Preview
Louis A Gonzalez, Jr., State Bar No. 157373
lgonzalez@weintraub.com
2 Kavan J. Jeppson, State Bar No. 327547
kjeppson@weintraub.com
3 weintraub tobin chediak coleman grodin 12/23/2021
LAW CORPORATION
4 400 Capitol Mall, 11th Floor
Sacramento, California 95814
5 Telephone: (916} 558-6000
Facsimile: (916} 446- 1611
6
Attorneys for Defendant Brian Howe
7
8 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
9 IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF BUTTE
C:
10
=s0
I,,.,
C) 11 13290 CONTRACTORS LANE, LLC, a Case No. 21 UD02707
C:
r.!
California limited liability company,
E
ci>
12 DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF AUTOMATIC
0 Plaintiff, STAY OF UNLAWFUL DETAINER ACTION
0
~
r.!
13 PENDING APPEAL OF RELATED CASE
=sci> vs.
.c:
0
14 [CCP § 916(0)]
C BRIAN HOWE, an individual,
:a0C: 15
- o
.a :.::. Defendant. Date: December 3, 2021
_
::,~
16
,~ ...oC. Time: 1:30 p.m.
CV
...
C
·-
o
0 Dept: VLG
17 Commissioner Virginia L. Gingery
18
19
20 TO ALL PARTIES, THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD, AND THE ABOVE CAPTIONED
21 HONORABLE COURT:
22 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that, because ERIK BENIK, WISHBONE RANCH, LLC, and JAMES
23 HEATH ("Plaintiffs") fileda timely notice of appeal on December 23, 2021, in the related matter
24 Erik Benik et al. v. Richard Bringgold et al, Butte County Superior Case No. l 8CV03508,
25 challenging the statement of decision that concluded litigation and dissolved a preliminary
26 injunction regarding the subject property located at 13290 Contractors Drive, Chico, California
27 95973, entered by the Butte County Superior Court earlier on December 3, 2021 .
28 Ill
{3329613.DOCX:}
Defendant's Notice of Automatic Stay of Unlawful Detainer Action Pending Appeal of Related Case
That appeal, as specified in the notice thereof, challenges the statement of decision
2 {including the injunctive relief) on the claims Plaintiffs asserted against Defendants Richard
3 Bringgold and 13290 Contractors Lane LLC, and necessarily involves and affects the subject
4 property that isat issue in this instant unlawful detainer proceeding. See Cal. Code Civ. Proc.,
11
5 § 916, subd. (a) [mandating an automatic stay pending appeal upon the matters embraced
6 therein or affected thereby, including enforcement of the judgment or order11 ];Byington v.
7 Superior Court (1939) 14 Cal.2d 68, 70 [92 P.2d 896] (holding that a notice of appeal
8 automatically stays a mandatory injunction]; Brydon v. Hermosa Beach (1928) 93 Cal. App.
9 615, 620 [270 P.2d 255] (holding that "all orders granting or refusing injunctions, whether
C: 10 temporary or permanent or provisional pending appeal, shall be appealable"). As such, this
=o0
~
C) l l instant action must be automatically stayed pending appeal.
C:
n)
E 12
Cl>
0
0
~ 13 Respectfully submitted,
-~
"O
Cl>
.r:
0
14 Dated: December 23, 2021 WEINTRAUB TOBIN CHEDIAK COLEMAN GRODIN
C
:s0 Law Corporation
C: 15
- o
.0 .:
·-- .
E
::::s
n)
...
0
0. 16
C o
;1 (,)
17 By: _--=::--=----------=---:--;,-:::.-r----------------
Louis A Gonza ~ z, Jr., SBN 157373
18 Attorneys for Defendant
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
{3329613 .DOCX:} 2
Defendant's Notice of Automatic Stay of Unlawful Detainer Action Pending Appeal of Related Case
1 PROOF OF SERVICE
2 I am a citizen of the United States, employed in the City and County of Sacramento, California.
My business address is 400 Capitol Mall, 11th Floor, Sacramento, California 95814. I am over
3 the age of 18 years and not a party to, nor interested in, the within action. On this date, I caused
to be served the following:
4
5 DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF AUTOMATIC STAY OF UNLAWFUL DETAINER ACTION
PENDING APPEAL OF RELATED CASE
6
7
United States mail by placing such envelope(s) with postage thereon fully prepaid in
8 the designated area for outgoing mail in accordance with this office's practice
whereby the mail is deposited in a United States mailbox after the close of the day's
9 business.
C: 10 By personally delivering, or causing to be delivered, a true copy thereof to the persons
:s0 at the addresses set forth below.
...
C) 11
C:
(ti Via overnight courier
E
Q)
12
0(.) X Via ELECTRONIC DELIVERY: By transmitting electronically the listed document(s) to the
.::t.
(ti
13 email addresse(s) below on this date before 5:00 p.m .
:s
Q)
.r:.
(.)
14
C:
:a0 15
-o
C:
Gregory M. Finch
.c;
-C:
·-
~
::::s
cu
...
0
a.
...
0
u
16 Signature
3400
Law Group,
Bradshaw Road,
LLP
Suite A-4A
11 17 Sacramento, CA 95827-2614
Email: gfinch @signaturelawgrou p.com
18
19 Attorney for Plaintiff 13290 Contractors Lane,
LLC
20
21
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
22
Executed 23 December 2021, at Sacramento, C lifornia.
23
24
25
26
27
28
{3329613.DOCX:} 3
Defendant's Notice of Automatic Stay of Unlawful Detainer Action Pending Appeal of Related Case
Preview
Louis A Gonzalez, Jr., State Bar No. 157373 lgonzalez@weintraub.com 2 Kavan J. Jeppson, State Bar No. 327547 kjeppson@weintraub.com 3 weintraub tobin chediak coleman grodin 12/23/2021 LAW CORPORATION 4 400 Capitol Mall, 11th Floor Sacramento, California 95814 5 Telephone: (916} 558-6000 Facsimile: (916} 446- 1611 6 Attorneys for Defendant Brian Howe 7 8 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 9 IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF BUTTE C: 10 =s0 I,,., C) 11 13290 CONTRACTORS LANE, LLC, a Case No. 21 UD02707 C: r.! California limited liability company, E ci> 12 DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF AUTOMATIC 0 Plaintiff, STAY OF UNLAWFUL DETAINER ACTION 0 ~ r.! 13 PENDING APPEAL OF RELATED CASE =sci> vs. .c: 0 14 [CCP § 916(0)] C BRIAN HOWE, an individual, :a0C: 15 - o .a :.::. Defendant. Date: December 3, 2021 _ ::,~ 16 ,~ ...oC. Time: 1:30 p.m. CV ... C ·- o 0 Dept: VLG 17 Commissioner Virginia L. Gingery 18 19 20 TO ALL PARTIES, THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD, AND THE ABOVE CAPTIONED 21 HONORABLE COURT: 22 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that, because ERIK BENIK, WISHBONE RANCH, LLC, and JAMES 23 HEATH ("Plaintiffs") fileda timely notice of appeal on December 23, 2021, in the related matter 24 Erik Benik et al. v. Richard Bringgold et al, Butte County Superior Case No. l 8CV03508, 25 challenging the statement of decision that concluded litigation and dissolved a preliminary 26 injunction regarding the subject property located at 13290 Contractors Drive, Chico, California 27 95973, entered by the Butte County Superior Court earlier on December 3, 2021 . 28 Ill {3329613.DOCX:} Defendant's Notice of Automatic Stay of Unlawful Detainer Action Pending Appeal of Related Case That appeal, as specified in the notice thereof, challenges the statement of decision 2 {including the injunctive relief) on the claims Plaintiffs asserted against Defendants Richard 3 Bringgold and 13290 Contractors Lane LLC, and necessarily involves and affects the subject 4 property that isat issue in this instant unlawful detainer proceeding. See Cal. Code Civ. Proc., 11 5 § 916, subd. (a) [mandating an automatic stay pending appeal upon the matters embraced 6 therein or affected thereby, including enforcement of the judgment or order11 ];Byington v. 7 Superior Court (1939) 14 Cal.2d 68, 70 [92 P.2d 896] (holding that a notice of appeal 8 automatically stays a mandatory injunction]; Brydon v. Hermosa Beach (1928) 93 Cal. App. 9 615, 620 [270 P.2d 255] (holding that "all orders granting or refusing injunctions, whether C: 10 temporary or permanent or provisional pending appeal, shall be appealable"). As such, this =o0 ~ C) l l instant action must be automatically stayed pending appeal. C: n) E 12 Cl> 0 0 ~ 13 Respectfully submitted, -~ "O Cl> .r: 0 14 Dated: December 23, 2021 WEINTRAUB TOBIN CHEDIAK COLEMAN GRODIN C :s0 Law Corporation C: 15 - o .0 .: ·-- . E ::::s n) ... 0 0. 16 C o ;1 (,) 17 By: _--=::--=----------=---:--;,-:::.-r---------------- Louis A Gonza ~ z, Jr., SBN 157373 18 Attorneys for Defendant 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 {3329613 .DOCX:} 2 Defendant's Notice of Automatic Stay of Unlawful Detainer Action Pending Appeal of Related Case 1 PROOF OF SERVICE 2 I am a citizen of the United States, employed in the City and County of Sacramento, California. My business address is 400 Capitol Mall, 11th Floor, Sacramento, California 95814. I am over 3 the age of 18 years and not a party to, nor interested in, the within action. On this date, I caused to be served the following: 4 5 DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF AUTOMATIC STAY OF UNLAWFUL DETAINER ACTION PENDING APPEAL OF RELATED CASE 6 7 United States mail by placing such envelope(s) with postage thereon fully prepaid in 8 the designated area for outgoing mail in accordance with this office's practice whereby the mail is deposited in a United States mailbox after the close of the day's 9 business. C: 10 By personally delivering, or causing to be delivered, a true copy thereof to the persons :s0 at the addresses set forth below. ... C) 11 C: (ti Via overnight courier E Q) 12 0(.) X Via ELECTRONIC DELIVERY: By transmitting electronically the listed document(s) to the .::t. (ti 13 email addresse(s) below on this date before 5:00 p.m . :s Q) .r:. (.) 14 C: :a0 15 -o C: Gregory M. Finch .c; -C: ·- ~ ::::s cu ... 0 a. ... 0 u 16 Signature 3400 Law Group, Bradshaw Road, LLP Suite A-4A 11 17 Sacramento, CA 95827-2614 Email: gfinch @signaturelawgrou p.com 18 19 Attorney for Plaintiff 13290 Contractors Lane, LLC 20 21 I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. 22 Executed 23 December 2021, at Sacramento, C lifornia. 23 24 25 26 27 28 {3329613.DOCX:} 3 Defendant's Notice of Automatic Stay of Unlawful Detainer Action Pending Appeal of Related Case