Motion,Ex Parte: WAREHOUSE 1050 CORP VS WILLIAMS, WALTER J

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                Filing # 31994534 E-Filed 09/14/2015 09:52:22 AM

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 11"
JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND | FOR
MIAMEDADE COUNTY, FLORIDA

CASE NO.: 09-36802 CA (11)

WAREHOUSE 1050 CORP.,
J AND J REFRIGERATION
SUPPLY, INC., AND AME
MANUFACTURING CORP.,

Plaintiffs,
v.

FLORIDA SOL SYSTEMS, INC.,
COMCAST CABLE COMMUNICATIONS
HOLDINGS, INC., COMCAST CABLE
HOLDINGS, LLC, COMCAST OF
MIAMI, INC. a/k/a COMCAST OF
CALIFORNIA/ COLORADO FLORIDA/
OREGON, INC.,

 

Defendants
f
PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO STRIKE COMCAST DEFENDANTS”
MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES FOR FRAUD ON THE COURT

Plaintiffs’ request the Court strike Comcast’s Motion for Attorneys’ Fees due to fraud on
the court. Since the initial hearing on entitlement, the Comcast Defendants have produced
documents subsiantiating Plaintiffs’ position that the Offer of Judgment was not served byje-mail

and proving that Mr. Jobhnson’s statements in his certificate of service to the contrary, an anfi upon

which this Court relied in granting the Comcast Defendants’ motion with respect to entitlement,

were false and a fraud on the Court. In support, Plaintiffs sfate:
introduction

On February 13, 2015, the Comcast Defendants sérved their motion for attorneys’ fees

based on an Offer of Judgment. The Offer of Judgment cqntained a certificate of service} signedby Mr. William Johnson, Esq. that the Offer of Judgment wag served on then-counsel for Pla|

Mark L. Pomeranz, Esq. and Robert Zarco, Esq., as well as; Angela Daker “via E-Mail anc
Mail.” A copy of the Offer of Judgment is attached as Exhibit A.

In granting the Comcast Defendants’ motion for attorneys’ with respect to entitlemey

Court relied on the certificate of service executed by Mr. Jphnson as prima facie proof th

Offer of Judgment was served by e-mail.

The Offer of Judgment was properly served. The Court finds that the

affidavits presented by Plaintiffs are insuffigient to rebut the prima facie

proof of service established by the Certificate of Service of the Offer of

fudgment.

See this Court's May 13, 2015 Order at 41{g), a copy of whigh is attached as Exhibit B.

Following the Court’s order on Hability, Plaintiffs} served discovery to Comeas

August 20, 2015, the Comcast Defendants produced account} statements rendered by the la

 

Moore Ingram Johnson & Steele, LLP for its representation of the Comcast Defendants
action, including for work performed July 2, 2013, the date the offer of judgment was alleg
mailed. These documents were not available to counsel for Plaintiffs or the Court when the}
granted the Comcast Defendants’ motion for attorneys’ feesjon May 13, 2015.

Mr. Johnson only billed for one event on July 2, 2013 the date service was all

effected, ig. a “{cJall to Florida Sol attorneys regarding the discovery dispute and need t

tiffs

US.

it, this

lat the

On
y firm
this
idly e-

Court

motion to compel.” See COM-FEES -00001 1.! Copies of Mpare Ingram Johnson & Steele, LLP’s

account statements are attached as Exhibit C.

2 Pursuant to Fla. Stat. §90.803(7), the absence of entry on Moore Ingram Johnson &
LLP’s account statements for the service of the offer of judgment by e-mail is proof that thi
of judgment was never e-mailed.

ieele,
offerYet from July 2, 2013 (the date from which Account Statements were produced from

Moore Ingram Johnson & Steele, LLP) through October 24, 2013 (the last date Moore If gram

Johnson & Stecle, LLP produced Account Statements) (a period of 115 days), Mr. Johnson ehtered

at least 96 entries on the Account Statements related to th sending or receipt of e-mailg.

ee

COM-FEES-00001- 00046). Not a single one of those entries reflects that the offer of judbment

was served on Plaintiffs’ counsel by e-mail on July 2, 2013 ér anytime thereafter.

Moreover. the account statements produced by White & Case, alse reflect that no attorney

from White & Case reviewed any emails or Offers of J adgmpnt allegedly served on July 2,2013.

White & Case's account statement for the period in questionlis attached hereto as Exhibit D.

This new evidence supports Plaintiffs’ position that the Offer of Judgment was jnever

served on counsel for Plaintiffs by-email. See affidavits of Robert Zarco and Mark Pomeranz,

attached hereto as Exhibits E and F, respectively.

 

Argument

Fraud on the court occurs where “it can be demonstr: ted, clearly and convincingly, that a

party has sentiently set in motion some unconscionable scheme calculated to interfere with

the

judicial system's ability impartially to adjudicate a matter by improperly influencing the tjer of

fact or unfairly hampering the presentation of the opposing party's claim or defense.” Clox vy.

Burke, 706 So. 2d 43, 46 (Fla. 5™ DCA 1998) quoting Aoudé y. Mobil Oil Corp., 892 F.2d | 115,

1118 (ist Cir.1989). In determining whether a claim should He dismissed based on the condtct of

a party’s attorney, the trial court must consider “1) Whether the attorney's disobedience

was

willful, deliberate, or contumacious, rather than an act of negject or inexperience; 2) Whethdr the

attorney has been previously sanctioned; 3) Whether the client was personally involved in the act

of disobedience; 4) Whether the delay prejudiced the opposing party through undue expense,

 

   

lossof evidence, or in some other fashion; 5) Whether the attorney offered reasonable justificati
noncompliance; and 6) Whether the delay created significant problems of judicial administra
See Deutsche Bank Nat. Trust Co. y. Avila-Gonzalez, 164 S013 90, 93 (Fla. 3d DCA 2015

Moreover, Rule 4-3.3 of the Rules Regulating the Florida Bar prohibit a lawyer

knowingly making a false statement of fact or law to a tritumal, from failing to correct a!

in for

*

ion.

from

false

statement of material fact or law previously made to the tribunal, and from offering evidefice a

lawyer knows to be false. See R. Regulating Fla. Bar 4-3.3(ad.
in this case, the certificate of service which purportsito prove that the offer of judg
was served on counsel for Plaintiffs by e-mail is a fraud.? Mr. Johnson did not serve the off

judgment by e-mail despite his affirmative representations to the contrary, as revealed by his f

ment

jer of

rai’s

account statements and the account statements from White & Case, neither of which were available

to the Court at the May 1, 2015 hearing, See Exhibits C, D, E, and F.

 

   
  
   

If the offer of judgment was not served by e-mail, ther the offer of judgment is invali
the Comcast Defendants’ motion for attorneys” fees must be denied. See Fla. R. Civ. P. 1
Fla. R. Jud. Admin. 2.516; of Matte. V. Caplan, 140 So. 3d 6 (Fla. 4" DCA 2014).
The Comeast Defendants” continued prosecution of their motion for attorneys” fees
the knowledge that the offer of judgment was not served by e-rhail and that the certificate of se
contained in the offer of judgment is fraudulent, is in bad faith, needlessly increasing the cog

litigation, and in violation of Rule 4-3.3 of the Rules Regulatihg the Florida Bar.

 

A certificate of service is evidence. See Nesslein v. Ni
DCA 1996) (“The certificate of service is prima facie proof that service was effectuated o
date sworn to by counsel”).

¢ and

vith
ice

is of

stein, 672 So. 2d 582, 583 (Fla. 3d

theWHEREFORE, Plaintifs request the Court strike Cdmeast’s Motion for Attorneys’ Fees
due to fraud on the court, and award all other relief as the Court determines is just and proper.

LAW OFFICES OF SAMUEL COZZ0, P.A.

400 Northeast 35" Street

Miami, Plorida 33137

Tel: (305) 815-G109
©

Gees,

 

 

  

By:

SAMUEL C. COZZO7 Esq,
Fla Bar Nlo.: 0012541

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
THEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was sent via electfonic

gh

ue
mail to all counsel of record through the e-portal this Ww day of September, 2015

 

  

  

SAMUEL C. COZZO,Fsq.
Fla Bar No.: 0012541EXHIBIT A

  

Law Offices of Samuel Cozzo, P.A., 400 Northeast 36" Str t, Miami, Florida 33137
‘Tel: 305.815.0109 E-Mail: scozzo@cozzolawfirm.comIN THE CIRCUIT OF THE 11TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA

INC., COMCAST CABLE HOLDINGS,
LLC, and JOHN & JANE DOES,
4-100,

WAREHOUSE 1050 CORP., *
J AND J REFRIGERATION SUPPLY, *
INC,, and AME MANUFACTURING *
CORP., *
@
Plaintiffs, *
*

vs. * CASE NQ. 09-36802CAI1

*
WALTER J. WILLIAMS, FLORIDA *
SOL CORP, COMCAST CABLE *
COMMUNICATIONS HOLDINGS, *
*
*
*
*
*

Defendants.

 

 

OFFER OF JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO FLA. STAT. §768.79

    
 
 
   
 
 
   

COME NOW Defendants Comcast Cable Communications Holdings, Inc. and Comcast

Cable Holdings, LLC, and hereby serve upon Plaintiffs Warehouse 1056 Corp., J and #
Refrigeration Supply, Inc., and AME Manufacturing Corp., anil show that an Offer of Judgment
is being made and further show as follows:

(a) This Offer of Judgment is being made pursuant to Fis, Stat, §768.79;

(b) This Offer of Judgment is being made by Comcast Communications Holding, Inc.
Comcast Cable Holdings, LLC, all of (hereinafter Hlectively “Comeast”) and all o
its affiliates, parent corporations, subsidiaries, and rélated entities to Warehouse 105
Corp., J and J Refrigeration Supply, Inc., and AME lanufacturing Corp. (hereinafter
collectively “Plaintifis”} and all of Plaintiffs’ jaffiliates, parent corporations,

subsidiaries, representatives, agents, principals, officers, and directors;

 

EXHIBIT(c) This amount is being offered to settle all claims including any for punitive damageg;

(4) The amount of the Offer of. Judgment is $150,000100.

as

Respectfully submitted this 2 _ day of July, 2013.
MOORE INGRAM JOHNSON & STEELE, LLP

William R. Johnson/

Admitted Pro Hac Vice
Ryan G, Prescott
Florida Bar No. 0049914
Aitomeys for Defendants, Comcast

 

10151 Deerwood Park Boulevard
Building 200, Suite 256
Jacksonville, FL 32256

(904) 428-1465 (Office)

(904) 672-4236 (Facsimile)
wri@mijs.com

Page 2CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

 

This hereby certifies { have this day served a true and correct copy of the foregoing
OFFER OF JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO FLA. STAT. $768.79 via E-mail and U.S. Mail upon

the following:

Mark L.. Pomeranz, Esq. Steven J. Lachterman, Esq.

Pomeranz & Associates, PA. 2655 Ue Jeune Road, Penthouse 1-D

1926 East Hallandale Beach Blvd, Suite 802 ‘oral Gables, FL 33134
Hallandale, FL 33009
Luis Perez, Esq. Robert Zarco, Esq.
Angelica M, Torrents, Esq. Zarco; Einhorn & Salkowski, B.A.
Perez, Goran & Rodriguez, P.A. 100/SE 2nd Street, Suite 2700
93 Merrick Way, Suite 610 fiami, FL 33131-2122

Coral Gables, FL 33134

Angela D. Daker, Esq.
Jaime A. Bianchi, Esquire
White & Case LLP
200 South Biscayne Boulevard, Suite 4900
Miami, FL 33131-2352

 

   

wh
This 2 _ day of July, 2013,

 
 
   

William R. Johnson
Admitted Pro Hac Vice
Ryan G. Prescott

Florida Bar No. 0049914
Attorneys for Defendant, Comcast

10151 Deerwood Park Boulevard
Building 200, Suite 250
Jacksonville, FL 32256

(904) 428-1465 (Office)

(904) 872-4236 (Facsimile)

wi @mijs.com

Page 3EXHIBIT B

Law Offices of Samuel Cozzo, P.A., 400 Northeast 36" Streét, Miami, florida 33137
Tel: 305.815.0109 E-Mail: scozzo@cozzolawfirm.comIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
1) TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
MIAMLDADE COUNTY, FLORIDA

CASE ND. 09-36802 CA (11)
WAREHOUSE 1050 CORP,, et al.,

Plaintiffs,
v8.
PLORIDA SOL CORP., et al.,

Defendants.

ORDER ON COMCAST DEFENDANTS’ MOTION FOR ATTORNEY’S FEES
THIS CAUSE having come before the Court on Ma 1, 2015 on Comeast Defendants*
Motion for Attorney’s Fees dated February 13, 2015 (“Motion”). The Court having hebrd

atgument of counsel, having reviewed the record and bei g otherwise duly advised in fhe

 

premises, it is hereby ORDERED AND ADIUDGED as follo

 
 
 
 

1 ‘The Motion is hereby GRANTED, as to entitlément, This Ruling is based on the
following findings by the Court:

a. The Comeast Defendants’ Offer of Jud: iment, dated July 2, 2013, is valid,
enforeeable, and was made in good fait

b, The Offer of Judgment complied with Section 768.79 and Rute 1.442;

G Apportionment of the Offer of Judgment was not necessary because bil
Plaintiffs and the Comcast Defendants were treated collectivaly
throughout the pretrial proceedings and the trial by Plaintiffs;

ad Apportionment of Comeast’s Offer of Judgment was also not requirgd

because of the vicarious liability exception in Rule 1,442(c\4), which ¢

o

Court finds is applicable here;8 ‘The Offer of Judgment was not ambiguous and sufficiently identified the

parties to allow the offerees to conside the Offer of Judgment;

m

The Offer of Judgment stated ail felevant conditions with suffidient
particularity;
g The Offer of Judgment was properly| served. The Court finds that} the
affidavits presented by Plaintiffs are ihsafficient to rebut the prima facie
proof of service established by the Certificate of Service of the Offef of
Judgment. Plaintiffs’ ore tenus request for an evidentiary hearing to
resolve the factual issues related to sérvice of the Offer of Judgment is
denied.;

h Plaintiffs’ argument that the Offer of Judgment violated Plaintiffs’

 

constitutional rights is frivolous and widhout basis;

i, William Jobnson was properly and | wfully representing the Comdast

Defendants in this matter pro hac vice when the Offer of Judgment was

served; and

i The Offer of Judgment was reasonable and not nominal. The offerlof

$150,000 exceeded the jury award anil was made in 2013 based on a

sound analysis of the potential liability.

2, An evidentiary hearing will be held on September 25, 2015 at 1:00 p.m. fio
determine the nunrber of hours reasonably spent by Comeast’é counsel detending this case after
July 2, 2013; the reasonableness of counsel’s hourly rate; and {he total amount due and owing to

Comcast for its attorney’s fees and costs incurred in this action’DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers at Miami-Da:

May, 2015,

Copies furnished to:

(All counsel of record}

oN

|

 

 

4 2,
Gptlk

ie County, Florida, this L2 day

V. WARD

 

ofEXHIBIT C

Law Offices of Samuel Cozzo, P.A., 400 Northeast 36" Street, Miami, Florida 33137
Tel: 305.815.0109 E-Maif: scozzo@cozzolaivfirm.comSTATEMENT
MOORE INGRAM JOHNSON & STEELE, LLP

ATTORNEYS ATLAW
EMERSON OVERLOOK
326 ROSWELL STREET
MARIETIA, GA 30060
FEDERAL LO. NO, TELEPHONE TRECOPIER POST OFFICE 80x 3305
S$8-2153374 (970) 429-1499 #970) 427-5631 MARIETTA, GEORGIA 30087
July 15, 2013
Invedce# 346195 WRI
Libery Mutual Insurance Our fle# POR840 0001
Attm Micheile Kupronis Billing thrdugh 07/10/2013
P.O. Box 7214

London, KY 40744

Ciaim of Elan Feldman dib/a J&i Refrigeration
Claim #: P505-14307301; Legal Exchange 1D¥1620092700

 

Prior balance on invoice dated June 15,2013
Payments received since last invoice

AJR adjustments made since last invoice

Prior balance less credits

PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED

 

   

COM-FEES-000004[Liberty Mutual Comeast (Lit) FoRs40 00001

Invoice# 346155 Page 2

 

rf

 

 

COM-FEES§-000002[Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit)

"

 

F98840

90601

In

Olive! 346155

 

 

 

Page 3

 

COM-FEE

5-000003Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit) F98R46 = 00001

"

 

 

in

 

 

 

ice# 346155

Page 4

 

COM-FEE

S-000004Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lith F98840 00001

Inyoice# 346155 Page 5

 

m

 

 

COM-FEES-000005Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit)

   

FORRO 00001

In

 

 

olce# 346155

 

Page °

reer

 

COM-FEE

S-000006Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit)

 

F98340

06001

inj

 

ice 346155

 

 

Page 7

i

COM-FEE

 

5-000007Liberty Mutual Comeast (Lit) F98840

rf

   

00001

In

 

 

ice 345155

 

Page 8

COM-FEE

 

5-000008Liberly Mutual Comcast (Lit) P98840 60001

 

 

Invoice# 346155

   

 

 

Page 3

re

COM-FEE:

 

S-000009fiiberty Mutual Comcast (Lit) FO8840 00001 Injoice# 346155 Page 10

 

nM

 

 

COM-FEEB-000010Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit)

 

ries from.
07/02/2013

07/10/2013

07/10/2013

OT/1 02013

07/10/2013

07/10/2013

 

Of

WRI

Li20
AHS

L120

Liz
WRI

Liz0

Li20
WRI

L120

 

d
L126 Analysis/Strategy

Call to Florida Sol attomeys regarding the

F98840

90691

discovery dispute and the need to file a

Mation to Compel same.

A108
L120 Analysis/Strategy
.e

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Contact Court regarding our pending motion,

Al08

L120 Analysis/Sirategy

ALOE
L126 Analysis/Strategy

Prepare correspondence to Mr. Feldman's

attorney regarding discovery dispute and our
8 ry dispui

motion.

A103
L126 Analysis/Strategy

Prepare correspondence to Florida Sal's

attomey regarding discovery dispute and our

motion.
A103

 

invoice# 346155

0.26 brs

 

0.40:hrs

0.26 ihrs

0.10

8.20

6.20

HM

130.06 Ahr

150.00 /br

150.00 /hr

150.00 /hr

150.00 fbr

150.00 fbr

Page i

36.00

60.00

30.00

15.00

30.00

30.00

 

COM-FEE

§-000011Liberty Mutual Comeast (Li} F98840 = O0001 Tovoice# 346155 Page 12

07/10/2013 BUZ L110 Fact investigation/Development Fact 6.2@ brs 110.00 far 22.00
investigation regarding status of Property
Damage Appraiser's current status,

Lil A104
DISBURSEMENTS:
07/09/2013 B20 Pe i 98.00
pemit/roof investigation on 6/27/13,
Total disbursements for this matter $248.00
Fees $217.00
Disbursements $98.00
Charges From 7/2/13 through 7/19/2013 $315.00

 

 

COM-FEES-000012STATEMENT

MOORE INGRAM JOHNSON & STEELE, LLP
ATTORNEYS AT LAW

EMERSON OVERLOOK

326 ROSWELL STREET

MARIETTA. GA 30060

FEDERALL.D. NO. TELEPHONE TEECOPER POST OFFICE BOX 3305
SB-2153374 {770} 429-1497 UA) 429-863) MARIETIA, GEORGIA 30061

August 15,2013
Invdice# 348949 WRI

Libery Mutual Insurance Our file# F9R840 00001
Atin: Michelle Kapronis Billing through 08/10/2013
P.O. Box 7214

London, KY 40744

Claim of Elan Feldman d/b/a J&] Reftigeration
Claim #: P505-14307301; Legal Exchange 1041620092706

 

 

Prior balance on invoice dated July 15,2013
Payments received since last invoice

AJR adjustments made since last invoice

Prior balance Jess credits

PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED

07/11/2013 AHS L2i0 Pleadings 2.10 150.00 /hr 315.06
Extensive review of returns of service,
summons, service and summons transmittal
and docket records to develop detalied
timeline of service of process, and plaintiffs’
efforts to serve all parties,
L210 Al04
O71/2013 AHS 1120 Analysis/Strategy 0.90 Tis 150.00 far 135.06
Draft additional arguments for Motion to
Dismiss regarding failure of service as to
non-party Comcast of Miami based on service
of said party 162 days after filing of

complaint.
Li20 A10a
07/11/2013 AHS L110 Fact Investigation’ Development 1.70 150.00 /hr 255.00

Review case law related to effect of dismissal
where statute of limitations has nm and
impact same has on plaintiffs ability to bring

 

somresne 3Liberty Mutual Cameast (ip F98840 00001 htivoice# 348949 Page

we

action again pursuant to renewal statute.

LiO AlO4

O7/I2013 AHS  Lize Analysis/Strategy 0.80 brs 150.00 fr 126.0

Draft argument related to plaintiffs!
knowledge of identity of clients’ registered
agent despite plaintiff interrogatory response
to the contrary.

LI26 A103

O7/12/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.80 hrs 150.00 far 120.0
Emails back and forth with client repardi

   

    

L120
OF/II2013 WRI L126 Analysis/Strategy 9.10 hrs 150.00. /hr 15.0
Email from Marna Salimena a
L120 n
97/12/2013 AHS L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.56 hrs 150.00 far 75.00

  

 

O712/2013 AHS L120 Analysis/Strategy O.3¢ hrs 150.00 fbr 45.00
Receipt and review of lengthy correspondence
from client regarding

Li20 A104
07/12/2013 AHS L110 Fact Investigation/Development OSG hrs 150.00 fbr 75.00

Draft demiled client's questions as
|

LG A103

87/12/2013 AHS L110 Fact Investigation/Development 0.60: hrs 150.00 far 90.00
Address entity issues and clarify same for
Motion to Dismiss.
Li Alo4
07/12/2013 ANS L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.70inrs 150.00. far 105.00
Determine handling of Plaintiffs attempted
filing of Amended Complaint after service of
process and Motion to Dismiss.
L120) AIOL
07/12/2013 AHS L110 Pact investigation/Development 0.90ihrs 150.00 fhe 135.00
Review voluminous correspondence, totalling
150 pages, to determine whether Plaintiff
timely provided payment for service of
process.

Lio A104

 

COM-FEES-000014Liberty Mutual Comeast (Lit) F98840 = 60001 Invoice? 348949 Page 3

07/12/2013 AHS 1310 Written Discovery 0.40 brs 180.00 /hr 90,08
Review discovery responses to determine if
Plaintiff properly responded to request for
justification of late service issues,
L31G ALO4
0712/2013 WRI 1.120 Analysis/Strategy 6.30 brs 150.00 far 75.0
Emails back and forth to Marna Salimena and

a in Miami concerni:

L120 A106
07/2/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Sirategy 0.13 hrs 150.00 far 15.0
Email tp i pel
L120 t
07/12/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy 6.39 hrs 150.00 Abr 45.08
Work on we eo to suggestions of
L260 A103
07/12/2813 BUZ 1130 Experts/Consultants G.2@ hrs 110.00 /hr 22.00)

Telephone conversation with potential
investigator regarding whereabouts of
Feldman's appraiser.
Li3Q) A107
07/12/2013 BUZ L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.3G brs 110.00 /br 33.06
Review Feldman's discovery responses in
order to compare/contrast same with
investigation pertaining to permit research and
status of companies performing work on
subject roof.
Li20 ALO4
07/15/2013 AHS 1.140 Decument/File Management 0.70brs 150.00 /hr 105.00
Identify, redact and prepare voluminous
exhibits to Motion to Dismiss.

Li AIO

OWIS2013 AHS L110 Fact Investigation/Development O.60ihrs 150.00 fir 96.00
Review Amendment to Rule 1.070()} to
determine impact of same on pleadings.

 

Lio Aled
07/15/2013 AHS L110 Fact Investi ation/Development 0.60ihrs 150.00 fbr 90.00
LG A102
O7/15/2013 AHS L110 Fact Investigation/Development O.80thrs 150.00 fbr 126.06
Draft additional arguments regarding
Amended Complaint and procedural

insufficiencies of same.

 

COM-FEES-000015Liberly Mutual Comcast (Lit)

O7LS/2013

07/15/2013

07/16/2013

O7/1 6/2613

87/17/2013

07/17/2013

0717/2013

07/17/2013

O7F/1 8/2013

O71 8/2013

07/18/2013

 

LIiG = Al63
AHS 1246 Diepositive Motions 0.4
Draft multiple e-mails with client and
co-counsel regarding
L240 A106
WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy OL
i Florida attorney regarding

L120 ALO7
AHS L126 Analysis/Strategy 0.5

Exchange iple e-mails y m
ing

“i200 A107
WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.66

Emails to

L120 AlGS
AHS  Lil0 Fact investigation/Development 0.36

hrs

lus

hrs

hrs

 

Exchange e-mail with co-counsel re; arding

LUO AIG?

AHS 1126 Analysis/Strategy 0.46
Determine proper strategy for Ve

Li20 Al0l

WRJ 1120 Analysis/Strategy 0.60
Work on brief concerning dismissal due to
timing of service.

L120 A103

WRI 1120 Analysis/Strategy 6.30
? en . ,

Li20 ALOs

AHS 1126 Analysi: s/Strategy 9.30
Develop additional exhibits for Motion to
Dismiss.

LI26 All

AHS 1120 Analysis/Strategy 6,80
Multiple e-mails with client and co-counsel

LI20 A106

AHS 1120 Analysis/Strategy 0.50

 

 

F98840 00001 Ingoice# 348949

150.00

158,00

150.00

150.00

150.00

150.00

156.00

450.00

150.00

150.00

150.00

fae

for

jor

foe

for

Page

60.06

15.00

75.00

75.00

45.00

60,00

90.00

45.00

45.00

120.00

75.00

 

COM-FEE:

5-000016Liberty Mutual Comeast (Lid F98840 © 06001

O7/18/2013

OTM18/2013

87/18/2013

07/48/2013

07/18/2013

87/18/2013

07/18/2013

07/22/2013

07/22/2013

07/23/2013

 

Li20

L120

L126
WRI

Lize

L120

Li20
BUZ

 

Li20
BUZ

Li
AHS

L110
AHS

£120

Determine proper handling of investigation of
principals of appraiser and contactor, in light
of potential insolvency.

AIOE

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Extensive investigation of issues related to
Comcast of Miami's involvement and service
on same,

Al02

L320 Analysis/Strategy

Emaelis back and forth with Miami counsel
regarding

ALN8

L120 Analysis/Sirategy

Review revisions to Motion to Disinise,
ALOd

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Work in revisions into motion for filing.
A103

L120 Analysie/Strategy

Emails to and from Marna regarding i

L129 Analysis/Strategy
Receipt and review of email corr ndences
with Marna Salime:

  

L110 Fact Investigation/Development
Draft summary of certain tasks to be
performed pertaining to roof investigation,

AlO3

L110 Fact Investigation/Development
Review documents, totaling 85 pages, related
to substiuution of party to determine status of
same and impact on pending motions,

Alg4

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Develop strategy related to response in
support of Motion to Dismiss in li ight of issues
with substitution of parties.

ALQE

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Call to co-Defendant's attorney regarding
upcoming motion to set her client's

 

 

Invoice? 349949

0.99 brs

8.30: hrs

0.20thrs

 

6.10

0.20

1.00 Eres

9.60 Hes

0.30 hi

 

156.60

150.00

$50.00

136.08

150.00

110.06

110.00

130.00

150.00

150.00

(be

thy

fox

far

fr

Page

5

135,00)

45.00

45.00

30.00

11.00

150.00

90.00

45.00

COM-FEES

-000017Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit) 98840-00001

07/24/2013

OT/24/2013

07/24/2013

07/24/2813

O7/25/2013

OW252013

07/26/2013

07/30/2013

97/30/2013

07/31/2013

07/31/2013

 

L126
is

L360
WRI

L120

L126
WRI

Li20
BUZ

Lito
BUE

Li3e
WRI

L120

WRI

L450
WRI

L120
WRI

deposition.

ALOT

1360 On Site Inspections

Research on Florida law regarding right to
inspect property.

A102

L120 Analysis/Strategy.

Emails to and from Angela Daker in Miami
A107

L120 Analysis/Strategy

iJ

AlG3

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Prepare letter to Mark Pomeranz conseming,
inspection of building.

Al03

L110 Fact Investigation/Development

on aa to Marna 0 2

L130 Experts/Consultants

Telephone conversation with private
investigator specializing in locating defunct
business entities,

A108
£126 Analysis/Strategy

Emails back and forth io Marna Salimena

A108

L450 Trial and Hearing Attendance
Travel to Miami for hearing.

AlZ

1.120 Analysis/Strategy

Emails to and from Sherman Humphrey
regarding Special Master.

ADB

£120 Anslysis/Strategy

Emails back and forth ‘i a =
L320 106

WRI

1350 Discovery Motions
Prepare for hearing on Motion to Enforce
Depositions and Appointment of Special

 

Invoice# 348949

6.5@ brs

0.4G brs

0,36 hrs.

0.20 hrs

0.40; brs

 

0.20ihrs

0.40

6.30 jus

0.30

0.20 brs

2.40 brs

150.60

150.06

150.00

150.00

110.00

110.00

150.00

156.00

150.00

150.00

136,00

for

fbr

hr

Page

6

75.50

60.00

45.00

30.00

44.00

60.00

945.00

45.00

360.00

 

COM-FEE:!

5-000018Liberty Mutual Comeast (Lit) FOS840 = GO001

07/31/2013

08/01/2013

08/01/2013

08/01/2013

08/01/2013

08/01/2013

08/01/2013

08/01/2013

08/01/2013

08/01/2013

08/01/2013

L356

L120
AHS

Li20

Lilo
WRI

L250

L250

L250

L120

L120

Lizg

 

 

Master.

Aidt

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Review Motion to Dismiss just in case Court
wanted to hear same at August ist hearing.
Al04

£120 Analysis/Strategy

Develop strategy related to Motion to Compel
deposition testimony.

ALOL

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Develop outline of arguments for response t¢
Motion to Compe! Cohen's deposition.

AOL

L110 Fact Investigation/Development
Extensive review of case law related to filing
of Affidavits in FCC related matters ta
develop strategy for Cohen's Motion.

Aids

£250 Other Written Motions and Submissions
Travel to Court during rush hour for hearing
on Motion to Compe! Deposition Testimony
and to Appoint Special Master.

AlI2

1.230 Other Written Motions and Submissions
Wait for Court te call case and argue case
with a winning result.

AlN9

£250 Other Written Motions and Submissions
Travel to airport.

Aly2

L120 Analysis/Stratepy

Email to Sherman Humphrey regarding case,
Al08

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Call to Marna regarding Cy
AL06

L120 Analysis/Strate;

Email from Mar:

AlNG

1120 Analysis/Strategy

Determine appropriate handling after ruling of
the Court based on upcoming motions that we
are expecting from Plaintiff.

=

G.40 brs

0.4

6.5

0.8

irs

brs

hrs

 

1.2

0.5

8.1Gthrs

0.20 thrs

9.10 thrs

0.30 tars

‘cicelt 348949

150.00

450.00

150.00

150,00

150.06

150.00

150.00

150.06

150.60

150.00

150.00

fae

fhe

fe

for

fbr

Page

7

60.0

60.09

75.00)

180.00

120.00

180.00

75.00

15.00

30.00

15.00

 

COM-FEE

S-000019Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit) F98840 = 00001

98/01/2013

08/02/2013

08/04/2013

08/05/2013

08/05/2013

08/05/2013

08/06/2013

08/07/2033

08/07/2023

08/07/2013

 

Lizo
WRI

L250

L120
WRI

Lize
AHS

£120
AHS

L240
AHS

£120
AHS

L120

 

Algd

1250 Other Written Motions and Submissions
Return travel to Atlanta from Miami,

AlI2Z

L120 Analysis/Sirategy

Email from Sherman Humphrey regarding our
win on the motion and the Special Master
being appointed,

Al08

L120 Analysis/Strategy
Email to Marna Salimena repardin,

Al06

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Determine appropriate means of presenting
Motion to Dismiss to Court.

AIG]

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Work on motion to prevent any deposition of
Mr. Cohen.

AI03

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Receipt and review i

ALO4

L126 Analysis/Strategy

Continue development of argument related to
Motion to Compel Cohen's testimony.

Allg]

L240 Dispositive Motions

Exchange, i Bree

ALOT

£120 Analysis/Strategy

Develop strategy related to tial and handling
of dispositive motions.

A101

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Determine availability of Motion to Dismiss
in event Plaintiff does not provide dates for
depositions in accordance with court Order.

ALO!

 

  

Invbice# 348949

7.80; hrs

0.10thes

0.10 thes

0.40 ihrs

0.20 rs

 

0.10 prs

2.10

0.40

0.90 ¥

0.80

150.00

156.00

150.068

150.06

150.00

150.00

450.60

150.00

130.00

150.00

Age

Page

1,170.06

15.00

15,00

60.00

30.06

15.06

315.00

60.00

135,00

120.00

 

COM-FEES

 

200020Liberty Mutual Comcast (Li F98840 = 00001 Hivoice# 348949 Page 9

08/07/2013 WRI LI20 Analysis/Strategy O40 brs 150.00 /ar 15.00
Email to adjuster to obtain information

    

L120
08/07/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Steategy 140 brs 150.00 fir 150.0}
Begin trial prep including listing potential
witnesses and coming up with issues which
had to be proven in our case.
L120 AIO}
08/07/2013 RGP 1210 Pleadings 0.20 brs 125.00 far 25.08
Prepare Interrogatories to J&J.
L210 A103
08/07/2013 RGP L210 Pleadings 0.20 brs 125.06 Ar 25.0
Prepare interrogatories to AME
Manufacturing.
L210 A103
08/07/2013 RGP L210 Pleadings 0.28 frs 125.00 far 25.065
Prepare Request for Documents to JJ.
L210 A103
08/07/2013 RGP L210 Pleadings 0.20 rs 125.00 fhe 25.00)
Prepare Request for Documents to AME
Manufacturing.
L210 A103
08/08/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy O.1@ brs 180.00 fhe 15.00)
Call from attorney for Florida Sol regarding
the motion that we had heard and the Order
resulting fom sarne,
L120 A107
08/08/2013 BUZ 1.140 Document/File Management O30 hrs 110.00 Ahr 33.00
Conducted review of file in order to aid in
preparation of discovery requests to J&J and
AME,
LI40 A104
08/09/2013 AHS  Lil0 Fact Investigation/Development 2.20%hrs 150.00 /hr 330.00
Review discovery statute and interpreting case
law to develop legal basis for Motion to
Dismiss on grounds of Plaintiff's failure to
comply with Court's Order.
LUO A104
08/09/2013 AHS Li20 Analysis/Strategy 0.50 hrs 150.00 far 75.00
Exchange correspondence with Court and
c0-counsel regarding special setting of Motion
to Dismiss for failure of service of ‘process.

LI2G A108

 

COM-FEES-000021Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit) FOB840 —- GAOOL Inpoicet 348949 Page 19
08/09/2013 AHS L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.30 hrs 150.00 hr 45.0)
Li20 A106
08/09/2013 WRI Liza Analysis/Strategy 6.4 hrs 150.00 /hr 60.01
Work on Motion to Dismiss for failure to
respond to discovery.
LI2G Al03
08/09/2013 WRI L126 Analysis/Strategy 0.26 hrs 150.00 far 30.00)
L120 A106
Smith, Angela H. 27.76 brs 150.00 fr $4,155.00)
Wehunt, Marshall 1.76 bre 110.00 vn $187.00)
Skelton, Jack 8.5@ brs 150.00 fbr $75.00)
Prescott, Ryan G. O80 brs 125.00 she $160.00)
Jobson, William 29.00; bre 150.00 Air $4,335.00
Total fees for this matter 59.78 hs $8,852.00
BILLING SUMMARY
Smith, Angela H. 27.74 hes 150.00 far $4,155.00
Wehunt, Marshall 1.7@ bre 110.00 far $187.00
Skelton, Jack 0.5q brs 150.00 far $75.00
Prescott, Ryan G. 0.8¢ brs 125.00 fbr $100.00
Johnson, William 29.0@ hrs 150.00 /hr $4,335.00
Total Fees 59.76 hrs $8,852.00
Total Current Charges $8,852.00
Balance Due $8,852.80

 

romeespanuen2STATEMENT

MOORE INGRAM JOHNSON & STEELE, LLP
ATTORNEYS ATLAW

EMERSON OVERLOOK

326 ROSWELL STREET
MARIETIA, GA 30060

FEGERAL iD. NO. TELEPHONE TELECOPIER POST OFFICE BOX 3305)
5B-2153374 {P70} 429-4499 (770) 429-863) MARIETTA, GEORGIA 30054

September 15, 2613
Invoice# 350438 WRI

Libery Mutual Insurance : Our file# Foggan 00001
Attn: Michelle Kupronis Billing tHrough 09/10/2013
P.O. Box 7214

London, KY 40744

Claim of Elan Feldman d/b/a J&J Refrigeration
Claim #: PS05-14307301; Legal Exchange 1D#1620092700

 

Prior balance on invoice dated August 15, 2013 $8,852.00

Prior balance jess credits $8,852.00
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED

08/12/2013 AHS 1120 Analysis/Strategy 0.69 hrs 150.00 /br 90.00

Exchange multiple e-mails between
ca-counsel and court regarding proper
presentation of multiple Motions to Dismiss
in light of Florida Sols recent agreeance to

depositions.
LI20 ALO?
08/12/2013 ABS L240 Dispositive Motions 1.46 hrs 150.00 far 210.00

Draft portion of Brief in Opposition to Motion
to Compel David Cohen's deposition
regarding Plaintiff's prior attempt to
inipraperly depose Mr. Cohen.
L240 AIO3
08/12/2013 AHS L240 Dispositive Motions L3G hrs 150.00 far 195.00
Draft factual analysis of filing of Opposition
with FCC for use in opposition to Motion to
Compel Deposition of David Cohen.
L240 A103
08/12/2013 AHS 1240 Dispositive Motions 1.60:hrs 150.00 far 246,00
Draft legal argument related to Declarations

 

COM-FEES-000023Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit) F98840 — GO001 invoiced

08/12/2013

08/12/2013

8/12/2013

08/13/2013

08/13/2013

08/13/2013

08/13/2013

08/14/2013

08/14/2013

 

 

as they are associated with FCC oppositions
for use in response te Mation to Compe!
Deposition of David Cohen.

L240 AIG3

AHS — 1240 Dispositive Motions 80 hrs
Develop factual statement for Motion to
Dismiss on basis of failure te comply with

Court Order.
L240 AIO
WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy 620 brs

Emails to and from Miami att

 
  

 

 

Li20 ALO?

WRI L120 Analysis/Sirategy G40 hrs
Calls from Florida Sol attorney regarding
discovery dispute and corporate
representative.

Li20 A107

AHS L120 Analysis/Strategy 680 hrs
Develop analysis of discovery abuses for use
in Motion for Sanctions.

L120 Aiol

AHS 1120 Analysis/Strategy 0:
Determine exhibits necessary to support
Motion for Sanctions.

LiZ0 A101

WRI 120 Analysis/Strategy 0.40 hrs
Email to Marna Salimena ‘iin a
L320 AI06

WRI L120 Analysis/Swaiegy 1.80 hes
Begin working on Brief in support of Motion
to Dismiss for failure to provide depasition

 

  

dates.

Li20 AIO3

AHS 1120 Analysis/Strategy 0.70 brs
Develop strate i

 
      

LI26 AIOL
AHS L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.

Exchange multiple e-mails with co-counsel

brs

 

350438

150.00

150.00

150.00

150.00

150.06

150.00

150.00

156.06

150.00

for

for

for

far

for

Page 2

126.00

36.$0

60.00

135.40

75.00

15.00

270.0p

105.0

90.0

 

COM-FES

3-000024Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit} F98840 = 00001

O8f14/2613

08/14/2013

OB/15/2013

08/15/2013

08/16/2013

08/16/2013

08/16/2013

8/16/2013

O8/162013

O8/16/2013

8/16/2013

 

Liza
WRI

L120
WRI

Lie
ANS

1.240
AHS

1240

AHS

L240
AHS

L240
AHS

LHe
AHS

L120
AHS

 

ALOT

£120 Analysis/Suategy

Call from Florida Sol's attorney regarding
their corporate representative that they had
designated.

ALO?

1120 Analysis/Strategy

Prepare status report to Marna Salimena

ALO3

L230 Court Mandated Conferences
Exchange, Inle e-mails wi i
regardin

AQ?

L110 Fact Investigation/Development
Review case law for use in Motion to Dismiss
as a sanction.

A104

£240 Dispositive Motions

Draft procedural history for Brief in Support
of Motion to Dismiss.

A103

L240 Dispositive Motions

Drall factual history for Brief in Support of
Motion to Dismiss.

A103

L240 Dispositive Motions

Draft Standard for Mution to Dismiss.

Ai03

L240 Dispasitive Motions

Draft Conclusion for Motion to Dismiss.
A103

L110 Fact Investigation/Development
Analyze Kozel factors for Motion to Dismiss
including all interpreting case law.

Al04

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Conduct HAM analysis for purposes of
Motion to Dismiss for failure to comply with
Court Order on discovery.

Alda

L110 Fact Investigation/Develapment
Determine facts needed for use in Affidavit in
Support of Motion to Dismiss.

 

 

Tgvoice# 350438

0.20 hrs

0.20 hrs

0.20 hrs

0.89 hes

1.38 hrs

 

9.48 brs

0.36 his

0,76 hrs

0.80) hrs

150.60

150.60

150.00

150.00

150.00

130.00

150.00

156.00

150.09

150.00

150.00

fae

for

for

for

for

fer

Page 3

36.04

30.06

78:

120.01

195.00

90.80)

66,00

45.00

435.00

105.00

120.06

 

COM-FEES

000025Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit) F98840 00001 myoice# 350438 Page 4

 

LilQ) AlO2
08/16/2013 WRI 1.120 Analysis/Strategy 70 hrs 150.00 for 105.90
Wark on Motion to Dismiss.
L120 A193
O8/t6/2013 WRI Li20 Analysis/Strategy O10 brs 150.00 far 15.06
L120 ALOT
98/16/2013. WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy O40 hrs 150.00 fy 60.40
L206 A
08/16/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.30 hrs 150.00 /ar 45.00
Work on the response brief on the Cohen
motion.
L120 AI03
08/16/2013 WRI Liz0 Analysis/Strategy 0.20 bes 150.00 fir 30.00
Call to Florida Sol's attorney regarding their
corporsie representative that they had
designated.
L200 Alo?
08/16/2013 ISF — Li10 Fact investigation/Development 9.40 ls 125.00 Ahr 62.51
i I i

    

LI

08/17/2013 AHS L110 Fact Investigation/Development 140 hrs 156.00 /hr 210.01
vi :

LIIO Al04
O8/tH2013 AHS 1110 Fact Investigation/Development 0.99 hrs 150.00 Ahr 135.06
Draft Affidavit of William R, Johnson in
support of Motion to Dismiss.
LUO A103
08/17/2013 WRI Lido Analysis/Strategy 0.26 brs 150.00 Ahr 30.06}
Work on Affidavit in Support of Motion to
Disiniss.
Li2ze | A103
08/17/2013 WRI Li2d Analysis/Stratepy 0.2) hrs 150.00 fhe 30.06)
Research regarding the causal standard as to
dismissal and use for the brief and later for
use in the argument:

 

COM-FEES-000026Tiberry Muntal Comeast (Lit) F98840 © -G0001 invoice
Li20 A102
08/19/2013 AHS 1250 Other Written Motions and Submissions 90 hrs
Prepare and redact exhibits for Motion to
Dismiss.
£250 ANGI
08/19/2013 AHS L250 Other Written Motions and Submissions 4.40 hrs
Finalize Motion to Dismiss.
L250 A103
08/19/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Stratezy 50 hrs
Final changes on various motions te be
presented te the Court to try to get case
dismissed,
Li20 AIG3
98/492013 WRI L120 Analysis/Stratepy 0:20 hrs
Cali from Mr. Lachterman (Florida Sul's first
atiorney) regarding my motion.
Li20 A107
08202013 WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy 026 hrs
Emails back and forth to Miami atomey
regardin;
LI2G ALOT
08/21/2013 WRI Liz Analysis/Strategy 6.50 hrs
Numerous emails back and forth with
Sherman Humphrey in Judge Farina's office
regarding problems with discovery and their
involvement as Special Master.
L120 Al0g
08/21/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Stategy 0.30 brs
Work on an addition to the Cohen Brief to be
filed with the Plaintiffs file their motion.
L120 A103
08/23/2013 WRI Liz0 Analysis/Strategy 8.40 hrs
Emails back and forth to Marna Salimena and
Li2D A106
08/23/2013 WRI Lizo Analysis/Swategy O.EQ brs
Email from Pomeranz regarding his inability
to attend the Florida Sol deposition due to
teligious reasons,
Li20) Alo?
08/27/2013 WRI Lize Analysis/Strategy 0.30 hires

Li20

 

Emails to and from Mr. Pomeranz’ office
regarding dispute as t deposition and failure
to provide dates.

ALO?

 

350438

150.00

150.00

156.00

150.00

150.00

156.06

159.00

150.00

150.00

130.00

Ae

fe

far

fr

far

Page 3

13500

69.00

46.90

30:

75.00

45,0D

60.0

 

COM-FEE

S-000027Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit) F98840 00001 Kavoice# 350438 Page 6
08/27/2013 WRJ L120 Analysis/Strategy 020 brs 150.00 far 30.00
eg Oe
Lt20 A103
08/27/2013 WRI 1.120 Analysis/Strategy 0.40 brs 150.00 /hr 15.00
Email to Angela Daker (Miami co-counsel)
regarding
Li20 A107
08/27/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.20 hrs 150.00 fbr 39.0
Emails to and trom Florida Sol’s attorney
regarding dispute by Pomeranz’ office and
handling of same.
L126 A107
OB/28/2013 TLS L120 Analysie/Strategy 6.80 hrs 150.00 /ar 90.09
Receipt and review of new file materials,
Li26 Ald
08/28/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Strtegy 6.20 brs 150.00 Abr 30.08
Prepare correspondence to Plaintiff's attorney
regarding the discovery dispute and the
depasition dispute.
LI20 A103
08/28/2013 WRI L126 Analysis/Strategy OD brs 150.00 /ar 15.0
Receipt and review of email from Plaintiffs
attorney regarding the deposition dispute.
L120) Al
08/28/2013 WRI 1.120 Analysis/Strategy GAD brs 150.00 /hr 19.0
email to Marna Salimena —
Li20 A106
08/28/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy O19 hrs 150.00 far 15.00
Email from counsel for Florida Sol regarding
discovery dispute.
Li20 Ai07
08/28/2013 WRI 1.120 Analysis/Strategy 0.26 hrs 150.00 sir 36.00)
Emails to and from Mama Salimena —
L120 A106
08/29/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.40 hrs 150.00 /hr 60.00)
Emails to and from Plaintiff's attomey
regarding the dispute concerning Florida Sol's
deposition,
Li20 ALN?
08/29/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Stratezy O.1G brs 150.00 hr 15.00
COM-FEE$-000028Liberty Mutual Comoast (Lit) Foasde = 00001 Tavoice# 358438

08/30/2013

08/30/2013

98/20/2013

08/30/2013

09/03/2013

09/03/2013

09/03/2013

09/03/2013

99/03/2013

09/04/2013

 

Lg
AHS

L120
WRI

Li20
WRI

L126

1126
WRI

L120
WRI

£120

L310
WRI

L126

L120

 

Ennail to Florida Sol regarding the dispute as
to their deposition and future handling.

AlG7 .

L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.30 hrs
Develop strategy as to Case Manepement
Order.

Alot :

1120 Analysis/Strategy * 0.40 hrs

7 io and from Angela Daker regarding

A107
L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.40 hrs
Email to Florida Sol regarding discovery
dispute.

AO?

L120 Analysis/Strategy 6.20 hrs
Prepare | Marna Salirnena
regardin:

A103

L120 Analysia/Strategy 0.49 hes.
Calis to Florida Sel regarding discovery
dispute and trying to work out same to
arrange for corporate representative
deposition,

ALO?

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Emaits to and from Florida Sol's attorney
regarding discovery dispute,

AIG?

LUO Written Discovery

Prepare Amended Notice of Depwsition
seiting deposition of corporate representative
of Florida Sol.

Al03

L120 Analysis/Sirategy

 

hrs

 

 

AL06

L120 Analysis/Strategy 1G brs
Receipt and review of email from Angela
Daker regardins

Al0g
L120 Analysis/Strategy

   

 

150.00

150.00

350.00

150.00

150.00

150.00

150.00

130.00

130.00

fhe

fe

for

for

fir

Page 7

45.00

60.0)

15.0

30,09

60.01

60.09

15.00)

15.00)

13.00

30.00

 

COM-FEES-000029Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit) P9884 G000! Invoice# 350438 = Page &g
Emails to and from Marna Salimena regardi
Li20 ALO6
09/05/2013 WRI 1.120 Analysis/Strategy 6.90 brs 150.00 far 45.0
Emails to and from Florida Sol's attorney
regarding their corporate representative and
the issues to which he should testify.
LI20. A107
09/06/2013 WRI Liza Analysis/Strategy 8.30 hrs 150.00 Abr 45.01
L126 A108
09/09/2013 WRJ L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.20 brs 150.00 hr 30.01
Call to Florida Sol's attomey regarding their
former representati ve.
LI2G AIO?
O909/2013 WRI 1120 Analysis/Strategy 04D brs 150.06 far 15.09
Email from Marna Salimena regarding me
L120 ALD6
09/10/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.18 brs 150.00 far 15.60}
‘Receipt and review of email sonceming
appearance of new altomey in case.
L120) ANH
Smith, Angela H. 20.6@ hrs 150.00 Ahr $3,090.00)
Skelion, Jack 0.6@ hrs 150.00 /hr $90.00)
Putrell, Jonathan O.5G hrs 125,00 Air $62.50)
Johnson, William W226 hrs 150.00 /br $1,830.00
Total fees for this matter 33.99 hrs $5,072.50
DISBURSEMENTS
08/15/2013 E10 Out-of-town Travel 94.55
Travel Expense for rentai car paid te William R. Johnéon while in
Miami on 8/1/13.
08/16/2013 EG Out-of-town Travel 327.30
Travel Expense for flight to Miami paid to William RJ Johnson on
FALA3,
08/16/2013 £110 Out-oFtown Travel 35.00
Paid to William R, Johnson for Aladdin Travel Service on 7/11/13,
09/03/2013 E110 Out of Town Travel 44,38

Paid to William R, Johnson for travel expense on 7/31/2013 for

   

 

COM-FEE:

B-000030Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lid) F98840 06001 mvoice# 350438 Page 9

Casa Larios, Miami F.,
G9/03/2013 E10 Out of Town Travel

 

 

17 BS
‘Travel Expense for PNF Allanta, Parking cost on 8/1/13 Paid to
William R. Johnson.
09/0/2013 £110 Out of Town Travel 35.0
Travel Expense for Meal, Bongo's Cafe, while in Miami Florida
paid to William R. Johnson. [
Total disbursements for this matter $551.08
BILLING SUMMARY
Smith, Angela H, 24.60 brs 150.00 Ahr 33,096.00
Skelton, Jack 60 hrs 150.00 far 390.0
Futrell, Jonathan 50 hrs 125.00 /ar $62.90
Johnson, William 1226 fxs 150.00 far $1,830. 0
Total Fees 33,96 hrs $5,072.5|
Total Disbursements $551.08
‘Total Current Charges 33,623.35
Prior Balance Less Credits $8,852.40
Balance Due 31447538

 

 

COM-FEE$-000031STATEMENT

MOORE INGRAM JOHNSON & STEELE, LIP
ATTORNEYS AT LAW

EMERSON OVERLOOK

326 ROSWELL STREET

MARIETTA, GA 30060

FEDERAL ILD. NO. TELEPHONE TERECOPIER POST OFFKCE BOK 4365]
582153376 (77) 429-1499 4278) 429-663! MARIETIA, GEGRGIA 30061

October 15,2013

invoice 353132 WRI

Libery Mutual Insurance Our fle# F9S840 00001
Atm: Michelle Kupronis Billing trough 10/10/2013
P.O. Box 7214

London, KY 40744

Claim of Blan Feldman d/wva J&] Refrigeration
Claim # P505-14307301; Legal Exchange 1D#1620092700

 

Prior balance on invoice dated September 15, 2013 $14,475.58
Payments received since last invoice 8,852.00
Prior balance less credits $5,623.58
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED
09/12/2013 WRI L110 Fact Investigation/Development €.1@ hrs 150.00 /hr 15.00)
Call from new attorney,
LNG Al07
09/2/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy O.1G hrs 150.00 Mr 15.00
Email i new attorney regarding
L2G) AN?
09/12/2013 WRI LI10 Bact Jnvestigation‘Developm: O.30brs 156.00 far 45.00
wei research on
LO A102
O9/62013 WRI Liz0 Analysis/Sirategy O.10ihrs 150.00 far 13.00

Receipt and review of Order from Court
regarding upcoming hearing (3 pages).
L120 Ald4

G9/16/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy 8.20 ibrs 150.00 Ahr 30.00
re status re i i

COM-FEES-00003209/46/2013

Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit) F98840 06007 nvoice#
L320 A103
WRI £120 Analysis/Strategy G10 hrs
Email to = counsel for Comcast as
Liz
WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy O11 brs

09/16/2013

O9/1 71/2013

09/18/2013

O9/18/2013

09/18/2013

09/18/2013

09/18/2013

09719/2013

 

Email to Jeff Shapiro (local contact} regarding
information he may have as to new attorney
entering case.

L120 ALO8

WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy 9220 bre

Emails to and from Marne regarding (Co

L120 AIQ6
WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy 020 hrs

Emails to » from a Salimena regarding

L120 A186
WRI L120 AnalysisStrategy 0.30 hrs

Emails to and from focal ae me

LI20) A107
WRI L126 Analysis/Strategy 0.20 hes

Emails tog i ney)
regardin;

L120 A108

 

 

L320
RGP L110 Fact Investigation/Development 2.40 hrs
Review Master Construction agreement,
Florida Sol documents, work order,
correspondences involving Florida Sol and
pertinent discovery pleadings for use in
preparing for Florida Sol deposition (approx.
200 pages).
LM0 A104
AHS L250 Other Written Motions and Submissions 0.90 hrs
Draft Supplemental Brief in Support of
Motion to Dismiss regarding Plaintiffs' recent
attempt to provide deposition dates,

L250 A103

     

333132

150.00

130.00

156.00

150.00

150,00

136.00

156.00

125.00

150.00

fhe

oar

oy

thr

for

Page 2

13.p0

15.90

36.90

30.

45.5

30.00

300.0

135.06

 

COM-FEES-000033Liberty Mutual Comcast (Lit) F98840 00001 lgveice# 353132 Page 3

OS/19/2013 WRI Li2z0 Analysis/Strategy 0.80 brs 156.00 fhr 45.00
Work on Supplemental Brief to Dismiss.
L120 A103
0915/2013 WRI Liz Analysis/Strategy € 026 bys 15000 Ar 30,

Emails from local contact regarding new
allomey in case,
L120 Atos

09/20/2613 WRI Li20 Analysis/Strategy 0.10 hrs 150.00 fbr 15.0
Receipt and review of email from local
attorney regarding new eo-counsel for

Plaintiff,
LI20 AlGd
09/20/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Stratepy 0.20 hrs 150.00 fbr 30.0
Emails to and from oe 7 =
L1Z0) ALOT
09/20/2013 WRI Liz0 Analysis/Strategy 6.40 brs 150.00 fbr 60.00

Emails to and from Plaintiff's new attorney
regarding upcoming motions.
Li26; A107
09/20/2013 RGP 1330 Depositions 1.2) hrs 125.00 fhr 156.00)
Review S Valido deposition and index of D
Beaman deposition for prior testimony on
Similar topics for use in preparing for Florida
Sol corporate deposition (70 pages).
£330 Al04
09/20/2013 RGP L330 Depositions 0.6G hrs 125.00 /hr 75.00
Prepare exhibits, including redacting
+ Subscriber information en documents being
“used to show Florida Sol's employment of
tech 628 Rodriquez for use at Florida Sol

 

deposition.
L330 AIO}
09/20/2013 RGP 1330 Depositions 1L.7:hrs 125.00 far 212,50

Prepare questions for FL Sol deposition
regarding corp. representative, construction
agreement, indemnification, work order, tech
§28, employment records, invoicing,
installation records, cancellation, and daily

converter logs.
L336 AlOl
09/21/2013 WRI L120 Analysis/Strategy 0.20 thrs 150.00 far 30.60

 

COM-FEES-000034Liberty Mutual Comcast (Li) FOR840 00001

09/21/2013

99/23/2013

09/23/2013

05/23/2013

09/23/2013

09/23/2013

09/23/2013

99/23/2033

09/23/2013

89/23/2013

09/29/2013

 

Li26
WRI

Li20
AHS

L250
AHS

LUO
AHS

L120
WRI

L120
WRI

Liz0

L250

Lig
WRI

Li20
WRI

Li2o

AlO?

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Email to Plaintiff's attorney regarding
disputing his version of the facts as it related
to depositions being offered by Mr, Feldman,
ALO?

L250 Other Written Motions and Submisstons
Finalize Supplemental Reply to Motion to
Dismiss.

AO

L110 Fact Investigation/Development
Develop time line of issues for use in lengthy
correspondence to opposizig counsel,

AlO2

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Draft lengthy correspondence to opposing
counsel regarding handling of Motion to
Dismiss.

ALOD

L120 Analysis/Strategy

Receipt and review of Order from co-counsel
for Plaintiff regardi