1. Home
  2. State Courts
  3. New York
  4. New York County Supreme Courts
  5. Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon, Diane Melendez, Sarah Ali, Jewell Stanley, Edward Bayas, Marcos Aviles, Justin Elyachar, Steve Holzer, Jodi Berger, Adam Berger, Maria Alt, Ivan Knezevic, Santo Competiello, Viola Melpignano, Mukul Puri, John Does
SEARCH TIPS
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators
Date
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators

Contents

Details Parties Documents Case Events

We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon,

Case Last Refreshed: 8 months ago

Track Case Changes
Download Docket Print Docket

Flat Rate Movers, Ltd., filed a(n) Breach of Contract - Commercial case represented by Travis, Christopher R, against Abid Ali, Adam Berger, Ariel Bornstein, Balquees Ali, Bryan Sanicela, (total of 30) See All represented by Brown, Zavier, David, Michael N., Langweber, Richard Marc, in the jurisdiction of New York County. This case was filed in New York County Superior Courts New York County Supreme Court with SHERWOOD, O presiding.

Case Details for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. v. Abid Ali , et al.

Case Number

(Subscribe to View) Track Case Changes

Judge

SHERWOOD, O Track Judge’s New Cases

Filing Date

January 26, 2017

Category

Commercial - Other (Breach Of Fiduciary Duty)

Last Refreshed

July 30, 2023

Practice Area

Commercial

Filing Location

New York County, NY

Matter Type

Breach of Contract

Filing Court House

New York County Supreme Court

Case Outcome Type

Disposed

Case Cycle Time

523 days

Parties for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. v. Abid Ali , et al.

Plaintiffs

Flat Rate Movers, Ltd.

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Travis, Christopher R

Defendants

Abid Ali

Adam Berger

Ariel Bornstein

Balquees Ali

Bryan Sanicela

Dan Aizer

Danial Harris

Diane Melendez

Edward Bayas

Ivan Knezevic

Jelena Nedic

Jewell Stanley

Jodi Berger

John Does

Justin Elyachar

Keren Aizer Shemel

Marcos Aviles

Maria Alt

Mukul Puri

Neil Appollon

Nihal Dogu

Saadia Bangash

Saadi Agha

Santo Competiello

Sarah Ali

Sarah Ismail

Shirley Aizer Bornstein

Steve Holzer

Viola Melpignano

Xavier Brown

Attorneys for Defendants

Brown, Zavier

David, Michael N.

Langweber, Richard Marc

Case Documents for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. v. Abid Ali , et al.

for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon, Diane Melendez, Sarah Ali, Jewell Stanley, Edward Bayas, Marcos Aviles, Justin Elyachar, Steve Holzer, Jodi Berger, Adam Berger, Maria Alt, Ivan Knezevic, Santo Competiello, Viola Melpignano, Mukul Puri, John Does

ORDER ( PROPOSED )

Date: June 11, 2018
for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon, Diane Melendez, Sarah Ali, Jewell Stanley, Edward Bayas, Marcos Aviles, Justin Elyachar, Steve Holzer, Jodi Berger, Adam Berger, Maria Alt, Ivan Knezevic, Santo Competiello, Viola Melpignano, Mukul Puri, John Does

SUMMONS + COMPLAINT

Date: January 26, 2017
for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon, Diane Melendez, Sarah Ali, Jewell Stanley, Edward Bayas, Marcos Aviles, Justin Elyachar, Steve Holzer, Jodi Berger, Adam Berger, Maria Alt, Ivan Knezevic, Santo Competiello, Viola Melpignano, Mukul Puri, John Does

ANSWER (AMENDED)

Date: February 28, 2017
for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon, Diane Melendez, Sarah Ali, Jewell Stanley, Edward Bayas, Marcos Aviles, Justin Elyachar, Steve Holzer, Jodi Berger, Adam Berger, Maria Alt, Ivan Knezevic, Santo Competiello, Viola Melpignano, Mukul Puri, John Does

STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)

Date: January 17, 2018
for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon, Diane Melendez, Sarah Ali, Jewell Stanley, Edward Bayas, Marcos Aviles, Justin Elyachar, Steve Holzer, Jodi Berger, Adam Berger, Maria Alt, Ivan Knezevic, Santo Competiello, Viola Melpignano, Mukul Puri, John Does

ANSWER

Date: March 03, 2017
for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon, Diane Melendez, Sarah Ali, Jewell Stanley, Edward Bayas, Marcos Aviles, Justin Elyachar, Steve Holzer, Jodi Berger, Adam Berger, Maria Alt, Ivan Knezevic, Santo Competiello, Viola Melpignano, Mukul Puri, John Does

ANSWER

Date: February 28, 2017
for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon, Diane Melendez, Sarah Ali, Jewell Stanley, Edward Bayas, Marcos Aviles, Justin Elyachar, Steve Holzer, Jodi Berger, Adam Berger, Maria Alt, Ivan Knezevic, Santo Competiello, Viola Melpignano, Mukul Puri, John Does

ANSWER

Date: March 10, 2017
for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon, Diane Melendez, Sarah Ali, Jewell Stanley, Edward Bayas, Marcos Aviles, Justin Elyachar, Steve Holzer, Jodi Berger, Adam Berger, Maria Alt, Ivan Knezevic, Santo Competiello, Viola Melpignano, Mukul Puri, John Does

ANSWER (AMENDED)

Date: March 21, 2017
for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon, Diane Melendez, Sarah Ali, Jewell Stanley, Edward Bayas, Marcos Aviles, Justin Elyachar, Steve Holzer, Jodi Berger, Adam Berger, Maria Alt, Ivan Knezevic, Santo Competiello, Viola Melpignano, Mukul Puri, John Does

ANSWER (AMENDED)

Date: April 03, 2017
for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon, Diane Melendez, Sarah Ali, Jewell Stanley, Edward Bayas, Marcos Aviles, Justin Elyachar, Steve Holzer, Jodi Berger, Adam Berger, Maria Alt, Ivan Knezevic, Santo Competiello, Viola Melpignano, Mukul Puri, John Does

ORDER - REFERENCE

Date: August 29, 2017
for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon, Diane Melendez, Sarah Ali, Jewell Stanley, Edward Bayas, Marcos Aviles, Justin Elyachar, Steve Holzer, Jodi Berger, Adam Berger, Maria Alt, Ivan Knezevic, Santo Competiello, Viola Melpignano, Mukul Puri, John Does

STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER

Date: March 09, 2017
for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. V. Ariel Bornstein, Shirley Aizer Bornstein, Dan Aizer, Keren Aizer Shemel, Saadi Agha, Xavier Brown, Abid Ali, Balquees Ali, Sarah Ismail, Nihal Dogu, Saadia Bangash, Danial Harris, Bryan Sanicela, Jelena Nedic, Neil Appollon, Diane Melendez, Sarah Ali, Jewell Stanley, Edward Bayas, Marcos Aviles, Justin Elyachar, Steve Holzer, Jodi Berger, Adam Berger, Maria Alt, Ivan Knezevic, Santo Competiello, Viola Melpignano, Mukul Puri, John Does

ORDER - OTHER

Date: July 03, 2018

Case Events for Flat Rate Movers, Ltd. v. Abid Ali , et al.

Date Type Description
July 03, 2018 Docket Event ORDER - OTHER
View Document
July 03, 2018 Hearing OTHER FINAL DISP. (PRE-NOTE)
IAS PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE 49
9:30AM

Judge: SHERWOOD, O. PETER
June 11, 2018 Docket Event ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Order Discontinuing Action Against Xavier Brown
View Document
May 22, 2018 Hearing PRELIM CONFERENCE ADJOURNED
IAS PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE 49
9:30AM CONTROL/NO APP

Judge: SHERWOOD, O. PETER
February 20, 2018 Hearing PRELIM CONFERENCE ADJOURNED
IAS PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE 49
9:30AM CONTROL

Judge: SHERWOOD, O. PETER
January 17, 2018 Docket Event STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
View Document
January 16, 2018 Hearing STATUS CONFERENCE ADJOURNED
IAS PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE 49
9:30AM

Judge: SHERWOOD, O. PETER
January 09, 2018 Hearing PRELIM CONFERENCE ADJOURNED
IAS PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE 49
9:30AM

Judge: SHERWOOD, O. PETER
November 21, 2017 Hearing PRELIM CONFERENCE ADJOURNED
IAS PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE 49
10:30AM

Judge: SHERWOOD, O. PETER
October 24, 2017 Hearing PRELIM CONFERENCE ADJOURNED
IAS PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE 49
10:30AM

Judge: SHERWOOD, O. PETER
See all events
Request redaction

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.