Exhibit,Appendix: ROBERT ROSS et al VS. C.C. MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                IAN P. DILLON, State Bar No. 203612
idillon@wtfbm.com
PAMELA L. STEVENS, State Bar No. 232609

pstevens@wibm.com ELECTRONICALLY
ALEX A. LOZADA, Siate Bar No. 275416 FILED
alozada@wibm.com Superior Court of California,
WALSWORTH FRANKLIN BEVINS & McCALL, LLP County of San Francisco
601 Montgomery Street, Ninth Floor FEB 21 2013

San Francisco, California 94111-2612
Telephone: (415) 781-7072 or oor tre Court
Facsimile: (415) 391-6258 Deputy Clerk

Attorneys for Defendant
D. ZELINSKY & SONS, INC.

SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

ROBERT ROSS and JEAN ROSS, Case No, CGC-10-275731
Plaintiffs, Hon: Teri L. Jackson
Dept: 503
vs. Date: May 7, 2013

Time: 9:30 a.m.
C.C. MOORE & CO, ENGINEERS; et al.,
DECLARATION OF ALEX A. LOZADA
Defendant. IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT D.
ZELINSKY AND SONS, INC.'S MOTION
FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION

Trial Date: June 10, 2013

T, ALEX A. LOZADA, declare as follows:

1. | am an attorney-at-law duly licensed to practice before all courts in the State of
California, and am an associate with the law firm of Walsworth, Franklin, Bevins & McCall, LLP,
attorneys of record for D. Zelinsky and Sons, Inc. (“Zelinsky”), a party to this action.

2. i have personal knowledge of all of the facts contained in this declaration and, if
called as a witness, could and would testify competently to those facts under oath.

3. A true and correct copy of plaintiffs’ complaint for personal injury and loss of
consortium, filed on December 17, 2010, is attached hereto as Exhibit A.

i
it
-[-

DECLARATION OF ALEX A. LOZADA IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT D. ZELINSKY AND SONS, INC'S
MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION

2277012.)
FOIA 2595,tw

Warswortl,
Fran

MeCall, LL?

4. A true and correct copy of plaintiffs request for dismissal of the third cause of
action for False Representation and Punitive Damages as to defendant D. Zelinsky & Sons, Inc,
filed on January 13, 2012 is attached as Exhibit B.

5. A true and correct copy of relevant portions of the deposition transcript of James
McCloskey, taken in the Kenneth Sheffield case on August 9, 2006, is attached as Exhibit C.

6. A true and correct copy of Zelinsky’s Special Interrogatories to Plaintiff, Set One, is
attached as Exhibit D.

7. A true and correct copy of plaintiff's Responses to Zelinsky’s Special
Interrogatories to Plaintiff, Set One, is attached as Exhibit E.

8. A true and correct copy of Zelinsky’s Special Interrogatories to Plaintiff, Set Two, is
attached as Exhibit F.

9. A true and correct copy of piaintifi’s Responses to Zelinsky’s Special
Interrogatories to Plaintiff, Set Two, is attached as Exhibit G.

10. True and correct copies of pages of relevant portions of Robert Ross’ deposition

transcript, taken in this matter over thirteen sessions between July and September 2012, are
attached as Exhibit H.
i. A true and correct copy of Zelinsky’s Requests for Admission to Plaintiff, Set One.
is attached as Exhibit 1.
12, A true and correct copy of plaintiff's Responses to Zelinsky*s Requests for
Admission to Plaintiff, Set One, is attached as Exhibit J.
13. A true and correct copy of Zelinsky’s Requests for Admission to Plaintiff, Set Two,

is attached as Exhibit K.

14, A true and correct copy of plaintiffs Responses to Zelinsky’s Requests for
Admission to Plaintiff, Set Two, is attached as Exhibit L.
17, A true and correct copy of Zelinsky’s Request for Production of Documents, Set

One, is attached to Exhibit M.

18. A true and correct copy of plaintifi’s Responses to Zelinsky’s Request for

Production of Documents, Set One, is attached as Exhibit N.

-2-
DECLARATION OF ALEX A. LOZADA IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT D. ZELINSKY AND SONS, INC'S
MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION

22770121
3O19-3.25981

Walsworth,
Krank

Be

MeCall,

9
0

19. A true and correct copy of Zclinsky’s Request for Production of Documents, Set
Two, is attached as Exhibit O,

20. A true and correct copy of plaintiff's Responses to Zelinsky’s Request for
Production of Documents, Sct Two, is attached as Exhibit P.

21. A true and correct copy of Zelinsky’s Request for Production of Documents, Set
Three, is attached as Exhibit Q.

22. A true and correct copy of plaintiff's Responses to Zelinsky’s Request for

Production of Documents, Set Three, is attached as Exhibit R.

23. A true and correct copy of Zelinsky’s Form Interrogatories to Plaintiff, Set One, is
attached as Exhibit S.

24, A true and correct copy of plaintifi’s Responses to Zelinsky’s Form Interrogatories
to Plaintiff, Set One, is attached as Exhibit T.

25. A true and correct copy of plaintiff's Responses to Standard Asbestos Case
Interrogatories, Set One, is attached as Exhibit U.

26. A true and correet copy of plaintiff's Responses to Standard Asbestos Case

Interrogatories, Set Two, is attached as Exhibit V.

27. True and correct copies of plaintiff's Supplemental/Amended Responses to Standard

Asbestos Case Interrogatories to Plaintiff, Sets One and Two, are attached as Exhibit W.

Executed this” day of February, 2013, at San Francisco, California.
} declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the

foregoing is true and correct.

oc ph

(ALEX A. LOZADA

3-
DECLARATION OF ALEX A. LOZADA IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT D. ZELINSKY AND SONS, INC.'S
MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION1 PROOF OF SERVICE
2 Robert Ross and dean Ross v. C.C. Moore & Co, Engineers, et al.
San Franciseo Superior Court Case Number: CGC-10-275731
3 Our Client: D. Zelinsky & Sons, Tine,
4 .
fam employed in the County of San Francisco, State of California. Tam aver the age of 18
5 land not a party-to the within action. My business address is 601 Montgomery Street, Ninth Floor,
San Francisco, California 94111-2612:
6
On Pebruary-21, 2013, I served the within document(s) described as:
7
DECLARATION OF 4LEX A. LOZADA IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT D.
8 ZELINSKY AND SONS, INC'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION
9 on ihe-interested parties in this action as stated below:
10 Brayton Purcell LLP
222 Rush Landing Road
il P.O. Box 6169
Novato, CA 94948
12
(BY ELECTRONIC FILING/SER VICE) I provided the document(s) sted above
3 electronically to the LexisNexis File & Serve Website to.the parties on the Service List
maintained on the. LexisNexis File & Serve Website for this:case. If the document is
4 provided to LexisNexis electronically by 5:00 p.m., then the document will be deemed
served on the date that it was provided to LexisNexis. A copy of the "LexisNexis File &
5 Serve Filing Receipt" page will be maintained with the original document(s).in.our office.
6 [x] (BY PERSONAL SERVICE) L caused First Legal Services to.deliver a true copy of the
foregoing document(s) in a sealed envelope by hand to the offices of the above
7 addressee(s).
18 Ldeclare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the
foregoing is truc’and correct.
%
Executed on February 21, 2013, at San Francisco, California.
20
2hy ___Neysa Alia oe a
Boe or nil
» (Type or print name)
23
24
25
26
27
28
“von ne
pec be DECLARATION OF ALEX A-LOZADA IN SUPPORT OP DEFENDANT D. ZELINSKY AND SONS, INC'S”
Sea G88 ayf613.4 MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADIUDICATION
3619-32505EXHIBIT ASUMMCNS Fort COURT USE ONLY
(CITATION; /DICIAL) (501 SS ae ate
NOTICE TO DEFENDANT: .
(AVISO AL DEMANDADO):
©.C, MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS;
Defendants as Reftected on Exhibit 4
attached to the Summary Complaint herein; and DOES 1-8500.

YOU ARE BEING SUED BY PLAINTIFF:
(LO ESTA DEMANDANDC EL. DEMANDANTE):
ROBERT ROSS and JEAN ROSS

HOTIGE! You have been sued, The court may decide against you without your being heard wnelss you respond within 30 days. Read the information
below.

“Yow have 30 CALENDAR DAYS after this summons and tegat papors are served on yau to filo a written response at this court and have a copy served
on the piaintitt & letter or phone call will not protect you, Your wrltten response must be In proper legal form if you want the court to hear your case.
Thece may be a court farm that you can use for your response, Yau can find these court forms and more information at the Callfornia Courts
Gaiine Self-Help Centar (www.courtinfo.ca.gaviselfhelg), your county law fibrary, or the courthouse asarest you: Ifyou cannot pay the fling fee, ask
Han couat clerk for a fee waiver form. if you do not file your resparse on flme, you may lose the case by dafauit, and your wages, money, and property
may be taken without further waraing trom the cour,

ae oe ore other lagat requiramctits, YOU may want to cali an attorney right away. If you do fot Know an atferiey. you may Want to call an atlommey
aterm service. I yon cannot afford an attorney, you may be eligible for trae legal services from a nonprotit egal Servicas brea am You can locate
those nonprofit groups at the Catitomia Legal Services Web site (www lawheipcaliforaia.org), tha Califordda Courts Outing Self-Help Center
{wenn -courtato.ca.goviseltielp}, or by contacting your local court or eausty bar association, NOTE: The cowed has a statutory tien for waived foes and
posts on any selement or arbitration awacd af $10,000 or rnora in a civil case, The court's Hen inuest be paid hefore tha court will dismias the case,
AVISO! Lo han demanetado. Sino respunde dentro de 30 dias, la corte puede decidir en su contra sin escuchar su vorsidn, Lea fa informacion a
continuacién.

srone 30 DIAS DE CALENDARIO después de que fe entreguen esta citactin y papeles legales para prosentar una respuesta Por escrito en esta
corte y hacer que se entregue una copia al domandante, Una carte 0 wna Hanada teletdnica na fe protager, Su respuesta por escrita tiene quo ester
crrormate tegol corracto si desea que procesen su caso on ta corte. Es postbie qiie haya an formulacia que usted, ‘pueda usar para su respuesta.
cree tnoontar estos Formularios do ia corte y més infarmacién en el Geniro de Ayuda de las Cortes de California (veww.sucorte.ca.gov}, on fa
piotfotece de loyee de su condado o en ia corte que le quede mds cerea. Sino puede pagar ia cuota de prosemiscién, pida al sacrataria de ta corte quo
Je dé un formuario de exencion de pago de cuatas. Sino presenta su respuesta a tiempo, puede perder el C50 Por incumplindente y fa corte to podrd
quitar su suetdo, dinero y bienes sin mds advertencia.

Hoy otros requisitos legates. Es recomendable que lame a un abogada inmadiatamente, Si no conoce 9 yn abogado, puette itamar aun servicio de
ronitign a abagades. Sino puede pagar 2 un abogado, es posible que cumpla con fas requisites pars obtener servicios tegales gratuitos de un
programa de servicios legates sin fines de lucra. Puede encontrar catas grupos sin fines de Iucro en el sitio web de California Legal Sarvices,
{anavelavrhelpcalifornia.org), en ef Centro de Ayuda de tas Cortes de Caiifarnia, (www. sucort.ca.gov) 0 ponténdose en contasto con la corte o ef
colegio de shagados locales, AVISO: Par loy, ta corte ene derecho a reclantar las cuotas y tos costos exentas por imponer un gravamen sobre
cualquier recuperacién de $10,000 4 mds de valor recibida mediante un acuerdo a una concesiOn de arbitrafe en un caso de derecho civil, Tiene que
pagar el gravaman de la corte antes de que le carte pueda desechar el 250, :

The name and address of the court is:
(El nombre y direccién de‘la corte es). CASE NUMUEK

TY supeve pg Cas
SAN ASO GN SUPERIOR COURT C 6 a tn ("2.7 5 7 3 Lo

San Francisco, CA 94102

‘The name, address, and telephone number of plaintiff's atlarney, or plaintiff without an attorney, is:
El nombre, la direccién de teléfona del abogado del demandante, 0 dei demandante que na tien abogado, es).
AVID R. DONADIO, ESQ., STATE BAR NO. 154436

BRAYTON*PURCELL LLP

222 Rush Landing Road, Novato, CA 94948-6169 (415) 898-1855

DATE: Clerk, by NATTY Deputy
gig CLERKOFTHE CORT epuly

SE eeha)

(For proof of service of tis Summons, use Prool of Service of Summons (form POS-010),)

(Para prueba de entrega de esta citation use al formulario Proof of Service of Summons, (POS-010)).
NOTICE TO THE PERSON SERVED: You are served

[SEAL 1, O as an individual defendant.
2. 0 as the person sued under the, malt name of (spegify):
3.52 on vohattotfepeciy: D» G2 insky $ Sore VY C:
under CCP 416,10 (corporation) Oo CCP 416.60(minor)
oO CGP 416.20 (defunct corporation) Oo CP 416,70 (conservatee)

O CCP 416.40 (association of partnership) Oo CCP 416.90 (authorized person)
oO other (specify):
4, x by personal delivery on (date):

P: Lol
RNR iSGNPURE “Caae aT arasn Seo,
Tam Glia SUMMONS ma ee Se.

SUM-100 (Rav.dudy 1, 2009BRAYTON PURCELL LLP

ATTORNEYS AT LAW
222 RUSH LANDING ROAD

C.C. MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS

ASSOCIATIED INSULATION OF CALIFORNIA

FLUOR CORPORATION

HANSON PERMANENTE CEMENT, INC. FORMERLY KNOWN AS KAISER CEMENT CORPORATION
METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
OAKFABCO, INC.

SLAKEY BROTHERS, INC,

BAYER CROPSCIENCE INC,

GRAYBAR ELECTRIC COMPANY, INC.

CSK AUTO, INC.

THE GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY

JOHNSON CONTROLS, INC.

PHARMACIA CORPORATION, WHICH WILE. DO BUSINESS IN CALIFORNIA AS PHARMACIA PHARMACEUTICAL CORPORATION
H & C INVESTMENT ASSOCIATES. INC.

FOLEY ELECTRIC CO.

CINCINNATI VALVE COMPANY

C&R PLASTERING, INC.

TUTTLE AND BAILEY CORP

LAUB SHEET METAL WORKS

WILLARD ELECTRIC

WESTBURNE SUPPLY, INC.

COMMAIR MECHANICAL SERVICES

ACCO ENGINEERED SYSTEMS, (NC.

IMPERIAL PLASTERING & DRYWALL

GENERAL MILLS, INC,

KENTILE FLOORS, INC.

DOMCO PRODUCTS TEXAS. L.P.

FULLER FLOORS

ROBERT MAGEE

MARSHCO AUTO PARTS, INC.

EMIL J, WEBER ELECTRIC CO.

THE W.W. HENRY COMPANY

TEMPORARY PLANT CLEANERS, INC.

D, ZELINSKY & SONS, INC.

ALBAY CONSTRUCTION COMPANY

PACIFIC MECHANICAL CORPORATION

WALNUT CREEK SHEET METAL, FURNACE & AiR CONDITIONING, INC.
PARKER INSULATION CONTRACTING & SUPPLY CO. INC.
EX- FM, INC. (FKA FISCHBACH AND MOORE ELECTRIC, INC.)
GIAMPOLINI & CO.

WEBCOR BUILDERS, INC.

JONES PLASTERING COMPANY

J.W.MCCLENAHAN COMPANY, INC.

SCOTT CO. OF CALIFORNIA

BARNES CONSTRUCTION CO.

BALLIET BROS. CONSTRUCTION CORPORATION
CLAUSEN-PATTEN, INC.

A. TEICHERT & SON, INC.

CRITCHFIELD MECHANICAL, INC.

JOSEPH BRUNO SHEET METAL CO,, INC.oD wm NDA HH Bw N

BELL PRODUCTS INC.

ALLEN-SIMMONS HEATING & SHEET METAL COMPANY INC
ROLLIE R. FRENCH, INC.

HENRY C. BECK COMPANY

INSULATION SPECIALTIES, INC.

TEMPER INSULATION

RED TOP ELECTRIC CO. EMERYVILLE, [NC.
SFL,INC.

ALLSBERRY MECHANICAL CORPORATION
MIDSTATE MECHANICAL, INC.

ROUNTREE PLUMBING & HEATING INC.
COLLINS ELECTRICAL COMPANY, INC.
HAROLD BEASLEY PLUMBING AND HEATING, INC,
SUGDEN ENGINEERING CO.

JAMES A. NELSON CO., INC.

MICHAEL BROTHERS

MACK CONSTRUCTION CO,

MITCHELL BROS, TRUCK LINES, INC.

AIR SYSTEMS MECHANICAL CONTRACTOR
A& K HEATING COMPANY, INC.
ADVANCED MECHANICAL

PACIFIC FIREPROOFING

MATTOCK CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
HARRY LEE PLUMBING & HEATING

W.C. THOMASON

CLIMATE AIR, INC,

ALLIED SPRINKLER COMPANY, INC.
DELUCCHL SHEET METAL WORKS
MCCLURE ELECTRIC, INC,

DPR CONSTRUCTION

CIR PLASTERING

“COSCO SPRINKLER

ROLLINS CONSTRUCTION

BANNER DRYWALL & PAINTING CO. INC.
ORTHO-CRAFT

DONOVAN CONSTRUCTION

BETA MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS, LIMITED
PRIBUSS ENGINEERING

DILLAND SEDERBERG PLUMBING

ER WIN MECHANICAL INC.

CLIMATE CONTROL CO., INC.

DORN REFRIGERATION

CASTRO CONSTRUCTION, INC.

VAN MULDER SHEETMETAL

W.C. THOMPSON

CALIFORNIA DRYWALL CO.

BRAGG INVESTMENT COMPANY, INC.
FAIRMONT HOTEL COMPANY

D.W. NICHOLSON CORPORATION
SWINERTON BUILDERS

and DOES 1-8500,

Defendants.

Robert Ross and Jean Ross vs. C.C, Moore & Co. Engineers, et al.
San Franciséo Superior CourtI

oe
CASE NUMBER: CGC-10-275731 ROBERT ROSS et al VS. C.C. MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS
NOTICE TO PLAINTIFF

A Case Management Conference is set for:
DATE: DEC-15-2011
TIME: 4:30PM

PLACE: Department 220
400 McAllister Street
San Francisco, CA 94102-3680

All parties must appear and comply with California Rules of Court 3.110

CRC 3.725 requires the filing and service of a case management

statement form CM-110 no later than 15 days before the case
management conference.

Plaintiff must serve a copy of this notice upon each party to this action with the
summons and complaint. Proof of service subsequently filed with this court shall
so state.

(DEFENDANTS: Attending the Case Management Conference does not take the
place of filing a written response to the complaint. You must file a written
response with the court within the time limit required by law. See Summons.]CM-010

ATTORNEY OR PARTY WITHOUT ATTORNEY (Wome, steua bor number, and odbess), | FOR COURT USE ONLY
DAVID RK. DONADIO. SQ. STATE WAT), 154436

BRAYTON®PURCELL LLP

222 Rush Landing Road

Novato, California 94948-6169

TELEPHONE NO: (4 § 5) BOR-1555 FRENO. (415) 898-1247 : ENDORSED
ATTOANGY FOR (wat) _Plainbfits) _ ]
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO . San Francisca County Sugeise Court

STREET ADDRESS: 400 McAllister Street
MAILING ADDRESS: DEC 17 2010

CITY AND ZIP CODE: San Francisco, CA 94102

BRANCH NAME ————-| CLERK OF THE COURT
PARAM NATT

bass NAME: py:
ROBERT ROSS and JEAN ROSS vs. C-C“MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS. et al. ‘ A iy Cer

r CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Complex Case Designation CASE NUMBER:
Unlimited D Limited C] Counter 1] Joinder ¢ G c ~ 4 0 ” 2 7 5 7 3 1
(Amount (Aniount Filed with first appearance by defendant
demanded demanded is (Cal, Rules of Court, rule 3.462) JUDGE:
exceeds $25,000) — $25.000 or tess} .
Der, _|

a ltems 1-6 hulow must be completed (see inytructions on page 2).
|, Check one box below of the case type that best describes this case:

Auto Tort Contract Provisionalty Complex Civit Litigation
Caso a2 C2] Breach or comtanct'vareanty (06) {get Rules of Court. rules 3.400-3.403)
| Uninsured mozoris (48) CJ saute 3,740 collcesians (ayy AritewstfTeade reyalation (03)
Other PEPE WD (Persoaal lnjury/Peopenty I cities Cottecrions 109) Consuruetion detect 110)
Damage/Wrongiul Death) Fort LJ} ncurmane coves (185 Mass tort (404
Asbusts (04) ( other cameact (37% £2) Securities tigation (2X)
Producs Liability (24) Real Property’ (21 tenvisonmental “Taste ert (30)
‘Medical malpractice (45) Hiainent domainfinverse lnsurauice covcrage elaiais arising from the
CT outer eveprwn 3) ‘condemnation (14) above listed provisionally complex case types (41)
Non-PUPDAWD (Other) Tori ‘Weonuful eviedon (34) Gnforcement of Judgment
Gudiness tortfunfair business peavtece (07) Corner real property 264 Enforcement of judgment (20)
i civit sights (08) Unlawful Detainer Miscellancous Civit Complaint
‘Defivation (13) 0 Commercial (315 oO
Fr ‘ RICO 7)
OD rrauscasy (TF resistemsat 6329
snetleciual propery 19) Daye tan) Othor comphacar jen qpeeyfiel ebro) (42)
(2 professional aeytigence(234 Judieint Review Miscellaneous Civil Petition
(3 omter nan-PEPDIWD tent (354 Asset forfvivare (05) CD rrarinershin and cmpurate governance (25)
Empiayment {2 Peartinu ce: adtvteation ay ard (it CD one petition fru spcifieel huey (A3)
Wrongful termination (364 2) writ of eranctate (03
Other employment (15) [71 other judicial review (391
2. This case Os & is not complex under rute 3.400 of the California Rules of Court. If the case is complex, mark the factors
requiring exceptional judicial management; .
a Large number of separately represented panties d Large number of witnesses
b, [1] Extensive motion practice raising difficult or novel ce. LJ Coordination and related actions pending in one or more courts
issues that will be time-consuming to resolve in other counties, siates or countries, or in a federal court
¢, CD substantial amount of ‘documentary evidence f. Substantial post-judgment judicial supervision
3. Remedies sought (check atl that apply): a. 5) money >. CJ nommonetary; declaratory or injunctive relief —_¢, BSI punitive
4. Number of causes of action (specify: 9
5. This case [is isnot a class action suit.
6. [fthere are any known related cases, file and serve 2 notice of refated case, (Yow MAUS ornt CM-HU5.)
Date: | | ;
(epi ‘avid R. Donadio. » \ C5 é
(TYEE OR PRINT NAME) GIGNATURE OF PARTY 08% ATTORNEY FOR PARTY)
NOVICE

+ Plaintiff must file this cover sheet with the first paper filed in the action or proceeding (except sinall claims cases ar cases filed under the Probate Code,
Family Code, or Welfare and Institutions Code). eal. Rutes of Cour, rule 3.220.) Fatlurc to file may result in sanctions,

+ Fife thts cover sheet in addition to any cover sheet required by local court rule,

* If this case is complex under rule 3.400 et seq. of the California Rules of Court, you must serve a copy of this cover sheot on all other parties to

the action or proceeding.
+ Unless this is a collections case under rule 3.740 or a complex case, this cover shect shall be used for statistical purposes only, Page t of?
Form Adapted for Mandatory Use CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Cel Rakes of Cot, 502.29, 22U, IAD A, 3,740
ses Creel Cai Cot Samat it Adenine 83.00
‘cee a 12097} sos ei

ests Tosa sews Crema ste Cant PraATTORNEYS AT LAW
222 RUSH LANDING ROAD
at5) 8B S83

BRAYTONSPURCELL LLP
MOVATO, CALIFORNIA 94988-6169

DAVID R, DONADIO, ESQ., 8.8. #154436

BRAYTON*PURCELL LLP ENDORSED
Attorneys-at Law

22 ye ‘Landing Road Son Francteo Caualy Superior Cows?
P. Ox, 6)

NovatoyGalifornia 94948-6169 — aagpesTOS DEC 17 2010
(415) 898-1555 CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE

. RT
Attorneys for Plaintifis DEC 15 20it 42M ENA
ty

fail

DEPARTMENT 220
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA

COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

ROBERT ROSS and JEAN ROSS,
Plaintiffs,

ASBESTOS
No.

10-275731

}
VS. ) comm siget con PERSONAL INJURY
) AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM -
C.C, MOORE & CO. ENGINEERS; )
Defendants as Reflected on Exhibit ] )
attached to the Summary Complaint )
herein; and DOES 1-8500. )

1, Plaintiff ROBERT ROSS was born September 9, 1935,

ASBESTOS

2. The ©Brayton*Pureell Master Complaint for Personal Injury [and Loss of
Consortium]- Asbestos (hereinafter "Master Complaint”) was filed January 2, 2003, in San
Francisco Superior Court. A copy of the Master Complaint and General Order No. 55 may be
obtained upon request from Brayton*Purcell, and designated portions of the Master Complaint
are incorporated by reference herein pursuant to the authority conferred by General Order No. 55.
Plaintiffs’ claims are as set forth in said Master Complaint against defendants herein as follows:
ut
it
m THIS CASE 1S SUBJECT TO

MANDATORY ELECTRONIC FILING
PURSUANT TO AMENDED G.O, 158

exes indeed \
A ON PEOR PERSONAL INIURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM > ASBESTOSDEFEN. DANTS* ON

EXHIBITS:

Cause of Action

%
lo

E F

o

First (Negligence)

Second (Strict Liability)

Third (False
Representation}

Fourth (Loss of

G

Oo OO

wm O Whe
&

Consortium)

Fifth (Premises Owner/
Co xctor Liability)

Sixth, Seventh, Eighth 0
(Unszaworthiness, Negligence
[Jones Act},Maintenance and Cure)

Ninth (Longshore and Harbor Workers
Compensation Act [LHWCA}}

Tenth, Eleventh ELA) 0

Tweifth. Thirteenth (Respiratory
Safety Devices}

Fourteenth, Fifteenth
(Brake Shoe Grinding}

Sixteenth (Concert of Action}

Seventeenth, Eighteenth (Fraud, Deceit/Negligent
Misrepresentation/Concealment)

Nineteenth (Fraud/Deceit/
Intentional Misrepresentation)

Twentieth (Fraud/Deceit ~ Kent)

Twenty-First (Aiding/Abetting Battery - Met Lite)

Twenty-Second
{Civil Battery)

B I j

OOF

OK

oepaong oO ob oO ee 8

*and their allernate entities as set forth in the Master Complaint or on any Exhibit.

|z

X3. Plaintiff's asbestos-related injury, date of diagnosis, employment status, and
history of exposure to asbestos are as slated on Exhibit A.
4, Plaintifts were married on December 15, 1975.
5. Plaintiff hereby amends the Master Complaint on file herein, to incorporate a
new Twenty-First Cause of Action, set forth below, specially plead against the defendant listed
on Exhibit N, namely METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY. (Plaintiffs are in
the process of amending the Master Complaint herein and will include this new Cause of Action
in said amendment.)
“TWENTY-FIRST CAUSE OF |
Aiding and Abetting Batte

[Against Metropolitan Life Inswance Company
and Does 7501-7900, Inclusive)

AS AND FOR A FURTHER, TWENTY-FIRST, SEPARATE AND DISTINCT
CAUSE OF ACTION FOR AIDING AND ABETTING BATTERY, PLAINTIFF
COMPLAINS OF DEFENDANTS METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY,
DEFENDANTS ON EXHIBIT N, DOES 7501-7900, THEIR ALTERNATE ENTITIES AND
EACH OF THEM, AND ALLEGES AS FOLLOWS:

225. Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference, as though fully set forth hereat, each
and every allegation of the First through Third and Sixteenth, Seventeenth, Eighteenth and
Nineteenth Causes of Action as though fully set forth herein. (As used throughout this cause of
action, ‘plaintiff refers to afl named plaintiffs and/or all named decedents from whom the
named plaintiff's injuries may derive.)

226. This cause of action is for the aiding and abetting of battery by METROPOLITAN
LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY (“MET LIFE”), primarily through ils assistant medical
director Anthony Lanza, M.D., of a breach of duty committed by Johns-Manville Corporation
(“-M’).

227. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and thereon alleges, that at all times herein
mentioned defendant MET LIFE was and is a corporation organized and existing under and by
virtue of the laws of the State of New York or the laws of some other state or foreign

scat oss piete 3
COMPLAINT to) ee SONAL INJURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM - A: BESTOSjurisdiction, and that this defendant was and is authorized to do and/or was and is doing

business in the State of California, and regularly conducted or conducts business in the County
of San Francisco, State of California. At times relevant to this cause of action, MET LIFE was
an insurer of |-M.

228. Plaintiff, was exposed Lo asbestos-containing dust created by the use of the
asbestos products manufactured, distributed and/or supplied by J-M, This exposure to the
asbestos or asbestos-related products supplied by J-M caused Plaintiff's asbestos-related disease
and injuries.

229. Starting in 1928, MET LIFE sponsored studies of asbestos dust and asbestos-
related disease in Canadian mines and mills, including those of J-M. Those studies revealed
that miners and mill workers were contracting asbestosis at relatively low levels of dust.
MoGill University. which conducted the studies, sought permission from MET LIFE to publish
the results but they were never published. MET LIFE prepared ils own report of these studies.

230, Between 1929 and 1931, MET LIFE siudied dast levels and disease al live U.S.
plants manufacturiny asbestos-containing products. including a J-M plant. Those studies
showed that workers in substantial numbers were contracting asbestosis, at levels less than what
became the Threshold Limit Value CTLV") of 5mppef, The MET LIFE report was never
published or disseminated except to plant owners. including J-M.

231. In 1932, MET LIFE studied dust levels and disease at the 1-M plant at Manville,
New Jersey. Results were consistent with those of the Canadian and previous U.S. plant
studies, They were never published.

232. In 1934, J-M and others whose plants MET LIFE had studied agreed with MET
LIFE that it should issue a report of its studies.

233. MET LIFE submitted a draft of its report to JM. J-M requested, for legal and
business reasons, that certain critical parts of the craft be changed. MET. LIFE’s official in
charge was Lanza. MET LIFE through Lanza did make changes that J-M requested, including:

(a) Deletion of MET LIFE’s conclusion that the permissible dust level for asbestos

should be less than that for silica;

Kure 19349) ley

et 4
MPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOS(b) Addition of the phrase that asbestosis clinically appeared to be milder than
silicosis,

The report. thus altered, was published in 1935. [1 was misteading, and intentionally so,
because it conveyed the incorrect propositions that asbestosis was a less serious disease process
than silicosis and that higher Jevels of asbestos dust could be tolerated without contracting
diseases than was the case for silica dust.

234. MET LIFE had a close relationship with J-M. It invested money in J-M. It
provided group health and fife insurance to J-M. MET LIFE IN 1934 agreed to supply
industrial hygiene services to J-M, inciuding dust counts, training employees to monitor dust
levels, examining employees, and recommending protective equipment. MET LIFE and Lanza
were viewed as experts on industrial dusts.

235. In 1933, MET LIFE through Lanza issued the following advices to J-M:

{a) Disagreeing with the recommendation of a J-M plant physician, MET LIFE
advised against warning workers of the fact that asbestos dust is hazardous to
their health, basing its advice in view of the extraordinary legal situation;

(>) When the plant physician judged the best disposition of an employee with
asbestosis was to remove him from the dust, MET LIVE advised instead that
disposition should depend on his age, nature of work and other factors and to
leave him alone if he is old and showing no disability, for, MET LIFE stated,
economic and production factors must be balanced against medical factors.

236. J-M followed the MET LIFE advices and did not warn its workers, including
plaintiff, of the hazards of asbestos dust, and J-M also intentionally refrained from notifying
workers of their disease.

237. In 1936, MET LIFE, J-M and others founded the Air Hygiene Foundation
(“AHF”). One of the AHF purposes was to develop standards for dust levels that would serve
as a defense in lawsuits and workers’ compensation claims.

238. MET LIFE funded partially another study thal tentatively recommended in j938a

‘SLY for asbestos dust of Smpeef, the'same as for silica dust. MET LIFE was aware of data

A uuired Day glowed _ 5
SOMPLATNT TOR PERSON TAL INTURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOSfrom its own, unpublished reparts that showed that level was too high for asbestos dust. MET
LIFE nonetheless promoted that TLY as proper.

239, In June 1947, the Industrial Hygiene Foundation (“IHF”) which succeeded to the
AUF, issued a report of studies by Dr. Hemeon of U.S. asbestos plants, including a J-M plant.
That report showed that workers exposed to less than the recommended maximum levels of
dust were developing disease. MET LIFE was a member of the [HF and Lanza was on its
medical committee. The Hemeon report, which was supplied to J-M and other owners, never
was published.

240. In 1936, J-M and other asbestos companies agreed with a leading medi¢al research
facility, Saranac Laboratories, that Saranac would research asbestos disease, but J-M and the
others retained control over publication of the results. In 1943 Saranac’s Dr. Leroy Gardner, in
charge of the research, sent a draft to J-M that revealed thal 81.8% of mice exposed to long
fiber asbestos contracted cancer,

241. Dr. Gardner died in 1946. J-M and other companies wanted parts of the Saranac
results published and enlisted the assistance of MET LIFE’s Lanza. J-M and other companies
decided that Saranac’s findings of cancer caused by asbestos in mice must be deleted, as well as
Saranac’s critique of existing dus: standards. Lanza directed Saranac to delete the offending
materials. Saranac did so, and the altered report was published in 1951 by Saranac's Dr.
Vorwald, in the AMA Archives of lndustrial Hygiene.

242. Lanza left MET LIFE at the end of 1948, and took a position at New York
University, funded by MET LIFE. He continued to misrepresent that asbestos does not cause
cancer into the 1950s.

243. The EHF (formerly AHF), of which MET LIFE was a member and MET LIFE
official was on its medical committee, through Drs. Braun and Truan conducted a study of
Canadian miners. The original report, in 1957, found an increased incidence of lung cancer in
persons exposed to asbestos. The sponsors, including J-M, caused those findings to be stricken,
and the report published in 1958 contained the false conclusion that asbestos exposure alone did
not increase the risk of lung cancer.

“ADI IAsnp- sil

Ee Jet 6
MPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INSURY ANDY LOSS OF CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOS244, The false and misleading reports that a link between asbestos exposure and cancer
was not proven influenced the TLV. for if a substance causes cancer the TLY must be very low
or zero.

245, IM not later than 1933 was inflicting asbestos dust on its workers in is plants
knowing that the dust was hazardous and was causing workers lo contract disease that could
and would disable and kill them. As MET LIFE advised, J-M did not warn its wotkers of the
hazard. J-M committed battery on workers in its plants, including plaintiff, by that conduct.

246. MET LIFE knew that J-M’s conduct constituted a breach of its duties to its
workers, MET LIFE gave substantial assistance to J-M in committing batteries On its workers,
including plaintiff, through MET LIFE’s conduct described above, including by:

(a) Affirmatively urging J-M not to warn workers of the hazards of asbestos dust, ia
view of the extraordinary legat situation, such that J-M did not warn its workers,
including plaintiff;

(b) Deleting the findings of its own draft report that the allowable limits for asbestos
dust should be less than those for silica dust, and promoting a false and unsafe
TLV which specified maximum levels of silica dust, and promoting a false and
unsafe TLV which specified maximum levels of dust for workers, including
plaintiff, which MET LIFE knew was wrong through its own studies;

(c) Advising J-M to keep certain workers continuing to work at dusty areas in the
plant even after J-M was aware that their lungs showed asbestos-induced
changes, lest other workers including plaintilf be alerted to the dangers of
working in the dust.

WHEREFORE, plaintiff prays judgment as is hereinafter set forth.”

6. Plaintiffs do not make a claim for either false representative or punitive damages

against any named defendant herein.

pated: \Aybl\o BRAYTON-+PURCELL LLP

By: ~d ¢ _
David R. Donadio
Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Sdvahueas gale tener oy 2
COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOSEXHIBIT 1EXHIBIT t - LIST OF DEFENDANTS

C.C. MOORE & CO, ENGINEERS

ASSOCIATED INSULATION OF CALIFORNIA

FLUJOR CORPORATION

HANSON PERMANENTE CEMENT, INC, FORMERLY KNOWN AS KAISER CEMENT CORPORATION
METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
OAKFABCO. INC.

SLAKEY BROTHERS, INC.

BAYER CROPSCIENCE INC.

GRAYBAR ELECTRIC COMPANY, INC,

CSK AUTO, INC.

THE GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY

JOHNSON CONTROLS, INC.

PHARMACIA CORPORATION, WHICH WILL BO BUSINESS IN CALIFORNIA AS PHARMACIA PHARMACEUTICAL CORPORATION
H& C INVESTMENT ASSOCIATES, INC.

FOLEY ELECTRIC CO.

CINCINNATI VALVE COMPANY

C&R PLASTERING, INC.

TUTTLE AND BAILEY CORP

LAUB SHEET METAL WORKS

WILLARD ELECTRIC

WESTBURNE SUPPLY, INC.

COMMAIR MECHANICAL SERVICES

ACCO ENGINEERED SYSTEMS, INC,

IMPERIAL PLASTERING & DRYWALL

GENERAL MILLS, SNC.

KENTILE FLOORS, INC.

DOMCO PRODUCTS TEXAS, L.P.

FULLER FLOORS

ROBERT MAGEE

MARSHCO AUTO PARTS, INC.

EMIL J. WEBER ELECTRIC CO.

THE W.W. HENRY COMPANY

TEMPORARY PLANT CLEANGRS, INC.

D. ZELINSKY & SONS, INC.

ALBAY CONSTRUCTION COMPANY

PACIFIC MECHANICAL CORPORATION

WALNUT CREEK SHEET METAL, FURNACE & AIR CONDITIONING, INC.
PARKER [INSULATION CONTRACTING & SUPPLY CO. INC.
EX- FME, INC. (FKA FISCHBACH AND MOORE ELECTRIC, INC.)
GIAMPOLINE & CO,

WEBCOR BUILDERS, INC.

JONES PLASTERING COMPANY

J.W. MCCLENAHAN COMPANY, INC.

SCOTT CO. OF CALIFORNIA

BARNES CONSTRUCTION CO.

BALLIET BROS, CONSTRUCTION CORPORATION
CLAUSEN-PATTEN, INC.

A, TEICHERT & SON, INC.

CRITCHFIELD MECHANICAL, INC.

JOSEPH BRUNO SHEET METAL CO., INC.

Als e920 dep cee et

9.
COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOSaoe

BELL PRODUCTS INC,

ALLEN-SIMMONS HEATING & SHEET METAL COMPANY INC.
ROLLIE 8. FRENCH, INC.

HENRY C. BECK COMPANY

INSULATION SPECIALTIES, INC.

TEMPER INSULATION

RED TOP ELECTRIC CO. EMERYVILLE, INC.
SFL INC.

ALLSBERRY MECHANICAL CORPORATION
MIDSTATE MECHANICAL, INC.
ROUNTREE PLUMBING & HEATING INC,
COLLINS ELECTRICAL COMPANY. INC.
HAROLD BEASLEY PLUMBING AND HEATING, INC,
SUGDEN ENGINEERING CO.

JAMES A, NELSON CO., [NC.

MICHAGL BROTHERS,

MACK CONSTRUCTION CO.

MITCHELL BROS. TRUCK LINES, INC.

AIR SYSTEMS MECHANICAL CONTRACTOR
A & K HEATING COMPANY, INC,
ADVANCED MECHANICAL

PACIFIC FIREPROOFING

MATTOCK CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
HARRY LEE PLUMBING & HEATING

W.C. THOMASON

CLIMATE AIR, INC,

ALLIED SPRINKLER COMPANY, INC.
DELUCCHI SHEET METAL WORKS
MCCLURE ELECTRIC, INC.

DPR CONSTRUCTION

CIR PLASTERING

COSCO SPRINKLER

ROLLINS CONSTRUCTION

BANNER DRYWALL & PAINTING CO. INC.
ORTHO-CRAFT

DONOVAN CONSTRUCTION

BETA MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS, LIMITED
PRIBUSS ENGINEERING

DILLAND SEDERBERG PLUMBING

ERWIN MECHANICAL INC,

CLIMATE CONTROL CO., INC.

DORN REFRIGERATION

CASTRO CONSTRUCTION, INC.

YAN MULDER SHEETMETAL

W.C. THOMPSON

CALIFORNIA DRYWALL CO.

BRAGG INVESTMENT COMPANY, INC,
FAIRMONT HOTEL COMPANY

D.W. NICHOLSON CORPORATION
SWINBRTON BUILDERS

and DOES 1-8500,

Defendants,

Yuan apart pepe pd 10
COMPLAINT HOR PERSONAL INJURY ANTS LOSS OF CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOS”EXHIBIT ASD wo et DH eB YN

12

EXHIBIT A

Plaintiff's exposure to asbestos and asbestos-containing products occurred at various

locations both inside and outside the State of California, including but not limited to:

E:mplover

Philip Carey
Cincinnati, OH

Coast Insulating Products
Los Angeles, CA

Universal Insulation
520 6" Avenue
Menlo Park, CA

Universal Insulation
520 6" Avenue
Menlo Park, CA

AC&S
Lancaster, PA

Western Asbestos

Western Asbestos
3150 3 Sweet
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA

Heat, Frost & Asbestos
Workers Union
Local 16

Western Asbestos

3150 3 Streat
San Francisco, CA

Mi

Location of
Exposure

Warehouse
10) Williams
San Francisco, CA

Jack Tar Hotel

(aka Cathedraf Hill Hotel)
1101 Van Ness

San Francisco, CA

Fertilizer Plant
Helm, CA

Mare Island Naval
Shipyard
Vallejo, CA

Hewleu Packard
Menlo Park, CA

UC Berkeley (Central
Steam Plant),
Berkeley, CA

Tidewater Associated Oi)
Avon, CA

PG&E Powerhouse
Pittsburg, CA

Queen of the Valley
Hospital
Napa, CA

Maritime Union
Mission Street
San Francisco, CA

Job Title

Exposure
Dates

Warehouseman 2/1959-8/1959;

Insulator
(Apprentice)

Insulator
(Apprentice)

Insulator
(Apprentice)

insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

McKinteyville High School Insulator

McKinleyville, CA

12/3959-1/1960
(1 week)

8/1959-9/1959
(approx. 5 wks)

1959 (on and off
for 3 months)

1959 (1-2 weeks)

1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966
(1 week)

1959-1965
(3 weeks)

1/1960-7/1960

7/1960 (3 weeks)

Approx. 1960
(i day}

T1961-10/1961;
7/1962-5/1965
(3 ‘4 weeks, on
and off)

EXHIBIT A

KAnjurea i934 ple Ne. 12
& MOLATNT SOR BERSONAT INJURY ANID LOSS OF CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOSEmployer

Western Asbestos
3150.3" Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
315034 Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150.3" Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3% Street
San Francisco, CA

Wester 0 Asbe
3150 38)
San Francisco, CA

3{OS

Western Asbestos
3150 3% Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3" Surcet
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3” Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3% Street
San Francisco, CA

wt

EXHIBIT A (contd.

Location of
Exposure

Calaveras Cement Plant
Redding, CA

Tidewater Oil Company
Avon, CA

Mansanto Chemical
Avon, CA

PG&E Powerhouse
Pittsburg, CA

Colgate Palmolive
Berkeley, CA

Gerber Foods
Oakland, CA

Ampex Systems ( Corp
hvood City, CA

Pacific Beli Telephone
San Francisco, CA

PG&E
Antioch, CA

Hercules Powder
Hercules, CA

Georgia Pacific
Arcata, CA

Job Tite

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Exposure
Dates

1961-1965
(1 month)

1961-1962
(Approx 1 month)

1961-65 (Approx
1 Soot)

1961-1965
(3 months)

7/1961-10/1961;
711962-5/1 965
(5 weeks, on and
off)

7/1961t-10/1961;
7I1962-S/1965
(3 weeks, on and
off)

1961-1962 (2-3
weeks, on and off}

1961-1965
(3 months)

1961-1965
(3-6 months)

7/196}-LO/1961;
7N962-S/1965
(1 month, on and
off)

7/1961-10/1961;
7/1962-5/1965
(2-3 months, on
and off)

EXHIBIT A

KAjuecdisg semi 13
COMPLA’ NT OR TER PERSONAL INJURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM - ASHESTOSSB Oo mM A wm Bw ON

EXHIBIT A (cont'd.

Location of .
Eniployer Exposure Job Title
Western Asbestos Bethlehem Steel insulator
3150.3 Street Shipbuilding
San Francisco, CA San Francisco, CA

Triple A Machine Shop

(Pier 64)

San Francisco, CA

Willamette Shipyard
Richmond, CA

Pacific Ship Repair
Pier 36) °
san Francisco, CA

Todd Shipyard
Oakland, CA

Matson Navigation
(Pier 30)
San Francisca, CA

Naval Air Station
Alameda, CA

JOSEPH | P. KENNEDY
(DD-850)

CHEYENNE
(T-AG-174)

HAWAUAN PLANTER
(1945)

GRAFFIAS
(AF-29)

MATHEWS
(AKA-96)

MERRICK
(AKA-97)

TWINING
@D-540)

WW

A

Exposure

Dates

F/961-30/1961,
TN962-5/1965

(on and off for
approx. | week
each time)

EXHIBIT A

Moje neosamyp dang gilep te yd {4
COMPLAINT FORD EICSONAL INJURY ANS LOSS OF CONSORTIOM - ASBESTOSEmployer

Western Asbestos
3450 3" Street
San Francisco. CA (cont'd)

Western Asbestos
3150.3" Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3 Street
San Francisca, CA

Western Asbestos
3450 3" Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos.
31503" Street
San Francisco, CA,

HE

EXHIBIT A (cont'd.

Location of
Exposure

Bethichem Steet Insulator
Shipbuilding
San Francisco, CA

(
MONTEREY (1952)
BLAND (APA-134)

PONTCHARTRAIN
(WPG-70)

CALIFORNIAN
(1946) :

Grace Cathedral Insulator
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos Pad Insulator
Shop, 3° Avenue and
Army, San Francisco, CA

PG&E Nuclear Powerhouse Insulator
Humboldt County
Eureka, CA

PG&E insulator
San Francisco, CA
(Potrero Siation)

ppc 9249 Nshennp-pilephser wp
co

MPLA’ FOR PERSONAL INJURY A.

Exposure

Jaies

711961-1 0/1961;
7/1 962-511965

1963 - 1965

7/1 961-LO/N9GE;
11962-5/1965
(2 weeks, on and
off)

T/1961-10/1961;
TN962-5/1965
(2-3 days, on and
off)

TH1961-10/1961;
TIN962-1 2/1962
(5 months, on and
off)

7/1961-1 0/1961;
7/1962-12/1962
(2 weeks)
7/1961-10/1961,
T962-5/1965
(2 to 3 weeks, on
and off)

EXHIBIT A

15 te
ND LOSS GF CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOS26

Employer

Western Asbestos
3150.3" Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3° Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Ashestos
3150 3° Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3” Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3 Street
San Francisco, CA.

Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3 Street
San Francisco, CA

Western Asbestos
3150 3" Street

San Francisco, CA

He

KMart lem obs 16 ae
COMPLAIN SR SERSONAT. INITIRY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOS

EXHIBIT A (contid.

Location of
Exposure

Dow Chemical
Pittsburg, CA

Sheil Oi!
Martinez, CA

PG&E
Oakland, CA

Vallecitos Atomic
Laboratory
Pleasanton, CA

Missile Base
Live Oak, CA

University of California
Berkeley, CA
(Boiler Plant)

Shell OU
Martinez, CA

Standard Oil
Richmond, CA

Shell Oil
Martinez, CA

Hills Brothers Coffee
San Francisco, CA

Job Title

Tnsulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Exposure
Dates

Tit961-10/1961;
714962-3/1965
(1 month, on and
off)

71961-10/1961;
7/$962-5/1965
(6 weeks, on and
off)

7 9G1-10/1961,
7/4962- 12/1962
(2 weeks, on and
off)

7H1961-10/1961;
71962-5/1965
(2 weeks, on and
off)

7/1961-10/1961;
T41962-5/1965
(month, on and
off)

7196 1-10/1 961;
F1962-5/1965
(3 weeks)

TAN9GI-LO/E IGE;
711962-5/1965
(2 weeks, on and
off)

7/1961-10/1961;
FI1962-5/1965
(3 weeks, on and
off)

TAIGI-LO/1961;
TN962- 12/1962
(3 weeks, on and
off}

7/1961-10/1961;
711962-5/1965
(2 weeks, on and
off)

EXHIBIT AEmplover

ACK&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

ACKS Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster. PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S insulation
P.O, Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O, Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

a

x sab nent 49

EXHIBIT A (cont'd,

Location of
Exposure

US Department of
Agricu ture.
Albany, CA

Steinhart Aquarium
San Francisco, CA

Union Oil
Rodeo/Oleum, CA

Sonoma State University

Rohnert Park, CA

(Beience Building Boiler
oom)

Oakland Coliseum
Oakland, CA

Firestone Tire & Rubber
Salinas, CA

Golden Gateway
Apartments
San Francisco, CA

Oakiand Museum
Oakland, CA

California State University
Humboldt, CA
(Science Building}

Tasulator

Insulator
Insulator

(Foreman)

Insulator

Tosulalor

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator
(Foreman)

Insulator

Exposure

Daies

8/1960-7/1 961;
10/1961-6/1962;
5/1965- 12/1966
(2 months, on and
off}

1961-1965
(20 days)

8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
(3 weeks, on and
off)

8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
CL month, on and
off)

8/1960-7/1961:
10/1961 -6/1962;
3/1965-12/1966
(5 weeks)

8/1960-7/L96 1;

10/1961-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
(3-4 weeks)

8/1960-7/5961;

10/1961-6/1962;
3/1965-12/1966
(1 month)

8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
(month, on and
off)

8/1960-7/1961;
10/1961 -6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
Q to 3 months, on
and off)

EXHIBIT A

any
COMPLAINT TOR PERSONAL INJURY AND LOSS Of CONSORTIUM ASBESTOSEmployer

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O, Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O, Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

AC&S Insulation
P.O. Box 1268
Lancaster, PA

Mt

HAlaiuied 193  ASBESTOS

EXHIBIT A (cont'd.

Location of

Berkeley High School
Berkeley, CA

Shell Oil
Martinez, CA

“Naval Hospital

Oakland, CA

Emerson Elementary
Schoot
Berkeley, CA

1BM
Cottle Road
San Jose, CA

Hewlett Packard
Palo Alto, CA

General Motors
Fremont, CA

Washinglon Hospital
Fremont, CA

St. Luke’s Hospital
San Francisco, CA

Chiron Building
Berkeley, CA

K-Mart
Vallejo, CA

Job Tile

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

insulator

Insulator

insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Exposure
Dates

8/1960-7/1961;

10/1961 -6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
(3 days)

8/1960-7/1961;

10/1961-6/1962;
5/1965-12/1966
{2 weeks, on and
off)

1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966

(3 weeks, on and
off)

1960 - 1962;
1965 ~ 1966
2 weeks

{on and off)
1966 - 1962;
1965 - 1966

1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966

1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966

1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966

1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966

1960 - 1962;
1965 - 1966

1967 - 1972

EXHIBIT A<==

3 er

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

Consolidated Insulation

Consolidated Insulation

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA
Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA
Ww
He

KAlgjres 9) Vyichuong pi

EXHIBILA (cont'd.)

Location of
Exposure

State Compensation
Building, 1275 Market St,
San Francisco, CA

Alameda County
Administration Building,
Oak Street,

Oakland, CA

Children’s Hospital,
San Francisco, CA

Community College,
Mission Street,
San Francisco, CA

Stanford University
Encina Hall
Palo Alto, CA

Ghirardelli Square
Northpoint Street
San Francisco, CA

Mount Zion Hospital &
Medical Center
San Francisco, CA

Naval Supply
Center Annex
Alameda, CA

Hilton Hotel
Union Square
San Francisco, CA

Fisherman’s Wharf
San Francisco, CA

Pier 39
San Francisco, CA

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

(Foreman)

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

Insulator

insulator

Exposure

rales

1967 - 1972;
1977 - 1979

(6 weeks, on and
off)

1967 - 1972;
1977 - 1979
(2 weeks)

1967 - 1972;
1977-198! (on
and off)

1967 - 1972,
1977 - 1981

(5 weeks, on and
off}

1967 - 1972
(1-2 weeks)

1967 - 1972
(2 weeks)

1967 - 1972
(6 weeks off & on)

1967 - 1972
(3 weeks)

1967 - 1972
(1 month, on and
off)

1966-1973
(1 month, on and
off); 1977-1980

1967-1970

EXHIBIT A

wpe 21
INT FOR PERSONAL INJURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIOM - ASBESTOS18

Employer
Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Betmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

Consolidated Insulation

517-D Marine View Ave.

Belmont, CA

ur

KNieheed 950 idoep-pleg lot wy 22
COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY AND LOSS OF CONSORTIUM - ASBESTOS

EXHIBIT A (cont'd.)

Location of
Exposure

Ghiradelli Square
San Francisco, CA

Bechtel Building
50 Beale Street
San Francisco, CA

Golden Gateway Center
Apartment Towers
San Francisco, CA

Hewlett Packard
Palo Alto, CA

General Motors
Fremont, CA

Oakland Coliseum
Oakland, CA

Chabot College
Hayward, CA

St. Luke’s Hospital
San Francisco, CA

Chiron Building
Berkeley, CA

Stanford University
Palo Alto, CA

San Francisco General
Hospital
San