Case Number:
21SMCV00991
Hearing Date:
November 9, 2023
Dept:
207 TENTATIVE RULING





DEPARTMENT



207





HEARING DATE



November 9, 2023





CASE NUMBER



21SMCV00991





MOTIONS



Motions to Quash Third Party Subpoenas





MOVING PARTY



Plaintiff 1059Corning, LLC





OPPOSING PARTY



Defendant Marmar Corning, LLC






BACKGROUND




This lawsuit arises from a dispute between the owners of adjoining residential properties.

Plaintiff 1059Corning, LLC (Plaintiff) alleges that construction defects in Defendant Marmar Corning, LLCs (Defendant) adjoining building caused damage to Plaintiffs building.



Prior to initiating litigation, Plaintiff hired third party consultants Soil Pacific, Inc. and PSFEG, Inc. to evaluate the damage.

Also prior to initiating litigation, Plaintiff sent Defendant copies of the consultant reports.

Defendants have sent third party subpoenas to both So