Preview
oe. A
=
Michele Ballard Miller (SBN 104198)
mbm@millerlawgroup.com CLIETS
Mary L. Guilfoyle (SBN 143308) ALAMEDA COUNTY
NO
mig@millerlawgroup.com
Gregory F. Fortescue (SBN 249133) FEB 17 2012
WO
gff@millelawgroup.com
MILLER LAW GROUP CLERK OF THE SUPERI
RIOR ORT
FP
A Professional Corporation By 2 Lecet
111 Sutter Street, Suite 700
oO
San Francisco, CA 94104
Tel. (415) 464-4300
OO
Fax (415) 464-4336
nN
Attorneys for Defendants KAISER
FOUNDATION HOSPITALS, INC.,
wa
KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN, INC.,
And RON NAVARRA
oO
lek
OC =|
lle
£
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
LHP
PNY
CORPORATION
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF ALAMEDA
CALIFORNIA
WH
Group
om
ls
Fk
er
LAW
IRANCISCO,
ee
PROFESSIONAL
ROBIN BONGON, Case No.: RG10495979
Oo
ed
MILLER
ae
oo
ASSIGNED FOR ALL PURPOSES TO
ih
DMD
SAN
Plaintiff, JUDGE John M. True, Ill
A
DEPARTMENT 512
or
ON
NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER OF
=
PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING
KAISER FOUNDATION HOSPITAL, INC.; DEFENDANTS’ PRODUCTION OF
&=&
ODO
KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN, INC.; PRIVILEGED DOCUMENTS
KAISER PERMANENTE, IJNC.; RON
CO
PF
NAVARRA; and DOES 1 THROUGH 10,
=
PO
Complaint filed: January 27, 2010
Defendants.
NY
KN
WO
PO
FR
HF
oO
PD
OD
RP
NAN
bo
oOo
Dh
NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER OF PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING DEFENDANTS’
PRODUCTION OF PRIVILEGED DOCUMENTS - Case No.: RG10495979
— PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that on January 31, 2012, the Court entered itsOrder
on Protective Order Regarding Defendants’ Production of Privileged Documents, in the
PP
above-referenced case. A true and correct copy of that Order is attached hereto as Exhibit
DW
A.
BR
oO
Dated: February 17, 2012 MILLER LAW GROUP
OO
A Professional Corporation
nN
oO
By: Co SS
oO
Gregory F. Fortescue
Attorneys for Defendants
on
KAISER FOUNDATION HOSPITAL, INC.,
KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN,
edUrmedhUum
INC., and RON NAVARRA
©
0)
CORPORATION
CALIFORNIA
GRouP
em
Law
FRANCISCO,
0)
PROFESSIONAI.
4820-8916-4558,v. 1
em
MILLER
SAN
oe
>
A
2
© ©
=
|
©
PO
NM
©
HM
>)
NH
CO
KH
PO
©) ©>
NM
SE
nm
Coo
hw
1
NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER OF PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING DEFENDANTS’
PRODUCTION OF PRIVILEGED DOCUMENTS - Case No.: RG10495979
J&n 30 4% 09:48a THE ROSA tA@rour . Qis27-9425
Andrea Rosa (SBN 122658) 2. RAIL
-—
THE ROSA LAW GROUP ALAMEDA COUNTY
5050 Laguna Blvd., Suite 112-580 ;
N
Elk Grove, CA 95758 a JAN © 1 2012
Tel: (918) 647-9425
WO
Fax: (916) 647-9425 , CLERK py THE fSUPERIOR couRr
F&F
Marylon M. Boyd (SBN 139642) “ Deputy
Law Offices of Maryion M. Boyd
om
2201 Broadway Street, Suite 315 coe
Oakland, CA 94612
DO
Tek 61 0) 663-8772
Fax: (510) 663-8781
NN
Attorneys for PlaintiffROBIN BONGON
wa
oO
Michele Ballard Miller (SBN 104198) _
10 mbm@millerlawgroup.com
Mary L. Gullfoyle (SBN 143308)-
41 miq@millerlawgroup.com
Gregory F. Fortescue (SBN 249133)
12 gu@millerawgroup,com
MILLER LAW GROUP
13||A Professional Corporation
111 Sutter Street, Suite 700
14 || San Francisco, CA 94104
-|| Tel. (44 2} 464-4300
15 ||Fax (415) 464-4336
16 || Attorneys for Defendants
FOUNDATION HOSPITALS, INC.,
17 || KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN, ING.,
48 And RON NAVARRA
49 SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
20 COUNTY OF ALAMEDA
of ROBIN BONGON, ~— - . Case No.: RG10495979
ASSIGNED FOR ALL PURPOSES TO
22 Plaintiff, JUDGE John M. True, Ill
DEPARTMENT 512
* 23 Nl¥.
24 STIPULATION REGARDING .
KAISER FOUNDATION HOSPITAL, INC.; DEFENDANTS’ PRODUCTION OF
25 || KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN, iNG.; PRIVILEGED DOCUMENTS AND
KAISER PERMANENTE, INC.; RON [PROPO OTECTIVE ORDER
26 || NAVARRA; and DOES 1 THROUGH 10,
27 Complaint filed: January 27, 2010
Defendanis. .
28 - |
STIPULATION PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING DEFENDANT KAISER'S
PRODUCTION OF PRIVILEGED DOCUMENTS
Case No,; RG10495975
Jan 30 12 09:48a THE ROSA LAW GROUP 916-647-9425 p.4
“~
“WHEREAS, Defendant KAISER FOUNDATION HOSPITALS ("Kaiser”} has
taken the position inthe course of discovery that the following two documents are protected
from disclosure by attorney-client privilege and/or attorney work product doctrine: {1) a
memorandum dated July 1, 2009 from Patia Dial, a third-party investigator, to
representatives in Kalser Permanente’s California Workers’ Compensation Department
regarding her investigation into Plaintiff's workers’ compensation claim for emotional
distress stemming from alleged sexual harassment; and (2) aCase Summary memorandum
dated July 9, 2009 by Sharon Burton, an investigator in Kaiser's EEO Investigations Unit, to
representatives inKaiser's legal department regarding Plaintiff'sintemal complaint of sexual
harassment (collectively, the "Memoranda’”);
WHEREAS, Plaintiff disputes Kaiser's claim of privilege regarding these two
documents and seeks their disclosure;
_ WHEREAS, Kaiser wishes to disclose these two documents voluntarily with
the express understanding that Its production of these documents does not waive the
attorney work-product doctrine or attorney-client privilege as to any other communication
with counsel relevant to this litigation:
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff and Kaiser, through their respective undersigned
counsel! of record, hereby stipulate and agree as follows:
1, Kaiser willproduce copies of the Memoranda within five (5) calendar
days following receipt of the entry of the Court's order deeming that such disclosure does
not waive Kaiser's rightto assert attorney work-product doctrine or attorney-client privilege
as to any other communication with counsel relevant to this litigation, including but not
Jimited to written and/or oral communications with counsel in the course of the investigations
1
STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING DEFENDANT KAISER’S
PRODUCTION OF PRIVILEGED DOCUMENTS
Case No.:34-2008-000-25804
@
Jan 30 12 09:48a THE ROSA LAW GROUP 916-647-9425 p.5
‘
conducted by Ms. Burton or Ms. Dial.
—_
WD
2. Plaintiff agrees not to argue or take the position in the course of this
W
litigationthat Kaisers disclosure of the Memoranda constituted a waiver of Kaiser’s rightto
HR
assert attorney work-product doctrine or attorney-client privilege as to any other
HW
communication with counsel relevant to this litigation.-
Oo
ON
3, This stipulation is entered into pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure
sections 2031.060 and all other applicable provisions of the Code of CivilProcedure.
oO
OC
Ok
IT1S SO STIPULATED.
+
lll
NY
Dated: May .-—— THE ROSAJLAW GROUP
DO
ie
&®
me
B ——»
os,
BW
OT
Andrea Rosa ,
_ Attorney for Plaintiff
DW
wm
ROBIN BONGON
Van. 23, 2Op2.
or
LON M, BOYD
DN
Dated: Mey 2041 - THE LAW/OFFICES OF
=|
ODO
=
By: io oe
/Marylon M. Boyd’ Na
AD
OO
Attorney for Plaintiff
ROBIN BONGON
RP
=
NM
fT
Dated: May ,2071 MILLER LAW GROUP
MH
O
A Professional Corporation
FF
PF
OA
By: C o>
WM
Gregory F. Fortescue
Oo
DY
Attorney for Defendants
KAISER FOUNDATION HOSPITALS,
Mw
ant
INC., KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH
PLAN, INC., and RON NAVARRA
mM
2
STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING DEFENDANT KAISER'S
PRODUCTION OF PRIVILEGED DOCUMENTS
Case No.:34-2008-000-25804
@ ®
_dan 30 12 09:49a THE ROSA LAW GROUP
‘
'916-647-9425 D6
PROTECTIVE ORDER
—s
|
N
ITISSO ORDERED. . ,
Wwe
WH
&
| Dated: In Ble [Le
Hon. ohn M. ridge}
a
Superior Court Judge
DW
Alameda County .
4824-3839-7193,
v.1
N
OD
o
ek
OO
+
ak
NY
WD
fF
Re
Oo
ee
DW
HS
AN
we
eo
OF
CO
DR
LK
=
HD
PR
WO
BD
fF
KN
oO
BH
®m
PR
PO
an
hm
3
STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING DEFENDANT KAISER'S
. PRODUCTION OF PRIVILEGED DOGUMENTS
Case No.: 34-2008-000-25804
Jan 30 12 09:49a THE ROSA LAW GROUP 916-647-9425 p7
a
Case name: Robin Bongon v. Kaiser Foundation Hospitals,Inc., etal.
Case No.; RG10-495969
DECLARATION OF SERVICE
(CCP, § 1013(a), 2915)
Tam a citizenof the United States and employed inSacramento County, California;[am over
the age of 18 years,and not a partyto the within action. My business address is5050 Laguna
Blvd. Suite 112-580, Elk Grove, CA 95758.
On the date below, I served the following documents:
Stipulation Regarding Defendant's Production ofPrivileged Documents and
[PROPOSED] Protective Order
at thefollowing address:
Gregory F. Fortescue Attorneys for
Defendant
10
MillerLaw Group Kaiser Foundation Hospitals, Inc.,etal.
111 Sutter Street,Suite 700
11
San Francisco, CA 94104
12
BK By United States Mail. [ enclosed the document in asealed envelope or package
- addzessed tothe person(s) atthe address listedabove and deposited such envelope with
postage thereon fullyprepaid with the United States Postal Service.
i) By
the
Personal
person(s)
Service.
listed
I caused
above.
such document tobe delivered
.
by hand to the officeof
[] By Overnight Delivery. Icaused such document to be delivered by overnight
delivery to theoffice of the person(s) listedabove.
18
O By Facsimile. I cansed such document tobe transmitted by facsimilemachine to the
officeof the person(s) listedabove.
19
[] By Email. I caused such document to be transmitted by email tothe office of the
20
person(s) listedabove.
21
J declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing istrue and correct and was executed on
22
January 26,2012 atElk Grove, California.
23 Meese
24
AliciaJackson”
25
THE ROSA LAW GROUP
Declaration of Service
Superior Court of California, County of Alameda
Hayward Hail of Justice
Case Number: RG10495979
Order of 01/31/2012
DECLARATION OF SERVICE BY MAIL
i certifythat |am not a party to thiscause and that a true and correct copy of the
foregoing document was mailed firstclass, postage prepaid, in a sealed envelope,
‘addressed as shown on the foregoing document or on the attached, and that the
mailing of the foregoing and execution ofthis certificate occurred at
24405 Amador Street, Hayward, California.
Executed on 01/31/2012.
Executive Officer / Clerk of the Superior Court
By jig Opie.
Deputy Clerk
= PROOF OF SERVICE
1,Cheryl Bower, declare that |! am employed at Miller Law Group, A Professional
NYO
Corporation, whose address is 111 Sutter Street, Suite 700, San Francisco, CA 94104; |am
WO
over the age of eighteen (18) years and am not a party to this action. On the below date, by
the method noted below, | served the following document(s):
FF
NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER OF PROTECTIVE ORDER REGARDING
DEFENDANTS’ PRODUCTION OF PRIVILEGED DOCUMENTS
oo
on the interested parties in this action by placing a true and correct copy thereof, enclosed
ODO
in a sealed envelope addressed as follows:
N
Oo
Marylon M. Boyd, Esq. Andrea Rosa, Esq.
LAW OFFICES OF MARYLON M. BOYD THE ROSA LAW GROUP
oO
2201 Broadway Street, Suite 815 5050 Laguna Bivd., Suite 112-580
Oakland, CA 94612 Elk Grove, CA 95758
OO
Tel: (510) 663-8772 Tel: (916) 647-9425
oe
Fax: (510) 663-8781 Fax: (916) 647-9425
|=
Email: fawofficeofmarylonboyd@yahoo.com Email: andrea.rosa@therosalawgroup.com
Re
DB
Attorney for Plaintiff: Robin Bongon Attorney for Plaintiff: Robin Bongon
WO
ee
XI BY OVERNIGHT DELIVERY: By placing the document(s) listed above in a sealed
HR
CORPORATION
CALIFORNIA
envelope(s) and consigning it/them to an express mail or overnight courier for
Group
Bw
guaranteed delivery on the next business day following the date of consignment to
OO
the address(es) set forth above. A copy of the consignment slip is attached to the
Law
FRANCISCO,
DO
PROFESSIONAL
me
last page of this proof of service.
MILLER
Bw
NN
BY MAIL: By placing a true copy thereof enclosed in a sealed envelope with
SAN
postage thereon fully prepaid, in the ordinary course of business for collection and
A
Bm
DH
mailing on this date at Miller Law Group, 111 Sutter Street, San Francisco, California.
| declare that | am readily familiar with the business practice of Miller Law Group for
0O©
|
collection and processing of correspondence for mailing with the United States Postal
Service and that the correspondence would be deposited with the United States
OO
PP
Postal Service that same day in the ordinary course of business.
|=
DO
| declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the
HO
foregoing is true and correct.
PD
DH
NY
Executed on February 17, 2012 at San Francisco, California.
F&F
DN
hay plLI VAN
nM
DP
oOo
HN
Cheryl Royler
PN
on
NB
PROOF OF SERVICE
Case No. RG10495979