We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

BETTY ZORNIZER VS MARK STEVEN ARONOWICZ, ET AL.

On December 05, 2018 a partnership & corporate governance case (general jurisdiction) case was filed by (Subcribe to view) against (Subscribe to view) represented by (Subscribe to view) in the jurisdiction of Los Angeles County. Judge Mark A. Young presiding.

Case Details

Case Number

(Subscribe to View)   

Filing Date

December 05, 2018

Last Refreshed

October 19, 2023

Filing Location

Los Angeles County, CA

Filing Court House

Santa Monica

OTHER JUDGES ON THIS CASE

Helen Zukin;

Judge

Hon. Mark A. Young Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Mark A. Young   

Category

civil

Practice Area

Securities

Matter Type

Business Governance

Case Outcome Type

Unknown disposition

Status

Non-Jury Verdict

OTHER JUDGES ON THIS CASE

Parties

Plaintiffs

Zornizer Betty
Zornizer Osvaldo

Defendants

Aronowicz Mark Steven
Colby Development Ltd
Rubinstein Herbert C.
Rubinstein Pauline L.
Zornizer Osvaldo

Attorneys for Defendants

Graham Bruce N
Wald Stuart Jay

Other Parties

Aronowicz Mark Steven (Cross-defendant)
Barsegyan Shushan (Attorney For Cross-complainant)
Barsegyan Shushan (Attorney For Cross-defendant)
Colby Development Ltd (Cross-defendant)
Landau Bruce G. (Attorney For Cross-complainant)
Rubinstein Herbert C. (Cross-defendant)
Rubinstein Pauline L. (Cross-defendant)
Zornizer Betty (Cross-defendant)

Case Documents

Substitution of Attorney

Date: Nov 19, 2020

Case Management Statement

Date: Oct 02, 2020

Case Management Statement

Date: Oct 01, 2020

General Denial

Date: Aug 17, 2020

Notice of Ruling

Date: Aug 17, 2020

Notice of Ruling

Date: Aug 17, 2020

Answer

Date: Jan 14, 2020

Answer

Date: Jan 14, 2020

Answer

Date: Jan 14, 2020

Answer

Date: Jan 14, 2020

Cross-Complaint

Date: Dec 04, 2019

Answer

Date: Dec 04, 2019

Notice of Ruling

Date: Nov 19, 2019

Case Management Statement

Date: May 28, 2019

Case Management Statement

Date: May 24, 2019

Case Management Statement

Date: May 23, 2019

Answer

Date: Mar 21, 2019

Answer

Date: Feb 13, 2019

Answer

Date: Feb 13, 2019

Answer

Date: Feb 13, 2019

Answer

Date: Feb 13, 2019

Proof of Personal Service

Date: Jan 08, 2019

Proof of Service by Mail

Date: Jan 08, 2019

Summons (on Complaint)

Date: Dec 05, 2018

Complaint

Date: Dec 05, 2018

Civil Case Cover Sheet

Date: Dec 05, 2018

Case Events

Type Description
Docket Event in Department M Final Status Conference - Not Held - Vacated by Court
Final Status Conference - Not Held - Vacated by Court
Docket Event in Department M Jury Trial ((4-5 days)) - Not Held - Vacated by Court
Jury Trial ((4-5 days)) - Not Held - Vacated by Court
Docket Event in Department M Hearing on Motion in Limine (to Bifurcate Trial) - Not Held - Vacated by Court
Hearing on Motion in Limine (to Bifurcate Trial) - Not Held - Vacated by Court
hearing Department M at 1725 Main Street, Santa Monica, CA 90401
Non-Jury Trial
hearing Final Status Conference scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Vacated by Court on
Docket Event Updated -- Stipulation and Order Stipulation to Retain Jurisdiction & Request for Dismissal: Filed By: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); Result: Granted; Result Date:
Docket Event On the Complaint filed by Betty Zornizer on , entered Order for Dismissal with prejudice as to the entire action
hearing Jury Trial (4-5 days) scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Vacated by Court on
hearing Hearing on Motion in Limine to Bifurcate Trial scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Vacated by Court on
hearing Stipulation and Order (Stipulation to Retain Jurisdiction & Request for Dismissal)
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
Docket Event in Department M Hearing on Motion to Bifurcate - Not Held - Rescheduled by Court
Hearing on Motion to Bifurcate - Not Held - Rescheduled by Court
Docket Event in Department M
Hearing on Motion to Bifurcate - Not Held - Rescheduled by Court
hearing Hearing on Motion in Limine To Bifurcate and try First and Separately Non-Jury Equitable Causes of Action, et. al scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Taken Off Calendar by Court on
hearing Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) scheduled for in Beverly Hills Courthouse at Department 207 updated: Result Date to ; Result Type to Held
Docket Event in Department M Final Status Conference - Not Held - Rescheduled by Party
Final Status Conference - Not Held - Rescheduled by Party
Docket Event in Department M Hearing on Motion in Limine (To Bifurcate and try First and Separately Non-Jury Equitable Causes of Action, et. al) - Not Held - Rescheduled by Party
Hearing on Motion in Limine (To Bifurcate and try First and Separately Non-Jury Equitable Causes of Action, et. al) - Not Held - Rescheduled by Party
Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held - Continued
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held - Continued

Judge: Helen Zukin

Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held

Judge: Helen Zukin

hearing Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) scheduled for in Beverly Hills Courthouse at Department 207 Not Held - Taken Off Calendar by Court on
hearing Hearing on Motion in Limine to Bifurcate Trial scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
Docket Event Minute Order (Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC))
hearing Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) scheduled for in Beverly Hills Courthouse at Department 207
Docket Event in Department M Final Status Conference - Not Held - Continued - Court's Motion
Final Status Conference - Not Held - Continued - Court's Motion
Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Not Held - Taken Off Calendar by Court
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Not Held - Taken Off Calendar by Court

Judge: Helen Zukin

Docket Event in Department M Hearing on Motion in Limine (To Bifurcate and try First and Separately Non-Jury Equitable Causes of Action, et. al) - Not Held - Taken Off Calendar by Court
Hearing on Motion in Limine (To Bifurcate and try First and Separately Non-Jury Equitable Causes of Action, et. al) - Not Held - Taken Off Calendar by Court
hearing Department M at 1725 Main Street, Santa Monica, CA 90401
Final Status Conference
Docket Event in Department M
Final Status Conference - Not Held - Continued - Court's Motion
Docket Event in Department M
Hearing on Motion in Limine (To Bifurcate and try First and Separately Non-Jury Equitable Causes of Action, et. al) - Not Held - Taken Off Calendar by Court
Docket Event in Department M
Final Status Conference - Not Held - Rescheduled by Party
hearing Minute Order ( (Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC)))
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Not Held - Taken Off Calendar by Court Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

Judge: Helen Zukin Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held - Continued Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

Judge: Helen Zukin Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

Judge: Helen Zukin Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

Docket Event in Department M
Hearing on Motion in Limine (To Bifurcate and try First and Separately Non-Jury Equitable Causes of Action, et. al) - Not Held - Rescheduled by Party
hearing Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) scheduled for in Beverly Hills Courthouse at Department 207 updated: Result Date to ; Result Type to Held - Continued
hearing Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) scheduled for in Beverly Hills Courthouse at Department 207 Held - Continued was rescheduled to 10:00 AM
Docket Event Minute Order (Court Order)
Docket Event Certificate of Mailing for (Court Order) of ; Filed by: Clerk
Docket Event Minute Order (Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC))
hearing Pursuant to oral stipulation, Final Status Conference scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Rescheduled by Party was rescheduled to 11:00 AM
hearing Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) scheduled for in Beverly Hills Courthouse at Department 207
hearing Pursuant to oral stipulation, Hearing on Motion in Limine To Bifurcate and try First and Separately Non-Jury Equitable Causes of Action, et. al scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Rescheduled by Party was rescheduled to 11:00 AM
Docket Event in Department M Court Order
Court Order
hearing On the Court's own motion, Final Status Conference scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Continued - Court's Motion was rescheduled to 09:00 AM
Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held - Continued
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held - Continued

Judge: Helen Zukin

hearing Minute Order ( (Court Order))
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held - Continued Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

Judge: Helen Zukin Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

Docket Event in Department M
Court Order
hearing Certificate of Mailing for ((Court Order) of 01/22/2021)
Filed by Clerk
hearing Minute Order ( (Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC)))
Filed by Clerk
hearing Updated -- Event scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Type changed from Hearing on Motion to Bifurcate to Hearing on Motion in Limine (name extension)
Docket Event Declaration Declaration of Bruce G. Landau, Esq. Regarding Status; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Hearing on Motion to Bifurcate scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
hearing On the Court's own motion, Hearing on Motion to Bifurcate scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Rescheduled by Court was rescheduled to 09:00 AM
Docket Event Notice Notice of Advancement of Hearing Date on Motion to Bifurcate; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant) et al.
hearing Notice (Notice of Advancement of Hearing Date on Motion to Bifurcate)
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Declaration (Declaration of Bruce G. Landau, Esq. Regarding Status)
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Minute Order (Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC))
hearing Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) scheduled for in Beverly Hills Courthouse at Department 207 Held - Continued was rescheduled to 09:00 AM
hearing Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) scheduled for in Beverly Hills Courthouse at Department 207
Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held - Continued
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held - Continued

Judge: Helen Zukin

hearing Minute Order ( (Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC)))
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held - Continued Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

Judge: Helen Zukin Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

hearing Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) scheduled for in Beverly Hills Courthouse at Department 207
Docket Event Minute Order (Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC))
hearing Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) scheduled for in Beverly Hills Courthouse at Department 207 updated: Result Date to ; Result Type to Held - Continued
hearing Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) scheduled for in Beverly Hills Courthouse at Department 207
Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held - Continued
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held - Continued

Judge: Helen Zukin

Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Held - Continued Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

Judge: Helen Zukin Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

hearing Minute Order ( (Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC)))
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event Motion in Limine Betty Zornizer's Motion in Limine to Bifurcate; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Motion in Limine (Betty Zornizer's Motion in Limine to Bifurcate)
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Notice NOTICE CONTINUANCE OF MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant) et al.
Docket Event Notice of Continuance of MSC; Filed by: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); As to: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Notice (NOTICE CONTINUANCE OF MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE)
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Notice (of Continuance of MSC)
Filed by Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant)
Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Not Held - Continued - Stipulation
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Not Held - Continued - Stipulation

Judge: Helen Zukin

hearing Department 207 at 9355 Burton Way, Beverly Hills, CA 90210
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC)
Docket Event in Department 207, Helen Zukin, Presiding
Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) - Not Held - Continued - Stipulation Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

Judge: Helen Zukin Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Helen Zukin

hearing Pursuant to oral stipulation, Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) scheduled for in Beverly Hills Courthouse at Department 207 Not Held - Continued - Stipulation was rescheduled to 09:00 AM
Docket Event Minute Order (Hearing on Ex Parte Application For Order Setting Jury Trial ...)
hearing Updated -- Event scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Type changed from Non-Jury Trial to Jury Trial
Docket Event Updated -- Ex Parte Application Ex Parte Application For Order Setting Jury Trial (As Opposed To Bench Trial), Setting Trial Date And Setting Hearing On Terminating Motion For Judgment: Filed By: Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant),Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant),Colby Development, LTD (Defendant); Result: Granted; Result Date:
hearing Hearing on Ex Parte Application For Order Setting Jury Trial (As Opposed To Bench Trial), Setting Trial Date And Setting Hearing On Terminating Motion For Judgment scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M updated: Result Date to ; Result Type to Held - Motion Granted
Docket Event in Department M Hearing on Ex Parte Application (For Order Setting Jury Trial (As Opposed To Bench Trial), Setting Trial Date And Setting Hearing On Terminating Motion For Judgment) - Held - Motion Granted
Hearing on Ex Parte Application (For Order Setting Jury Trial (As Opposed To Bench Trial), Setting Trial Date And Setting Hearing On Terminating Motion For Judgment) - Held - Motion Granted
hearing Department M at 1725 Main Street, Santa Monica, CA 90401
Hearing on Ex Parte Application For Order Setting Jury Trial (As Opposed To Bench Trial), Setting Trial Date And Setting Hearing On Terminating Motion For Judgment
hearing Minute Order ( (Hearing on Ex Parte Application For Order Setting Jury Trial ...))
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event in Department M
Hearing on Ex Parte Application (For Order Setting Jury Trial (As Opposed To Bench Trial), Setting Trial Date And Setting Hearing On Terminating Motion For Judgment) - Held - Motion Granted
hearing Hearing on Ex Parte Application For Order Setting Jury Trial (As Opposed To Bench Trial), Setting Trial Date And Setting Hearing On Terminating Motion For Judgment scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
Docket Event Opposition DECLARATION OF BRUCE LANDAU, ESQ. AND EXHIBITS THERETO IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS? EX PARTE APPLICATION AND APPLICATION FOR ORDER SETTING JURY TRIAL, CHANGING TRIAL DEADLINES AND SETTING A DATE FOR A ?TERMINATING MOTION FOR JUDGMENT?; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Opposition to Ex Parte Application; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
Docket Event Ex Parte Application Ex Parte Application For Order Setting Jury Trial (As Opposed To Bench Trial), Setting Trial Date And Setting Hearing On Terminating Motion For Judgment; Filed by: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant); Colby Development, LTD (Defendant); As to: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Opposition (to Ex Parte Application)
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
hearing Opposition (DECLARATION OF BRUCE LANDAU, ESQ. AND EXHIBITS THERETO IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS? EX PARTE APPLICATION AND APPLICATION FOR ORDER SETTING JURY TRIAL, CHANGING TRIAL DEADLINES AND SETTING A DATE FOR A ?TERMINATING MOTION FOR JUDGMENT?)
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Ex Parte Application (Ex Parte Application For Order Setting Jury Trial (As Opposed To Bench Trial), Setting Trial Date And Setting Hearing On Terminating Motion For Judgment)
Filed by Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant); Colby Development, LTD (Defendant)
Docket Event Writ of Execution (Los Angeles); Issued by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant); As to: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant); County: Los Angeles
Docket Event Notice of Rejection - Post Judgment; Filed by: Clerk
hearing Notice of Rejection - Post Judgment
Filed by Clerk
hearing Writ of Execution ((Los Angeles))
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
Docket Event Substitution of Attorney; Filed by: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant)
hearing Substitution of Attorney
Filed by Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant)
Docket Event Notice Notice of Mandatory Settlement Conference; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant); Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant) et al.
hearing Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC) scheduled for in Beverly Hills Courthouse at Department 207
hearing Notice (Notice of Mandatory Settlement Conference)
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Memorandum of Costs After Judgment, Acknowledgment of Credit, and Declaration of Accrued Interest; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant); As to: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant); Interest: 28.77; Service Date:
hearing Memorandum of Costs After Judgment, Acknowledgment of Credit, and Declaration of Accrued Interest
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
Docket Event Updated -- Case Management Statement: Document changed from Statement of the Case to Case Management Statement; As To Parties: removed
Docket Event in Department M Jury Trial - Not Held - Vacated by Court
Jury Trial - Not Held - Vacated by Court
Docket Event in Department M
Jury Trial - Not Held - Vacated by Court
hearing Final Status Conference scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
Docket Event Minute Order (Trial Setting Conference)
hearing Trial Setting Conference scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M updated: Result Date to ; Result Type to Held
hearing Non-Jury Trial (4-5 days) scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
Docket Event in Department M Trial Setting Conference - Held
Trial Setting Conference - Held
Docket Event in Department M Final Status Conference - Not Held - Vacated by Court
Final Status Conference - Not Held - Vacated by Court
hearing Minute Order ( (Trial Setting Conference))
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event in Department M
Final Status Conference - Not Held - Vacated by Court
Docket Event in Department M
Trial Setting Conference - Held
Docket Event Case Management Statement; Filed by: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant); Colby Development, LTD (Defendant)
hearing Case Management Statement
Filed by Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant) et al.
Docket Event Case Management Statement; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
hearing Case Management Statement
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
Docket Event General Denial; Filed by: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
Docket Event Notice of Ruling; Filed by: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
Docket Event Notice of Ruling; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
hearing General Denial
Filed by Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
hearing Notice of Ruling
Filed by Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
hearing Notice of Ruling
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
Docket Event Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter as Official Reporter Pro Tempore Sharon Cahn #6210; Filed by: Clerk
hearing Hearing on Motion to Strike Motion to Strike First and Second Causes of Action from Plaintiff's Cross-Complaint Against Herbert C. Rubinstein scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M updated: Result Date to ; Result Type to Held - Motion Granted
hearing Hearing on Motion to Compel Interrogatories , production of documents and request for admissions to be deemed admitted scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M updated: Result Date to ; Result Type to Held - Motion Granted
hearing Order to Show Cause Re: re monetary sanctions for violation of Civil Procedure section 177.5 scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M updated: Result Date to ; Result Type to Held - Motion Granted
Docket Event Minute Order (Hearing on Motion to Strike Motion to Strike First and Second...)
Docket Event in Department M Order to Show Cause Re: (re monetary sanctions for violation of Civil Procedure section 177.5) - Held - Motion Granted
Order to Show Cause Re: (re monetary sanctions for violation of Civil Procedure section 177.5) - Held - Motion Granted
Docket Event in Department M Hearing on Motion to Strike (Motion to Strike First and Second Causes of Action from Plaintiff's Cross-Complaint Against Herbert C. Rubinstein) - Held - Motion Granted
Hearing on Motion to Strike (Motion to Strike First and Second Causes of Action from Plaintiff's Cross-Complaint Against Herbert C. Rubinstein) - Held - Motion Granted
Docket Event in Department M Hearing on Motion to Compel Interrogatories (, production of documents and request for admissions to be deemed admitted) - Held - Motion Granted
Hearing on Motion to Compel Interrogatories (, production of documents and request for admissions to be deemed admitted) - Held - Motion Granted
Docket Event in Department M
Hearing on Motion to Strike (Motion to Strike First and Second Causes of Action from Plaintiff's Cross-Complaint Against Herbert C. Rubinstein) - Held - Motion Granted
Docket Event in Department M
Order to Show Cause Re: (re monetary sanctions for violation of Civil Procedure section 177.5) - Held - Motion Granted
hearing Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter as Official Reporter Pro Tempore (Sharon Cahn #6210)
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event in Department M
Hearing on Motion to Compel Interrogatories (, production of documents and request for admissions to be deemed admitted) - Held - Motion Granted
hearing Minute Order ( (Hearing on Motion to Strike Motion to Strike First and Second...))
Filed by Clerk
Tentative Ruling CASE NAME: Betty Zornizer v. Mark Steven Aronowicz, et al. CASE NO.: 18SMCP00111 MOTIONS: Defendant/Cross-Complainant Osvaldo Zornizers Motion to Deem Requests for Admissions Admitted and Motion to C...

Judge: Mark A. Young

Docket Event Reply Reply Brief in Support of Motion to Strike First and Second Causes of Action; Filed by: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
Docket Event Affidavit Statement of Herbert C. Rubinstein with regard to Motions to Compel and for Sanctions; Declaration of Stuart J. Wald in response to Order to Show Cause; Filed by: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
hearing Affidavit (Statement of Herbert C. Rubinstein with regard to Motions to Compel and for Sanctions; Declaration of Stuart J. Wald in response to Order to Show Cause)
Filed by Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
hearing Reply (Reply Brief in Support of Motion to Strike First and Second Causes of Action)
Filed by Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
Docket Event Notice of Change of Address or Other Contact Information; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Notice of Change of Address or Other Contact Information
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Notice of Non-Opposition to Motions; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant); As to: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
hearing Notice (of Non-Opposition to Motions)
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
hearing On the Court's own motion, Final Status Conference scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Vacated by Court on
hearing Order to Show Cause Re: re monetary sanctions for violation of Civil Procedure section 177.5 scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
Docket Event Minute Order (Informal Discovery Conference (IDC))
hearing Hearing on Motion to Compel Interrogatories , production of documents and request for admissions to be deemed admitted scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
hearing Trial Setting Conference scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
hearing On the Court's own motion, Jury Trial scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Vacated by Court on
hearing Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M updated: Result Date to ; Result Type to Held
Docket Event Certificate of Mailing for (Informal Discovery Conference (IDC)) of ; Filed by: Clerk
Docket Event in Department M Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) - Held
Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) - Held
hearing Certificate of Mailing for ((Informal Discovery Conference (IDC)) of 07/21/2020)
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event in Department M
Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) - Held
hearing Minute Order ( (Informal Discovery Conference (IDC)))
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event Declaration of Shushan Barsegyan in Support of IDC Statement; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
Docket Event Informal Discovery Conference; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
hearing Informal Discovery Conference
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
hearing Declaration (of Shushan Barsegyan in Support of IDC Statement)
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
Docket Event Certificate of Mailing for (Court Order) of ; Filed by: Clerk
Docket Event Minute Order (Court Order)
hearing Informal Discovery Conference (IDC) scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
Docket Event in Department M Court Order
Court Order
hearing Minute Order ( (Court Order))
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event in Department M
Court Order
hearing Certificate of Mailing for ((Court Order) of 06/19/2020)
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event in Department M Hearing on Motion to Strike (Motion to Strike First and Second Causes of Action from Plaintiff's Cross-Complaint Against Herbert C. Rubinstein) - Not Held - Rescheduled by Court
Hearing on Motion to Strike (Motion to Strike First and Second Causes of Action from Plaintiff's Cross-Complaint Against Herbert C. Rubinstein) - Not Held - Rescheduled by Court
Docket Event in Department M
Hearing on Motion to Strike (Motion to Strike First and Second Causes of Action from Plaintiff's Cross-Complaint Against Herbert C. Rubinstein) - Not Held - Rescheduled by Court
Docket Event Motion to Compel Discovery (not Further Discovery) - 1 moving party, 1 motion; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant); As to: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
Docket Event Motion to Compel Anwers to Interrogatories; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant); As to: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
hearing Motion to Compel Discovery (not Further Discovery) - 1 moving party, 1 motion
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
hearing Motion to Compel (Anwers to Interrogatories)
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
Docket Event Motion for Order Establishing Admissions and for Sanctions; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
hearing Motion for Order (Establishing Admissions and for Sanctions)
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
Docket Event Opposition OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO STRIKE CROSS-COMPLAINT; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
hearing Opposition (OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO STRIKE CROSS-COMPLAINT)
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
hearing Reset - Court Unavailable, Hearing on Motion to Strike Motion to Strike First and Second Causes of Action from Plaintiff's Cross-Complaint Against Herbert C. Rubinstein scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Rescheduled by Court was rescheduled to 08:30 AM
Docket Event Notice Re: Continuance of Hearing and Order; Filed by: Clerk
Docket Event Notice of Continuance Due to COVID-19 State of Emergency Declarations; Filed by: Clerk
hearing Notice of Continuance Due to COVID-19 State of Emergency Declarations
Filed by Clerk
hearing Notice Re: Continuance of Hearing and Order
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event in Department M Jury Trial - Not Held - Continued - Court's Motion
Jury Trial - Not Held - Continued - Court's Motion
Docket Event in Department M
Jury Trial - Not Held - Continued - Court's Motion
Docket Event in Department M Final Status Conference - Not Held - Continued - Court's Motion
Final Status Conference - Not Held - Continued - Court's Motion
Docket Event in Department M Order to Show Cause Re: (Plaintiff Counsel's Failure to Appear) - Not Held - Vacated by Court
Order to Show Cause Re: (Plaintiff Counsel's Failure to Appear) - Not Held - Vacated by Court
Docket Event in Department M
Final Status Conference - Not Held - Continued - Court's Motion
Docket Event in Department M
Order to Show Cause Re: (Plaintiff Counsel's Failure to Appear) - Not Held - Vacated by Court
Docket Event Answer; Filed by: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Cross-Defendant); As to: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
Docket Event Answer; Filed by: Colby Development, LTD (Cross-Defendant); As to: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
Docket Event Answer; Filed by: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant); As to: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
Docket Event Answer; Filed by: Pauline L. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant); As to: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
hearing Answer
Filed by Colby Development, LTD (Cross-Defendant)
hearing Answer
Filed by Pauline L. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
hearing Answer
Filed by Mark Steven Aronowicz (Cross-Defendant)
hearing Answer
Filed by Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
hearing Hearing on Motion to Strike Motion to Strike First and Second Causes of Action from Plaintiff's Cross-Complaint Against Herbert C. Rubinstein scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
Docket Event Updated -- Motion to Strike (not anti-SLAPP) - without Demurrer First and Second Causes of Action From Plaintiff's "Cross-Complaint" Against Herbert C. Rubinstein; Memorandum of Points and Authorities: Document changed from Motion to Strike (not initial pleading) to Motion to Strike (not anti-SLAPP) - without Demurrer; As To Parties: removed
Docket Event Motion to Strike (not anti-SLAPP) - without Demurrer First and Second Causes of Action From Plaintiff's "Cross-Complaint" Against Herbert C. Rubinstein; Memorandum of Points and Authorities; Filed by: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
hearing Motion to Strike (not anti-SLAPP) - without Demurrer (First and Second Causes of Action From Plaintiff's "Cross-Complaint" Against Herbert C. Rubinstein; Memorandum of Points and Authorities)
Filed by Herbert C. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant)
Docket Event Answer; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Cross-Complaint; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant)
hearing Cross-Complaint
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Answer
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing On the Court's own motion, Final Status Conference scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Continued - Court's Motion was rescheduled to 09:00 AM
hearing On the Court's own motion, Jury Trial scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Continued - Court's Motion was rescheduled to 09:30 AM
hearing Hearing on Motion for Leave to File a Cross-Complaint scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M updated: Result Date to ; Result Type to Held - Motion Granted
Docket Event Cross-Complaint for Damates,Equitable Relief, and Appointment of Reciever; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant); As to: Betty Zornizer (Cross-Defendant); Colby Development, LTD (Cross-Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Cross-Defendant) et al.
Docket Event Minute Order (Hearing on Motion for Leave to File a Cross-Complaint)
Docket Event [Proposed] Order re: Motion Granting Leave to File Cross-Complaint; Signed and Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant); As to: Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant)
Docket Event Updated -- Order re: Motion Granting Leave to File Cross-Complaint: Status Date changed from to ; Exact Name changed from [Proposed] Order re: Motion Granting Leave to File Cross-Complaint to Order re: Motion Granting Leave to File Cross-Complaint; Result Date changed from to ; As To Parties changed from Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant) to Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant)
Docket Event Updated -- Motion for Leave to File Cross-Complaint: Filed By: Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant); Result: Granted; Result Date:
Docket Event Notice of Ruling; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Jury Trial scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
hearing Final Status Conference scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
Docket Event in Department M Hearing on Motion for Leave to File a Cross-Complaint - Held - Motion Granted
Hearing on Motion for Leave to File a Cross-Complaint - Held - Motion Granted
Docket Event in Department M
Hearing on Motion for Leave to File a Cross-Complaint - Held - Motion Granted
hearing Notice of Ruling
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Order re: Motion Granting Leave to File Cross-Complaint
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant)
hearing Cross-Complaint (for Damates,Equitable Relief, and Appointment of Reciever)
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Cross-Complainant)
hearing Minute Order ( (Hearing on Motion for Leave to File a Cross-Complaint))
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event Response To Motion By Osvaldo Zornizer For Leave To File Cross-Complaint; Filed by: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant); Colby Development, LTD (Defendant)
Docket Event OSVALDO ZORNIZER?S NOTICE OF NON-OPPOSITION BY PLAINTIFF BETTY ZORNIZER AND ALL OTHER PARTIES TO OSVALDO ZORNIZER?S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE CROSS-COMPLAINT; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant); As to: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant) et al.
hearing OSVALDO ZORNIZER?S NOTICE OF NON-OPPOSITION BY PLAINTIFF BETTY ZORNIZER AND ALL OTHER PARTIES TO OSVALDO ZORNIZER?S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE CROSS-COMPLAINT
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant)
hearing Response (To Motion By Osvaldo Zornizer For Leave To File Cross-Complaint)
Filed by Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant) et al.
Docket Event Betty Zornizer's Statement of Non-Opposition to Osvaldo Zornizer's Motion for Leave to File Cross-Complaint; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Betty Zornizer's Statement of Non-Opposition to Osvaldo Zornizer's Motion for Leave to File Cross-Complaint
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Hearing on Motion for Leave to File a Cross-Complaint scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
Docket Event Motion for Leave to File Cross-Complaint; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant)
hearing Motion for Leave (to File Cross-Complaint)
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant)
Docket Event Declaration DECLARATION OF BRUCE G. LANDAU IN RESPONSE TO OSC RE. FAILURE TO APPEAR AT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Declaration (DECLARATION OF BRUCE G. LANDAU IN RESPONSE TO OSC RE. FAILURE TO APPEAR AT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE)
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Jury Trial scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
hearing Order to Show Cause Re: Plaintiff Counsel's Failure to Appear scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
Docket Event Address for Shushan Barsegyan (Attorney) null
hearing Case Management Conference scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M updated: Result Date to ; Result Type to Held
hearing Final Status Conference scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
Docket Event Address for Stuart Jay Wald (Attorney) null
hearing On the Court's own motion, Order to Show Cause Re: Plaintiff Counsel's Failure to Appear scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M Not Held - Vacated by Court on
Docket Event Address for Bruce G. Landau (Attorney) null
Docket Event Certificate of Mailing for Minute Order (Court Order) of ; Filed by: Clerk
Docket Event Minute Order (Case Management Conference)
Docket Event Minute Order (Court Order)
Docket Event in Department M Case Management Conference - Held
Case Management Conference - Held
Docket Event in Department M Court Order
Court Order
hearing Minute Order ( (Case Management Conference))
Filed by Clerk
hearing Minute Order ( (Court Order))
Filed by Clerk
hearing Certificate of Mailing for (Minute Order (Court Order) of 06/03/2019)
Filed by Clerk
Docket Event in Department M
Case Management Conference - Held
Docket Event in Department M
Court Order
Docket Event Case Management Statement; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant)
hearing Case Management Statement
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant)
Docket Event Case Management Statement; Filed by: Bruce G. Landau (Attorney)
hearing Case Management Statement
Filed by Bruce G. Landau (Attorney)
Docket Event Case Management Statement; Filed by: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant); Colby Development, LTD (Defendant)
hearing Case Management Statement
Filed by Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant) et al.
Docket Event Answer; Filed by: Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant); As to: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Answer
Filed by Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant)
Docket Event Answer; Filed by: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant)
Docket Event Answer; Filed by: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant)
Docket Event Answer; Filed by: Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant)
Docket Event Answer; Filed by: Colby Development, LTD (Defendant)
hearing Answer
Filed by Colby Development, LTD (Defendant)
hearing Answer
Filed by Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant)
hearing Answer
Filed by Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant)
hearing Answer
Filed by Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant)
Docket Event Notice Notice of Case Management Conference; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant) et al.
Docket Event Proof of Service by Substituted Service; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Proof of Mailing Date: ; Service Cost: 0.00; Service Cost Waived: Yes
Docket Event Proof of Service by Substituted Service; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Colby Development, LTD (Defendant); Proof of Mailing Date: ; Service Cost: 0.00; Service Cost Waived: Yes
hearing Notice (Notice of Case Management Conference)
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Proof of Service by Substituted Service
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Proof of Service by Mail; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant)
Docket Event Proof of Personal Service; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant); Service Date: ; Service Cost: 39.50; Service Cost Waived: No
Docket Event Declaration re: Due Diligence; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant)
Docket Event Proof of Service by Substituted Service; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); Proof of Mailing Date: ; Service Cost: 104.00; Service Cost Waived: No
hearing Proof of Personal Service
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Declaration re: Due Diligence
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Proof of Service by Mail
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Proof of Service by Substituted Service
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
Docket Event Notice and Acknowledgment of Receipt; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Osvaldo Zornizer (Defendant)
hearing Notice and Acknowledgment of Receipt
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Case Management Conference scheduled for in Santa Monica Courthouse at Department M
Docket Event Case assigned to Hon. Mark A. Young in Department M Santa Monica Courthouse
Docket Event Civil Case Cover Sheet; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant) et al.
Docket Event Summons on Complaint; Issued and Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant) et al.
Docket Event Complaint; Filed by: Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff); As to: Mark Steven Aronowicz (Defendant); Herbert C. Rubinstein (Defendant); Pauline L. Rubinstein (Defendant) et al.
Docket Event Notice of Case Assignment - Unlimited Civil Case; Filed by: Clerk
hearing Notice of Case Assignment - Unlimited Civil Case
Filed by Clerk
hearing Summons (on Complaint)
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Complaint
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)
hearing Civil Case Cover Sheet
Filed by Betty Zornizer (Plaintiff)

Please wait a moment while we load this page.

New Envelope

Your free document request was received.

Your request has been received. We will email you this document within 4 business hours.

You have used out of 0 document requests this month.

Continue

Document Requested

You have exceeded your document request limit for this month.

If you need immediate assistance, please contact support@trellis.law

Continue
Docket Refresh Requested

Your docket refresh request has been received. You will receive a notification when the docket is refreshed.

Docket Refresh Requested

A refresh is already in progress.

If you need immediate assistance, please contact support@trellis.law

Continue