On December 20, 2018 a
Miscellaneous
was filed
involving a dispute between
Lizzarago, Trynity,
and
Hill, Shari,
Hill, Taylor,
for PI Motor Vehicle
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
i i
M 01
A7TOFlMEY FOAGOIIRT USE ONtY
OR PAfiTV WITHOUT ATTORNEY Name Stafe 8ermamber mrd t ddressj
ALEXANDER C EISNER SBN 29846
SHAWN STEEL LAW FIRM
3010 OLD RANCH PKWY SUITE 260 SEAL BEACH CA 90 4q SUPERK7R COUT
OFp
LlFORiVtA
r Ep n 949 551 90 4 c ao 449 612 9797 CQUNTY QF SA t 8 F NARDtNO
ATTORNEY FOR Nerrre TRYNITY LIZZARAGQ AN BERtVt l L71FJC CtVll DIVISION
SUPERIOR COURT OF CAUFORNIA couum ot SAN BERNARDINO
247 WEST THIRD STREET
L QZ t
srn eraooREss
r vur aaaoR ss 247 WEST THIRD STREET
c v n a z Q cooE SAN BERNARI INO 42415 0210
a anr cr rann e SAN BERNARDINp DISTRICT CiVIL DNISION
CASE NAME LI ZARAGO v HILL
CASENUMBER
CIVI CASE COVER SHEET Complex Case Designation
0 Uniimited I irnited
ounter Jainrle
Amount Amount
1D E
demanded demanded is Filed first appearance by defendant
with
exceeds 25 0 25 000 ar tess Gal Rutes of Court rule 3 4a2 o P
ICems f 6 belaw must be compteted see Instructions on page 2
1 Gheck ons box t low for the case type that best describes this case
Auta ToK Contract PravtsMonalty Comptex Cive Lttigat on
8reach af contracUwananty j CaL Rules of Court rules 3 4tHl 3 403
Auto 22
Uninsured motaist 46 Rute 3 74Q collections 09 O AntilrusUTrac reguladan 03
Qther PIJPDlVYCI Persanai lher collections 09 Construclion deEeCt 10
Injury Property
DamageMtrongtul Death Tort L insurance coverage 18 Mass tprt 4Q
Asbestos 4d Q pther cantraci 37 L Securities litigaliqn 28
Q Product liabdity 24 Reai Property Q EnviranmentaUfoxic tort 30
Q Medicai ma practice 45
Q Emir ent dorrra nlinverse
Q insurance caverage ctaims ajising from tl e
id
Criher PIIPO WD 23 candemnation above listed provisionaliy complex case
Wrongful eviciion 33 lypes 41 j
Non PUPOMID Qtherj Toct
Er far cemsnt of Judgmeat
C 8usiness torUunfair business practice 07j
her reai prttperty 28
Enforcement oF judgment 20
Q Civil rights OS Unlawlul laer
Q Qefamation 13 COmrnerGial 31 MisceNan us CivN Complat t
Fraud 18 Residentiai 32 Q RICO 27
C lntellectual Property 19 Orugs 38 u C ther complaini not specitred above 42
Praiessionai negiigence 25 Judici l Review
Miscellaneous C1vt1 PetiUan
I 1 Asset forfeiture pS
I i Other npn PUPD WO tort 35 Q p ership and oorparate governance 27j
Petition re asbilraiion award ti
p qY ther petitian not specified abave 43
Q Wrongful termirtaiian 36 Q Writ ot mandate 02
Q Clther emplayment 15 7ther dieial review 39
2 This case is X is not compfex under nale 3 4Q0 of the California Fiules of Court if the case is comptex mark the
factors requiring exceptional judicial management
a 0 taige number a separateiy represented parties d large mber o witnesses
b Extensive motlon practice raising difficuit pr novel e C Coardination with related actions pending in one or more courts
issues ihat wiil be time consuming ta resolve in other counites states ar eountrte or n a federat couri
c Q Substa tial amount of docurnentary evidence f Substantiai postjudgment judicial supervislon
3 Remedies sought check ati fhatapply a monetary t Q nonmonetary declaratary ar in unctive elef Q nitive
4 Numb r of causes of action specrfy TWO GENER4L NEGLIGBNCE AND M TOR VEHICLE
5 Thts case is is noi a class action suit
6 if there are any knawn related cases fiEe and serve a natice af related case Yo y u or t 15
y
Oate 212U12418
gi ExANDFR C EISNER ESC
IYPE OR PRINT C ORNEY PARTY
NAAAEj
N T E
Ptaintiff must fiie this caver sheet with the first paper filed in ihe acttan or praceeciing except smail claims cases ar cases filed
under the Probate Code Farrrily Code or Welfare and Ins tutions Code Cal Rules of Gourt rule 3 22Q Failure to file may resuit
in sanctions
Fi1e this cover sheet in additio ta any c8ver sheet required 6y eat court ru1e
if this case is compiex under rute 3 4p0 et seq of the California Rules of Gaurt you musk serve a c py af this caver sheet on all
ather parties to the action or proceeding
Unless this is a coilections case under rule 3 740 ar a campiex case this cover sheet wiii be used ar statisticai puspases on
e s s
cai pubs a co ti a 3a s n s a a aaa s ao
Fw nao sa ro a torr uee G V L CASE COYER SFIE ET C StendsrcfsW Judi at A dm st atlon std 3 10
JndKiat Counctl Gaidomia
CMfiIQ Rgv Juty I 2407j 9
Y eFtlswLSr
rC 6 Form BWWv
GM 010
INSTRUCTlONS ON HOW TQ C4MPLETE THE COVER SHEET
To Rlaintifis and Ofhars iling Flrst Papers If you are filing a flrst paper for exarr le a cqrr iaintj in a civii case you must
complste and fite along with your flrst paper the CIvlJ Case Caver Sheef contained on page 1 This information will be u5ed to cnmpile
statistics about the types and numbers of cases filad You must complete items i thraugh 6 a the sheet In item t you must oheck
one bax or tfie case type that best tescribes the case If the oase flts both a generat and a more specific lype of case listed in item i
check the more specifiC one If the case has multipie causes of action cheCk the box that best indieates the primary cause of action
To assist you ln ct rr p eting the sheet examptes of ttte ases ihat belong under each case type in ltem 1 are ptovided betow A cover
sheet must be fiiled aniy with your irtikia paper Failure to fiie a caver sheet with the first paper fiiied in a civii case may suk ject a party
its counsei or both to sanctlons under rules 2 30 and 3 220 of the Catifqmia Rules of Court
To Parties tn Rule 3 74Q Collections Gases A collec ions case unc r rule 3 74Q is defined as a actian or recovery o money
owed in a sum stated to be certain that is not mare than 25 Op0 exciusive of interest and attorney s fees arising from a transactian i
whiCh property services ar money was acqui ed on credit A coilections case does nat include an actton seeking the foUowing t j tort
damages 2j Punitive damages 3 recavery of reai properh 4 recovery of persanal praPertY ar 5 a prejudgment writ of
attachment The Identi8aation af a case as a rule 3 740 collections case on this farm means that it wiii be exempt from the general
time for service requirements and case management rules unless a defendant files a responssve pieading A ruls 3 740 colkectlons
case witl be subject to ihe requirements for service and obta9ning a judgment in sule 3 740
Ta Parties in Comptex Cases In camplex oases pniy parties must also use the Civii Case Gaver Sheet to designate whether the
case is complex If a ptalntiff believes th case is complex under vte 3 40Q of the Cafif rnSa Rules of Gourt thls musf be tndkated by
campleting the appropriate baxes in items 1 and 2 if a piaintiff designates a case as compiex the caver sheet must be served with the
camplaint an ail parties to the actian A defendant may file and serve no later than the time of i s first appearance a jainder in the
pfatntifYs designation a counter clesignation that ihe case ts nat compiex or if the pEain ft has made no designatian a c esignation that
the case is campiex CASE TYPES AND EXAMPLE5
Auto Tort CaMract P ovlsiooaliy Complex Civit Lltigatlon Cal
Auto 22 F ersa ai InjurylFrc erly BreaCh af ContraCtJWanar ty 48 Ruies o Canrt Rules 3 40ti 403
DamageNVrongful Death Breach ol ReMaULease AntiirusUTrade Regulation 03
Unirtsured Motorist 46 if the Contraci rrot unlawJul detainer Consiructio Defect 14
case invalves uninsured or wrangtul evicfion Ciaims invoiving Mass Tc ri 40
ContracUWarraniy 8reach Setfer Securities Litigation 28
matodst c aim subjeG to
PlaintifF not fraud a n6gligerrce EnvironmentaUToxic Torf 90
arbitra6on Check this item
insfead of Autot Negtigent Beeaeh oF ConiracU insuran Covesa e Gtaims
Other PItPDlWD Rersonai Injury Y ar sing fiom provrsionally camp ez
Other Breach of CantracUWarranty case type listed above 41
Property OamagelWrangful Death
T K Colleciions e g money owed npen Eniorcemen af Judgment
bouk accounts U8 Enforcemeflt of JudgmeM 20
Asbestos 04
Asbestos Damage Cr Aeciion Case Selfer Plaintiff Abstract af Judgment Out of
Property
Other Promissory NotelCallections County
Asbesios Personal injury Contess
e of Judgment ncxr
Wrangiui Death
Insurance Coverage not provisionatly damestic retaUons
Pratuct Liabifily rrot asbestas or 8
Gpmp1eX Sister 5tate Judgment
taxic nviranmentalJ 24
MediCal MalpraGtice 4S Auta Subroga ian A ninistralive Aqer cy Award
Medicai Malpractice Cf rier Coverage natunpaid taxes
Surgeons
Physicians Oiher Coniract 37 PetiGaNCertification af EMry af
Qiher Prafessiar a Neatth Care Contractuaf Fraud Judgmen on Unpaid Taxes
af Jurfgment
Maipractice
Other PI PD WO 23j
Other Carnracl Dispute
Real Property OtheCa
Emineni Oomainllnverse Misceltaneaus Civii Complaint
Premises li biiity e g slip
iA RICt 27
and fatl Condemna6
IMernional Other ComplaiM not specified
Bodily InjurylPDiWD Wrongfui Eviction 33
above 42
e g assauit vanda ism Other Rea Property e g quiet titie 26
Intenlianat inflicti n at Writ ot Possessian of Real Deciaratory Relie 4niy
raperty
Emotianat 0istress
injunctive Relief Oniy non
Mortgage Foredosure
harassment
Negiigeni Infliction oC Quiet Titie echsnics lien
Emational Distress 4ther Reai Property r t eminent
Other Cortxnerciai CompiainT
t3ther PIiPDiW domarn larrdioaUtenant or
Case nan torUnon complex
Nan PI PD WD Other Tort loredosure
Other Civit COmplaint
Business ToNUn air Business UhiBxAul DetsinCr
nor tartfr nr mptex
Practice 07 Ganmerciaf 31
Miscellaneous Civii Petition
Civil F ights e g discrimirtatian Residential 32
PaMership and Carporate
false anestj not civii Drugs 38 if the case inuoJves iJlegal
Govem ce 21
harassr ntt t drugs check th s ftem atherwrse
Othef Petitian nvt specrfied
Defamation e siander libel report as Gommercial or ResidentialJ
g above 43
Judiciai Review Givil NarassmerEt
Fraud t6 Asset For eiture OS
Wodcpi e V salence
inteilecivai Property 19 Petitic n Re Arbii atan Award 11 Elder Clependent Adu1t
Protessional Ne ligence 25 Writ of Mandate 02 Aduse
t ega Matpractice Wrii Administrative Mandamus
Eleclian Ganiest
Qther Professianai Matpract sce Writ Mandamus on i imited Caurt petitian far Name Change
not medica or legal Case Matter Petition for Relief From Late
Other Non PIlPD1Wl7 Tort 35 V trit Other l mited CauR Case G
Empiayment r
C ther Civi Petition
Wrongfui Termination 36
OiherJudiciai Review 39
Other Employm nt 15 Review af Health Otficer C rder
Noticc of Appeal l a r
Commissioner A eals
vaQa s wz
c oio ae a y i 200
CIVlL CASE CQYER SHEET
Document Filed Date
December 20, 2018
Case Filing Date
December 20, 2018
Category
PI Motor Vehicle
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
i i M 01 A7TOFlMEY FOAGOIIRT USE ONtY OR PAfiTV WITHOUT ATTORNEY Name Stafe 8ermamber mrd t ddressj ALEXANDER C EISNER SBN 29846 SHAWN STEEL LAW FIRM 3010 OLD RANCH PKWY SUITE 260 SEAL BEACH CA 90 4q SUPERK7R COUT OFp LlFORiVtA r Ep n 949 551 90 4 c ao 449 612 9797 CQUNTY QF SA t 8 F NARDtNO ATTORNEY FOR Nerrre TRYNITY LIZZARAGQ AN BERtVt l L71FJC CtVll DIVISION SUPERIOR COURT OF CAUFORNIA couum ot SAN BERNARDINO 247 WEST THIRD STREET L QZ t srn eraooREss r vur aaaoR ss 247 WEST THIRD STREET c v n a z Q cooE SAN BERNARI INO 42415 0210 a anr cr rann e SAN BERNARDINp DISTRICT CiVIL DNISION CASE NAME LI ZARAGO v HILL CASENUMBER CIVI CASE COVER SHEET Complex Case Designation 0 Uniimited I irnited ounter Jainrle Amount Amount 1D E demanded demanded is Filed first appearance by defendant with exceeds 25 0 25 000 ar tess Gal Rutes of Court rule 3 4a2 o P ICems f 6 belaw must be compteted see Instructions on page 2 1 Gheck ons box t low for the case type that best describes this case Auta ToK Contract PravtsMonalty Comptex Cive Lttigat on 8reach af contracUwananty j CaL Rules of Court rules 3 4tHl 3 403 Auto 22 Uninsured motaist 46 Rute 3 74Q collections 09 O AntilrusUTrac reguladan 03 Qther PIJPDlVYCI Persanai lher collections 09 Construclion deEeCt 10 Injury Property DamageMtrongtul Death Tort L insurance coverage 18 Mass tprt 4Q Asbestos 4d Q pther cantraci 37 L Securities litigaliqn 28 Q Product liabdity 24 Reai Property Q EnviranmentaUfoxic tort 30 Q Medicai ma practice 45 Q Emir ent dorrra nlinverse Q insurance caverage ctaims ajising from tl e id Criher PIIPO WD 23 candemnation above listed provisionaliy complex case Wrongful eviciion 33 lypes 41 j Non PUPOMID Qtherj Toct Er far cemsnt of Judgmeat C 8usiness torUunfair business practice 07j her reai prttperty 28 Enforcement oF judgment 20 Q Civil rights OS Unlawlul laer Q Qefamation 13 COmrnerGial 31 MisceNan us CivN Complat t Fraud 18 Residentiai 32 Q RICO 27 C lntellectual Property 19 Orugs 38 u C ther complaini not specitred above 42 Praiessionai negiigence 25 Judici l Review Miscellaneous C1vt1 PetiUan I 1 Asset forfeiture pS I i Other npn PUPD WO tort 35 Q p ership and oorparate governance 27j Petition re asbilraiion award ti p qY ther petitian not specified abave 43 Q Wrongful termirtaiian 36 Q Writ ot mandate 02 Q Clther emplayment 15 7ther dieial review 39 2 This case is X is not compfex under nale 3 4Q0 of the California Fiules of Court if the case is comptex mark the factors requiring exceptional judicial management a 0 taige number a separateiy represented parties d large mber o witnesses b Extensive motlon practice raising difficuit pr novel e C Coardination with related actions pending in one or more courts issues ihat wiil be time consuming ta resolve in other counites states ar eountrte or n a federat couri c Q Substa tial amount of docurnentary evidence f Substantiai postjudgment judicial supervislon 3 Remedies sought check ati fhatapply a monetary t Q nonmonetary declaratary ar in unctive elef Q nitive 4 Numb r of causes of action specrfy TWO GENER4L NEGLIGBNCE AND M TOR VEHICLE 5 Thts case is is noi a class action suit 6 if there are any knawn related cases fiEe and serve a natice af related case Yo y u or t 15 y Oate 212U12418 gi ExANDFR C EISNER ESC IYPE OR PRINT C ORNEY PARTY NAAAEj N T E Ptaintiff must fiie this caver sheet with the first paper filed in ihe acttan or praceeciing except smail claims cases ar cases filed under the Probate Code Farrrily Code or Welfare and Ins tutions Code Cal Rules of Gourt rule 3 22Q Failure to file may resuit in sanctions Fi1e this cover sheet in additio ta any c8ver sheet required 6y eat court ru1e if this case is compiex under rute 3 4p0 et seq of the California Rules of Gaurt you musk serve a c py af this caver sheet on all ather parties to the action or proceeding Unless this is a coilections case under rule 3 740 ar a campiex case this cover sheet wiii be used ar statisticai puspases on e s s cai pubs a co ti a 3a s n s a a aaa s ao Fw nao sa ro a torr uee G V L CASE COYER SFIE ET C StendsrcfsW Judi at A dm st atlon std 3 10 JndKiat Counctl Gaidomia CMfiIQ Rgv Juty I 2407j 9 Y eFtlswLSr rC 6 Form BWWv GM 010 INSTRUCTlONS ON HOW TQ C4MPLETE THE COVER SHEET To Rlaintifis and Ofhars iling Flrst Papers If you are filing a flrst paper for exarr le a cqrr iaintj in a civii case you must complste and fite along with your flrst paper the CIvlJ Case Caver Sheef contained on page 1 This information will be u5ed to cnmpile statistics about the types and numbers of cases filad You must complete items i thraugh 6 a the sheet In item t you must oheck one bax or tfie case type that best tescribes the case If the oase flts both a generat and a more specific lype of case listed in item i check the more specifiC one If the case has multipie causes of action cheCk the box that best indieates the primary cause of action To assist you ln ct rr p eting the sheet examptes of ttte ases ihat belong under each case type in ltem 1 are ptovided betow A cover sheet must be fiiled aniy with your irtikia paper Failure to fiie a caver sheet with the first paper fiiied in a civii case may suk ject a party its counsei or both to sanctlons under rules 2 30 and 3 220 of the Catifqmia Rules of Court To Parties tn Rule 3 74Q Collections Gases A collec ions case unc r rule 3 74Q is defined as a actian or recovery o money owed in a sum stated to be certain that is not mare than 25 Op0 exciusive of interest and attorney s fees arising from a transactian i whiCh property services ar money was acqui ed on credit A coilections case does nat include an actton seeking the foUowing t j tort damages 2j Punitive damages 3 recavery of reai properh 4 recovery of persanal praPertY ar 5 a prejudgment writ of attachment The Identi8aation af a case as a rule 3 740 collections case on this farm means that it wiii be exempt from the general time for service requirements and case management rules unless a defendant files a responssve pieading A ruls 3 740 colkectlons case witl be subject to ihe requirements for service and obta9ning a judgment in sule 3 740 Ta Parties in Comptex Cases In camplex oases pniy parties must also use the Civii Case Gaver Sheet to designate whether the case is complex If a ptalntiff believes th case is complex under vte 3 40Q of the Cafif rnSa Rules of Gourt thls musf be tndkated by campleting the appropriate baxes in items 1 and 2 if a piaintiff designates a case as compiex the caver sheet must be served with the camplaint an ail parties to the actian A defendant may file and serve no later than the time of i s first appearance a jainder in the pfatntifYs designation a counter clesignation that ihe case ts nat compiex or if the pEain ft has made no designatian a c esignation that the case is campiex CASE TYPES AND EXAMPLE5 Auto Tort CaMract P ovlsiooaliy Complex Civit Lltigatlon Cal Auto 22 F ersa ai InjurylFrc erly BreaCh af ContraCtJWanar ty 48 Ruies o Canrt Rules 3 40ti 403 DamageNVrongful Death Breach ol ReMaULease AntiirusUTrade Regulation 03 Unirtsured Motorist 46 if the Contraci rrot unlawJul detainer Consiructio Defect 14 case invalves uninsured or wrangtul evicfion Ciaims invoiving Mass Tc ri 40 ContracUWarraniy 8reach Setfer Securities Litigation 28 matodst c aim subjeG to PlaintifF not fraud a n6gligerrce EnvironmentaUToxic Torf 90 arbitra6on Check this item insfead of Autot Negtigent Beeaeh oF ConiracU insuran Covesa e Gtaims Other PItPDlWD Rersonai Injury Y ar sing fiom provrsionally camp ez Other Breach of CantracUWarranty case type listed above 41 Property OamagelWrangful Death T K Colleciions e g money owed npen Eniorcemen af Judgment bouk accounts U8 Enforcemeflt of JudgmeM 20 Asbestos 04 Asbestos Damage Cr Aeciion Case Selfer Plaintiff Abstract af Judgment Out of Property Other Promissory NotelCallections County Asbesios Personal injury Contess e of Judgment ncxr Wrangiui Death Insurance Coverage not provisionatly damestic retaUons Pratuct Liabifily rrot asbestas or 8 Gpmp1eX Sister 5tate Judgment taxic nviranmentalJ 24 MediCal MalpraGtice 4S Auta Subroga ian A ninistralive Aqer cy Award Medicai Malpractice Cf rier Coverage natunpaid taxes Surgeons Physicians Oiher Coniract 37 PetiGaNCertification af EMry af Qiher Prafessiar a Neatth Care Contractuaf Fraud Judgmen on Unpaid Taxes af Jurfgment Maipractice Other PI PD WO 23j Other Carnracl Dispute Real Property OtheCa Emineni Oomainllnverse Misceltaneaus Civii Complaint Premises li biiity e g slip iA RICt 27 and fatl Condemna6 IMernional Other ComplaiM not specified Bodily InjurylPDiWD Wrongfui Eviction 33 above 42 e g assauit vanda ism Other Rea Property e g quiet titie 26 Intenlianat inflicti n at Writ ot Possessian of Real Deciaratory Relie 4niy raperty Emotianat 0istress injunctive Relief Oniy non Mortgage Foredosure harassment Negiigeni Infliction oC Quiet Titie echsnics lien Emational Distress 4ther Reai Property r t eminent Other Cortxnerciai CompiainT t3ther PIiPDiW domarn larrdioaUtenant or Case nan torUnon complex Nan PI PD WD Other Tort loredosure Other Civit COmplaint Business ToNUn air Business UhiBxAul DetsinCr nor tartfr nr mptex Practice 07 Ganmerciaf 31 Miscellaneous Civii Petition Civil F ights e g discrimirtatian Residential 32 PaMership and Carporate false anestj not civii Drugs 38 if the case inuoJves iJlegal Govem ce 21 harassr ntt t drugs check th s ftem atherwrse Othef Petitian nvt specrfied Defamation e siander libel report as Gommercial or ResidentialJ g above 43 Judiciai Review Givil NarassmerEt Fraud t6 Asset For eiture OS Wodcpi e V salence inteilecivai Property 19 Petitic n Re Arbii atan Award 11 Elder Clependent Adu1t Protessional Ne ligence 25 Writ of Mandate 02 Aduse t ega Matpractice Wrii Administrative Mandamus Eleclian Ganiest Qther Professianai Matpract sce Writ Mandamus on i imited Caurt petitian far Name Change not medica or legal Case Matter Petition for Relief From Late Other Non PIlPD1Wl7 Tort 35 V trit Other l mited CauR Case G Empiayment r C ther Civi Petition Wrongfui Termination 36 OiherJudiciai Review 39 Other Employm nt 15 Review af Health Otficer C rder Noticc of Appeal l a r Commissioner A eals vaQa s wz c oio ae a y i 200 CIVlL CASE CQYER SHEET