Preview
Page 1 of 3
~~ SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF PLACER
MINUTES
Case Name: Kimberly Hole, et al vs Sutter Roseville Medical Center, et al Case Number: S-CV-0034326
Judicial Officer: Charles Wachob Date: 9/14/18
Department: 42 Courtroom Clerk: Mylee Taylor
Nature of Proceedings: Jury Trial Court Reporter: Catharine LaPlante,
CSR 10140
Eric Ratinoff present with plaintiff,Kimberly Hole and for plaintiff,Larry Hole
Kat Todd and Robert Zimmerman present with defendant, Terry Arikawa and for defendant, Sutter Medical Group; Dr.
Harris Levin present as a representative for Sutter Medical Group
8:58 a.m. Court reconvenes from the previous day of 9/13/18, forongoing jury trial,with allparties are present as
stated above. By stipulation of counsel, the lastphoto of Exhibit 227 isexcluded (military photo) and Exhibit 225-
000002 isexcluded. Counsel stipulate that only the underlined portions of Larry Hole’s testimony (Exhibit 189) were
played for the jury yesterday. Exhibit 191 is marked for identification, which reflect the portion of Kimberly Hole’s
testimony that was played for the jury yesterday. Again, only the underlined portions of this exhibit were played.
Counsel stipulate that only the underlined portions ofThomas Stevenson’s testimony (Exhibit 188) were played for the
jury yesterday. Exhibit 497 is marked for identification. Counsel stipulate Exhibit 497 represents the portion of Dr.
Leggett’s testimony played for the jury on 9/6/18. (see exhibit list)Jury instructions are discussed.
9:10 a.m. The jury is now present. Ms. Todd presents closing argument on behalf of the defendant. Jurors are
admonished and excused for break. Outside of the presence of the jury, scheduling isdiscussed.
10:28 a.m. Recess taken.
10:39 a.m. Court reconvenes with allparties present as stated above. The jury isalso present. Mr. Ratinoff presents
rebuttal closing argument on behalf ofthe plaintiff.
11:14 a.m. The Court provides finalinstructions to the jury.
11:23 a.m. Deputy David Cox is sworn to take charge of the jury, and the jury retires to begin deliberations. The
alternate jurors are placed on telephone standby and excused pending notification from the clerk. Off the record:
S-CV-0034326 Hole vs Sutter 9/14/18
Page 2 of 3
Counsel review the exhibits, verdict forms, and jury instructions before they go to the jury. Counsel agree Exhibit 225-
000001 should not go to the jury; SO ORDERED. Court stands in recess pending notification from the jury.
12:15 p.m. The jury leaves for lunch.
1:15 p.m. The jury returns from lunch, and retiresto continue deliberations. Court remains inrecess pending
notification from the jury.
2:23 p.m. Request #1 isreceived from the jury and itreads as follow:
Testimony read back to us from Kim Hole on 9/6 at 2:00 p.m. Kim was being interviewed by Mr. Ratinoff. Specifically
interested inthe Motrin she took on Saturday night.
2:34 p.m. The following written response is provided to the jury from the court:
Ms. Hole firsttestified September 7, 2018. Your request refers to testimony of Ms. Hole on September 6, 2018.
Please clarifyor confirm that you are seeking Ms. Hole’s testimony from September 7, 2018.
2:41 p.m. The following written response is provided from the jury: Yes
The clerk contacts counsel are requests that they return to court. Mr. Ratinoff advises the clerk that David Allard willbe
appearing on his behalf.
3:01 p.m. Court reconvenes. David Allard ispresent on behalf of plaintiffs. Kat Todd present with defendant, Terry
Arikawa. Counsel agree upon what will be read back to the jury.
3:13 p.m. — 3:15 p.m. The court reporter enters the jury deliberation room to provide the requested read back. Court
stands inrecess pending notification from the jury.
3:50 p.m. The bailiffinforms the Court that the jury has reached a verdict.
4:03 p.m. Court reconvenes with allparties present as stated above. At the direction of the Court, the bailiffescorts the
jury into the courtroom. The foreperson indicates that the jury has reached a verdict. The bailiffhands the verdict
forms to the Court. The Court reviews the verdict forms. The Court reads the verdict, to wit:
We, the jury inthe above entitled case, find the following Special Verdict on the questions submitted to us:
1. Was Terry Arikawa, D.O./Sutter Medical Group negligent inthe diagnosis or treatment of Kim Hole?
No
Signed and dated by the jury foreperson
Court inquired of the jury ifthis istheir verdict, alljurors responding yes. Plaintiff requests polling. There are 12
negative responses.
4:09 p.m. Verdicts are recorded. The Court orders alljuror information sealed. Jurors are thanked, released from the
admonishment, and excused.
S-CV-0034326 Hole vs Sutter 9/14/18
Page 3 of 3
4:13 p.m. Recess taken. The clerk calls to thank and excuse the alternate juror.
4:20 p.m. Court reconvenes with Mr. Allard and Ms. Todd present. Depositions are ordered returned to the offering
party with an order for retention pending further proceedings. Exhibits are retained in Department 42’s exhibit locker,
2"? floor,GIB.
4:22 p.m. Court stands in recess.
S-CV-0034326 Hole vs Sutter 9/14/18
Page 1 of 16
PLACER COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT
EXHIBIT LISTING
Case Name: Kimberly Hole, et al vs Sutter Roseville Medical Center, et al
Court Case No.: S-CV-0034326
Parties:
(A) Plaintiff (C) Joint exhibits
(B) Defendant (D) Court exhibits
Exhibit Listing
No | Pty | Marked Ident Admit Refused/ Description
W/D/Held
‘ C | 4/2/18 9/6/18 9/13/18 3/31/13 Urgent Care
2 C | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Admission Registration Record
3 C | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Clinical Report Nurses
c. | 4/2/18 9/6/18 9/13/18 4/2/13 Dr. Webster ER Physician Clinical
4 Report
c | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Dr. Webster ED Physician Order
5 Sheet
6 C | 4/2/18 9/6/18 9/13/18 4/2/13 Diagnostic Imaging Report
7) © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 ER Nursing Summary of Care
g| © | 42/18 4/2/13 ED Labs
g| © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 ICU Admission Data
| © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 ICU Nurse Admissions Notes
ul} © {42/18 9/6/18 9/13/18 4/2/13Dr. Aghili Critical Care Consultation
wo} © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 ICU Physician Notes
c | 4/2/18 9/7/18 9/13/18 4/2/13 Dr. DeMar General Surgical
13 Consultation
c. | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Dr. Finkemeier Orthopedic
14 Consultation
is| © 4/2/18 4/2/13 Dr. Finkemeier Operative Report
ie| © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Dr. DeMar Operative Report
7 C | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Anatomic Pathology Report
ig| © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Operating Room Record
19 C_ | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Critical Care Admission Orders
20 C | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
Page 2 of 16
21 C | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Progress Records
7 c | 4/2/18 oe Trauma Neuro ICU Admission
23 C | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Sepsis Early Detection Orders
4 | © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Arterial Blood Gas Report
a5 | © | 4/2/18 4/3/13 Anatomic Pathology Report
96 | © | 42/18 4/3/13 Operative Report
57| © | 4/2/18 4/3/13 Operating Room Record
og | © | 4/2/18 4/3/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
c. | 4/2/18 9/10/18 9/13/18 4/4/13 Dr. Kalyan Infectious Disease
29 Consultation
39 | © | 4/2/18 4/4/13 Operative Report
31| © | 4/2/18 4/4/13 Anatomic Pathology Report
» c | 4/2/18 vm htatieg) Report (through knee
33| © 4/2/18 4/4/13 Dr. Maher Consultation
34} © | 4/2/18 4/4/13 Progress Record
35| © | 4/2/18 4/5/13 Operative Report
36 | © 4/2/18 4/5/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
37| © | 42/18 4/6/13 Operative Report
aR C | 4/2/18 4/6/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
39| © | 4/2/18 4/7/13 Operative Report
ao| © | 42/18 4/7/13 Operating Room Record
Py C | 4/2/18 4/7/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
5 C | 4/2/18 4/8/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
43 C | 4/2/18 4/8/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
44 C | 4/2/18 4/8/13 Progress Record
4S C | 4/2/18 4/9/13 Operative Report
AG C | 4/2/18 4/9/13 Operating Room Record
4g C | 4/2/18 4/9/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
ag C | 4/2/18 4/9/13 Dr. Kalyan Progress Note
an C | 4/2/18 4/10/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
_ C | 4/2/18 4/10/13 Progress Record
51
C | 4/2/18 4/10/13 Dr. Kalyan Progress Note
Page 3 of 16
52 C | 4/2/18 4/11/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
53 C | 4/2/18 4/11/13 Progress Record
ae {15
5A
Ore
C | 4/2/18
Ra
4/12/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
56 | © | 4/2/18 4/12/13 Dr. Wong Operative Report
57| © | 4/2/18 4/12/13 Anatomic Pathology Report
5g | © | 4/2/18 4/12/13 Operating Room Record
59| © | 4/2/18 4/12/13 Progress Record
6o| © | 4/2/18 4/13/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
61 | © | 4/2/18 4/13/13 Progress Record
62 | © | 4/2/18 4/14/13 Operative Report
63 | © | 4/2/18 4/14/13 Operating Room Record
6a | © | 4/2/18 4/14/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
65 | © | 4/2/18 4/14/13 Progress Record
66 | © | 4/2/18 4/14/13 Nephrology Consultation
a C | 4/2/18 4/15/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
68 C | 4/2/18 4/15/13 Infectious Disease Progress Record
69 | © | 4/2/18 4/15/13 Progress Record
5 C | 4/2/18 4/16/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
4 C | 4/2/18 4/16/13 Infectious Disease Progress Record
7" C_ | 4/2/18 4/16/13 Progress Record
"8 C | 4/2/18 4/17/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
| © 4/2/18 4/17/13 Infectious Disease Progress Record
75 C | 4/2/18 4/17/13 Progress Record
” C_ | 4/2/18 4/18/13 Anatomic Pathology Report
47| © | 4/2/18 4/18/13 Operating Room Record
8 C | 4/2/18 4/18/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
70 C | 4/2/18 4/19/13 Operative Report
go | © | 4/2/18 4/19/13 Operating Room Record
84 C | 4/2/18 4/19/13 Infectious Disease Progress Record
o C | 4/2/18 4/19/13 Progress Record
83
C | 4/2/18 4/19/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
Page 4 of 16
84 C | 4/2/18 4/20/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
85 C | 4/2/18 4/20/13 Progress Record
a6 | © | 4/2/18 4/21/13 Operative Report
g7| © | 4/2/18 4/21/13 Anatomic Pathology Report
gg | © | 4/2/18 4/21/13 Operating Room Record
gg | © | 4/2/18 4/21/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
99 | © | 4/2/18 4/21/13 Progress Record
91 | © | 4/2/18 4/22/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
92 | © | 4/2/18 4/22/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
93| © | 4/2/18 4/22/13 Progress Record
on C | 4/2/18 4/23/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
gs | © | 4/2/18 4/23/13 Operative Report
96 | © | 4/2/18 4/23/13 Operating Room Record
97 | © | 42/18 4/23/13 Progress Record
3 C | 4/2/18 4/24/13 Dr. Wong Consultation
ee C | 4/2/18 4/24/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
100 C | 4/2/18 4/24/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
101 C | 4/2/18 4/24/13 Progress Record
102 C | 4/2/18 4/25/13 Anatomic Pathology Report
a03 C | 4/2/18 4/25/13 Operating Room Record
‘6A C | 4/2/18 4/25/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
165 C_ | 4/2/18 4/25/13 Progress Record
106 C | 4/2/18 4/26/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
107 C | 4/2/18 4/26/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
108 C | 4/2/18 4/26/13 Progress Record
108 C | 4/2/18 4/27/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
140 C | 4/2/18 4/27/13 Progress Record
ia | © 4/2/18 4/28/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
115 C | 4/2/18 4/28/13 Progress Record
7 C | 4/2/18 4/29/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
itd C | 4/2/18 4/29/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
115
C | 4/2/18 4/29/13 Progress Record
Page 5 of 16
116 C | 4/2/18 4/30/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
117 C | 4/2/18 4/30/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
118 C | 4/2/18 4/30/13 Progress Record
119 C | 4/2118 5/1/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
120 C | 4218 5/1/13 Progress Record
121 C | 42/18 5/2/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
122 C | 4/2/18 5/2/13 Progress Record
123 C | 4/2/18 5/3/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
124 C | 4/2/18 5/3/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
125 C | 4/2/18 5/3/13 Progress Record
126 C | 4/2/18 5/4/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
127 C | 4/2/18 5/4/13 Progress Record
vg| © | 4/2/18 5/5/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
v9} © | 4/2/18 5/5/13 Progress Record
130 C | 4/2/18 5/6/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
31| © 4/2/18 5/6/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
w2| © | 4/2/18 5/6/13 Progress Record
133 C | 4/2/18 5/7/13 Operative Report
134} © | 42/18 5/7/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
"ee C | 4/2/18 5/7/13 Progress Record
126 C_ | 4/2/18 5/8/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
i37 C | 4/2/18 5/8/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
33| © 4/2/18 5/8/13 Progress Record
aaa C | 4/2/18 5/9/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
san C | 4/2/18 5/10/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
wai| © | 4/2/18 5/11/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
w2| © | 4/2/18 5/12/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
_ C | 4/2/18 5/13/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
1an C | 4/2/18 5/13/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
iag| © 4/2/18 5/14/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
jas C | 4/2/18 5/14/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
C_ | 4/2/18 5/14/13 Progress Record
147
Page 6 of 16
148 C | 4/2/18 5/15/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
149 C | 4/2/18 5/16/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
150 C | 4/2/18 5/17/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
151 C | 4/2/18 5/17/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
152 C | 4/2/18 5/18/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
153 C | 4/2/18 5/19/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
154 C | 4/2/18 5/20/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
155 C | 4/2/18 5/20/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
156 C | 4/2/18 5/21/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
157 C | 4/2/18 5/22/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
isg| © | 4/2/18 5/22/13 Progress Record
sg) © | 4/2/18 5/23/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
160 | © | 4/2/18 5/23/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note
wei | © | 4/2/18 5/24/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
162| © 4/2/18 5/25/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
163| © | 42/18 5/26/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
s.| © 4/2/18 5/27/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
165 C | 4/2/18 5/28/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
166 | © | 2/18 5/28/13 Progress Record
ig C | 4/2/18 5/29/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
168 C | 4/2/18 5/29/13 MRI Pelvis
169 C | 4/2/18 5/30/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note
70 C | 4/2/18 5/31/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note
oi C | 4/2/18 6/1/13 Transfer Summary
in| © 4/2/18 6/1/13 Dr. Basrai Consultation
173| © 4/2/18 6/5/13 Dr. Kalyan Consultation
17a C | 4/2/18 6/6/13 Progress Record
175 C | 4/2/18 6/11/13 Discharge Summary
c | 4/2/18 5/9/13 — 5/27/13 Rehabilitation Services PT
176 Wound Care Treatment Notes
c. | 4/2/18 5/9/13 — 6/1/13 PT Evaluation and Inpatient -
177 Treatment Summary
c | 4/2/18 5/9/13 — 6/1/13 OT Evaluation and
178 Treatment Summary
Page 7 of 16
4/2/18 Dr. William Webster — Medical Records
179 (Exhibit A to 10/18/16 Deposition)
4/2/18 Dr. Ranjani Kalyan — Medical Records
180 (Exhibit A to 9/9/15 Deposition)
181 4/2/18 Dr. Sharon Katuin (3/31/13 to 2/22/14)
4/2/18 UC Davis - Medical Records (3/7/14 to
182 4/23/14)
183 18 9718 9/13/18 Exhibit A from Snyder’s deposition
184 9/10/18 9/12/18 9/13/18 Order for Toradol 3/31/13
9/12/18 9/12/18 9/13/18 Summary of Future Loss — Table 1-A —
185 Agency Hire
9/12/18 9/12/18 9/13/18 Summary of Future Loss — Table 1-B —
186 Direct Hire
9/12/18 9/12/18 9/13/18 Summary of Lost Earning Capacity —
187 Table 1
9/13/18 9/13/18 Videotaped Trial Testimony of Thomas
188 Stevenson M.D.
189 9/13/18 9/13/18 Videotaped Deposition of Larry Hole
190 9/13/18 9/13/18 Videotaped Deposition of Kimberly Hole
9/14/18 9/14/18 Videotaped Deposition of Kimberly Hole —
191 pg 165 only
4/2/18 Dr. Philip Bosco — Medical Records 4/2/13
200 to 11/6/13
4/2/18 Brian Hayes, CPO (River City Prosthetics —
201 12/6/13 to 6/3/15)
4/2/18 Dave Scurti, CPO (Hanger Clinic - 3/1/16 to
202 6/30/16)
4/2/18 Jason Solomon, MD — Medical (4/11/16 to
203 7/25/16)
4/2/18 Terry Zimmerman, MD — Medical (8/16/16
204 to 10/5/16)
4/2/18 Robert D. Dubanski, D.M.D. — Records
205 (Rocklin Dental - 1/10/17 to 10/18/17)
4/2/18 Wrist Fracture — Medical (2/6/17 to
206 2/17/17)
4/2/18 Plaintiff Kimberly Hole’s W-2s 2009
207 through 2016
4/2/18 Plaintiff Kimberly Hole’s Form SSA-1099
208 2014 through 2016
4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Supplemental
209 Request for Production of Documents, Set 1
4/2/18 Plaintiffs Supplemental Document
210 Production, Set 1
4/2/18 Plaintiffs’ Response to Supplemental
211 Request for Production
Page 8 of 16
212 | A | 4/2/18
Reserved
A_ | 4/2/18 Plaintiff's Request for Production of
213 Documents to Sutter Medical Group, Set 6
A | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Written Responses
to Request for Production of Documents,
214 Set 6.
A_ | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Production of
Documents, Set 6. P&Ps for Hiring
214.1 Credentialing October 3, 2007
A | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Production of
Documents, Set 6. P&Ps for Hiring
214.2 Credentialing November 18, 2008
A | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Production of
Documents, Set 6. P&Ps for Hiring
214.3 Credentialing January 25, 2010
A_ | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Production of
Documents, Set 6. P&Ps for Hiring
214.4 Credentialing revised in 2011
A_ | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Production of
Documents, Set 6. P&Ps for Hiring
214.5 Credentialing
A | 9/13/18 9/13/18 Kimberly Hole: Economic Damages
215 Summary
216 Reserved
217 Reserved
A | 4/2/18 Plaintiff's Request for Admissions to Sutter
218 Medical Group, Set 1
A_ | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Written Response
219 to Request for Admissions, Set 1
A_ | 4/2/18 Plaintiff's Request for Admissions to Sutter
220 Medical Group, Set 2
A_ | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Written Response
997 to Request for Admissions, Set 2
922 | A | 4/2/18 MRI Imaging 1|through 2 9/12/13 Pelvis
A_ | 4/2/18 Radiology Imaging 1through 3 2/6/2017
223 Wrist Fracture (prior to surgery)
A | 4/2/18 9/12/18 Radiology Imaging 1through 3 2/9/2017
224 Wrist Fracture (post-surgery)
A_ | 4/2/18 9/5/18 9/13/18
(225-
sot ans Photos taken by Plaintiff Larry Hole Photos
000002 1 through6
excluded
225 on 9/14/18)
A | 4/2/18 oH si18 Photos taken by Defendant Sutter Roseville
(except Medical Center Photos | through 3
226 226-
Page 9 of 16
000003)
A | 9/7/18 9/13/18
last photo :
eatin d Kim Hole Pre Amputation Photos 1 — 4
227 on 9/14/18)
928 | A | 9/7/18 9/13/18 Kim Hole Post Amputation Photos 1 — 8
229 Reserved
A | 4/2/18 American Osteopathic Association Policies
230 and Procedures Amended April 2013
A | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Kim Hole’s Military Certificates of
231 Completion
A | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Expert — Barchuk, Alex
232 Curriculum Vitae
A_ | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Expert Barchuk, Alex Physical
Medicine and Rehabilitation LCP
233 Evaluation dated 12-4-2015
A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert Barchuk, Alex Life Care
234 Plan Worksheet updated 8-8-2017
A_ | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Expert Barchuk, Alex Telephone
Conference — LCP Reevaluation dated 8-8-
235 2017
A_ | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Expert Barchuk, Alex Handwritten
236 Notes & LCP Reevaluation — Exhibit 5
A_ | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Expert Barchuk, Alex Pages from
237 Medical File — Exhibit 8
A | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Expert Barchuk, Alex LCP
238 Questionnaire — Exhibit 9
A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Photos 1
239 through 8
940 | A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 1
9a1| A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 2
ya2| A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 3
943 | A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 4
aaa | A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 — | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 5
nas | A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 6
nag | A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 7
547 | A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Al
Preview
Page 1 of 3 ~~ SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF PLACER MINUTES Case Name: Kimberly Hole, et al vs Sutter Roseville Medical Center, et al Case Number: S-CV-0034326 Judicial Officer: Charles Wachob Date: 9/14/18 Department: 42 Courtroom Clerk: Mylee Taylor Nature of Proceedings: Jury Trial Court Reporter: Catharine LaPlante, CSR 10140 Eric Ratinoff present with plaintiff,Kimberly Hole and for plaintiff,Larry Hole Kat Todd and Robert Zimmerman present with defendant, Terry Arikawa and for defendant, Sutter Medical Group; Dr. Harris Levin present as a representative for Sutter Medical Group 8:58 a.m. Court reconvenes from the previous day of 9/13/18, forongoing jury trial,with allparties are present as stated above. By stipulation of counsel, the lastphoto of Exhibit 227 isexcluded (military photo) and Exhibit 225- 000002 isexcluded. Counsel stipulate that only the underlined portions of Larry Hole’s testimony (Exhibit 189) were played for the jury yesterday. Exhibit 191 is marked for identification, which reflect the portion of Kimberly Hole’s testimony that was played for the jury yesterday. Again, only the underlined portions of this exhibit were played. Counsel stipulate that only the underlined portions ofThomas Stevenson’s testimony (Exhibit 188) were played for the jury yesterday. Exhibit 497 is marked for identification. Counsel stipulate Exhibit 497 represents the portion of Dr. Leggett’s testimony played for the jury on 9/6/18. (see exhibit list)Jury instructions are discussed. 9:10 a.m. The jury is now present. Ms. Todd presents closing argument on behalf of the defendant. Jurors are admonished and excused for break. Outside of the presence of the jury, scheduling isdiscussed. 10:28 a.m. Recess taken. 10:39 a.m. Court reconvenes with allparties present as stated above. The jury isalso present. Mr. Ratinoff presents rebuttal closing argument on behalf ofthe plaintiff. 11:14 a.m. The Court provides finalinstructions to the jury. 11:23 a.m. Deputy David Cox is sworn to take charge of the jury, and the jury retires to begin deliberations. The alternate jurors are placed on telephone standby and excused pending notification from the clerk. Off the record: S-CV-0034326 Hole vs Sutter 9/14/18 Page 2 of 3 Counsel review the exhibits, verdict forms, and jury instructions before they go to the jury. Counsel agree Exhibit 225- 000001 should not go to the jury; SO ORDERED. Court stands in recess pending notification from the jury. 12:15 p.m. The jury leaves for lunch. 1:15 p.m. The jury returns from lunch, and retiresto continue deliberations. Court remains inrecess pending notification from the jury. 2:23 p.m. Request #1 isreceived from the jury and itreads as follow: Testimony read back to us from Kim Hole on 9/6 at 2:00 p.m. Kim was being interviewed by Mr. Ratinoff. Specifically interested inthe Motrin she took on Saturday night. 2:34 p.m. The following written response is provided to the jury from the court: Ms. Hole firsttestified September 7, 2018. Your request refers to testimony of Ms. Hole on September 6, 2018. Please clarifyor confirm that you are seeking Ms. Hole’s testimony from September 7, 2018. 2:41 p.m. The following written response is provided from the jury: Yes The clerk contacts counsel are requests that they return to court. Mr. Ratinoff advises the clerk that David Allard willbe appearing on his behalf. 3:01 p.m. Court reconvenes. David Allard ispresent on behalf of plaintiffs. Kat Todd present with defendant, Terry Arikawa. Counsel agree upon what will be read back to the jury. 3:13 p.m. — 3:15 p.m. The court reporter enters the jury deliberation room to provide the requested read back. Court stands inrecess pending notification from the jury. 3:50 p.m. The bailiffinforms the Court that the jury has reached a verdict. 4:03 p.m. Court reconvenes with allparties present as stated above. At the direction of the Court, the bailiffescorts the jury into the courtroom. The foreperson indicates that the jury has reached a verdict. The bailiffhands the verdict forms to the Court. The Court reviews the verdict forms. The Court reads the verdict, to wit: We, the jury inthe above entitled case, find the following Special Verdict on the questions submitted to us: 1. Was Terry Arikawa, D.O./Sutter Medical Group negligent inthe diagnosis or treatment of Kim Hole? No Signed and dated by the jury foreperson Court inquired of the jury ifthis istheir verdict, alljurors responding yes. Plaintiff requests polling. There are 12 negative responses. 4:09 p.m. Verdicts are recorded. The Court orders alljuror information sealed. Jurors are thanked, released from the admonishment, and excused. S-CV-0034326 Hole vs Sutter 9/14/18 Page 3 of 3 4:13 p.m. Recess taken. The clerk calls to thank and excuse the alternate juror. 4:20 p.m. Court reconvenes with Mr. Allard and Ms. Todd present. Depositions are ordered returned to the offering party with an order for retention pending further proceedings. Exhibits are retained in Department 42’s exhibit locker, 2"? floor,GIB. 4:22 p.m. Court stands in recess. S-CV-0034326 Hole vs Sutter 9/14/18 Page 1 of 16 PLACER COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT EXHIBIT LISTING Case Name: Kimberly Hole, et al vs Sutter Roseville Medical Center, et al Court Case No.: S-CV-0034326 Parties: (A) Plaintiff (C) Joint exhibits (B) Defendant (D) Court exhibits Exhibit Listing No | Pty | Marked Ident Admit Refused/ Description W/D/Held ‘ C | 4/2/18 9/6/18 9/13/18 3/31/13 Urgent Care 2 C | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Admission Registration Record 3 C | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Clinical Report Nurses c. | 4/2/18 9/6/18 9/13/18 4/2/13 Dr. Webster ER Physician Clinical 4 Report c | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Dr. Webster ED Physician Order 5 Sheet 6 C | 4/2/18 9/6/18 9/13/18 4/2/13 Diagnostic Imaging Report 7) © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 ER Nursing Summary of Care g| © | 42/18 4/2/13 ED Labs g| © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 ICU Admission Data | © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 ICU Nurse Admissions Notes ul} © {42/18 9/6/18 9/13/18 4/2/13Dr. Aghili Critical Care Consultation wo} © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 ICU Physician Notes c | 4/2/18 9/7/18 9/13/18 4/2/13 Dr. DeMar General Surgical 13 Consultation c. | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Dr. Finkemeier Orthopedic 14 Consultation is| © 4/2/18 4/2/13 Dr. Finkemeier Operative Report ie| © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Dr. DeMar Operative Report 7 C | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Anatomic Pathology Report ig| © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Operating Room Record 19 C_ | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Critical Care Admission Orders 20 C | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note Page 2 of 16 21 C | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Progress Records 7 c | 4/2/18 oe Trauma Neuro ICU Admission 23 C | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Sepsis Early Detection Orders 4 | © | 4/2/18 4/2/13 Arterial Blood Gas Report a5 | © | 4/2/18 4/3/13 Anatomic Pathology Report 96 | © | 42/18 4/3/13 Operative Report 57| © | 4/2/18 4/3/13 Operating Room Record og | © | 4/2/18 4/3/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note c. | 4/2/18 9/10/18 9/13/18 4/4/13 Dr. Kalyan Infectious Disease 29 Consultation 39 | © | 4/2/18 4/4/13 Operative Report 31| © | 4/2/18 4/4/13 Anatomic Pathology Report » c | 4/2/18 vm htatieg) Report (through knee 33| © 4/2/18 4/4/13 Dr. Maher Consultation 34} © | 4/2/18 4/4/13 Progress Record 35| © | 4/2/18 4/5/13 Operative Report 36 | © 4/2/18 4/5/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note 37| © | 42/18 4/6/13 Operative Report aR C | 4/2/18 4/6/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 39| © | 4/2/18 4/7/13 Operative Report ao| © | 42/18 4/7/13 Operating Room Record Py C | 4/2/18 4/7/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 5 C | 4/2/18 4/8/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 43 C | 4/2/18 4/8/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note 44 C | 4/2/18 4/8/13 Progress Record 4S C | 4/2/18 4/9/13 Operative Report AG C | 4/2/18 4/9/13 Operating Room Record 4g C | 4/2/18 4/9/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note ag C | 4/2/18 4/9/13 Dr. Kalyan Progress Note an C | 4/2/18 4/10/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note _ C | 4/2/18 4/10/13 Progress Record 51 C | 4/2/18 4/10/13 Dr. Kalyan Progress Note Page 3 of 16 52 C | 4/2/18 4/11/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 53 C | 4/2/18 4/11/13 Progress Record ae {15 5A Ore C | 4/2/18 Ra 4/12/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note 56 | © | 4/2/18 4/12/13 Dr. Wong Operative Report 57| © | 4/2/18 4/12/13 Anatomic Pathology Report 5g | © | 4/2/18 4/12/13 Operating Room Record 59| © | 4/2/18 4/12/13 Progress Record 6o| © | 4/2/18 4/13/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 61 | © | 4/2/18 4/13/13 Progress Record 62 | © | 4/2/18 4/14/13 Operative Report 63 | © | 4/2/18 4/14/13 Operating Room Record 6a | © | 4/2/18 4/14/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 65 | © | 4/2/18 4/14/13 Progress Record 66 | © | 4/2/18 4/14/13 Nephrology Consultation a C | 4/2/18 4/15/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 68 C | 4/2/18 4/15/13 Infectious Disease Progress Record 69 | © | 4/2/18 4/15/13 Progress Record 5 C | 4/2/18 4/16/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 4 C | 4/2/18 4/16/13 Infectious Disease Progress Record 7" C_ | 4/2/18 4/16/13 Progress Record "8 C | 4/2/18 4/17/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note | © 4/2/18 4/17/13 Infectious Disease Progress Record 75 C | 4/2/18 4/17/13 Progress Record ” C_ | 4/2/18 4/18/13 Anatomic Pathology Report 47| © | 4/2/18 4/18/13 Operating Room Record 8 C | 4/2/18 4/18/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 70 C | 4/2/18 4/19/13 Operative Report go | © | 4/2/18 4/19/13 Operating Room Record 84 C | 4/2/18 4/19/13 Infectious Disease Progress Record o C | 4/2/18 4/19/13 Progress Record 83 C | 4/2/18 4/19/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note Page 4 of 16 84 C | 4/2/18 4/20/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 85 C | 4/2/18 4/20/13 Progress Record a6 | © | 4/2/18 4/21/13 Operative Report g7| © | 4/2/18 4/21/13 Anatomic Pathology Report gg | © | 4/2/18 4/21/13 Operating Room Record gg | © | 4/2/18 4/21/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 99 | © | 4/2/18 4/21/13 Progress Record 91 | © | 4/2/18 4/22/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note 92 | © | 4/2/18 4/22/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 93| © | 4/2/18 4/22/13 Progress Record on C | 4/2/18 4/23/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note gs | © | 4/2/18 4/23/13 Operative Report 96 | © | 4/2/18 4/23/13 Operating Room Record 97 | © | 42/18 4/23/13 Progress Record 3 C | 4/2/18 4/24/13 Dr. Wong Consultation ee C | 4/2/18 4/24/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 100 C | 4/2/18 4/24/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note 101 C | 4/2/18 4/24/13 Progress Record 102 C | 4/2/18 4/25/13 Anatomic Pathology Report a03 C | 4/2/18 4/25/13 Operating Room Record ‘6A C | 4/2/18 4/25/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 165 C_ | 4/2/18 4/25/13 Progress Record 106 C | 4/2/18 4/26/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note 107 C | 4/2/18 4/26/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note 108 C | 4/2/18 4/26/13 Progress Record 108 C | 4/2/18 4/27/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note 140 C | 4/2/18 4/27/13 Progress Record ia | © 4/2/18 4/28/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note 115 C | 4/2/18 4/28/13 Progress Record 7 C | 4/2/18 4/29/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note itd C | 4/2/18 4/29/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note 115 C | 4/2/18 4/29/13 Progress Record Page 5 of 16 116 C | 4/2/18 4/30/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 117 C | 4/2/18 4/30/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note 118 C | 4/2/18 4/30/13 Progress Record 119 C | 4/2118 5/1/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 120 C | 4218 5/1/13 Progress Record 121 C | 42/18 5/2/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note 122 C | 4/2/18 5/2/13 Progress Record 123 C | 4/2/18 5/3/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note 124 C | 4/2/18 5/3/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note 125 C | 4/2/18 5/3/13 Progress Record 126 C | 4/2/18 5/4/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 127 C | 4/2/18 5/4/13 Progress Record vg| © | 4/2/18 5/5/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note v9} © | 4/2/18 5/5/13 Progress Record 130 C | 4/2/18 5/6/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 31| © 4/2/18 5/6/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note w2| © | 4/2/18 5/6/13 Progress Record 133 C | 4/2/18 5/7/13 Operative Report 134} © | 42/18 5/7/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note "ee C | 4/2/18 5/7/13 Progress Record 126 C_ | 4/2/18 5/8/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note i37 C | 4/2/18 5/8/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note 33| © 4/2/18 5/8/13 Progress Record aaa C | 4/2/18 5/9/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note san C | 4/2/18 5/10/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note wai| © | 4/2/18 5/11/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note w2| © | 4/2/18 5/12/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note _ C | 4/2/18 5/13/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 1an C | 4/2/18 5/13/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note iag| © 4/2/18 5/14/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note jas C | 4/2/18 5/14/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note C_ | 4/2/18 5/14/13 Progress Record 147 Page 6 of 16 148 C | 4/2/18 5/15/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 149 C | 4/2/18 5/16/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 150 C | 4/2/18 5/17/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 151 C | 4/2/18 5/17/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note 152 C | 4/2/18 5/18/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 153 C | 4/2/18 5/19/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 154 C | 4/2/18 5/20/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 155 C | 4/2/18 5/20/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note 156 C | 4/2/18 5/21/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 157 C | 4/2/18 5/22/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note isg| © | 4/2/18 5/22/13 Progress Record sg) © | 4/2/18 5/23/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 160 | © | 4/2/18 5/23/13 Infectious Disease Progress Note wei | © | 4/2/18 5/24/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note 162| © 4/2/18 5/25/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note 163| © | 42/18 5/26/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note s.| © 4/2/18 5/27/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 165 C | 4/2/18 5/28/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 166 | © | 2/18 5/28/13 Progress Record ig C | 4/2/18 5/29/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 168 C | 4/2/18 5/29/13 MRI Pelvis 169 C | 4/2/18 5/30/13 Trauma Critical Care Progress Note 70 C | 4/2/18 5/31/13 Dr. DeMar Daily Progress Note oi C | 4/2/18 6/1/13 Transfer Summary in| © 4/2/18 6/1/13 Dr. Basrai Consultation 173| © 4/2/18 6/5/13 Dr. Kalyan Consultation 17a C | 4/2/18 6/6/13 Progress Record 175 C | 4/2/18 6/11/13 Discharge Summary c | 4/2/18 5/9/13 — 5/27/13 Rehabilitation Services PT 176 Wound Care Treatment Notes c. | 4/2/18 5/9/13 — 6/1/13 PT Evaluation and Inpatient - 177 Treatment Summary c | 4/2/18 5/9/13 — 6/1/13 OT Evaluation and 178 Treatment Summary Page 7 of 16 4/2/18 Dr. William Webster — Medical Records 179 (Exhibit A to 10/18/16 Deposition) 4/2/18 Dr. Ranjani Kalyan — Medical Records 180 (Exhibit A to 9/9/15 Deposition) 181 4/2/18 Dr. Sharon Katuin (3/31/13 to 2/22/14) 4/2/18 UC Davis - Medical Records (3/7/14 to 182 4/23/14) 183 18 9718 9/13/18 Exhibit A from Snyder’s deposition 184 9/10/18 9/12/18 9/13/18 Order for Toradol 3/31/13 9/12/18 9/12/18 9/13/18 Summary of Future Loss — Table 1-A — 185 Agency Hire 9/12/18 9/12/18 9/13/18 Summary of Future Loss — Table 1-B — 186 Direct Hire 9/12/18 9/12/18 9/13/18 Summary of Lost Earning Capacity — 187 Table 1 9/13/18 9/13/18 Videotaped Trial Testimony of Thomas 188 Stevenson M.D. 189 9/13/18 9/13/18 Videotaped Deposition of Larry Hole 190 9/13/18 9/13/18 Videotaped Deposition of Kimberly Hole 9/14/18 9/14/18 Videotaped Deposition of Kimberly Hole — 191 pg 165 only 4/2/18 Dr. Philip Bosco — Medical Records 4/2/13 200 to 11/6/13 4/2/18 Brian Hayes, CPO (River City Prosthetics — 201 12/6/13 to 6/3/15) 4/2/18 Dave Scurti, CPO (Hanger Clinic - 3/1/16 to 202 6/30/16) 4/2/18 Jason Solomon, MD — Medical (4/11/16 to 203 7/25/16) 4/2/18 Terry Zimmerman, MD — Medical (8/16/16 204 to 10/5/16) 4/2/18 Robert D. Dubanski, D.M.D. — Records 205 (Rocklin Dental - 1/10/17 to 10/18/17) 4/2/18 Wrist Fracture — Medical (2/6/17 to 206 2/17/17) 4/2/18 Plaintiff Kimberly Hole’s W-2s 2009 207 through 2016 4/2/18 Plaintiff Kimberly Hole’s Form SSA-1099 208 2014 through 2016 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Supplemental 209 Request for Production of Documents, Set 1 4/2/18 Plaintiffs Supplemental Document 210 Production, Set 1 4/2/18 Plaintiffs’ Response to Supplemental 211 Request for Production Page 8 of 16 212 | A | 4/2/18 Reserved A_ | 4/2/18 Plaintiff's Request for Production of 213 Documents to Sutter Medical Group, Set 6 A | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Written Responses to Request for Production of Documents, 214 Set 6. A_ | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Production of Documents, Set 6. P&Ps for Hiring 214.1 Credentialing October 3, 2007 A | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Production of Documents, Set 6. P&Ps for Hiring 214.2 Credentialing November 18, 2008 A | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Production of Documents, Set 6. P&Ps for Hiring 214.3 Credentialing January 25, 2010 A_ | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Production of Documents, Set 6. P&Ps for Hiring 214.4 Credentialing revised in 2011 A_ | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Production of Documents, Set 6. P&Ps for Hiring 214.5 Credentialing A | 9/13/18 9/13/18 Kimberly Hole: Economic Damages 215 Summary 216 Reserved 217 Reserved A | 4/2/18 Plaintiff's Request for Admissions to Sutter 218 Medical Group, Set 1 A_ | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Written Response 219 to Request for Admissions, Set 1 A_ | 4/2/18 Plaintiff's Request for Admissions to Sutter 220 Medical Group, Set 2 A_ | 4/2/18 Sutter Medical Group’s Written Response 997 to Request for Admissions, Set 2 922 | A | 4/2/18 MRI Imaging 1|through 2 9/12/13 Pelvis A_ | 4/2/18 Radiology Imaging 1through 3 2/6/2017 223 Wrist Fracture (prior to surgery) A | 4/2/18 9/12/18 Radiology Imaging 1through 3 2/9/2017 224 Wrist Fracture (post-surgery) A_ | 4/2/18 9/5/18 9/13/18 (225- sot ans Photos taken by Plaintiff Larry Hole Photos 000002 1 through6 excluded 225 on 9/14/18) A | 4/2/18 oH si18 Photos taken by Defendant Sutter Roseville (except Medical Center Photos | through 3 226 226- Page 9 of 16 000003) A | 9/7/18 9/13/18 last photo : eatin d Kim Hole Pre Amputation Photos 1 — 4 227 on 9/14/18) 928 | A | 9/7/18 9/13/18 Kim Hole Post Amputation Photos 1 — 8 229 Reserved A | 4/2/18 American Osteopathic Association Policies 230 and Procedures Amended April 2013 A | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Kim Hole’s Military Certificates of 231 Completion A | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Expert — Barchuk, Alex 232 Curriculum Vitae A_ | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Expert Barchuk, Alex Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation LCP 233 Evaluation dated 12-4-2015 A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert Barchuk, Alex Life Care 234 Plan Worksheet updated 8-8-2017 A_ | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Expert Barchuk, Alex Telephone Conference — LCP Reevaluation dated 8-8- 235 2017 A_ | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Expert Barchuk, Alex Handwritten 236 Notes & LCP Reevaluation — Exhibit 5 A_ | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Expert Barchuk, Alex Pages from 237 Medical File — Exhibit 8 A | 4/2/18 Plaintiff Expert Barchuk, Alex LCP 238 Questionnaire — Exhibit 9 A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Photos 1 239 through 8 940 | A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 1 9a1| A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 2 ya2| A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 3 943 | A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 4 aaa | A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 — | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 5 nas | A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 6 nag | A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Alex Video 7 547 | A | 4/2/18 9/10/18 | 9/13/18 Plaintiff Expert -Barchuk, Al