arrow left
arrow right
  • RODRICK BRECKLER et al VS. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B*P) AS REFLECTED ON et al ASBESTOS document preview
  • RODRICK BRECKLER et al VS. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B*P) AS REFLECTED ON et al ASBESTOS document preview
  • RODRICK BRECKLER et al VS. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B*P) AS REFLECTED ON et al ASBESTOS document preview
  • RODRICK BRECKLER et al VS. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B*P) AS REFLECTED ON et al ASBESTOS document preview
  • RODRICK BRECKLER et al VS. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B*P) AS REFLECTED ON et al ASBESTOS document preview
  • RODRICK BRECKLER et al VS. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B*P) AS REFLECTED ON et al ASBESTOS document preview
  • RODRICK BRECKLER et al VS. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B*P) AS REFLECTED ON et al ASBESTOS document preview
  • RODRICK BRECKLER et al VS. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B*P) AS REFLECTED ON et al ASBESTOS document preview 
						
                                
Preview

                                HOWARD ROME MarTIN & RIDLEY LLP

1775 WOODSIDE ROAD, SUITE 200

REDWOOD CITY, CA 94061-3436

‘TELEPHONE (650) 365-7715

ELECTRONICALLY
FILED

Superior Court of California,
County of San Francisco

JUL 01 2011

SHAWN M. RIDLEY, ESQ. SBN 144311
LISA A. CORMAN, ESQ. 216709
HOWARD ROME MARTIN & RIDLEY LLP
1775 Woodside Road, Suite 200
Redwood City, “A 94061-3436
Telephone: 365-7715

p (650) 365-77 Clerk of the Court

Attorneys for Defendant ee eek clerk
EATON ELECTRICAL INC., SUED HEREIN AS DOE 7 epuly ier

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

RODRICK BRECKLER and JOANN Case No: CGC 08 274566

BRECKLER,
DECLARATION OF LISA A. CORMAN IN
Plaintiffs, SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT EATON
ELECTRICAL INC.’S MOTION IN
vs. LIMINE TO EXCLUDE MAS STUDIES
ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (BP), AND VIDEOTAPED SIMULATIONS

Defendants. NO.2

I, LISA A. CORMAN, declare:

1. That I am an attorney licensed to practice law in the state of California and am an
associate with Howard Rome Martin & Ridley, LLP counsel of record for defendant EATON
ELECTRICAL INC. in the above entitled action. I have personal knowledge of the facts set forth
below, and if called upon to do so, could competently testify thereto.

2. Attached hereto as Exhibit A is a true and correct copy of the Order dated July 5, 2001,
In Re: Lamar County Asbesios Cases Filed Or To Be Filed By Waters & Kraus In Lamar

County, Texas.
iit

1

DECLARATION OF LISA A. CORMAN IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE MAS STUDIES - NO. 2HowaRD ROME MARTIN & RIDLEY LLP

1775 WOODSIDE ROAD, SUITE 200

REDWOOD CITY, CA 94061-3436

TELEPHONE (650) 365-715

I declare under penalty of perjury of the laws of the state of California that the foregoing is
true and correct, Executed this 1 day of July, 2011 at Redwood City, California.

Lisa A. Corman

2

DECLARATION OF LISA A. CORMAN IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT’S MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE MAS STUDIES ~NO,2EXHIBIT AORDER oo i
_ Relarlug to Gatlook, hse, Motion th Suppresy Testimony of &
Bee Wilton Longo ond My, Richard Hatstebt ee
° ono an

Findjing of Farkund Contlasions nf Law Wy, /y

. Oy
On Jone 2p, 2001 wls rime campy on before the court upon a motion filed by Gales, Rag
Longo und Richurd Hasiiald (Longe-Harield) of Mnterlals Analytical Secyiaes Inc. (MAS) front
whnesses, Plainly folned tsoue dnd Wewount on April 23, 200 Served Int Onder getting the date He
"BA Seren nan ve ree ptr oy A la
js ert) sett Wwolving Nt ers nye! oI JOM bee
Pale “Seve by Bie testo of such wiknenses WH] be bowitd by the results: of the hésrlagsy gt milingy ofthe

folate”

exmmei-ot rately tht cour piocecded wht thy heming, The partes walved nots thy

. Aijot amnown opening at
. Sourtrecelved waarlmeny and exhibits thoi Bit piytles ropether whi final prgumonts, Plaintitts tended thie thstionny of

Ds Longe for ber Dp, Longo itd for Ms Hetfield,

tT.
‘Bred upon the teallmony, danements snd photeyrkphy wdzalited ws the boring aid Bye abs save of ait
the evldenen, wha pols meter the fellows Budinee one: nod conchuloas of law, Bac Selly ul eer Matsa be

cortsdenell x eoncluslon of AW avd cach conclusion oF hoy sll alsa tn oonsldered a Tndlitg oF thet IndoPy es they are nor?”
- bltarly délinested ws one othe other of possibly involve bot. : q

WINDINGS GF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 4

“3 } ’
LM ovammenymnd professional sesuehafon standards perpertoted by ria Oconpationa) Safety and Health ,
Admintaration (OSHA), the United States Environmental Tencnton a (EPA), Nattura Tastitate: aE soul
Beal and Safety (NIOSH) and Ue Ametitan Soutety of Tasty Mate (ASTM) for mesaucing alborde sbextag +
fibers for human etpoesityas, aro mink, sardurds thee do rink provide a dethnay Zor compliance. Suck; fo,
however, provitie reliable source avidene bot the court In undorsmndlug penesally accepeed sclentifle metundologtes anid.
es fle 1 rellublliry smndords of Panbrre-Roplnron’? vigdevis Rules 40, 402, 403,702 and 703 of ibe Betas Rules oF
2 "The tests conducrad nt Matattals Anutytieal Services, fe (MAS) by Dy, Winns Longe bud My, saad Fiscal,
(howe Heels on enor Semple Hana ee ad piss wis brushing of gan pouring Sok RG"
‘copa iy OY yl producry and mls! sanding foore Jolor compounds ay reflecr ong FG,
13, i I Hand Sa etoertenealyealettesntareiorsaatet he formes se:
% “Tht MAS testa consthure “funk gelence,* : . a .
a we MAS tests do np oniset thie senna of Rules 401 und 102 Teang Ruler of Byidencs tn tharhh bons are,
heb suifitlently Hed to the. thors pr may Indlvithial ease Jy a matty re ald the fader wk tact ta resolybsg a firtual dispar,
$. ‘Thy MAS testa fal ro apcownt for reson ably foreysnable conditions and prehways oF exposure thor. could be-

-exposlonced with respecere tha tegnival, seriplag, hind whe brushing tnd electrig wha broshlay OF peskerd, pouring Jolne
sainpunnds, sowlig Kaylo products and mixing sud seading Kelly-Moore Joint compounds go ap ta renherghe MAG testy -*

Utde tiara thas speediatton,

6. Wihts court hes whiurtdersipod she teattmony std exhibtty'admitted diving tha DaubererRab eoring yoo
‘De lncotreut fn Ite findings lets anit concluslons oP law the exroc(i) vrs catised by the oondislng, mlseading ind
Preto presenertion of the evidsiics tw tha Brulcr fine, ~ i

. 4 Judge doas pochave to be tiled Ip celenes 10 pvoluate the yelinbiity of selontific vicory or tashntque,
Adshough tho detalls p¢zelengy Tey hereon the characrerstiog of-valld seleutiife kuowledge nd tho kind ofreseontag
thar prnduca [rare ot difficult to greep, Judged are oupuble of uiderstdading ad avalunelng yolent{ite vellhlilry. .

. ‘The courr mnilers io fining pot wha ruth or fulalcy ofthe opiylone exprestad in thls case by Dr, hongo
‘individually or on beliti@ of Mx, Hattteld conceniiny ixposared or paliways of iery

2

' Tie vbbrovistion Donderv Robeson In used to bidleare the Follawhigdecislows: Daubert y. Merrell Dow
Pharatagenteals, Ine, $03 ws S79 (1993) and & 2 Dy Pont da Nemopre Rablasor, 923 SW, 349

Wan.

LAMAR COUNTY ASBESTOS ESTIGATION © farlark In Finidarr riedtae

bEr

hal
it none mes

VW Behibivh, euizslyedl hergre and k patient forall aie fhetual wna the werot
nia part Hirpal porpeses, contain tie pala by |

Teadiagers Satake het

. ° Fone iS Singot, HO.

. . . ‘ Tadge dint " . .

weet Sout Toten HEF ae

tatthnony,
: ‘Tha Motion by Gasloctt, Ins. to Suppress the of Dy William Longo ond Me-Richitd Potteldh
+ “pommted, This onder ee At cer todeateau tne Tae Cot ence,
Hed by antes ds Kraus ualag Ube nestitony mane psy ado ene

- Beles betnorts td wire Bravhing, eects wira bnnsh ating cement (pouring), Kaylo products
Hipkbor fg compound Gus et snares ay ase eo

BR

pan stabs ee ene EP

hee TM

Teen Fa Pree