On May 01, 2018 a
Letter,Correspondence
was filed
involving a dispute between
Karen Maloney,
Karen Maloney As Adminstratrix For The Estate Of Kevin K. Maloney,
and
Amchem Products, Inc., N K A Rhone Poulenc Ag Company, N K A Bayer Cropscience Inc.,,
Armstrong Pumps, Inc.,,
Burnham, Llc, Individually, And As Successor To Burnham Corporation,,
Cbs Corporation, F K A Viacom Inc., Successor By Merger To Cbs Corporation, F K A Westinghouse Electric Corporation,,
Crane Co. Individually And As Successor To Pacific Valves,,
Flowserve Us, Inc. Solely As Successor To Rockwell Manufacturing Company, Edward Valve, Inc., Nordstrom Valves, Inc., Edward Vogt Valve Company, And Vogt Valve Company,,
General Electric Company,,
Goulds Pumps Llc,,
Honeywell International, Inc., F K A Allied Signal, Inc. Bendix,,
Itt Llc., Individually And As Successor To Bell & Gossett And As Successor To Kennedy Valve Manufacturing Co., Inc.,,
Owens-Illinois, Inc.,,
Peerless Industries, Inc.,,
Pfizer, Inc.,
Union Carbide Corporation,,
U.S. Rubber Company,
Weil-Mclain, A Division Of The Marley-Wylain Company, A Wholly Owned Subsidiary Of The Marley Company, Llc,,
for Torts - Asbestos
in the District Court of New York County.
Preview
McELROY, DEUTSCH, MULVANEY & CARPENTER, LLP
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
1300 MOUNT KEMBLE AVENUE
P 0.BOX 2075
MORRISTOWN, NEW JERSEY 07962-2075
(973)993-8100
FACSIMILE (973)425-0161
BRIAN SORENSEN
Direct diah
(973) 425-4222
bsorensen@mdmc-law.com
July 17, 2018
VlA NYSCEF & FIRST CLASS MAIL
Lindsay DeCicco, Esq.
Weitz & Luxenberg, PC
700 Broadway
New York, New York 10003
RE: New York City Asbestos Litigation
Kevin K. Maloney and Karen Maloney v. Amchem Products, Inc., et al.
Index No. 190142/2018
MDMC File No.: V0105-3487
Dear Ms. DeCicco:
As you are aware, this firm represents defendant Flowserve US, Inc., solely as successor to
Rockwell Manufacturing Company, Edward Valves, Inc., Nordstrom Valves, Inc., and Edward Vogt
Valve Company ("Flowserve US"), in the above referenced matter. Based upon our review of all
discovery served in this matter and deposition testimony taken to date, it isour belief that there is
no identification of any product manufactured by Flowserve US. Therefore, in accordance with
the Amended CMO (Moulton, J.) dated June 20, 2017 Re: Unopposed Summary Judgment
Motion and Order ("USJM"), I request that you kindly execute the enclosed USJM and return
the original to my attention in the enclosed envelope within ten days as provided for by the June
20, 2017, Amended Case Management Order.
Please do not hesitate to contact me should you have any questions. Thank you for your
courtesies.
Very truly yours,
McELROY, DEUTSCH, MU VANEY & CARPENTER, LLP
Bnan Sorensen
slk
Enclosure
c: All Counsel of Record (w/enclosure, via NYSCEF Only)
NEW JERSEY NEW YORK PENNSYLVANIA CONNECTICUT MASSACHUSETTS COLORADO DELAWARE
3626025vl
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NEW YORK
ÏNitE: NÉÏV YORI COUNΟ NYCAL
ASBESTOS LITIGATION I.A.S. Part 13
_________... . . (Mendez, M.)
Index No.: 190142/2018
KEVIN K. MALONEY AND KAREN
MALONEY UNOPPOSED SUMMARY
JUDGMENT MOTION AND ORDER
____________.................
WHEREFORE, defendant, Flowserve US, Inc., solely as successor to Rockwell
Manufacturing Company, Edward Valves, Inc., Nordstrom Valves, Inc., and Edward Vogt Valve
Company (improperly named as Flowserve US, Inc., solely as successor to Rockwell
Manufacturing Company, Edward Valves, Inc., Nordstrom Valves, Inc., Edward Vogt Valve
Company, and Vogt Valve Company) ("Flowserve US"), hereby requests summary judgment in
the above-entitled case, pursuant to Civil Practice Law and Rules Section 3212, dismissing
plaintiffs'
Complaint against Flowserve US with prejudice, and there being no opposition
thereto.
ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against
defendant Flowserve US be and the same are hereby dismissed with prejudice and without costs.
Dated:
New York, New York
o
Lindsay DeCicco, Esq. Brian Sorensen, Esq.
Weitz & Luxenberg, PC McElroy, Deutsch, Mulvaney & Carpenter, LLP
Attorneys for Plaintiffs Attorneys for Defendant Flowserve US, Inc.
36th
700 Broadway 225 Liberty Street, Floor
New York, New York 10003 New York, New York 10281
SO ORDERED,
Honorable Manuel Mendez, J.S.C.
3626056vl
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NEW YORK
ÏN IÏË NÈW ŸOIEV COUNTY NYCAL
ASBESTOS LITIGATION LA.S. Part 13
..._________________________.__.___ _ (Mendez, M.)
KEVIN K. MALONEY AND KAREN Index No.: 190142/2018
MALONEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
STATE OF NEW JERSEY )
) ss:
COUNTY OF MORRIS )
HADIYA GRANT, being duly sworn, deposes and says: That deponent is not a party to
this action, is over 18-years of age and is employed at McElroy, Deutsch, Mulvaney, &
Carpenter, LLP, 1300 Mount Kemble Avenue, Morristown, New Jersey 07962-2075.
Further, deponent delivered on 2018 a true of the Unopposed
July | 7 , copy
Summary Judgm.ent Motion and Order, via NYSCEF and first class mail upon:
Lindsay DeCicco, Esq.
Weitz & Luxenberg, PC
700 Broadway
New York, New York 10003
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
and served via NYSCEF on the following:
HA YA GRANT
Sworn to and subscribed before me
this \3 day of July 2018
Notary Public
ODESSA S. AL ANO
Public of New Jerse
A Notary
Expires08/08/2 k%
Commission
My
36~6056vl
Received:259500 a 2018%O6e P002
KEVIN K. MAt.ONEY $9ryice (tider -
indmos ..
.'NSN4MS
N9.490142A6
Jonnuer Derger Esq
dudith Yev4t Esq
DARGER ERRANTE YAVITR & SLAU LLP
East 27th Street,12th
kterv.Yorlr,' Moor
New Voth, NY10016
(212)562-5300
far(2t2) 452-5301
EWisitidarger@daybUp.com:)yantz@NieytWlp.com
Attomeye for Demandant:
AMCHEfR PRODU T$, INC.
Nkta RHONEPOULRNCÂG COMPANY.
nWa BAYER CROPSCIENCE INC.
UNION CARBIDE€ORPORAT1DN
Kenyann Cook Esq
McGNNEY,KLUGER 8 COOK.P.C
80 Sroad Street, 23rd Floor
New York, NY 10004
(212).509-3456
5694420
fax'(212)
. E4Initkcook mklaw-ua.com
Attomeysibr Defendant.
ARMSTRONG POMRS. iNC.
Peter Dirnatzlo Esq.
CLYDE & CoUS L1)
The'
The Chrysler Soliding
4D5leñngton Avenue, 40th Floor
14tw York, NY 10174
(212) 7104913
. 7104950
fhr(212)
.E pitpete,øinunzie@cty4eco.us
. ..
ASomeVp for OefendanL' -.. .. ._, --
- -.-
..-., - - - -- . .
I
svJektlIAII,
SURNIIAN, the,
LLC,
fll4vi~ anrf ea elrpgeeeer,fe
5URNHAMCOMPORATION
Mtobeet
~
lNobeel f~nhaNll ~
'f@nenbsurn Foq
YAHSHIAU4l
Orts IIewM Center
LIP
1085Asymondsou evardd5thSt eat
Wvratk,
IIewark,ILI {Pf 02
II40y102
97 242-9002
fac(973)242-8099
E-Meit; mtanenha ,uom
Attomoysfor DefandanL'
Qetendarlr.
'- . .. . . .
. . Cffff
coRPQRATION, 9We VIACOM AC
. cas
comporation.1wo
; WESTRIGHOUSE ELECTRIC.COMPORATOQN
NERAL.t%ECTRIC C ANY . .
Angelo piQyliir
foal.
Xy,g&VSSLu
599 Leinfffan
Lextnglort AVa,
Qknrl FIOOr
Ave, 32ndFloor
hleMrYak,
New
..New NY40022
i(21+ 636.3900
(21+ - .
.
5384$IOI
Ier.'f242) 53MOI
forfar%)
6-MaI.
644k enget
angelo,~lb©Wyobsa,oem
4yete
AttomiyaIer a endant. .
In4vt
Irr4vlAelly ea Saioceeeor.
Chelly anrl
anrI eeSueceaaorIn
fe IrACIFIC
ppgIRC yAI„jjg
@ALES
I
1
I
1
.
hmI~H:)1BQ
IteIIJH:ÃBQ Asi ( 2018 11:0% IE
i
AsafW.5
Nancy McDonald Esq.
MCELROY, OEUTCH , MULVANEY 4 CARPENTER LLP
1300 Mount Kemble Avenue
P.0,tion 2075
Monistown,NJ07962
(973) 4284703
fan:(973) 425-0161 .
- .8-Ms'J.
E4llail: amedonaksdmo-law.com
Attomeys forDefendant
FLOWSERVEUsi9iC. .
as successorto RockweN Stanufacturing
Edward Valve,sac Company,
Nordstrom Va Inc.,EdamnfVogt
vahrecompany, ane vostvalvecompany
Seth Hughes Esq
Brady EdwardsEs4
Ctwistopher fanrwoelliEsq.
MORGAN LEWIS 8 GOCKlUS LLP
1000touIslane
StreetSuite4000
Houston, TX 77002 .
(212) 3094000
far(212)309·500t
E-Mail:
beth.hughes@morganlewis.corn;
brady,edwardsQmotganiewis.com;
ciannicanigmorgentewis.com
Attomeysfor Defendan
GQULDS PUMPS LLC
frT LLC..
Irnuvidualtyand
as successorto IIELt.
& 0088ETT
andaps•=•••ar toMENNEDY VALVE
MANIVACTURMG CO.,hc.
John Fanning Esq.
Raghs Benaeartadt Esq.
CULLEN AND DYKMAN, LLP
.44
44 WatSueet, 16th Floor
New York, NY 10005 .
(212)7324000
7424166.
fa×;(212)
E-Mall; pan ~
lenanddylonamooric
unependDyhmen.com - . .
Altomeysfor t. .
GOOLOGPUMPSta.C
DONALDPUGUESE Esq. . .
MCDERMOTT, WILL 4 EMERY
540saedison Ammu•.14thFloor
NEW YORK, NY 1@I73
(212) 5474400
'
fax(212)54NG44 . ..
E4sil:DPUGU COM
Anompys (or Oefenrfsntr
tfQStKA%iLL
HQHbhh%LI. --
INTGINATKMAL, 'OC
fHtr»
tWa ALUEDSIGNAL.INC.f BEND0t
Amory Mjnot Eaq
Amnry Esrf
dwrd Caprnere Es .
Joshus LeeEsq
RILEY SAFERNOIMES5 CANCILAttP
1330 Avenne
.1330Avence
1XQ Ayerioe catha Americas
6thFloor
New York, NY10019 · -
. (212)6Q0-1000 .
660-1000
far(gf·2)
EWait:eminat@rshoisw.core;ecaemeregraho4mw.com;
eiopeersheasw.concJewershWpw.com
Deleted„'
Attomeys for Defenders;
. -
':.:owess.a.uNois,sec.
-.- ' !
2 - '
}
7
4
I
'rlIf
I
I
Ii
bceived:25585500 h all!0% . 5
of /ts
PhHip O'8ourke Esq
$teven Corbirt Geg,
LEWIS BR(6001$ SISGAARD 4 SMITH,itP
77 WaterStreet.21stFloor
New York, NY 10006
(212)232-1300 .
232-1399
fax:(2i2)
E-Maik pNiip.o'rourkegiew)strisheis.com:
stavart Corbin@iewisbrisbois.com
Attorrieys forDefendatit
PEnRt,ESS ,lNDUSTR¾ INC.
Joan cestorEsq .
RENEULLI IAW F RM, LLP
1 North Broadway. Sute
1005
NV'
White Plains. NW10601
(014)2854700
fax:(914)285-1213
E4Wiait.jgasiorgrenzutliew.com
Attomeys forDefendant
PFEER, INC. (PFlZER)
Chris 0snoonEsq
Kim Reiter/peralegal
Steven Rosenblatt Esq
Theodore Eder Esq
SEGAL MCCAMBftlDGE $1NGER 4 MAHONEY. LTD .
660 Third Avenue. Suite 1100 .
york,NY 10022
(212 $51-750D
12) 651-74.99
E44altegennon@smaritcom; KReitergomernm
SROSENBIATTQ SMSM,COGR tedergsmsm.mrp
AttomeysforDefendent . - . ..
WinianCLAINL
a seAoNg
a evision
OWrrsd aobolOasy
«trOIty owned ~
of Theanadvy-Wygnip
Conveny,
ef The teartey CoIsijajy,
aebattmary of LLC
tLC
Cerrspeiy,
3
Preview
McELROY, DEUTSCH, MULVANEY & CARPENTER, LLP ATTORNEYS AT LAW 1300 MOUNT KEMBLE AVENUE P 0.BOX 2075 MORRISTOWN, NEW JERSEY 07962-2075 (973)993-8100 FACSIMILE (973)425-0161 BRIAN SORENSEN Direct diah (973) 425-4222 bsorensen@mdmc-law.com July 17, 2018 VlA NYSCEF & FIRST CLASS MAIL Lindsay DeCicco, Esq. Weitz & Luxenberg, PC 700 Broadway New York, New York 10003 RE: New York City Asbestos Litigation Kevin K. Maloney and Karen Maloney v. Amchem Products, Inc., et al. Index No. 190142/2018 MDMC File No.: V0105-3487 Dear Ms. DeCicco: As you are aware, this firm represents defendant Flowserve US, Inc., solely as successor to Rockwell Manufacturing Company, Edward Valves, Inc., Nordstrom Valves, Inc., and Edward Vogt Valve Company ("Flowserve US"), in the above referenced matter. Based upon our review of all discovery served in this matter and deposition testimony taken to date, it isour belief that there is no identification of any product manufactured by Flowserve US. Therefore, in accordance with the Amended CMO (Moulton, J.) dated June 20, 2017 Re: Unopposed Summary Judgment Motion and Order ("USJM"), I request that you kindly execute the enclosed USJM and return the original to my attention in the enclosed envelope within ten days as provided for by the June 20, 2017, Amended Case Management Order. Please do not hesitate to contact me should you have any questions. Thank you for your courtesies. Very truly yours, McELROY, DEUTSCH, MU VANEY & CARPENTER, LLP Bnan Sorensen slk Enclosure c: All Counsel of Record (w/enclosure, via NYSCEF Only) NEW JERSEY NEW YORK PENNSYLVANIA CONNECTICUT MASSACHUSETTS COLORADO DELAWARE 3626025vl SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK ÏNitE: NÉÏV YORI COUNΟ NYCAL ASBESTOS LITIGATION I.A.S. Part 13 _________... . . (Mendez, M.) Index No.: 190142/2018 KEVIN K. MALONEY AND KAREN MALONEY UNOPPOSED SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION AND ORDER ____________................. WHEREFORE, defendant, Flowserve US, Inc., solely as successor to Rockwell Manufacturing Company, Edward Valves, Inc., Nordstrom Valves, Inc., and Edward Vogt Valve Company (improperly named as Flowserve US, Inc., solely as successor to Rockwell Manufacturing Company, Edward Valves, Inc., Nordstrom Valves, Inc., Edward Vogt Valve Company, and Vogt Valve Company) ("Flowserve US"), hereby requests summary judgment in the above-entitled case, pursuant to Civil Practice Law and Rules Section 3212, dismissing plaintiffs' Complaint against Flowserve US with prejudice, and there being no opposition thereto. ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against defendant Flowserve US be and the same are hereby dismissed with prejudice and without costs. Dated: New York, New York o Lindsay DeCicco, Esq. Brian Sorensen, Esq. Weitz & Luxenberg, PC McElroy, Deutsch, Mulvaney & Carpenter, LLP Attorneys for Plaintiffs Attorneys for Defendant Flowserve US, Inc. 36th 700 Broadway 225 Liberty Street, Floor New York, New York 10003 New York, New York 10281 SO ORDERED, Honorable Manuel Mendez, J.S.C. 3626056vl SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK ÏN IÏË NÈW ŸOIEV COUNTY NYCAL ASBESTOS LITIGATION LA.S. Part 13 ..._________________________.__.___ _ (Mendez, M.) KEVIN K. MALONEY AND KAREN Index No.: 190142/2018 MALONEY AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ) ) ss: COUNTY OF MORRIS ) HADIYA GRANT, being duly sworn, deposes and says: That deponent is not a party to this action, is over 18-years of age and is employed at McElroy, Deutsch, Mulvaney, & Carpenter, LLP, 1300 Mount Kemble Avenue, Morristown, New Jersey 07962-2075. Further, deponent delivered on 2018 a true of the Unopposed July | 7 , copy Summary Judgm.ent Motion and Order, via NYSCEF and first class mail upon: Lindsay DeCicco, Esq. Weitz & Luxenberg, PC 700 Broadway New York, New York 10003 Attorneys for Plaintiffs and served via NYSCEF on the following: HA YA GRANT Sworn to and subscribed before me this \3 day of July 2018 Notary Public ODESSA S. AL ANO Public of New Jerse A Notary Expires08/08/2 k% Commission My 36~6056vl Received:259500 a 2018%O6e P002 KEVIN K. MAt.ONEY $9ryice (tider - indmos .. .'NSN4MS N9.490142A6 Jonnuer Derger Esq dudith Yev4t Esq DARGER ERRANTE YAVITR & SLAU LLP East 27th Street,12th kterv.Yorlr,' Moor New Voth, NY10016 (212)562-5300 far(2t2) 452-5301 EWisitidarger@daybUp.com:)yantz@NieytWlp.com Attomeye for Demandant: AMCHEfR PRODU T$, INC. Nkta RHONEPOULRNCÂG COMPANY. nWa BAYER CROPSCIENCE INC. UNION CARBIDE€ORPORAT1DN Kenyann Cook Esq McGNNEY,KLUGER 8 COOK.P.C 80 Sroad Street, 23rd Floor New York, NY 10004 (212).509-3456 5694420 fax'(212) . E4Initkcook mklaw-ua.com Attomeysibr Defendant. ARMSTRONG POMRS. iNC. Peter Dirnatzlo Esq. CLYDE & CoUS L1) The' The Chrysler Soliding 4D5leñngton Avenue, 40th Floor 14tw York, NY 10174 (212) 7104913 . 7104950 fhr(212) .E pitpete,øinunzie@cty4eco.us . .. ASomeVp for OefendanL' -.. .. ._, -- - -.- ..-., - - - -- . . I svJektlIAII, SURNIIAN, the, LLC, fll4vi~ anrf ea elrpgeeeer,fe 5URNHAMCOMPORATION Mtobeet ~ lNobeel f~nhaNll ~ 'f@nenbsurn Foq YAHSHIAU4l Orts IIewM Center LIP 1085Asymondsou evardd5thSt eat Wvratk, IIewark,ILI {Pf 02 II40y102 97 242-9002 fac(973)242-8099 E-Meit; mtanenha ,uom Attomoysfor DefandanL' Qetendarlr. '- . .. . . . . . Cffff coRPQRATION, 9We VIACOM AC . cas comporation.1wo ; WESTRIGHOUSE ELECTRIC.COMPORATOQN NERAL.t%ECTRIC C ANY . . Angelo piQyliir foal. Xy,g&VSSLu 599 Leinfffan Lextnglort AVa, Qknrl FIOOr Ave, 32ndFloor hleMrYak, New ..New NY40022 i(21+ 636.3900 (21+ - . . 5384$IOI Ier.'f242) 53MOI forfar%) 6-MaI. 644k enget angelo,~lb©Wyobsa,oem 4yete AttomiyaIer a endant. . In4vt Irr4vlAelly ea Saioceeeor. Chelly anrl anrI eeSueceaaorIn fe IrACIFIC ppgIRC yAI„jjg @ALES I 1 I 1 . hmI~H:)1BQ IteIIJH:ÃBQ Asi ( 2018 11:0% IE i AsafW.5 Nancy McDonald Esq. MCELROY, OEUTCH , MULVANEY 4 CARPENTER LLP 1300 Mount Kemble Avenue P.0,tion 2075 Monistown,NJ07962 (973) 4284703 fan:(973) 425-0161 . - .8-Ms'J. E4llail: amedonaksdmo-law.com Attomeys forDefendant FLOWSERVEUsi9iC. . as successorto RockweN Stanufacturing Edward Valve,sac Company, Nordstrom Va Inc.,EdamnfVogt vahrecompany, ane vostvalvecompany Seth Hughes Esq Brady EdwardsEs4 Ctwistopher fanrwoelliEsq. MORGAN LEWIS 8 GOCKlUS LLP 1000touIslane StreetSuite4000 Houston, TX 77002 . (212) 3094000 far(212)309·500t E-Mail: beth.hughes@morganlewis.corn; brady,edwardsQmotganiewis.com; ciannicanigmorgentewis.com Attomeysfor Defendan GQULDS PUMPS LLC frT LLC.. Irnuvidualtyand as successorto IIELt. & 0088ETT andaps•=•••ar toMENNEDY VALVE MANIVACTURMG CO.,hc. John Fanning Esq. Raghs Benaeartadt Esq. CULLEN AND DYKMAN, LLP .44 44 WatSueet, 16th Floor New York, NY 10005 . (212)7324000 7424166. fa×;(212) E-Mall; pan ~ lenanddylonamooric unependDyhmen.com - . . Altomeysfor t. . GOOLOGPUMPSta.C DONALDPUGUESE Esq. . . MCDERMOTT, WILL 4 EMERY 540saedison Ammu•.14thFloor NEW YORK, NY 1@I73 (212) 5474400 ' fax(212)54NG44 . .. E4sil:DPUGU COM Anompys (or Oefenrfsntr tfQStKA%iLL HQHbhh%LI. -- INTGINATKMAL, 'OC fHtr» tWa ALUEDSIGNAL.INC.f BEND0t Amory Mjnot Eaq Amnry Esrf dwrd Caprnere Es . Joshus LeeEsq RILEY SAFERNOIMES5 CANCILAttP 1330 Avenne .1330Avence 1XQ Ayerioe catha Americas 6thFloor New York, NY10019 · - . (212)6Q0-1000 . 660-1000 far(gf·2) EWait:eminat@rshoisw.core;ecaemeregraho4mw.com; eiopeersheasw.concJewershWpw.com Deleted„' Attomeys for Defenders; . - ':.:owess.a.uNois,sec. -.- ' ! 2 - ' } 7 4 I 'rlIf I I Ii bceived:25585500 h all!0% . 5 of /ts PhHip O'8ourke Esq $teven Corbirt Geg, LEWIS BR(6001$ SISGAARD 4 SMITH,itP 77 WaterStreet.21stFloor New York, NY 10006 (212)232-1300 . 232-1399 fax:(2i2) E-Maik pNiip.o'rourkegiew)strisheis.com: stavart Corbin@iewisbrisbois.com Attorrieys forDefendatit PEnRt,ESS ,lNDUSTR¾ INC. Joan cestorEsq . RENEULLI IAW F RM, LLP 1 North Broadway. Sute 1005 NV' White Plains. NW10601 (014)2854700 fax:(914)285-1213 E4Wiait.jgasiorgrenzutliew.com Attomeys forDefendant PFEER, INC. (PFlZER) Chris 0snoonEsq Kim Reiter/peralegal Steven Rosenblatt Esq Theodore Eder Esq SEGAL MCCAMBftlDGE $1NGER 4 MAHONEY. LTD . 660 Third Avenue. Suite 1100 . york,NY 10022 (212 $51-750D 12) 651-74.99 E44altegennon@smaritcom; KReitergomernm SROSENBIATTQ SMSM,COGR tedergsmsm.mrp AttomeysforDefendent . - . .. WinianCLAINL a seAoNg a evision OWrrsd aobolOasy «trOIty owned ~ of Theanadvy-Wygnip Conveny, ef The teartey CoIsijajy, aebattmary of LLC tLC Cerrspeiy, 3