Motion,Ex Parte: Butler America LLC vs UCOMMG LLC et al

• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                ELECTRONICALLY FILED
                                                                                           Superior Court of California
                  CHORA YOUNG & MANASSERIAN LLP                                            County of Santa Barbara
            1                                                                              Darrel E. Parker, Executive Officer
                  Armen Manasserian, Esq. (State Bar No. 288199)                           5/2/2022 12:59 PM
            2     Cameron Totten, Esq. (State Bar No. 180765)                              By: Terri Chavez, Deputy
                  650 Sierra Madre Villa Avenue, Suite 304
            3     Pasadena, California 91107
                  Tel.: (626) 744-1838
            4
                  Fax: (626) 744-3167
            5     Email:    cameron@cym.law

            6     Attorneys for Plaintiff
            7     Butler America, LLC

            8                                      SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
                                      COUNTY OF SANTA BARBARA – ANACAPA DIVISION
            9
           10     BUTLER AMERICA, LLC, a Delaware limited                      Case No.: 20CV03877
                  liability company,
           11                                                                  PROOF OF SERVICE OF (1) PLAINTIFF
           12                                  Plaintiff,                      BUTLER AMERICA, LLC’S EX PARTE
                            vs.                                                APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER
           13                                                                  CONTINUING DEFENDANTS’ MOTION
                  UCOMMG, LLC, a Nevada limited liability                      TO QUASH SERVICE OF SUMMONS TO
           14     company; UNIFIED COMMUNICATIONS                              A DATE AFTER THE COMPLETION OF
           15     GROUP, INC., a dissolved Washington                          JURISDICTIONAL DISCOVERY; (2)
                  corporation; KENNETH W. NEWBATT, an                          DECLARATION OF CAMERON TOTTEN
           16     individual; BIANCA NEWBATT, an                               IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF BUTLER
                  individual; MITCHELL C. LIPKIN, an                           AMERICA, LLC’S EX PARTE
           17
                  individual; MICHAEL J. BELLAS, an                            APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER
           18     individual; JIMMIE GARRETT BAKER, JR.,                       CONTINUING DEFENDANTS’ MOTION
                  an individual; WESTELE UTILITY                               TO QUASH SERVICE OF SUMMONS TO
           19     SOLUTIONS, LLC, a California limited                         A DATE AFTER THE COMPLETION OF
                  liability company; and DOES 1 through 50,                    JURISDICTIONAL DISCOVERY; (3)
           20
                  inclusive,                                                   [PROPOSED] ORDER RE PLAINTIFF
           21                                                                  BUTLER AMERICA,               LLC’S EX PARTE
                                              Defendants.                      APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER
           22                                                                  CONTINUING DEFENDANTS’ MOTION
           23                                                                  TO QUASH SERVICE OF SUMMONS TO
                                                                               A DATE AFTER THE COMPLETION OF
           24                                                                  JURISDICTIONAL DISCOVERY
           25                                                                  Hearing Date: May 3, 2022
           26                                                                  Time: 8:30 a.m.
                                                                               Dept.: 4
           27                                                                  Judge: Hon. Donna D. Geck
           28



                                                                 PROOF OF SERVICE
                                                               PROOF OF SERVICE
            1
            2                           STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES

            3              I am employed in the County of Los Angeles, State of California.                   I am over the age of
                  eighteen (18) years and not a party to the within action.          My business address is: 650 Sierra Madre
            4
                  Villa Ave., Ste. 304, Pasadena, CA 91107.
            5
                           On   May    2, 2022,    I served   the  foregoing    document(s)     described    as:  (1)  PLAINTIFF
            6     BUTLER         AMERICA,           LLC’S      EX      PARTE        APPLICATION             FOR      AN     ORDER
            7     CONTINUING DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO QUASH SERVICE OF SUMMONS TO A
                  DATE       AFTER        THE      COMPLETION             OF     JURISDICTIONAL               DISCOVERY;            (2)
            8     DECLARATION             OF    CAMERON          TOTTEN        IN   SUPPORT        OF    PLAINTIFF         BUTLER
                  AMERICA,         LLC’S      EX    PARTE        APPLICATION            FOR     AN    ORDER        CONTINUING
            9     DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO QUASH SERVICE OF SUMMONS TO A DATE AFTER
           10     THE     COMPLETION           OF    JURISDICTIONAL             DISCOVERY;          (3)  [PROPOSED]         ORDER
                  RE    PLAINTIFF        BUTLER        AMERICA,          LLC’S     EX    PARTE       APPLICATION           FOR     AN
           11     ORDER         CONTINUING            DEFENDANTS’             MOTION          TO     QUASH         SERVICE         OF
                  SUMMONS           TO     A   DATE       AFTER        THE     COMPLETION             OF     JURISDICTIONAL
           12     DISCOVERY on the interested parties in this action, as follows:
           13
                   Shayna Balch Santiago                                     Attorneys for Defendants
           14      FISHER & PHILLIPS LLP                                     UCOMMG, LLC; Unified Communications
                   3200 N. Central Avenue, Suite 1550                        Group, Inc.; Kenneth W. Newbatt; Bianca
           15      Phoenix, Arizona 85012-2487                               Newbatt; Mitchell C. Lipkin; Michael J.
           16      E-Mail: ssantiago@fisherphillips.com                      Bellas; Jimmie Garrett Baker, Jr.; WesTele
                                                                             Utility Solutions, LLC; and Cynthia Baker
           17      Kathryn M. Evans
                   FISHER & PHILLIPS LLP
           18
                   4747 Executive Drive, Suite 1000
           19      San Diego, California 92121
                   E-Mail: kmevans@fisherphillips.com
           20
                  (XX)     (BY   ELECTRONIC          MAIL)     I caused   the  document(s)     listed above    to the  electronically
           21
                           transmitted to the email addresses of the addressees as indicated above.
           22
                  Executed on May 2, 2022, at Pasadena, California.
           23
           24     (X)      (STATE) I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that
                           the above is true and correct.
           25
                  ( )      (FEDERAL) I declare that I am employed in the offices of a member of this court at whose
           26              direction the service was made.
           27
                                                          _________________________
           28                                                        Jaclyn Poon



                                                                 PROOF OF SERVICE