1. Home
  2. State Courts
  3. New York
  4. Albany County Supreme Courts
  5. Donald M. Airey , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Blenheim, Stephen Weinhofer , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Broome, John H. Leavitt , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Carlisle, Werner T. Hampel , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Cobleskill, William A. Federice , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Conesville, Earl Vanwormer Iii , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Esperance, Philip Skowfoe Jr. , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Fulton, Alicia A. Terry , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Gilboa, Margaret Hait , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Jefferson, John Paul Youmans , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Middleburgh, Jeffrey Haslun , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Richmondville, Alan Tavenner , Individually, Earlin Rosa , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Seward, Sandra R. Manko , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Sharon, Harold Vroman , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Summit, Alex K. Luniewski , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Wright, Cynthia A. West , Individually, Benjamin J. Oevering , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Schoharie, V. The State Of New York, Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York, The New York State Senate, The New York State Assembly
SEARCH TIPS
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators
Date
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators

Contents

Details Parties Documents Case Events

We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

Donald M. Airey , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Blenheim, Stephen Weinhofer , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Broome, John H. Leavitt , Individually And In His Official C

Case Last Refreshed: 1 week ago

Track Case Changes
Download Docket Print Docket

Alan Tavenner , Individually, Alex K. Luniewski , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Wright, Alicia A. Terry , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Gilboa, Benjamin J. Oevering , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Schoharie,, Cynthia A. West , Individually, (total of 18) See All filed a(n) Agency Action - Administrative case represented by Harris, Dylan Christopher, against Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York, The New York State Assembly, The New York State Senate, The State Of New York, in the jurisdiction of Albany County, NY, . Albany County, NY Superior Courts Supreme.

Case Details for Alan Tavenner , Individually v. Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York , et al.

Case Number

(Subscribe to View)

Filing Date

April 24, 2024

Category

Special Proceedings - Cplr Article 78

Last Refreshed

April 27, 2024

Practice Area

Administrative

Filing Location

Albany County, NY

Matter Type

Agency Action

Filing Court House

Supreme

Case Complaint Summary

This complaint is a hybrid CPLR Article 78 and Declaratory Judgment action seeking to declare Real Property Tax Law ("RPTL") § 575-b unconstitutional and to annul certain actions of the Respondent-Defendants related to RPTL § 575-b. The Petitioners-P...

Subscribe to see entire Complaint Summary

Parties for Alan Tavenner , Individually v. Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York , et al.

Plaintiffs

Alan Tavenner , Individually

Alex K. Luniewski , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Wright

Alicia A. Terry , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Gilboa

Benjamin J. Oevering , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Schoharie,

Cynthia A. West , Individually

Donald M. Airey , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Blenheim

Earlin Rosa , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Seward

Earl Vanwormer Iii , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Esperance

Harold Vroman , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Summit

Jeffrey Haslun , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Richmondville

John H. Leavitt , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Carlisle

John Paul Youmans , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Middleburgh

Margaret Hait , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Jefferson

Philip Skowfoe Jr. , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Fulton

Sandra R. Manko , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Sharon

Stephen Weinhofer , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Broome

Werner T. Hampel , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Cobleskill

William A. Federice , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Conesville

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Harris, Dylan Christopher

Defendants

Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York

The New York State Assembly

The New York State Senate

The State Of New York

Case Documents for Alan Tavenner , Individually v. Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York , et al.

for Donald M. Airey , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Blenheim, Stephen Weinhofer , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Broome, John H. Leavitt , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Carlisle, Werner T. Hampel , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Cobleskill, William A. Federice , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Conesville, Earl Vanwormer Iii , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Esperance, Philip Skowfoe Jr. , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Fulton, Alicia A. Terry , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Gilboa, Margaret Hait , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Jefferson, John Paul Youmans , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Middleburgh, Jeffrey Haslun , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Richmondville, Alan Tavenner , Individually, Earlin Rosa , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Seward, Sandra R. Manko , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Sharon, Harold Vroman , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Summit, Alex K. Luniewski , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Wright, Cynthia A. West , Individually, Benjamin J. Oevering , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Schoharie, V. The State Of New York, Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York, The New York State Senate, The New York State Assembly

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT

Date: April 24, 2024
for Donald M. Airey , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Blenheim, Stephen Weinhofer , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Broome, John H. Leavitt , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Carlisle, Werner T. Hampel , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Cobleskill, William A. Federice , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Conesville, Earl Vanwormer Iii , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Esperance, Philip Skowfoe Jr. , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Fulton, Alicia A. Terry , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Gilboa, Margaret Hait , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Jefferson, John Paul Youmans , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Middleburgh, Jeffrey Haslun , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Richmondville, Alan Tavenner , Individually, Earlin Rosa , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Seward, Sandra R. Manko , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Sharon, Harold Vroman , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Summit, Alex K. Luniewski , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Wright, Cynthia A. West , Individually, Benjamin J. Oevering , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Schoharie, V. The State Of New York, Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York, The New York State Senate, The New York State Assembly

EXHIBIT(S)  - C

Date: April 24, 2024
for Donald M. Airey , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Blenheim, Stephen Weinhofer , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Broome, John H. Leavitt , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Carlisle, Werner T. Hampel , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Cobleskill, William A. Federice , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Conesville, Earl Vanwormer Iii , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Esperance, Philip Skowfoe Jr. , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Fulton, Alicia A. Terry , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Gilboa, Margaret Hait , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Jefferson, John Paul Youmans , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Middleburgh, Jeffrey Haslun , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Richmondville, Alan Tavenner , Individually, Earlin Rosa , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Seward, Sandra R. Manko , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Sharon, Harold Vroman , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Summit, Alex K. Luniewski , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Wright, Cynthia A. West , Individually, Benjamin J. Oevering , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Schoharie, V. The State Of New York, Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York, The New York State Senate, The New York State Assembly

EXHIBIT(S)  - B

Date: April 24, 2024
for Donald M. Airey , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Blenheim, Stephen Weinhofer , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Broome, John H. Leavitt , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Carlisle, Werner T. Hampel , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Cobleskill, William A. Federice , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Conesville, Earl Vanwormer Iii , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Esperance, Philip Skowfoe Jr. , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Fulton, Alicia A. Terry , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Gilboa, Margaret Hait , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Jefferson, John Paul Youmans , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Middleburgh, Jeffrey Haslun , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Richmondville, Alan Tavenner , Individually, Earlin Rosa , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Seward, Sandra R. Manko , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Sharon, Harold Vroman , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Summit, Alex K. Luniewski , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Wright, Cynthia A. West , Individually, Benjamin J. Oevering , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Schoharie, V. The State Of New York, Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York, The New York State Senate, The New York State Assembly

EXHIBIT(S)  - A

Date: April 24, 2024
for Donald M. Airey , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Blenheim, Stephen Weinhofer , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Broome, John H. Leavitt , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Carlisle, Werner T. Hampel , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Cobleskill, William A. Federice , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Conesville, Earl Vanwormer Iii , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Esperance, Philip Skowfoe Jr. , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Fulton, Alicia A. Terry , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Gilboa, Margaret Hait , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Jefferson, John Paul Youmans , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Middleburgh, Jeffrey Haslun , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Richmondville, Alan Tavenner , Individually, Earlin Rosa , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Seward, Sandra R. Manko , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Sharon, Harold Vroman , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Summit, Alex K. Luniewski , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Wright, Cynthia A. West , Individually, Benjamin J. Oevering , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Schoharie, V. The State Of New York, Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York, The New York State Senate, The New York State Assembly

RJI -RE: ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE

Date: April 24, 2024
for Donald M. Airey , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Blenheim, Stephen Weinhofer , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Broome, John H. Leavitt , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Carlisle, Werner T. Hampel , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Cobleskill, William A. Federice , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Conesville, Earl Vanwormer Iii , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Esperance, Philip Skowfoe Jr. , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Fulton, Alicia A. Terry , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Gilboa, Margaret Hait , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Jefferson, John Paul Youmans , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Middleburgh, Jeffrey Haslun , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Richmondville, Alan Tavenner , Individually, Earlin Rosa , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Seward, Sandra R. Manko , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Sharon, Harold Vroman , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Summit, Alex K. Luniewski , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Wright, Cynthia A. West , Individually, Benjamin J. Oevering , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Schoharie, V. The State Of New York, Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York, The New York State Senate, The New York State Assembly

ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )

Date: April 24, 2024
for Donald M. Airey , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Blenheim, Stephen Weinhofer , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Broome, John H. Leavitt , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Carlisle, Werner T. Hampel , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Cobleskill, William A. Federice , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Conesville, Earl Vanwormer Iii , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Esperance, Philip Skowfoe Jr. , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Fulton, Alicia A. Terry , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Gilboa, Margaret Hait , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Jefferson, John Paul Youmans , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Middleburgh, Jeffrey Haslun , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Richmondville, Alan Tavenner , Individually, Earlin Rosa , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Seward, Sandra R. Manko , Individually And In Her Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Sharon, Harold Vroman , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Summit, Alex K. Luniewski , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Wright, Cynthia A. West , Individually, Benjamin J. Oevering , Individually And In His Official Capacity As Supervisor Of The Town Of Schoharie, V. The State Of New York, Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York, The New York State Senate, The New York State Assembly

PETITION

Date: April 24, 2024

Case Events for Alan Tavenner , Individually v. Kathleen C. Hochul , In Her Official Capacity As The Governor Of The State Of New York , et al.

Date Type Description
April 24, 2024 AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
Affirmation in Support of Order to Show Cause with Temporary Restraining Order
View Document
April 24, 2024 EXHIBIT(S) - C
Exhibit C -Section N to the 2023 Omnibus Budget Bill
View Document
April 24, 2024 EXHIBIT(S) - B
Exhibit B - 575-b. Solar or wind energy systems
View Document
April 24, 2024 EXHIBIT(S) - A
Exhibit A - Affidavit of Charlene Ruszkowski
View Document
April 24, 2024 RJI -RE: ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
View Document
April 24, 2024 ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )
Order to Show Cause
View Document
April 24, 2024 PETITION
Verified Petition-Complaint
View Document
See all events
Request redaction

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.