Complaint,Petition: CV 2011 02 0630

On February 22, 2011 a Complaint,Petition was filed in the District Court of Butler County.

Preview
‘IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS

o2 0: £3 BUTLER COUNTY, OHIO i] oa,
; a G53;
FIRSTENERGY SOLUTIONS CORP. ) '
341 White Pond Drive <>+5 ) CASENO. (; ;
Akron, Ohio 44320, ) oe a
) JUDGE ,
Plaintiff, )
)
-v- ) COMPLAINT - Other Civil
)
MANCHESTER ENTERPRISES INC. )
D/B/A THE MANCHESTER INN ) (Breach of Contract)
1027 Manchester ) (Unjust Enrichment)
Middletown, Ohio 45042 ) (Action on Account)
)
Defendant. )

For its Complaint, Plaintiff, FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. (“Plaintiff” or “FES”)
states as follows:

THE PARTIES
1. Plaintiff is a corporation located in Summit County, Ohio.
2. Defendant Manchester Enterprises Inc. d/b/a The Manchester Inn (“Manchester”

or “Defendant”) is an Ohio corporation with its principal place of business in Middletown, Ohio.

JURISDICTION AND VENUE

3. Jurisdiction is proper in this Court pursuant to Ohio Revised Code § 2305.01.
4, Venue is proper in this Court pursuant to Ohio Civil Rules 3(B)(2), (3) and (6).
FACTS
5. On or about April 22, 2010, Defendant entered into two separate supply
agreements (the “Contract”) wherein FES contracted to provide electricity at an agreed upon
price to the Defendant for six accounts. Copies of the two enrollment form supply agreements
executed by Defendant are attached as Exhibit A and B. The agreed upon terms and conditions

are attached as Exhibit C.

{K0256025.1}ho io 5 3G .
6. Plaintiff billed Defendant on account for the supply of electricity. ‘Transaction
Reports for the six accounts demonstrating energy usage, credits to the: accounts, and a
Chow be ee
cumulative balances of the accounts are attached as Exhibit D.

7. Pursuant to the Contract, Defendant has consumed electricity and incurred a

balance in the amount of at least $41,371.03.

8. Despite numerous demands, Defendant has refused to satisfy the balance on the
account.

9. Such action, along with the failure to pay for services, constitutes a breach of the
Contract.

COUNT ONE - Breach of Contract

10. Plaintiff restates and re-avers each and every allegation contained in the preceding
paragraphs as if fully rewritten herein.

11. Plaintiff duly performed all of the conditions and services under the Contract and
provided electricity to the Defendant.

12. Defendant has used and/or consumed the electricity.

13. Despite numerous demands by Plaintiff requiring the Defendant to cure the
balance on the account pursuant to the Contract, Defendant refuses to pay.

14. Defendant has breached the Contract by failing to make payments due and owing
for Plaintiff's services and electricity pursuant to the Contract in the amount of at least
$41,371.03.

15. Defendant’s failure to pay as set forth herein constitutes a breach of contract.

{K0256025.1} 216. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant’s breach, Plaintiff has been
ye bt AOD Ha
damaged in the amount of at least $41,371.03, plus continuing interest ‘at the rate’ of 18% per
annum from August 31, 2010, costs and all obligations pursuantito the Contract,
Link Gr GOL S

COUNT TWO - Unjust Enrichment

17. Plaintiff restates and re-avers each and every allegation contained in the preceding
paragraphs as if fully rewritten herein.

18. Plaintiff has performed services for Defendant and incurred costs with a
reasonable value of at least $41,371.03.

19. As aresult of Defendant’s failure to pay the reasonable value of the costs incurred
by Plaintiff, Defendant has been unjustly enriched in the amount of at least $41,371.03.

20. As a result of Defendant’s unjust enrichment, Plaintiff has been damaged in the
amount of at least $41,371.03, plus continuing interest and costs.

COUNT THREE — Action on Account

21. Plaintiff restates and re-avers each and every allegation contained in the preceding
paragraphs as if fully rewritten herein.

22. Defendant was billed on account for services rendered.

23. Although due demand has been made for Defendant to satisfy the overdue
account, Defendant has refused to satisfy the account and, therefore, Plaintiff is entitled to
judgment on the remaining balance of at least $41,371.03, plus continuing interest at the rate of
18% per annum from August 31, 2010 until the account is paid in full, costs and all other
obligations pursuant to the Contract.

WHEREFORE, Plaintiff FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. requests judgment in its favor in

the amount of $41,371.03, together with continuing interest at the rate of eighteen percent (18%)

{K0256025.1} 3per annum from August 31, 2010 until satisfied, plus costs, attorneys’ fees, and any and all other
. hr ome AS

20
poe Uo
obligations pursuant to the Contract, along with other relief to be provided by this Honorable

Court, against Manchester Enterprises Inc. d/b/a The Manchester Inn.

¢
eee

Respectfully submitted,

me JACKSON & KRANTZ PLL

John P. Archer(#0073721)

Candice B. Miller (#0084042)

One Cleveland Center, 20" Floor

1375 East Ninth Street

Cleveland, OH 44114

Telephone (216) 696-8700

Facsimile (216) 621-6536

Email: jpa@kjk.com; cbm@kjk.com

Counsel for Plaintiff FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.

{K0256025.1} 4REQUEST FOR SERVICE
TO THE CLERK OF SAID COURT: Gone Se weed

Please issue service of Summons on Complaint herein upon the Defendant by certified

mail, return receipt requested, at the following addresses:

Manchester Enterprises Inc.
d/b/a The Manchester Inn
1027 Manchester
Middletown, Ohio 45042

Manchester Enterprises Inc.

c/o Barry J. Levey

400 First National Bank Building
Middletown, Ohio 45042

Respectfully submitted,

KOH JACKSON & TZ PLL

John P. Archer (#0073721)

Candice B. Miller (#0084042)

One Cleveland Center, 20" Floor

1375 East Ninth Street

Cleveland, OH 44114

Telephone (216) 696-8700

Facsimile (216) 621-6536

Email: jpa@kjk.com; cbm@kjk.com

Counsel for Plaintiff FirstEnergy Solutions Corp.

{K0256025.1} 5LAST

2b10-04-22 18326 fax 419756(896 >> irst Energy Corp P 9/16
Apr 22 10 04:48» ——-Riohbuik Apts 5134241090 pt
\ aa gage
FirstEnergy we

Solutions
OG!

Yes, please enroll me/my company 7 the Volunteer Electric Program In wiich FhetEnergy
Solutions Gorp. (FES) will provide me the special Volunteer Electric Program discouni* on my
generation and transmission. Limited ime offar and subject to eligibility requicemants.

*Voluntesr Eleoric Program digoaunt for custome’s or Commacial Rate Gose DS: A fixed pce of 5 9v. gar 4Ver through
Apdl 2013 For customers oF ‘Cammerclal Fiste Coda DM: A “xed price of 6.9% oer Wh fivough Agri 2073, Service ©
begia as soor as passitis. .

! flereby agree to purchase electricity from FES under the agreanen. and included Terms and
Conditions. | understand and agree to those Tems ‘and Gondltions anc agree to participate in the
Zlactre Choice Program. | acknowledge (het! am an atthorivad representative of the company {sted
above and | have the autitority to make decisions on behalf of the company Tegacding its sisctiic
generation supplier. FES has my perilssion to obtain my past & currant eleciric usage data.

Syeres Gao ccedh’ OFF psi cheat .

Electric Account Holder's Name Title
Ty a
= The. Manchestet. LAD
Electric Account Holder's Signature Company Name
~. = _ S63 Ya SY ES ack 5 ¢, aoa
Date Phone Numbke-
Emait Address

ACCOUNTS TO BE ENROLLED:
Ploase include a copy of your electric bill in order to determine eligibility.

Account Number: (10 digits) ope z :
Wj 2i slaele o/ 3d3| Nes

eter Number (9 digits) _..
giz! slalelois|

area Coals Beran Rdaroas [Sigg Sinia' [Hip Coils “| Weta Gada Obilly Name”)

: TOH |.
fot Me Mavg St. Viiddlbed | Woda) ato/ | owe

Please fax this form with ALL PAGES OF THE BILL to
First Energy Solutions VOLUNTEER PROGRAM at
1-866-973-1870

VE ~ SICEA2010-04-22 : fax 4197567896 >> irst Energy Corp P 10/16
2010 One eee lchhull Ans . BG42M1900. pa
ayy 82 Be
ADDITIONAL ACCOUNTS ENROLLMENT FORM : §) ValunteerEnergy
Please attach as many as necessary
Account Nuntber: (10 digits) Mater Number: (8 digits} |
A (SIF 20 Ob FR ee
Service Address: Sity State _| Zip Codo | Rate Code | Utility Namo.
hina | w “so
1 k th) At df beta! OH \ ¥8eea\ Dogo s\__Obla
Account Numbar; (10 digits) Meter Number: (9 digits)

CF RloLleleli[talt)] (Ree sie

Servicg Addrass. City Stato | Zip Cade [Wate Gade | Utlity Name}
Duke Energy
Mer.2 Manchester vd bioun | Of \Ysoual paes | Oho |
. Account Number: (10 digits) Meter Number: (2 digits)
LLIETLETTIT) ChE TT ttt
Service Addrass City: State [Zip Code [Rafa Goda! Utiity Name |
Duke Energy
Chia
Account Number: (10 digits) Mater Number: (8 digits)
Lt TT Td Lf
Satvice Address ony, sists [Zip Code | Rate Gane | Utiity Name
Duke Energy
L Ohio

Please fax this form with ALL PAGES OF THE BILL to
First Energy Solutions VOLUNTEER PROGRAM at
1-866-973-1870

VE. SuGBAfax
Richbuik Apts

- DukeEnergy.

2010-04-22 18226
Apr 22 10 04:58p

Ancount Number 2320-06 13-23-6

Far baet datellad biling information on
ote meni Bil ovek box on right

oonanT?

4197367896 7 irst Energy Corp P 11/16
5134.

24190 pb
Bye 4g 9638
APR O1 ED | DiscoNNEgt NOT
mt
ca 8 $, _
‘HeatBnare Conuibuton = Amount Eceloeed *
. {for Customer Axsistarica)

G19 0.440 ANGLE LOROKD ASCADIGIZI? COPIOOI

snk hf M nef hg GED Lat Ltt tf

‘The Manchester Inn
4027 Manchester
Middletown OH 46042-1827

PO Box 9004084
Loubvilla KY 40200-1084

41.0 DDUDO72S2397 2a20Gb1323b D4LA2OLOb UOuGd 73.015

heater Inn

Tho:
101 MainN

Niddistown OH 46042

PO Box 91001084
Loulsville KY 40280-1004

DISGONNECT NDWGE _AWUIcATIURN Tiiecoe PORTEMMAN OURAN

Duke Energy

Payments altes Mar 24 not included BY prepared anMar 28, 2010
‘Leas payrgent rocelved Maz 1? Nesd mater reading Apr 26, 2010

- * (IMPORTANT. Your sorvies maybo dlecomectad if your past due sunount of $969.47 Js nol pald before
oaneszo 10. A reconnection charge will ba required, For questions, plage cal the number ‘Shown

your: service Is disconnected for non gayment, in addition to a. reconnection: charge, you willba
sequived fo payan additional depastt in the aminuant of $480.00 balora xervice Is resiorad.

Current Electric Charges

830.60
js

Balénos Forward “e508
Current Electdc Charges SbG21
SPB

J DukeEnergy.

$320.01 06-0997 1-602: QOS Visit us at ew. duke-enesgy.core080109 Richbuitt Apis 6134241900
B DukeEnergy.

DISCONNECT NOTH!

2010-04-22 18:27 fax 4197567896 >> irst Enéray Corr, P 12/16
Apr 22 10

Duke nergy

Rats OMO1 + Disir Svo-SmallWinter
Ce Chg $18.00
sibator-Eneray ©
B88 sabhoano e564:
*BR A Rider 82.87

Total Dallvery Charges STAT

+, Axersge Ueege 968 : : .
MAAS} 5 eer} !
oy Reed aay atid aid ae)” Rad O20: vavd a
. — = booms:

» DukeEnergy. seBnc1Ns eoKayFRONZORIIN2010-04-22 18:27 fax 4197367896 >> iret Energy Corp P 13/16

Apr 22 10 04:49p. Richbulll Apis 6134241999 pe

BB DukeEnergy.
. WAR oheee

Aagount Number 5320-0613-21-5 a0 17
For teat detailed Information |
your mony Mcnekbocen en ca

0001262 —oravane “AMD SANTI IMMINENT sCOLPUOHTON IE

clase EP Soe

ume a
i .
(Middlatywn ON 45042-1027 . tn patio RY an2sa-1076

400 GOOODE37508 S32U0KLS2LL DYLAZOANL O00G038067

oe sca yibiNeaeiianst oe we
PIekse RETA THE OXHON WITH YOUR RINNE Paga 1 of

basen
PO Box 001076 Peyrrete sft Mer Spartina BAl prepared on Mar 26, 20:0
Loukville KY 40280-1076 Last payment rogaivisd Mae

Ait Dre: Liera tated Ht
ame Payment Chargete)

Qutdoor Light 1 Duke 2
any ana ou Recs Mowe ie

. e- fderou Vapor
esas vot
Fob 24- Mar 26

29 Days:

Bien ay Cha $ 10.20
1A4

Peta Dalian Cha stra
danention Sarge ‘ore
aneration Energy Cl

Rider .
Rigor TCR OB

Total Ganaratlon Gharges $1868

$1856

BE PulraEnamens — wioeooracmome

vlult 08 ot vm ru ze-anerey na2010-04-22 18:28 fax 4197567896 >> rst Energy Corp P 14/16
| Apr 22 10 0466p —-Richbullt Apis 6134241899 p7

DukeEnergy. ; 9584
Q

106 Main
Middletown OH 40044 nee

Cider batt erantcoual +8 race ley
Tota tae
Average Orage a1

foal oy oad feel ial
eH |

B Huta navey msn teil 90 a2 nate chake-anerow enen2010-04-22 18:28
Apr 22 10 05:

WIVTSETENG | >> irst Energy ores P 15/16

tax
Riohtuilt Apts 134241999
B DukeEnergy.
WAR 84 HELI
Agoount Number 8120.0813-26-8 wo 17 .
For lees dptatied bi lkrmadon on ¢ .
yeaa mani bd, checkbox on AGH Cf \TeeatGhre Gopitntion Ane Enclosed

(her Customer Assistance)
0007251 wi avoss ‘aut WD VOT 48642-19727 OL-POCOET A
og fe nfo eA a At Maple

The Manchester inet
1027 Manchester Avo PO Box 90020/8
Middietowm OH 46042-1827 Loubvilla = KY 40290-1076

YOU OUDOUNISOLG BLZ00G)3260 O42920L0L 00000018333

Page 1 m2

The. Hanchesir fon
1077 Manel hae
Middfetown OH 6042

sprore efor ar 20 notlacaded

PO Box 90010; 75 , a jon tdar 26, 2010
Louisville KY 40200-1076 Espa coca is Naxt moter raading Apr 26, 2010

Usage - 19KWh Ane Due- Previows & Bi

Dutee Energy - Rate DMO nis} Re

Current Elestrio Charges: tate Payment aed)

Pa Balance Forward
Current Etacirle Charges
Current Amount Due

Bly Pes slres Bivens mene encncotconsgn canes tant ote wt samen disbaararna On:2010-04- spe 18:29 tax
Apr 22.10 05:48p ——-Richboullt Apts

BB DukeEnergy.

4197567896 >> irst Energy Corp P 16/16
5134241999 pig”

cette TTT Distr SeoGmallwWinter
Dabur canionor ho

o ome
aon Ee atha00 ox
Defvery Riders lB
ont Deliver Charges S1D8

cera i Flam

$198

"sto |
Calon bunestca rrontceneed * Penocsh st Aey
' average Usage 3
ce]

SEEPS

Wie slens Eneavene, Wri momnn maenine visit up at winw.cuke-energy.comTTT

2010-04422 18:21 fax
Ape 22 10 04:48p Richbult Apts
Firs
Sonrtiong ¥

Yes, pleasa snroll meimy company |
Solutions Garp. (FES) will provia me
generation and tranemissian.

in te Voluntaer
the epactal
Limited time offer and subject to eligibility requirements.

4197567896 >> irst Energy Corp P 1
p3

5194241999

jo Prograny iy whlch FirstEnergy
Volunteer Electric Prog‘am discount" on my

Volunteer Biectic Progiam disse.snt for cuaterers on Commarea! Rate Code DS: A fixed pricy nt 6.9¢ par heh througt

Apr} 2013, For custor-ers on Commercial Rate
begltt a8 seon 3s possible,

| haraby agres to purchase electricity -from
Conditions. | understand and agree to those
Electric Choice Program. | acknowledge that |

Code DM: A Mixed price

of B.8u per hWh through Api 2013, Sarvice to

FES under thé agreement and included Terns and
‘Terms and Cencitlons and agree to panicipate in the
am an authorized representative of the company listed

above and | have the auchorily to make decisions on behalf of the company regarding Ite eleatiio

generation supplier. FES nas my permiseton to obtain my

paal & currant electric usage data.

2hercee. Croarce Ask Preseinl ent
Electric Account Holder's Name Title
_ Wrens, seloonuth... The Planchester
Electric Account Holder's Signature Company Name
_Y-dh d/o SIR aa SIE)
Date Phore Number
imalicess ~

ACCOUNTS TO BE ENROLLED:
Please inctude a copy of your electric

bill in order to determine eligibility.

Agcount Number: 10 diptts) _ y;
al alyiclelel7eiai| ws a“
tater Nuasger (9 digits) .
ilole 7431] lo]
“Bervice Location Street Addrawe | City State | Zip Gode | Rate Cade”) Utitity Raia”)
OH! ; ‘| uke Enoray |
1927 Manchestet Lickel lou} dsb¢a\p50 } | ohio no

Please fax this form with ALL PAGES OF THE BILL to
Firat Energy Solutions VOLUNTEER PROGRAM at
4-866-973-1870

VE ~ SICKA2010-04-22 18:22 fax 4197567896 >> irst Energy Corp, Pe
Apt 22 10 04:49p Richbullt Apts 5134241969 p4

ADDITIONAL ACCOUNTS ENROLLMENT FORM: a
Please attach as many as necessary - :
oe %

‘Account Number: (10 digits) Mater Nupaher: {odigite) - ve
J aren re —y
Lo .. wit bw be : vince bt he eat
Service Address city State | Zin Gade | Rate Code j tility Nama

Duke Energy
10327 Menchesrer \Midblitrun | Of \1S07a\ PS® } Ohw

} Account Number: (10 digits) Meter Number: (9 digits}

2 \VOLy7Teratelsletol/ Tlolélelsilatst ji

Service Addrgss "Gite State Zip Cade | Rete Cada | Utikty Name.

Duke En
27 (Me wc |\Meldlyona |e \Yspyloue? Ohio

Account Number: (10 digite) . Meter Number: (9 digits)

[el7tatoroler it st ais Leora 3 fT 7] TAIL

Service Address City. State [Zip Code | Rate Code | Utility ‘ane
: Duke Energy
OX) Mancheter Midthtom LOH ALTAYA ONBS | Sho

Please fax this form with ALL PAGES OF THE BILL, to
First Energy Solutions VOLUNTEER PROGRAM at
1-866-973-1870

VE ~ SCSAA eT

2010-04-22 18:18 fax 4197567896 >> irst Energy Corp P 1
Apr 22 10 0448p —-Richbult Apts : 6134241999 pa

Baiutlons

Mi N R RGYELECUS L oe VIED ¥
Yes, please entol! me/my company in the Volunfagr Electic Program in which FirsiGnaryy
Solutions Corp. (FES) will proviée me the spacial Volunteer Electric Program diecourt* on my
generation and tranarnisston. Limited dime offer and subject to ellgiblity requirements.

"Yeluateer Elacire S-ograny disaunt for customers a1 Commercial Reve Gode DS A fixed price of 6.8c per KWVt througa
Apri 2013, For custorre’s on Commeargral Rate Cade SH: A Ikad ptce of 6.0 per kWh through Apri 2313. Service to

beat as soud ag oossibie,

{ hereby agres to ourchase electricity -from FES under the agreement and included Tors and
Gondilions, 1 understand and agree to thosa Terms and Conditions and agree to particivate In the
Electric Choloa Program. | acknowledge thal | am an authorized representative of the company listed
above and | have tha authority to rake daclslons on benalf of the company regarding its elentic
generation supplier. FES has my permission to obtain my past & current e ectrio usage dafa,

: er sila eget

os Pe.
Electric Account Holder's Name Title

meppined > irst Energy Corp P 2
Apr 22 10 04:45 Richbutt Apts Bigd2atoge © p4

ADDITIONAL ACCOUNTS ENROLLMENT FORM! @Bronswereneray
Please attach as many as negessary ;

: Li
‘Account Number: (10 digits) Meter Number: (Seats) 1
ower Semen |
rr 8 setae ane hoe cs | ete 4

Service Address. City State ip Cotte _| Rate Gdde | Uulity Name

4 po ke Ei
103-7 Manchegeer \Mickllefovin “OH sera bse} ene

Account Number: (10 digits} jeterN ben {8 digits} :
AN elalolslZtol) gear e212)
Service Address, “_Sity Bigs [an De Rate Code Utility Narre :

: Duke Era!
10227 Munrbester \ Muddlorater \ Ofd dames Psa) one | |2010-04-22 18:22
‘Apr 22 10 Ob:28p

3
fax 4197567896 >> irst “prere
Richbutll Apts 5134241999

BB DukeEnergy.

Account Number 2470-0676-01-0 2017
» For fess calailed biitng information on
Cs

your monthly bil, oliack box on tight
ON0dN26 | msrvsw vane repecranoun tern covrmmi7a
sata hf CRD fenton]
The Manchest

1027 Manches!
Middletown On ‘4s092-1807

PO Box g0010H4
Loulavitte KY 40250-1004

420 DDUISIIIVGE 2470UG7ENI0 OFZLANLOD DOD‘ eae

° Page | al2

Duke Ens mF 1 ‘1-800-774-1202. 2470-0670-01-0
For Accat ivicea, please conlact
Business Getvies Caner

The Manchester _
1027 Manchester
Middietowa OH 46042

PO Box so01aad Payrrwnte altar Moe ‘So not included

BN prepared on Mar 30, 2010
Pivot |

* Eaquisville KY 40200-1684 Last payment racelved Mor 17 Next reading Apr 28, 2010
‘ANT. \ectad 1 due amount of 87,167.54 ts la
ee i a oan

bslora 0446/2010.
shaven above,

Dacaise we ware nabs ta gal

on this bil have Rewh ostin:
ing arrangements before your gn,

It Hees
pa age The us to maka pormanent mater

entre ‘mater, soos
echeduks

+ 000580764 Feb za Mar?5 29 48734 E 4904 E 50
106949090 Feb 24 Mar 25 29 8727 e927 120 63.6
Glac 104207279 Feb 24 Mar 25 20 2063 2167, 160 16,640 MAD

eee

9779.05 |
$TFSDS

|Current Gas Charges Payment Ghargota)
[Gas Cost Rocavary $0,69840000K.CF Batanco Forward | 21008
Cure Electric Charges 6,046.96

Currant Atnourd Due
fr 40.8401 173.40 KW! °
Deke Enorgy= eo $6046.96
|Current Electric Charges: “Feo se

‘
ened 0 60s of Pi al Previe us Minn Actual

PLONE 2001 4900050

#® DukeEnerav.

vigit Us a* wurw.mitke-crwey 6ort2010 ah ilo et

Richbuit Apts fax

PB DukeEnergy, .

‘DISGONNEOT NOTICE

4197567896 BYwohfgs Energy Cory P 4/16

The Manchester - 102% Manche
Misaiemim OH
Thle month's Recovery ss purch the’ na
pote reagan steafitoteteneltoone
E Ri is
ite. oocgso7ed | Rutt GS aansiat Service Large
CCF Usaga- te Fema Savioe Oheays $ 180.00
Fete 24 - Mar 36
ae Cot @ 8 0.1048N000 68.4
28 Days aa Qalvary me 225
a0 CCE ao $0,89840000 $778.05
even $ 773,06
Etectrio Duke Eaarey aan
Molar = 409943000 | Rale DSO ~ Distribution Service
ligts - $20
EWI . 2 000 SR gs Chg * $4040
Actual kW = 68.60 ibn Donan ftzae
Metar « 404207873 Ran | Bon be
ult * 160 ve ane iron Charges ST S36
su one 1sE49 Genbtation a don. * .
pacts” Paap | 7340 RW fazeioobo © i aae.ta .
Basdiw-,. 17940" an aden GF B.potasA0 peat .
[Feb 24 ~ Mar 26 Bidet FV . aah
28 Days Beer hn 2h. 89 :
Total Gonarallon Charges 6946.06
Emme
Gor ap sage anh loot Mage

“

Caiaiatons bated px moet-acent 12 anh tte.

, : Hctgalitgs

bus poe basad on most reef 12 monk
% — Cawvulns ane OR Th mney

warage Veage $240) *

SEPI

“etal
ans

3,304
asa

MM PukaF nore.

bis
ef ard tte
soatd say Td wat a

one cpoodom 4.0002-0000081

7 120Y 908
Sat saa) ak dar ad

Mint eat whine oanlen masini naee,2010-04-22 18:25 fax 4197567896 >> irst Energy Corp P 5/16
“Apr 22 10 06:28 ——-Riohbuikt Apts : 5134241099 pi4

3B DukeEnergy. .

APR Q.1 RECD

Acoount Number 0240-2056-01-1 20 17

For lose detailed biling Infarmafon on oO $ oad

your monthly bl oheck bon an ight HaalShore Contebulicn 1 Simei rconed”
{for Customer Assiaiance}
ONGGDT4 —o Paco wencie Logon esse? -COHTWONEOL LA

sale PU) efor fos HEB ade ae etl ft
The Manchester

1027 Manchester ,
Middletown OH 46042-1027 . [Babee RY 40290-1004

440 OAOCAL?S4A? GSHOAUSSOSL 0429260 DORDS7AI0I5

bisconecT Narice MA anuarTet artacusndy [Gnesi Pago 1 if?2
ThaMannoeer Dune Ener "4-800-774-1202 oedn 2066-001 !
1027 Manel ‘ET a “please contact

Middiotown OF Setvice Contor

PO Dox woot0ad : -Payrons as Mar 26 oiled BA proparad on ar 28,2010
Loulsvila = KY 40289-1084 Last payitent teortved Mar a moter reading Apr 28, 2010

RMPORTANT- Your aervice. nay be disconnected it: ‘[duo amgurtal6t 1,58 fs not pald
Delors 09/7010 A roona alia uppenioe reli, oh sialon nee cli ster

Lb gp pone nen cin, In aduition to a feconnoction 0 a, pan yt be :
reauied, 40 pay an: eloal azo hems of 61.800.00 be etorsten ge yu a ;

LAm! Due - Previous Bi
3 Paymente Recelvei
Current Efectio Charges BPRS | | Late Payineut Sinpote

* Gilling Domand has been reduced to attuln
minimum toad factor of 71 hours uss.

& BukeEnergy. covoarooanonscearennndt ‘abt us at werw.ctake onorgy.can,2010-04-22 18:24 fax 4197567896 >> inst Energy Corp P 6/16
Apr 22 10 OBs4p Richbuilt Apts 8134241900 ps
B DukeEneray:
I ‘OISCON!
LE CURTS

Bteotrle . | Duke Bi

Rem? ansonasie | Rate 6250 osbuton Serko

Mullion - 820 |-pistrtution-Cusiamer Ch $40.00

kwh : 6 ‘

Bonand Read - 0083 | Be Nay ora

Actual KW + 9.60 en 0 358.95

SRT

Fob 24- Mar 26

29 Days 624,66

valdh

aa eae en unt. : ores |
1 fond factor of Fi hdurs'us ue . 140.66

Rider Tel 113.61 |.
Total’ Gerieaten Gharges SUEAZ $1,723.69
$1,728.63

Hh * Gtaotto Uerge

enc
. . Average | io) TONGS

cee ae nen mee fennty | — sere} str —a | =~ piped = peat ey speel —son—peul— sa _
. pect sae SM mee] anf “aRee] Ze 30.8: vey Or ee er eT 6,443]

ke haste ape
aati a

BS DukeEnerny, «seven vislt ve at wemdoke anemy.cem2010-04-22 18:25 “tax 4197567896 >> irst Energy Corp P 7/16
- “Apr 22 10 06:38p —— Richbuilt Apts 5134201980 p.lG

BB DukeEnergy.

Account Numbor 6120-0619-20-8

DED 2L4 «St AVODSE MALTO 0107" ArmeR NODE? LOLITA

ole tQte dee fg A aE teeth

‘The Manchesier soo
1027 Manchester Ave PO Box 9004076

Middietown OH 45042-1927 . Loulsvilla KY 40280-1076

QOD BONNOLSLAS2 b1Z006123229 O4S9FOLDb goupoLe4O4F

Fine Searum nd Caen Pea ah, YOUR mates

te
1027 tanchestor
Kiddtetown OF [ 45042

PO Box 101076 ‘Pampats etter Mae 28 not trokuded » 2010.
Loulavile KY 40200-1076 (Can payment cacavod Mer 17 Naxt nvtarrenctag Apr 26, 2010

Fob 24 Mar 26 2907007, 70ny 24 0 0.00
BRR tebe 3s aaa 20298 = 0 490 200

Usage - 490 RWh
Duka Enorgy - Rate DMO1
Currant Eleairle Chargas

at
Apr 19,2010

® Nokaknarvay, esos2010-04-22 1225 fax 4197567896 >> irst Energy Corp P 8/16
Apr 22 10 0642p Richbullt Apts s1q2aiggg- eT

BB DukeEnergy.

tha Manchester. 1027 Manchester
Middletown GH 4u042

uke Energy, . .
Rate oiler ~ Distr Svc-Smallirter
’ | Diateibuilon-Customar Chg

D894A77AL
10

Wh! * 490
= B ‘Talal Dalvery Charges:
Demand Head 00.26 Gon econ Cha ny Chav

panes, Mares ie i geen

’

Cofsulaiians basad evs not saoent 12 monde hissy
Totat Usage: 10,078

Vy is SEPL_OO7 NOM MARI
necks aT OM ae 104M Er ae ay

MB Desires mer onnconnonion,

Adlets ne ad shane unbenamenines sorSolutions
FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. ~ Terms and Conditions

“These Terms and Conditions together with the enrollment information
for electric generation service with FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. ("FES").
copy of this agreement for your records.

are your agreement
Please keep a
a his 1 for your records.

FES is certified by the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (“PUCO") to offer and supply
electric generation services in Ohio. As a Competitive Retail Blectric Service (°CR ”)
provider, FES. will supply the electric generation to your Electric Distribution Utility
(EDU") based on your usage. Your EDU then distributes or delivers the electricity to
you, FES sets the generation prices and charges that customers pay. The PUCO regulates
distribution prices and services.

DEFINITIONS:

Generation Service - The production of electricity.

Frangmission Service ~ Moving high voltage electricity from a generation facility to the
distribution lines of an EDU.

Distribution Service ~ Physical delivery of electricity to customers by the EDU

RIGHT OF RESCISSION ~ Once you have been enrolled to receive generation service
from FES, your EDU will send you a confirmation leter. You will have the right to
rescind your enrollment within seven (7) calendar days following the postmark date of the
Centitmation letter by following the instructions contained in the letter. The Right of
Rescission only applies when a customer switches to a generation supplier and not on
Foncwal enrollments. Your EDU will not send a confirmation notice upon any renewal of
this Agreement.

‘TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF SERVICE

1, Elighbility.
Commercial: Small commercial customer accounts with a peak demand below 100
KW are eligible for this offer from FES. FES reserves the right to refuse enrollment to
any commercial customer with an outstanding balance.

2. Basle Service Prices. During the term of this Contract, you agree to pay FES for
combined electric Transmission, Generation, and Generation Related Charges. You
will be billed at a fixed price per KWh per billing month depending on the offer you
accepted as specified in the enrollment notification.

In addition to FES" charges, you will be charged by your EDU for distribution and
various other charges. FES reserves the right (0 unilaterally modify this billing format
in the event the EDU is unable or unwilling to provide consolidated billing in this
format.

In addition to the charges described above,
costs, and obligations imposed by a Regional ‘

will charge you for any and all fees,

-ansmission Organization (“RTO”),
Such as the Midwest ISO or successor organizations, that are not otherwise reimbursed
to FES, regardless of whether such charges are greater than, less than, or equal to the
charges Customer currently pays for these services ("Midwest [SO/Transmission and
‘Ancillary Charges”). FES will pass these Midwest [SO/Transmission and Ancillary
Charges, which may be variable, through to you and you will receive no discount on
such charges.

3. Length of Agreement, Your service from FES will commence with the next available
eter reading following the seven (7) day rescission period, and after the acceptance of
the enrollment request by FES (at its discretion and consistent with Paragraph 7
below), and after processing of the enrollment by your EDU, and will continue for the
term ag specified in the offer inaterials from FES, ending on the meter read for the last
month of service.

4. Billing, You will continue to receive a single bill from your EDU that will contain
both your EDU and FES charges. FES does not offer budget billing. If you do not pay
your bill by the due date, FES may cancel this Agreement after giving you a minimum
Of fourteen (14) days written notice. Upon cancellation you will be returned to your
EDU as a customer, You will remain responsible to pay FES for any electricity used
before this Agreement is cancelled as well as any late payment charges. Further, your
failure to pay EDU charges may result in your electric service being disconnected in
accordance with the EDU tariff.

5. Penalties, Fees and Exceptions. Your EDU may
customer. {f you do not pay the full amount owed to FE:
FES may charge a 1.5% per month late payment fee.

6. Cancellation/Termination Provisions. If this agreement is not rescinded during the
rescission period, enrollment will be sent to your EDU. You may terminate this
“Agreement, without penalty, if you move outside the CRES provider's service area or
into an area where the CRES provider charges a different price, by providing FES with
a thirty (30) day written notice, Upon termination and return to standard offer service
with your EDU, you may not be served under the same rates, terms, and conditions
that apply to other EDU customers. There will be a $100 charge per account if you
terminate this Agreement for any other reason, except as expres led herein.
Should you cancel service with FES and return to standard offer service with your
FDU, you may not be served under the same rates, terms, and conditions that apply to
other EDU customers.

4. Customer Consent and Information Release Authorization. By choosing to accept
this offer from FES you understand and agree to the terms and conditions of this
Agreement with FES. You authorize FES to obtain information from the EDU that
includes, but is not limited to: billing history, payment history, historical and future

charge a switching fee to the
by the due date of the bill,

|. Miscellaneous. You have the right to request from FES,

|. Warranty. FES warrants title and the right to all electricity sold hereunder. 7

‘Ohio Duke C&I 10-27-09 v1

electricity usage, meter readings. and characteristics of electricity service. | FES
reserves the right to determine if your credit standing is satisfactory before accepting
your enrollment requests hig rere shall Pe dered executed by FES
following acceptance of your lenfolimert #equest BY FES, the end of the 7 day
rescission period and subsequent acceptance of the enrollment by your EDU.

Contract Expiration, At the end of its term, this Agreement will expire, You are

responsible for arranging ar electric supply. upon Ihe sanpaton of the Agreement.
Dispute Procedures, Cliadt' FES: wit, dny’ questiohs jgoncerning the terms of
service by phone at 1-88S}54-6359, (toll-free) M 00am - 5:00 pm EST or in
writing at 341 White Pond Drive, Attn: Contract Administration, Akron, OH 44320,
Our web address is www.firstenergysolutions.com. If your complaint is not
resolved after you have called your electric supplier and/or your electric utility, oF
for general utility information, residential and business customers may contact (he
Public Utilities Commission of Ohio for assistance at 1-800-686-7826 (toll free) or
TTY at 1-800-686-1570 (toll free) from 8:00 am to 5:00 pm weekdays or at
www. PL hio.gov.

twice within a 12 month
period, up to 24 months of payment history, without charge,

FES is prohibited from disclosing a customer's social security number and/or
account number(s) without the customer's affirmative written consent except for the
FES" collections and reporting, participating in programs funded by the universal
service fund, pursuant to section 4928.54 of the Revised Code, or assigning @
customer's contract to another CRES provider.

FES’ environmental disclosure statement is available for viewing on our website
wwwfirstenergysolutions.com, You agree that FES will make the required
{quarterly updates to the statement electronically on our website, We will also
provide the information upon request.

FES may assign its rights to another, including any successor, in accordance with
the rules and regulations of the PUCO.

FES assumes no responsibility or liability for the following items that are the
responsibility of the EDU: operation and maintenance of the BDU’s electri
system, any interruption of service, termination of service, or deterioration of the
EDU's service. In the event of a power outage, you should contact your local
EDU.

Customer is responsible for providing FES with accurate account information. If
said information is incorrect, FES reserves the right to re-price the applicable
account(s) or terminate the agreement,

FES reserves the right to return any customer to the EDU if the customer's rate code
is changed and the account is no longer eligible for this program.

Customer authorizes, but does not obligate FES, to exerc!
aggregation opt-out rights.

Customer's government

WARRANTIES,

FORTH IN THIS PARAGRAPH ARE
ARE IN LIEU OF ALL OTHER WARRANTIES, WHETHER STATUTORY,
EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO ANY
WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR
PURPOSE OR ARISING OUT OF ANY COURSE OF DEALING OR USAGE OF
TRADE.01/28/11

Page 1 of 1 .
Sot
The Manchester ZuVi ?rangactions Report
$9,904.94
Acct # 92429731 Total Account Balance,"
ot

eee ae RAGES re , Tree en Da Cees ESIC
01/24/11 $137.52 0940205501
0124/11 $472.00 0940205501 ESRV GEN 8,000 KH 41/22/10 12/27/10
12/29/10 $127.40 0940205501 LPC CALC 0
11/30/10 $127.40 0940205501 LPC CALC 0
11/30/10 $547.52 0940205501 ESRV GEN 9,280 KH 40/22/10 11/22/10
10/31/10 $1,019.52 0940205501 ESRV GEN 17,280 KH 09/23/10 10/22/10
10/31/10 $90.97 0940205501 LPC CALC 0
09/30/10 $90.97 0940205501 LPC CALC 0
09/30/10 $1,227.20 0940205501 ESRV GEN 20,800 KH 08/24/10 09/23/10
08/31/10 $1,963.52 0940205501 ESRV GEN 33,280 KH 07/26/10 08/24/10
08/31/10 $60.60 0940205501 LPC CALC 0
07/30/10 $2,265.60 0940205501 ESRV GEN 38,400 KH 06/24/10 07/26/10
06/30/10 $1,774.72 0940205501 ESRV GEN 30,080_KH 05/25/10 __ 06/24/10
FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. - Confidential j EXHIBIT01/28/11

Page 1 of 1
The Manchester , , Transagtions Report
$29, 135.25

Acct # 92429731 Total Account Balance

Trans Date Trans Amt Ree Noo Hie SubType [Trans ty |4 "Gy [Period Stet |Penod End
01/24/11 $373.86 2470067601
01/24/11 $3,511.56 2470067601 ESRV 59,518 KH 11/22/10 12/27/10
12/29/10 $326.10 2470067601 LPC 0
41/30/10 $326.10 2470087601 LPC 0
41/30/10 $2,857.49 2470067601 ESRV 48,432 KH 40/22/10 11/22/10
40/31/10 $3,101.87 2470067601 ESRV 52,574 KH 09/23/10 10/22/10
10/34/10 $212.43 2470067601 LPC 0
09/30/10 $212.43 2470067601 LPC 0
09/30/10 $4,051.24 2470067601 ESRV 68,665 KH 08/24/10 09/23/10
08/31/10 $4,701.89 2470067601 ESRV 79,693 KH 07/26/10 08/24/10
08/31/10 $139.81 2470067601 LPC 0
07/30/10 $5,022.91 2470067601 ESRV 85,134 KH 06/24/10. 07/26/10
06/30/10 $4,297.56 2470067601 ESRV 72,840 _KH 05/25/10 __ 06/24/10

FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. - Confidential01/28/11

Page 1 of 1
12 06%
The Manchester Tr ansactions Report
Acct # 92429731 Total Account Balance 8758. 48
Melon Naoa hie) Sub Type | Trans Qty rcrareeR sa0e)
01/24/11 6120061321 CALC 0
01/24/11 $7.59 6120061321 ESRV GEN 4110 KH 11/22/10 12/27/10
12/29/10 $10.12 6120061321 LPC CALC 0
41/30/10 $10.12 6120061321 LPC CALC 0
11/30/10 $44.85 6120061321 ESRV GEN 650 KH 10/2210. 11/22/10
10/31/10 $90.25 6120061321 ESRV GEN 1,308 KH 09/23/10 10/22/10
10/34/10 $5.58 6120061321 LPC CALC 0
09/30/10 $5.58 6120061321 LPC CALC 0
09/30/10 $201.62 6120061321 ESRV GEN 2,922 KH 082410 09/23/10
08/31/10 $125.72 6120061321 ESRV GEN 1,822 KH 07/26/10. 08/24/10
08/31/10 $3.64 6120061321 LPC CALC 0
07/30/10 $144.07 6120061321 ESRV GEN 2,088 KH 06/24/10 07/26/10
06/30/10 $98.39 6120061321 ESRV, GEN 1,426_KH 05/25/10 06/24/10

FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. - ConfidentialPage 1 of 4 02/15/11
The Manchester Inn , Transactions Report
c Oi
Acct # 92429795 Total Accou int Baldnee $51.58
el wall | eee RSICiis
76 320061321 CALC 0
01/04/11 $0.65 5320061321 LPC CALC 0
0104/1 $6.97 5320061321 ESRV GEN 4101 KH 11/22/10 12/27/10
11/25/10 $6.97 5320061321 ESRV GEN 101 KH 40/22/10 11/22/10
14/25/10 $0.54 5320061321 LPC CALC 0
10/26/10 $0.32 5320061321 LPC CALC 0
10/26/10 $6.97 5320061321 ESRV GEN 101 KH 09/23/10 10/22/10
09/27/10 $6.97 5320061321 ESRV GEN 101. KH 08/24/10 09/23/10
09/27/10 $0.32 5320061321 LPC CALC 0
08/26/10 $6.97 5320061321 ESRV GEN 101 KH 07/26/10 08/24/10
08/26/10 $0.10 5320061321 LPC CALC 0
07/30/10 $0.10 5320061321 LPC CALC 0
07/30/10 $6.97 5320061321 ESRV GEN 101. KH 06/24/10 07/26/10
06/29/10 $6.97_5320061321 ESRV___GEN 401 KH 06/26/10 06/24/10

FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. - Confidential02/15/11

Page 1 of 1
The Manchester Inn Transactions Report
4,496.07
Acct # 92429795 Total Account Balance —$1,496.0
Period End

02/08/11 $22.11 2320081323 CALC
01/04/11 $17.68 2320061323 CALC 0
01/04/11 $277.38 2320061323 ESRV GEN 4,020 KH 11/2210 12/27/10
11/25/10 $14.68 2320061323 LPC CALC 0
11/25/10 $185.61 2320061323 ESRV GEN 2,690 KH 40/22/10 11/22/10
10/26/10 $169.05 2320061323 ESRV GEN 2,450 KH 09/23/10 10/22/10
10/26/10 $9.48 2320061323 LPC CALC 0
09/27/10 $9.48 2320061323 LPC CALC 0
09/27/10 $158.70 2320061323 ESRV GEN 2,300 KH 08/24/10 09/23/10
08/26/10 $160.77. 2320061323 ESRV GEN 2,330. KH 07/26/10 08/24/10
08/26/10 $3.38 2320061323 LPC CALC 0
07/30/10 $238.74 2320061323 ESRV GEN 3,460 KH 06/24/10 07/26/10
07/30/10 $3.38 2320061323 LPC CALC 0
06/29/10 $225.63_ 2320061323 ESRV GEN 3,270_KH 05/25/10 _ 06/24/10

FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. - Confidential02/45/11

Page 1 of 1
The Manchester Inn Transactions Report
f 24.71
Acct # 92462755 Total Accdurit Balance $24.7
Beae eC ene. Rete Nooa te) Sub Type ; > Start | Period End
02/01/14 8120061326 CALC Gyen. 8
01/04/14 $0.32. 8120061326 CALC 0
01/04/11 $2.62 8120061326 ESRV GEN 38 KH 41/22/10. 12/27/10
41/25/10 $2.07 8120061326 ESRV GEN 30 KH 10/22/10 = 11/22/10
41/25/10 $0.29 8120061326 LPC CALC 0
10/26/10 $0.18 8120061326 LPC CALC 0
10/26/10 $3.11 8120061326 ESRV GEN 45 KH 09/23/10. 10/22/10
09/27/10 $0.18 8120061326 LPC CALC 0
09/27/10 $3.66 8120061326 ESRV GEN 53 KH 08/24/10 09/23/10
08/26/10 $3.11 8120061326 ESRV GEN 45 KH 07/26/10 08/24/10
08/26/10 $0.08 8120061326 LPC CALC 0
07/30/10 $3.45 8120061326 ESRV GEN 50 KH 06/24/10 07/26/10
07/30/10 $0.08 8120061326 LPC CALC 0
06/28/10 $5.24 8120061326 ESRV GEN 76 _KH 05/25/10 06/24/10.

FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. - ConfidentialKohrman
Jackson&
Krantz

ATTORNEYS AT LAW

V 216-736-7272
F 2166216536
E cbm@kjk.com

One Cleveland Center
20th Floor

1375 East Ninth Street
Cleveland, OH 44114-1793
216.696.8700
www.kjk.com

Cleveland and Columbus

—_ Member of:
FIT MERITAS LAW FIRMS WORLDWIDE

February 18, 2011

'T' 92 0630

Bui:
Butler County Court of Common PleasCLEi.. 3.
Government Services Center
315 High Street, Third Floor
Hamilton, Ohio 45011

Re: FirstEnergy Solutions Corp. v. Manchester Enterprises Inc.
COMPLAINT
Dear Clerk:

Please file the enclosed Complaint and Notices of Appearance in the above-
referenced matter. Also enclosed is a Docket Statement and a check for
$300.00.

Please return time-stamped copies of the Notices and the Complaint in the
envelope provided. Thank you for your assistance.

Sincerely,

Candice B. Miller

CBM/rh
Enclosures

{K0256600.1}

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.

Complaint,Petition: CV 2011 02 0630

Preview

Case Info

Parties