Preview
Filing # 108684924 E-Filed 06/10/2020 04:24:04 PM
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
EN AND FOR CHARLOTTE COUNTY, FLORIDA
CIVIL ACTION
CASE NO. 17-CA-917
HARRY BIEBERSTEIN,
Plaintiff,
v
GABRIEL KIRCHBERGER, CAROL DEVILLE
SOUTHERN SHORES ENTERPRISES, LLC, a
Florida limited liability company and
MOONSTONE HOLDINGS, LLC, a
Nevada limited liability company
Defendants.
GOLDEN KEY PROPERTIES, LLC'S SUMMARY OF PROPERTY APPRAISER’S
JUST VALUES AND PRINTOUT FROM PROPERTY APPRAISER’S WEBSITE
Golden Key Properties, LLC and Andreas Kirchberger, through counsel, file their
Summary of Property Appraiser’s Just Values (“Summary”) and Printout from the Charlotte
County Property Appraiser’s website ("Printout")
The Summary and Printout are submitted for use in connection with the bearing
scheduled on Golden Key Properties, L1.C's and Andreas Kirchberger’s Motion to Discharge Lis
Pendens or, Alternatively, to Require a Bond and for an Award of Attorneys’ Fees and Costs (the
“Mation”) The Motion is presently set for hearing on june 17, 2020.
‘The parties have stipulated that for purposes of the hearing on the Motion, the values
listed on the Property Appraiser’s website represent the fair market values of the properties.
‘The panties have aot stipulated that the amount of any lis pendens bond should be based
on such market values
‘The parties have stipulated that the attached printouts from the Property Appraiser's
website will suffice as evidence admitted at the hearing solely on the issue of establishing fair
market values of the listed properties
The Summary and Print are attached herete.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
WE HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and comect copy of the foregoing has been filed with the
Cierk of Court via the Florida Courts B-Filing Portal which will serve as a notices of electronic
filing upon all counsel of record on June 14), 2020
BAUR & KLEIN, @A
Attorneys for Golden Key Properties, LLC
& Andras Kiechberger
1001 Brickell Bay Grive, Suine 1200
Miami. Plorida 33171
Phone, (305) 377-3561
a
By
CURL OPHER JL ALBIN
Pla No. SHSSS
eklein@ worldwidelaww.com
vcardonne@woridwidelaw.com
eet mnie annaemint a co ps
|
apie =
eSeee
SLR e "Ss oaoe By Bey 5a) ft
)
7
tt
bd
ee
ee ep
| sf -
RGalGalealialclon he aSaS kore
i
{ee
1 ee
Hl
ER
a8 15 88
lal
%
‘eleeal 2)eal es
a8 Rei BD
a Be) Bl
LAO. 5
Set fel ca
3 ey ie 2 Bl 3
is
Bei
i ay 13 ahh tat le alels She1
te JPRS eB
Saeed gf By
bo:
sans Br
8 spieaeah
ea) wi Sy
1,
me 15]
Sie
Be
ata leis
&e
5 EE!
ait ae
ate six
212 38
lB Sh 8 |5
8, 51/1818 2s ey oie ie
a2 ~~ Fi
a! itA a B
ielel 8 Soe xe Blea
oy Teee
=
ag Sole 8S 6G)
ulaet i
i
gee
= Fe 2a
2 Py Bz
clo 99 723
e=
i Be aye
Ble he ie eee Siyis
Bie ee Paes
BiB|e gig
a7 Best
6 sie ae Pe2
Sx
a3 HT Th etyabn ny oyeee
ay ale
BB
4
& tse se deo 4 alc a Bits
oe
ag 8)&
: :
ol iit
Bie
rica S| |
ashe’ aos 2 Feige bel Be 5 & Bl
A SS alo! oe Bm solic :
RANI
is BUYS
2
= a8 Si31e3
oS
Bs BSS
Se Sei6 g
RRS
S12
as ee
|=
f
S815) let Se8a
a gil Soonl eg Bs a Haul
ee
ie “a 23) a St
®
i
mS Sete “el % SI
Oe 7H etEighs Bas Bi
* Joe |iSGe
tet
#
a
= oe
|
il s easeloe wa wdZi i Se es 0 SE
al Be He Sie
elt
aH
se
Bl ala Dos ol
Bit gle
Be! iies, HeLa Ent no) Sleeel eS
i SR calea|
3 al 1818) gsleisie's3 2 HC
Real Property Record Search
see CLICK ON PARCEL ID FOR PARCEL DETAIL *****
2015
2019 Current
Parcel 1D Oumer Cortified
Property Address = Short Legal ; Certified
Taxable
[Just Vai?
Value?
)GOLDEN KEY 950 TAMIAMI TRL - “GOP
000 0DCa 80
PROPERTIES LLC |BLOG 1 ‘COMM $0) 4978
GOLDEN KEY 946 TAMIAMI TRL + GOP 000 feaG
402101878000 "PROPERTIES Lic
BLOG 2 COMM 41476
{GOLDEN KEY 942 TAMIAMI TRL - GOP gd 0000
__. {PROPERTIES LLC BLDG 3 ‘COMM 1178 |
a
GOLDEN KEY 942 TAMIAMI
TRL - {GOP G00 0000
PROPERTIES LLC UNIT 304 0301 $128,839, $98,537 1806
GOLDEN KEY 942 TAMIAMI TRL - GOP 000 0000
> ARA1DABZENDR PROPERTIES Lic $128,839) $98.537 1906
ce UNIT 302
|
IGOLDEN KEY
ROPERTIES LLC
1842 TAMIAMI TRL-
jUNIT 303
GOP
000 0000
$51,436 $Sh.138
| 1203 |
GOLDEN KEY 1042 TAMIAMI TRI, GOP
000 0000
402101875004 PROPERTIES Lic
[UNIT 304 851135 $91,138 1203 |
—. oe
iGOLOEN KEY — 945 TAMIAMI TRL - GOP 000 0000
AQZIDIBTHONS “PROPERTIES LLC
JUNIT 204 8264
$122,844 $%6.537) 1906
GOLDEN KEY ‘948 TAMIAMI TRL - GOP 000.9000 |
wena PROPERTIES LLC UNE 202 looaz $57.82: s67.s28)
~
1203
“GOLDEN KEY
4024 01876007. (PROPERTIES LEC
(046 TAMIAMI TRL GOP
000 o000
UNIT 203 $91,088. $87,086; 1104
nehrerere:
2ag of January 1, 2019
Page
t of 11 Next Last
You can download a data file cr create reports from the results of your search.
.
3
Copyright 2620 Chartotie County Property Appraiser All nghis resnresd.
we see
Real Property Record Search
sane®
ante CLICK O1 IN PARCEL ID FOR PARCELDI ET: TAIL see
|
"
2018
2019 Current
Parcel iD Cortified
Owner Property Address — Short Legal { Certified Taxable
fuse Value? Code
— Value?
~~}
(GOLDEN KEY ‘946 TAMIAMITRL- GOP 000 0000
OPERTIES LLC [UNIT 204 0204
394, $91,098 1104
oe
}GOLDEN KEY (946 TAMIAMI
TRL - GOP 000 op00
$80,
ROPERTIES (LC UNIT 205 0205 $57,428 1104
GOLDEN KEY (50 TAMIAMI TRI GOP
000 0000
ADZUNISTEOI
a PROPERTIES LLC UNIT 104 2104
236,473, $224,473; 1906
IGOLOEN KEY
(PROPERTIES
ft onan LLC
(950 TAMIAMI TRL -
(ner 103,
iGOP
000 0000
103
sad $80,453 1908
950 TAMIAMI TRL -
S021
iGOLDEN KEY
TOI. PROPERTIES Lic UNET 104
OP 000 000
O14—
sescca $66,402; 1104
GOLDEN KEY 950 TAMIAMI TRL - GOP 000 0000
A02101BTEOM4
on operties LLC UNIT 105 105
$85,428, $06,428 1203
AOZI1BTMIS,
GOLDEN KEY 950 TAMIAMI TRL - ‘GOP 000 0000
PROPERTIES LLC UNIT 106 3106 1906
GOLDEN KEY
A0ZIOUBZARIG PROPERTIES Li.C
(950 TAMIAMI TRL - SOP 000 0000.
(UNIT 107
$1 men S77 S74 1906
107 i
i GOLDEN KEY "950 TAMIAME TRE - ‘GOP 060 ODN |
|nazeosavens7"PROPERTIES LLC $26,154 $236,194 1908
f UNIT 708 3108
GOLDEN KEY
“PROPERTIES LLC
950 TAMIAMI TRL -
UN 109
OP 000 0000
ote $160686 wud 1906
2s of January1, 2019
First Previous Page 2ef 11 Next Last
You can download a data fle ov create reports from the results of your search.
~—
Sopyright
2070 Chactotie Coons: Property Appratuer A: nyhts reserved.
re
noha) aoe es
Ss,
Real Property Record Search
es mmm ann GLICK ON PARCEL
aa neh tnd1G preps
FOR mtn
PARCEL GETAIL
fen ****
ae _ Current
» Paroel2 Property Adiimae | Short Legal Certified -
ol
auabie
haat Vale?
peersso eennin serena Cabot.
OLDEN KEY “Sh TAMARA TRL
{GOP 000 O80)
OPERTIES WC teat ne be
$240,589 $246, S85 1908
ecg es ae fsa
IGOLBEN KEY bso TAMU TAL - SOP G08 S000
AOE on eeerics & Se 208 4288 18
femme tre ndmnasitiammesne oe ONT 44 ont
waned
oe rein
NY REY “Jes0 Taian TRL - sOOP G00 0000 ©
MOAI O 2b (PROPERTIES: Be june st2 O02
waied 1203
vee os nbn sername
GOLDEN KEY (980 TAMIAMI TRL GOP 600 GONG
"PROPERTIES LLG 1.¢ AUMIT 11 Ove
sesacd —— s0h.400 noe
ce
_GOLDEN KEY RE CORTES
eases BENE 8ar 27
vemunnatiesh SOUDEN EY Aca
HOO KINGS HWY
GOLDEN KEY
nt tpege ea
GOINGS HINY
ate Pg
R68023.
see
$0
beara pomenn | '
PROPERNES Re Pie
$10 Oot
sie nein sean e etintnmntenninn th
IGOLOEN KEY REZ O6A02S
A senting PROPSITIES wi Sto et
pier mini eonULC snc ee ta PABnny
etna ene oe ms
GOLDEN KEV
ROPERTE
sea
GOLDEN
pres $10,352 sio.ste) S008
pes inne spe:
PROPERTIES LLC
Aas RIMES HAE
PST
SE08.S08 SmRE ase dOnt
co cons Sense sin tt pie
GOLDEN REY SAGES TIGEO BLVD BFC 000.0000
AUESEERUOT opescries 120
aman tn Agena nsbtncheBLOG)
eto Korea sions se
SUB R
aan na
Sh AST AR 4800
Le
|
*Aa
of January4,
Firat Previous: Paye Sof th Next Last
You can download a date fle or create reports from the results of your search.
ve cond | serine
iF
Conpeptght 2020 Charge Gowrey Propaniy Apgensar. Ad aghts cemarueet,
seman soem agement eter i ntnornion nnn nance,
Real Property Record Search
sen CLICK ON PARCEL ID FOR PARCEL DETAIL ***
re | om Property Address. Short Lega!
2019
Certified
Just Val
20%:
Certified
Taxable
Current
ween me Value*
GOLDEN KEY
(402307 101007, PROPERTIES L1.C
‘Ee4050 TISEO Bi vo BFC 000 0009,
$1,882,2 $1,487,105
|
LOG UNIT 1 looot
OLDEN KEY
‘|
(24050 TISEO BLVD
PROPERTIES LLC ‘BLDG 1-UNIT 2 BFC 000 ls $3,882,738! $4,487,100
001
‘GOLDEN KEY
SOREL, PROPERTIES LLC
24050 TISEO BLVD - Jere 060 0000
BLOG 1-UNIT3 $ 1,062. 738! $1,457,
70008
se
OLDEN KEY 124050 TISEO BLVD - BFC 000 0000
_ PROPERTIES ULC (BLOG 4-UNIT 4 0001 $1,962,738} $1,457,100 4800
Ln een
“GOLDEN KEY 124050 TISEO BLVD - ‘BFC 000 0000
AO2SO7INIDOT PROPERTIES LLC
‘GOLDEN KEY
BLDG
124050
1-UNIT 5
TISEO BLVD -
0001
BFC 000 0000
$1,962,738
=
$1,457,1
he $1 902.798 $1,457,100
PROPERTIES LLC BLOG 1-UNIT6 9001
serene
{GOLDEN KEY 124050 TISEO BLVD - BEC
000 on00!
peoaaazaeioar, PROPERTIES LLC (BLOG 1-UNIT 7 0004
$4,862,738,- naval 4800
a
‘GOLDEN KEY [24050 TISEO BLVD - BFC 000 0000
ROPERTIES LLC LOGS TUNITS looes 34,862,738 84467100; 480)
rene merfemrn i
GOLDEN KEY
(PROPERTIES LLC
2a 00 TISEO BLVD | BFC 000 000
31,862.738) $1,457.11 4800
“
BLOG2 0001 tenn ae
GOLDEN KEY 24100 TISEO Bu CG 000 0000!
PROPERTIES LLC $1,082,738: $1,457.100' 400
BLOG 2-UNIT 10
ne
74% of January 1, 2019
Ekst Previous Page
4 of 17 Next Last
You can download @ data file or create reports from the results of your search,
ene *
Copyright 2020 Cha totte County Proparty Anpeaizer All righis reserved,
Le
Real Property Record Search
“68 CLICK ON PARCEL ID FOR PARCEL DETAIL *****
2019
2019 Current
Cartified
Parcel iD Owner Property Address | Shovt Legal Certified Usi
raxabi
Just Value? Code °
Vatue®
DEN KEY 124100 TISEO BLVD - iBFC 090 oo00
$1,862,738) $1487,10% 4800 |
|st,
‘PROPERTIES iL
ramen KEY
iBLDG 2-UNIT 12
{24100 TISEO BLVD -
10001
(BFC 900 0000
| ‘
PROPERTIES LLC
t
{BLOG 2-UNIT 13 0001
$1,862, 738! $1,457, 19 4800
“GOLDEN KEY, ‘ear00 TISEO BLVD - "BFC
000 0000"
$1,862,738)
AOROTIOIONT popeRTIES LLC BLOG 24UNIT 14 (0004
$4,457,100. 4800
OLDEN KEY 24100 TISEO BLVD ~ "BFC 000 0000
AS $1.802.736. $14874
PROPERTIES LLC BLOG 2-UNIT 16
GOLDEN KEY 24100 TISEO BLVD - ‘BFC 000 0000:
soci PROPERTIES LLC BLOG 2.UNIT 3 0007
$4,082,738 $1,487,105
LDEN KEY 24100 TISEO BLVD [BFC 000 C000.
$1,882,738 $1,457,10 4800
_ PROPERTIES LLC levoe 2ANNIT 4 = 004 pot ee {_ 2 in
“‘To.nen kev (24100 TISEO BLVD - BFC 000 0000)
$1,862,738 $1.487,100 4800
PROPERTIES LLC jBLOG 2-UNIT5 jo001
GOLDEN KEY 241000 TISEO BLVD- ‘BFC
$1882,7381 $1457, 100 4800
ROPERTIES LLC 'BLOG 2-UNIT6 0001
;OLDEN KEY BFC 000 0000;
124150 TISEO BLVD = 3319, 872) 1100
fOPERTIES LLC
GOLDEN KEY 24450 TISEO BLYD -UNIT BFC 000 0000)
An2BL1N1008, PROPERTIES LLC 0002 i $319,872 $319, 872. 4400
As of January 4, 2019
Flest Previous Page
5 of 11 Mext Last
You can download a data file or create reports from the results of your search.
Copyright 2020 Charlotte Coury Praperty Agoraiger, All rights ceseeved.
a ee,
oe
aS
Real Property Record Search
See me"
see GLICK OR PARCEL (D FOR PARCEL DETAR, “se
i O18
219
Corified
Parosit | Couner | Property Addroas ShortLegel Certified
Tanabe
| dost Vatue*
sina
Vitus?
een
{GOLDEN KEY Qai10d TISEO BLYO - BSC
oo0 DOG Tf
SHee $20,872, OO
heteroFROPERTIOS U0 snc thfeNe Oca eaten Lebron tne ars san on a foe
EN Baise SFSEO BLVE- BEC G8 0000
BD. IES LLC ‘UNITS 0002
3319,078) SG are von”
oe ue tn sine ese
GOLDEN KEY eae TISEG BLVD « “Gre 090 8000
SNG8TE, IRIE MOO
Pace satenantetett PROPERTIES
_
eee a
BL UNIT 4
stent sete ce sc ce
‘GOLDEN KEY eet PLACIDARD > “gee800
AUT MOPERTIES LL BLOG
S1AMATE 4a008.173 te08
poemecnnni vce oe oe Gece “annem
sana ip oe
OLDEN KEY 2851 PLACIDARD = BNC 008
(PROPERTIES
1.469,4179 SHA8S.173, 1900
Lo nencnsint ate inane tet LLGmeta aioe Bn a IS1QGALL,
smo stonehenge ae
GOLDEN KEY 2864 PLACIDARD - Tove 009
yuna “PROPERTIES LLC BIDS sit OAL
BY 483,473 S1A8373 ROD
Spree . sedfestorae .
“GOLDEN KEY (A887 PLACIOA RD « VG OGD
ST 8SY
PROPER VES (1.0 LISLE 109 $1824 {ee :
be ristesnren si ade regions annie
GOLDER KEY 2651 GLACIDA RD + OVC oo
BACLT S1Aa5,073, 1800
SUAULAL Nenorernies the
shins enone otOBALL cee
JON Ae ep cyano yenopenatna mone nt Se i
‘GOLDEN KEY
AURIS PROPERTIES LL
“285 PLAGIDA RD - SVC OD $,683,1% SABAH