Motion-Secondary: CHARLES TOBEY VS. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B*P) AS REFLECTED ON EXHIBITS et al

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                cee DOD A ee BH

YR Be YY Bw NR NY KR DP Be SB ee ee ee ee
SAA eh BF BN = SF OC HB HW DH A RB WBN & S

Douglas G. Wah, Esq. SBN 64692
Michael R. Roberts, Esq. SBN 258769
Foley & Mansfield P.L.L.P.

1111 Broadway, 10th Floor

Oakland, California 94607
Telephone: (510) 590-9500

Facsimile: (510) 590-9595

Attorneys for Defendant
FLUOR CORPORATION

ELECTRONICALLY
FILED

Superior Court of California,
County of San Francisco

JAN 22 2010
GORDON PARK-LI, Clerk
BY: JUDITH NUNEZ
Deputy Clerk

SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA

COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

CHARLES TOBEY,
Plaintiff,

VS.

ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (B¢P),

Defendants.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

T, Michael R. Roberts, declare as follows:

Case No. CGC-07-274226
“Asbestos-Related Case”

DECLARATION OF MICHAEL R. ROBERTS
IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT FLUOR
CORPORATION’S MOTION FOR
SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR, IN THE
ALTERNATIVE, SUMMARY
ADJUDICATION

Date: April 8, 2010
Time: 9:30 a.m

Dept.: 220

Judge: Hon. Harold Kahn

Complaint Filed: June 5, 2007
Trial Date: May 10, 2010

1. T am an attorney at law, duly licensed to practice before all the courts of the State of

California, and am an attorney at the firm of Foley & Mansfield, the attorneys of record for Defendant

FLUOR CORPORATION (hereinafter “Fluor’), in this action. I have personal knowledge of the

matters stated herein and, if called upon, would and could competently testify thereto.

2. Attached hereto as Exhibit A is a true and correct copy of Plaintiff's Personal Injury

Complaint, filed June 5, 2007.

3. Attached hereto as Exhibit B is a true and correct copy of Fluor’s Special Discovery

Requests, dated December 22, 2008.

DECLARATION OF MICHAEL R. ROBERTS IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT FLUOR CORPORATION'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, SUMMARY ADJUDICATIONcee DOD A ee BH

YR Be YY Bw NR NY KR DP Be SB ee ee ee ee
SAA eh BF BN = SF OC HB HW DH A RB WBN & S

4, Attached hereto as Exhibit C is a true and correct copy of Plaintiffs’ Response to Fluor’s
Special Discovery, dated January 23, 2009.

5. Plaintiff was deposed over five days on February 10-12, 2009 and April 8-9, 2009.
Attached hereto as Exhibit D is a true and correct copy of relevant excerpts from Plaintiff's Deposition
Testimony, Volume V.

6. Robert Ross gave testimony in this case on January 19, 2010. Plaintiff did not identify
Mr, Ross as a witness against Fluor in his Response to Fluor’s Specially Prepared Interrogatories, and, at
his deposition, Plaintiff's counsel stipulated that Mr. Ross would not be offered as a witness against
Fluor.

7. Phillip Talley gave testimony in this case on August 18-19, 2009, Attached hereto as
Exhibit E is a true and correct copy of relevant excerpts from Mr. Talley’s Deposition Testimony,
Volumes I and II.

8. John Minster gave testimony in this case on September 9, 2009, Attached hereto as
Exhibit F is a true and correct copy of relevant excerpts from Mr. Minster’s Deposition Testimony.

9. John Minster gave testimony in a prior asbestos-related case — Shirley McClure v.
Asbestos Defendants (SFSC 407408) — on June 5-6, 2003 and July 7-8, 2003. Attached hereto as
Exhibit G is a true and correct copy of relevant excerpts from Mr. Minster’s Prior Deposition
Testimony, Volume IL.

10. Attached hereto as Exhibit H is a true and correct copy of the Declaration of Howard
Spielman.

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is

true and correct. Executed on January 22, 2010, at Oakland, California.

iL

Michael Roberts 4

2
DECLARATION OF MICHAEL R. ROBERTS IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT FLUOR CORPORATION'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, SUMMARY ADJUDICATIONsd EXHIBITASUM-LUS

. SUMMONS FOR COURT USE ONLY
(CITATION JUDICIAL) (S010 PARA USO DELACORTE)
NOTICE TO DEFENDANT: : :
(AVISO AL DEMANDADO): :

ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (8P)
As Reflected on Exhibits B, B-1, C, H, I; and OOES 1-850,
and SEE ATTACHED LIST. .

YOU.ARE BEING SUED BY PLAINTIFF:
(LO ESTA DEMANDANDO EL DEMANDANTE);

CHARLES TOBEY : .

‘You have 30 CALENDAR DAYS after this summons and legal papers.are served on you to.file a written response at this court and have a
copy served-on the plaintiff. A letter of phane call will not protect you. Your written response must be In, proper fegal form.tf you want the
court to hear your. case. There may be.a court form that you can use for your response, You can find these court forms and more-
information at tha Califomla Courts Onfine Self-Help Center {www.courtinfo.ca.goviselihelp), your county taw library, or the courthouse
nearest you. Ifyou cannot pay the filing fea, ask the court clark fora fea waiver form. If you do not file. your response on time, you may

Jose the casa by default, and your wages, money, and property may be taken without further waming from the court.

‘There are other logat requirements. You may want to call_an attorney: right away. If you do ngt know an attormey, you may want to call an
attomey referral service. If you cannat afford an attorney, you may be eligible for free tegal services from a nonprofit legal services
program. You can locate. these nonprofit groups at te Callfom|a Legal Sorvices. Web site (www.lawhelpcalifarnia.org), the Catifornia
Courts Onling Self-Help Canter {www,courtinfo,ca.gov/satfhalp), or by contacting your local court or county bar assoclation,

Trene. 30 DIAS DE CALENDARIO después de que le. entrequen esta cltacién y papeles legales para presentar una respuesta por.escrito
en esta carta y hacer que se entregue una copla al demandante. Una carta 9 una llamada telefénica no fo protegen. Su respuesta por
aserita tlene que estar an formato legal coirecto si desea que procesen su casa en la corte. Es posible que haya un formularto quo usted
pueda usar paras respuesta. Puede encontrar estos formularfos do fa corte y ms Infomiacién en ed Centra de Ayuda de Jas Cortes do
California (www.courtinfo.ca.gov/selihelp/espancl), en ia biblioteca de layes.de su condado a en la corta que fe quede.mas corca. Sino
puede pagar ja cuota de prasentacién, pida af socrotario da ta.corte que le. dé wn formularta de exencién de pago. de cuotas. Sino presents
‘Su respuesta a tiempo, puede pander of casa por incumplimiento y la corte te podré quitar su suefda, dinero y blenes sin mas advertencia,

Hay otros requisitos legales. Es recomendable que ilamea un abogads Inmediatamente. Sno conoce a un aboyada, puede Hlamara un
servicia de remisién a abogadas. Sino puede payar.a urn abogsdo, as posible que cumpla con las requisitos para obtener servicios
Jegales gratuitos de un programa de servicios legates sin fines.dalucro. Puede encontrer estos grupas sin fines.de tucro en el sitio web da

| California Legal Services, (wwwlawhelpeatifornia.org), en el Centra de Ayuda de las Cortes de Califomia, ° .
(www. couttinfo.ca.gow/selfhelp/espanal) o poniéndasa on contacté con Ja corte o ef colegio da abogadas locales.

The name-and address of he court ‘ . . oe ee
El nombre y direcci6n deta corte. es): . .

CON ERANCISCO COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT | peSetee 07274226
400 MeAllistor Streat .

San Francisca, CA 94102

The name, adcress, and telaphone number of plaintiff's attorney, or plaintiff without an attomey, is:
(Et nombre, la direccién de teléfona del abogado del derandante, o del demandante que no tien abagado,. es)
DAVID R. DONADIO, ESQ., STATE BAR NO. 154436 vee

BRAYTONS PURCELL LLP :

222 Rush Landing Road, -Novato, CA 94948-6189 FUCA Paak ay

DATE: .-{ Clerk, b ISTINAE. BAUTISTA _ Depul
Fecha). wUN 5 200%, : Geomen ee

(Far proof of service of this summons, use Proof of Service of Summons (form POS~016).,
{Para prueba de entrega de esta ciation use ef tormulario Proof of Service of Summons, (POS-070)).
NOTICE TO PERSON SERVED: You are served

SEA ~~ 14. Ces am individual defendant. . ~:
2, Kd as the person sued under the fictitious name of (specify): MOE a ‘S Bices
3. (Dl on behatt of (apecitys: Fiver Corpo ono’

under 2G cop 418.10 (corporation) [7] cop 446.60(minor)
a COP 415.20 (defunct corporation) Cece 416.70 (conservatee}

CCP 416.49 (association of partnership} Oo CCP 416.90 (authorized person)

2 Oo other (specify): .

* 4. id by personal delivery on (date): .
Fa RESEL OE aOR OR COR RHE S
dalleat Count of cation SUMMONS ° :

SLM-100 fRev.danuary 1, 2004)° BRAYTON@PURCELL LEP
‘ATTORNEYS AT LAW
222 RUSH LANDING ROAD
P.O, BOK 6169
NOVATO, CALIFORNIA 94968-8169
(ANS) 29661555

ALLIS-CHALMERS. CORPORATION PRODUCT LIABILITY TRUST.

ASBESTOS CORPORATION LIMITED -
BUCYRUS INTERNATIONAL, INC.
BECHTEI. CORPORATION (DE)
SEQUOIA VENTURES, INC.

‘THOMAS DEE ENGINEERING CO., INC.
FOSTER WHEELERLLC
GARLOCK SEALING TECHNOLOGIES, LLC
GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY
HANSON PERMANENTE CEMENT, INC.
KAISER GYPSUM COMPANY, INC, >
LAMONS GASKET COMPANY.
METALCLAD INSULATION. CORPORATION
OWENS-ILLINOIS, INC.
PARKER-HANNIFIN CORPORATION
PLANT INSULATION COMPANY
QUINTEC INDUSTRIES, INC.
RAPID-AMERICAN CORPORATION
RILEY POWER INC. te
UNIROYAL KOLDING, INC.
VIACOM, INC. ©

WALDRON, DUFFY, INC.

ZURN INDUSTRIES, INC.

WESTERN MacARTHUR COMPANY
MacARTHUR COMPANY =~

WESTERN ASBESTOS COMPANY
HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL, INC.
DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION
FORD MOTOR COMPANY

GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION
GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION
CSK AUTG, INC.

INGERSOLL-RAND COMPANY,
GOODLOE E. MOORE INC.

SCOTT CO. OF CALIFORNIA ~
CONSOLIDATED INSULATION, INC.
OSCAR E. ERICKSON, INC,
HOPEMAN BROTHERS, INC.

JT. THORPE & SON, INC,
ABHI-CROCKETT, INC.

THE DOW CHEMICAL COMPANY .
E.L DU PONT DE NEMOURS AND COMPANY

PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY.

SHELL OL COMPANY

. CHEVRON PRODUCTS COMPANY

UNOCAL ‘CORPORATION
DILLINGHAM CONSTRUCTION, N.A., INC. _
ALBAY: CONSTRUCTION COMPANYOW BW WA WwW BWR me

SANTA FE BRAUN, INC. AS SUCCESSOR-IN-INTEREST TO C.F. BRAUN, INC.
METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY

GATKE CORPORATION ~

AMERICAN CONFERENCE OF GOVERNMENTAL INDUSTRIAL HYGIENISTS, INC.
UNDERWRITERS LABORATORIES, INC.

PNEUMO ABEX LLC

and DOES 1-850,

Defendants.

Charles Tobey vs, Asbestos Defendants {BP}
San Francisco Superior CourtCASE NUMBER: CGC-07-274226 CHARLES TOBEY VS. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (8*P} AS :
we to NOTICE TO PLAINTIFF

A Case Management Conference is set for .
DATE: Juseta-agge. Oox <1 FE
TIME: ~~ 1:30PM

PLACE: . Department 206
400 McAllister Street
San Francisco, CA 94102-3680

All parties must appear and sormply with Local Rule 3.3 and 3.4.

CRC 212 (g){1)- requires the filing and service of a case management statement

form CM-110 no later than 15 days before.the Gase management conference.

Plaintiff must serve a copy of this notice upon each party to this action with the.
_ summons and complaint. Proof of service subsequently filed with this court shall
so state. ©

! [DEFENDANTS: Attending the Case Management Conference does not take the
place of filing a written response to the complaint, You must file a written
Tesponse with the court within the time limit required by law. See Summons.}

Superior Court Alternative Dispute Resolution Coordinator
400 McAllister Street, Room 103

San Francisco, CA 94102

(415) 551-3876CM-010.

| ATTORNEY OR PARTY WITHOUT ATTORNEY (ame, slate bar mumber, ant addeesy): 7 FOR COURT USE ONLY

DAVID RB. DONADIO, ESO., STATE BAR NO. 154436 - vey
BRAYTONPURCELL LLP . E
222 Rush Landing Road NDORSED
Novato, California 94948-6169 ‘Sen Fy

TELEPHOMEND: (415) 898.1555 . ~ FAXMOs (415) 298-1247 unlace Comms dD
ATTORNEY FOR (NAME) Plaintiffs) d RPDF Chowarg
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO UN 6” 2007

\STREETADDRESS: 400 McAllister Street Oo Gore

MAILING ADDRESS: on ROON PARK.
‘4

CITY AND ZIP CODE: San Francisco, CA 94102 °~ | . . ht Clarke
BRANCH NAME: ho.
CASE NAME; ° ° " . ~ cs

CHARLES TOBEY vs. ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (BP)

CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Complex Case Designation ~ : (geEs 07 274226

52 .
Bl untimitea 1 Limited O Counter Cj Joinder -
(Amouet (Amount Fited with first apy ce by defendant fp 2un0e:
demanded lemanded is (Cal, Rules of Court, rule (811),
exceeds $25,000) $25,000 or less) Derr

Al five (5) items below must be completed (see instructions on page 2).

1, Check.one box below of the case type that best describes this case:

Auto Tort . Contract Provisionally Complex Civil Litigation
JAuto(22) [2 Breach of ennrracttwarranty (06) ge Rules of Coun, rules 1800-1812)
Uninsured mataris (46) Collections (09) . AncitrustFTeade regilanion (03)

Other PIPD/WD (Personal Injury/Property LI} tasurance-coverage (13) . C1 construction defect (10)

Damage/Wronegful Death} Tort Daher contract (32) CO massion (40)

Asbestos (04) Real Property ‘ ‘Scourities litigation (23)

Product Liability (24) Emineat demaiatnverse . Environmental / Toxic tort (20)

Medicat malpractice (45) condemnation (14) Insurance coverage claims arising from the

Other PUPDAYD (233. > Oo Wrongfut eviction (33) . | tabave listed provisionally complex case rypes (41)
NonmPUPDYWD (Other) Tort LD other reat property (25) Enforcement of Judgment

Business tost/un fair business practice (07) Unlawful Detainer . MF Enforcement ofjudgent (20)

Civil eights (08) . Commercial 1) Miscellaneaus Civi) Complaint

Octamation{i3) LD resideatist 32” RICOQ7)

Fraud (16) > SS . Drugs (38) ~ . Diher complaint (not specified above} (42)

Intellectual property (19) Judicial Review - ~ Miscellaneaus Civil Petition

Professional neyligence(25} ° Asset forfeiture (05) * LL) eariocrship and corporate governance (21)

Dither non-PYPDAWD tort (35) Petition re: arbitratioa award (11) Other petition (act speeyfied above} (43).
Employment. a ‘Writ of mandate {02} .

‘Wrongful termination 36) . Other jodiciat review (39)

‘Other emptoymeat (15)

2. This case B is a is not complex under. rute 1800-of the California Rules.of Court. If the.case is complex, mark the factors
requiring exceptional judicial management

a. CO Large number of separately represented parties... 3. CD Large number of wimesses :

b. CF Extensive motion practice raising difficult or novel * ¢. Cc} Coordination and related actions pending in one or more courts
issues that will be lime-consuming:to resolve in other counties, states oF countries, or in:a federal court

C1 subscantial amount of documentary evidence £. C7 substantial post-judgment judicial supervision

e

. ‘Type of remedies'saught (check all what apply):

2. BS stovetary ». CJ Nonmonetary: declaratory or injunctive riot °c, Sl punitive
4, Number of causes of action (specify): 7

‘5. This case Lis, isnot a class action suit : On
Date: . a
nate: |S % y

avid R. Donadio.
CIVPE OR PRN NAMED (SIGHATURE OF PARTY On ATTORNEY FOR PARED),
Plaingiff mast fle thi shoot with the ft Peg. filed in the acti Sr orveee ( 5 cla filed under.the Prob:
~ Plainnif? must file shis cover shect with the first ited in the action or ling (except small claims cases or cases fited under.the Probate,
Family, or Welfare and institutions Code}. (Cal. Rules of Coust, rule 201.3.) ‘Satture wd fic way result in sonetions, +
+ File this cover stieet int addition tc any cover sheet required by local court sule-
+ Ethis case is complex under rule 1800 et seq, of the California Rules of Court, you must serve a copy of this coversheet on all other parties to

the action or proceeding.
+ Unies this is a complex case, this caver sheet shall be used for statistical purposes only. Page Lot
Form Adopted foc Mandatory Use CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET

Iie Cmts Caer . . ,

5 Behr Sep LOD]227 RUSH LANDING ROAD.
_ POBOXélév
NOVATO, CALIFORNIA 94948-6169
(41S) E98-1858

DRAYTON®PURCELL LLP
ATTORNEYS AT LAW °

DAVID &. DONADIO, ESQ,, S.B. #154436.

ERIC C SOLOMON, itis #T19131 . ENDORSzp
TON? PURCE:
: | Aromas at Law : ee Fame Seine cou
222 Rush Landing Road
P.O. Box 6169 8 JUN 6 2007. - hy

Novato, California 94948-6 Han oma
(a5) 808 wags ‘hs ON PARK.L, tec

Attorneys for Plaintiff : JUN 19 2008 a °

me, _THIS CASE Is sup
ECT Tr
~ DEPARTMENT 206 rune HE ECTRON C FILIN
SUPERIOR CouRT OF CATHREKANT TO AvEN CD 6.0) "en
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

CHARLES TOBEY, } RoVEENO7 274226

. Plaintiff, )
vs. } COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY -

5 . ASBESTO:

ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS esp), )
As Reflected on Exhibits B, B-1, C, H, }
I, and DOES 1-8500; and SEE
ATTACHED LIST. )

“1. Plaintiff CHARLES TOBEY was bom huly #5, 1940,

2, The ©BraytouPureel Master Complaint for Personal Injury Tand Loss of
Consortium|- Asbestos (hereinafter "Master Complaint") was filed January 2, 2003, in San
Francisco Superior Court. A copy of the Master Complaint and General Order No. 55 may be
obtained upon request from BraytonPurcell, and designated portions. ‘of the ‘Master Complaint.
are incorporated by reference herein pursuant to the authority conferred by General Order No. 55.
Plaintiff's claims are as set forth in said Master Complaint against defendatits herein as follows:
ut :
iit
if

ris itr . i
| COMPLAUNT FOR PERSONAL INJURY ~ASHESTOS‘es
3
a
a
3
Go
&
5
=
+
z
S
&
&
2
3B

3
Z
a
2
8
E
=

3
9
a
6
&
&
a
z
§
2

g

g
2
$
Z
g

NovaTo,

ALLIS-CHALMERS CORPORATION PRODUCT LIABILITY TRUST
ASBESTOS CORPORATION LIMITED

BUCYRUS INTERNATIONAL, INC.

BECHTEL CORPORATION (DE}

SEQUOIA VENTURES, INC.

THOMAS DEE ENGINEERING CO,, INC.

~ FOSTER WHEELER LLC

GARLOCK SEALING TECHNOLOGIES, LLC
GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY
HANSON PERMANENTE CEMENT, INC.
KAISER GYPSUM COMPANY, INC.
LAMONS GASKET. COMPANY.
METALCLAD INSULATION CORPORATION
OWENS-ILLINOIS, INC.”
PARKER-HANNIFIN CORPORATION
PLANT INSULATION COMPANY
QUINTEG INDUSTRIES, INC.
RAPID-AMERICAN CORPORATION
RILEY PGWER INC.

HNIROYAL HOLDING, INC.

VIACOM, INC.

WALDRON, DUFFY, INC.

ZURN INDUSTRIES, INC,

WESTERN MacARTHUR GOMPANY
MacARTHUR COMPANY ~~ >
WESTERN ASBESTOS COMPANY
HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL, INC.
DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION
FORD MOTOR COMPANY

GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION
GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION
SK AUTO, INC,

INGERSOLL-RAND COMPANY -
GOODLOE B. MOORE INC.

SCOTT.CO. OF CALIFORNIA .
CONSOLIDATED INSULATION, INC.
OSCAR E. ERICKSON, INC, -
{1OPEMAN BROTHERS, INC.

1.7. THORPE & SON, INC.
ABHI-CROCKETT, INC.

THE DOW CHEMICAL COMPANY

E,1. DUPONT DE.NEMOURS AND COMPANY
PACIPIC GAS.& ELECTRIC COMPANY
SHELL Of. COMPANY

CHEVRON PRODUCTS COMPANY
UNOCAL CORPORATION
DILLINGHAM CONSTRUCTION, N.A.,INC.
‘ALBAY CONSTRUCTION COMPANY.© ON

|

SANTA FE BRAUN, INC. AS SUCCESSOR-IN-INTEREST TO C.’ P BRAUN, INC.
METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY

GATKE CORPORATION

AMERICAN CONFERENCE OF GOVERNMENTAL INDUSTRIAL HYGIENISTS, ANG,
UNDERWRITERS LABORATORIES, INC,

PNEUMO ABEX LLC

and DOES 1-8560,

Defendants,

Charles Taber ve, Asbestos Defendans (BP)

‘San Francisca Superior CourtCause of Action : bb
First (Negligence) oO
Second (Strict Liability)

Third (False
Representation)

Fourth (Loss of
Consortium)

Fifth (Premises Owner/
Contractor Liability)

Sixth, Seventh, Eighth oO
(Unseaworthiness, Negligence.
[Yones Act],Maintenance and Cure)

Ninth (Loagshore and Harbor Workers
_ Compensation Act [LHWCA])

Tenth, Eleventh (F.E.L.A.)

Twelfth, Thirtecnth (Respiratot
Safety Devices) *

Fourteenth, Fifteenth "
(Brake Shoe Grinding)

Sixteenth (Concert of Action)

O @ aah

" Seventeenth, Eighteenth (Fraud, Deceit/Negligent
Misrepresentation/Concealment}

Nineteenth (Frand/Deceit/
Intentional Misrepresentation)

Twentieth (Fraud/Deceit - Kent)

*and their alternate entities as set forth in the Master Complaint or on any Exhibit.

DEFENDANTS" ON EXHIBITS:

F

Oo

&

QO
oO.
0

EL

I

Oo

-

Oo
oar

a

oO

dkOe NW Dh RB iw IN

sme oe
N=

13

28

3. ° _ Plaintiff's asbestos-related injury, date of diagnosis, employment status, and
history of exposure to asbestos are.as-stated.on Exhibit A. . :

4. (@) "Exposed persons" in paragraphs 21, 68 and 69 of the Master Complaint
include plaintiff CHARLES TOBEY herein and plaintiffs father, Merlin Tobey. _

5. Plaintiff's claims against defendant VIACOM, INC. (successor by merger fo
CBS CORPORATION. which is successor-in-interest to WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC
CORPORATION) exclude military and federal government jobsites,

Dated: 6l sl > K .» BRAYTON“PURCELL LLP

“David R-Donadio
Attorneys for Plaintiff

= . : . . ‘ . 3
COSPEANIOE Paxson aL RUURY ASBESTOSEXHIBIT A_ EXHIBIT A

Plaintiff's exposure to asbestes and asbestos-containing products occurred at various

locations both inside and outside the State of California, including but not limited to:

Employer
Plant Asbestos

Plant Asbestos

Plant Asbestos

Maritime Union

“y} Plant Asbestos

Plant Asbestos

Western Asbestos Company

Plant Asbestos

Plant Asbestos .

Western Asbestos Company

Western Asbestos

Western Asbestos

tt

~. Sierra Pacific Power Co.,

Location of
Exposure -

Shell Oil,
Martinez, CA

California State University
Hayward, CA

Bank of America
‘Van Ness Branch
San Francisco, CA

Maritime Union Hall
San Francisco, CA

UC Berkeley
Berkeley, CA

Tracy Clark Power Station,
Sparks, Nevada

Various Ships at

Hunters Point Naval.
Shipyard,

San Francisco, CA
GENERAL W.A. MANN
{AP-112) we
Chevron Standard Oil)
Richmond, CA

Fibreboard

* Antioch, CA

PG &B
Bureka, CA...

Shell Oil,
Martinez, CA

Bethlehem Steel,
Shipbuilding ~
San Francisco, CA

Job Title |

Insulator
(Apprentice).

Insulator

Insulator

(Apprentice)

Insulator
(apprentice)

Insulator
(apprentice)

* Insulator

(apprentice)

Insulator
(apprentice) .

Insulator ~~

_ (Apprentice)
. Insulator

(Apprentice)

Insulator
(Journeyman)

insulator
(Journeyman)

Insulator
Goumeyman)

Exposure

Dates _

W1958-3/1959

» -AL1959-8/1959
(Apprentice). .

8/1959-3/1960

1960
1960
5/1960-10/1960

1960-1961
(1 year)

1961.
1960-1961

1962-1964

~. 1965

1965

EXHIBIT.A

os ie 5
CORPCAINT FOR PERSONAL TNIURY 7ASOESTOSew PRA WP UY we

o

i

EXHIBIT A (cont'd.)

: . Location of Exposure
Employer . Exposure : Job Title .. Dates
Western Asbestos Company Dow Chemical Insulator 1968
Pittsburg, CA ..- Gourneyman)
Owens Coming Chevron Standard Gil) Insulator 1965
. Richmond, CA (Journeyman)
EI. Dupont de Nemoirs E.L Dupont de Nemoirs Insulator 1965-1966
. on Antioch, CA (Journeyman) .
Plant Asbestos : Bagle Picher | Insulator 1967
‘Lovelock Nevada . Gourneyman)
Owens Corning Various ships and {insulator 1968
. ’” submarines (Journeyman) (1-year)
Mare Island Naval
Vallejo, CA
‘THRESHER.
(SSN 596) :
Plant Asbestos . California & Hawaiian Insulator ~ 1968
Lugar . (Journeyman)
: - Crockett, CA. . .
Western Asbestos or Westen Union Oil . *~ Insulator - 1968 —
MacArthur Rodeo/Oleam, CA" Gourneyman)
Chromex Corporation ‘Chromex . : “Machinist 1969-1974
‘| Tobey’s Lounge Tobey’s Lounge Owner. - 1986-1993
Souix City, lowa Souix City, lowa : CS
PARA-OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE:

Ht Plaintiff's father worked as an insulator out.of Local 16, Plaintiff. shared home with his father

from 1948-1960. Plaintiff recalls father coming home from work wearing coveralls that were
covered with asbestos. Plaintiff currently contends he was exposed to asbestos'as a resuit of his
father’s employment. Plaintiff's irivestigation and discovery are continuing.

NON-OCCUPATION B;
Plaintiff recalls purchasing auto parts from the. following suppliers:

GRAND AUTO PARTS, Richmond California. Plaintiff recalls purchasing clutches, brakes
and mufflers during the years of 1956-1970, : :

FORD Dealership, Richmond California. Plaintiff recalls purchasing auto parts during the
years of 1956-3970. . . .

EXHIBIT A

seca sot 6
GONMPLAINT TOR PERSONAT INJURY 7 ASRESTOSwe LU DW Bw

10

EXHIBIT_A (conf'd.)

FORD Dealership, Sioux City, lowa. Plaintiff recalls purchasing brakes, rauilens and engine
parts during the years of 1976-1980; 1956-1970 and 1976-1987.

SEARS Department Store. Sioux City, Towa. Plaintiff recalls purchasing, brakes during the.
years 1976-1980. .

Plaintiff recalls performing the: following spain on the following specific vehicles.

1964 OLDSMOBLLE. Plaintiff recalls changing the original brakes on this vehicle in 1959 in
his driveway. Plaintiff was assisted by his fiend Tom Chamberlin,

1955 CHEVROLET COUPE acquired in 1965. Plaintiff recalls changing the xg brakes,
chitch and laciny the engine in his garage, Plaintiff recalls purchasing the replacement parts

from G) in Richmond, California, Plaintiff recalls purchasing B
CHEVROLET seplacerent parts. Plaintiff worked with Tom Chamberlin and Tray Courier on

this vehicle,
1974 CHEVROLET CORVETTE sce in 1976 or 1980. Plaintiff recalls changing the.
original brakes in his driveway i in 1979. Plaintiff recalls purchasing the replacement parts ftom |
SEARS. Plaintiff recalls p ing RAYBESTOS replacement parts. Plaintiff worked with
Geny Taque on this. vehicle.
Plaintiff's exposure to asbestos and asbestos-containing products caused severe and.

permanent injury to the plaintiff, including, but not limited to breathing difficulties, asbestosis, :
and/or other lung damage, and increased tisk and fear of developing mesothelioma, lung cancer
and various other cancers. Plaintiff was diagnosed with asbestosis and asbestos-related pleural’ :
disease on or about March 2007.

: Plaintiff’ retired from his last place of employment at regular Tetirement age. He has
therefore suffered no disability fom his asbestos~ related disease as "disability" is defined.in -

California Code of Civil Procedure § 340.2.

EXHIBIT A. |

Khiremonseedeaienepogs LZ
COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INTORY - ASBESTOS.EXHIBIT Bwoe NY A wR eR

aoe OR OR ee
Ro Bw NS Oo

|

DEFEND,

ALLIS-CHALMERS CORPORATION PRODUCT

LIABILITY TRUST
ASBESTOS CORPORATION LIMITED
BUCYRUS INTERNATIONAL, INC.
BECHTEL CORPORATION (DE)
SEQUOIA VENTURES, INC.
THOMAS DEE. ENGINEERING CO., INC.
FOSTER WHEELER LLC

GARLOCK SEALING TECHNOLOGIES, LLC

GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY

HANSON PERMANENTE CEMENT, INC.

KAISER GYPSUM COMPANY, INC.
LAMONS GASKET COMPANY

METALCLAD INSULATION CORPORATION

OWENS-ILLINOIS, INC.
PARKER-HANNIFIN CORPORATION
PLANT INSULATION COMPANY
QUINTEC INDUSTRIES, INC.

ASBESTOS CORPORATION LIMITED

BUCYRUS INTBRNATIONAL, INC.

FOSTER WHEELER LLC

GARLOCK SEALING
TECHNOLOGIES, LLC

SXHIBITB

RAPID-AMERICAN CORPORATION
RILEY POWER INC,

UNIROYAL HOLDING, INC.

VIACOM, INC.

WALDRON, DUFFY, INC.

ZURN INDUSTRIES, INC,

WESTERN. MacARTHUR COMPANY
MacARTHUR COMPANY

WESTERN ASBESTOS:COMPANY
HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL, INC.
DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION
FORD MOTOR COMPANY ©
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION
GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION
CSK AUTO, INC.

INGERSOLL-RAND COMPANY
GOODBLOE E. MOORE INC.

DOES [-800

ALTERNATE ENTITY
GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION

JBUCYRUS-ERIE

MARION POWER SHOVEL COMPANY, THE
OSGOOD COMPANY .

‘GENERAL EXCAVATOR COMPANY
FOSTER WHEELER CORPORATION

GARLOGCK, INC.

.COLTEC INDUSTRIES, INC.

FAIRBANKS-MORSE ~ .
FAIRBANKS MORSE ENGINES
BELMONT PACKING & RUBBER CO.
GARLOCK PACKING.CO.

U.S, GASKET CO.

GOODRICH CORPORATION

* ENPRO INDUSTRIES, INC.

GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY

MATTERN X-RAY
HOTPOINT ELECTRIC APPLIANCE COMPANY LIMITED

“TRUMBULL ELECTRIC MANUFACTURING COMPANY

GE INDUSTRIAL SYSTEMS:
CURTIS TURBINES. -
PARSONS TURBINES

. GENERAL ELECTRIC JEP ENGINES

i

i

LOS ior

EXHIBIT B

3
LAIN POR PERSONAL INURY - ASBESTO:LAMONS GASKET COMPANY

RILEY POWER, INC. ,

SEQUOIA VENTURES, INC.

UNIROYAL HOLDING, INC,

IAGOM, INC.

HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL, INC.

EXHIBIT B (cont'd.

ALTERNATE ENTITY

LAMONS METAL GASKET CO.
POWER ENGINEERING AND EQUIPMENT COMPANY, INC,
POWER ENGINEERING COMPANY

BABCOCK BORSIG POWER, INC,
DB RILEY, INC.

RILEY STOKER CORPORATION
BADENHAUSEN

UNION TRON WORKS

~ UNION IRON WORKS OF SPOKANE, WA
~ BECHTEL CORPORATION (DE)

UNIROYAL, INC.

CBS CORPORATION
WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC CORPORATION

" WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC AND

MANUFACTURING COMPANY

BLP. STURTEVANT ©

KPIX TELEVISION STATION
PARAMOUNT COMMUNICATIONS, INC.

HONEYWELL, INC. ~~
HONEYWELL CONTROLS
ALLIEDSIGNAL, INC.

» ALLIED-SIGNAL, INC.

THE BENDIX CORPORATION

BENDIX PRODUCTS AUTOMOTIVE DIVISION

BENDIX PRODUCTS DIVISION, BENDIX AVIATION CORP.
BENDIX HOME SYSTEMS:

ALLIED CORPORATION

ALLIED CHEMICAL CORPORATION

_ GENERAL CHEMICAL CORPORATION

FRAM

FRICTION MATERIALS OF LOS ANGELES
NORTH AMERICAN REFRACTORIES COMPANY
EM SECTOR HOLDINGS INC.

UNIVERSAL OLL PRODUCTS COMPANY
BOYLSTON CORPORATION

EHRHART & ASSOCIATES, INC.
EMRHART & ARTHUR, INC. .
GARRETT AIR RESEARCH CORP. .
STANLEY G. FLAGG & CO.
MERGENTHALER LINOTYPE COMPANY.
ELTRA CORPORATION

BUNKER RAMO-ELTRA-CORPORATION

_ EXHIBIT BZURN INDUSTRIES, INC.

FORD MOTOR COMPANY

GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION.

CSK AUTO, INC.

INGERSOLL-RAND COMPANY

MW

_ BLAW-KNOX:COMPANY

EXHIBIT B (cont'd.)
ALTERNATE ENTITY

ZURN INDUSTRIES, INC., ENERGY DIVISION
ERIE CITY ENERGY DIVISION

ERIE CITY IRON WORKS

ERIE CITY BOILERS

WILKINS-ZURN INDUSTRIES

BRITISH LEYLAND MOTORS, INC,
BRITISH MOTOR CORPORATION
JAGUAR CARS, INC.

TRIUMPH

LINCOLN CONTINENTAL

AUSTIN HEALEY

“NEW DEPARTURE
... CHEVROLET

AC, DELCO.CO. .

BUICK AUTOMOTIVE CORPORATION
CADILLAC

PONTIAC

LaSALLE

OLDSMOBILE

GM. GOODWRENCH

ROCHESTER PRODUCTS DIVISION
EUCLID ROAD MACHINERY CO.”
FRIDGLDAIRE (for exposure pre 4/9/1979)

KRAGEN AUTO SUPPLY CO.

NORTHERN AUTOMOTIVE CGRPORATION
CHECKER AUTO PARTS, INC,

TBRPC CORPORATION

PACCAR AUTOMOTIVE, INC.

GRAND AUTO, INC. ©

AL’S AND GRAND AUTO SUPPLY, INC.
SCHUCK’S AUTO SUPPLY

TOPPS AUTOMOTIVE,

TRAK AUTO PARTS

INGERSGLUL-DRESSER PUMP

DRESSER-RAND.CO. .

PACIFIC PUMP WORKS

FLOWSERVE CORPORATION

INGERSOLL ROCK ‘DRILL COMPANY

TERRY STEAM TURBINE CO.

RAND DRILL:-COMPANY -
RAND & WARING DRILL. AND COMPRESSOR COMPANY
INGERSOLL-SERGEANT

SCHLAGE LOCK COMPANY

VON DUPRIN

THE TORRINGTON COMPANY

EXHIBIT Bwe RD Hw ON oe

ALTERNATE ENTITY,

GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION CONVAIR
. . VULTEE AIRCRAFT INC, .
CONSOLIDATED VULTEE AIRCRAFT CORPORATION
ASBESTOS CORPORATION LIMITED

GOODLOE BE. MOORE INC GEMCO INSULATION,

EXHIBIT B

oS a
EGBCAING OK PERSONAL BURY ASBESTOSEXHIBIT B-1Lie

2
“4
4
5
6
7
8
9

10
i
12
B
14.
AS
16
W
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

}) DEFENDANTS

EXHIBIT B-1

ALBAY CONSTRUCTION COMPANY OSCAR E. ERICKSON, INC.
SANTA FE BRAUN, INC. AS SUCCESSOR-IN- HOPEMAN BROTHERS, INC.
INTEREST TO C.F. BRAUN, INC. 1:0, THORPE & SON, INC.
SCOTT CO. OF CALIFORNIA THOMAS DEE ENGINEERING CO., INC,
CONSOLIDATED INSULATION, INC. DOES 1-800; DOES 1001-2000 .
: ALTERNATE ENTITY
SCOTT CO. OF. CALIFORNIA __ SCOTT COMPANY OF CALIFORNIA

SCOTT COMPANY OF NORTHERN CALIFORNIA
SCOTT. CO. INDUSTRIAL CONTRACTORS .
SCOTT-BROADWAY CONTRACTORS, INC,
BROADWAY PLUMBING CO., INC,

BROADWAY MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS, INC.

OSCAR E. ERICKSON, INC, * ASSOCIATED [INSULATION OF CALIFORNIA,
. . . OSCAR B. ERICKSON COMPANY
OSCAR ERICKSON, INCORPORATED

J.T. THORPE & SON, INC. THE THORPE: COMPANY
THORPE PRODUCTS CO.
1.7, THORPE NORTHWEST

“EXHIBIT B-E

Sees 4s
OMP| ONAL INRIRY - ASBESTOSEXHIBIT Cat

I . EXHIBITC
2) DEFENDANTS .
3 || ABHI-CROCKETT, INC. SANTA FE BRAUN, INC. AS SUCCESSOR-IN-
THE DOW CHEMICAL COMPANY INTEREST TO C.F. BRAUN, INC, |. :
4|) EL, DU PONT DE NEMOURS AND COMPANY BECHTEL CORPORATION (DE)
PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY SEQUOIA VENTURES, INC.
5 | SHELL OUL COMPANY METALCLAD INSULATION CORPORATION
© ‘|| CHEVRON PRODUCTS COMPANY HOPEMAN BROTHERS, INC.
6] UNOCAL CORPORATION J.T. THORPE & SON, INC.
SCOTT CO. OF CALIFORNIA THOMAS DES ENGINEERING CO., INC.
74). CONSOLIDATED INSULATION, INC. PLANT INSULATION COMPANY
OSCAR E. ERICKSON, INC. . WESTERN MacARTHUR COMPANY
8 {| ZORN INDUSTRIES, INC. ~ MacARTHUR COMPANY ~
DILLINGHAM CONSTRUCTION, N.A., INC. WESTERN ASBESTOS COMPANY
91) ALBAY CONSTRUCTION COMPANY DOES 1091-2000
10. . ALTERNATE ENTITY
11} ABHE-CROCKETT, INC. CALIFORNIA AND HAWAIIAN SUGAR COMPANY
: : C.& K-HAWAI, INC.
12 C.& H SUGAR COMPANY
13 || CHEVRON PRODUCTS COMPANY CHEVRON U.S.A. PRODUCTS COMPANY
~ CUIEVRON CORPORATION PRODUCTS COMPANY
14 ‘CHEVRON CORPORATION .
CHEVRON OIL REFINERY
15 CHEVRON CHEMICAL COMPANY,
“WILSHIRE OF.
16 STANDARD OIL COMPANY OF CALIFORNIA
. STANDARD OU. COMPANY OP CALIFORNIA,
7 WESTERN OPERATIONS, INC.
GULF OIL COMPANY
18 GULF OIL OF CALIFORNIA
GULF OIL CORPORATION
19 ‘GULF OIL PRODUCTS COMPANY
CHEVRON RESEARCH AND
20 TECHNOLOGY:
PACIFIC OJL REFINING
2 PACIFIC REFINING CO.
: SEQUOIA REFINING CORP.
22 CHEVRON US.A., INC.
8 CHEVRON U.S.A. PRODUCTS, INC.
PREMISES OWNER. .
24) DEI ANTS, LOCATION ‘TIME PERIO!
25 || ABHI-CROCKETT, INC. California & Hawaiian Sugar 1968
: Crockett, CA
26 .
THE DOW CHEMICAL COMPANY Dow Chemical 1965
27 : Pittsburg, CA soy : .

EXHIBIT C

yp
@
oe sgememiniseincn

Kxeppost 107: ed . 16
COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INIURY “ASBESTOSXO. NI tO ON eee

Se O'R GF BON ES
sa

RoR ON ON RP ow
BR RRR CS Hs

EXHIBIT C (cont'd.

PREMISES OWNER .
DEFENDANTS. . . LOCATION

E.L DU PONT DE'NEMOURS AND ELL Dupont:de Nemoirs
COMPANY. . Antioch, CA

PACIFIC. GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY = PG &E,
. . Eureka, CA

SHELL OIL. COMPANY _ “Shelf Oil,
Martinez, CA

CHEVRON PRODUCTS COMPANY Chevron (Standard Oil)
Richmond, CA
UNOCAL CORPORATION Union Oit
Rodeo/Oleasn, CA

CONTRACTOR
DEFENDANTS LOCATION

SCOTT CO. OF CALIFORNIA ._ ~ Sbell. Oi,
. Martinez, CA

Bank of America
Van Ness Branch
San Francisco, CA

Chevron (Standard Oil)
Richmond, CA

Bethlehem Steel,
Shipbuilding

‘San Francisco, CA

California & Hawaiian Sugar
“Crackett, CA

Various ships and submarines:
‘Mare Island Naval Shipyard
Vallejo, CA ~ .

CONSOLIDATED INSULATION, INC. Bank of America
so . Van Ness Branch
‘San Francisco, CA.

OSCAR E. ERICKSON, INC. Shell Oil,
Martinez, CA
Mn

ww

TIME PERIOD

1965-1966.
1962-1964
TA958-3/1959,

1965
196151965

1968

TIME PERIOD

TAQSB-3/1959;
1965

8/1959-3/1960

19611965

1965.

1968
1968 {1 year)
8/1959-3/1960

TADSE-3/1959;
1965

EXHIBIT C

Stvsonhtan ice AZ
BOMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY 2 ASBESTOS‘Soeiaicimeiaereteeroorameem

CONTRACTOR
DEFENDANTS.

OSCAR E. ERICKSON, ENC, (cont’d.)

ALBAY CONSTRUCTION COMPANY

SANTA FE BRAUN, INC. AS.

SUCCESSOR-IN-INTEREST TO CF.

BRAUN, INC.

We

EXHIBIT C (contd)

LOCATION

Various Ships at

Hunters Paint Naval Saipyard.
San Francisco, CA

Chevron (Standard oi.
Richmond, CA

Eagle Picher
Lovelock, NV

California & Hawaiian Sugar
Crockett, CA.

Various ships and submarines
‘Mare [sland Naval Shipyard
Vallejo, CA

Union Oi!

Rodeo/Oleam, CA

Sheti Oil,
Martinez, CA

Fibreboard.
Antioch, CA

Chevron (Standard Oil} »
Richmond, CA

Dow Chemical,
Piusburg, cA

ELL Dupont de Nemoirs
Antioch, CA

Califomia & Hawaiian Sugar

Crockett, CA

Shell Oil,
Martinez, CA

‘Chevron (Standard Oil)
Richrooad, CA

Dow Chemical
Pittsburg, CA.

TIME PERIOD

1960-1961
(1 year)

196151965
1967
1968,

1968 (I year)

1968

FALGSE-3/1959; -

1965

1960-1961

196151965
1965
1965-1966
1968

TAIS8-3/1959;
1965

1961;1965

1965

"EXHIBIT C

erate sheret . -_ p18.
EGHPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY ASBESTOS. ee it
BRE RPRRRRRSRARRESEES

Oe A A eB Be ON

| CONTRACTOR

DEFENDANTS

INC,

BECHIEL CORPORATION

METALCLAD INSULATION
CORPORATION

uM

"DILLINGHAM CONSTRUCTION, NA.,

(DEVSEQUOIA VENTURES, INC,

EXHIBIT C{cont'd.)

LOCATION

“Shell Oil,

. “Martinez, CA

Fibreboard
Antioch, CA

Various Ships at

Hunters Point Naval Shipyard,
San Francisco, CA .

Chevron (Standard Oit)
Richmond, CA

Dow Chemical
Pittsburg, CA

California & Hawaiian Sugar,
Crockett, CA,

Various ships and submarines
Mare Island Naval Shipyard
Vallejo, CA

Shell Oil,
‘Martinez, CA

. Fibseboard

Antioch, CA

Chevron (Standard Oil)
Richmond, CA .
Dow Chemicat

Pittsburg, CA

§.L Dupont de Nemoirs
Antioch, CA

California & Haweiian Sugar

Crockett, CA

Shell Oil,

Martinez, CA.

‘Various Ships at .
Hunters Point Naval Shipyard,
“San Francisco,CA

2

TIME PERIOD

TAISB-3/1959;
1965.

1960-1961

1960-1961 {1 year)

196151965,

1965,
1968

1968
(1 year)

711958-3/1959;
1965
1960-1961
1961;1965
1965
1965-1966

1968

HAI58-3/1959;

1965

| 1960-1961 (1 year),

EXHIBIT C

ee
COMDLAINT FOR PERSONAL IRIORY ~ ASBESTOSwo Sw DR A PR WON

CONTRACTOR
DEFENDANTS

METALCLAD [INSULATION
CORPORATION {cont'd}

ZURN INDUSTRIES, INC.
HOPEMAN BROTHERS, INC.

LT. THORPE & SON, INC.

PLANT INSULATION COMPANY

WESTERN MacARTHUR
COMPANY /MacARTHUR
COMPANY/WESTERN ASBESTOS
COMPANY

THOMAS DEE ENGINEERING CO., INC.

__ EXHIBIT.G (contd)

LOCATION

Chevron (Standard Oil)
Richmond, CA

E.I. Dupont de Nemoirs
Antioch, CA

“Various ships:and submarines

Mare Island Naval Shipyard
Vallejo, CA. -

~ Various

“Various

Various
Various
Various

Various

TIME PERIOD

1961; 1965
1965-1966

1968

(1 year}
Various
Various
Various
Warious
Various

Various

EXHIBIT C

Er rot?
i "FOR PERSONAL INJURY - ASBESTOSss #XBIBIT Hpoo

13

Wc NV AY & w

EXHIBIT H

DEFENDANTS

METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
PNEUMO ABEX LLC
BORGWARNER MORSE TEC, INC.
HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL, INC. tsuccessorit-
interest to ALLIEDSIGNAL, ING}
THE BUDD COMPANY
DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION
DANA CORPORATION :
FORD MOTOR COMPANY
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION
BRIDGESTONE/FIRESTONE
NORTH AMERICAN TIRE, LLC
LEAR SIEGUER DIVERSIFIED HOLDINGS CORP.
MAREMONT CORPORATION
MORTON INTERNATIONAL, INC.
PARKER-HANNIFIN CORFORATION
STANDARD MOTOR PRODUCTS, INC.
GATKE CORPORATION
GARLOCK. SEALING TECHNOLOGIES, LLC *
BRASSBESTOS BRAKE LINING COMPANY
A. KRASNE MANUFACTURING COMPANY
AUTG SPECIALTIES MANUFACTURING COMPANY

STUART-WESTERN, INC. .
RITESET MANUFACTURING COMPANY

~- ASBESTOS MANUBACTURING COMPANY -

FIBRE & METAL PRODUCTS COMPANY

LASCO BRAKE PRODUCTS

LJ. MILEY COMPANY

ROSSENDALE-RUBOIL COMPANY

SOUTHERN FRICTION MATERIALS COMPANY

U.S. SPRING & BUMPER COMPANY

AUTO FRICTION CORPORATION

EMSCO.ASBESTOS. COMPANY

FORCEE MANUFACTURING CORPORATION

MOLDED INDUSTRIAL FRICTION CORPORATION

NATIONAL TRANSPORT SUPPLY, INC,

SILVER LINE PRODUCTS, INC,

STANDCO, INC.

UNIVERSAL FRICTION MATERIALS COMPANY

WHEELING BRAKE BLOCK MANUFACTURING
COMPANY .

OWENS-ILLINOIS, INC.

BELL ASBESTOS MINES.LTD.

DOESSO00-8000:

EXHIBIT 1

s 22
EOHPLAINE FOR PERSONAL INIURY "ASBESTOSEXHIBIT I~BOR ERO RRS SSS RGR CS ES ee a a we

EXHIBIT |

DEFENDANTS

METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
OWENS-ILLINOIS, INC,

PNEUMO ABEX LLC

GATKE CORPORATION

GARLGCK SEALING TECHNOLOGIES, LLC

AMERICAN CONFERENCE OF GOVERNMENTAL INDUSTRIAL HYGIENISTS, INC.

UNDERWRITERS LABORATORIES, INC.
DOBS5000-7500 .

EXHIBIT I

Rexivenior: aps . 24
SOMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL IWURY - ASBESTOSBRAVTONSPURCELL LLP
ATTORNEYS ATLAW
222 RUSH LANDING ROAD
POBOX 669
NOVATO, CALIFORNIA 94949-6169

(15) 899-1555

BAVID R. DONADIO, ES! .. 5,B. #154436

BRAYTON“PURCELL LL _ ENDORSED
Attorneys at Law .
222 Rush Landing Road... . san lato. Hor Court
P.O. Box 6169 .
(ats) ees 94948-6169. JUN $= 2007 |
4153} 898-155,
GORBON PARK. L, Slere
Attomeys for Plaintiff . on HECPINTA &

SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

CHARLES TOBEY, |

) ASB
} mEdES ~9 727226
Plaintiff, )
}
vs. } .. PRELIMINARY FACT SHEET/NEW
: ) _ FILING/ASBESTOS LITIGATION
ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (BP) }
" (See General Order No. 129, InRe:.
Complex Asbestos Litigation)
NOTICE

To! NEW DEFENDANTS SERVED. IN COMPLEX ASBESTOS LITIGATION INTHE ~
SUPERIOR COURT IN AND FOR THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, CITY AND COUNTY. OF
SAN FRANCISCO

“You have been served with process in an action which has been designated by the Court
as. complex Jitigation pursuant to Standard 19 of the Standards of Judicial Administration. ‘This
litigation bears the.caption “In Re: Complex Ashestos Litigation", [Sani Francisco Superior
Court No. 828684].

This litigation is governed by various general orders, : some of which affect the. judicial
management and/or discovery obligations, including the responsibility to answer interrogatories
deemed propounded in the case. You may contact the Court or Designated Defense Counsel,
Berry & Berry, P.O. Box 16070, 2930 Lakeshore Avenue, Oakland, CA 94610, Telephone:
(510) 835- 8330; FAX: (510) 835-51 17, for further information and/or cepies of these orders, at
your expensé.

1, State the complete name and address of each person whose claimed exposure to asbestos is

the basis of this lawsuit (exposed person"): Chart ries Tobey, §3 Rose Peak Road, Devon
Nevada 89403.

INARY FAI EW FT K x2. Does plaintiff anticipate filing a motion fora preferential trial date within the next four
months? Yes _X__No .
[Ifyes, the action will be governed by Gencral Order No. 140; if'no, the action will be governed
by General Order No, 129.] :
3, Date of birth of each expased person in item one and, if selina date of death:
‘Date of Birth: _ 7/15/40 __
~ Date of Death: NiA

Social Security Number of each exposed person: .-
483-40-9047

4. Specify the nature or type of asbestos-related disease alleged by each exposed ‘Person.

X__ Asbestosis a Mesothelioma
_—X__ Pleural Thickening/Plaques ___ Other Cancer: specify:
Lung Cancer Other Than Mesothelioma . Other: Specify:

5, ‘For purposes of identifying the nature of exposure allegations involved in this aclion, please
check one or more: / : :
_ Shipyard . __X__ Construction SK Friction-Automotive
—X__ Premises . _____ Aerospace. . oe Military

Other: Specify a all that apply:

[F applicable, indicate which exposure, allegations apply to which exposed person.

6. Identify each location alleged tobea source of an asbestos exposute, and to the.extent known,
provide the beginning and ending year(s): of each such exposure. Also specify each. exposed

person's employer and jab.title or job description. during each period of exposure. €or. example:

"San Francisco Naval Shipyard - -Pipefitter - 1939-1948"). Examples of locations of exposure

might bea specific shipyard, a specific raitroad maintenance yard,.or perhaps more generalized

| descriptions such as “merchant marine” or “construction”. Ifan exposed person claims exposure

during enly a portion of.a year, ihe answer should indicate that. year as the beginning and ending

year (e.g., 1947-1947).

Me -

Kewanee ee 2 ee
| PRECiEA MINARY FACT SABE T/NEW FILING?ASHESTOS LIMIOKTION(Owe RA WR OW ON

Location of a : Exposure

Employer . a Exposure Job Title | Dates
Plant Asbestos . . Shell Oil, : insulator ~~ TH9S8 3/1959
» Martinez, CA _ (Apprentice)
Plant Asbestos . “ California State University Insulator ANN 959-8959
. ‘Hayward, CA. {Apprentice) ..
Plant Asbestos Bank of America — Insulator ”-8/1959-3/1960
Van Ness Branch ~ (Apprentice)
San Francisco, CA .
Maritime Union Maritime Union Hall Insulator 1960
: San Francisco, CA {apprentice) .
Plant Asbestos =U Berkeley Insulator “1960
a Berkeley, CA __ . (apprentice) .
Plant Asbestos . Sierra Pacific Power Co., _ insulator 5/1960- 10/1960.
Tracy Clark Power Station, (apprentice) .
Sparks, Nevada .
Western Asbestos Company... Various Ships at Insulator » . 1960-1961
. os . Hunters Point Naval (apprentice) (1 year)
Shipyard, .
San Francisco, CA .
GE
(AP-1 2)
P. : UE NAL EXPOS! a
Plaintiff's father worked as an insulator out of Local 16. Plaintiff shared home with his father

from 1948-1960. Plaintiff recalls father coming home from work wearing coveralls that were
covered with asbestos, Plaintiff currently contends he was exposed to asbestos as a result of his
father’s employment. Plaintiff's iavestigation and discovery are continuing.

NON-OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE: 4

Plaintiff recalls purchasing auto parts from the following suppliers:

GRAND AUTO PARTS, Richmond Catifornia. Plaintiff recalls purchasing clutches, brakes and
mufflers duting the years of 1956-1970.

FORD Dealership, Richmond California. Plaintiff recalis purchasing auto parts during the years
of 1956-1970, J

FORD Dealership, Sioux City, lowa. Plaintiffrecalls purchasing brakes, mufflers:and engine
parts during the years of 1976-1980; 1956-1970 and 1976-1987.

SEARS. Department Store. Sioux City, Iowa. Plaintiff recalls purchasing brakes during the years:
1976-1980.

Ht

i eh 3
SRSCIMINAIY EX PACT’ SHEET/NEW FILING/ASBESTOS rn IGATIONPlaintiff recalls performing the following repairs on the following specific vehicles.

1964 OLDSMOBILE. Plaintiff recalls ghanging the original brakes on this vehicle in 1959 in his
driveway, Plaintiff was assisted by his friend Tom Chamberlin. ~~

1955 CHEVROLET COUPE acquired in 1965. Plaintiff recalls changing the original brakes,
clutch and replacing the engine in his garage. Plaintiff recalls purchasing the replacement parts
from GRAND AUTO in Richmond, California, Plaintiff recalls purchasing B TX and
GHEVROLET replaccment parts, Plaintiff worked with Tom Chamberlin and Tray Courier on
this vehicle. : :

1974 CHEVROLET CORVETTE acquired in 1976 or 1980. Plaintiff recalis changing the
original brakes in his driveway in 1979. Plaintiff recalls purchasing the replacement parts from
SEARS. Plaintiff recalls purchasing RAYBESTOS replacement parts. Plaintiff worked with
Geny Taque on this vehicle, --

Rieeruemeteaent : “4 ee
PRELIMINARY PACT SHEET/NEW FILING/ASHESTOS CUTIGATION- EXHIBITBDouglas G. Wah, Esq. .. SBN 64692
Jane B. Yee, Esq. SBN 118880
Linn E. Gillen, Esq. SBN 248923
Feley & Mansfi eld, P. L.L.P,

1111 Broadway, 10" Floor

Oakland, CA 94607

Telephone: (510) 590-9500
Facsimile: (510) 590-9595

Attomeys for Defendant
FLUOR CORPORATION sued herein as DOE 15 and
1005
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
CHARLES TOBEY, } Case No. CGC-07-274226
Plaintiff, ; “Ashestos- Related. Case”
oo VE } FLUOR CORPORATION? Ss FIRST SET OF
ey oe « ) SPECIALLY PREPARED .
ASBESTOS DEFENDANTS (BP), ) INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF
Defendants, 3 CHARLES TOBEY

[SET ONE]

PROPOUNDING PARTY: FLUOR CORPORATION :
RESPONDING PARTY: CHARLES TOBEY
SET NUMBER: . > ONE
Pursuant to Seetion 2030, 010, et seg., of the California Code of Civil Procedure,
Defendant FLUOR CORPORATION requests that YOu answer the efllowing interrogatories fully,
separately, and under oath within thirty- (30)- days after ihe date.of service,

In responding to these interrogatories, the following definitions shall apply:

1. “Plaintiff” shall refer to the individual(s) whose alleged injuries are. the subject of the
complaint. : . .
2... “FLUOR” shall refer to FLUOR CORPORATION, or any person or entity acting on

FLUOR’S behalf including, without limitation, those entities YOU claim are FLUOR’S predecessors,

t
FLUOR CORPORATION'S FIRST SET OF SPECIALLY PREPARED INTERROGATORIES TQ PLAINTIFF CHARLES TOBEYSee ON tA oe

oR oe hoe oe

subsidiaries, ‘parents, “other . subsidiaries .of the same parent, ‘officers, . directors, employees,
representatives, agents, or successors-in-interests.
3... “YOU” or “YOUR” shall refer to “Plaintiff”, as previously defined.
4, “DOCUMENT(S)” shall refer to any and all of the following: records; documents;

medical data, reports, and/or records; charts; summaries; readings; letters; correspondence; intra-

: company communications; notes; work papers; lists; reports; blueprints; instructions; specifications,

books; drawings; sketches; x-rays; printouts; video recordings; audio recordings: invoices; purchase
orders; bills; quotations; and, any and all other writings, printings, drafts, copies, or reproductions

thereof, whether in paper, electronic, or other form, in the possession, custody, or control of YOU or any :
of YOUR representatives, agents, employees, successors, assigns, or attomeys.

5. When an Interrogatory asks YOU to “IDENTIFY” a a person, the answer shall state that
person’s full name, his or her current.or last known residence address and phone number, and his or her ©
current employer and job title, if an Interrogalory asks YOU to “IDENTIFY” a business entity, the
answer shall state the full name of cach business entity, the type or nature of business such entity is
principally engaged in, the state of incorporation, the current or last known. business adress and phone
number, ‘and the dates during which, such entity was conducting business. It an Interrogatory asks You
to IDENTIFY” a product ¢ of service, , the answer shall describe the product. or service using ‘its market
trade name, ‘its generic name, and any slang or nickname, as well as any serial number or other
identifying information. Tf an Interrogatory asks YOU to “IDENTIFY” a location o or work site, the
answer shall state:the address, city, state, identifying name, and any other identifying. description of the
location or werk site in question.

6. “PERSON(S)" shall refer to a natural person, firm, association, organization, partnership,
business, trast, corporation, joint venture, or public entity, or their F agents, employees, representatives, or
anyone else acting on their behalf.

Mt
Ht
it
if

5
FLUOR. CORPORATION'S. FIRST SET OF SPECIALLY PREPARED INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF CHARLES TOBLY_

Oo Ww NA wn fe wo

Boe ie
BC ae 3 Aw FW ye Be Ss

21

INTERROGATORIES

INTERROGATORY NO. 1:
IDENTIFY each site YOU claim YOU were present at the time FLUOR was  pefoming a
construction contract,

INTERROGATORY. NO. 2:

For each site, identified i in Interrogatory No. 1, state the name and address, cross streets or
nearby streets and landmarks if the address if not known and specific unit(s) or area within each location
at which FLUOR was performing a construction contract where YOU claim YOU were present.,

INTERROGAI TORY NO. 3:

IDENTIFY each ASBESTOS- -containing product to which You claim YOU were EXPOSED ag
aresult of FLUOR’S conduct, at each site YOU visited where FLUOR was performing a construction

CO: mtract,

INTERROGATORY NO. 4:

State the manner YOU claim YOU.were EXPOSED to ASBESTOS- -containing products asa

Weresult of FLUOR’S conduct at each site at which FLUOR was performing a construction contract.

INTERROGATORY NO. 5:

‘Tf YOU have received any monetary or other settlements from any party to this action, please list
each party who has settled and the total amount of those settlements asa result of. PLUOR.
INTERROGATORY. NO. &

State the factual basis for YOUR allegation that You: were EXPOSED to ASBESTOS-
containing products as a result of FLUOR’S conduct at each site at which FLUOR was > performing a
construction contract,

INTERROGATORY NO. 7:
__ For each site identified in Interrogatory No. L state YouR employer at the time YOU visited a
location where FLUOR was performing a construction contract. :

INTERROGATORY NO, 8:

State YOUR job duties fo: each site identified in Interragatory No. 1 where YOU claim FLUOR

was performing a construction contract, —

7 ~
. FLUOR CORPORATION'S FIRST