Martinez Vs Carranza Lopez

Notice of Document Return.

Defendants' Reply in Support of Motion to Vacate/Amend Void Judgment and Strike Abstract and Writ(s) of Execution Based Thereon on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Request for Judicial Notice

Plaintiff's Opposition To Defendants' Motion To Vacate/Amend Void Judgment And Strike Abstract And Writs Of Execution Based Thereon on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Proof Of Service Of Application And Order For Appearance And Examination on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Document Return.

Application and Order for Appearance and Examination

[Proposed] Order Granting Defendants' Motion to Vacate/Amend Void Judgment and Strike Abstract and Writ(s) of Execution Based Thereon on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Defendants' Notice and Motion to Vacate/Amend Void Judgment and Strike Abstract and Writ(s) of Execution Based Thereon; Memorandum of Points and Authorities; Declaration of Jeanette D. Lawrence; Declaration of John C. Ellis; Declaration of Glenn S. Goldby on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Document Return.

Order from District Court of Appeal Appellant's application for an extension of time to serve and file the appellant's opening brief is GRANTED on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Proof of Service RE [Proposed] Order Granting Defendants' Motion to Vacate/Amend Void Judgment and Strike Abstract and Writ(s) of Executed Based Thereon on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Document Return.

Appeals Clerk's Certificate. on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Notice of Document Return.

Amended Notice to Prepare Transcript on Appeal due 07/11/23 on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Abstract of Judgment

Receipt for Record on Appeal Amended Notice to Prepare on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Notice to Prepare Transcript on Appeal. Record due on 07/11/23 on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Receipt for Record on Appeal Notice to Prepare on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Notification of Estimate of Costs on Appeal due 04/07/23 on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Notice of Change of Address or Other Contact Information on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Request for Estimate of Reporter's Transcript for M. Holt on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Register of Actions Imaged (Appeals). on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Request for Estimate of Reporter's Transcript by Christina Foster on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Request for Estimate of Reporter's Transcript by Michelle Castellanos on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Request for Estimate of Reporter's Transcript For Danny Andrews on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Notice of Ruling re: Hearing on Defendant's Motion to Tax Costs on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Minute Order: Hearing on Motion to Tax Costs by JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ, DAVID SANCHEZ

Tentative Ruling dated 3-1-23 Ordered to be Final Ruling

Appellant's Notice Designating Record on Appeal. on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Receipt for Record on Appeal Appeal Packet received by DCA on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Notification of Filing Notice of Appeal on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

Proof of Service re: [Proposed] Order Granting Defendants' Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding Verdict on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Proposed Order (hearing) re: Granting Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding Verdict on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ for hearing on 01/13/2023

Declaration of Edye A Hill for Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding Verdict

Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding Verdict on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Proposed Judgment

Order Fixing Time for Hearing Motion for New Trial. on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Defendant's Motion to Tax Costs on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

[Proposed] Order Granting Defendant's Motion to Tax Costs on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Clerk's Certificate of Mailing on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Defendants' Notice of Intent to File a Motion for New Trial on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

DEFENDANTS' OBJECTION TO PLAINTIFFS [PROPOSED] AMENDED JUDGMENT ON SPECIAL VERDICT on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Document Return.

Proposed Order Fixing Time for Hearing on Motion for New Trial on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Proof of Service Re: Proposed Order Granting Defendant's Motion to Tax Costs on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Memorandum of Costs (Summary) on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Entry of Judgment or Order on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Returned Mail

Defendants' Notice of Intent to File a Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding Verdict

Proof of Service by Electronic Service (non-complaint) of [Proposed Judgment on Special Verdict on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

DEFENDANTS OBJECTION TO PLAINTIFFS [PROPOSED] JUDGMENT ON SPECIAL VERDICT on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Minute Order: Court on its Own Motion

Certificate of Mailing

Judgment on Special Verdict

Notice of Document Return.

[Proposed] Judgment on Special Verdict

Jury Instructions

Special Verdict

Jury Request or Question(s) (Confidential). #1

Minute Order: Jury Trial - Jury Deliberating

Jury Question(s) (Confidential). # 2

Jury Question(s) (Confidential). # 3

Jury Foreperson Designation

Minute Order: Jury Trial in Progress

COURT RULING JOINT LIST OF JURY INSTRUCTIONS

Minute Order: Jury Trial in Progress

Exhibit List 01

Minute Order: Jury Trial in Progress

PLA'S BENCH BRIEF RE: CA CIVIL JURY INSTRUCTION 3929

Minute Order: Jury Trial in Progress

Minute Order: Jury Trial in Progress

Amended Minute Order: Jury Trial in Progress

Juror's Notes (Confidential)

Minute Order: Jury Trial in Progress

AMENDED JOINT EXHIBIT LIST

Court Ruling Re: Joint Designations, Counter Designations & Objections to Play the Videotaped Deposition of Standiford Helm II M.D. at time of trial

Juror's Notes (Confidential)

Court's ruling as to Joint Designations, Counter Designations & Objections to play the videotaped deposition of Albert Lai M.D. at time of trial

Minute Order: Jury Trial in Progress

Minute Order: Jury Trial in Progress

Jury Telephone Number List (Confidential)

Trial Documents

Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter as Official Reporter Pro Tempore

PLA'S OPPO TO DEFS' MIL NO. 18 TO EXCLUDE SKI INVESTIGATIONS INC.'S INVOICES FOR SUB ROSE SURVEILLANCE OF PLAINTIFF

Minute Order: Jury Trial in Progress

Juror Seating Chart - (Confidential)

Minute Order: Jury Trial

Jury Hardship Questionnaires (Confidential)

Alphabetical and Random Jury Lists from Jury Room (Confidential)

Amended Minute Order: Jury Trial

Minute Order: Jury Trial

JUROR QUALIFICATION QUESTIONNAIRE (blank)

Defendants’ Notice of Motion in Limine & MIL no. 18 to Exclude Ski Investigations, Inc.’s invoices for Sub Rosa surveillance of Plaintiff and Testimony and Improper Inferences thereof: MPA; Declaration of Glenn S. Goldby

Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter as Official Reporter Pro Tempore

Minute Order: Jury Trial Trailing

Court Ruling re: Joint Designations, Counter Designations and Objections to Play the Videotaped Deposition of Albert Anderson, M.D. at Time of Trial

Court Ruling re: Joint Designations, Counter Designations and Objections to Play the Videotaped Deposition of Andrew Germanovich, M.D., at Time of Trial

Court Ruling re: Joint Designations, Counter Designations and Objections to Play the Videotaped Deposition of Ali Najafi MD at Time of Trial

Court Ruling re: Joint Designations, Counter Designations and Objections to Play the Videotaped Deposition of Tooraj Gravori, M.D., at Time of Trial

Court Ruling re: Joint Designations, Counter Designations and Objections to Play the Videotaped Deposition of Michael Dawson DC, at Time of Trial

Plaintiff's Reply to Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No 12

Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter as Official Reporter Pro Tempore

Notice of Document Return.

Proposed Joint Witness List

Joint Exhibit List

DEF'S NTC OF MIL NO. 17 TO PRECLUDE TESTIMONY FROM DR. ELAINE KINDLE, EXCLUDE EXPERT TESTIMONY RELYING ON DR. KINDLE'S OPINIONS AND TO EXCLUDE MATERIAL EVIDENCE REALTED PLAINTIFF'S PRCEDURES INVOLVING A SPINAL CORD STIMULATOR; MPA'S; DECL OF EDYE A. HILL

PLA'S OPPOSITION TO DEF'S MIL NO. 17 TO EXCLUDE TESTIMONY FROM DR. ELAINE KINDLE, EXCLUDE EXPERT TESTIMONY RELYING ON DR. KINDLE'S OPINIONS AND TO EXCLUDE MATERIAL EVIDENCE REALTED TO PLAINTIFF'S PRCEDURES INVOLVING A SPINAL CORD STIMULATOR

(PROP) JOINT LIST OF JURY INSTRUCTIONS

DEFENDANT'S TRIAL BRIEF

Notice of Document Return.

Opposition to Mtn in Limine

Trial Binders

jury trial documents

Minute Order: Court on its Own Motion

Minute Order: Jury Trial

Minute Order: Jury Trial Trailing

Certificate of Mailing

Minute Order: Jury Trial Trailing

Minute Order: Jury Trial Trailing

Notice of Case Reassignment to Department

Notice of Hearing at Continued Trial Call on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Reassignment of Department for All Purposes on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Remote Appearance for Hearing on April 8, 2022 Jury Trial Trailing on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Minute Order: Jury Trial Trailing

Notice of Document Return.

Notice of Ruling re: Jury Trial Trailing hearing scheduled for April 8, 2022 at 8:30am in Dept PS2 on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Remote Appearance for Hearing on April 8, 2022 Jury Trial on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Remote Appearance for Hearing on 4-8-22 Jury Trial on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Remote Appearance for Hearing on Jury trial - April 8, 2022 on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Joint Statement of the Case

Minute Order: Jury Trial Trailing

Joint Designations, Counter Designations and Objections to Play the Videotaped Deposition of Standiford Helm, II, M.D. at time of Trial

Trial Docs

Joint Designations, Counter Designations and Objections to Play the Videotaped Depostion of Albert Lai, M.D. at time of Trial

Notice of Telephonic Appearance for Hearing on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Special Verdict Form

Minute Order: Notice Of Ex Parte Application And Ex Parte Application; (1) to Quash Subpoenas Duces Tecum and (2) an Order for Evidentiary Sanctions

(Proposed) Joint List of Jury Instructions

Joint Witness List

Notice of Errata re: Exhibit H attached to Ex Parte Application. on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition TO DEFENDANTS EX PARTE APPLICATION: (1) TO QUASH PLAINTIFFS SUBPOENAS DUCES TECUM PURSUANT TO CCP 1987.1, AND 2) AN ORDER FOR EVIDENTIARY SANCTIONS PURSUANT TO CCP 2023.030; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES; DECLARATION OF HEATHER N. SEIGLER on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Minute Order: Notice Of Ex Parte Application And Ex Parte Application; (1) to Quash Subpoenas Duces Tecum and (2) an Order for Evidentiary Sanctions

Minute Order: Jury Trial Trailing

Notice of Hearing (eFiling) on Ex Parte Application re: on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Motion for Protective Order and for Sanctions Against Plaintiff & Plaintiff Counsel on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice Of Ex Parte Application And Ex Parte Application; (1) to Quash Subpoenas Duces Tecum and (2) an Order for Evidentiary Sanctions on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Courtesy copies of Notice of Ex Parte Application/Proposed Order

Proposed Order (hearing) re: Ex Parte Application on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ for hearing on 02/02/2022

Reply FOR MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER TO PRECLUDE DEPOSITIONS DOCUMENT PRODUCTION AFTER THE DISCOVERY CUT-OFF DEADLINE AND FOR 3,575.00 IN SANCTIONS AGAINST PLAINTIFF PLAINTIFF COUNSEL; DECLARATION OF EDYE A. HILL on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Joint Designations, Counter Designations and Objections to Play the Videotaped Deposition of Tooraj Gravori, M.D., at Time of Trial on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Minute Order: Hearing re: Motion for Protective Order by JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ, DAVID SANCHEZ

JOINT DESIGNATIONS, COUNTER DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAY THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF ALI NAJAFI, MD AT TIME OF TRIAL

Joint Designations, Counter Designations and Objections to Play the Videotaped Deposition of Andrew Germanovich, M.D. at Time of Trial on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

JOINT DESIGNATIONS, COUNTER DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAY THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF ALBERT ANDERSON, M.D. AT TIME OF TRIAL

Opposition TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

JOINT DESIGNATIONS, COUNTER DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAY THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF MICHAEL DAWSON, DC AT TIME OF TRIAL

Notice of Telephonic Appearance for Hearing

Notice of Telephonic Appearance for Hearing on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition TO PLAINTIFFS EX PARTE APPLICATION TO ENFORCE COURT ORDER; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES; DECLARATION OF ANI ASLANIAN on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Minute Order: Jury Trial Trailing

Notice of Ruling re: PLAINTIFFS EX-PARTE APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER ENFORCING THIS COURTS DECEMBER 22, 2021 RULING RE: PRODUCTION OF SUB ROSA MATERIALS [DEC. OF M. JEANDRON] on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Minute Order: Ex Parte Hearing re: an Order Enforcing this Court's December 22, 2021 ruling RE: Production of Sub Rosa Materials (Dec. of M. Jeandron) by BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Reply to Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 12: To Exclude Defense Medical Billing Expert Marilyn Pacheco on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Document Return.

Notice of Hearing (eFiling) on Ex Parte Application re: on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Ex Parte Application re: an Order Enforcing this Court's December 22, 2021 ruling RE: Production of Sub Rosa Materials (Dec. of M. Jeandron) on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Document Return.

Reply To Defendants Opposition to Plaintiff's Amended Motion in Limine No. 11: to Preclude Evidence of Alternate Cause on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Telephonic Appearance for Hearing on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

DEFENDANTS OPPOSITION TO PL;AINTIFFS AMENDED MOTION IN LIMINE NO 11 on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter as Official Reporter Pro Tempore

Minute Order: Hearing re: Motion to Compel: Answer/Response to Production of Documents by BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Reply TO PLAINTIFFS OPPOSITION TO DEFENDNATS MOTION IN LIMINE NO.16 TO PRECLUDE PLAINTIFFS NON-RETAINED EXPERT ALBERT ANDERSONMD FROM TESTIFING AT TRIAL on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Reply TO PLAINTIFFS OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO.14 TO PRECLCUDE PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATED AND RETAINED EXPERT on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Reply TO PLAINTIFFS OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO.15 PRECLUDE ANDREW MORRIS D.C FROM TESTIFYING ABD OFFERING EVIDENCE PERTAINING on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

DEFENDANTS OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFD MOTION IN LIMINE NO.12 TO EXCLUDE DEFENSE MEDICAL BILLING EXPERT MARILYN PACHECO

Minute Order: Jury Trial

Opposition to Motion in Limine re: NO.16 to exclude Plaintiff's Non-Retained expert, Albert Anderson, M.D. from testifying at trial

Certificate of Mailing

Reply to Defendants' Opposition to Motion to Compel Further Responses to Request for Production and Production of Documents and Things, Set Two on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Minute Order: Court on its Own Motion

Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 14 to Preclude Plaintiff's Designated and Retained Expert, Khyber Zaffarkarhan, D.O., from Testifying at Trial on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Statement of Agreement or Nonagreement on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Motion in Limine re: No. 15 for an Order Precluding Andrew Morris, D.C., from Testifying and Offering any Evidence Pertaining to Medical Billing on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Amended Motion in Limine No. 11 to Preclude Evidence of Alternate Cause on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Trial Brief on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Defendants' Notice of Motion in LImine and Motion in Limine No. 14 to Preclude Plaintiff's designated and retained expert, Khyber Zaffarkhan, D.O. from testifying at trial on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Defendants' Notice of Motion in Limine and Motion in Limine No. 15 for an Order Precluding Andrew Morris, D.C. from testiffying; Memorandum of Points & Authorities; Declaration of Ani Aslanian on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Proposed Order re: Defendant's Mtoin in Limine No. 14 on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 12: to Exclude Defense Medical Billing Expert Marilyn Pacheco on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Minute Order: Jury Trial

Objection to: PLAINTIFFS NOTICE FOR WARREN M GERSTEIN TO APPEAR AND PRODUCE DOCUMENTS AND MATERIALS AT TRIAL on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Document Return.

Defendants' Notice of Motion in Limine and Motion in Limine No. 16 to exclude Plaintiff's non-retained expert, Albert Anderson, M.D. from testifying at trial; Memorandum of Points & Authorities; Declaration of Ani Aslanian on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Proposed Order re: Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 15 on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion To Compel Further Responses to Request for Production of Documents on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Proposed Order re: Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 16 on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Motion in Limine re: NO.13 : To exclude argument of when or why Defendants admitted liability

Notice of Document Return.

Proposed Order (hearing) re: Joint Timeline Chart for hearing on 12/23/2021

Objection to: PLAINTIFFS OTICE FOR SUANE ALAN MINARD TO APPEAR AND PRODUCE DOCUMENTS AND MATERIALS AT TRIAL on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Objection to: PLAINTIFFS NOTICE FOR THE PERSON MOST KNOWLEDGABLE (PMK) OF SKI INVESTIGATIONS TO APPEAR AND PRODUCE DOCUMENTS AND MATERIALS AT TRIAL on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Joint Exhibit List

Joint Witness List

Defendants Motion In Limine NO.13 to Exclude Argument and Evidence of when or why defendants Admitted Liability; Memorandum of Points and Authorities; Declaration of Jeanette D Lawrence on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Proposed Order (hearing) re: Granting Defendants Motion In Limine to Exclude Argument and Evidence of When or Why Defendants Admitted Liability on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ for hearing on 12/23/2021

Joint List of Jury Instructions

Declaration of EDYE A. HILL for Protective Order to Preclude Depositions & Document Production after the Discovery Cut-Off Deadline

Notice of Document Return.

Proposed Order (hearing) re: GRANTING THE MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ for hearing on 01/26/2022

Declaration of Pre-Trial Good Faith By Michael Jeandron, Esq.

Motion for Protective Order to Preclude Depositions & Document Production after the Discovery Cut-Off Deadline on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Reply to Defendant's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 5: to Exclude "Factoring" evidence

Reply to Defendant's opposition to Plaintiff's Motion in LImine No. 9: to permit Plaintiff Benjamin Martinez to testify as to the full amounts billed for his medical treatment

Reply to Defendant's opposition to Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 3 to exclude evidence that Plaintiff was referred to Doctors by an Attorney

Reply to Defendant's opposition to Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 10: to preclude defense counsel Robert Reisinger from Making improper arguments and/or referencing his own life

Reply to Defendants opposition to Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 8 : to exclude evidence regarding civil case involving Andrew Morris, DC

Reply to Defendants' opposition to Plaintiff's Motion in LImine No.1: to exclude evidence Plaintiff failed to mitigate damages by not treating through health insurance for past medical care

Minute Order: Ex Parte Hearing re: an Order advancing Hearing on Plaintiffs discovery Motion

Certificate of Mailing

Reply to Defendants' opposition to Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No.4: to prevent Defendants and Their experts from publishing, referencing, or admitting medical record hearsay into evidence without the proper foundation

Reply to Defendants' opposition to Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No.2: to exclude evidence of health insurance or medicare reimbursement rates to discount Plaintiff's Past and Future Medical Expenses

Opposition to Motion in Limine No. 8 on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Courtesy Copy of Opposition to Plaintiffs Ex Parte

Opposition TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 4 TO PREVENT DEFENDANTS AND THEIR EXPERTS FROM PUBLISHING, REFERENCING, OR ADMITTING MEDICAL RECORD HEARSAY INTO EVIDENCE WITHOUT FOUNDATION on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Motion in Limine No. 5 on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 2 TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF HEALTH INSURANCE OR MEDICARE REIMBURSEMENT RATES TO DISCOUNT PLAINTIFFS PAST AND FUTURE MEDICAL EXPENSES on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 3 TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE THAT PLAINTIFF WAS REFERRED TO DOCTORS BY AN ATTORNEY on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Answer to Complaint of MARTINEZ by JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ, DAVID SANCHEZ represented by FORD, WALKER, HAGGERTY & BEHAR filed. (Over $25,000.00)

Legacy Minute Order: Case Management Conference Hearing

Certificate of Counsel filed. The zip code is 92201.

Notice (PLAINTIFFS) OF CASE REASSIGNMENT AND C CONTINUED CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE by BEJAMIN MARTINEZ filed.

Proof of Service (Sub-Served and Mailed) on Complaint of MARTINEZ as to APPLE MARKETS INC; mailing date of 09/09/19 filed.

System Generated Notice re: CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE HEARING.

Notice of Case Assigned to Department PS2. (Palm Springs)

Notice of Appeal of Order in Superior Court with Deposit on Appeal of Order JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ

PLAINTIFF'S OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO TAX COSTS on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Reply for Motion to Tax Costs on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Minute Order: Hearing re: Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding Verdict by Carranza Lopez & Sanchez

Receipt for Exhibits

Corrected Nunc Pro Tunc Exhibit List 01

Minute Order: Hearing re: Motion for New Trial by by Carranza Lopez & Sanchez

Minute Order: Nunc Pro Tunc Hearing

NOTICE OF RULING AT HEARING ON DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL AND MOTION FOR JUDGMENT NOT WITHSTANDING THE VERDICT (JNOV) on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Defendants Reply for Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding Verdict on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Minute Order: Hearing re: Order to Show Cause re: SUBMISSION OF JUDGMENT as to BEJAMIN MARTINEZ; Roberts/Jeandron

Tentative Ruling dated 1-13-23 Ordered to be Final Ruling

Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter as Official Reporter Pro Tempore

Declaration of DEANNA AUSTIN

PLAINTIFF'S OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR JUDGMENT NOTWITHSTANDING THE VERDICT; DECLARATION OF JENNY ANGLIN, ESQ. IN SUPPORT on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Response to PLAINTIFFS MOTION AND MOTION TO STRIKE EVIDENCE on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Reply for Defendants' Motion for New Trial on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Declaration of JULIE FULKMAN

Declaration of JARED DOBBINS

OBJECTION TO EVIDENCE; MOTION TO STRIKE EVIDENCE on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

PLAINTIFF'S OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL; DECLARATION OF JENNY ANGLIN, ESQ. IN SUPPORT on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Declaration of IRMA GONZALEZ

Declaration of edye A Hill for Motion for New Trial

Motion for New Trial on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Proposed Order (hearing) re: Granting Motion for New Trial on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ for hearing on 01/13/2023

SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF EDYE A. HILL FOR DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL

Returned Mail

Opposition TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 1 TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE THAT PLAINTIFF FAILED TO MITIGATE DAMAGES BY FAILING TO TREAT THROUGH HEALTH INSURANCE FOR PAST MEDICAL TREATMENT on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 9 TO PERMIT PLAINTIFF TO TESTIIFY AS TO THE FULL AMOUNTS BILLED FOR HIS MEDICAL TREATMENT on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Plaintiffs Ex Parte Application for an Order Advancing Hearing on Plaintiffs Discovery Motion; Declaration of Robert L. Reisinger on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE NO.11 TO PRECLUDE EVIDENCE OR ALTERNATE CAUSE on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Ex Parte Application re: Plaintiff's Ex Parte Application for an order advancing hearing on Plaintiff's Discovery Motion [Dec.of. M. Jeandron] on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Motion in Limine re: No. 1 to Exclude Testimony or Evidence on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 10 TO EXCLUDE DEFENSE COUNSEL FROM ARGUING ABOUT HIS OWN LIFE on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Telephonic Appearance for Hearing on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Hearing (eFiling) on Ex Parte Application re: on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Motion in Limine re: No. 3 to Exclude Testimony and Evidence on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Motion in Limine re: No. 7 RE: Covid -19 on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Motion in Limine re: No. 2 to Exclude Testimony and Evidence on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Non- Opposition to Motion in Limine No. 6 RE: To limit Plaintiff 's Experts Testimony on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Non-Opposition to Motion in No. 4 "Golden Rule" Arguments on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Motion in Limine re: No. 5 RE: "Reptile Theory" on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Motion in Limine re: No. 8 and 9 RE: Improper Voir Dire and "Anchoring" on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Motion in Limine re: No. 11 RE: Loss of Earnings on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Plaintiff's Ex Parte Application for an order advancing hearing on Plaintiff's Discovery Motion

Non- Opposition to Motion in Limine No. 10 RE: Exclude Witnesses on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Opposition to Motion in Limine re: No. 12 Re: Duplicative, Cumulative Witnesses on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 4 EXCLUDE EVIDENCE TESTIMONY AND ARGUMENT OF THE ' GOLDEN RULE'MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES; DECLARATION OF GLENN S GOLDBY on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 3 TO EXCLUDE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE OF DEFENDANTS INSURANCE; DECLARATION OF GLENN S GOLDBY on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO.1 TO EXCLUDE TESTIMONY OR EVIDENCE OF MEDICAL BILLS IN EXCESS OF THE AMOUNTS PAID; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES DECLARATION OF GLENN S GOLDBY on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO.5 TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE, TESTIMONY AND ARGUMENT OF THE "REPTILE THEORY"; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES; DECLARATION OF GLENN S GOLDBY on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO.02 TO EXCLUDE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE NOT PREVIOUSLY PRODUCED IN DISCOVERY BY PLAINTIFF;MEMORANDUM OFPOINTS AND AUTHORITIES;DECLARATION OF GLENN S GOLDBY on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO.7 TO PRECLUDE EXAMINATION REGARDING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC OR MAKING ARGUMENTS TO INCOKE SYMPATHY FROM THE JURY;MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES; DECLARATION OF GLEEN S GLODBY on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Defendants Motion in Limine NO.9 to Exclude Improper VOIR DIREl; Memorandum Of Points and Authorities; Declaration of Glenn S Goldby on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 6 TO LIMIT PLAINTIFFS EXPERTS TESTIMONY TO THOSE OPINIONS DISCLOSED AT DEPOSITIONS AND TO EXCLUDE TESTIMONY BASED UPON MATERIALS NOT REVIWED OR PORVIDED AT THE EXPERTS DEPOSTION on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Defendants Motion In Limine NO.8 to Preclude Plaintiffs Counsel From Preconditioning Jurors During Voir Dire and Opening Statements with Hypothetical or Dollar Figures Specific To The Case("Anchoring");Declaration of Glenn S Goldby on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Motion in Limine re: Defedants Motion In Limine NO.12 To Exclude Duplicate Witnesses ;Memorandum Of Points and Authorities; Declaration of Glenn S Goldby on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Telephonic Appearance for Hearing on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Defendants Motion in Limine NO.11 To Exclude/Limit Plaintiff' s Loss Of Earnings and Loss Of Earning Capacity Claims; Memorandum of Points and Authorities; Declaration of Glenn S Goldby on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Defendants Motion In Limine NO.10 Excluding Witnesses Prior To The Giving Of Testimony; Memorandum Of Points and Authorities; Declaration of Glenn S Goldby on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Separate Statement in Support of Plainitff's Motion to Compel Further Responses to Request for Production of Documents and Tangible Things on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 4: to Prevent Defendants and their Experts from Publishing, Referencing, or Admitting Medical Record Hearsay Into Evidence Without the Proper Foundation on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 3: to Exclude Evidence that Plaintiff was Referred to Doctors by an Attorney on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 1: To Exclude Evidence Plaintiff Failed to Mitigate Damages by not Treating Through Health Insurance for Past Medical Care on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Motion to Compel Further Responses to Request for Production of Document and Things; Declaration Answer/Response to Production of Documents on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 2: to Exclude Evidence of Health Insurance or Medicare Reimbursement Rates to Discount Plaintiff's Past and Future Medical Expenses on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 6: to Preclude Mention of Multiple Law Firms Representing Plaintiff on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 9: to Permit Plaintiff Benjamin Martinez to Testify as to the full Amounts Billed for his Medical Treatment on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 7: to Exclude All Non-Party Witnesses from the Courtroom until they have been "Excused" from Testifyingn on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 5: to Exclude "Factoring" Evidence on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 8: to Exclude Evidence Regarding Civil Cases Involving Andrew Morris, DC on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Trial Setting Order; Honorable Judge David M Chapman

Minute Order: Trial Setting Conference

Notice of Telephonic Appearance for Hearing on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Change of Firm Name on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 10: to Preclude Defense Counsel Robert Reisinger From Making Improper Arguments and/or Referencing his Own Life on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Minute Order: Motion to Compel further Response to Request for Identification and Production of Documents Set One/Declaration

Notice of Association of Counsel on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Telephonic Appearance for Hearing on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Amendment to Trial Setting Order; Honorable Judge David M Chapman

Minute Order: Trial Setting Conference

Clerk's Certificate of Mailing of Minute Order dated 08/13/20.

Notice of Reassignment of Department for All Purposes on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Proposed Order

Separate Statement in support of Motion to Compel Re Request for Production of Documents Set One

Legacy Minute Order: Trial Setting Conference

Notice of Telephonic Appearance for Hearing on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Reply IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS MOTION TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR IDENTIFICATRION AND PRODUCTIONS OF DOCUMENTS (SET ONE), DECLARATION OF ANI ASLANIAN on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Plaintiff's Motion in Limine No. 11: to Preclude Evidence of Alternate Cause on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Legacy Minute Order: Trial Setting Conference

Clerk's Certificate of Mailing on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Notice of Document Return.

Minute Order: Continuance of Trial Setting Conference

Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendant's Motion to Compel Further Responses to Requests for Production of Documents, Set One; Declaration of Michael Jeandron, Esq. on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Motion to Compel further Response to Request for Identification and Production of Documents Set One/Declaration Answer/Response to Production of Documents

Legacy Minute Order: Case Management Conference Hearing

Notice of posting jury fees by BEJAMIN MARTINEZ.

Case Management Statement filed by JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ, DAVID SANCHEZ

Notice of Department Reassignment for all purposes Hearing re: Case Management Conference is rescheduled to 03/05/20 at 8:30 in Department PS2.

Notice of posting jury fees by JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ, DAVID SANCHEZ.

Complaint Filed Fast Track. (Palm Springs)

Opposition to CROSS DEFENDANTS MOTION TO STRIKE PORTIONS OF THE AMENDED CROSS COMPLAINT by DEFENDANTS filed

Proof of Service (Sub-Served and Mailed) on Complaint of MARTINEZ as to JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ; mailing date of 09/18/19 filed.

Summons Issued on Complaint of MARTINEZ and filed.

Civil Case Cover Sheet filed.

Case Management Statement filed by BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Demand for Jury Trial by JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ, DAVID SANCHEZ filed

Minute Order: Jury Trial – Jury Deliberating

Oppostion to Motion in Limine re: No. 15 for an Order Precluding Andrew Morris, D.C., from Testifying and Offering any Evidence Pertaining to Medical Billing on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Oppostion to Motion in Limine re: NO.16 to exclude Plaintiff's Non-Retained expert, Albert Anderson, M.D. from testifying at trial

Oppostion to Motion in Limine re: NO.13 : To exclude argument of when or why Defendants admitted liability

Proposed Order (hearing) re: Joint Timeline Chart for hearing on 12/15/2021

Proposed Order (hearing) re: Granting Defendants Motion In Limine to Exclude Argument and Evidence of When or Why Defendants Admitted Liability on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ for hearing on 12/10/2021

Oppostion to Motion in Limine re: No. 1 to Exclude Testimony or Evidence on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Oppostion to Motion in Limine re: No. 2 to Exclude Testimony and Evidence on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Oppostion to Motion in Limine re: No. 3 to Exclude Testimony and Evidence on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Oppostion to Motion in Limine re: No. 5 RE: "Reptile Theory" on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Oppostion to Motion in Limine re: No. 8 and 9 RE: Improper Voir Dire and "Anchoring" on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Oppostion to Motion in Limine re: No. 12 Re: Duplicative, Cumulative Witnesses on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Oppostion to Motion in Limine re: No. 7 RE: Covid -19 on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Oppostion to Motion in Limine re: No. 11 RE: Loss of Earnings on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

Proposed Order (hearing) re: Ex Parte Application on Complaint of BEJAMIN MARTINEZ for hearing on 02/04/2022

Proposed Order (hearing) re: Joint Timeline Chart for hearing on 02/04/2022

PLA'S REPLY TO DEF'S OPPOSITION TO PLA'S MIL NO. 12 TO EXCLUDING DEF MEDICAL BILLING EXPERT MARILYN PACHECO

Proposed Order (hearing) re: Joint Timeline Chart for hearing on 04/22/2022

Proposed Order (hearing) re: Joint Timeline Chart for hearing on 12/10/2021

Proposed Order (hearing) re: Joint Timeline Chart for hearing on 05/27/2022

Proposed Order (hearing) re: Joint Timeline Chart for hearing on 01/07/2022

NON-PROOF OF SERVICE HEARING SET FOR 1/02/20 AT 8:30 IN DEPT CLKP

CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET FILED.

CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT FILED BY BEJAMIN MARTINEZ

NOTICE (PLAINTIFFS) OF CASE REASSIGNMENT AND C CONTINUED CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE BY BEJAMIN MARTINEZ FILED.

CLERK'S CERTIFICATE OF MAILING OF MINUTE ORDER DATED 08/13/20.

PROOF OF SERVICE (SUB-SERVED AND MAILED) ON COMPLAINT FILED 09/03/2019 OF BEJAMIN MARTINEZ AS TO APPLE MARKETS INC; MAILING DATE OF 09/09/19 FILED.

DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL BY JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ, DAVID SANCHEZ FILED

CERTIFICATE OF COUNSEL FILED. THE ZIP CODE IS 92201.

ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED 09/03/2019 OF BEJAMIN MARTINEZ BY JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ, DAVID SANCHEZ REPRESENTED BY FORD, WALKER, HAGGERTY & BEHAR FILED. (OVER $25,000.00)

CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT FILED BY JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ, DAVID SANCHEZ

NOTICE OF CASE ASSIGNED TO DEPARTMENT PS2. (PALM SPRINGS)

SYSTEM GENERATED NOTICE RE: CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE HEARING.

COURT ON ITS OWN MOTION SET ON 8/13/20 AT 8:30 IN DEPARTMENT PS2

JURY FEE DEPOSIT OF $150.00 PAID BY JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ, DAVID SANCHEZ.

COMPLAINT FILED FAST TRACK. (PALM SPRINGS)

NOTICE OF DEPARTMENT REASSIGNMENT FOR ALL PURPOSES HEARING RE: CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE IS RESCHEDULED TO 03/05/20 AT 08:30 IN DEPARTMENT PS2.

NOTICE OF POSTING JURY FEES BY BEJAMIN MARTINEZ.

OPPOSITION TO CROSS DEFENDANTS MOTION TO STRIKE PORTIONS OF THE AMENDED CROSS COMPLAINT BY DEFENDANTS FILED

PROOF OF SERVICE (SUB-SERVED AND MAILED) ON COMPLAINT FILED 09/03/2019 OF BEJAMIN MARTINEZ AS TO JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ; MAILING DATE OF 09/18/19 FILED.

DAVID SANCHEZ ERRONEOUSLY SUED AS APPLE MARKETS INC

ESUBMIT FEE BY DEFENDANTS

ON COMPLAINT FILED 09/03/2019 OF BEJAMIN MARTINEZ AS TO BEJAMIN MARTINEZ ATTORNEY CABRAL LAW GROUP ADDED.

SUMMONS ISSUED ON COMPLAINT FILED 09/03/2019 OF BEJAMIN MARTINEZ AND FILED.

MINUTE ORDER: CONTINUANCE OF TRIAL SETTING CONFERENCE

ESUBMIT FEE BY DEFENDANT

NOTICE OF POSTING JURY FEES BY JOSE HUMBERTO CARRANZA LOPEZ, DAVID SANCHEZ.

JURY FEE DEPOSIT OF $150.00 PAID BY BEJAMIN MARTINEZ.