arrow left
arrow right
  • Jane Doe vs Spark Charter School et al Other PI/PD/WD Unlimited (23)  document preview
  • Jane Doe vs Spark Charter School et al Other PI/PD/WD Unlimited (23)  document preview
  • Jane Doe vs Spark Charter School et al Other PI/PD/WD Unlimited (23)  document preview
  • Jane Doe vs Spark Charter School et al Other PI/PD/WD Unlimited (23)  document preview
						
                                

Preview

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

F>I>5F6 I 6BB6G@F6 H6 Q6G5<5I= IB H6 *FDI>5P% !6G5I= 0% !@GG6< :I>I>F6 +5Q@G5F>56< B F=P F= I> >@< GI*F=P 6?6> <@GG66Q< I H6 >@< @<5=6<< IB F=P GI>I>F6 Q@G5F>P <6>?5=S F< F ">@<66 @=Q6> H5< FS>66*6= H6H6> 6GF@<6 IB F =F*6 GHF=S6 I> F=P IH6> BI>* IB >6I>SF=5TF5I= I> 5B <@GH GI>I>F6 Q@G5F>P 6?6> >F=< F IB 5< 6O5<5=S @<5=6<< I F=P IH6> F= I> >@< GI*F=P H6 <@GG6< 6@I= 5HI@ F=P FG5I= 65=S >6A@5>6Q <@GG66Q I H6 >@<665S5=FP =F*6Q% >5G6 #5SH ">@<66< Q*5=5<>F5?6 F=Q 5=?6<*6= $I6>< !6G5I= % =>IQ@G5I= I ">@<66< $I6>< #OG6 F< IH6>5<6 >I?5Q6Q 5= H5< FS>66*6= I> *IQ56Q P :I@> I>Q6> H6 ">@<66 F5?6 F=Q 5=?6<*6= I6>< 6=@*6>F6Q @=Q6> H5< >5G6 F=Q F=P IH6> I6>< S>F=6Q @=Q6> :F5BI>=5F $>IF6 :IQ6 !6G5I= '.// F <6A I> 5< F*6=Q*6=% "H6 6=@*6>F5I= IB G6>F5= I6>< IB H6 ">@<66 @<66< S6=6>F I> 5*56Q I6><% !6G5I= .% $I6>< I &6 #O6>G5<6Q 5= H6 &6< =6>6<< IB H6 % I6 "H6 ">@<66 G5<6 H6 BII5=S FQ*5=5<>F5?6 F=Q 5=?6<*6= I6>< 5HI@ H6 I>Q6> IB F=P GI@> F< H6 ">@<66 Q66>*5=6< 5= 5< 65I= I 6 5= H6 6< 5=6>6<< IB H6 >5*F>P 6=6B5G5F>P %% I6 F=Q GI=<5<6= 5H H6 5=6= IB H5< ">@< F< 6O>6<<6Q 5= >5G6 =6% H56 H6 ">@<66 65I= 5H >6SF>Q I H6 6O6>G5<6 IB 5=?6<*6= I6>< H6>6@=Q6> 5 5< H6 5=6= F=Q 6O6GF5I= IB H6 ">@< F6> HF @<< I?6>F 5=?6<*6= <>F6SP F=Q ID6G5?6<% K I5H<F=Q5=S F=PH5=S I H6 GI=>F>P 5= H5< FS>66*6= H6 ">@<66 G5<6 F=P I6> 5= F *F==6> 5=GI=<5<6= 5H H6 >5*F>P 6=6G5F>P< >5SH I H6 6=6G5F 6=DIP*6= IB H6 >@< >I6>P 5= FGGI>QF=G6 5H H6 S6=6>F >5=G56< IB H6 F IB >@<<% !6G5I= 4% =?6<*6= $I6>< "H6 ">@<66 I 5=?6< >@< 5=Q< 5HI@ F@HI>5TF5I= IB H6 GI@> F< <6 BI>H 5= :F5BI>=5F $>IF6 :IQ6 [ .17)% "H6 ">@<66 5HI@ F@HI>5TF5I= IB H6 GI* *FP 5=?6< *Q< 5= LFM 5>6G I5SF5I=< IB H6 =56Q !F6< I> IB H6 !F6 IB :F5BI>=5F *F@>5=S =I F6> HF= ?6 P6F>< B>I* H6KQF6 IB *F5=S H6 5=?6<*6=% ( LM =56Q !F6< ">6F<@>P I=Q< >6Q66*F6 F F> ?F@6 I= H6 Q6FH IB H6 HIQ6> BI> FP*6= IB B6Q6>F 6<F6 FO6< >6SF>Q6<< IB *F@>5P QF6% L/M !6G@>556< 5<6Q I= F= 6<F5 I=Q 6OGHF=S6 5= H6 =56Q !F6< H5GH F>6 5@GHF<6Q I= <@GH 6OGHF=S6% LQM #5S56 <6G@>556< BI> H6 5=?6<*6= IB <@>@< <F6 *I=6P< F< >I?5Q6Q BI> 5= !6G5I= ')4/ IB H6 -I?6>=*6= :IQ6% L'M = 5=6>6< 5= F *I=6P *F>6 *@@F B@=Q >6S5<6>6Q @=Q6> H6 =?6<*6= :I*F=P G IB 0)/ L1 %!%:% !6G% (/ .Z 6 <6A%M I> F= 5=?6<*6= ?6H5G6 F@HI>5T6Q BI> H6 GI6G5?6 5=?6<*6= IB >@< B@=Q< @><@F= I !6G5I= 0%( IB $F> 0 IB "56 . IB H6 :IQ6 IB +6Q6>F ,6S@F5I=< H6 I>BI5I< IB H5GH F>6 5*56Q I =56Q !F6< SI?6>=*6= I5SF5I=< *F@>5=S =I F6> HF= ?6 P6F>< B>I* H6 QF6 IB 5=?6<*6= F=Q I >6@>GHF<6 FS>66*6=< B@P GIF6>F5T6Q P =56Q !F6< SI?6>=*6= I5SF5I=<% LBM =5< IB F GI**I= >@< B@=Q Q656Q 5= !6G5I= 1') IB H6 +5=F=G5F :IQ6% "H6 GI**I= >@< *Q 5*F>5P 5= 6>* O6Q 5=GI*6 I5SF5I=< F=Q *56Q I ?F@6 5=?6<*6=< F GI< @><@F= I >6S@F5I=< IB H6 F>I>5F6 >6S@FI>P F@HI>5P% IH5=S 5= H5< <6G5I= 5*5< H6 F@HI>5P IB H6 ">@<66 I <66 GI@> F@HI>5TF5I= BI> F=P 5=?6<*6= I> I *F6 IH6> 5=?6<*6=< 5H GI@> F@HI>5TF5I=% >5G6 5=6 -6=6>F $>I?5<5I=< !6G5I= % "H6 ,@6 SF5=< $6>6@556< =6<< 6>*5=F6Q P H6 6O>6<< >I?5<5I=< IB H5< FS>66*6= 6FGH >@< G>6F6Q 5= H5< FS>66*6= *5=F6 6=PI=6 P6F>< FB6> H6 Q6FH IB H6 F< <@>?5?I> IB H6 S>I@ GI*I<6Q IB H6 >5*F>P 6=6G5F>P F=Q HI<6 IB H6 Q65*F>P 6=6G5F>P 5?5=S F H6 5*6 IB H6 >5*F>P 6=6B5G5F>PK< Q6FH%  HF 5*6 H6 >I6>P H6Q 5= >@< S6Q IB F=P B@>H6> >@< F=Q 5@6Q I HI<6 6>6G65?6 I> HF?6 H6 6=6 IB H6 5=GI*6 B>I* H6 >6<6G5?6 >@<% +I> @>I<6< IB Q5<>5@5I=< @=Q6> H5< !6G5I= I=P 5 6<@*6Q HF F=P 6>6G65?6 F=P Q565I=F>P FP*6=< IB H6 5=GI*6 IB F <6F>F6 >@< 5< 6=56Q I >6G65?6 F IB H6 5=GI*6 F=Q 5 6<@*6Q HF F=P GF<< IB 6>6G65?6 Q565I=F>P FP*6=< IB 5=GI*6 5< 6=56Q I >6G65?6 F IB <@GH 5=GI*6% !6G5I= .% $>I6G5?6 :F@<6 "I H6 B@6< 6O6= 6>*56Q P F H6 5=6>6<< IB F H6 6=6G5F>56< 5= H6 ?F>5I@< >@<< F=Q >@< >I6>P <@D6G I H5< FS>66*6= 6=G@*6>6Q @=6<< <6G5GFP F@HI>5T6Q P H6 6>*< IBH5< FS>66*6=% !@GH %5=6>6<< H56 H6P >6*F5= >@< >I6>P IG6<< I> I H6 GF5*< IB F=P G>6Q5I><% !6G5I= 4% F5=F5=5=S $>I6>P 5= ">@< B I= H6 6>*5=F5I= IB F=P <6F>F6 >@< G>6F6Q @=Q6> H5< FS>66*6= F =F Q5<>5@5I= 5< I 6 *FQ6 I F 6=6G5F>P BI> HI* H6 ">@<66 HIQ< F >@< G>6F6Q @=Q6> H5< FS>66*6= <@GH Q5<>5@5I=< @< >FH6> HF= 65=S Q5<>5@6Q% !6G5I= )% -6=6>F F6>< "H6 BII5=S S6=6>F *F6>< IB GI=<>@G5I= I?5<5I=< IB H5< FS>66*6= F% :I=<>@G5I= =6<< H6 GI=6O >6A@5>6< IH6>5<6 I>Q< Q6=I5=S H6 <5=S@F> *FP 6 GI=<>@6Q F< Q6=I5=S H6 @>F F=Q I>Q< IB H6 @>F *FP 6 GI=<>@6Q F< Q6=I5=S H6 <5=S@F>% I>Q< IB I=6 S6=Q6> *FP 6 GI=<>@6Q F< Q6=I5=S F=IH6> S6=Q6> F< 5< F>I>5F6 5H5= <@GH GI=6O% % 6FQ5=S< IB >5G6< !6G5I=< F=Q $F>FS>FH< "H6 H6FQ5=S< IB >5G6< !6G5I=< F=Q $F>FS>FH< @<6Q 5H5= H5< FS>66*6= F>6 5=G@Q6Q H6 GI=?6=56=G6 F=Q >6B6>6=G6 IB H6 >6FQ6>% "H6P >6F5I= I> GI=<>@G5I= IB H5< FS>66*6=% G% I5G6< %  =I5G6< >6A@5>6Q I 6 S5?6= 5= H5< FS>66*6= 55=S P 65H6> $6>5=S =I5G6 I H6 F>P >6A@5>5=S 5 F=Q <6G@>5=S F >56= >6G65 I> F55=S =I5G6 P G6>56Q =56Q !F6< *F5 >6@>= >6G65 >6A@6<6Q I H6 F< =I= FQQ>6<< IB H6 F>P >6A@5>5=S =I5G6% "H6 6BB6G5?6 QF6 IB H6 =I5G6 56= >6G65 I> H6 QF6 IB H6 >6@>= >6G65 5B >6G65?6Q I> 5B =I H6 QF6 5 I@Q HF?6 =I>*FP 66= >6G65?6Q ?5F G6>56Q *F5 >I?5Q6Q H6>6 5< 6?5Q6=G6 IB *F55=S% L% 65?6>P +I> @>I<6< IB H5< FS>66*6= 3Q65?6>P I F=P F>P I> 65?6>P P G6>56Q =56Q !F6< *F5 >6@>= >6G65 >6A@6<6Q I H6 F>P *F5=S Q65?6>P% "H6 6BB6G5?6 QF6 IB Q65?6>P P I> H6 QF6 IB H6 >6@>= >6G65 5B >6G65?6Q I> 5B =I H6 QF6 5 I@Q HF?6 =I>*FP 66= >6G65?6Q ?5F G6>56Q *F5 >I?5Q6Q H6>6 5< 6?5Q6=G6 IB *F55=S% 6% 5GF6 !F6 F "H6 ?F5Q5P IB H5< >@< *5=6Q P >6B6>6=G6 I H6 F< IB H6 !F6 IB :F5BI>=5F% K @6<5I=< 5H >6SF>Q I H6 GI=<>@G5I= F=Q FQ*5=5<>F5I= IB H6 ?F>5I@< >@<< GI=F5=6Q 5= H5< FS>66*6= *5=6Q P >6B6>6=G6 I H6 F< IB H6 <F6 5= H5GH H6 >@< 5< H6= G@>>6=P 65=S FQ*5=5<6>6Q% B% @5GF6 >5S5=F< "H5< FS>66*6= *FP 6 6O6G@6Q 5= <6?6>F GI@=6>F>F> 6Q F Q@5GF6 I>5S5=F FS>66*6=% S% !6?6>F55P B F=P >I?5<5I= IB H5< FS>66*6= 5< Q6GF>6Q P F GI@> IB GI*66= D@>5 F=P >6F6*F5=5=S >I?5<5I=< IB H5< FS>66*6=% "H6 >6*F5=5=S >I?5<5I=< F6 F=Q H5< FS>66*6= @6Q F=Q 6=BI>G6Q F< 5B H6 5=?F5Q >I?5<5I= HFQ =6?6> 66= 5=G@Q6Q 5= H5< FS>66*6=% 6 HF?6 6O6G@6Q H5< FS>66*6= H6 QFP F=Q P6F> >< >56= FI?6%  G6>5BP HF  HF?6 >6FQ H6 BI>6SI5=S >@< FS>66*6= H6 % I6 5=I>< !66*6= ">@< QF6Q K ./7 F=Q HF 5GI>>6GP <F6< H6 6>*< F=Q GI=Q55I=< @=Q6> H5GH H6 >@< >I6>P 5< I 6 H6Q *F=FS6Q F=Q Q5<I<6Q IB P H6 ">@<66%  F>I?6 H5< >@< 5= F F>5G@F><%