereto as.
Exhibit 3);

The Asbestos Worker, May 1959 produced at the deposition of Steve Stecle on
Augost 21, 2009 and attached thereto as Exhibit N, is a true and correct copy of the
May 1959 official joumal of the International Association af Heat & Frost
Insulators and Asbestos Workers Union, The Asbestos Worker {attached hereto as
Exhibit 4);

The Asbestos Worker, November 1961 produced at the deposition of Steve Steele
on August 21, 2009 and attached thereto as Exhibit H, is a true and correct copy of
the November 1961 official journal of the International Association of Heat & Frost
Insulators and Asbestos Workers Union, The Asbestos Worker (attached hereto as
Exhibit 5);

The Asbestos Worker, February 1963 produced at the deposition of Steve Steele on
August 21, 2009 and attached thereto as Exhibit [, is a true and correct copy of the
Febmary 1963 official journal of the International Association of Heat & Frost

6
SPIELMAN DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF ROBERTSHAW'S MOTION FOR,
SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR, ALTERNATIVELY, SUMMARY ADJUDICATIONhe
SESTEEL, LLP.

©)

w)

®

Insulators and Asbestos Workers Union, The Asbestos Worker (attached hereto as
Exhibit 6);

The Asbestos Worker, February 1964 produced at the deposition of Steve Steele on
August 21, 2009 and attached thereto as Exhibit J, is a trac and correct copy of the
February 1964 official joumal of the International Association of Heat & Frost
Ynsulators and Asbestos Workers Union, The Asbestos Worker (attached hereto as
Exhibit 7);

The Asbestos Worker, November 1964 produced at the deposition of Steve Steele
on August 21, 2009 and attached thereto as Exhibit K, is a true and correct copy of
the November 1964 official journal of the International Association of Heat & Frost
Insulators and Asbestos ‘Workers Union, The Asbestos Worker (attached hereto as
Exhibit 8); and

The Asbestos Worker, August 1968 produced at the deposition of Steve Steele on
Avgust 21, 2009 and attached thereto as Exhibit O, is a tre and correct copy of the
August 1965 official journal of the International Association of Tleat & Frost
Insulators and Asbestos Workers Union, The Asbestos Worker (uttached hereto as

Exhibit 9).

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the

foregoing is true and correct. ‘Executed on January £8, 2042, at Los Angeles, California,

I e

fwees i iy . E 7

o
Hoxard B. Spielman

7
SPIELMAN DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF ROBERTSHAW'S MOTION FOR

sats SUMMARY FIDGMENT OR, ALTERNATIVELY, SUMMARY ADJUDICATION

|
i
|
|
\
i
EWilliam O. Martin, Jr. (Bar No. 135399)
Robert D. Tobey (Bar No, 224652)
Stephen J. Squillario (Bar No. 257781)
HAIGHT BROWN & BONESTEEL LLP
7) Stevenson Street, 20th Floor
San Francisco, California 94105-2981
Telephone: 445.546.7500
Facsimile, 415.546.7505
Attorneys for Defendant ROBERTSHAW CONTROLS
COMPANY
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
FOR THE CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
UNLIMITED CIVIL JURISDICTION
EUGENE MILLARD, ) Case No, CGC-09-275091
Plaintiff, } EXHIBIT 1TO DECLARATION OF
) HOWARD B. SPIELMAN IT G
) To DECLARATION OF STEPHEN J.
vs. ) SOUT ANE IN SUPPORT OF
\ DEFENDANT ROBERTSHAW
) CONTROLS COMPANY’S MOTION
: } FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR,
ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (BP), ALTERNATIVELY, SUMMARY
ADJUDICATION)
Defendants.
} Date: April 5, 2012
) Time; 9:30 a.m.
J} Judge: Honorable Teri L. Jackson
} Dept: 503
) Trial Date: May 7, 2012
; Complaint Filed: February 26, 2009
)
)
)
i
EAHIDIT LTO DECLARATION OF HOWARD B. SPEILMAR (EXHIBIT GTO DECLARATION
n4-000254

3896638.1

OF STEPHEN J. SQUILLARIO

S/O MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT)SS ic. :
HE OFFICIAL JOURNAL OF THE INTERNATIONAL
TROGIATION OF HEAT AND FROST INSULATORS
AND ASBESTOS WORKERS.
GFRLIATED WITH THE AFLTIO AND BUILDING AND
CONSTRUCTION TRADES DEPARTMENT

C, W, SICKLES, Editor
JOHN W, HOFF, Astociate Editor
ADDEESS ALL (COMMUNICATIONS TO

THE ASBESTOS WORKER.
ROOM 145, MACHINISTS BLDS.. 1300 CONNECTICUT AYE. nw
WASHINGTON & D.C.

To NSDRE PUBLICATION, COFY SHOULD BE AT THE
TO ARE Nar CATER THAN THE 7ST DAT OF JANUAR,
“APRIL, JULY, OCTOBER.

GENERAL EXECUTIVE BOARD MINUTES:

LOCAL WAGE RATES ..--+---

BUSINESS REPORT ..

CORRESPONDENSE =. ere ,

IN MEMORIAM ...-----

MINUTES OF (CONFERENCE MEETINGS

OFFICIAL DIRECTORY ...--

.
«

Some Facts About
YOUR COVER PICTURE

-ATCRAL BRIDGE, one of che seven na
tural wonders of the world, is the Souther:
gateway to the bexsiful Sherandosh Valley o
Virginia. ig miracle. in stone, carced by =
simpic mountain stream over the centuries. is 215
fret high and 90 fret 1k is composed ol
36,000 tons of limestone. In it can be seen suck
colors as yellow, dull red, rich cream and ochre
She vou appzoach the bridge you will novice that
Yhe ‘contour of the arch changes. A geutle ply
of Fights and shadows wary with each changing
four and each passing season, Every creming,
throughout the year the Dram of Creation is
under the Bridge, Jt is an iuminated
pareant im which colored lights stream smoothly
tyer ite towering walls, ‘The scene tales on an
even deeper significance as the Bridge reaches
greater heights of mxjesty.

Natural Bridge fs a. partal through which ont
enters the beautifud Glen whieh stretches a suile
up Cedar Creek, In the Glea we find clifis which
are pvethung with creepers. We can‘siso se
Cathedral Wall, Pulpit Rock, Saltperer Cave,

‘Lost Riwer, Lace Waterfalls and

Yn 1774, Thomas Jefferson the Bri
we eee eee Bene
Of England for the “sum of twenty shillings ot
good and lawed money.”the Heeilding and Construction Trades Department in =
body. There was a total of 37 Ashestos Worker dete-

gates Tepresent
Terence. This

Sccrctary-Tresurer Hoff read telegrams and come
mmunieations having to do with charges, appeafs and
and saine

Tendering hig recigeation at 2 Vie President and mem-
per of the General Exccotive Board which was acc

The Secretary was instructed 19 write am appropriat=
communication to former Vice President Kammer ¢x-
presing sppreciation of our International for services
rendered

yard for decision as to Wibdrawal Cand issuznce to

‘Analysts and Scheduicrs, Planners and Estimators.
This subject was given due consideration and a review
of the definitions of these various classifications ae set
forth in official naval regulstions to the end that the
General Executive Board voted that only the Quarter
san was hy nature of his emplorment in comparison
wath our outside bailding crait membership entitled to
and could request Withdrawal Card isswance. hut that
so doing would be voluntary on the part of the indi-
‘dus? srember botling the Quartcrmas rating and he
cauld continue his active good standing menthership if
be sx desired.

to procesd. sith and bring about Hie compliance with
these instructions using such authority as delegated
by this Board as is found warranted in apy individhsal
case. The audit of the General Oftice finance when
completed showed all monies received ant expendi~
tures properly accounted for in exact amount as re~
flected hy the financial repost of the Secretary-Treas-
ree.

Business Agent Westley Gregory appeared fefore
the General Executive Board on bchalf of focal No. 97
its defense of several ints to the General Office
regarding the adrvmistration of our Anchorage, Alaska,
Local So. 97 for sumetime past, these complaints
qrranating from various employers and West Coast

ness Agem Gregory was, attr
the complaints agai

Gencrat Offic, advised to report tack and instruct
aH cficers and members of Local No. 97 that said
loca! would hereafter operate on a probationary basis
aml the General Executive Board would further review
the states of Local No. 97 taling into consideration aif
reports and/or complains: which come to the General

‘Agent Gregory was further instructed bo
the anonal assessment payable in advance which had
heen complained of to the General Office especially by
‘ofzimes was of short dura

raust be applied in fact equally wo the local member-

Ship as well as t0 the Travelers and in mo instance

ahould the Traveler be obliged to pay im exerss of the

amount paid by the Local Ne. 97 membership through

any medinm whatever.

‘A delegation comprising President Joseph McCoy,
nial Secretary

Teteace McConnell and Corcesponding Secretary Her-

tions in connection wih several items in dispute. and
3s a consequence of this hearing Loral No. 32 is here
with officially advised and instritcted:

a} That the General Offer will issue a charter to
the Asbestes Workers employed em shipyard work in
Local Ne. 32 tertitory.

bY That the focal is instructed 10 grant membership
to at least 15 of the Asbestos Workers cither currently
or im the past emplored as Ashestos Worker Mechanics.
whose trade cxpericoce both as to length of tise served

and ability most certainly warrants their Mechanic
membership issuance.
) Thar that portion of the territory of Local Ne. 32

chonwhich extends bevand the New ferscy aovthero boure
dary into Rorkland County, N, ¥., wil te transferred
zo and become a parr of Local Xo. $1, White Plains
N.Y owhlch 35 as a consequence of previous recon
Jrendation from Vice President George Rider who 0
recommended same after due Investigation

Phe delegation of Local No. 32 together with Busi-
ness Ageut Kapp of Local 0. 89, Trenton, X- J. dis
cussed the dispute over territorial jurisdiction espe-
dally aa so the ‘sub-division of Local No. 32 and Local
So. BY, and the copunittee representing Local No 32
Ghd in the person of Busincas Agent Springle answer in
She affirmative as 10 the question placed fo him by the
Board as to whether or not he would recognize and
proceed to operate fm accordance with the territorial
jurisdiction a5 set forth by" she Official Rand- McNally
imap previnusly adupted by oor International as the

Artautic States. -

“The conmitree representing Local Xo. 32 and bacal
No, 89 were officially notified that this verritoriad bon
the map refeered to sould be
Secognizcd by the General Offic as the oficial dividing
fee between these two locals and any and ll territorial
javistiction seould be based on this boundary Ene

“The General Executive Board invited all of the As”

J epeval session of the Board open 10 afl Toca! nnion
officers om Wednesday afternoon at which time they

ers’ Int
12. 1934 Agreements

the position taken by the Genera! Executive Board to
cease work om all operations where the Sheet Ment

The chair called to the attention of the Board Mem
here the Incerint decision arrived at by the March.
5956 Board Meeting—The Board considered the joint
invitation from the Southwest zed Southeast State

bold the [5th Convention of our International Assoca-
Hon in the aty of Ne + Oricans, Louisiana, to convene
en the frst Tuesday September, 1957." View Presi~
Yuet Hallinghorst and Vice President Howell vill as
cee aiemen wake care ol all dctails and are authorized to
Grae deposits and withtrawals on checks signed jointly
frou funds in the name of “Asbestos Workers Interna-
temal Association Convention Fand” in payment of
Conrention fund expenses. ‘The Beard did then wy

z

‘The Secretary was then instructed to send out the
1957 Convention Delegate Credentials and have ther
Gn possession of all afiliaicd locals prior to their first
scheduled June, 1957 meeting.

‘Throughout the session all members oi.the Genctai
Exceutve Board made detailed reports as to our craft
conditions within their territory which found ol sicra-
bership in full employment «ith very few obliged to
leave their home territory and solicie employrient
through neighboring Jocal iwions, Exery indication is
thar the work lead will increase dering the coming
veat,

Gur Intemational Attarpes Carlton R. Sickles ap-
peared before the Board and ave a report covering his
egal activities in connection with issucs Involving im
nome instances oar International 2nd in ether instances
igoues involving jointly our International and aur affi-
fiated local enions,

International Charges and Appesls ze Heard and
Decided ot this Session

Local No. 48, Adanta, Ga, ¥s. Dwight NN. Mith .
Reg. No, 9419, Local No. 77, Charleston, 5. Cu work
ing for other Gum a bonafide insulating eantracior, Re-
ferred to General President €. W. Sickles for inves-

‘Loc Xa. 84, Akron, Ohio, vs. Frank Tait, Reg.
Ne. 10920, Local No, 3, Cleveland, Ola, failure to re-
port, Charges sustained. Penalty in amouzt of $25.00.

‘Loesl Nu. 12, New Yerk Giy, 7. ¥., v% Thoms
Gallagher. Reg. Na. 7156, Locil No. 32, Newark, No T-
Tuledor work. Charges dismissed_—insufficient tr
dence.

Local Ka, 45, Toledo, Ghie, vs. Dante Lippi, Ret-
Na. 16676 and Lorenss Lippi, Reg. No. 15602, Lost

No. 41, Fort Wayne, Ind, and Billy G. Alexander,

Reg. No. 16444, and Robert Alexander, Reg Ne.
22138 of Local No. 73, Phoenix. Ariz, Iailure to repart.
Charges nustained, Penalty io amotnt of $28 cach.
Penalty suspended pening future trade baw observance
jn the jostence of Bily B. Alexander (Improver).

Local No, 6, Boston, Mass, vs Mitchell Plonia,
Reg. No. 21370, Locat No. Bi, Providence, R. 1. fail-
ure tg report, Emprover working in territory without
Mechanic, Charges sustained. Penalty $25 not re
porting, §90 working without Mechanic,

Lol No. 6, Boston, Mass, vs. Joha Lamberton,
Reg. No, 14900, Local No, 31, Providence, K. Ty Tn
ferior werk. Chatges sustained. Penalty in aniount
ef $50,

‘Loca! No 13, Corps Christi, Larede end Harlingen,
‘Ten, ve Eogene Jupe, Reg. No, 19184, and Edwin
Jape, Reg. No. 10808, Local No. 87, Sam ‘Antonio aod
‘Austin, Tex. Fellure to report Chargss sustained.
Penalty in atnount,of $25 cach,

THE ASBESTOS WORKERLocal Ne. 114, Corpus Christi, Laredo and Hartingen,
2 Tex, ve WOK. Baker, Reg. No. 20780, and Doyle

Moore, Rag Ne. 14444, Local No. £7, San Aatenja and

‘Austin, Tex. Faihire to report. Churges astained,

Penalty ix armotnt of $25 each,
Locat No. 110, Regina, Sask, Cony vt Janes Hicks,
eg. No. 13192, Local Xo. 99, Winsipes ‘Man., Can,
Working in territory without anthoriztion ond viola
fon Imermtionsl ss, Charges sustrined.  Peualty
suspended pending fusure trade Tne obserrancs:

Local No. 26, Rochester, X. Yo VE Eard Funnelt,

Reg. Ne. 2081, Joseph Chapas, Reg. No, 10776. and”

Frank Ellsworth, Reg. No. 7924, Local No. 4, Buffalo,
BM. ¥. Iefedor werk. Heterred to Vire President
George Rider for investigation and decision:
Tacal No, 6, Boston, Mass., v6. Armand Stella, Reg:
Ko. 17250, Local Na. 98, Bostan Noval Shipyard.
Failure to report. Working for other than banatide
| jasulsting contractor. Ne jurisiiction Member fapsed
subsequent ta Sling oF charges.
‘ya. Allen S. Mitler, Reg.
we Wenncrstrom, Reg. No. S743, Ronald
2, 13647, Melvin L. Greenway Reg.

ing Third Legislative
Trodes Departsncrd, Presdent Ris ard Gray of the

so. HOGG, Jesse Mayne, Reg. No. 11739, and Earl w.
Dolson, Reg. No. 1804, Tacal No. 6©, Salt Lake City.
Ciah, Molation of Tateraationsl laws. Busiacss Agent
Calcgors, in defense af his membership, the accscd,
alleges charges Improperly suimitted and signal in sc
eiianer with reguirementé of our International fw,
Defense sustained. Charges disarlssed.

Axppeal of G. ML Hatheld, Reg. No. 9333, Local No.
7, San Antonio and Austin, Tex. against trint action
and penalty, Appeal sustained—instrfficient evidence.
Penalty revoked.

"Appaal of Thomas Sultivas, Reg No. 4165, Local Na.
12, New York Gity, against trial action ‘and penaliy_
Denied Local action sustained

Appeal of Delhert E. Beyer. Reg. No. 20474, Local
Xe. 97, Anchorage, Alaska, against trial action and
penalty, Appeal sustained, Penalty revoked.

With vo Further business belore the board, adjourn-
rnuent was declared at 4:30 p, m., Thursday. Merch 14,
1937,

Respectfully submitted,

Conference of
“Satlding ond Consievction Trades Department t

standing to the right and to the front of President Sickles.

oer

cee tnt

{
\
\a

Gincinmatl, Obi

Norfolle, Vay Navy Yard
Little

City

a St Lonis, Mo. -
(Pier ‘de pet
(Pins 10e per

{Plas F4e Pe

Baltimore, 2fd. -.

New Yark, N-
Pian 5 per

(Pies i075¢

TEpeciion July ¥, B57,
Epc Lae ibe ea
hoor Vecetion Fund}

caak' Welizze Be

100
ES ar ie

i
tEgecre

hour Weitere Peat
zowr Vacation Fund)

Rock, Ark,
(Esertioe Saty 5, 257,

Local Wage Rates

¢These rates published 2s reported to Genexal
¥

e Tica 3, FO, .
(per Bout Wetlsce Fund)

Pa Worth, Tex, and,
as, Fe. 5!

(Efective Angust 21, 1957. $I)
{Plas Fie per kone Weltace Pend}

Heuston, Beamcont, Port Acther, Galveston,
Tom nuns a
WEferise

(Flos 106
Washiogien D Gaig 1, 54, 5)
ec
PEE pe bint Welfare Fund)
Meds cee eeeectneerenestagcent
(pias te per eer
(Pisa toe per boar Peavivs Fund)

Gfice and subject to change, Contact Local Uniox tor
erificati

jon}

No.

Ne

No, 32 Ni we ©
(BBector NEputher Bi
(bfect

No.

No,

Ka

Na

24k Springhdld, Mase ein owengeanarnen 32
a

ciy
28 Rochester, Ne Ye overs boners:
‘(Pine 10¢ per howe Wells
2 Kansas City, Slo...
(Pins ice per bour ‘Welfare

Bie

a
3a

a

dive September I7, I9:
(Plas Zoe Pr

34) Connectiest
ria 7960 per Bs
uu ‘Minneapolis ard St. Paul, Minn, ...- +--+ 308
Apia Face pes Rous, We
‘Yacation Font)

as

Wilke Barre and Serantea, Pa.
LEBective Inly L, 1957- $320)
Pine ‘aoe per bor Welfare Wand)
29 Omaha, Kebx. a
{Flux 100 pe hour Weliee Fend)
40 Albany, NY. o>
(Pins 100 oper Boor ‘Welfare
ax Se per

zual)
is Wacetian Fond)

figs,

Zhipective July 35, WS7_ $550)
(Rgfereioe January V5, TOSE, $3974)
(Pins 100 per buor Welfare Pandy

EAs per bout Wellare Fond)
44 Cohunbus, Obie -or- 7 apeyyeee"
Epecteve func £, 157. $2466)
(wins ¥ofe per kane Weltare 2ema)
AS Toleda, Obie
‘(Pies Je eifere
(CPias 6 paid delice)
45 Keogvilte, Tem
TEgeciive Neveu ‘$i?
(Bias Tike pox bout Wettare Fund)
Caged Rage nie Jackson, Kafacax00,

(Pine ioc per hoor Weilase Punt)
(pian Ibe pur bors Retirement Yond)Xe

City

Wew (leave sid awa Rowge. ta a0
(eine 7PAe per bour Weltare Pond)
Lawrenceburg, ind, (Distillery Plant Work-
‘en Only eer
Music. Als aes
+ Apr ite Pals Bi Way
(Phin ye pen bens Weliace Fond)
56 Wood River, UL (Oi "Reimar Rsinte-
tianiee Only] ---+»: an
37 Sioux City, lewa_- 200
SE Montrral, Que, Cam -. 205
{Elus 1 pee cant Wollsre Fund)
(Pius 2 per cemt Vacation
39 Post Acthar and Fort William, Oot, Can... 210
(Grins ¢ per cont Vacstion Fund)
“ as
a
ae
@
“a
6
&
a . 210
oe 23
© Salt Lake Cty, Utah --. 300
(Plas 10e per hour Welfare
70 Mare [stand naval ‘Shipyard, Valicjo, I aie 2A
71 Allentown, P: 335
Weepection Ealy 20, Ba ae
(Plas te per hour Wi
zm ec 250%
3
nm” 2
as 425
% 2m
00
+ as
nm 1a
a - 20
aL - 1
326
5
Sy
a 8
35 a7
36 ato

tin Ficly 2, BE,
“Gere Ue 3 nr
‘dour Welfare i

Ne. Be
z meee Jy 1 Tes,
(Pini Toe per boot Wellare Fund)
No, 8) Trenton, Js + 370
TEpection July 13, 72:

Legelice Jwanary 15, 2938. $1929)
(Pies Ide per hows Weltate Psd)
Xa W Mempis, Tene. -
(hur Tyr pet beer Wellare
Xe PL White Bee RY jah # 475
(Efiectere the Sonar 3H 7
res fr ‘cent We

o
98 Philadelphh, Pa. 3
=

Piet 3
Eis 2B Eat vacation Foedd
Xu Ga. - 310
*Eferitae J
rine Tse exon ‘Welisre Fund)
No WF Anchoraee eeerree WEE

(Bia it por hows Wesda iai

zat
195
0
as
24
an, OE lime 2, Pe
Mo 16 Mew ‘York Naval Shipyard -rvy-veresveres 245
No. MOS Texas, Cis Tex, Comte Carbon Chom
‘Malotenance Only} 4+: 2am
No 16 EL “Pee, tee am
No 17 Greenville, $C 28
Ba. 18 Olegm, Call (Union Olt Con
only} 3a
{Plus joc per our
(Pius bic pet hear Vacation Fond)
Ne 109 Loy Alamos, MMe, (BSunicSpal Opesa
Bons, Mamsterance Only) 285
Se Ho 225
Ko. til
zs
Ne iz Take atl 9 ; Opn Te 5a a 1
ectiog September E1057.
(Pin The pe boxe Bettas Tuad)
Ne M3 coy pet Toe Hatin rig °*
fects Au *
Pha 1S PEE Bone eis
1 am
Na. 14 seg ie
(Pins 77$e per bows We
Xe, HS 325
~ 163

Xa 16

g

Na UE

Na WW

BE

e

t
}
|
|The 1957 Auto Situation, Buying Qpportunities
By Stdrey Margstivs

May is one of the beet months 10 _Anothes ronson, for the ta in pede comeincks. For the time he-
Be een many neccastien sales, bankers says isnt ruby Poo, Ford fas becons the most wide-
Fi ee ore, Tie spring cs ple are still paying, for nll the Core Jy bought cary closely Sotlosred  b
pecially W's worth shopping the sales they Be oss, when easy Chreveoict, which had been top bird
poeta orceds imcanae we're terms sold a record nainher of re Gog for the two previows years
Vipmouth bas regained its old place

cantly, Fort and Piymomh were
most dirastic
rportanity 3 larged im size this voor. On the
Be ee empararily-reduced prices low, road ~ bugging pwdern design “other band, the Kanihler, the most
see spring clothing dearances, pas arided to +e Mijbculties of cimb- compact of ‘the popular-price cars,
jng in and out of cars. On some is beng snore widely-bought and, ia.
qiodels, it also is responsible for fact is one of the few makes saling:
More vain Jeaks Because the door faster tham Just year.
opening now is cut pastly ita the If recent models are more expen-
toot, Jamodcls where the fear seat sive, they Fave also proved to bave
protraudes heyand the door opening, heen cheapened in one imposter rr
passengers have to “angle” ito HE spect, servicemen repart. Not only
the 1937, but even sine earlier nod

ger into, once you're in, we Sower, circuits, faulty igmitiod and even rec
Te ie Soe gives you amore stable ards of fires clue ta the cheaper plas
ae ride, with, des on ciryes and tie wiring now ut

ing to be avaibable the next Stv comers. ¥ models in gen- Plastic wirisy rs to bh
sorts The spring upsurge makers eral are safer, more stable cats OF abte to stand overheating [te trad
eMidenlers had been hoping for haz the highwax- Jn city traffic, the St0fY ional wire with cotton and rubber
jot maaterialized. The result iscom= Bs Vifferent. The new longer S175 covering could to some extent} and

pmaterialized: Tere interme, end hen wed as calm. ate, sponse ont
Fen rece being ovtcped, for msgre tabi neilenie Ske cae ammufactrer a oe ee Te
Tarper Gietilg get es meh 2s $705 York Taxicab Buteas fepat ee ine © et Decoge i Seo

on the fit price of the higher-priced The public is also showing Signy Sp™ and in the case of the =
frodels," ane trade report mores, of resenting the rmany Toads chants ean fotights, poweriol
eee et ielieve one reason for ag and the confusing number of modcls soit nee wining is Stee ta z
sing 1997 soles is resistance to this mde, which alds to the cost of GTS. Heste., Shae ok E.

Fear’s higher prices, Wards Auto Wards repores that there are three 27S" no canly are a modi
year's Mtports esumates the aver- hanéired 7957 eoodels, even COW OT hut he tel stirs ee
Bee standard sqpipped 1957 wodel is there are wow fee smanufarturers. reel rea ane
2749, not including taxes, com “compared to 272 in 1956 and 260 m= imadcinate syne cues f

Faved 10 $2,553 in 1956 and $2,300 195%, Hardtops and station wagons et hot wey a greater frouey
Pevgse, Sigaifeantly, more penple are booming (0 Popularity, and man. Of shart circwits at fires. Some
i fower-priced makes ifcticers believe Thar in afew years service Experts, WOW are inswolling
this year. The big thes lowers they will displace the standard sedan Sach safety devices as inses znd cir
priced makes have accounted for completely. Coupes have almost cuit breakers on Jatomodel cars, The
Pee gD per ceat of all purchases vanished, cdrcpit treakers are more satisfac-
ae ee menpared to 57 per ome. -\mang she popular~ priced  =

Fight
CEREBRAL PALSY

Soin. the.
Golden Deed
CRUSADE

Sead Your Gift to Your Local United
Gorabral Paley AiiEahe. -<

4
re
ca
Pe
et
=
a
g
a

INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION -
OF HEAT AND FROST INSULATORS AND ASBESTOS WORKERS

. Roam 505, Machinists Building
13

HEADQUARTERS:

Washington 6, 0. C.

00 Cumneriteut Avance, N. W.

GENERAL SECRETARY-TREASURER
JOHN W, HOFF
Office Phones Hivdron 5-6768
Howe Prenat Sanipar 7-4550

INTERNATIONAL VICE PRESIDENTS

NEW YORK-NEW ENGLAND STATES CONFERENCE

TLR MeCORMICK, Fresidaot HEABERT ANDERSON, Seerctorr
107 Rumall Fisex, 493 Cynn SE
Malden, Mom

ponies, exe Springfield, Mare, Providence, RL Cangnctiont
Beale, Ne Rochester NY. Albany NY.
Now Yok Gil. FLT. Syrmcane, HF White Flaine, N.Y,

MIDBLE ATLANTIC STATES
IARDELL, Pretest STEPHEN J. KOMP, Secretory

aly
Trentew 50, WJ

{727 Yoweg St
‘Hon Orlewnt, Le, Dates Ty tase
AStibsted Cito:
akes Tox, See Antes Tex. Amatilio end Sonper, Tox
Horton, To, Tada, CHa Obiore, Cia,
New Mobile, Ale

Hl Fes, Toe Aibeqeerges,
Lobe Charles, Lo, Jochen, bet.

”

A. MUUUNGHORST
1670 Nartle Derganeis, Mew Orlaors, Las
Welly 6582 .

WILLIAM HOWELL
RU, 2, Baw 158, Basemner, Als
Phone: Kitmingher, Ale. Teemont 1-265

GEORGE RIDER
A827 Francis tenis Bird,
Bayside, LY.
Phoser 45587

SOUTHEAST STATES
WA, HOWELL, Freddest  GHARLES Fe Secretary
maveae eo tral Se
Al Memplie 11, Tenn,

Biradughsta, ALA. Credlosnon, 5S Socksom Te, Fee
Chelate, HS Knosvilie, Fenn Columbia, $C
Sard. Fie, Hobbs. Forme Tene
Grecvite, 5. Ce Soratnah Gar " °

WESTERN STATES CONFERENCE

AURERT E MUTCHINSOR, President (LW, KELLY, Seeretery
AGRE Danstord Shroot 4027 Lens RA.

Letewood It, Calif Oohlend, Cal.
Afflicted Cifies:
‘Santtin, Wark Tecoma, Wath, Wiings, Mest,
Se Frances cae ter —_ Whack,
Sit Lala Gay, Ue Sher dake
hong Horch Valles San Francine, & Drweretton, Watka
Hewal Shigyond 1

MIDWEST STATES CONFERENCE

|
|
l
\Fincock) Gecevtsry—Gemld Mania, 307
Eyertanta Are, Zoe a, Mohewke <

mate Acent— ied 3. Manetest. 1444
Auintal ee, Zone 16 Laat siete

Na. PLE ELAWD, ONG Starts Joh Toe:
sya ee

ome Woe Zone 1 Maier

Cees ee bbe
Geis bors em.t a
ie

Fumeadial Ractstery —Thenkory Z. Duna,
‘Sena web Aca, Wi, Zamads, Wark,
Grocaweat sibs,

betce Aeris ¥. Bi 1 et

Biggie ee
SRR ae
OCR nee eee

Prelteht—Lewie Bircham, 2601 Marearct
Kye, Fertomenth, Va Bes ithe

we
copmraa ot Scamber yk Dork

Fipuaelel Soetner yi Fe bere, nese

‘We TA LONE BEACH. CALI, Nawy ¥4
Eevee ee ere

Ka. SOWE, TDABO Mats ohh Friday
Sorts PA eS

=
Bieae gar ney Jee he be
ore Bence se =o
roma

ce {Onee 7,
George Bt,
Press Se

icaes.
ac.

Ke, San aS CHET, Sat eo
Fe egy at aE a ae Bo Fe

eS
3 L
wroetee Sena tater ete
ren peep at
Hie ated Bi, Kemann Coty, Kone
ce Arete Sete
” ae
Sree oes, Be =

careeetin
imei aoe oe
nyheel Sah any Ee He

pekioas, Agvet
Sitien FE Fene Eon
a LP KOvIOENCe,
Be Dept Bn 0 Bee
Pirie edwin Cleon, Cote Hey Babe

ree Hecate Conn

AT pandiog ecretarengy Poa Avmalit, TA
Dine View terme, Hew come
Fulton, 7-3,

Vicente 0 a
itieae Bie West Martlond T, Come:

day ne Dhecerteiena Wall Danby ond Jemeor

Birertae
inne E Haeding, 231 Cam
Wien CGE
Roker M. Tyo
i

wlan Ex Parrnit. Mt
‘Guuera Lees, Rome Wik Hew Carte,
EEE Paoces Wlimneton, Del. Oivecelt

dudlpad Agest— Willan 7. Wardell, 

Tie C$ aren

cnn ance adeemiemmees Ji, dead tr hss prado

cee eM rnemnng Cem An Veins Pualishes of imeem

ni 501 O9t41 | Wiltiam ©. Martin, Jr. (Bar No. 135399)
Robert D. Tobey (Bar No. 224652)
2, || Stephen J. Squillario (Bar No. 257781)
TIAIGHT BROWN & BONESTEEL LLP
371 Stevenson Street, 20th Floor
San Francisco, California 94105-2981
4| Telephone: 415.546.7500
| Facsimile: 415.546.7505
5
Atiorneys for Defendant ROBERTSHAW CONTROLS
6 |} COMPANY
7
8 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA,
9 FOR THE CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
10 UNLIMITED CIVIL JURISDICTION
1] | EUGENE MILLARD, } Case No. CGC-09-275091
12 Plaintiff, ) EXHIBIT 2, PART 1, TO
)} DECLARATION OF HOWARD B.
1B ) SPIELMAN (EXHIBIT G TO
vs. )} DECLARATION OF STEPHEN J.
14 ; SQUILLARIO IN SUPPORT OF
DEFENDANT ROBERTSHAW
15 )} CONTROLS COMPANY’S MOTION
ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (BP), } FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR,
16 ) ALTERNATIVELY, SUMMARY
Defendants. } ADJUDICATION)
174
) Date: April 5, 2012
18 ) Time: 9:30 a.m,
} Judge: Honorable Teri L. Jackson
19 3 Dept: 503
20 ) Trial Date: May 7, 2012
} Complaint Filed: February 26, 2009
21
)
22 | )
23
24
25
26
27 |
28
\ 1
inranon2s EXHIBIT 2. PART 1, T0 DECLARATION OF HOWARD B. SPEILMAN (EXHIBIT G TO
3198106.1 DECLARATION OF STEPHEN J. SQUILLARIO S/O MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT)DEFENDANT'S
EXHIBIT

Steele §-ato71 | William O. Martin, Jr. (Bar No. 135399)
Robert D. Tobey (Bar No. 224652)
2. | Stephen J. Squillario (Bar No. 257781)
HAIGHT BROWN & BONESTEEL LLP
3,171 Stevenson Street, 20th Floor
San Francisco, California 941 05-2981
4} Telephone: 415.546.7500
Facsimile: 415.546.7505
5
Attorneys for Defendant ROBERTSHAW CONTROLS
6 | COMPANY
7
8 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
9 FOR THE CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
10 UNLIMITED CIVIL JURISDICTION
1] )EUGENE MILLARD, } Case No. CGC-09-275091
12 Plaintiff, ) EXHIBIT 2, PART 1, TO
} DECLARATION OF HOWARD B.
13 ) SPIELMAN eH BIT GTO
vs. } DECLARATION OF STEPHEN J.
14 SQUILLARIO IN SUPPORT OF
) DEFENDANT ROBERTSHAW
15 } CONTROLS COMPANY’S MOTION
ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (BP), } FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR,
16 } “ALTERNATIVELY, SUMMARY
Defendants. } ADJUDICATION)
7
| \ Date: April 5, 2012
184 ) Time: 9:30 a.m.
) Judge: Honorable Teri L. Jackson.
19} } Dept.: 503
20 ) Trial Date: May 7, 2012
} Complaint Filed: February 26, 2009
21
)
22 )
23
24
25
26
27
28
LAW OFNICRS 1
HMGHTEROWNS |, oonase ERHIBIT 2, PART 1, TO DECLARATION OF HOWARD B. SPEILMAN (EXHIBIT GTO
DONESTERT LY srgsi96.b DECLARATION OF STEPHEN J. SQUILLARIO YS/O MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT)THE SERIAL 4 GHAL OF SHE, INTERNATIONAL

HSSOW ANON OF HEAT AND BOeT IMS LAFONE

ANE ASHESTOS WOREBRS,
SPILIATSD WITH TOE APL TANS BULLETS aro
SONETEUCHON, Tie: Berwin

a CRLES. Edrce

Ww,

AODRESS Au, SOMMLIICATIONE TO.
spnOk
if Gnas WORE
«Jie CONNBET OW aL Bw

RGOM TOE, maElS

2h I aURE FY
CEMGENO! LATER “HAY

Abear
PICTERE

i
1Eps
rehar’g policies) “a

eth CONVENTION SETS RECORDS ON...
9th CONVENTION SETS BEC

etme tne <'

took 4
ide bul
ee

Rickles set
fevmiational. |

every soanper ton. Be
ge secord: La concistion, 2
said, ve “are
frying 2x the Office of ot
itil lasion, “chiang” why. bs
Eations and Sailiky to, mide the, destiny:
Association,’ we

ficaeat_ ewe!

Sebeniant
Saxe Asbestos, Workets its,
+ ppt aniy: tip ikaat suite
sented.z2 the Bases Je
the fast “tirse peargy ber
igang

1semana, andéox
ions

tasy pears of silort, ia Rena :
‘aval Shigyatg  Weuinbotstip. --Hevanidy
“aiid? beat a Hoven yaasy of ofa ne

“obit ee sates ind.

“poripany. 6f amd conmpensaied

Hece wid sha wage “tate pattem. as

5 efit toe thie cabie, trait a
2,

‘ | nother. gebged test
ey-Teniontet Hott, starts should, ie proud ot, of réboril hy, Seer
Gh swords “af “comeplisnent : fy wan thikat the Gms
alr 200 5 :

‘Deep sfgyeeal ta. tale cart of the 2
+ greta de We ‘weenie ig ie
: fe, peksimcable ebE, |

ee fice! ate ie j

= wlth ob: offices 2h

sport '9F ott gil Genie
Sicides a the. General -

! ‘oth Hie, Seating
res Boh ated to ie cout:

crete ates fae ah

GS of Pye, Mindlsalsns:

eer iyiSeptomnbs
iaporsIg. President §
lore % Convenitinn shat
eatest’ abtendancl, “snbiias*

fag Hindreents Comyeiition of &
ratiral jacion 92 (Float ‘ ard

a eri
Tongrinlaipd ae {
ae HE aging. in

be fibre,

i
:

l
1fp preneated,

A ae

eae
eat
Crot,.-2 - jeay

ids this’
worse

tig, one, hom
heh
envfeatsen

uit

yr every scorormnity?” 3a dl
id “Labatt.
swell a

ere wey
Bed. Gass, nad Tair

eaaltry “told

ot ig re
a.A satereks
Ditiehes fo the aahie gf Babar

welensing 4

ruc,

‘Hest. and:

Erget-rofulabors-dnd. Aahcaicy We
“Reppevelt Hotels 8

‘Reoweyelt Haket =
e. Oiobis of the Tallis did Lab

seat, Peedes: Jeperbrént eter,
ict:op ages new tO jo s : se roams wth Hie wa at, Zs
dershtg aatting inty ast sade the Soli
ris eee :

Bex auigee 3207
Gone hare oe

pean Jrayi 5 ame the Fo aL
aber: erat He 3 .
je a dieasgre ¢ quand mp watinest . . . |
i peaaren wiel also greetgh FFT Le ie 8 “s wy

5 Ws, ened Se -
Firen ‘T, Sqacpizaes iat
. aE es, tr Slates, Shiney Reels we Q
oft Azs0rittton. .

it fngales, Catt ond *
ae rslatre ood Ase 4e fa al hm, cote Welles Abed
A ecards sbi>'s ‘ .
«punts, abana Reo: nag in the i) | ea
oe ee eos ne ee”
hs me teatn@ Sayers, Hi
ery ane igh recsiel Ay id
Conyedtion, a
fel set
Ge Sahogel

|iabore, aghtl Fr
placiag: dignr ‘in hafel

(Lafrbettary Whitaker,
: aed chectlag lash

2 soevcnie fra Ellen
oe Hory sealtenercs a

. 28 os fatinta, dy a ow ane
woe fours sect frp Josenh Leash "

“fatal Nac 26 Waibtigict, Hi 65, nailed et sant two, Deesell Kamar and Juke H. Leal’ Ma, PB Socth, ig, tndldng, “er! *

peel v0 ls : “Wid is de; snd tea, Doneid E C¥lim |

4 set wet fei CM iin es Bye gated to hg Thom :

He Being a Toa He 18

L Beda” , 5
ear he. re i anid to” we rr ove Hore .
an ent ze sire ee johp. =, Lecat Ng: $8; Oak Ridge. Tein. etimt hy,
Digs Eugene 0. MeGhee- ang & Wee Maitteninet, only), entitled

Charles SS.Dovin cond

Feige, :
Epes! Nes ge} Rocksttig HL’ a .
te baby est Heber A. teed, Bie Md! Grinning. and Basan

p, Kans ics, entitled _Kauger La, eptitled te fom; teat tous de be
1a ere eat ian OF Wnty John Fees
cence econ
Dio, 4. Lewcomesburg, nds (Distik
Flan Totlled sé Sem,
vo Hetchitesn *
sad Fecae MLE™NG ot chasutin ind Pasion
fgrioa Cee) ech, oghad oe exe ome
il,

é a,
. as ae eo Sala and

antieed Cail, Wawel
ofa: ah one Pale doula,

& Bout: Gere)
ind Lamar. Pes,
heral Ne 5a Weed River I

eal NEF
wot ge elm Fr oer,2 fee .
sett He hvergee na Forges.
a) No, 10, Rods a, Veritas ele

ad twos ig na!
Pases Torah, dnped to 3 Fomen
“Tevet, and tpary 5 Lebel aa. ks Habis,

Laval’ Sa.) febyvel, Fiibi Cabyin-
Sta, Canada, Jeiiitled > ves 3, ieee,
RL Mi, CBee ad, Matin

Josue R: Set,

He Deus.labo meyesrentt
fs bower

33 ade eented,
Vicoit nas forsvant hee ©
{plernaket Eendgren Tio, ASL:

Represmariog’ 3 3
Union Bt, Exeeeeive Seceetary, of the
Sd,“ Erie Tras Cows oft

‘in Hp.

he” ape Fe sit

want fae foe" etme
aL er ai ing Tog
Beer

‘Chip’ “deere. Cabanon ee ©
32590, 5 vas seal, Dg. sith Mead

4 Labor:
Headecsbia, “ine
seria solvita isegy prot “

neat yerBroil) Pegsdent
ion} Kasctiation S

"Report of tie Conpiter br Slee.

‘Te ‘se, Cliears yates of. ths,
‘yinsieenih Covmenifon.
i ition, of Hae dad
sHos Wordert

Prog dosnlstare
The Boone Bi

cal i oe stirs
ofr he
SOR cain poo

{3 Adjoncanent:
seqceduie stall bet

1
Il
1|
|
|Ls
“Leck Wa

a, Az,

Soseah,“BeCo,

ay
we eee Ay

Bea

Xo.

Legal
3b

|
|
|
|i
i
|
|
|
iof ‘pestis

vaeailiteshig, 3ui

cyibeds torinestell With ob,

feds Shy Cormeen, 63
~The, epdcdmice,
at vane i yu conifer

yaily' ribs For Mech

Baby $4.52, seer

Best ep: of muy Farifeysieee, oh
rah aL hereulie arin

1. agemiaioy oot

die 20,
of

!ie fae ase Uy one 3
J Neksan. Siu SWeldidg. Guc-'end sine, 2

covés: Tpeul
spokes of, The
snethods. fo8the aoc oF, ae

Gad specs 2

ied "oa

wits
the

Uagersonciay trees

aes:

Prepon’
Sd” reat’ ep foe. gab wha “mde “Bian
eribbled! mp

“air Svbeon, ce

THe AsHESTOS WORKERoeeg Braden

a A le oevation
a of expla MPT TE K sack, args at ie, the
et use a shod te, refoct af sae her

“tare are, uae of ocr xtabate’. oes)

lediss

af yea a ery Sa FRiohs oder Ditemnattinal Suse
eb ‘eiieat ofhes. ih Toe We
é

met nratairementy ete
Gpabehal fob Be. poetic
imbut aig, oF

Setar bt dhe reset me SF Od |
wo Gomgared an mica of Bae in ade *
ge banefts of welerey Face

wetceed Fim as your, Generzl Presid
° gay this “oar! oh “tnttenitional. Gaa- “com ee a oa. ite apy 1
festa. re et tans i cane ay teenie at thie dnd de Jat
fete" ‘eettanct ant mogptition . sh A

og oan “gto! Eecitive Bi i

ode wakiaten, “oF
Slistit: 100 por ‘eqn

Chait She sepoct granted pembeithh

consi ee Seb raf ck
Feconamaa} oS Ys inghating ‘renitiations wh

soe Le membershige sasued? ly oe geet -

the’ Ofice dver the tse fine $70 Sen

1 oe from * sho
“padey 1SBA Powidoot wi

vey Ser

he *so0-© finmenetal eels

of more years of afflludios

be BE te gitivactied, and Sheriig, che
Serco “ngiei as

sribaretip backs, Four} “Assessment,
“gmat be fncerieded ts the
oq Fong de tobat valon
as wir booklceomz” ,
system 9 nok get ap to, Haridie ananctal

Hanmcticnr Erah the menbershig. dirt!

jou, Loeet Ala,
Fel aie GF the siosicr Theceiare beh

vate

* gESOH, Veit NG: &

Sidlmirted bp Local Nb. se, Wew 2
fo Reet Shisaant 5”

2
‘Sinailing, if sossiile, air oft
a va! r lipened

rested an
"Ser Us Mace o¢
one fae

ene

‘Wantsd the! arg Siiprardé te
ae Roma on on Tenaga heels

* pitich by Logie, 28, Duron For

"anne andl Skrabeper Te:
- parva AC we tee:
ent 193, eit eter

‘Drie Nes 88, Ci ise
“Rinstigion, WY, Pos gt 2 ree,
bo Let, Na -2, Putibheg

Q a
ip-garsien tee inde slag:
Jats At prbseak thie Twsrtiel

grit “interes of the Sinserence
Heechanie (Job Fovemed) da leaproeer | unioys ward be bese afeved
a be meimbére of the, came

etitsied to ie Bue ea.
Ee Tames the SRdwest

|“ght ibe eeeeatens! Piaiiee oe
Sréretary Tre ETE Tiss

Retohed, That we pa tafe x be
crise & the ambomut wecessarg ta nape

Watkabon, page
4g) of Code.

* Shbuieted Be Bis
idles, Califor

‘Waimtag By 'sicion of she, é Spee, instance over Eo
‘Caltage;- Serfemibée ing wh