On September 18, 2013 a
Party Discovery
was filed
involving a dispute between
St. Lucia Free Press,
and
Gobat, Oliver,
for civil
in the District Court of San Francisco County.
Preview
MA
- SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
Document Scanning Lead Sheet
Oct-16-2013 5:27 pm
Case Number: CPF-13-513220
Filing Date: Oct-16-2013 5:19
Filed by: LINDA FONG
Juke Box: 001 Image: 04240125
ORDER
IN RE: ST. LUCIA FREE PRESS
001004240125
Instructions:
Please place this sheet on top of the document to be scanned.we we YN DR Hw eR WN
wb NN NY NY NY NN BD SF FP Ee Pe ee Se Sp oF Ss
RB Saas BP Fe So we NIN DH PF WY =
L,E,D
Peaarater & ‘Superior Court ft
GATHERING & Toe 138, ES@. Gounty of San Francisco
Oo. BOx 2477
Blears, GS AAadada oct 16 2013
Ten BOS Ader SEAT CLERK OF THE COURT
ASTORN oy woe Luca Faee Press BY:
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
St. Lucia Free Press, California Case No: CPF-13-513220
Petitioner, ORDER St4NTING PET TION TO
RUASH INVALID FotsiGn SUBPOENS
AND 2waep &S45orn4eQ ue Expenses
Date: October 16, 2013
Vv.
Oliver Gobat, Time: 9:00 A.M.
Dept: 302 -DISCOVERY
Respondent. Judge: Hon. Marla J. Miller
The petition of St. Lucia Free Press for an order to quash the invalid foreign subpoena
came on regularly for hearing by the court on October 16, 2013. Petitioner appeared by counsel
Catherine R. Gellis; Respondent appeared by counsel David Owens. On proof made to the
satisfaction of the court that the petition should be granted,
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that he subpoena for production of business records in S.F.
Superior Ct. No. CPF-13-513220 and High Ct. of Justice, Queen's Bench Division, Strand,
London, U.K. No. HQ13D04242 is hereby Quashed.
\
\
\
\\
J
ORDER GRANTING PETITION TO QUASH INVALID FOREIGN SUBPOENA AND AWARD
REASONABLE EXPENSES:Bo
| oP IT IS HEREBY FURTHER ORDERED that Respondent Oliver Gobat orhis-attomey
2 | Davie Owens,-beingjeintly-and-severalty tiable, pay to St. Lucia Free Press the reasonable
3 | expenses incurred in bringing this petition, including $1800.00 +22 __ in
4 yeasonable attorney fees and $510.00 Coe __ in additional costs and expenses.
5
6
7 | Dated: October 16, 2013
8 H
9 |
10 | By:
il DAVID MAY
i Judge Pro Tem of the
12 Superior Court of San Francisco
2
ORDER GRANTING PETITION TO QUASH INVALID FOREIGN SUBPOENA AND AWARD
REASONABLE EXPENSES,
Document Filed Date
October 16, 2013
Case Filing Date
September 18, 2013
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
MA - SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO Document Scanning Lead Sheet Oct-16-2013 5:27 pm Case Number: CPF-13-513220 Filing Date: Oct-16-2013 5:19 Filed by: LINDA FONG Juke Box: 001 Image: 04240125 ORDER IN RE: ST. LUCIA FREE PRESS 001004240125 Instructions: Please place this sheet on top of the document to be scanned.we we YN DR Hw eR WN wb NN NY NY NY NN BD SF FP Ee Pe ee Se Sp oF Ss RB Saas BP Fe So we NIN DH PF WY = L,E,D Peaarater & ‘Superior Court ft GATHERING & Toe 138, ES@. Gounty of San Francisco Oo. BOx 2477 Blears, GS AAadada oct 16 2013 Ten BOS Ader SEAT CLERK OF THE COURT ASTORN oy woe Luca Faee Press BY: SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO St. Lucia Free Press, California Case No: CPF-13-513220 Petitioner, ORDER St4NTING PET TION TO RUASH INVALID FotsiGn SUBPOENS AND 2waep &S45orn4eQ ue Expenses Date: October 16, 2013 Vv. Oliver Gobat, Time: 9:00 A.M. Dept: 302 -DISCOVERY Respondent. Judge: Hon. Marla J. Miller The petition of St. Lucia Free Press for an order to quash the invalid foreign subpoena came on regularly for hearing by the court on October 16, 2013. Petitioner appeared by counsel Catherine R. Gellis; Respondent appeared by counsel David Owens. On proof made to the satisfaction of the court that the petition should be granted, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that he subpoena for production of business records in S.F. Superior Ct. No. CPF-13-513220 and High Ct. of Justice, Queen's Bench Division, Strand, London, U.K. No. HQ13D04242 is hereby Quashed. \ \ \ \\ J ORDER GRANTING PETITION TO QUASH INVALID FOREIGN SUBPOENA AND AWARD REASONABLE EXPENSES:Bo | oP IT IS HEREBY FURTHER ORDERED that Respondent Oliver Gobat orhis-attomey 2 | Davie Owens,-beingjeintly-and-severalty tiable, pay to St. Lucia Free Press the reasonable 3 | expenses incurred in bringing this petition, including $1800.00 +22 __ in 4 yeasonable attorney fees and $510.00 Coe __ in additional costs and expenses. 5 6 7 | Dated: October 16, 2013 8 H 9 | 10 | By: il DAVID MAY i Judge Pro Tem of the 12 Superior Court of San Francisco 2 ORDER GRANTING PETITION TO QUASH INVALID FOREIGN SUBPOENA AND AWARD REASONABLE EXPENSES,