December 17, 2022
Pennisula Properties Compa… (Defendant)
Track This PartySheinbaum, Jordan (Attorney)
Track This PartyYu, Angela Julie (Attorney)
Track This PartyHenderson, Matthew Cable (Attorney)
Track This PartyShiber, Basil Sami (Attorney)
Track This PartyCounty of Santa Cruz (Cross Complainant)
Track This PartySheinbaum, Jordan (Attorney for the Defendant)
Track This PartyYu, Angela Julie (Attorney for the Defendant)
Track This PartyHenderson, Matthew Cable (Attorney for the Defendant)
Track This PartyShiber, Basil Sami (Attorney for the Defendant)
Track This PartyCounty of Santa Cruz (Defendant)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPyers, Paula (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party240 Beach Drive LLC (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyLawrie, William L. (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyWilliam L. and Beverly B. … (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVan Loucks Living Trust (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyThe Eric Martin Stark Revo… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyLawrie, Shelley (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyRobson, Sharleen (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyHosseini, Roya (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyRobson Family Living Trust (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyEllis, Renee (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyRancho Land Holdings LLC (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPhoenix Family, LP (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyMelehan Revocable Trust of… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyBecerra, Mary Christi (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyMartz Family Trust (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyMajid Gerami and Kim Gurri… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyGerami, Majid (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPlageman, Laura (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyKotab Revocable Trust (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyMartz, Kenneth (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyMelehan, Joseph (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyKontoudakis, John (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney)
Track This PartySchwartz, Jay (Cross Defendant)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartySchwartz, Jay (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyAhrens, Jan (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVan Loucks, Geoffrey (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney)
Track This PartySchwartz, Gail (Cross Defendant)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartySchwartz, Gail (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyBialek, Fred (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyFaris Beach, LLC (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyStark, Eric Martin (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPlageman, Elizabeth (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyLucas, Donald Lee (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyRobson, Brad (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyBialek, Betty George (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVenturacci, Barbara Plagem… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney)
Track This PartyNelson, Barbara (Cross Defendant)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyNelson, Barbara (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyKontoudakis, Barbara (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVaudagna, Ann (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney)
Track This PartyPoncetta, Danielle (Cross Defendant)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPoncetta, Danielle (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyWilliam E. and Jeanne M. W… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVaudagna, Susan (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartySunny Cove Getaway LLC (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyBecker, Stuart (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPoncetta, Scott C. (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyROSL Walker Family II LLC (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartySchlichting, Muriel (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyWalker, Michael (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVaudagna, Lynn (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVaudagna, Josephine (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyWeseloh, Jeanne M. (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVaudagna, James P. (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVaudagna, James S. (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyKotab, Gretchen (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney)
Track This PartyPoncetta, Greg (Cross Defendant)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPoncetta, Greg (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartySchlichting, Frederick (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyFamily Tides LLC (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyKotab, Dominic (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyClark, Stephanie Nicole (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyWeseloh, Christopher J. (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyLawri… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyRobso… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyHosse… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyEllis… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyBecer… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyGeram… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPlage… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyMartz… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyMeleh… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyKonto… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney)
Track This PartySchwa… (Cross Defendant)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartySchwa… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyAhren… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVan L… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney)
Track This PartySchwa… (Cross Defendant)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartySchwa… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyBiale… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyStark… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPlage… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyLucas… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyRobso… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyBiale… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVentu… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney)
Track This PartyNelso… (Cross Defendant)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyNelso… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyKonto… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVauda… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney)
Track This PartyPonce… (Cross Defendant)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPonce… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVauda… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyBecke… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPonce… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartySchli… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyWalke… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVauda… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVauda… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyWesel… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVauda… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVauda… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyKotab… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney)
Track This PartyPonce… (Cross Defendant)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPonce… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartySchli… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyKotab… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyDibennedetto, Anna (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyWesel… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPenni… (Defendant)
Track This PartyYu, Angela Julie (Attorney)
Track This Party… (Attorney)
Track This PartyShiber, Basil Sami (Attorney)
Track This PartyCount… (Cross Complainant)
Track This PartyYu, Angela Julie (Attorney for the Defendant)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Defendant)
Track This PartyShiber, Basil Sami (Attorney for the Defendant)
Track This PartyCount… (Defendant)
Track This PartyWilli… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyWilli… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyVan L… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyThe E… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartySunny… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyROSL … (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyRobso… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyRanch… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPhoen… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyMeleh… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyMartz… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyMajid… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyKotab… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyFaris… (Plaintiff)
Track This PartyFamil… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party240 B… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyPyers… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This PartyLawri… (Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party… (Attorney for the Plaintiff)
Track This Party2023-09-27T00:00:00
2023-09-26T00:00:00
2023-09-25T00:00:00
2023-09-24T00:00:00
2023-09-23T00:00:00
2023-09-22T00:00:00
2023-09-21T00:00:00
2022-12-22T00:00:00
2022-12-21T00:00:00
2022-12-20T00:00:00
2022-12-19T00:00:00
2022-12-18T00:00:00
2022-12-16T00:00:00
2022-09-29T00:00:00
2022-09-28T00:00:00
2022-09-27T00:00:00
2022-09-26T00:00:00
2022-09-25T00:00:00
2022-09-24T00:00:00
2022-09-23T00:00:00
2022-09-22T00:00:00
2022-09-21T00:00:00
2022-09-20T00:00:00
2022-09-19T00:00:00
2022-09-18T00:00:00
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Please wait a moment while we load this page.
18CV03315
WESELOH v COUNTY OF SANTA CRUZ et al.
RE: PLAINTIFFS’ REQUEST FOR FINAL RULING ON WRIT CLAIMS FOR
VIOLATIONS OF CEQA AND COASTAL ACT
The Court has read and considered the briefs filed by the parties on whether to issue a
ruling on Plaintiffs’ claims for violations of CEQA (2d cause of action) and the Coastal Act (3rd
cause of action). The Court finds that these claims are now moot.
In the first phase of the trial of this matter this Court resolved the title issue as to the 37
foot Walkway fronting Plaintiffs’ homes in favor of Plaintiffs, finding that neither the County
nor the public have any interest in, or rights to use the Walkway. This determination effectively
prevents the County from asserting that the Walkway had been dedicated for public use, which