Preview
**** CASE NUMBER: 502017CA005035XXXXMB Division: AY ****
Filing # S0UZU997 E-Filed 05/04/20 1'/ 06:24:36 PM
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15"
JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
CASE NO.:
(City of West Palm Beach Case No.: CE17010266)
SCIANNO INTERNATIONAL CORP,
a Florida corporation,
Appellant,
vs.
CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH,
Code Compliance Division,
Appellee.
/
NOTICE OF APPEAL! OF FINAL ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION
NOTICE IS GIVEN that SCIANNO INTERNATIONAL CORP (“Scianno”) appeals to
the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit Court the order of the City of West Palm Beach Code Compliance
Sracial Manictrate Tennifor Ashton rendered and executed on Anril 4, 2017, The nature of the
pecias ivaapiouuw venus 2.01
Order is a final Order that requires Scianno to relocate or modify its HVAC system to comply with
' See Article V, Section 5(b) of the Florida Constitution (“The circuit courts... shall have the power
of direct review of administrative action prescribed by general law.”); section 26.012, Florida
Statutes (“Circuit courts shall have jurisdiction of appeals from final administrative orders of local
government code enforcement boards.”); section 162.11, Florida Statutes (“aggrieved party... may
appeal a final administrative order of an enforcement board to the circuit court.”); Rule
9.030(c)(1)(C), Fla. R. App. P. (circuit courts shall review, by appeal, “administrative action if
provided by general law.”); Rule 9.110(c), Fla. R. App. P. (“In an appeal to review final orders of
lower administrative tribunals, the appellant shall file the notice with the clerk of the lower
ee tenintuntionn tulhemal © in 2 daue af vanditian of the arder ta he re wed ani all alco file
@amiiustiauve Wiouiiar witain SU Gays Or renGitien Of Lie Croer tC Oe TEVieweG, ane Sides 2aS0 2S
a copy of the notice... with the clerk of the court.”); and West Palm Beach Ordinance 26-37
(“aggrieved party... may appeal a ruling or order [of] a special master to the circuit court.”).
FILED: PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL, SHARON R. BOCK, CLERK, 05/04/2017 06:24:56 PMthe 65 dBA limitation, imposes fines of $250.00 per day or re-inspection assessments for non-
compliance, deems the HVAC’s noise level a nuisance activity in the event of non-compliance,
and authorizes the City of West Palm Beach to abate the violations at Scianno’s cost. Copies of
the Order and the Notice of Violation referenced in the Order are attached hereto.
Respectfully submitted this 4th day of May 2017.
RICHMAN GREER, P.A.
Attorneys for Appellant
One Clearlake Centre, Suite 1504
250 Australian Avenue, South
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-5016
Telephone: (561) 803-3500
Facsimile: (361) 820-1608
By: /s/ Adam M. Myron
Adam M. Myron
Florida Bar No. 0895121
amyron@richmangreer.com
Brett L. Goldblatt
Tata. Dae MA NOCOIN
PIOlIUa Dai INO, vos7LU
bgoldblatt@richmangreer.comCade Complionce Speclal Magintente
cu Eat net ain Rach rie
AEST PALAE SEACH 401 Clematie Sree West Palas thea *
cs eet Went Pain each, #teasdes [Sagara aaece
Y an te
VIOLATION ADDRESS: SS LVERNIAST MUS
WEST PALM BEACH CODE SECTION VIOLATIONS,
RE:
Sele
The Special Magitinte has Beard teicney at the Code Coretlance esting beld
Pare the Speulal Magiscate herchy enters te following FINDINGS OF Tact, Concatsions rene nee
ORDER: Eisprscsorracr
[ANNO INTERNATIONAL CORP ts are the Cmter(a) Respensenis) in the above came.
Service of pevvers was made by Us Centified Mail andlor by posting the an . 7
EF it afican 10 aay spose the bearing dase, 1 the Property referenced shove as math ab
4 Tic Ose Repeoters)) Doug, Earane lla —. spent athe ening
Be NOONE appeared atthe eating oO behalf of ownert a) tesponseraty)
ution,
4) 0 Tee Oenerte) Responsenats) crested bso w i
FF The Owner(s) Resprrodere(s) did not enter into 8 tiptation.
The Cir of West Patn Beach at shown by substantial compcters evidence that afl fats set forth ca the Notice
y ScU
“18
»
of Victation ave true ans correct
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW.
“The above stated facts constiate a violation of the Section(s) listed above of the Code of Ordsaanses of te Cty of Wot
Pats Beach, Phvida
ORDER
ae that Chaner(s) Respurdentis), shall cory the above cited violations wichia 30if
Ged thea withia 45 cays or the City will Empose $250 per dry wel coeplicd ce re-
36-4 and Rewlution No. 172-11,
In iy the Onder of this Speelal Mi
fo permit it required, if permit is equ
inspection asseramects purvaant to 36-2
Uopald reinspection aseesements shall be tevied as a Bol assessment sepertor to all otber private
rights, interests lens, encumbrances, tiles aad claims wpon the property and equal ia ra snd ign wha len
Heed valorem tanec. Unpaid rriaspection axscrsmcnts may be certified tothe (33 collector fer coticton penestt
«fo the uniform method provided In FS, § 197.3632 or tw tbe same manaer 8 asienmeat for ©
n-ad valoreat
service ausenaments,
; + 2-87
Upon sensing, Den: nected rvnioetify Cole Lnfescome OMe, MARGARITA CRUZ 4 seth
bs st(ah Besson ice ‘ is
Hachcincting ce faring to (S61) K22-1446, a letter stating coersluance has been 7
GARITA CRUZ - B22-1487 0 vers rece of this kt.
Lup teleshoce call ly made to Code Enforcement Officer MAR
ved the insnector shall fzspect the property #9 verify the comptiznce
DONE AND ORDERED Apvil §, 2017, 7
ATIEST:_ py
a
_ Secretary to te Specs Na pistrs®
Code Cumepliance Special MagistrateCITY OF WEST 55
CODE COMPLIAN sg; DIVISION i
401 Clemat:. street !
West Palm Bca,. L 33401 !
‘eh, F Fax: (561) 822-1486
Phone: (561)822-1465
Feb 27, 2017 \ i
To: SCIANNO INTERNATIONAL CORP . CE17010266 Hl
312 S DIXIE HWY :
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33401-5805
Address in Violation: 255 EVERNI, MU-4
Folio Number: 7443432329¢0s 5040
You are hereby notified that the following violation exists.
relating to the City of West. Palm Beach Code of Ordinances, ~
Section(s): :
34-37-c-1-b . : :
In all other areas of the downtown master plan that are not
described in subsection (c) (1)a., any sound that exceeds 65
GBA will be deemed "unreasonably loud."
Specific details regarding each violation:
34-37-c-1-b i
Noise limitations in a specific area i
By authority of City of West Palm Beach Ordinances, the following :
corrective action must be taken by 03/29/2017: !
34-37-c-1-b |
Relocate or modify HVAC system in alley to comply
with 65 DBA limitation. i
Failure to correct the violation(s) by that date will result in
presentation of this/these matters to the City of West Palm Beach
Special Magistrate for a hearing to be held on 04/05/2017)
9:00 AM at the City‘of West Palm Beach City Hall Commission’ 1
Chambers 401 Clematis Street, West Palm Beach, Florida. ;
Ef -the-Special: Magistrate determities that any violation exists,
he/she is empowered to impose fines of up to $1000.00 per day for
each day that any violation continues to exist beyond the date
established for compliance in the Order of the Special Magistrate
Pursuant to State Statutes, such fine will become a lien upon
the real property of the owner where the violation exists or will
become a lien upon the personal property of the violator. /
: :
If the violation is corrected and then recurs or if the violation |
is not corrected by the time specified for correction by: the '
sode inspector, the case may be presented to the Special Magistrati
even if the violation has been corrected prior to the hearing.
ID#: E5427
Service:
Preview
**** CASE NUMBER: 502017CA005035XXXXMB Division: AY **** Filing # S0UZU997 E-Filed 05/04/20 1'/ 06:24:36 PM IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15" JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA CASE NO.: (City of West Palm Beach Case No.: CE17010266) SCIANNO INTERNATIONAL CORP, a Florida corporation, Appellant, vs. CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH, Code Compliance Division, Appellee. / NOTICE OF APPEAL! OF FINAL ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION NOTICE IS GIVEN that SCIANNO INTERNATIONAL CORP (“Scianno”) appeals to the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit Court the order of the City of West Palm Beach Code Compliance Sracial Manictrate Tennifor Ashton rendered and executed on Anril 4, 2017, The nature of the pecias ivaapiouuw venus 2.01 Order is a final Order that requires Scianno to relocate or modify its HVAC system to comply with ' See Article V, Section 5(b) of the Florida Constitution (“The circuit courts... shall have the power of direct review of administrative action prescribed by general law.”); section 26.012, Florida Statutes (“Circuit courts shall have jurisdiction of appeals from final administrative orders of local government code enforcement boards.”); section 162.11, Florida Statutes (“aggrieved party... may appeal a final administrative order of an enforcement board to the circuit court.”); Rule 9.030(c)(1)(C), Fla. R. App. P. (circuit courts shall review, by appeal, “administrative action if provided by general law.”); Rule 9.110(c), Fla. R. App. P. (“In an appeal to review final orders of lower administrative tribunals, the appellant shall file the notice with the clerk of the lower ee tenintuntionn tulhemal © in 2 daue af vanditian of the arder ta he re wed ani all alco file @amiiustiauve Wiouiiar witain SU Gays Or renGitien Of Lie Croer tC Oe TEVieweG, ane Sides 2aS0 2S a copy of the notice... with the clerk of the court.”); and West Palm Beach Ordinance 26-37 (“aggrieved party... may appeal a ruling or order [of] a special master to the circuit court.”). FILED: PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL, SHARON R. BOCK, CLERK, 05/04/2017 06:24:56 PMthe 65 dBA limitation, imposes fines of $250.00 per day or re-inspection assessments for non- compliance, deems the HVAC’s noise level a nuisance activity in the event of non-compliance, and authorizes the City of West Palm Beach to abate the violations at Scianno’s cost. Copies of the Order and the Notice of Violation referenced in the Order are attached hereto. Respectfully submitted this 4th day of May 2017. RICHMAN GREER, P.A. Attorneys for Appellant One Clearlake Centre, Suite 1504 250 Australian Avenue, South West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-5016 Telephone: (561) 803-3500 Facsimile: (361) 820-1608 By: /s/ Adam M. Myron Adam M. Myron Florida Bar No. 0895121 amyron@richmangreer.com Brett L. Goldblatt Tata. Dae MA NOCOIN PIOlIUa Dai INO, vos7LU bgoldblatt@richmangreer.comCade Complionce Speclal Magintente cu Eat net ain Rach rie AEST PALAE SEACH 401 Clematie Sree West Palas thea * cs eet Went Pain each, #teasdes [Sagara aaece Y an te VIOLATION ADDRESS: SS LVERNIAST MUS WEST PALM BEACH CODE SECTION VIOLATIONS, RE: Sele The Special Magitinte has Beard teicney at the Code Coretlance esting beld Pare the Speulal Magiscate herchy enters te following FINDINGS OF Tact, Concatsions rene nee ORDER: Eisprscsorracr [ANNO INTERNATIONAL CORP ts are the Cmter(a) Respensenis) in the above came. Service of pevvers was made by Us Centified Mail andlor by posting the an . 7 EF it afican 10 aay spose the bearing dase, 1 the Property referenced shove as math ab 4 Tic Ose Repeoters)) Doug, Earane lla —. spent athe ening Be NOONE appeared atthe eating oO behalf of ownert a) tesponseraty) ution, 4) 0 Tee Oenerte) Responsenats) crested bso w i FF The Owner(s) Resprrodere(s) did not enter into 8 tiptation. The Cir of West Patn Beach at shown by substantial compcters evidence that afl fats set forth ca the Notice y ScU “18 » of Victation ave true ans correct CONCLUSIONS OF LAW. “The above stated facts constiate a violation of the Section(s) listed above of the Code of Ordsaanses of te Cty of Wot Pats Beach, Phvida ORDER ae that Chaner(s) Respurdentis), shall cory the above cited violations wichia 30if Ged thea withia 45 cays or the City will Empose $250 per dry wel coeplicd ce re- 36-4 and Rewlution No. 172-11, In iy the Onder of this Speelal Mi fo permit it required, if permit is equ inspection asseramects purvaant to 36-2 Uopald reinspection aseesements shall be tevied as a Bol assessment sepertor to all otber private rights, interests lens, encumbrances, tiles aad claims wpon the property and equal ia ra snd ign wha len Heed valorem tanec. Unpaid rriaspection axscrsmcnts may be certified tothe (33 collector fer coticton penestt «fo the uniform method provided In FS, § 197.3632 or tw tbe same manaer 8 asienmeat for © n-ad valoreat service ausenaments, ; + 2-87 Upon sensing, Den: nected rvnioetify Cole Lnfescome OMe, MARGARITA CRUZ 4 seth bs st(ah Besson ice ‘ is Hachcincting ce faring to (S61) K22-1446, a letter stating coersluance has been 7 GARITA CRUZ - B22-1487 0 vers rece of this kt. Lup teleshoce call ly made to Code Enforcement Officer MAR ved the insnector shall fzspect the property #9 verify the comptiznce DONE AND ORDERED Apvil §, 2017, 7 ATIEST:_ py a _ Secretary to te Specs Na pistrs® Code Cumepliance Special MagistrateCITY OF WEST 55 CODE COMPLIAN sg; DIVISION i 401 Clemat:. street ! West Palm Bca,. L 33401 ! ‘eh, F Fax: (561) 822-1486 Phone: (561)822-1465 Feb 27, 2017 \ i To: SCIANNO INTERNATIONAL CORP . CE17010266 Hl 312 S DIXIE HWY : WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33401-5805 Address in Violation: 255 EVERNI, MU-4 Folio Number: 7443432329¢0s 5040 You are hereby notified that the following violation exists. relating to the City of West. Palm Beach Code of Ordinances, ~ Section(s): : 34-37-c-1-b . : : In all other areas of the downtown master plan that are not described in subsection (c) (1)a., any sound that exceeds 65 GBA will be deemed "unreasonably loud." Specific details regarding each violation: 34-37-c-1-b i Noise limitations in a specific area i By authority of City of West Palm Beach Ordinances, the following : corrective action must be taken by 03/29/2017: ! 34-37-c-1-b | Relocate or modify HVAC system in alley to comply with 65 DBA limitation. i Failure to correct the violation(s) by that date will result in presentation of this/these matters to the City of West Palm Beach Special Magistrate for a hearing to be held on 04/05/2017) 9:00 AM at the City‘of West Palm Beach City Hall Commission’ 1 Chambers 401 Clematis Street, West Palm Beach, Florida. ; Ef -the-Special: Magistrate determities that any violation exists, he/she is empowered to impose fines of up to $1000.00 per day for each day that any violation continues to exist beyond the date established for compliance in the Order of the Special Magistrate Pursuant to State Statutes, such fine will become a lien upon the real property of the owner where the violation exists or will become a lien upon the personal property of the violator. / : : If the violation is corrected and then recurs or if the violation | is not corrected by the time specified for correction by: the ' sode inspector, the case may be presented to the Special Magistrati even if the violation has been corrected prior to the hearing. ID#: E5427 Service: