On January 31, 2008 a
MINUTES FOR APR-28-2008 9:00 AM FOR DEPT 504
was filed
involving a dispute between
Helland, Patrick,
and
Bronner, Ray,
for civil
in the District Court of San Francisco County.
Preview
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
MINUTES
Department. 504
April 28, 2008
Case Number: CUD-08-624838
PATRICK HELLAND
Nature of Cause
PLAINTIFF
Unlawful Detainer
VS.
Jury Trial — Day 4
RAY BRONNER
Jury - Day 4
DEFENDANT
Present:
Judge: MARY E. WISS Clerk: KEVIN LEE
Reporter: DIANA CHEN, CSR #11312 Bailiff: VICTOR JUNG
Appearing for Plaintiff (s):
Charles M. Collins, Esq,
225 Bush Street, 16" Floor
San Francisco, CA 94104
Tel. 415-355-0310
Appearing for Defendant(s)
Pro Per
Court reconvenes for jury trial. The Defendant, both Plaintiffs Counsel and the
Plaintiff are present and outside the presence of the jury to address jury
Court reconvenes for jury trial. The Defendant, both Plaintiffs Counsel and the
Plaintiff are present and outside the presence of the jury to further address jury
09:18am
instructions
10:00am The Court steps off the bench
10:10am
Instructions
10:11am Defense files Supplemental Trial Objection
10:28am The Court steps off the bench
Case Number: CUD-08-624838
Case Title: PATRICK HELLAND VS. RAY BRONNER
-l-
Date: April 28, 2008
Form: C010060:46am Court reconvenes for jury trial. The Defendant, both Plaintiff's Counsel
and the Plaintiff are present and outside the presence of the jury to address
the verdict form and Defendant’s exhibit U & U1. The Court makes a
ruling on Defendant’s exhibit #U1 which is moved into evidence.
1:01am The court instructs the clerk to bring the jury in
1:02am Jury Instruction commenced
1:27am Closing argument by the Plaintiff
1:37am Closing argument by the Defendant
2:17pm Rebuttal Argument by the Plaintiff
2:23pm Additional Jury Instruction
2:28pm Bailiff Victor Jung is sworn to take charge of the jury. Jury deliberation
begins. The jury follows the bailiff to the jury room with all of the
exhibits admitted into evidence and with all of the verdict forms
2:30pm The Court allows the two alternates to remain on telephone standby
2:31pm Court in recess for Lunch break — Jurors admonished not to talk about the
case until they are all in the jury room
01:30pm The jury resumes deliberations in the jury room
04:05pm The Court takes the bench outside the presence of the jury regarding a
possible replacement for one of the twelve jurors
04:25pm Jury returns to court with a verdict for the Plaintiff on both questions on
the Special Verdict
04:27pm Jurors are polled at the request of the Defendant
On the first question 11-1 for the Plaintiff and on the second question 11-1
for the Plaintiff
04:28pm The verdict(s) are recorded
04:29pm Jurors are given final instructions
Admonishment is lifted. Jurors are thanked and excused
04:30pm All exhibits are returned to the preferring parties
04:31pm Court is adjourned
Case Number: CUD-08-624838
Case Title: PATRICK HELLAND VS. RAY BRONNER
-2- Date: April 28, 2008
Form: C01006
Document Filed Date
April 28, 2008
Case Filing Date
January 31, 2008
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO MINUTES Department. 504 April 28, 2008 Case Number: CUD-08-624838 PATRICK HELLAND Nature of Cause PLAINTIFF Unlawful Detainer VS. Jury Trial — Day 4 RAY BRONNER Jury - Day 4 DEFENDANT Present: Judge: MARY E. WISS Clerk: KEVIN LEE Reporter: DIANA CHEN, CSR #11312 Bailiff: VICTOR JUNG Appearing for Plaintiff (s): Charles M. Collins, Esq, 225 Bush Street, 16" Floor San Francisco, CA 94104 Tel. 415-355-0310 Appearing for Defendant(s) Pro Per Court reconvenes for jury trial. The Defendant, both Plaintiffs Counsel and the Plaintiff are present and outside the presence of the jury to address jury Court reconvenes for jury trial. The Defendant, both Plaintiffs Counsel and the Plaintiff are present and outside the presence of the jury to further address jury 09:18am instructions 10:00am The Court steps off the bench 10:10am Instructions 10:11am Defense files Supplemental Trial Objection 10:28am The Court steps off the bench Case Number: CUD-08-624838 Case Title: PATRICK HELLAND VS. RAY BRONNER -l- Date: April 28, 2008 Form: C010060:46am Court reconvenes for jury trial. The Defendant, both Plaintiff's Counsel and the Plaintiff are present and outside the presence of the jury to address the verdict form and Defendant’s exhibit U & U1. The Court makes a ruling on Defendant’s exhibit #U1 which is moved into evidence. 1:01am The court instructs the clerk to bring the jury in 1:02am Jury Instruction commenced 1:27am Closing argument by the Plaintiff 1:37am Closing argument by the Defendant 2:17pm Rebuttal Argument by the Plaintiff 2:23pm Additional Jury Instruction 2:28pm Bailiff Victor Jung is sworn to take charge of the jury. Jury deliberation begins. The jury follows the bailiff to the jury room with all of the exhibits admitted into evidence and with all of the verdict forms 2:30pm The Court allows the two alternates to remain on telephone standby 2:31pm Court in recess for Lunch break — Jurors admonished not to talk about the case until they are all in the jury room 01:30pm The jury resumes deliberations in the jury room 04:05pm The Court takes the bench outside the presence of the jury regarding a possible replacement for one of the twelve jurors 04:25pm Jury returns to court with a verdict for the Plaintiff on both questions on the Special Verdict 04:27pm Jurors are polled at the request of the Defendant On the first question 11-1 for the Plaintiff and on the second question 11-1 for the Plaintiff 04:28pm The verdict(s) are recorded 04:29pm Jurors are given final instructions Admonishment is lifted. Jurors are thanked and excused 04:30pm All exhibits are returned to the preferring parties 04:31pm Court is adjourned Case Number: CUD-08-624838 Case Title: PATRICK HELLAND VS. RAY BRONNER -2- Date: April 28, 2008 Form: C01006