We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

XIN CHEN VS GHP MANAGEMENT CORPORATION ET AL

On July 13, 2018 an other commercial/business tort (not fraud/ breach of contract) (general jurisdiction) case was filed by (Subcribe to view) represented by (Subcribe to view) against (Subscribe to view) represented by (Subscribe to view) in the jurisdiction of Los Angeles County. Judge Elihu M. Berle presiding.

Case Details

Case Number

(Subscribe to View)   

Filing Date

July 13, 2018

Last Refreshed

November 17, 2023

Filing Location

Los Angeles County, CA

Filing Court House

Stanley Mosk Courthouse

OTHER JUDGES ON THIS CASE

Robert A;

Judge

Hon. Elihu M. Berle Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Elihu M. Berle   

Category

Other Commercial/Business Tort (not fraud/ breach of contract) (General Jurisdiction)

Practice Area

Commercial

Matter Type

Breach of Contract

Case Outcome Type

Unknown disposition

Status

Unknown

OTHER JUDGES ON THIS CASE

Overview
Causes of Action

COMPLAINT FOR:

OF CIVIL CODE, §

NTRACT;

AND

BUSINESS PRACTICES

F. CODE § 17200);

TRIAL

Parties

Plaintiffs

Chen Xin
Chiang Brian

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Affeld David William
Markevitch David
Robinson Damion D
Grivakes Chris Andrew

Defendants

4914 Olive Street Properties Llc
Bridewell Properties Ltd
Canyon Sierra Apartments
Ccv Partnership Ii
Easton Investments Ii
Figter Limited
Gh Palmer Associates
Ghp Management Corporation
Lr 9Th & Broadway Llc
Orsini Iii Llc
Palmer Boston Street Iii
Palmer Boston Street Ii Lp
Palmer Boston Street Properties Ii Inc.
Palmer Boston Street Properties I L.P.
Palmer City Center Ii Inc.
Palmer Flower Street Properties Ii Llc
Palmer Flower Street Properties Ii Lp
Palmer Ontario Properties Lp
Palmer Sand Canyon Ltd.
Palmer-Saugus
Palmer St. Paul Properties Lp
Palmer Temple Street Properties Llc
Palmer Temple Street Properties L.P.
Palmer Third Street Properties L.P.
Park Sierra Apartments Llc
Park Sierra Properties
Park Sierra Properties Ii Inc.
Park Sierra Properties Ii Ltd.
Piero Properties Ii Llc
Saugus Colony Limited
Solemint Heights Partnership
Upland Village Green
Upland Village Green Llc
Visconti Apartments Llc
Warner Center Summit Ltd.
Westcreek Properties Ltd.
Chen Xin
Chiang Brian

Attorneys for Defendants

Amin Siobhan Coley
Haas Jason Lee
Latham Robert Allen Iii
Nguyen Hao Thi
Velie Erik Stephen
Waxman Robert Michael
O'Meara Frances Mary

Other Parties

4914 Olive Street Properties Llc (Appellant)
Bridewell Properties Ltd (Appellant)
Canyon Sierra Apartments (Appellant)
Ccv Partnership Ii (Appellant)
Easton Investments Ii (Appellant)
Figter Limited (Appellant)
Gh Palmer Associates (Appellant)
Ghp Management Corporation (Appellant)
Lr 9Th & Broadway Llc (Appellant)
Palmer Boston Street Ii Lp (Appellant)
Palmer Boston Street Iii (Appellant)
Palmer Boston Street Properties I L.P. [Doe 1] (Appellant)
Palmer Boston Street Properties Ii Inc. (Appellant)
Palmer City Center Ii Inc. (Appellant)
Palmer Ontario Properties Lp (Appellant)
Palmer Sand Canyon Ltd. (Appellant)
Palmer St. Paul Properties Lp (Appellant)
Palmer Temple Street Properties L.P. (Appellant)
Palmer Third Street Properties L.P. (Appellant)
Park Sierra Properties (Appellant)
Park Sierra Properties Ii Inc. (Appellant)
Park Sierra Properties Ii Ltd. (Appellant)
Saugus Colony Limited (Appellant)
Upland Village Green Llc (Appellant)
Warner Center Summit Ltd. (Appellant)
Westcreek Properties Ltd. (Appellant)

Case Documents

Appeal Record Delivered

Date: Jan 14, 2022

Substitution of Attorney

Date: Sep 08, 2020

Joint Status Report

Date: Jan 08, 2020

Substitution of Attorney

Date: Dec 13, 2019

Status Report ((Joint))

Date: Nov 15, 2019

Joint Status Report

Date: Sep 20, 2019

Substitution of Attorney

Date: Apr 05, 2019

Joint Statement

Date: Apr 03, 2019

Notice of Appearance

Date: Mar 27, 2019

Notice of Ruling

Date: Mar 22, 2019

Joint Statement

Date: Mar 08, 2019

Notice of Ruling

Date: Feb 11, 2019

Complaint ( (1st))

Date: Jan 31, 2019

Status Report

Date: Dec 10, 2018

Status Report

Date: Sep 21, 2018

Proof-Service/Summons

Date: Sep 19, 2018

Receipt

Date: Aug 27, 2018

Notice

Date: Aug 27, 2018

Order

Date: Aug 15, 2018

Complaint

Date: Jul 13, 2018

Case Events

Type Description
Declaration - PLAINTIFFS' COMPENDIUM OF DECLARATIONS IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL
Motion for Preliminary Approval of Settlement
Proof of Service (not Summons and Complaint)
Notice of Ruling - NOTICE OF RULING AT STATUS CONFERENCE
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (FURTHER STATUS CONFERENCE)
Status Report
Stipulation and Order - STIPULATION AND ORDER STIPULATION AND ORDER RE: LEAD COUNSEL
Notice of Ruling - NOTICE OF RULING AT STATUS CONFERENCE
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (STATUS CONFERENCE)
Status Report
Stipulation and Order - STIPULATION AND ORDER STIPULATION AND PROPOSED ORDER STAYING MATTERS FOR 30 DAYS
Appeal - Remittitur - Appeal Dismissed - APPEAL - REMITTITUR - APPEAL DISMISSED (B316382)
Stipulation and Order - STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER STAYING LITIGATION FOR 90 DAYS
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (STATUS CONFERENCE; HEARING ON MOTION - OTHER TO APPOINT REFER...)
Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter as Official Reporter Pro Tempore
Status Report
Reply - REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO APPOINT REFEREE
Informal Discovery Conference
Declaration - DECLARATION OF NICK TOURSE IN SUPPORT OF OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO APPOINT REFEREE TO DETERMINE CLASS LIST AND QUALIFYING DEPOSIT WITHHOLDINGS
Declaration - DECLARATION OF JASON L. HAAS IN SUPPORT OF OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO APPOINT REFEREE TO DETERMINE CLASS LIST AND QUALIFYING DEPOSIT WITHHOLDINGS
Opposition - OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO APPOINT REFEREE TO DETERMINE CLASS LIST AND QUALIFYING DEPOSIT WITHHOLDINGS
Motion for Order - PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION TO APPOINT REFEREE TO DETERMINE CLASS LIST AND QUALIFYING DEPOSIT WITHHOLDINGS; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES; DECLARATION OF DAMION R
Notice of Ruling
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (HEARING ON MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT)
Substitution of Attorney
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (STATUS CONFERENCE)
Stipulation and Order - STIPULATION AND ORDER TO VACATE STATUS CONFERENCE ON JUNE 21, 2022
Declaration - COMPENDIUM OF DECLARATIONS IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS' UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT AND SETTLEMENT NOTICE
Motion for Preliminary Approval of Settlement - PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF MOTION AND UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT AND SETTLEMENT NOTICE; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AU
Proof of Service (not Summons and Complaint)
Order - ORDER SETTING STATUS CONFERENCE
Status Report - STATUS REPORT RE: MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF CLASS SETTLEMENT AND REQUEST FOR STATUS CONFERENCE
Notice of Ruling - NOTICE OF RULING RE: SETTLEMENT APPROVAL SCHEDULE
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE - SETTLEMENT)
hearing Department 6 at 312 North Spring Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Order to Show Cause - Settlement
Notice of Ruling - NOTICE OF RULING RE: JANUARY 25, 2022 STATUS CONFERENCE
Docket Event Notice of Ruling (re: January 25, 2022 Status Conference)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Status Conference ((Pre Trial Conference)) - Not Held - Vacated by Court

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (NON-APPEARANCE CASE REVIEW)
Clerks Certificate of Service By Electronic Service
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Non-Appearance Case Review

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Docket Event Clerks Certificate of Service By Electronic Service
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event Minute Order ( (Non-Appearance Case Review))
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event Appeal Record Delivered
Filed by Clerk
Notice of Settlement - NOTICE OF SETTLEMENT OF ENTIRE CASE
Docket Event Notice of Settlement of Entire Case
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Stipulation and Order - STIPULATION AND ORDER STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER
Docket Event Stipulation and Order (Stipulated Protective Order)
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant); Palmer Boston Street Properties II, Inc. (Defendant) et al.
Appeal - Notice Court Reporter to Prepare Appeal Transcript
Docket Event Appeal - Notice Court Reporter to Prepare Appeal Transcript
Filed by Clerk
Appeal - Notice of Filing of Notice of Appeal
Docket Event Appeal - Notice of Filing of Notice of Appeal
Filed by Clerk
Appeal - Ntc Designating Record of Appeal APP-003/010/103
Docket Event Appeal - Ntc Designating Record of Appeal APP-003/010/103
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Appellant); GHP Management Corporation (Appellant); Palmer Boston Street II, LP (Appellant) et al.
Appeal - Notice of Appeal/Cross Appeal Filed
Docket Event Appeal - Notice of Appeal/Cross Appeal Filed
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Appellant); GHP Management Corporation (Appellant); Palmer Boston Street II, LP (Appellant) et al.
Objection - OBJECTION PLAINTIFFS' OBJECTION TO DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF OCTOBER 18, 2021 INFORMAL DISCOVERY CONFERENCE FILINGS
Docket Event Objection (Plaintiffs' Objection to Defendant's Notice of October 18, 2021 Informal Discovery Conference Filings)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Notice - NOTICE OF OCTOBER 18, 2021 INFORMAL DISCOVERY CONFERENCE RULINGS
Docket Event Notice (of October 18, 2021 Informal Discovery Conference Rulings)
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant); Palmer Flower Street Properties II, LP (Defendant) et al.
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (INFORMAL DISCOVERY CONFERENCE (IDC))
Docket Event Minute Order ( (Informal Discovery Conference (IDC)))
Filed by Clerk
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

hearing Department 6 at 312 North Spring Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Informal Discovery Conference (IDC)
Notice - NOTICE OF ENTRY OF JUDGMENT OR ORDER (CONSOLIDATING RELATED CASES FOR ALL PURPOSES)
Informal Discovery Conference
Docket Event Informal Discovery Conference
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Notice (of Entry of Judgment or Order (Consolidating Related Cases for All Purposes))
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Notice of Ruling - NOTICE OF RULING ON MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE CROSS-COMPLAINT AND STATUS CONFERENCE RE: CLASS NOTICE
Docket Event Notice of Ruling (on Motion for Leave to File Cross-Complaint and Status Conference Re: Class Notice)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (FURTHER STATUS CONFERENCE; HEARING ON MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FIL...)
Stipulation and Order to use Certified Shorthand Reporter - STIPULATION AND ORDER TO USE CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTER JEANESE JOHNSON, CSR # 11635
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Further Status Conference - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Docket Event Minute Order ( (Further Status Conference; Hearing on Motion for Leave to Fil...))
Filed by Clerk
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Hearing on Motion for Leave to File a Cross-Complaint - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Docket Event Stipulation and Order to use Certified Shorthand Reporter (Jeanese Johnson, CSR # 11635)
hearing Department 6 at 312 North Spring Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Further Status Conference
hearing Department 6 at 312 North Spring Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Hearing on Motion for Leave to File a Cross-Complaint
Stipulation and Order - STIPULATION TO CONSOLIDATE RELATED ACTIONS FOR ALL PURPOSES AND ORDER
Docket Event Stipulation to Consolidate Related Actions for All Purposes and Order
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Reply (Defendants' Reply to Opposition to Motion for Leave to File Class Action Cross-Complaint)
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant); Palmer Boston Street Properties II, Inc. (Defendant) et al.
Status Report - STATUS REPORT JOINT STATUS REPORT RE: CLASS NOTICE
Docket Event Status Report (Joint Status Report RE: Class Notice)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Opposition - OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE CLASS-ACTION CROSS-COMPLAINT
Docket Event Opposition (To Defendant's Motion for Leave to File Class-Action Cross-Complaint)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Order - ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION AND APPOINTMENT OF CLASS COUNSEL
Docket Event Order Granting Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification and Appointment of Class Counsel
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Notice of Lodging - NOTICE OF LODGING OF PROPOSED ORDER RE: CLASS CERTIFICATION AND OBJECTIONS
Docket Event Notice of Lodging (of Proposed Order Re: Class Certification and Objections)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Motion for Leave to File a Cross-Complaint
Other - - DEFENDANTS' NOTICE OF ASSOCIATION OF COUNSEL
Declaration - DECLARATION OF JASON L. HASS IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE CLASS ACTION CROSS-COMPLAINT
Docket Event Motion for Leave to File a Cross-Complaint
Filed by GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Docket Event Declaration (of Jason L. Hass in Support of Defendants' Motion for Leave to File Class Action Cross-Complaint)
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Docket Event Defendants' Notice of Association of Counsel
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Objection - OBJECTIONS TO NOTICE OF RULING
Docket Event Objections to Notice of Ruling
Filed by GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Stipulation and Order to use Certified Shorthand Reporter - STIPULATION AND ORDER TO USE CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTER SHEILA PHAM, CSR # 13293
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (HEARING ON MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION)
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Hearing on Motion for Class Certification - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Docket Event Minute Order ( (Hearing on Motion for Class Certification))
Filed by Clerk
hearing Stipulation and Order to use Certified Shorthand Reporter (Sheila Pham, CSR # 13293)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
hearing Department 6 at 312 North Spring Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Hearing on Motion for Class Certification
hearing
Opposition - OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT'S EX PARTE
Docket Event Opposition (to defendant's Ex Parte)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Ex Parte Application - EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER GRANTING LEAVE TO FILE ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE IN SUPPORT OF THEIR OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATIONS ON SHORTENED TIME
Docket Event Ex Parte Application (for an Order Granting Leave to File Additional Evidence in Support of Their Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Class Certifications on Shortened Time)
Filed by GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Supplemental Declaration - SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF DAMION ROBINSON IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION
Reply - PLAINTIFFS' REPLY TO REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION
Proof of Service (not Summons and Complaint)
Response - RESPONSE TO EVIDENTIARY OBJECTIONS
Objection - PLAINTIFFS' EVIDENTIARY OBJECTIONS IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION
Reply - PLAINTIFFS' REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION
Docket Event Plaintiffs' Evidentiary Objections in Support of Motion for Class Certification
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Plaintiffs' Reply to Request for Judicial Notice in Support of Motion for Class Certification
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Proof of Service (not Summons and Complaint)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Response (to Evidentiary Objections)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Plaintiffs' Reply in Support of Motion for Class Certification
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
hearing Supplemental Declaration (of Damion Robinson in Support of Plaintiff's Motion for Class Certification)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff)
Notice - NOTICE OF RELEVANT DECISION OF THE CALIFORNIA SUPREME COURT
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Hearing on Motion for Class Certification - Not Held - Continued - Stipulation

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Docket Event Notice (of Relevant Decision of the California Supreme Court)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Hearing on Motion for Class Certification - Not Held - Advanced and Continued - by Court

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

hearing Department 6 at 312 North Spring Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Hearing on Motion for Class Certification
Other - - APPENDIX OF EVIDENCE IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS' OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTIONS FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION [VOL. 3 OF 3 (EXH. 29-55)]
Other - - APPENDIX OF EVIDENCE IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS' OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTIONS FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION [VOL. 2 OF 3]
Docket Event Appendix of Evidence in Support of Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiff's Motions for Class Certification [Vol. 2 of 3]
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant); Orsini III, LLC (Defendant) et al.
Docket Event Appendix of Evidence in Support of Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiff's Motions for Class Certification [Vol. 3 of 3 (Exh. 29-55)]
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant); Orsini III, LLC (Defendant) et al.
Opposition - DEFENDANTS' OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS' MOTIONS FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION
Objection - EVIDENTIARY OBJECTIONS IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS' OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTIONS FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION
Other - - APPENDIX OF EVIDENCE IN SUPPORT PF DEFENDANTS' OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTIONS
Opposition - DEFENDANTS' OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS' REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS' MOTIONS FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION
Docket Event Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiffs' Request for Judicial Notice in Support of Plaintiffs' Motions for Class Certification
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Docket Event Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motions for Class Certification
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Docket Event Evidentiary Objections in Support of Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiff's Motions for class certification
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Docket Event Appendix of Evidence in Support pf Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiff's Motions
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Docket Event Minute Order ( (Informal Discovery Conference (IDC)))
Filed by Clerk
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

hearing Informal Discovery Conference (IDC)
Response - PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE BRIEF TO DEFENDANT'S IDC STATEMENT
Docket Event Plaintiffs' Response Brief to Defendant's IDC Statement
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Informal Discovery Conference - JOINT INFORMAL DISCOVERY CONFERENCE STATEMENT
Docket Event Joint Informal Discovery Conference Statement
Clerks Certificate of Service By Electronic Service
Order - ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT'S EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER CONTINUING DEFENDANTS' DEADLINE TO FILE THEIR CLASS CERTIFICATION OPPOSITIONS AND CORRESPONDING BRIEFING AND HEARING DATES
Request - PLAINTIFFS' REQUEST FOR LEAVE TO FILE SURREPLY TO DEFENDANTS' IMPROPER REPLY BRIEF ON EX PARTE APPLICATION TO CONTINUE CLASS CERTIFICATION HEARING
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (COURT ORDER: RE EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER CONTINUING ...)
Docket Event Clerks Certificate of Service By Electronic Service
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event Minute Order ( (Court Order: Re Ex Parte Application for an Order Continuing ...))
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event Order Granting Defendant's Ex Parte Application for an Order Continuing Defendants' Deadline to File their Class Certification Oppositions and Corresponding Briefing and Hearing Dates
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event Plaintiffs' Request for Leave to File Surreply to Defendants' Improper Reply Brief on Ex Parte Application to Continue Class Certification Hearing
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Court Order

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Reply - DEFENDANTS' REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER CONTINUING DEFENDANTS' DEADLINE TO FILE THEIR CLASS CERTIFICATION OPPOSITIONS AND CORRESPONDING BRIEFING AND HEARING DAT
Docket Event Defendants' Reply in Support of Their Ex Parte Application For an Order Continuing Defendants' Deadline to File Their Class Certification Oppositions and Corresponding Briefing and Hearing Dates
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant); Palmer Boston Street Properties II, Inc. (Defendant) et al.
hearing Plaintiffs' Opposition To Defendants' Ex Parte Application To Continue Class Certification Hearing; Declaration Of Damion Robinson
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Ex Parte Application (For An Order Continuing Defendant's Deadline to File Their Class Certification Opposition and Corresponding Briefing and Hearing Dates)
Filed by GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Hearing on Motion for Class Certification - Not Held - Continued - Stipulation

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Notice of Ruling - NOTICE OF RULING AT INFORMAL DISCOVERY CONFERENCE
Docket Event Notice of Ruling at informal discovery conference
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (INFORMAL DISCOVERY CONFERENCE (IDC))
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Docket Event Minute Order ( (Informal Discovery Conference (IDC)))
Filed by Clerk
hearing Department 6 at 312 North Spring Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Informal Discovery Conference (IDC)
Notice - NOTICE OF INFORMAL DISCOVERY CONFERENCE
Docket Event Notice Of Informal Discovery Conference
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Exhibit List - COMPENDIUM OF DECLARATIONS IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION AND APPOINTMENT OF CLASS COUNSEL VOLUME II
Exhibit List - COMPENDIUM OF DECLARATIONS IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION AND APPOINTMENT OF CLASS COUNSEL VOLUME I
Motion for Class Certification
Exhibit List - COMPENDIUM OF DECLARATIONS IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION AND APPOINTMENT OF CLASS COUNSEL VOLUME III
Request for Informal Discovery Conference - Complex - PLAINTIFFS' REQUEST FOR INFORMAL DISCOVERY CONFERENCE
Request for Judicial Notice
Proof of Service (not Summons and Complaint)
Docket Event Plaintiffs' Request for Informal Discovery Conference
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Compendium of Declarations in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification and Appointment of Class Counsel Volume II
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Compendium of Declarations in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification and Appointment of Class Counsel Volume I
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Proof of Service (not Summons and Complaint)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Motion for Class Certification
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Request for Judicial Notice
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Compendium of Declarations in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification and Appointment of Class Counsel Volume III
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Stipulation and Order - STIPULATION AND ORDER MODIFYING MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEFING SCHEDULE AND RELATED DISCOVERY ISSUES
Docket Event Stipulation and Order (Modifying Motion for Class Certification Briefing Schedule and Related Discovery Issues)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff)
Substitution of Attorney
Docket Event Substitution of Attorney
Filed by Robert Allen Latham, III (Attorney) Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for
Notice of Ruling - NOTICE OF RULINGS AT STATUS CONFERENCE AND INFORMAL DISCOVERY CONFERENCE
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (INFORMAL DISCOVERY CONFERENCE (IDC))
Docket Event Joint Status Report Regarding Discovery and Mediation
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Notice of Rulings at Status Conference and Informal Discovery Conference
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff)
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Docket Event Minute Order ( (Informal Discovery Conference (IDC)))
Filed by Clerk
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) - Not Held - Rescheduled by Court

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Unknown - NOTICE OF CONTINUANCE DUE TO COVID-19 STATE OF EMERGENCY DECLARATIONS
Clerks Certificate of Service By Electronic Service
Docket Event Notice of Continuance Due to COVID-19 State of Emergency Declarations
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event Clerks Certificate of Service By Electronic Service
Filed by Clerk
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) - Not Held - Rescheduled by Court

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Other - - JOINT INFORMAL DISCOVERY CONFERENCE STATEMENT
Docket Event Joint Informal Discovery conference statement
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Notice of Ruling - NOTICE OF RULING RE: JANUARY 12, 2020 STATUS CONFERENCE
Docket Event Notice of Ruling (re: January 12, 2020 Status Conference)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (FURTHER STATUS CONFERENCE)
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Further Status Conference - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Docket Event Minute Order ( (Further Status Conference))
Filed by Clerk
Status Report - JOINT STATUS REPORT
Docket Event Joint Status Report
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Substitution of Attorney
hearing Substitution of Attorney
Filed by Frances Mary O'Meara (Attorney)
Answer - ANSWER TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
Answer - ANSWER TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT OF GHP MANAGEMENT CORPORATION AND DEFENDANTS LISTED BELOW
hearing Answer to First Amended Complaint of GHP Management Corporation and Defendants Listed Below
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
hearing Answer (to First Amended Complaint)
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); Palmer Boston Street Properties II, Inc. (Defendant); Palmer Flower Street Properties II, LP (Defendant) et al.
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (STATUS CONFERENCE; HEARING ON DEMURRER - WITH MOTION TO STRIK...)
Docket Event Minute Order ( (Status Conference; Hearing on Demurrer - with Motion to Strik...))
Filed by Clerk
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Status Conference - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Hearing on Demurrer - with Motion to Strike (CCP 430.10) - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Status Report - STATUS REPORT (JOINT)
Docket Event Status Report ((Joint))
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff)
Reply - DEFENDANTS' REPLY TO PLAINTIFFS' OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO STRIKE
Reply - REPLY TO PLAINTIFFS' OPPOSITION TO DEMURRER OF ALL DEFENDANTS TO PLAINTIFFS' FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
Docket Event Defendants' Reply to Plaintiffs' Opposition to Motion to Strike
hearing Reply (to Plaintiffs' Opposition to Demurrer of All Defendants to Plaintiffs' First Amended Complaint)
Opposition - PLAINTIFFS XIN CHEN AND BRIAN CHIANG'S OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO STRIKE
Docket Event Plaintiffs Xin Chen and Brian Chiang's Opposition to Defendants' Motion to Strike
Opposition - PLAINTIFFS XIN CHEN AND BRIAN CHIANG'S OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' DEMURRER
Docket Event Plaintiffs Xin Chen and Brian Chiang's Opposition to Defendants' Demurrer
Request for Judicial Notice
Declaration - DECLARATION OF HAO T. NGUYEN IN SUPPORT OF DEMURRER TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
Motion to Strike (not anti-SLAPP) - without Demurrer - MOTION TO STRIKE PLAINTIFFS' FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
Demurrer - without Motion to Strike - DEMURRER OF ALL DEFENDANTS TO PLAINTIFFS' FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
Declaration - DECLARATION OF ERIK VELIE, ESQ. IN SUPPORT OF DEMURRER TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
Docket Event Request for Judicial Notice
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
hearing Demurrer of all Defendants to Plaintiffs' First Amended Complaint
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant); Orsini III, LLC (Defendant) et al.
hearing Declaration (of Erik Velie, Esq. in Support of Demurrer to First Amended Complaint)
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
hearing Motion to Strike Plaintiffs' First Amended Complaint
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant); Orsini III, LLC (Defendant) et al.
hearing Declaration (of Hao T. Nguyen in Support of Demurrer to First Amended Complaint)
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Notice of Ruling - NOTICE OF RULING RE: SEPTMEBER 26, 2019 STATUS CONFERENCE
Docket Event Notice of Ruling (RE: Septmeber 26, 2019 Status Conference)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (STATUS CONFERENCE)
Docket Event Minute Order ( (Status Conference))
Filed by Clerk
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Status Conference - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Notice of Change of Address or Other Contact Information
Docket Event Notice of Change of Address or Other Contact Information
Filed by GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Joint Status Conference Report - JOINT STATUS REPORT
Docket Event Joint Status Report
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Status Conference - Not Held - Continued - Stipulation

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Request - JOINT STATUS REPORT AND REQUEST FOR CONTINUANCE OF POST-MEDIATION DEADLINES
Docket Event Joint Status Report and Request for Continuance of Post-Mediation Deadlines
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Notice - NOTICE OF ORDERS ISSUED AT STATUS CONFERENCE
Docket Event Notice (of Orders issued at Status Conference)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (STATUS CONFERENCE)
Docket Event Minute Order ( (Status Conference))
Filed by Clerk
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Status Conference - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Substitution of Attorney
Docket Event Substitution of Attorney
Filed by Frances Mary O'Meara (Attorney)
Other - - JOINT STATEMENT
Docket Event Joint Statement
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff); GH Palmer Associates (Defendant) et al.
Notice of Appearance - NOTICE OF APPEARANCE FOR VARIOUS DEFENDANTS
Notice of Appearance
Notice - NOTICE OF ORDER ISSUED AT STATUS CONFERENCE
Docket Event Notice (of Order Issued at Status Conference)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Notice of Appearance
Filed by Palmer Temple Street Properties, LLC (Defendant); LR 9th & Broadway LLC (Defendant); Figter Limited (Defendant) et al.
Docket Event Notice of Appearance (for Various Defendants)
Filed by GH Palmer Associates (Defendant); Orsini III, LLC (Defendant); Palmer Boston Street II, LP (Defendant) et al.
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (STATUS CONFERENCE; STATUS CONFERENCE)
Notice of Ruling
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Status Conference - Held - Continued

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Status Conference - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Docket Event Minute Order ( (Status Conference; Status Conference))
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event Notice of Ruling
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Notice - NOTICE OF CONTINUED STATUS CONFERENCE
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (COURT ORDER RE: RELATED CASES)
Docket Event Certificate of Mailing for (Minute Order (Court Order re: related cases) of 03/18/2019)
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event Notice (of Continued Status Conference)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Court Order

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Docket Event Minute Order ( (Court Order re: related cases))
Filed by Clerk
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (STATUS CONFERENCE)
Docket Event Minute Order ( (Status Conference))
Filed by Clerk
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Status Conference - Held - Continued

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Status Conference Statement - Joint Statement
Docket Event Joint Statement
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Opposition - Opposition to Request for Dismissal of individual claims against Xin Chen; Memorandum of Points and Authorities
Docket Event Opposition (to Request for Dismissal of individual claims against Xin Chen; Memorandum of Points and Authorities)
Filed by GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Notice of Related Case - Notice of Related Case (19STCV03883)
Docket Event Notice of Related Case ((19STCV03883))
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Notice of Ruling
Docket Event Notice of Ruling
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Minute Order - Minute Order (Court Order denying plaintiff's request to dismiss individual...)
Certificate of Mailing for - Certificate of Mailing for Minute Order (Court Order denying plaintiff's request to dismiss individual...) of 02/05/2019
Docket Event Certificate of Mailing for (Minute Order (Court Order denying plaintiff's request to dismiss individual...) of 02/05/2019)
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event Minute Order ( (Court Order denying plaintiff's request to dismiss individual...))
Filed by Clerk
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Court Order

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Amendment to Complaint (Fictitious/Incorrect Name)
Complaint - (Amended)
Proof of Service (not Summons and Complaint)
Notice of Lodging - Notice of Lodging in support of Request For Dismissal of individual claims of Xin Chen
Request for Dismissal - Request for Dismissal of individual claims of Xin Chen; Memorandum of Points and Authorities; Declarations of Xin Chen, Brian Chiang, and Damion Robinson
Docket Event Complaint ( (1st))
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Proof of Service (not Summons and Complaint)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Notice of Lodging (in support of Request For Dismissal of individual claims of Xin Chen)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
hearing Amendment to Complaint (Fictitious/Incorrect Name)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
hearing Request for Dismissal (of individual claims of Xin Chen; Memorandum of Points and Authorities; Declarations of Xin Chen, Brian Chiang, and Damion Robinson)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Brian Chiang (Plaintiff)
Order - Order for electronic service
Docket Event Order (for electronic service)
Filed by Clerk
Minute Order - Minute Order (Order to Show Cause Re: Settlement; Initial Status Conference)
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Initial Status Conference - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Docket Event Minute Order ( (Order to Show Cause Re: Settlement; Initial Status Conference))
Filed by Clerk
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Order to Show Cause Re: (Settlement) - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Proof of Service (not Summons and Complaint)
Docket Event Proof of Service (not Summons and Complaint)
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff)
Minute Order - Minute Order (Order to Show Cause Re: $10, 000.00 Sanctions against Defenda...)
Docket Event Minute Order ((Order to Show Cause Re: $10, 000.00 Sanctions against Defenda...))
Filed by Clerk
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Order to Show Cause Re: ($10, 000.00 Sanctions against Defendants for FTA on 9/28/18, 11/06/18, and 12/14/18;) - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Order to Show Cause Re: (entry of default against Defendants) - Held

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Initial Status Conference - Held - Continued

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Declaration - Declaration of Erik S. Velie regarding the Court's Orders To Show Cause
Notice of Appearance - Notice of Appearance for GHP Management Corporation
Docket Event Declaration (of Erik S. Velie regarding the Court's Orders To Show Cause)
Filed by GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Docket Event Notice of Appearance (for GHP Management Corporation)
Filed by GHP Management Corporation (Defendant)
Minute Order - Minute Order (Initial Status Conference; Order to Show Cause Re: Sanctions ...)
Docket Event Minute Order ((Initial Status Conference; Order to Show Cause Re: Sanctions ...))
Filed by Clerk
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Initial Status Conference - Held - Continued

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Order to Show Cause Re: (Sanctions against Defendant for FTA on 9/28/18) - Held - Continued

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Order to Show Cause Re: (Sanctions against Defendant for FTA on 11/06/18) - Held - Continued

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Status Report
Docket Event Status Report
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff)
Minute Order - Minute Order (Initial Status Conference)
hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Order to Show Cause Re: (Sanctions against Defendant for FTA on 9/28/18)

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

hearing in Department 6, Elihu M. Berle, Presiding
Initial Status Conference - Held - Continued

Judge: Elihu M. Berle

Docket Event Minute Order ((Initial Status Conference))
Filed by Clerk
Other - - Plaintiff's Further Status Statement
Docket Event Plaintiff's Further Status Statement
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff)
Notice - NOTICE OF CONTINUED. INITIAL STATUS CONFERENCE AND ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
Docket Event Notice Re: Continuance of Hearing and Order
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Notice NOTICE OF CONTINUED. INITIAL STATUS CONFERENCE AND ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
Minute Order - Minute order entered: 2018-09-28 00:00:00
hearing in Department 6
Initial Status Conference (Initial Status Conference; Court makes order) -
Docket Event Minute order entered: 2018-09-28 00:00:00
Filed by Clerk
Other - - PLAINTIFF S STATUS STATEMENT
Docket Event Status Report
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff)
Docket Event PLAINTIFF S STATUS STATEMENT
Proof of Service of Summons and Complaint -
hearing Proof-Service/Summons
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Proof of Service of Summons and Complaint
Civil Deposit -
Notice - NOTICE OF POSTING OF FEES
Docket Event Receipt
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff); Palmer Boston Street Properties II Inc. (Defendant)
Docket Event Notice
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Notice NOTICE OF POSTING OF FEES
Docket Event Civil Deposit
Minute Order -
Other - - INITIAL STATUS CONFERENCE ORDER (COMPLEX LITIGATION PROGRAM-CLASS ACTIONS)
Docket Event Minute order entered: 2018-08-15 00:00:00
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event Order
Filed by Court
hearing INITIAL STATUS CONFERENCE ORDER (COMPLEX LITIGATION PROGRAM-CLASS ACTIONS)
hearing in Department 6
(Order-Complex Determination; Case Determined to be Complex) -
Docket Event Minute Order
Complaint -
Notice of Case Assignment -
Summons -
Docket Event Notice of Case Assignment
Docket Event Complaint
Docket Event Complaint
Filed by Xin Chen (Plaintiff)

Please wait a moment while we load this page.

New Envelope

Your free document request was received.

Your request has been received. We will email you this document within 4 business hours.

You have used out of 0 document requests this month.

Continue

Document Requested

You have exceeded your document request limit for this month.

If you need immediate assistance, please contact support@trellis.law

Continue
Docket Refresh Requested

Your docket refresh request has been received. You will receive a notification when the docket is refreshed.

Docket Refresh Requested

A refresh is already in progress.

If you need immediate assistance, please contact support@trellis.law

Continue