Preview
Filing # 107826534 E-Filed 05/21/2020 04:48:04 PM
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 14™
JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR BAY
COUNTY, FLORIDA
JAMES MCDOUGAL AND GINGER
MCDOUGAL, CASE NO.: 19004523CA
Plaintiff,
vs.
CERTAIN UNDERWRITER’S AT
LLOYD’S, LONDON SUBSCRIBING TO
POLICY NUMBER: ACA080027600-01,
Defendant.
/
DEFENDANT, CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYD’S LONDON SUBSCRIBING
TO POLICY NUMBER ACA080027600-01, PRIVILEGE LOG RESPONSIVE TO
PLAINTIFF’S REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION
Defendant, Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s, London Subscribing to Policy Number
ACA080027600-01 (“Underwriters”), by and through its undersigned counsel and pursuant to
Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.350, serves the following Privilege Log in connection with the
documents being produced in response to Plaintiffs, James and Ginger McDougal (“Plaintiffs”),
Request for Production.
Bates No. Author Recipient Description of | Asserted
Document Privilege
McDougal__0001- | Rory Shawn Email Attorney-Client
0005 Zamansky, Quintana, correspondence | Communication.
Zelle, LLP; ICAT/ Boulder | exchanged with
Claims; counsel
Shawn regarding claim.
Quintana, Rory
ICAT/ Zamansky,
Boulder Zelle, LLP
Claims
ZELLE LLP
Sun Trust International Center, One Southeast Third Avenue, Suite 1600 Miami, Florida 33131
Telephone 786-693-2350 — Facsimile 612-336-9100CASE NO.: 19004523CA
Bates No. Author Recipient Description of | Asserted
Document Privilege
McDougal__0007- | Courtney Rory Email Attorney-Client
0008 Flowers, Zamansky, correspondence | Communication.
ICAT/ Zelle, LLP; exchanged with
Boulder counsel
Claims; Courtney regarding claim.
Flowers,
Rory ICAT/ Boulder
Zamansky, Claims
Zelle, LLP
McDougal__0027- | ICAT/ ICAT/ Boulder | Internal status Internal claim
0030 Boulder Claims report. handling
Claims document; Work
Product;
Confidential/
Proprietary/
Trade Secret;
Relevance.
McDougal__0040- | Courtney Christina Email Work Product and
0042 Flowers, Holton, ITEL | correspondence | Claims File
ICAT/ Laboratories; regarding Privilege. Not
Boulder internal claim reasonably
Claims; Courtney handling. calculated to lead
Flowers, to the discovery
Christina ICAT/ Boulder of admissible
Holton, ITEL | Claims evidence.
Laboratories
McDougal__0043 Courtney John Adams, Email Work Product and
Flowers, Compass correspondence | Claims File
ICAT/ Adjusting regarding Privilege. Not
Boulder internal claim reasonably
Claims handling. calculated to lead
to the discovery
of admissible
evidence.
McDougal__0044- | Keystone Courtney Email Work Product and
0045 Experts and Flowers, correspondence | Claims File
regarding Privilege. Not
reasonably
ZELLE LLP
Sun Trust International Center, One Southeast Third Avenue, Suite 1600 Miami, Florida 33131
Telephone 786-693-2350 — Facsimile 612-336-9100
Page 2 of 6CASE NO.: 19004523CA
Bates No. Author Recipient Description of | Asserted
Document Privilege
Engineers, ICAT/ Boulder | internal claim. calculated to lead
LLC Claims handling. to the discovery
of admissible
evidence.
McDougal__0049- | ICAT/ ICAT/ Boulder | Internal Work Product and
0050 Boulder Claims Assignment Claims File
Claims Sheet. Privilege. Not
reasonably
calculated to lead
to the discovery
of admissible
evidence.
McDougal__0066- | ICAT/ ICAT/ Boulder | Internal Status Work Product and
0069 Boulder Claims Report. Claims File
Claims Privilege. Not
reasonably
calculated to lead
to the discovery
of admissible
evidence.
McDougal__0141 Keystone ICAT/ Boulder | Billing Invoice. | Confidential/
Experts and Claims Non-privileged | Proprietary/
Engineers, portions of this Trade Secret;
LLC document will be | Relevance.
produced in
redacted form.
McDougal__0146 ITEL ICAT/ Boulder | Billing Invoice. | Confidential/
Laboratories | Claims Non-privileged | Proprietary/
portions of this | Trade Secret;
document will be | Relevance.
produced in
redacted form.
McDougal__0147- | Certain Certain Declarations Confidential/
0148 Underwriters | Underwriters | Page of Proprietary/
at Lloyd’s, at Lloyd’s, Insurance Policy. | Trade Secret;
London London Reserve Relevance.
ZELLE LLP
Sun Trust International Center, One Southeast Third Avenue, Suite 1600 Miami, Florida 33131
Telephone 786-693-2350 — Facsimile 612-336-9100
Page 3 of 6CASE NO.: 19004523CA
Bates No. Author Recipient Description of | Asserted
Document Privilege
Information
redacted. Non-
privileged
portions of this
document will be
produced in
redacted form.
McDougal__0322- | Mueller Certain Underwriting Confidential/
0335 Reports Underwriters Report. Proprietary/
at Lloyd’s Trade Secret;
London Relevance.
McDougal__0336- | US Adjusting | ICAT/ Boulder | Billing Invoice. | Confidential/
0337 Services Claims Non-privileged | Proprietary/
portions of this Trade Secret;
document will be | Relevance.
produced in
redacted form.
McDougal__0376- | Compass ICAT/ Boulder | Adjuster Loss Contfidential/
0378 Adjusting Claims Report. Reserve | Proprietary/
Services information Trade Secret;
redacted. Non- | Relevance.
privileged
portions of this
document will be
produced in
redacted form.
McDougal__0423 Compass ICAT/ Boulder | Billing Invoice. | Confidential/
Adjusting Claims Non-privileged | Proprietary/
Services portions of this | Trade Secret;
document will be | Relevance.
produced in
redacted form.
McDougal__0424- | Compass ICAT/ Boulder | Adjuster Loss Confidential/
0426 Adjusting Claims Report. Reserve | Proprietary/
Services information Trade Secret;
redacted. Non- | Relevance.
privileged
ZELLE LLP
Sun Trust International Center, One Southeast Third Avenue, Suite 1600 Miami, Florida 33131
Telephone 786-693-2350 — Facsimile 612-336-9100
Page 4 of 6CASE NO.: 19004523CA
Bates No. Author Recipient Description of | Asserted
Document Privilege
portions of this
document will be
produced in
redacted form.
McDougal__0453- | Compass ICAT/ Boulder | Adjuster Loss Confidential/
0454 Adjusting Claims Report. Reserve | Proprietary/
Services information Trade Secret;
redacted. Non- | Relevance.
privileged
portions of this
document will be
produced in
redacted form.
Defendant, Underwriters, reserves the right to amend this privilege log as necessary
throughout the course of ongoing discovery.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this 21% day of May, 2020, that a true and correct copy of
the foregoing was filed with the Court through the use of the Florida Courts eFiling Portal, and
has been served upon all parties on the attached Service List via 0 First Class U.S. Mail, and/or
M via the Florida Courts e-Filing Portal eService, in accordance with rule 2.516, Florida Rules of
Judicial Administration.
ZELLE LLP
Sun Trust International Center, One Southeast Third Avenue, Suite 1600 Miami, Florida 33131
Telephone 786-693-2350 — Facsimile 612-336-9100
Page 5 of 6Insurance Litigation Group, P.A.
Kimesha S. Smith, Esq.
1500 NE 162" Street
Miami, Florida 33162
service@ILGPA.COM
Counsel for Plaintiff
Law Offices J. Patrick Floyd, Chtd.
J. Patrick Floyd, Esq.
408 Long Avenue
Port St. Joe, FL 32456
j-patrickfloyd@jpatrickfloyd.com
Co-Counsel for Plaintiff
CASE NO.: 19004523CA
ZELLE LLP
Counsel for Defendant
SunTrust International Center
One Southeast Third Avenue, Ste. 1600
Miami, Florida 33131-4332
Tel: 786-693-2350
Fax: 612-336-9100
By:4s/ Christine M. Renella
CHRISTINE M. RENELLA
Florida Bar. No. 65485
crenella@zelle.com
STEFANY D. ESFANDIARY
Florida Bar No. 126304
sesfandiary@zelle.com
SERVICE LIST
ZELLE LLP
Sun Trust International Center, One Southeast Third Avenue, Suite 1600 Miami, Florida 33131
Telephone 786-693-2350 — Facsimile 612-336-9100
4826-7724-1782v1
Page 6 of 6
Preview
Filing # 107826534 E-Filed 05/21/2020 04:48:04 PM IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 14™ JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR BAY COUNTY, FLORIDA JAMES MCDOUGAL AND GINGER MCDOUGAL, CASE NO.: 19004523CA Plaintiff, vs. CERTAIN UNDERWRITER’S AT LLOYD’S, LONDON SUBSCRIBING TO POLICY NUMBER: ACA080027600-01, Defendant. / DEFENDANT, CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYD’S LONDON SUBSCRIBING TO POLICY NUMBER ACA080027600-01, PRIVILEGE LOG RESPONSIVE TO PLAINTIFF’S REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION Defendant, Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s, London Subscribing to Policy Number ACA080027600-01 (“Underwriters”), by and through its undersigned counsel and pursuant to Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.350, serves the following Privilege Log in connection with the documents being produced in response to Plaintiffs, James and Ginger McDougal (“Plaintiffs”), Request for Production. Bates No. Author Recipient Description of | Asserted Document Privilege McDougal__0001- | Rory Shawn Email Attorney-Client 0005 Zamansky, Quintana, correspondence | Communication. Zelle, LLP; ICAT/ Boulder | exchanged with Claims; counsel Shawn regarding claim. Quintana, Rory ICAT/ Zamansky, Boulder Zelle, LLP Claims ZELLE LLP Sun Trust International Center, One Southeast Third Avenue, Suite 1600 Miami, Florida 33131 Telephone 786-693-2350 — Facsimile 612-336-9100CASE NO.: 19004523CA Bates No. Author Recipient Description of | Asserted Document Privilege McDougal__0007- | Courtney Rory Email Attorney-Client 0008 Flowers, Zamansky, correspondence | Communication. ICAT/ Zelle, LLP; exchanged with Boulder counsel Claims; Courtney regarding claim. Flowers, Rory ICAT/ Boulder Zamansky, Claims Zelle, LLP McDougal__0027- | ICAT/ ICAT/ Boulder | Internal status Internal claim 0030 Boulder Claims report. handling Claims document; Work Product; Confidential/ Proprietary/ Trade Secret; Relevance. McDougal__0040- | Courtney Christina Email Work Product and 0042 Flowers, Holton, ITEL | correspondence | Claims File ICAT/ Laboratories; regarding Privilege. Not Boulder internal claim reasonably Claims; Courtney handling. calculated to lead Flowers, to the discovery Christina ICAT/ Boulder of admissible Holton, ITEL | Claims evidence. Laboratories McDougal__0043 Courtney John Adams, Email Work Product and Flowers, Compass correspondence | Claims File ICAT/ Adjusting regarding Privilege. Not Boulder internal claim reasonably Claims handling. calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. McDougal__0044- | Keystone Courtney Email Work Product and 0045 Experts and Flowers, correspondence | Claims File regarding Privilege. Not reasonably ZELLE LLP Sun Trust International Center, One Southeast Third Avenue, Suite 1600 Miami, Florida 33131 Telephone 786-693-2350 — Facsimile 612-336-9100 Page 2 of 6CASE NO.: 19004523CA Bates No. Author Recipient Description of | Asserted Document Privilege Engineers, ICAT/ Boulder | internal claim. calculated to lead LLC Claims handling. to the discovery of admissible evidence. McDougal__0049- | ICAT/ ICAT/ Boulder | Internal Work Product and 0050 Boulder Claims Assignment Claims File Claims Sheet. Privilege. Not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. McDougal__0066- | ICAT/ ICAT/ Boulder | Internal Status Work Product and 0069 Boulder Claims Report. Claims File Claims Privilege. Not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. McDougal__0141 Keystone ICAT/ Boulder | Billing Invoice. | Confidential/ Experts and Claims Non-privileged | Proprietary/ Engineers, portions of this Trade Secret; LLC document will be | Relevance. produced in redacted form. McDougal__0146 ITEL ICAT/ Boulder | Billing Invoice. | Confidential/ Laboratories | Claims Non-privileged | Proprietary/ portions of this | Trade Secret; document will be | Relevance. produced in redacted form. McDougal__0147- | Certain Certain Declarations Confidential/ 0148 Underwriters | Underwriters | Page of Proprietary/ at Lloyd’s, at Lloyd’s, Insurance Policy. | Trade Secret; London London Reserve Relevance. ZELLE LLP Sun Trust International Center, One Southeast Third Avenue, Suite 1600 Miami, Florida 33131 Telephone 786-693-2350 — Facsimile 612-336-9100 Page 3 of 6CASE NO.: 19004523CA Bates No. Author Recipient Description of | Asserted Document Privilege Information redacted. Non- privileged portions of this document will be produced in redacted form. McDougal__0322- | Mueller Certain Underwriting Confidential/ 0335 Reports Underwriters Report. Proprietary/ at Lloyd’s Trade Secret; London Relevance. McDougal__0336- | US Adjusting | ICAT/ Boulder | Billing Invoice. | Confidential/ 0337 Services Claims Non-privileged | Proprietary/ portions of this Trade Secret; document will be | Relevance. produced in redacted form. McDougal__0376- | Compass ICAT/ Boulder | Adjuster Loss Contfidential/ 0378 Adjusting Claims Report. Reserve | Proprietary/ Services information Trade Secret; redacted. Non- | Relevance. privileged portions of this document will be produced in redacted form. McDougal__0423 Compass ICAT/ Boulder | Billing Invoice. | Confidential/ Adjusting Claims Non-privileged | Proprietary/ Services portions of this | Trade Secret; document will be | Relevance. produced in redacted form. McDougal__0424- | Compass ICAT/ Boulder | Adjuster Loss Confidential/ 0426 Adjusting Claims Report. Reserve | Proprietary/ Services information Trade Secret; redacted. Non- | Relevance. privileged ZELLE LLP Sun Trust International Center, One Southeast Third Avenue, Suite 1600 Miami, Florida 33131 Telephone 786-693-2350 — Facsimile 612-336-9100 Page 4 of 6CASE NO.: 19004523CA Bates No. Author Recipient Description of | Asserted Document Privilege portions of this document will be produced in redacted form. McDougal__0453- | Compass ICAT/ Boulder | Adjuster Loss Confidential/ 0454 Adjusting Claims Report. Reserve | Proprietary/ Services information Trade Secret; redacted. Non- | Relevance. privileged portions of this document will be produced in redacted form. Defendant, Underwriters, reserves the right to amend this privilege log as necessary throughout the course of ongoing discovery. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this 21% day of May, 2020, that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was filed with the Court through the use of the Florida Courts eFiling Portal, and has been served upon all parties on the attached Service List via 0 First Class U.S. Mail, and/or M via the Florida Courts e-Filing Portal eService, in accordance with rule 2.516, Florida Rules of Judicial Administration. ZELLE LLP Sun Trust International Center, One Southeast Third Avenue, Suite 1600 Miami, Florida 33131 Telephone 786-693-2350 — Facsimile 612-336-9100 Page 5 of 6Insurance Litigation Group, P.A. Kimesha S. Smith, Esq. 1500 NE 162" Street Miami, Florida 33162 service@ILGPA.COM Counsel for Plaintiff Law Offices J. Patrick Floyd, Chtd. J. Patrick Floyd, Esq. 408 Long Avenue Port St. Joe, FL 32456 j-patrickfloyd@jpatrickfloyd.com Co-Counsel for Plaintiff CASE NO.: 19004523CA ZELLE LLP Counsel for Defendant SunTrust International Center One Southeast Third Avenue, Ste. 1600 Miami, Florida 33131-4332 Tel: 786-693-2350 Fax: 612-336-9100 By:4s/ Christine M. Renella CHRISTINE M. RENELLA Florida Bar. No. 65485 crenella@zelle.com STEFANY D. ESFANDIARY Florida Bar No. 126304 sesfandiary@zelle.com SERVICE LIST ZELLE LLP Sun Trust International Center, One Southeast Third Avenue, Suite 1600 Miami, Florida 33131 Telephone 786-693-2350 — Facsimile 612-336-9100 4826-7724-1782v1 Page 6 of 6