arrow left
arrow right
  • Harsen House Condominium v. The Tax Commission Of The City Of New York Tax Certiorari document preview
  • Harsen House Condominium v. The Tax Commission Of The City Of New York Tax Certiorari document preview
  • Harsen House Condominium v. The Tax Commission Of The City Of New York Tax Certiorari document preview
  • Harsen House Condominium v. The Tax Commission Of The City Of New York Tax Certiorari document preview
						
                                

Preview

HD I hIVHD I I/\I juTpooDo.Id sTqa uTeluTEul puE aanaT]suT oa ulnTuTmopuoD pTEs ;o s.zoGeue;n; ]O p.IEOa at{a pozpoqane X;np qoea OAEq S-lOU/V\O p;es oqa ';vter;XaJodo.Id TEOH Oqa ;O 7(-6EE 'DOS Oa au€ns-rnd 'VT 'TTOZ 'OC aunp oa oroz '; X;np,zeoX {EDS"[] oqa JOJ }[JO;t /V\ON ;o XaTD oqa ;o sdeut xeq oqa uo poaeuG-;sap sem Xq.zodo;d T€aJ pTEs oqa qo;q;vt Xq ;oqutnu ]o{ pue :(oo;q Xq ';oo;oqa q;ed opeut pue poxouue o;o-;oq v aTnpoqDS UT pOqTLlDSap s] Xq.zodo.zd ;eo; qDTqff\ ':(.zo( /\/\oN ;o /(aTD 'ueqqeque;nt ;O qGno;og oqa u; Xq;odo;d TeoJ UTE"]JOD ]O SJOU/V\O OLIa qDeo oJe SJOqUlOU1 OSOqm ulnTuTulopuoD E S"[ {{!lS PU€ se/V\ -;ouoppod oqq 'pauopuatu.Ioa]euTo.Ioq sotu]"l |{€ av 'r :aeqa soGo;;e pue smoqs A;;n;qoadso; pouteu OAOq€ JOUO!l!lOd Oq,[ :)IHOJ\ MfiN JO fi,LVJ,S HH.I, JO,[HnOD fi[\IgHdnS fiHJ, Ol aOOJas puz'/, asoN[ OZT 6 T PT - E O PT E IzTT SS O-Ippv aOr "X D OT g s quopuods a); )IHOA IVIEN JO JtJ,ID fiH,I, JO EDNVNIJ JO HENOISSIhIhlOD fiHI PU€ )IHOA lVlEl\I.lO AJ,ID fiHI,dO l\IOISSIhIhlOD XVI HHJ, - qsu-re6e - '.z ouo TaTa od TT-OTOC' ]o saxeJ, NOI,I,LLfid s;oGu>ue;g ;o p;eog ulnTuTulopuoD osnoH UOSJ€H ;o uopeoryddv oqa ;o ;aqqe;( aq,;, ul XUOJrL MgN JO A,I,NnOD XHOJ\ /vlHN JO fiIVIS fiHJ, JO IHnOD axauans OT0 'C -TEOA 'oN x apu I 9ET 'oN dnoJO Xou;oqqq RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/16/2010 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 1 INDEX NO. 259284/2010 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 10/16/2010 -g- ",,,'-,,,O-nDOs OPOD OJL!-le-TaSrUrUlpV pue 6glz uO-nDaS 'l,LdH suoTsTAo-Id oqa.zapun opeul osoq-] ueqa ;aqqo 's-]uouloAo]clulT Aue pue pue; ;o Oqa Oqa. oqa ]o onTeA oqa sn;d, sauomoJ\o-rdulr pue uoT-le-ra-]Te JO aUamODUOUlUlOD Gu;-paoa;d fi;aqe;potutu; olep srneas oTqex€a aqa Jaa]€ S{{OJ aUOUlSSOSSe Oqa uo Gupeadde 6u-;;;q;vtp Gups;xa snoTAoJd aqa ;o ;uotussosse aq] JO ssaDxa pos€aJDuT fi-(;n;me(un uoaq seq auaulssosse oqa 'EPZ-TI uoTlDoS ':(;o( /v\aN u; ;o fi-lTD aqa ;o opoD aATaeJ-]sTuTulpv aqa pu€ 68P UO-nDOS ffidH ;apun uo-nex€a tuo-;; ;dutaxa X(epzed ;o X((n; s"[ ffi-;odo;d qoo[qns aqa a;aqp) 'L '602-1l uoTaDaS oPoD OATa€]aSrUrUlPV oq quens;nd uopon.zasuoo ]o os.znoo aqa ur Gu;ppmq e se ,,auaulssasse sso;Go;d,, pue( e OA]ODOJ Oa poITeJ ffi.zodo.zd aqa qeqa ur OA;SSODXO &uo oa quens.znd o.Ie sauaulssosse oqa (p) pue Juopdutoxo oqa Gu;z-g.zoqane ft€| 0qa pollnua s! JOlffiO oqa.zo ffi;odo;d ;eo.z pTes I{DTIlm o; uopdmoxa ue ]oo.Ioqa uopzod e ;o OA!ODOJ Oa pa;;e; Xq;oclo;d I*'! p;es a€qa UT OATSSODXO ;o ;;e ql.Io] a1'e sauaulssasse oqa (o) fSOgT UO-nDOS /v\'e'] xe,;, /(aJocloJd ;eag uT qos uopeandtuoo ;o spdqaom pue soseo]DuT JO SUOTleaTUlTl aqa qq;m fi-(dtuoo o; S|]EJ OIl|€A possasse oTqexea oql a€qa Ur OA!"BSODXO S! aUOUlSSOSSe uoTlTsue-ra ;o/pue quotussosse TenaDe oq"] (q) J (g aTnpoqDS JO );g;) IItUtl{OJ UT q"]]o] los se) ]O| X€] qD€O ]O] pogpods anTeA {|tl] aDO.I.IOD poulTeTD aqa SBO{ (v alnppqDs ]O,f,, uulnToD) "lO| xeq qDea JOJ pogpoods quautssosse ;enaoe ;€lOl Oqa B] UOTl€nTeTL.IOJLO JO aUOaXa Oqa pue V oTnpoqDS JO );g;; utunloD uT anTeA poulTeTD oqa se IJJV\OqS S"[ oaep sna'eas a(qexea A.zoqnqeqs aqq uo, SaDUe-lSUJnD.ITD fi.zeu;p;o JOptrrt |{os p(no;vt Xq;aclo;d (eo; pTes oqa qDrt{JW -IO] utns oqa pue onTeA pue ffi;aclo.zd ;eo; aqa ;o onTeA "[|tl] Oqa SpOODXa uo!lenleA {{tl] aDOJ.IOD aqa *9 passasse aqa (e) aeqa u; OA;SSODXO o.Ie sauamssoss"e pTes aq,L 'soxe-] ]o UOTlDOTIOD pue E)uT/(JLaI oqa ;o; uoa;oqa papoaoo;d ITDunoD /UTD oqa pue v aTnpoqDs ]O,J}p pue,E, stlulnTOD UT umoqs se Xq.zado;d {€OJ pTes s,;auoppod uodn squotussasse pTes oqa pauTeauoD s{{o-r auoulssasse qDTq/q ';vte( fiq pa;;nbo; se :(;o;, /V\oN ;o 7(-]TD oqa ;o IpunoD r(aTD oqa oq pOJaATTOP pue poT]!-]]oD po;edo;d o;am 7702 '0E aunp oq 010E '; /(Tnr ;eoA Oq] JOJ, l[JOA /\/\ON ;o /(aTD oqa ur uo!l€xea oq ;oa[qns ffi.zado;d ;eo; oqa {€DSg 'g ]O S{{OJ auoulssass'e aqa ']arroq pu'e uoTaeul]o]uT uodn '-zoq;.eo;aq,;, ']oa-Ioq V oInpoqDS ;o ,,fz,,PU€ nEu suu]nToD uT UJqOqS squnotne oq-] uT TeuTJ se POUl-TTJUOD aJLalV\ S-]UOUlSSOSS€ Oqa pU€ 'uoTaeDTTdde pT€s uo UOTl€UTUJJOaOP IeuTJ e po;apua; A-(np 'at,e; ;o uope.zado fiq 'uo;ss;tutuo,) xe;, aqa 'otoa 'sz Xe;( qnoqe ao uo '-;oq;ea;aq:t 'p "JoTTa-r a;epdo-;dde popuetuap pue (;n;me-(un) X;;;eGa;-(-; pue (;enboun) Xa;;enbau-; 'UOT-]€DT]TSS€{DS!U1 ' (OTLTSsaDxO) UOn€nr€A-TOAO JO uosea; Aq snoauo;.zo o]o/v\ SlUOLUSSOSS€ Oq] "]Eqa pOLUT€TD ;auoppad uopeogdde p;es ul ""fi]OA /V\ON ;o fiap aqa A;;ado-;d sauotussoss€ {{€ -]DOJ]OD pU€ /'\O!AOJ O-] /weT uT uon€x"e"] ;-o; I€OJ ;o Aq po]na!lsuoD A;np uaaq GuTAEq UOTSSTLUUlOD xe,;, pTes 'pa;oa;;oo s]uoLussoss'e qDns aA€q oq /W€T fiq popTAo-rd se :(;o;( /V\oN ;o fi;p aqq J? UOTSSTUJLUOD X€,L Oqa Oa qa€O Gupp;vt u] uopeoqdde apetu z(;np Zfi;;ado;d ;ea; pT€S ;o -;opun UO!]€nl€A pOSSOSS€ pT€s Aq poAoTJ66€ Gu;oq pue Gu-;tu-;ep ';auoppad ;vte( Aq popTAo]d se po-p;ad ;aq;;n; qDns ;o 'uopoadsu; o;-(qnd ;o; uado a;a;vt s:cooq uaan;ag *E pTES aEq-] OUJ]I Oqa 'OTOE't qDJ€l/\I PUE OTOZ 'g; fi;enuep 'V oTnpoqDS ]O,h pue ,,[,, suulnToD U! U/qOqS S€ uOTsTATC r(]]odo]d pT€s ;O ODg]O aql u; ;da:( s:(ooq aqa u"[ rre-]op uT poJoaua aq o] SUOT]€nIEA possassE oqa pasneo pU€ V DTnpaqDS U"[ paqT]Dsop A;-;ado;d (ea; p;es aqa ssosse pTp '/v\eT q]Tff\ ODu€pJODDE u; 'DDueuTd JO JOUOTSSTUlUJOD Oq] ]o uoTlDTpsT-In[ aqa ;apun fiouaGe ue ':(-;o;( /v\aN ;o fiap aqa ;O ODU€UTd ]O ;uatu;;edag aqa ;o uOTSTATQ /(]]odo]d ;vte( fiq ;o; popTAoJd olu!"l aqa Gupn(; " g' Oqa ]o S-IOSSOSS€ aqa ]o ouo - E- 'saae-]s po-]run oq-] ]o pue l[JOA /v\aN JO a-]eas aqj ;o uonna-nsuoD aqa pue '2097 uoTlDoS '],[dll Aq p?zT"'q-]"* aOU S!" SS"O{D qDTL{/W pue ' (a)gOE uoTaDoS TJ,dH Xq pa-;;nbo; anl€A ;o aGe;uqo;ad ul-ro]Tun € a€ possosse aou s'[ qDTllff\ ffi;odo;d T€OJ ;o SS"O{D aqe.zedas pu€ ue aana!lsuoD aDT-Id SO{€S sso-;6 ;o gg(z uo poseq s"[ auoulssosse Tn]/weTun ggp osoq;vt s-(oo-:ed qeqa u; ;n;;vte;un s! auaulssasse oqa 'aDr.Id SO{"OS sso;6 ;o uo poseq aas uooq SEq (oo;ed ;oa[qns aqa ;o quotussosse oqa oJoqlv1 "9T. tGequoo;ad tu;o;;un qons qe passass€ aou o.Ie |{o-I pT€s uo sauatussosse oqa onIeA oGequao.zod ut;o;;un e qe passasse oq ITeqs q-gun Gu;ssosse a€qa pue ;o qoea u; ffi;ado;d ;ea; ((e ;eqa sa;-gnba; ;vte') xe;, T(aJOdOJd TeoH aqa ;o (a)90E uonDaS -l€qa uT TnJA\eTun pue (eGo;;-; a;e :(;o,( /v\aN ;o /(aTD oqa ;.o S{|OJ auaulssasse oqa uo sauomssasse oqa JO {|€ pu"e sauoulssasse OSOqJ, '9T J- 6EE UO!LlDaS TJ,d?I.zo/pue TgS UO!LlDaS T.[dH oq fi.ze-zquoo opetu uoaq seq auoulssasse aqa 'utn;u-;tuopuoo.IO aA-ne.IadooD e s] ffi;odo.zd s,.zauoppod a;oqp) 'rzl * ,,, a;q;ss;ut.zod Xpeuopna-; qsuoo a,e,I aql U€q] a.zotu Xed oq po;(adtuoo uooq seq.zouoppod ';oo.zoqa uosea.z Ag uTea-10D Oq uoTlexe"] UlOJ] suopdtuaxa paaue;6 /(TaA!lDO]]a GuTJ\eq =as-pmo.zcl suo!leaTuJTl oqa spaaDxo aa"e.I xPl Oq"] aeqa ]Taqa JO uosea.z fiq reuonn"]rlsuoD os aa€-]SO {€OJ ,,Olqex€a,, ;o onIeA oqa paonpo.z OA€q s;uapuodsa.z sopzado-zcl socL(q uoo;vt;aq Gupeu-gtu;.zos;cp fiq aeq; s.zeaX {€DSff OAg ]SO]€{ Oqa JOJ ;o gg/;.-g paooxo qou aaeasa {€O.I aTq"exea sl] JO anleJL ;(n; oGe-IoJ\e aqa ;o Il€qs JDTJL.Ias -]qop 'aeal, {€DS!] Aue uT :(;o;. /v\oN ;o /(aTD 'sauomo-IrnbaJ JO OA;Stl{DXO Oql ]o sonuoAo-r xea ole-]sa {€O-I aeqa soprAo.ld 'ot uoTlDoS's O{D!"l.IV ':(;oc /v\aN ]o aae-]s oqa ]o uorlrn-nsuoD oqa "]u'eAolo.I uTaJaq SOUJ!I {{€ av ' ET *Oa€aSO |€O-I IeTluapTso-r Xq queatu s!" ]eLlm OUTJOP fi-(oqenbape oq S{]€J "l! a€q-] uT onGeA fipeuoprn;qsuooun pue ' quomssasse pOS€O]DUT U€ JO OD!lOU oqenbope apTJLOJd oq S{!PJ pue Xq;ado.zd |€!DJOUJtUOD SnSJOA JOJL"eJ UT SOa€UTUlTilDSTP "]! -]€qa uT reuo-nn-]!-]suooun IeT-luopTso-I JO pue ;odo;clut; '-(tq;vte;_un s] al9T UO!-lDDS.Iaa.I€qD f;.;g-;,; UOrlDaS apoD oAT-]e-IaSrUrUlpv pue Z'T9T uonDas ;aa;eqo ffip :(-zo,t /\/\oN qa;;vt A-(dutoo Oa S"[!€] ]! -]eqa uT pTOA pue aA!lDaJOp '.zodo;dtu; ';n;;vte-(u'n s] sauoulssosse Oqa OSeOJDUT oq Gupzoclznd oDTlou aqa 'uopoodsu; o;--(qnd ;o; uodo pauT€ulo.I uo'nenreA possosse JO p]ODO] T€nuue aqa ]o s"qooq oqa Ol11"[l Oqa Oa quonbasqns ;o 6u-g;np quas sem ffi;ado;d qoo[qns oq; ;o sauoulssosse aqa 6u-;seo;ou; OD-nOU e O]Oq/W l€ql uT Tn]fi€TUn pue (eGa;(; o;e s;uatussasse OqJ, ' ar "UO"[l€X€l tuo;; qdtuaxo A(epzed ;o X-(-(oqm uaoq OA€q pTnoqs fi;;ado;d aqa ;eqa u] InJ/u€Tun pue ;eGa-(-(; a;e s;uotussasse oq,[ "rr '/qET o; T(J€]-]uOD apetu a;om Aaq; ;eqa uT In]fieTun pue (eGa-(-;; a;e s;uatussosse OqJ, "OI uauoppad fiq paDnppe oq oa ODUOpTAa ;o adoos aqa Sl!UJ!{ fi;;odo;dtu-; ar qeqa pue ;ado;dtu; ' pt;me(un s! ( E ) oa/, UOrlDOS 'mdH '6 uT T€uorln]r]suooun 'V aTnpoqDs ]O ,,g,, LIUJIl{OJ UT qa]OJ aDS ]O{ X€] qD€a ]o] Otl{€A pOLUTETD Oq] S€ pa;;;oads qunome aq-] JO %9T PU€ '\I olnpaqDS JO ))fi;) ULUnTOD UT q]-IOJ -]OS S€ OIl|€A possosse {€lOl T€n"]De pq"] uoam-]oq oDua]o]]Tp oq-] o] -(enba s] -(enbaun o;e s;uotussasse pTEs qDTl-I/q O-] ]ualxa oqa pue X;;-(enbau-; qons ]uo]xa DqJ, *JODgJO OUl€S aqa fiq {{OJ OUJ€S Oq] uo SS€{D OmES ;o aqa aqa u;qa;;vt fi;odo;d (ea; ;aq;o (q) ]o/pue 'zeaA atues aqa ;o; fia;o ;o S{{OJ ]UOLUSSOSS€ aqa uo X;;ado;d ;ea; ;aqao (e) ;o SUO]]Etl{€A passass€ oq"] UEq] UOT]€nl€A a;euop;odo;d ;096;9 e ;e apetu uooq OA€q Aaqa ;eqa u; (enbaun a;e pue A;;-;enbau-; uosea-; Aq snoauo;;a a-;e s]uoLussosse pT€s Oq,[ 'g ;o p- *SaSOD qaT/6 ;aqqaGoa '_zado.;d tuaap Xetu ]]noD oqa se ]O]{OJ ;aq;;n; pue ]oqao qons JO] pue /W€{ qaTffi ODU€pJODDe uT paonpaq aq szeaX xe; ;uanbasqns ;o; uoTlTsue,Ia OATSSODxa fiue qeqa os pue 'ate( oq'fi;e;quoo aq '!',F""*'''" qou squoutssasse oqa qeqa os pue 'q;nsa.z s-luaulssosse ;o figenbo qeqa pue ';enbaun aq qou {{!A\ sauaulssasse {{"[/'\ e passass€ Oq sapzado-;d pT'es aeqa os oGequoo.zad tn;o;;un ae Tleqs -]eqa pue ';ptsa.z sauotussosse ;o ffiryenba qeqa os ';eofi atu-es {{€ {{!fi ;oqao aqa -IOJ S|{O.I OUleS Oqa uo passasse SS€|D oules aqa ;o ffi.zado;d ;ea; .zo/pue s{|o.I aules oqa uo possoss"e ffi.zado.zd TeoJ -roq-]o ]o s-]uoulssasse oqa oa oqeuopzodo;d uoTlenTeA e o; pue 'sauau]aAo]duJr pue puel.IO] SODUeaSUlnDJTD X.zeu;rp;o ;-opun p;no;vt ffi;aclo;d p;es aqa qDrI{J6 JO] tuns aqa oa poDnpa.I ||os Sl! pue aq Xetu squatussosse pTes aqa aeqa puo oqa oa UOTleDTJTSS€{DS!UJ ffi.zodo.zd IeaJ pTes ]o sauaulssosse ;enbaun pue OA;SSODXO ';n;me;un '(eGo;;-.c 'qsn[un aqa moqs oa -zauoppad ;noA o;qeuo o; aDUOpTAO ol[ea 'snoauo;;o qas oqa uo uoTssTululoD a.InoD aqa aeqa pue 'uoppad s;qa u; qa.zo; spuno-z6 xeJ, aqa uo!leuTulJoaap IeuTJ POUOTlUOUlOJOJe Oqa s]!.Iotu aqa uo aDO.I.IOD pue ]o _znoX 'EHOdEHEHN1 /WO!AO.I aJnoD aulo.Iclns oqa ;eqa sqsonba.z.zauoppad tGpnp.zo a.InoD -zoqqo Aue ;o sTqa oq qqGnos uTo,Iaq JO!|O.I Oqa.IO] Opeu1 uooq s"eq uopeop(dde snoTAa-rd oN 'pg 'l[,IO,& /v\aN ffiTD oqa uT sopzodo.zc1 ;oqqo ;o uoTleTnDleD auoulssosse IeuoTlTsu€.Ia aqa ;o /(].Iado.Id qarm auaasrsuoDur.Iauueu1 e uT poaernDr'eD (q) ;o/pue 'mer; xe,;, ;eog suoTsTJLo.Id oqa qarffi aUO-]SrSUODUr JaUU€Ul e UT poaeInDIED (e) uoaq orL'et{ ;o oq,t g,'( Aoqa qeqa uT OA";SSODXO o.Ie sauoulssosse uonrsue,Ia s,fi.zodo.zd *asa.Io-]ur ur S.IOSSODDnS ;o/pue s-zossooopo.zd s,;ouoppod p;es ;o ||€ pU€ UTaJOq paul€u.zouoppad oq uTo.Ioq ODUOJOJO?J ''C,Z oqa opnTDuT oa paulaop aq Ileqs ,,.zauoppad,, u(;o;, /v\oN ;o /(aTD aqa ;o soxeq oqa ]o a.Ieqs ;odo;d S"l!E ueq; o;out Aed oq po;;adtuoo oq {{!/w pue 'Aqo;oqa pa-zn[u; oq poJLoT]66e uaaq seq ;ouoppad 'squautssosse ;eGo(;-; pue TTTm pue '-(n;me-(un 'snoouo;;o ';enboun 'aATssoDxo pT€SOJO]e Oq-] JO uoseo; Xg ;g fffi-fiT 61d bfififi |{OJ auatussosse oqa mO]J UO"qDT]aS pue pToA pue ITnu po]eTDap oq pTnoqs auoulssosse oqa OJO]OJOqJ, 'apoD oA-r]eJ;srurmpv r(aTD :(;o( /v\ON Oq-] ]o 9TC-TT UOnDOS pue ]ol]eqD fiap :(;o( /V\oN oql ]o 1907 pue fi9T 'E9T uoTaDas ]o UOn€TOTA uT fi;odo;d s,;auoppod sGupeaq pa;pba; poTuop seq pue a;npaoo;d ;o sa;n; pue ;o 'oz' sut-;o; panss; /qsnoppdeo pue Ap;en;q;e S€q UOTSSTUlUlOD X€J, Oq,[ 'OA!SBODXO pue -;n;me-(un '-(enbaun ;uoutssasse oqa SOl[€Ul pU€ ;vte( oq fi;e-;;uoo 'SnOTDT-1d€D 'A;e;a;q;e s! ffi;odo;d ;oa[qns aqa o; uopduaxa Gu;aua;6 a;nqe;s a-(qeo;-(dde fiue ;o 6glz UOnDOS T,[dH ;o/pue V-IETz UOT]DOS T,ldH -;apun uopcltuoxa ;o ;unome a;epdo;dde pue {{Il] ]O TETUOP OqJ, "6T 'Tn]/q€Tun puE SnO-rDr]d€D 'A;e-:a;q;e S] SS€{D xe-] ]o UOT-]€UTUl]O]OP ]OJ s;uapuodsa; Xq pasn €!JOl!JD oqa.'sosserD O]OUl JO O/V\-] UOO/qaOq uoTrenr'eA possoss€ S,TOD]€d oqa ;o uoTaeDorre ;DOJJODU!E UE UT SaTnSOJ ;ao;ed s,;ouop;aad ;o uopeuG-;sap SS€{D aqa.;X;;-ado;d s,;ouoppod ;o; SS€{D a;epdo;dde aqa ;o p€o]suT vt ;o tz 'E ':z 'aa 'vz 'a SS€{D u; Gu;aq se pOT]TSS€TDSTU1 uooq seq ffi;ado;d s,]ouo-nr]ad 'gl 'uTa]aq pa;-(dde se pue ooe; sl! UO T€UOT;n; T ;suooun s"[ TeTuop qDns 'r 'gOZ-TT UO]IDOS 'opo,) aA-ne]asruru]pv o] ;uens;nd uopsanb u; ]UOUlSSOSSE Oqa IDOJ]OD o; Gupeaq e ;auoppad poTuop fi(;n;Guo;nrt uT pue -(eGa(;; a_;e s]uoLussass€ OqJ, "LT aA€u S3uODuOdSO-I l€l]a Tn]/V\eTun -g- ( t/€0] 'a ldoS so;.tdxg uo!ss!LuLuo0 Alunoo suoono u! po!J!llanO 028260911/\1[0 'oN 41oA AtfN ;o olslS 'o!lqnd /Ut?loN JOlSJOlStlO!Y1l I0StlO!lfil SpOOC ] O JOUOT S S ]LtlU1 Cftld T[.I€aON suGTS T(J€aON J O T 1[U T M fJl[if' d]$ 8 ifJ' JO Xep sTql OU1 OJO]Oq Oa U.IO/v\s ' on.; a Oq Oa ]] SOAOTTO9 ;uauodop s;oqqeut asoqq o; se pue ']oTToq pu€ UO-rlE'UlJOJUT uo poGa;;e oq o; pa;eqs uToJaqa s]oll€m Oqa oq se adoDxa 'aGpo;;vtou:( u;vto s,quauodap oq on.z; s] OUlES Oqa a€qa pue f;oo;aqq s"lualuoD oqa SffiOUl[ pU€ uo-nnod 6u;o6a-;o; aqq pea.z seq quauodop qeqq fu-go.zaq JOUOTa!lOd aqq 's;oGeue;( ]O pJ€Oa UlnTUTUlOPUOD asnoH uos.IeH ;o /(.I€aOJDOs aU€lSTSSV S] quauodap qeq,t :sXes pue sosodap 'u.zo;vts X;np 6u-;aq 'Jap[uTM o"[{so'l )I?IO;L MHN J O AJ,NnOD ( )IHOA IVIHN dO fiIVJ,S Xau;oqqg 'l[D€TTOd 'hl aJO9OH :2(E w6' 0062-067z (ara') /.TOOT AN ':(.zo( /V\oN.IOO{J qq;; 'OnuOJLV P.ITqJ, gOL .IOUOrl-nOd.zo; sfiou.zoqqq 'drlrl l[DeTTOd '9 sno;e;( T(.IulO.IDOS lu€-lsTssV ';o(:(u-; TTS OT :7(E s.zaGeuepg ;o p.zeog ulnTuTuloPEg-L3EIloH uos.IeH :]OUOTlTlOd / / 'A'N /V\oN :pOaEc o roa ':(.zo( 0[02 d]S a 0 ooo 'g6T'-r s66 '69L 'r 9LO '6T8 S{€]OJ, ooo ' s6 9OT'Z6E occ ' L9 6 T fzT EPTT 000'98 OZ'6 'ZrrrE Pss ' s9 8 T PT E1777 OO0 ' 98 OZ'6 'Z,T/€ Fss ' s9 /.TPT E TzTT 000'927 989 'TO9 6C'T '9s 9 T TzT E IzT T ooo'otz s91z ' O9T E99 ' t-c 9TPT Ef7TT OZ'6 'ZIzE Tz88 ' 89 TZTPI ETzTT 000'98 OOO '98 OZ'6 'atzc Pss ' s9 ETPT E TzTT 000'012 T99 ' 89T 9PZ' ' t,c ZT IzT EPT T OOO'OP 89fz ' O9T E99 ' t,z TT IzT EPTT 000'98 OZ'6 'ZTzE Izss ' s9 OT TzT E IzT T OOO'OTz T99 ' 89l sta ' t,z 6 OIzT E TzT T OOO 'OP 89P ' O9T E99 ' LZ 8 O T7T E PT T 000'98 OO6'SEE Iz6T ' s9 L 0 PT E PTT OOO '6E O8Z ' 99T fz99 ' 97, 9 O PT E PT T OOO'OP 962'697 E9E ' z-c 9 O f7T C 1777 OOO '98 OO6 ' 8EE P6T ' s9 pO fzT E TzTT 0OO ' E6 9E9'O/,E ETz9 ' E9 E 0127 E IzTT ($) ($) ($ ) :g puer) pu€T "q D O onT€A paulT€TD sauomoAo-Idull aO'-I TE INfihlSSESSV TTOZ' 'OC ounp 6u-gpuo pue OTOE t X(np Gupuatuutoo popod aqa JOJ V ETnGEHD S E01z[-E17[ I -I/\i IIll II II lIII I|I IllIIlIIlIIlIIIiIIIlIIlIIIIIl I|I IlI II lI[I 0062'-06P (ZTZ') LTOOT fiN ':(.zo( /V\oN JOO{J qq;; 'OnuOJLV P.lTq,[ gOL SSOJppv 'O'd '9 ODgJO -IOUO!Ll!lOd ;o; sfiou;oqqg d'-IT l[D€TTOd '9 sno.ze;( J,NfihISSESSV ffiHEdOHd T\fEH JO MfilAfi?I HOJ NOIJ,IJ,fid =quopuodso); )IHOA IVIEN dO ;tJ,ID fiHJ, dIO fiDNVNIJ JO HfiNOISSIhIhIOD fiH,l PU€ )IHO;t IVIHN dO AJ,ID fiHJ, JO NOISSIhIhIOD XV,L fiHJ, - qsuteGe - '; ouo T a T a od s.zoGeue;g ;o p.zeog tunTuTulopuoD osnoH UOS.I€H ;o uopeoryddv oqa ;o -;oqqe;( oq,;, u; XHO/L /vlfiN JO AIN()OD HHOJ\ /VIHN JO fiJ,VIS fiHI JO IHnOD gl\IHHdnS OT O T, J€OA ' ON XOpUl 9ET 'oN dno.IO Aou-zo;qg