On October 31, 2011 a
MINUTES FOR JUN-11-2015 9:30 AM
was filed
involving a dispute between
Allstate Insurance Company,
Eseifan, Sanaa,
Eseifan, Yasmine,
Fua Cruz, Ida Christina,
Sanchez, Joel Enrique Andino,
and
Da Silva, Alan,
Does 1 To 10,
Does 1 To 20,
Does 1 To 50, Inclusive,
Gillespie, James,
Martinez, Pamela,
Mellegard, Hal,
Miller, Caroline,
Miller, Carolyn,
Olsen, Nick,
Reimers, Steven,
Sanchez, Joel,
Sanchez, Joel Enrique Andino,
San Francisco Independent Taxi Association,
San Francisco Independent Taxi Association, A,
Silva, Alan,
Taxi Equipment Leasing Llc,
Taxi Equipment Leasing Llc, A Limited Liability,
Taxi Property Company, Inc.,
Wiener, Richard,
Wolley, Llc,
Yellow Cab Cooperative, Inc.,
Yellow Cab Coopoerative, Inc A Corporation,
for civil
in the District Court of San Francisco County.
Preview
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
MINUTES
Thursday, June 11, 2015
IDA CHRISTINA FUA CRUZ
PLAINTIFF
VS.
JOEL ENRIQUE ANDINO SANCHEZ
et al
DEFENDANT
Present:
Judge: GARRETT L. WONG
Reporter: Mary Jackson, CSR 8688
209-993-8329; mjacksoncsr@gmail.com
Appearing for Plaintiff (s):
Todd P. Emanuel, Esq.
Deirdre O'Reilly Marblestone, Esq.
EMANUEL LAW GROUP
702 Marshall Street, Suite 400
Redwood City, CA 94063
650-369-8900
todd@teinjurylaw.com
Attys for Plaintiff Ida Cristina Cruz Fua
D. Douglas Shureen, Esq.
McMILLAN & SHUREEN LLP
50 Santa Rosa Avenue, Suite 200
Santa Rosa, CA 95404
707-525-5400
doug.shureen@memillianshureen.com
Atty for Defendant and Cross-Complainant Joel
Enrique Andino Sanchez
Department: 608
Lead Case Number: CGC-11-515542
(Consolidated with case nos.
529705 and 519794)
Nature of Cause: JURY TRIAL
Personal Injury — Vehicle Related
Trial Day - 23 —- Defendants’ Case
Jury Day — 17
Clerk: VICKI MACK
Bailiff: None
Appearing for Defendant(s)
Colin C. Munro, Esq.
Christopher J. Weber, Esq.
CARLSON, CALLADINE & PETERSON LLP
353 Sacramento Street, 16" Floor
San Francisco, CA 94111
415-391-3911
eweber@ccplaw.com
Attys for Defendants Taxi Equipment Leasing
LLC, and Yellow Cab Cooperative, Inc.
Robert S. Aaron, Esq. —present in the gallery
AARON & WILSON, LLP
150 Post Street, Suite 400
San Francisco, CA 94108
415-438-7800
rsaaron@aaron-wilson.com
Atty for Defendants/Cross-Defendants Taxi
Property Co., Inc.; Wolley, LLC; James Gillespie:
Hal Mellegard: Nick Olsen; Pamela Martinez;
Richard Wiener and Steven Reimers
Case Number: CGC-11-515542
Case Title: IDA CHRISTINA FUA CRUZ VS. JOEL ENRIQUE ANDINO SANCHEZ et al
Date: June 11, 2015
Form: C0100009:46am The trial continues from Tuesday, June 9, 2015. The court, counsel as indicated above,
all twelve jurors and three alternates are present in open court, on the record.
09:47am ALAN SHONKOFF, Ph.D. is called to testify on behalf of defendants Taxi
Equipment Leasing LLC, and Yellow Cab Cooperative, Inc. The clerk administers the oath.
Direct examination by Mr. Munro commences.
10:41am The court declares a recess.
11:05am All are present in open court, on the record. Direct examination of ALAN
SHONKOFF, Ph.D. by Mr. Munro resumes.
11:48am The court declares a lunch recess to accommodate a lunch commitment of a juror
Outside the presence of the jury and off the record, the court and counsel confer regarding trial
and deliberation scheduling and other matters.
12:05pm Counsel exit the courtroom.
01:41pm All are present in open court, on the record. Direct examination of ALAN
SHONKOFF, Ph.D. by Mr. Munro resumes.
01:46pm Cross examination of ALAN SHONKOFF, Ph.D. by Mr. Emanuel commences.
02:38pm Cross examination of ALAN SHONKOFF, Ph.D. by Mr. Shureen, counsel for
defendant and cross-complainant Joel Enrique Andino Sanchez, commences.
02:39pm Examination concludes. The witness, ALAN SHONKOFF, Ph.D.., is excused.
02:40pm DIANA BUBANJA, P.T. is called to testify on behalf of defendants Taxi Equipment
Leasing LLC, and Yellow Cab Cooperative, Inc. The clerk administers the oath. Direct
examination by Mr. Weber commences
Defendant identifies the following exhibit
Exh. no. 384 Diana Bubanja, P.T. Powerpoint ID/EVID
Viewed by Jury
03:07pm The court declares a recess at the request of Mr. Weber. Before court resumes, a
sidebar is held regarding juror scheduling requests.
03:34pm All are present in open court, on the record. Direct examination of DIANA
BUBANJA, P.T. by Mr. Weber resumes.
Case Number: CGC-11-515542
Case Title: IDA CHRISTINA FUA CRUZ VS. JOEL ENRIQUE ANDINO SANCHEZ et al
-2- Date: June 11, 2015
Form: C0100003:56pm Cross examination of DIANA BUBANJA, P.T. by Ms. Marblestone commences.
04:24pm Redirect examination of DIANA BUBANJA, P.T. by Mr. Weber commences
04:26pm Examination concludes. The witness, DIANA BUBANJA, P.T., is excused. The
court admonishes the jurors and orders each to return on Monday, June 15, 2015 at 9:30am.
The court requests that juror no. 3, Timothy Welsh, remain in the courtroom. Outside the
presence of the jury, the court acknowledges the juror’s request to be released at noon on June
18, 2015. Due to trial scheduling considerations, the court cannot accommodate the juror’s
request. The juror exits the courtroom.
04:32pm Outside the presence of the jury and off the record, the court and counsel confer
regarding scheduling.
The trial is continued to Monday, June 15, 2015 at 9:30am in Dept. 608.
Case Number: CGC-11-515542
Case Title: IDA CHRISTINA FUA CRUZ VS. JOEL ENRIQUE ANDINO SANCHEZ et al
-3- Date: June 11, 2015
Form: C01000
Preview
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO MINUTES Thursday, June 11, 2015 IDA CHRISTINA FUA CRUZ PLAINTIFF VS. JOEL ENRIQUE ANDINO SANCHEZ et al DEFENDANT Present: Judge: GARRETT L. WONG Reporter: Mary Jackson, CSR 8688 209-993-8329; mjacksoncsr@gmail.com Appearing for Plaintiff (s): Todd P. Emanuel, Esq. Deirdre O'Reilly Marblestone, Esq. EMANUEL LAW GROUP 702 Marshall Street, Suite 400 Redwood City, CA 94063 650-369-8900 todd@teinjurylaw.com Attys for Plaintiff Ida Cristina Cruz Fua D. Douglas Shureen, Esq. McMILLAN & SHUREEN LLP 50 Santa Rosa Avenue, Suite 200 Santa Rosa, CA 95404 707-525-5400 doug.shureen@memillianshureen.com Atty for Defendant and Cross-Complainant Joel Enrique Andino Sanchez Department: 608 Lead Case Number: CGC-11-515542 (Consolidated with case nos. 529705 and 519794) Nature of Cause: JURY TRIAL Personal Injury — Vehicle Related Trial Day - 23 —- Defendants’ Case Jury Day — 17 Clerk: VICKI MACK Bailiff: None Appearing for Defendant(s) Colin C. Munro, Esq. Christopher J. Weber, Esq. CARLSON, CALLADINE & PETERSON LLP 353 Sacramento Street, 16" Floor San Francisco, CA 94111 415-391-3911 eweber@ccplaw.com Attys for Defendants Taxi Equipment Leasing LLC, and Yellow Cab Cooperative, Inc. Robert S. Aaron, Esq. —present in the gallery AARON & WILSON, LLP 150 Post Street, Suite 400 San Francisco, CA 94108 415-438-7800 rsaaron@aaron-wilson.com Atty for Defendants/Cross-Defendants Taxi Property Co., Inc.; Wolley, LLC; James Gillespie: Hal Mellegard: Nick Olsen; Pamela Martinez; Richard Wiener and Steven Reimers Case Number: CGC-11-515542 Case Title: IDA CHRISTINA FUA CRUZ VS. JOEL ENRIQUE ANDINO SANCHEZ et al Date: June 11, 2015 Form: C0100009:46am The trial continues from Tuesday, June 9, 2015. The court, counsel as indicated above, all twelve jurors and three alternates are present in open court, on the record. 09:47am ALAN SHONKOFF, Ph.D. is called to testify on behalf of defendants Taxi Equipment Leasing LLC, and Yellow Cab Cooperative, Inc. The clerk administers the oath. Direct examination by Mr. Munro commences. 10:41am The court declares a recess. 11:05am All are present in open court, on the record. Direct examination of ALAN SHONKOFF, Ph.D. by Mr. Munro resumes. 11:48am The court declares a lunch recess to accommodate a lunch commitment of a juror Outside the presence of the jury and off the record, the court and counsel confer regarding trial and deliberation scheduling and other matters. 12:05pm Counsel exit the courtroom. 01:41pm All are present in open court, on the record. Direct examination of ALAN SHONKOFF, Ph.D. by Mr. Munro resumes. 01:46pm Cross examination of ALAN SHONKOFF, Ph.D. by Mr. Emanuel commences. 02:38pm Cross examination of ALAN SHONKOFF, Ph.D. by Mr. Shureen, counsel for defendant and cross-complainant Joel Enrique Andino Sanchez, commences. 02:39pm Examination concludes. The witness, ALAN SHONKOFF, Ph.D.., is excused. 02:40pm DIANA BUBANJA, P.T. is called to testify on behalf of defendants Taxi Equipment Leasing LLC, and Yellow Cab Cooperative, Inc. The clerk administers the oath. Direct examination by Mr. Weber commences Defendant identifies the following exhibit Exh. no. 384 Diana Bubanja, P.T. Powerpoint ID/EVID Viewed by Jury 03:07pm The court declares a recess at the request of Mr. Weber. Before court resumes, a sidebar is held regarding juror scheduling requests. 03:34pm All are present in open court, on the record. Direct examination of DIANA BUBANJA, P.T. by Mr. Weber resumes. Case Number: CGC-11-515542 Case Title: IDA CHRISTINA FUA CRUZ VS. JOEL ENRIQUE ANDINO SANCHEZ et al -2- Date: June 11, 2015 Form: C0100003:56pm Cross examination of DIANA BUBANJA, P.T. by Ms. Marblestone commences. 04:24pm Redirect examination of DIANA BUBANJA, P.T. by Mr. Weber commences 04:26pm Examination concludes. The witness, DIANA BUBANJA, P.T., is excused. The court admonishes the jurors and orders each to return on Monday, June 15, 2015 at 9:30am. The court requests that juror no. 3, Timothy Welsh, remain in the courtroom. Outside the presence of the jury, the court acknowledges the juror’s request to be released at noon on June 18, 2015. Due to trial scheduling considerations, the court cannot accommodate the juror’s request. The juror exits the courtroom. 04:32pm Outside the presence of the jury and off the record, the court and counsel confer regarding scheduling. The trial is continued to Monday, June 15, 2015 at 9:30am in Dept. 608. Case Number: CGC-11-515542 Case Title: IDA CHRISTINA FUA CRUZ VS. JOEL ENRIQUE ANDINO SANCHEZ et al -3- Date: June 11, 2015 Form: C01000