On March 23, 2017 a
Order
was filed
involving a dispute between
Bonnici, Timothy A,
and
Does 1 To 20, Inclusive,
Henry, Carroll,
Mcmackin, Charles,
for civil
in the District Court of San Francisco County.
Preview
HATE
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
Document Scanning Lead Sheet
Oct-03-2018 1:49 pm ©
Case Number: CGC-17-557688
Filing Date: Oct-03-2018 1:46
Filed by: ROSALLIE GUMPAL
Image: 06520518
ORDER
TIMOTHY A BONNICI VS. CHARLES MCMACKIN ET AL
001006520518
Instructions:
Please place this sheet on top of the document to be scanned.R. Michael Lieberman (SBN 120831) ey A
Law Offices of R. Michael Lieberman ior COUM Oc
1398 Post Street Seen at San Frans
San Francisco, CA 94109
Tel: 415-929-3197
Fax: 415-929-3476
Email: michael@spark84.com
Attorneys for Defendants
CARROLL HENRY and CHARLES MCMACKIN
SUPERIOR COURT — STATE OF CALIFORNIA
_ COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO — UNLIMITED JURISDICTION ~
TIMOTHY A. BONNICI, an individual, NO. CGC-17-557688
WK .
[RREROSED] ORDER GRANTIN
PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR RELIEF nol
JUDGMENT AND AWARDING FEES
COSTS TO DEFENDANTS
Plaintiff,
vs.
mmm
CHARLES MCMACKIN, an _ individual; te OCTOBER 3, 2018
CARROLL HENRY, an individual; and DOES os “Ni ,
1 to 200, inclusive. DEPT.: 302
, , TRIAL DATE: NONE SET
Defendants. HON. HAROLD A: KAHN
1/ [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR RELIEF OF JUDGMENT AND
AWARDING FEES AND COSTS TO DEFENDANTSOn October 3, 2018 at 9:30 a.m., in Department 302 of the San Francisco Superior Court, th
Honorable Harold A. Kahn presiding, this Court adopted its tentative ruling. :
Satisfactory proof having been made, good cause appearing, and in furtherance of justice,
IT IS ORDERED that plaintiff Timothy Bonnici's motion for relief from judgment is granted. Th
January 24, 2018 judgment is set aside based on the mandatory relief provisions of CCP section 473(b)
Defendants Charles McMackin and Carroll Henry are entitled to an award of fees and costs of $5,000 t
be paid by Mr. Bonnici's counsel Gino Molinari no later than December 31, 2018. While this is less thar
the amount claimed by defendants, the court's own review of the additional work caused by Mr.
Molinari's admitted fault shows that the high range of reasonable fees and costs for that work is $5000.
DATE:
ocroszns =H wm
JUDGE HAROLD KAHN
2/ [ER@R@SED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR RELIEF OF JUDGMENT AI
AWARDING FEES AND COSTS TO DEFENDANTS ~~
Document Filed Date
October 03, 2018
Case Filing Date
March 23, 2017
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
HATE SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO Document Scanning Lead Sheet Oct-03-2018 1:49 pm © Case Number: CGC-17-557688 Filing Date: Oct-03-2018 1:46 Filed by: ROSALLIE GUMPAL Image: 06520518 ORDER TIMOTHY A BONNICI VS. CHARLES MCMACKIN ET AL 001006520518 Instructions: Please place this sheet on top of the document to be scanned.R. Michael Lieberman (SBN 120831) ey A Law Offices of R. Michael Lieberman ior COUM Oc 1398 Post Street Seen at San Frans San Francisco, CA 94109 Tel: 415-929-3197 Fax: 415-929-3476 Email: michael@spark84.com Attorneys for Defendants CARROLL HENRY and CHARLES MCMACKIN SUPERIOR COURT — STATE OF CALIFORNIA _ COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO — UNLIMITED JURISDICTION ~ TIMOTHY A. BONNICI, an individual, NO. CGC-17-557688 WK . [RREROSED] ORDER GRANTIN PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR RELIEF nol JUDGMENT AND AWARDING FEES COSTS TO DEFENDANTS Plaintiff, vs. mmm CHARLES MCMACKIN, an _ individual; te OCTOBER 3, 2018 CARROLL HENRY, an individual; and DOES os “Ni , 1 to 200, inclusive. DEPT.: 302 , , TRIAL DATE: NONE SET Defendants. HON. HAROLD A: KAHN 1/ [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR RELIEF OF JUDGMENT AND AWARDING FEES AND COSTS TO DEFENDANTSOn October 3, 2018 at 9:30 a.m., in Department 302 of the San Francisco Superior Court, th Honorable Harold A. Kahn presiding, this Court adopted its tentative ruling. : Satisfactory proof having been made, good cause appearing, and in furtherance of justice, IT IS ORDERED that plaintiff Timothy Bonnici's motion for relief from judgment is granted. Th January 24, 2018 judgment is set aside based on the mandatory relief provisions of CCP section 473(b) Defendants Charles McMackin and Carroll Henry are entitled to an award of fees and costs of $5,000 t be paid by Mr. Bonnici's counsel Gino Molinari no later than December 31, 2018. While this is less thar the amount claimed by defendants, the court's own review of the additional work caused by Mr. Molinari's admitted fault shows that the high range of reasonable fees and costs for that work is $5000. DATE: ocroszns =H wm JUDGE HAROLD KAHN 2/ [ER@R@SED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR RELIEF OF JUDGMENT AI AWARDING FEES AND COSTS TO DEFENDANTS ~~