On February 26, 2019 a Motion,Ex Parte was filed involving a dispute between Torres, Christopher, Torres, Melissa, and Barnes Group Inc., As Successor By Acquisition Of Kar Products, Inc., A, Barnes Group Inc. As Successor By Acquisition Of Kar Products,Llc, B C Stocking Distributing, A California Corporation, B'Laster Llc, Chevron Corporation, A Delaware Corporation, Chevron U.S.A. Inc, Chevron U.S.A. Inc., Crc Industries, Inc. Which Will Do Businessin California As Pennsylvania Crc Industrie, Dap Products Inc., A Delaware Corporation, Does 3-100, Husqvarna Professional Products, Inc., A Delaware Corporation, Kern Oil & Refining Co., A California Corporation, Lighthouse For The Blind, Midwest Motor Supply Co., An Ohio Corporation, Nch Corporation, A Delaware Corporation, Oatey Co., An Ohio Corporation, Pennzoil-Quaker State Company, Petro Source Investments, Inc. A Delaware Corporation, Ppg Industries, Inc. A Pennsylvania Corporation, P-T Technologies, Inc., A Florida Corporation, Quaker State Corporation, As Successor By Acquistion Of Westland Oil Company, Inc., A, Safety-Kleen Systems, Inc., A Wisconsin Corporation, Union Oil Company Of California, A California Corporation, Wd-40 Company, A Delaware Corporation, for Product Liability Unlimited in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Please wait a moment while we load this page.
Preview
r SUPERIOR C4URT OF CAIIFORNIA 1 CSAN ERARDINO DISTRDC 2 JUIv 2 6 2019 3 il u1i i l t i 4 AMIE ARROYO PU Y 5 6 7 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 8 FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO 9 10 CHRISTOPHER TORRES and MELISSA 11 TORRES 12 Plaintiffs CASE NO CIVDS 1906092 13 V RULING ON MOTION FOR A 14 BARNES GROUP INC as successor by 15 pROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING acquisition of Kar Products Inc a Delaware corporation B C STOCKING DISTRIBUTING 16 a California corporation CHEVRON PENDING DISCOVERY CORPORATION a Delaware corporation 1 CRC INDUSTRIES INC which will do business in California as PENNSYLVANIA 1 g CRC INDUSTRIES INC a Pennsylvania corporation DAP PRODUCTS INC a 19 Delaware corporation et al 20 Defendants 21 22 23 The Court makes the following rulings on the following motions heard on June 26 2019 24 25 RULING 26 2 1 RULWG ON MOTION FOR A PROTECT IVE ORDER REGARDING PENDING DISCOVERY 28 The court finds Plaintiffs have not met their burden to demonstrate good cause for the full 1 2 protective order requested Plaintiffs have not identified redundancy in the discovery 3 propounded nor that the burden of response outweighs the likelihood that the discovery will lead 4 to admissible evidence Plaintiffs are permitted to jointly respond to the Form Interrogatories 5 with the exception that if any Request for Admissions were served concurrently with Form 6 Interrogatory No 17 1 those would need to be responded to individually The court finds the meet and confer requirement satisfied The court denies the full g 9 motion for protective order but grants the motion in part such that Plaintiffs is required to 10 respond once to Form Interrogatories Set 1 except as to Form Interrogatory No 17 1 if any 11 Request for Admissions were concurrently served 12 13 14 DATED June 26 2019 15 16 R AN F FOSTER JUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR COURT 1 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 2 RULING ON MOTION FOR A PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING PENDING DISCOVERY 28