Preview
4 JAMES A. & BARBARA A. HENRY
3108 Judy Drive
Middletown, Ohio 45044
(513) 420-9069
16 December 2005
Government Services Center .
Butler County Clerk of Courts
315 High Street
Suite 550
Hamilton, Ohio 45011-6016
To Whom It May Concern:
RE: CASE #: CV 2005 12 3853
DATE FILED: December 5, 2005
We have been in contact with HUD and Neighborhood Housing Agency who referred us to Legal
Aid Society of Greater Cincinnati. Legal Aid Society of Greater Cincinnati is currently working on
our foreclosure case as of now.
My husband, James A. Henry, is 100% disabled. His illness prohibits him to work. In early 2002
my husband went to the Butler County Dept of Job & Family Services, which approved my
husband for $115.00 a month starting April 2002 for Ohio disability. The Butler County Dept. of
Job & Family Services then referred him to the Social Security Adi istration. On May 3, 2004,
my husband was approved and received his first social security disability check for $1,115.00. My
husband is currently on social security disability benefits and continues to receive $1,115.00 per
month.
Beneficial was aware of our situation when we were living on just his Ohio disability check of
$115.00 before he was approved for social security and even lowered our monthly payment from
$677.74 to $508.00 per month for hardship. When we had no income except for my husband's
$115.00 Ohio disability check, we borrowed money from family and friends and sold personal
belongings in order for us to continue make our payments.
On October 3, 2005 Beneficial refused our monthly payment when we personally went into their
Middletown branch office to make our October's 2005 monthly payment. For the past eleven
years, Beneficial has always accepted our payments. Now that we have an increase in income
due to his social security check and are able to make our monthly payment, Beneficial has
decided to lock our account from any payment being made, forcing us into foreclosure. In the
past, there have been times when our account has gone into Foreclosure Review, but Beneficial
has always gave us the opportunity to bring our account to current, which we have.
The employee(s) informed us that after three missed payments, Beneficial would start the
foreclosure process. If Beneficial did not except our October monthly payment and the two
proceeding months payments, then we would be forced into foreclosure. The employee(s)
informed us that Beneficial would only accept a payment in full for our account or gave us the
option of refinancing our current loan.
Because my husband is still currently on social security disability benefits, Beneficial would not
refinance our loan with their company. We were told that our income no longer met their
guidelines. Because of Beneficial "New" guidelines, we are unable to refinance our current loan.
Now, Beneficial will no longer accept our payments, which is why they are foreclosing on us.We strongly feel, that The Beneficial branch manager Peggy Kennedy misled my husband and |.
Ms. Kennedy explained to us that we would be on a 30-year loan, but would need to come into
the Middletown Beneficial branch office every five years to update our information. In 2000, | ask
Ms. Kennedy about a statement that we received for which stated approximately $51,000.00 was
due. Ms. Kennedy explained that it was a standard procedure for Beneficial to show that the total
amount due was the payoff, because we were at our five-year mark and that we should continue
making our monthly payments.
We received the first letter concerning the balloon payment around the middle of 2001. We went
into the office and showed Ms. Kennedy. We were very upset, were told not to worry, that the
letter did not mean anything and that she; herself would take care of it.
We were served the foreclosure papers on December 5, 2005. The balloon payment was
supposed to be due, according to the loan papers on January 10, 2000. Beneficial waited five
years to inform us of the situation yet, Beneficial still took our monthly every month until October
2005.
We are trying to get assistance with this situation and re research all of our options. If necessary,
we are prepared to sell our home as a last resort.
Thank You.
Sincerely,
[2-17-05
DATE
BARBARA A. HENRY DATE
ENCLOSURE
cc:
Stephen D. Miles
18 W. Monument Avenue
Dayton, Ohio 45042bey Svar etite
BAK pau V Na
Ry ackCey)
ease
Sees
ag
CT eerste |
Se eae el)
rere a
Sem trarsiea
ea aa)
Ce
ernCeym
ear ATy
Tomiie)
Cay
SOOCm eo eir4
3 EST LT: |
4a3Ua> Mey AUNWIWOD
CO i Bale
SaLLNNOD
NauuvAA CNV
NOJIWVH LNOWY3TD
Be EMA AOI-M NTO). 0NL
SADIAYWSS 1V931
B
x
Zz
o
Z
oO
~
WwW
KH
a
iu
[4
o
Shie)
iienule
LLAIOO
ag
LEGAL AID SOCIETY oF
|
29
2
3
3
a
>
2
5
VU
5
5
>
=
5
é
E
6
8
2
é
g
3
4
a
2
€
5
6
s
=
S
=
x
°
3
€
&
S
&
0
3
8
8
3
3
a
sé
&
Zz
3
3
aWDXR 1117
0016782
BUTLER COUNTY DEPT OF JOB AND FAMILY SERVICES
159 CITY CENTRE MALL
MIDDLETOWN OH 450420000.
IMPORTANT NOTICE
Wedel tlfcosbeabstatsahfbsstlalbllbaltiell
JAMES A HENRY
3108 JUDY DR
MIDDLETOWN OH 45044-0000
Mailing Date: . 09/18/2002
From: DONNA M ROBINSON
Phone: (513) 425-8683 Ext:
Dear JAMES A HENRY
Worker ID: WDXRO9
Case Number: 5050451482
AGName: JAMES A HENRY
yh 20h 4d
wo! git
yok "
KEEP READING >>> Page 1 of 5
” SEQ# 0001342 THIS SPACE FOR OFFICIAL USEONLY PRINT SEQ. 0016782
DHS 8500 (Rev. 3/01) © 5050451482/GA A/01 NOTICE TYPE: AVC
HAA
NySocial Security Administration
Retirement, Survivors and Disability Insurance
Important Information
Office of Central Operations
1500 Woodlawn Drive
Baltimore, Maryland 21241-1500
Date: March 30, 2004
Claim Number: 282-68-8652HA
JAMES A HENRY
3108 JUDY DRIVE
MIDDLETOWN OH 45044-7533
LeabababaltanesleolafestQosstabatoastbeoctalaadbachabusll
vacito
You are entitled to medicare hospital and medical insurance beginning May 2004.
What We Will Pay And When
© You will receive $1,115.00 for April 2004 around May 3, 2004.
e After that you will receive $1,115.00 on or about the third of each month.
Information About Medicare
The monthly premium for your supplemental medical insurance is $66.60
beginning May 2004.
We will start to take premiums out of your May 3, 2004 check.
If You Have Any Questions
We invite you to visit our website at www.socialsecurity.gov on the Internet to
find general information about Social Security. If you have any specific
questions, you may call us toll-free at 1-800-772-1213, or call your local Social
Security office at 1-513-423-4929. We can answer most questions over the
phone. If you are deaf or hard of hearing, you may call our TTY number,
1-800-325-0778. You can also write or visit any Social Security office. The office
that serves your area is located at:
SOCIAL SECURITY
3860 TOWNE BLVD
FRANKLIN, OH 45005
Cc See Next Page
/
a0ogoeg Wd TCLOMI' (Dd LONUTLEA EX'dSVLON.PBEH OL NONPLALTS282-68-8652A Page 2 of 2
282-68-8652DI
Supplemental Security Income Payments are paid the month they are due.
(For example, Supplemental Security Income Payments for March are paid in
March.)
Date of Birth Information
The date of birth shown on our records is July 14, 1960.
Other Important Information
THIS IS A BENEFIT VERIFICATION NOTICE.
Medicare Information
You are entitled to hospital insurance under Medicare beginning May 2004.
Medicare Information
You are entitled to medical insurance under Medicare beginning May 2004.
Type of Social Security Benefit Information
You are entitled to monthly disability benefits.
Type of Supplemental Security Income Payment Information
You are entitled to monthly payments as a disabled individual.
If You Have Any Questions
If you have any questions, you may call us at 1-800-772-1213, or call your local
Social Security office at 513-423-4929. We can answer most questions over the
phone. You can also write or visit any Social Security office. The office that
serves your area is located at:
SOCIAL SECURITY
3860 TOWNE BLVD
FRANKLIN, OH 45005
If you do call or visit an office, please have this letter with you. It will help
us answer your questions.
Linda S. McMahon
Deputy Commissioner
for Operations
BEVO3.09 003222 0017Beneficial PO Box 4153
A Household International Company Carol Stream, IL 60197-4153
e
HOUSEHOLD 7
James Henry (a 16.09
Barbara Henry °
3108 Judy DR
Middletown, OH 45044 4 0%
Account #: 651770-00-105420
To Whom It May Concern: 408:
_ This letter is to inform you that your account wit Beneficial is now in
. Foreclosure Review. | have made several u! cessful attempts to try to
contact you. ~~ wav 34 ove 2
os oan F162? 200,22 “HAF EZ.
Your account is past due for 1016.00: 'A payment made on or before the 14th
of November 2003, certified funds only, for 1016.00 will postpone the
foreclosure action until we are able to make arrangements to bring your
account current. At this time, your account will be locked out from any
unidentified payments being made.
Your account will remain in foreclosure review until you are able to make
arrangements to bring this account current.
If there has been a change in your situation, | am interested in working with
you to cure your default. This will allow you to avoid the cost of additional fees
and allows you to remain in your home. We have many different plans that
may be suitable to your needs.
DAW gr
“ re
Rich Machota 2
Unit Manager
This is an attempt to collect a debt by a debt collector and any information
obtained will be used for that purpose.ee
Beneficial PO Box 4153
AHousehold International Company Carol Stream, IL 60197-4153
ae
HOUSEHOLD **
James Henry
Barbara Henry
3108 Judy DR
Middletown, OH 45044
Account #: 651 770-00-1 05420
To Whom It May Concern:
This letter is to inform you that your account with Beneficial is now in
Foreclosure Review. | have made several unsuccessful attempts to try to
contact you.
Your account is past due for 1216.00. A payment made on or before the 19th
of January 2004, certified funds only, for 1216.00 will postpone the foreclosure
action until we are able to make arrangements to bring your account current.
At this time, your account will be locked out from any unidentified payments
being made. .
Your account will remain in foreclosure review until you are able to make
arrangements to bring this account current.
If there has been a change in your situation, | am interested in working with
you to cure your default. This will allow you to avoid the cost of additional fees
and allows you to remain in your home. We have many different plans that
may be suitable to your needs.
Please call me within the next,2 business days to make arrangements at
1-800-958-2540 ext. 3360.
Sincerely,
Pr Mh
Rich Machota
Unit Manager
This is an attempt to collect a debt by a debt collector and any information
obtained will be used for that purpose.Page 1 of 7
@ . ©
: The Better Business Bureau”
BBB
T Serving Chicago and Nonner Hines wa
he elas Me te) Membership Membership Recommend »
CeCe Ca’ Leer Business
BBB Reliability Report
The Better Business Bureau
Serving Chicago and Northern Illinois
330 N Wabash Avenue Suite #2006
Chicago, IL 60611
HSBC Finance Corp.
140 W Industrial Dr
Elmhurst, IL 60126-1602
Telephone: (630) 758-4043
Fax: (800) 547-8646
www.Beneficial.com
www.household.com
www.unionplusloan.com
www.hsbcusa.com
www.HFC.com
(Yahoo Map)
The BBB reports on members and non-members, If a company is a member of the BBB,
it is stated in this report,
Original January 1878 Employees: 45000
Business Start
Date:
Principal: Mr. Craig Weaver , Customer File Open August
Resolution Dept. Date: 1928
Email Address: craig.m.weaver@us.hsbc.com
TOB Financial Services, Banks, Consumer Finance & Loan Companies,
Classification: Credit Cards & Plans, Credit Services, Investment Advisory Service,
Investment Securities, Loans, Mortgages
BBB This company is a member.
Membership:
Additional DBA Names
http://www.chicago. bbb.org/commonreport.html?bid=4757 12/14/2005Page 2 of 7
Household Recovery Services
Household Life Insurance Company
Household Credit Services
Household Financial Services
Household Finance (HFC)
BBB Membership Status
This company has been a member of this Better Business Bureau since April 2005. This
Means it supports the Bureau's services to the public and meets our membership
standards,
Nature Of Business
This company offers consumer loans, credit cards and auto financing. The company
Operates a special complaint handling system.
Customer Experience
When considering complaint information, please take into account the company's size
and volume of transactions, and understand that the nature of complaints and a firm's
responses to them are often more important than the number of complaints.
The Bureau processed a total of 5035 complaints about this company in the last 36
months, our standard reporting period. Of the total of 5035 complaints closed in 36
months, 1969 were closed in the last year.
These complaints concerned:
131 Acivertising Issues
44 Saies Practice Issues
13 Delivery Issues
4 Guarantee or Warranty Issues
26 Product issues
62 Refund or Exchange Issues
48 Contract Issues
408 Customer Service Issues
4235 Billing or Collection Issues
47 Service or Repair Issues
They were closed as:
4442Resolved
593 Administratively Closed
Competency Licensing
This company is in an industry that may require licensing, bonding or registration in
http://www. chicago. bbb.org/commonreport. html?bid=4757 12/14/2005Page 3 of 7
Order to lawfully do business. The Bureau encourages you to check with the appropriate
agency to be certain any requirements are currently being met.
These agencies may include:
Illinois Department of Banks & Real Estate
310 S. Michigan Ave.
Chicago, IL 60604
(312) 793-3000
Company Management
Additional company management personnel include:
Mr. Gregory L. Snyder - Director Corporate Relations
Ms. Loretta Abrams - Director Consumer Affairs
Ms Theresa Nicchia - Dept Manager
Ms. Jada Howard - Customer Resolution Dept.
Government Actions
On October 11, 2002, Household Finance reached a settlement with 19 States’
Attorneys General and other regulatory agencies concerning charges that the company
violated state laws by misrepresenting loan terms and failing to disclose material
information to borrowers. As of December 16, 2002, all 50 States’ Attorneys General
and the District of Columbia agreed to Participate in the settlement.
Under the settlement, Household agreed to: pay up to $484 million in restitution to
consumers nationwide, limit Prepayment penalties on current and future home loans to
only the first two years of a loan; ensure that new home loans actually provide a
benefit to consumers prior to making the loan; limit up-front points and origination fees
to 5%; reform and improve disclosures to consumers; reimburse states to cover the
costs of the investigations to Household's Practices; and eliminate "piggyback" second
mortgages.
Each state will design its own restitution plan as lending practices vary significantly
from state to state. The details of how affected consumers can obtain restitution
through the settlement will be announced at a later date.
On Wednesday, March 19, 2003, The Securities and Exchange Commission issued a
cease-and-desist order accused Household of giving materially "false and misleading"
information about the company's policy on dealing with delinquent loan payments.
Essentially, the government said Household failed to adequately inform investors about
its restructring policies for delinquent loans, which in some cases
allowed loans to be reset automatically after a missed payment without an assessment
of a borrower's continued ability to repay the loan.
“Restructring policies directly impact a financial institution's reported delinquency rates,
which analysts and investors use as a key measure to evaluate the financial condition
of a company like Household". said Mary Keefe, director of the SEC's Chicago office.
http://www.chicago.bbb.org/commonreport.html?bid=4757 12/14/2005Page 4 of 7
SEC officials noted Household's cooperation with the investigation, and legal experts
said that may have played a role in the company not being fined, despite the cease-
and-desist order.
SEC officials said the investigation is continuing but declined specifics,
Additional DBAs, Addresses and Telephone Numbers
Additional DBA Names
Household Mortgage Services
Beneficial
Household Retail Services
Household Bank VISA
Household Finance Corporation
Household Finance Company
Household Bank FSB
Household Bank Na Illinois
Household Automotive Finance Corporation
HRS
Household Loan
Ameritech Complete Card
Union Plus Card
USWEST Mastercard
Capital Financial Services, Inc.
Union Plus Loan Program
GM Card
Beneficial Finance
Beneficial Illinois, Inc.
Household Finance
Household Finance & Subsidiari
Household Retail Service, Inc
Household Bank (SB, N.A.)
Household Bank Retail Services
Orchard Bank Master Card
Orchard Bank
Beneficial
GM Card, The
Union Plus Master Card
HSBC Retail Services
Beneficial Finance Corporation
Beneficial Finance
Beneficial Inc
Household Bank Credit Services
Household Bank
Household Retail
http://www.chicago. bbb.org/commonreport.html?bid=4757 12/14/2005Household Investigations
HFC
Union Plus Credit Card Program
Household (now Known As HSBC)
HSBC Auto Finance
HSBC Auto Credit
HSBC Auto Account
HSBC Card Services
HSBC Bank Nevada
HSBC Consumer Lending
HSBC Mortgage Services
HSBC Mortgage Services Warehouse Lending
HSBC Retail Services
HSBC Taxpayer Financial Services
Decision One Mortgage Corp.
HSBC
Mortgage Corp (Buf)
Additional Addresses
2700 Sanders Road
Prospect Hts., IL 60070-2701
Tel: (847) 564-6110
PO Box 4144
Carol Stream, IL 60197
577 Lamont Rd
Elmhurst, IL 60126
P. O. Box 703
Wood Dale, IL 60191
P.O. Box 52222
Carol Stream, IL 60197
140 Industrial Dr.
Elmhurst, IL 60126
312 S Mclean Blvd
#B
Elgin, IL 60123-7137
P.O. Box 4153-K
Carol Stream, IL 60197
961 Weigel Dr.
Elmhurst, IL 60126
http://www. chicago. bbb.org/commonreport.html?bid=4757
ee
Page 5 of 7
12/14/2005Page 6 of 7
PO Box 5219
Carol Stream, IL 60197
P.O. Box 4155
Carol Stream, IL 60197
Post Office Box 4153-K
Carol Stream, IL 60197
PO Box 415
Carol Stream, IL 60197
P.0.Box 80084 salinas, ca
Chicago, IL 60601
PO Box 703
Wood Dale, IL 60191
703 N. Wood Dale Rd.
Wood Dale, IL 60191
P. O. Box 1453-K
Carol Stream, IL 60197
P.O. Box 59570
Schaumburg, IL 60159
PO Box 9000
Prospect Heights, IL 60070
PO. Box 9000
San Jose, CA 95128
Additional Phone Numbers
(630) 758-3805
(800) 365-8389
(800) 391-6311
(800) 959-1373
(800) 307-5626
(800) 365-2027
(800) 365-0197
(800) 216-1013
(503) 293-4037
(847) 741-4285
(813) 612-8997
(800) 622-2580
(800) 457-5779
(800) 333-1630
(800) 210-8115
(800) 343-7097
(407) 859-7720
(800) 395-4576
http://www.chicago. bbb.org/commonreport.htm!?bid=4757 12/14/2005Page 7 of 7
(630) 758-3836
Additional Fax Numbers
(847) 564-7094
Additional Email Addresses
info@bbbsilicon.org
Industry Tips
Contracts
As with any business transaction, be sure to read all agreements, guarantees, and
instructions before signing. Do not be pressured into signing an agreement before you
are ready and you understand all terms and conditions. Make sure all oral promises are
put in writing. Be wary of vaguely worded provisions, exclusions or limitations which
could pose a problem later. Never sign a contract with sections left blank.
If you would like to listen to a tip on "Conventional Mortgage Insuranc" 24 hours a day
please call the Better Business Bureau's Tel-Tips line at (312) 832-0500 and press 8#
and key in tip number 421. The Bureau has many other Tel-Tips on a wide array of
topics please call 24 hours a day to hear the menu of topics.
Credit Cards and Charitable Causes
Evaluating Unsolicited Credit Card Offers
Online Credit Cards - Look Before you Click!
Debit Cards Still Confusing to Many Consumers
Mortgage Choices
Shop, Compare and Negotiate -But Move with Caution When Refinancing Your Mortgage
Report as of December 14, 2005
Copyright® 2005 Better Business Bureau®, Inc.
BBB reports may not be reproduced for sales or promotional purposes.
The information in this report has either been provided by the company or has been
compiled by the Bureau from other reliable sources.
As a matter of policy, the Better Business Bureau does not endorse any product, service
or company. BBB reports generally cover a three-year reporting period, and are
provided solely to assist you in exercising your own best judgment. Information
contained in this report is believed reliable but not guaranteed as to accuracy. Reports
are subject to change at any time.
http://www.chicago.bbb.org/commonreport.html?bid=4757 12/14/2005