Preview
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 06/24/2020
06/23/2020 12:59
02:33 PM INDEX NO. 402342/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/24/2020
06/23/2020
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NASSAU
____________ ____--_ _____ _________-_ ______..------------------- -- -----X
**AMENDED**
In the Matter of NOTICE OF
PETITION
13 COLUMBIA PLACE INC.,
BOARD OF MANAGERS OF ACORN PONDS
CONDOMINIUM II AS AGENTS FOR THE UNIT OWNERS
Petitioner(s), Tax Year
2020/21
-against-
402342/2020
Index No.
THE BOARD OF ASSESSORS AND THE ASSESSMENT
REVIEW COMMISSION OF THE COUNTY OF NASSAU
Respondents.
---------------------------------------- ---------------------------------X
COUNTY OF NASSAU
Town: North Hempstead
23d
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that upon the annexed petition verified the day of June,
2020 an application will be made at an IA Part of the Supreme Court of the State of New York,
to be held in and for the County of Nassau at the Supreme Court Building, Mineola, New York,
24"'
on the day of August, 2020 at the opening of the Court on that day for review under Article
petitioners'
7 of the Real Property Tax Law of the assessment upon real property described in the
petition, and for such other and further relief as to the Court may seem just and proper.
Dated: East Rockaway, New York
June 23, 2020
Yours, etc.
I ONE PLLC
Attorneys for Petitioners
340 Atlantic Avenue
East Rockaway, New York 11518
(516) 593-0202
1 of 26
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 06/24/2020
06/23/2020 12:59
02:33 PM INDEX NO. 402342/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/24/2020
06/23/2020
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NASSAU
------------------------------------------------- - -¬X
In the Matter of VERIFIED
PETITION
13 COLUMBIA PLACE INC.,
BOARD OF MANAGERS OF ACORN PONDS
CONDOMINIUM II AS AGENTS FOR THE UNIT OWNERS Tax Year
Petitioner, 2020/21
-against-
Index No.
THE BOARD OF ASSESSORS AND THE ASSESSMENT
REVIEW COMMISSION OF THE COUNTY OF NASSAU
Respondents.
________..---------------------------------- -X
TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NASSAU:
The petitioner above named, by their attorneys, Law Offices of Scott Stone PLLC,
respectively alleges as follows:
"Petitioner"
1. If there is more than one Petitioner herein, the word shall mean
"Petitioners" Petitioners"
or "each of as the context requires.
2. At all times herein mentioned, Petitioner was and still is a taxpayer of the County
of Nassau, whose Board of Assessors and Assessment Review Commission are the Respondents
herein. Petitioner is an aggrieved party with respect to the assessment within the meañiñg of
Section 704 of the Real Property Tax Law, and, on the grounds set forth in Section 706 of the
Real Property Tax Law, Petitioner will be injured thereby.
3. Respondents have heretofore prepared, completed and perfected, purportedly
according to law, an assessment roll for said County for tax year 2020/21. The assessment roll
included an assessment for Petitioner's real property, described and assessed as set forth in the
following schedule. Said schedule includes, in Column 5, the extent of incorrect asss-ment in
that it is excessive, unequal, illegal, unconstitutional and/or misclassified.
4. Petitioners duly made and filed a courplaint(s) pursuant to Section 524 of the Real
Property Tax Law (Form EA-524) with Respondeñts to have said assessed valuation and
transitional of said real property corrected and revised, specifying therein the respect in which the
assessment complained of was incorrect and which complaint(s) sought to reduce the assessment
complained of as set forth in column III of paragraph 3 above. The said complaint(s) are hereby
referred to and made part of this petition as though fully set forth herein.
2 of 26
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 06/24/2020
06/23/2020 12:59
02:33 PM INDEX NO. 402342/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/24/2020
06/23/2020
..._____..---. __.____. ___ ..---..__---....--.___-..-__ ____......__..__
Column I Column II Column III Column IV Column V
.------------..----.__. _______.--- __.....--..--.----.__...--....---..--....---.........___
COUNTY OF NASSAU Original Claimed Final Extent of
Town: North Hempstead Va!uation Valuation Valuatian Inequality
SD: Herricks and/or Excessiveness
......--..-..-...-.,--- ..--.. ___.----...__.--.....----....-.__-.----._.---..-.______.----..
Petitioner: 13 Columbia Place Inc.
Section/Block/Lot(s):
5/10/34 Land $
SD NH4 Total $ 6858 1000 6858 5858
--.....----.____.._.______ _____---. ________ ________...--....------..-.. _________________...
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U155 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 905 150 905 755
_____._..---- ---- .........__..._-----------..---......----.....--- --------______ ...
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U156 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 622 150 622 472
.......---..---...__..____..... _____.--..---...____.---..--.----, ...........__.--------...--.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lat(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U157 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 710 150 710 560
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U158 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 697 150 697 547
...------....___..---.__.. ___...___. ____...........------..._......-----..... __...----.__...-.....-
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U159 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 634 150 634 484
----- ____......... .....----...._..........--...--..---....._ __...... __..--------..--...--
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U160 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 905 300 905 605
__________. . ____ ____....-- _..-------..._________ __________ __ ___________.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U161 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 677 150 677 527
--..--- . .. .____.. ....__ ---- _.------.--. ..._..
3 of 26
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 06/24/2020
06/23/2020 12:59
02:33 PM INDEX NO. 402342/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/24/2020
06/23/2020
___-- ____.- _______. _________. __________ ._.._____..___ ...____...... _ ___..
Column I Column II Column 111 Column IV Column V
----- .......___...__________ __._____..-.,________....--_______ ____ ______..________........
COUNTY OF NASSAU Original Claimed Final Extent of
Town: North Hempstead Valuation Valuation Valuation Inequality
SD: Herricks and/or Excessiveness
___..__..... ______... ____.._... ___.__.___ .... _.. __..___..-- __..________...------
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U162 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 622 150 622 472
.______-._____.--.._______ ..__._...__. ___..,_______ ..------ .._.. ___________.,_...-..____..--..------
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U163 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 610 150 610 460
_____________.._____ ______ ________ ______..______ ___________ ___________.....-----_.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U165 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 622 150 622 472
.______------...___________ .--..____.......___,...----_____...- ___________. - _____________.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U166 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 697 150 697 547
_____-----..____..-------... __ ----..________. _____.______.. ___...----..._ _______....---.....-----,.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U167 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 697 150 697 547
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U168 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 622 150 622 472
_..-- .________..___ .._..___, ,--..._.--.....--...______. ___.._____,... __._____..._________.....
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U169 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 603 150 603 453
____________________ __ --.____..___-,..____ _______----,.._..._ ______.___ ,_,.______._.________.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U170 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 600 150 600 450
4 of 26
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 06/24/2020
06/23/2020 12:59
02:33 PM INDEX NO. 402342/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/24/2020
06/23/2020
____ . _____._ _____. _______ __. ________. ______..__ ________________.
Column I Column II Column lil Column IV Column V
....---___..___ __.__.......____..___-..._________......--..--....__ _....__..___....__..___.
COUNTY OF NASSAU Original Claimed Final Extent of
Town: North Hempstead Valuation Valuation Valuation Inequality
SD: Herricks and/or Excessiveness
._____________________ _..--.___. __ ...______.----...--------- __...___...___...______..
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U171 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 622 150 622 472
__._ ..________.._ _____..._____...__.. _____..___ _________ ___________..____..
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U172 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 677 150 677 527
.__________-____________ ..______---.._____ _________. _____-_____ _..______________.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U173 Land $
SD NH9 . Total $ 694 150 694 544
__-___.._______..._______ .__----._,________ __.._____._. ___ ________--._.________.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U175 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 634 150 634 484
...-----------____--____ ________.----.--___ _______-___________ ________..--___.______.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U176 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 634 150 634 484
____________ ______ ..._____ ______... _________---________ ___________ _________.______-
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U177 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 634 150 634 484
...........----..--........__.__- ___.--.....-------... _..----- __..---..----.. __________._______..
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U178 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 714 150 714 564
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U179 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 697 150 697 547
5 of 26
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 06/24/2020
06/23/2020 12:59
02:33 PM INDEX NO. 402342/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/24/2020
06/23/2020
_......... __ ___ _____ .................__________.__
Column I Column II Column III Column IV Column V
_________,- _______.. _____..,-. ______ ....._..__......_... ___-__ _________.
COUNTY OF NASSAU Original Claimed Final Extent of
Town: North Hempstead Va!uation Valuation Valuation Inequality
SD: Herricks and/or Excessiveness
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U180 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 622 150 622 472
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U181 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 622 150 622 472
_________..______ ..._..___________ --__________ _____..-____ __.._.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U182 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 634 150 634 484
,________________________ ______. _.....____ ____.____ ...___... __________________,.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U183 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 634 150 634 484
________ . .........--.... .... _______ _____________. __ __________________
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U184 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 697 150 697 547
. .__- ____ _____. ____ _______ ________ ___ _______________----_.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U185 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 697 150 697 547
___________________..__ __.. ...________ ___ .____,,__ ..___..__
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U186 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 634 150 634 484
6 of 26
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 06/24/2020
06/23/2020 12:59
02:33 PM INDEX NO. 402342/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/24/2020
06/23/2020
Column I Column Il Column III Column IV Column V
COUNTY OF NASSAU Original Claimed Final Extent of
Town: North Hempstead Valuation Valuation Valuation Inequality
SD: kerricks and/or Excessiveness
Petitioner; Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U188 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 697 150 697 547
Petitioner; Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U189 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 622 150 622 472
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U190 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 704 150 704 554
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s);
8/A/823U CA41 U191 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 697 150 697 547
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U192 Land
SD NH9 Total 622 150 622 472
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s}:
8/A/823U CA41 U193 Land $
SD NH9 Total 603 150 603 453
Petitioner: Board of Maildael s of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U194 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 600 150 600 450
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U195 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 634 150 634 484
7 of 26
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 06/24/2020
06/23/2020 12:59
02:33 PM INDEX NO. 402342/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/24/2020
06/23/2020
_______ ___ .._______. __________ -____ ___.._______________--
COUNTY OF NASSAU Original Claimed Final Extent of
Town: North Hempstead Valuation Valuation Valuation ineqüslity
SD: Herricks and/or Excessiveness
.-.__..__........_________..___.--- ________-----....----..___________ ____________ ______--------------..
________________.________ _________....__________ __________-___ -___________ _._____________--------
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41U196 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 677 150 677 527
______.._________.._..------ __-_____. ___________ ___________ _____________ __-__________-________
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U197 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 683 150 683 533
-_______..--_______-______ _______.-__________..___________- ______-_____ ______-____________--
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U198 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 634 150 634 484
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U199 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 600 150 600 450
____-.-- .___ ______ ______-- ______,---- __________,- _________- ___-__________--------.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U200 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 600 150 600 450
________.._______________ ________. __________ ____ . ___________ _______________-------.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U201 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 622 150 622 472
________________-____ ____-__ ___________ __________.__________--________________-
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U202 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 708 150 708 558
8 of 26
FILED: NASSAU COUNTY CLERK 06/24/2020
06/23/2020 12:59
02:33 PM INDEX NO. 402342/2020
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 2
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/24/2020
06/23/2020
Column I Column li Column IN Column IV Column V
COUNTY OF NASSAU Original Claimed Final Extent of
Town: North Hempstead Valuation Valuation Valuation inequality
SD: Herricks and/or Excessiveness
_______________ .._____-- ______ ________ __.__._______ _____ . .._..___-___________.
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U204 Land $
SD NH9 Total $ 622 150 622 472
______________----- ___,----------___ ___________ ____....-_________-....-------
Petitioner: Board of Managers of Acorn Ponds Condo
Section/Block/Lot(s):
8/A/823U CA41 U205 Land $
SD NH9