Preview
CRTR2709-CR sea CVOOYCA MASSACHUSETTS
>
a BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT
zh Public Docket Report
Vi Iz,
8
2s. syAe;
2315CV001032 Commerce Insurance Company As Assignee of North Roofing, LLC v. PACCAR, INC.
CASE TYPE Civil FILE DATE 09/27/2023
ACTION CODE: DCF CASE TRACK: Civil Time Standards
DESCRIPTION: Money Action - District Court/BMC Filing
(c231 §§ 103-104)
CASE DISPOSITION DATE. CASE STATUS Disposed for Statistical Purposes
CASE DISPOSITION Pending STATUS DATE: 04/26/2024
CASE JUDGE: CASE SESSION:
= = = —
“ DCMTRACK ~
Tickler Description Due Date Completion Date
Service eeeee ee
| PMITS we 2 01/25/2024
ED ee ee
Dismissal NISI
een Lefor Non-,
ne Joinder
See |
een 05/24/2024
ONEEES == ----- = ----
Dismissal under Rule 41 09/26/2025
————== = <=
~ S PARTIES
Plaintiff Private Counsel 645690
Commerce Insurance Company As Assignee of North Laura A Demerle
Roofing, LLC Parenteau and O'Hara, P.C.
11 Gore Rd Parenteau and O'Hara, P.C.
Webster, MA 01570 1661 Worcester Rd
Suite 204
Framingham, MA 01701
Work Phone (508) 232-6267
Added Date: 09/27/2023 DB,
=z 2.
Plaintiff Private Counsel Ez 56
Co.
Masomi, Mostafa Laura A Demerle Se om
Parenteau and O'Hara, P.C. -, 2
ao
Parenteau and O'Hara, P.C. veFf > 4
an
1661 Worcester Rd
Suite 204 a
Framingham, MA 01701
Work Phone (508) 232-6267
Added Date: 09/27/2023
Defendant
CRW Corp
795 Marshall Avenue
Williston, VT 05495
Defendant Private Counsel 550650
CRW CORP D/B/A Wood's CRW Crop, Jeffrey Corbett McLucas
795 Marshall Avenue Manning Gross + Massenburg, LLP
Williston, VT 05495 Manning Gross + Massenburg, LLP
125 High St
Oliver Street Tower 6th Floor
Boston, MA 02110
Work Phone (617) 670-8800
Added Date: 10/26/2023
Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 1
CRTR2709-CR SPSy MASSACHUSETTS
fae
eS ‘cy BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT
{isi I Public Docket Report
izve, ie
Se
Fi ye
Defendant
Grove US, LLC
1565 Buchanan Trial
Shady Grove, PA 17256
Defendant Pro Hac Vice attorneys 561006
Hunter Services, Inc. Stephen T Armato
1463 Manheim Pike Cetrulo LLP
Lancaster, PA 17601 Cetrulo LLP
Two Seaport Lane
Boston, MA 02210
Work Phone (617) 217-5500
Added Date: 11/08/2023
Private Counsel 641837
Scott Joseph Burke
Cetrulo LLP
Cetrulo LLP
2 Seaport Lane
10th Floor
Boston, MA 02210
Work Phone (617) 217-5246
Added Date: 11/09/2023
Defendant Private Counsel 678499
PACCAR, INC. David Abraham Rich
777 106TH Avenue NE Chartwell Law
Bellevue, WA 98004 Chartwell Law
205 Newbury St
Suite 101
Framingham, MA 01701
Work Phone (205) 569-7445
Added Date: 12/21/2023
Private Counsel 703189
Megan K Baker
Chartwell Law
Chartwell Law
205 Newbury St
Suite 101
Framingham, MA 01701
Work Phone (617) 474-6064
Added Date: 02/02/2024
Defendant Private Counsel 678499
Peterbilt Motors Company David Abraham Rich
1700 Woodbrook Street Chartwell Law
Penton, TX 76205 Chartwell Law
205 Newbury St
Suite 101
Framingham, MA 01701
Work Phone (205) 569-7445
Added Date: 12/21/2023
Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 2
CRTR2709-CR MASSACHUSETTS
ae BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT
ah Xe Public Docket Report
i
i,
is
es,
ee
Shy 99
Defendant
Peterbilt, Hunter Keystone
480 Pittsburgh Road
Butler, PA 16002
Defendant
The Manitowoc Company Inc.
One Park Plaza
11270 West Park Place
Suite 1000
Milwaukee, WI 53224
Defendant Attorney 640970
The Manitowoc Company, Inc /Grove US, LLC/National Grace Victoria Bacon Garcia
Crane Morrison Mahoney LLP
One Park Plaza Morrison Mahoney LLP
11270 West Park Place 250 Summer St
Suite 1000 Boston, MA 02210
Milwaukee, WI 53224 Work Phone (617) 439-7500
Added Date: 11/29/2023
—— _ _ _ = =o
EVENTS™:
Date Session Event Result Resulting Judge
01/19/2024
nen Virtual Court
ene Session
ee Motion Hearing
ee(CV) Reschedule of Hearing oe Brophy
wo eeene
ee ee eee eee
02/02/2024 Virtual Court Session Motion Hearing (CV) Held - under Farrell
|. --- e e e --- - -- -- -- - advisement
SSIS, ee
03/01/2024 2S Civil Session Status Review (CV)
MADPIDL - =. - SS Review Completedee Farrell
04/05/2024 Virtual Court Session Motion Hearing (CV) Brought Forward Farrell
Held Farrell
ae nee eee eee 8 ee ee ee ree ee Fee
04/19/2024 © Virtual
PIER SL Court
PILESSession Motion
SE Hearing
SE (CV)
NY Held Farrell
oans0ne Virtual Court Session Case Management Conference Event Cancelled Farrell
= = =
ue, ao FINANCIAL SUMMARY- we
Fees/Fines/Costs/Charge Assessed Paid Dismissed Balance
Total 220.00 220.00 0.00 0.00
Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 3
CRTR2709-CR MASSACHUSETTS
oS e © BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT
Public Docket Report
Vo:
=
he
Ces,SS oS)
e
— —
INFO NAL ENTRIES
Date Ref Description Judge
09/27/2023 Appearance filed
On this date Laura A Demerle, Esq. added as Private Counsel for Plaintiff
Commerce
------------------- Insurance Company
ommerce insurance Com any one ee ee eee eee eee ee
09/27/2023
DME MENE? LE Complaint
MONMIPIGIE filed...
NIST LINA.
© WA eee ao 2-2-8 eeeee eee eee
09/27/2023 Statement of damages filed by Plaintiff alleging contract action for damages
------------------- of
OF more
more than
Man $25000. (Dist./Mun.Cts.Supp.R.Civ.P.
y2ov_". ADISLMUN. OTS. OU} | MGW 102A)
Wer) ee -
09/27/2023 Appearance filed
On this date Laura A Demerle, Esq. added as Private Counsel for Plaintiff
------------------- Mostafa
Mo Masomi. woe nee on ee ee ene
09/27/2023 Jury trial! claim on all issues endorsed upon pleading by Commerce Insurance
Company As Assignee of North Roofing, LLC, Mostafa Masomi (G.L. c.231
§103; Mass.R.Civ.P.
oo eee eee nee --- =e S19; MASS.IR-UIV.E. 38(b)).
90D). = =
09/27/2023
SMEIIENES 8 EXHIBIT
I ~ oo eee ee oo ee eee eee eee
10/18/2023 Return of service on complaint and summons to Peterbilt Motors Company:
Officer service SERVED to party's agent (Mass.R.Civ.P. 4(f)).
~2---------------- Served on 10/6/23 _ ~-- eee ee eee - - oo oe eee eee eee === --
10/18/2023 Return of service on complaint and summons to PACCAR, INC.: Officer
service SERVED to party's agent (Mass.R.Civ.P. 4(f)).
ween eee een nw Served
BEMEG onON 10/6/23
NGS ee eee eee ene ee eee ee ee eee
10/24/2023 Return of service on complaint and summons to CRW CORP D/B/A Wood's
CRW Crop,: Officer service SERVED to party's agent (Mass.R.Civ.P. 4(f)).
- 2-22-25 Served
Seed on 10/10/23
ONTUINUee ee eee
10/25/2023
ce ee ne Appearance
ee eeefiled nn on ee eee ee ee ee ee ee ===
10/26/2023 5 Appearance filed
On this date Jeffrey Corbett McLucas, Esq. added as Private Counsel for
.
ooo ee eee eee. . Defendant
BETENdANT CRW CRW CORP
GORE D/B/A Wood's CRW
IBID MNOO'S UNV Crop,
LTOP, _ oo eee eee eee eee e
10/27/2023
IMAMENES 0. Answer
EMISINSE filed
KIS with claim
aM) ofOF Jury
Ty Trial.
es ween eee e eee ~ ooo ee ae
10/27/2023 Return of service on complaint and summons to Hunter Services, Inc.:
Long-arm service SERVED (Mass.R.Civ.P. 4(f)).
Certified
Sentitied Mail
we 2-22 -e--------- Mat on
on 10/16/23
TOM Gles ao 2---------e - So eee eee =e
10/30/2023 Return of service on complaint and summons to The Manitowoc Company,
Inc /Grove US, LLC/National Crane: Certified mail returned DELIVERED:
signed receipt (Mass.R.Civ.P. 4(f)).
woe eee ee en eee Served
BOWED on 10/17/23
ON TIN eo = = == - =~
I11/08/2023
TMOENES LO Appearance
SIR RISE GRINS filed
NS ee eee oe eee eee eee =
11/08/2023
MMONENES oF ___ Appearance
EXPPSET AS filed
ee ee eee eee ane enn eee
11/08/2023
BM RIENES 8 LENS Answer filed.as
eee to eee
Peterbuild
eenMotors
ene -n 2 anne eee eee eee 2 ee a= eee
11/08/2023 Appearance filed
On this date Stephen T Armato, Esq. added as Pro Hac Vice attorneys for
Defendant Hunter Services, Inc.
Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 4
CRTR2709-CR mm MASSACHUSETTS
>e\ BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT
YY. a
ie Public Docket Report
i,ei &
wD
ES
11/09/2023 10 Appearance filed
On this date Scott Joseph Burke, Esq. added as Private Counsel for
wooo Defendant Hunter
eee eee ene Herendant unter Services,
Services, Inc.
Ine. ee ~e eee
11/20/2023 1 Motion to Dismiss filed by The Manitowoc Company, Inc /Grove US,
-----2------------- LLC/National
bY /Natlonal Crane-Defendant.
Crane-Derendam. eee eee
11/22/2023 Event Scheduled
Event: Motion Hearing (CV)
Date: 01/19/2024 Time: 09:00 AM
-------- +5. 2 - ~~ Result: Reschedule
FReSuIE Rese 2dule oFof Hearing
hearin ~ 22 2-2 oo ee eee ene
11/22/2023 Form generated:
Notice of Next Event(Event Notice) CV
~ oe 8 n eeenee - Sent
SOM On:
OM _11/22/2023
Melee 14:31:56
WAT = -- = ---------------
11/29/2023 12 Appearance filed
-- ~--- ~~~ Attorney:
flores y: Garcia,
Garcia, Esq.,
Esq., Grace
Grace Victoria
Victoria Bacon
bacon. =
4 412912023 13 Appearance filed
On this date Grace Victoria Bacon Garcia, Esq. added for Defendant The
~------------------ Manitowoc
Manttowoe Company,
Com an Inc /Grove
sroveUS,
Us, LLC/National
LLYINal 1 Crane
Grane ~--------------------------
12/20/2023
SLEMENED I14 Answer
ENISINSE filed.
MSPeterbiltee MOTORS Po ee eee ee eee eee
12/20/2023
cee 15
eee nen Answer filed. eee
eee PACCAR_ INC
eaeANSWERS oo eee eee eee
12/21/2023 16 Appearance filed
On this date David Abraham Rich, Esq. added as Private Counsel for
wa --------- ~~~. Defendant
Berengant Peterbilt
reterpit Motors
Viotors Company
Lom pany ee eee
1212112023 17 Appearance filed
On this date David Abraham Rich, Esq. added as Private Counsel for
wenn eee Defendant PACCAR, ING.
- MONENGANEFACOAIR INC. eee eee eee ee
01/16/2024 18 Motion to CONTINUE filed by Commerce Insurance CompanyAs Assignee of
North Roofing, LLC, Mostafa Masomi, PACCAR, INC., Peterbilt Motors
Company, Hunter Services, Inc., The Manitowoc Company, Inc /Grove US,
LLC/National Crane, CRW CORP D/B/A Wood's CRW Crop, and assented to
by other party(ies).
LINA
~------------------ HMA ----- ~--------- -- 2 - ee
01/17/2024 Motion for continuanceSo(Mass.R.Civ.P.40[b])
VEEL ENEN ES ELIE eee eee of
en Motion
nnn to Dismiss
en allowed .a eee
nee Brophy
ete ee
01/17/2024 Event Scheduled
Event: Motion Hearing (CV)
Date: 02/02/2024 Time: 09:00 AM
Result:
Result Held
meld =- under
~------------------ under advisement
advisement a-e a
01/17/2024 Form generated:
Notice of Next Event(Event Notice) CV
Sent On: 01/17/2024 09:06:32
Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 5
CRTR2709-CR
oN
MASSACHUSETTS
Se
‘
i BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT
zh Public Docket Report
12
VE. iS)
ae
$$ ——— ——— ———-_-———
01/30/2024 19 Opposition to Motion filed
Plaintiff , Commerce Insurance Company's Opposition to Defendants, The
Manitowoc Company, Inc./ Grove Us, LLC/ National Crane's Motion to
Dismiss.
ween eee eee AR
AB eee Wo oe eee eee eee eee
02/02/2024
TOMAIOSET 2 20SE 8 Appearance
TEES filed ~----------------------
ee e eee
02/02/2024 21 Appearance filed
On this date Megan K Baker, Esq. added as Private Counsel for Defendant
------------------ - 2PACCAR,
FAGGA INC. _ - oe n-ne e ee ee ee ee eee eee
02/02/2024 Event Resulted: Motion Hearing (CV) scheduled on: Farrell
02/02/2024 09:00 AM
Has been: Held - under advisement
wee eee ee eee ~~ - Hon.
FON, William
Vitam GSG Farrell,
Farrell, Presiding
Presidl Ng __ ~-------------------------------------------
02/08/2024 Taken under advisement Farrell
~ oo enn eee Judge: Farrell, Hon. William
~~ SUE @_Farren, ron. Vvillam ee G
02/06/2024 Event Scheduled
Event: Status Review (CV)
Date: 03/01/2024 Time: 07:00 AM
Result:
Result. Review
~------------------ Review Completed
Completed ee wo eee nee ee eee
03/01/2024 Event Resultes Status Review (CV) scheduled on: Farrell
03/01/2024 07:00 AM
Has been: Review Completed
we eee ee eee Hon.
ON, William
lam GG Farrell,
~~~ Farrell, Presiding
Frestalr We eee 22 --- =
03/08/2024 22
Motion to Add Facts, Correct Damages, Correct Party Names and Roles filed
by Commerce Insurance Company As Assignee of North Roofing, LLC
subject to opposition procedure (Joint Standing Order 1-04 or Dist. Ct.
ween eee eee ------ Standing
Sanain Order 1-98).7 eae e ee ee eee 2 ee
03/18/2024 23 Opposition filed by The Manitowoc Company, Inc /Grove US, LLC/National
Crane to Motion Defendant Crane's Opposition to plaintiff's motion for leave
to file an amended complaint. that was filed on 03/19/2024 subject to
opposition procedure (Joint Standing Order 1-04 or District Court Standing
-------------~~~ Order 1-98).
MIGORT99). woe eee ne ee eee ee ee = 5 +
03/20/2024 Event Scheduled
Event: Motion Hearing (CV)
Date: 04/05/2024 Time: 09:00 AM
~~ - Result:
---------------- Held
RESUME TENG ee wane ee 2-3-2 -- 2-2-2
- = --
03/20/2024 Form generated:
Notice of Next Event(Event Notice) CV
we ee eee - -- Sent On: 03/20/2024
DEM OM Voleeyes 08:29:57
MOeI IE ee eee ween eee === eee
03/25/2024 Event Resulted: Motion Hearing (CV) scheduled on: Farrell
04/05/2024 09:00 AM
Has been: Held
Hon. William G Farrell, Presiding
Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 6
CRTR2709-CR e7e MASSACHUSETTS
oY,
BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT
2 zh Public Docket Report
i
iz}
We?
&
oo ———_---- ———__----——_—
03/25/2024 Motion to dismiss (Mass.R.Civ.P. 12[b]) denied. Farrell
wee eee eee ee 8 Judge:je. Farrell,
Sue Farrell, Hon.
Fon. William
Wiliam GS one en eee eee eee eee
03/25/2024 24 Order: Order on the Defendant's Rule 12 B 6 motion to dismiss; parties Farrell
Notified.
~~~ Judge:
--------------- Farrell, Hon.
SUE e_Parrel, Mon. William G
VWillam eee
03/25/2024 Event Scheduled
Event: Case Management Conference
Date: 04/29/2024 Time: 02:00 PM
-- Result: Event CancelledGe -- wee oe
ice afil oye -s OO as --
03/27/2024 Event Scheduled
Event: Motion Hearing (CV)
Date: 04/19/2024 Time: 09:00 AM
Result:
esulk Held
~------------------Mela ee ae _- oo ee eee eee ee eee eee eee
03/27/2024 Form generated:
Notice of Next Event(Event Notice) CV
ene ene ene ee - Sent
BOM On: Vole
03/27/2024
le0eG 12:05:28
NEN CO ee = --- = -- --
04/01/2024 Motion for order admitting Atty Richard C Moreno Pro Hac Vice allowed Farrell
Attorney Richard C Moreno counsel for Defendant's PACCR, Inc and
Peterbilt Motors Company.
Murchison & Cummings , LLP
801 Grand Ave 9th Floor
LOs
wees ee eee --------- Angeles
EYSAN eles California
California 90017
YUN Ee woe eee eee
04/01/2024 Form generated:
Notice of Next Event(Event Notice) CV
wwe enn Sent
BEM On:
OM 04/01/2024
CAINE ee 08:56:58
MOO8 eee one ene ee eee ee
04/03/2024 Form generated:
Notice of Next Event(Event Notice) CV
ooo - == Sent
- BEM MMOn: 04/03/2024
UANVOI NEG 11:29:25
NN Ee9 - ween ee wee a
04/03/2024
eee et 26 Opposition fileda! filed. _
£0 AREAS aoe oe ------- we eee eee -- ee-e -
04/19/2024 Event Resulted: Motion Hearing (CV) scheduled on: Farrell
04/19/2024 09:00 AM
Has been: Held
wee eee ------ ~~~ - Hon.
ON, William
Mllam &G Farret,
Farrell, Presiding
rresialt 1 oo 2 ee 2 ee - e =
04/25/2024 Motion to amend complaint (Mass.R.Civ.P. 4[g] & 15) allowed . Farrell
- Judge: Farrell,
en, Hon.
Fi William
mam G ~ oo ene eee ne oon
ee eee nee eee eee eee
04/25/2024 Motion to dismiss (Mass.R.Civ.P. 12[b]) for exceeding the amount in Farrell
controversy of the District Court allowed .
Judge: Farrell, Hon. William G
Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 7
CRTR2709-CR aang MASSACHUSETTS
oo BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT
a Public Docket Report
Bi
&
oS
—— ——----- ——_
04/26/2024 Judgment Entered:: Judgment of Dismissal , upon motion for dismissal
Presiding: Hon. William G Farrell
Judgment For: PACCAR, INC.
Peterbilt Motors Company
Hunter Services, Inc.
The Manitowoc Company, Inc /Grove US, LLC/National
Crane
CRW CORP
Hunter Keystone Peterbilt
The Manitowoc Company Inc.
Grove US, LLC
CRW Corp
Judgment Against: Commerce Insurance Company
Mostafa Masomi
Terms of Judgment: Jdgmnt Date: 04/26/2024
Further Orders: . Dismissed for exceeding the amount in controversy of the
District
Piswmiet Court.
------------------- Gout, oo eeeeee --
04/26/2024 Event Resulted: Case Management Conference scheduled on: Farrell
04/29/2024 02:00 PM
Has been: Event Cancelled For the following reason: Brought forward
Hon. William G Farrell, Presiding
Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 8
Preview
CRTR2709-CR sea CVOOYCA MASSACHUSETTS > a BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT zh Public Docket Report Vi Iz, 8 2s. syAe; 2315CV001032 Commerce Insurance Company As Assignee of North Roofing, LLC v. PACCAR, INC. CASE TYPE Civil FILE DATE 09/27/2023 ACTION CODE: DCF CASE TRACK: Civil Time Standards DESCRIPTION: Money Action - District Court/BMC Filing (c231 §§ 103-104) CASE DISPOSITION DATE. CASE STATUS Disposed for Statistical Purposes CASE DISPOSITION Pending STATUS DATE: 04/26/2024 CASE JUDGE: CASE SESSION: = = = — “ DCMTRACK ~ Tickler Description Due Date Completion Date Service eeeee ee | PMITS we 2 01/25/2024 ED ee ee Dismissal NISI een Lefor Non-, ne Joinder See | een 05/24/2024 ONEEES == ----- = ---- Dismissal under Rule 41 09/26/2025 ————== = <= ~ S PARTIES Plaintiff Private Counsel 645690 Commerce Insurance Company As Assignee of North Laura A Demerle Roofing, LLC Parenteau and O'Hara, P.C. 11 Gore Rd Parenteau and O'Hara, P.C. Webster, MA 01570 1661 Worcester Rd Suite 204 Framingham, MA 01701 Work Phone (508) 232-6267 Added Date: 09/27/2023 DB, =z 2. Plaintiff Private Counsel Ez 56 Co. Masomi, Mostafa Laura A Demerle Se om Parenteau and O'Hara, P.C. -, 2 ao Parenteau and O'Hara, P.C. veFf > 4 an 1661 Worcester Rd Suite 204 a Framingham, MA 01701 Work Phone (508) 232-6267 Added Date: 09/27/2023 Defendant CRW Corp 795 Marshall Avenue Williston, VT 05495 Defendant Private Counsel 550650 CRW CORP D/B/A Wood's CRW Crop, Jeffrey Corbett McLucas 795 Marshall Avenue Manning Gross + Massenburg, LLP Williston, VT 05495 Manning Gross + Massenburg, LLP 125 High St Oliver Street Tower 6th Floor Boston, MA 02110 Work Phone (617) 670-8800 Added Date: 10/26/2023 Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 1 CRTR2709-CR SPSy MASSACHUSETTS fae eS ‘cy BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT {isi I Public Docket Report izve, ie Se Fi ye Defendant Grove US, LLC 1565 Buchanan Trial Shady Grove, PA 17256 Defendant Pro Hac Vice attorneys 561006 Hunter Services, Inc. Stephen T Armato 1463 Manheim Pike Cetrulo LLP Lancaster, PA 17601 Cetrulo LLP Two Seaport Lane Boston, MA 02210 Work Phone (617) 217-5500 Added Date: 11/08/2023 Private Counsel 641837 Scott Joseph Burke Cetrulo LLP Cetrulo LLP 2 Seaport Lane 10th Floor Boston, MA 02210 Work Phone (617) 217-5246 Added Date: 11/09/2023 Defendant Private Counsel 678499 PACCAR, INC. David Abraham Rich 777 106TH Avenue NE Chartwell Law Bellevue, WA 98004 Chartwell Law 205 Newbury St Suite 101 Framingham, MA 01701 Work Phone (205) 569-7445 Added Date: 12/21/2023 Private Counsel 703189 Megan K Baker Chartwell Law Chartwell Law 205 Newbury St Suite 101 Framingham, MA 01701 Work Phone (617) 474-6064 Added Date: 02/02/2024 Defendant Private Counsel 678499 Peterbilt Motors Company David Abraham Rich 1700 Woodbrook Street Chartwell Law Penton, TX 76205 Chartwell Law 205 Newbury St Suite 101 Framingham, MA 01701 Work Phone (205) 569-7445 Added Date: 12/21/2023 Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 2 CRTR2709-CR MASSACHUSETTS ae BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT ah Xe Public Docket Report i i, is es, ee Shy 99 Defendant Peterbilt, Hunter Keystone 480 Pittsburgh Road Butler, PA 16002 Defendant The Manitowoc Company Inc. One Park Plaza 11270 West Park Place Suite 1000 Milwaukee, WI 53224 Defendant Attorney 640970 The Manitowoc Company, Inc /Grove US, LLC/National Grace Victoria Bacon Garcia Crane Morrison Mahoney LLP One Park Plaza Morrison Mahoney LLP 11270 West Park Place 250 Summer St Suite 1000 Boston, MA 02210 Milwaukee, WI 53224 Work Phone (617) 439-7500 Added Date: 11/29/2023 —— _ _ _ = =o EVENTS™: Date Session Event Result Resulting Judge 01/19/2024 nen Virtual Court ene Session ee Motion Hearing ee(CV) Reschedule of Hearing oe Brophy wo eeene ee ee eee eee 02/02/2024 Virtual Court Session Motion Hearing (CV) Held - under Farrell |. --- e e e --- - -- -- -- - advisement SSIS, ee 03/01/2024 2S Civil Session Status Review (CV) MADPIDL - =. - SS Review Completedee Farrell 04/05/2024 Virtual Court Session Motion Hearing (CV) Brought Forward Farrell Held Farrell ae nee eee eee 8 ee ee ee ree ee Fee 04/19/2024 © Virtual PIER SL Court PILESSession Motion SE Hearing SE (CV) NY Held Farrell oans0ne Virtual Court Session Case Management Conference Event Cancelled Farrell = = = ue, ao FINANCIAL SUMMARY- we Fees/Fines/Costs/Charge Assessed Paid Dismissed Balance Total 220.00 220.00 0.00 0.00 Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 3 CRTR2709-CR MASSACHUSETTS oS e © BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT Public Docket Report Vo: = he Ces,SS oS) e — — INFO NAL ENTRIES Date Ref Description Judge 09/27/2023 Appearance filed On this date Laura A Demerle, Esq. added as Private Counsel for Plaintiff Commerce ------------------- Insurance Company ommerce insurance Com any one ee ee eee eee eee ee 09/27/2023 DME MENE? LE Complaint MONMIPIGIE filed... NIST LINA. © WA eee ao 2-2-8 eeeee eee eee 09/27/2023 Statement of damages filed by Plaintiff alleging contract action for damages ------------------- of OF more more than Man $25000. (Dist./Mun.Cts.Supp.R.Civ.P. y2ov_". ADISLMUN. OTS. OU} | MGW 102A) Wer) ee - 09/27/2023 Appearance filed On this date Laura A Demerle, Esq. added as Private Counsel for Plaintiff ------------------- Mostafa Mo Masomi. woe nee on ee ee ene 09/27/2023 Jury trial! claim on all issues endorsed upon pleading by Commerce Insurance Company As Assignee of North Roofing, LLC, Mostafa Masomi (G.L. c.231 §103; Mass.R.Civ.P. oo eee eee nee --- =e S19; MASS.IR-UIV.E. 38(b)). 90D). = = 09/27/2023 SMEIIENES 8 EXHIBIT I ~ oo eee ee oo ee eee eee eee 10/18/2023 Return of service on complaint and summons to Peterbilt Motors Company: Officer service SERVED to party's agent (Mass.R.Civ.P. 4(f)). ~2---------------- Served on 10/6/23 _ ~-- eee ee eee - - oo oe eee eee eee === -- 10/18/2023 Return of service on complaint and summons to PACCAR, INC.: Officer service SERVED to party's agent (Mass.R.Civ.P. 4(f)). ween eee een nw Served BEMEG onON 10/6/23 NGS ee eee eee ene ee eee ee ee eee 10/24/2023 Return of service on complaint and summons to CRW CORP D/B/A Wood's CRW Crop,: Officer service SERVED to party's agent (Mass.R.Civ.P. 4(f)). - 2-22-25 Served Seed on 10/10/23 ONTUINUee ee eee 10/25/2023 ce ee ne Appearance ee eeefiled nn on ee eee ee ee ee ee ee === 10/26/2023 5 Appearance filed On this date Jeffrey Corbett McLucas, Esq. added as Private Counsel for . ooo ee eee eee. . Defendant BETENdANT CRW CRW CORP GORE D/B/A Wood's CRW IBID MNOO'S UNV Crop, LTOP, _ oo eee eee eee eee e 10/27/2023 IMAMENES 0. Answer EMISINSE filed KIS with claim aM) ofOF Jury Ty Trial. es ween eee e eee ~ ooo ee ae 10/27/2023 Return of service on complaint and summons to Hunter Services, Inc.: Long-arm service SERVED (Mass.R.Civ.P. 4(f)). Certified Sentitied Mail we 2-22 -e--------- Mat on on 10/16/23 TOM Gles ao 2---------e - So eee eee =e 10/30/2023 Return of service on complaint and summons to The Manitowoc Company, Inc /Grove US, LLC/National Crane: Certified mail returned DELIVERED: signed receipt (Mass.R.Civ.P. 4(f)). woe eee ee en eee Served BOWED on 10/17/23 ON TIN eo = = == - =~ I11/08/2023 TMOENES LO Appearance SIR RISE GRINS filed NS ee eee oe eee eee eee = 11/08/2023 MMONENES oF ___ Appearance EXPPSET AS filed ee ee eee eee ane enn eee 11/08/2023 BM RIENES 8 LENS Answer filed.as eee to eee Peterbuild eenMotors ene -n 2 anne eee eee eee 2 ee a= eee 11/08/2023 Appearance filed On this date Stephen T Armato, Esq. added as Pro Hac Vice attorneys for Defendant Hunter Services, Inc. Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 4 CRTR2709-CR mm MASSACHUSETTS >e\ BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT YY. a ie Public Docket Report i,ei & wD ES 11/09/2023 10 Appearance filed On this date Scott Joseph Burke, Esq. added as Private Counsel for wooo Defendant Hunter eee eee ene Herendant unter Services, Services, Inc. Ine. ee ~e eee 11/20/2023 1 Motion to Dismiss filed by The Manitowoc Company, Inc /Grove US, -----2------------- LLC/National bY /Natlonal Crane-Defendant. Crane-Derendam. eee eee 11/22/2023 Event Scheduled Event: Motion Hearing (CV) Date: 01/19/2024 Time: 09:00 AM -------- +5. 2 - ~~ Result: Reschedule FReSuIE Rese 2dule oFof Hearing hearin ~ 22 2-2 oo ee eee ene 11/22/2023 Form generated: Notice of Next Event(Event Notice) CV ~ oe 8 n eeenee - Sent SOM On: OM _11/22/2023 Melee 14:31:56 WAT = -- = --------------- 11/29/2023 12 Appearance filed -- ~--- ~~~ Attorney: flores y: Garcia, Garcia, Esq., Esq., Grace Grace Victoria Victoria Bacon bacon. = 4 412912023 13 Appearance filed On this date Grace Victoria Bacon Garcia, Esq. added for Defendant The ~------------------ Manitowoc Manttowoe Company, Com an Inc /Grove sroveUS, Us, LLC/National LLYINal 1 Crane Grane ~-------------------------- 12/20/2023 SLEMENED I14 Answer ENISINSE filed. MSPeterbiltee MOTORS Po ee eee ee eee eee 12/20/2023 cee 15 eee nen Answer filed. eee eee PACCAR_ INC eaeANSWERS oo eee eee eee 12/21/2023 16 Appearance filed On this date David Abraham Rich, Esq. added as Private Counsel for wa --------- ~~~. Defendant Berengant Peterbilt reterpit Motors Viotors Company Lom pany ee eee 1212112023 17 Appearance filed On this date David Abraham Rich, Esq. added as Private Counsel for wenn eee Defendant PACCAR, ING. - MONENGANEFACOAIR INC. eee eee eee ee 01/16/2024 18 Motion to CONTINUE filed by Commerce Insurance CompanyAs Assignee of North Roofing, LLC, Mostafa Masomi, PACCAR, INC., Peterbilt Motors Company, Hunter Services, Inc., The Manitowoc Company, Inc /Grove US, LLC/National Crane, CRW CORP D/B/A Wood's CRW Crop, and assented to by other party(ies). LINA ~------------------ HMA ----- ~--------- -- 2 - ee 01/17/2024 Motion for continuanceSo(Mass.R.Civ.P.40[b]) VEEL ENEN ES ELIE eee eee of en Motion nnn to Dismiss en allowed .a eee nee Brophy ete ee 01/17/2024 Event Scheduled Event: Motion Hearing (CV) Date: 02/02/2024 Time: 09:00 AM Result: Result Held meld =- under ~------------------ under advisement advisement a-e a 01/17/2024 Form generated: Notice of Next Event(Event Notice) CV Sent On: 01/17/2024 09:06:32 Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 5 CRTR2709-CR oN MASSACHUSETTS Se ‘ i BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT zh Public Docket Report 12 VE. iS) ae $$ ——— ——— ———-_-——— 01/30/2024 19 Opposition to Motion filed Plaintiff , Commerce Insurance Company's Opposition to Defendants, The Manitowoc Company, Inc./ Grove Us, LLC/ National Crane's Motion to Dismiss. ween eee eee AR AB eee Wo oe eee eee eee eee 02/02/2024 TOMAIOSET 2 20SE 8 Appearance TEES filed ~---------------------- ee e eee 02/02/2024 21 Appearance filed On this date Megan K Baker, Esq. added as Private Counsel for Defendant ------------------ - 2PACCAR, FAGGA INC. _ - oe n-ne e ee ee ee ee eee eee 02/02/2024 Event Resulted: Motion Hearing (CV) scheduled on: Farrell 02/02/2024 09:00 AM Has been: Held - under advisement wee eee ee eee ~~ - Hon. FON, William Vitam GSG Farrell, Farrell, Presiding Presidl Ng __ ~------------------------------------------- 02/08/2024 Taken under advisement Farrell ~ oo enn eee Judge: Farrell, Hon. William ~~ SUE @_Farren, ron. Vvillam ee G 02/06/2024 Event Scheduled Event: Status Review (CV) Date: 03/01/2024 Time: 07:00 AM Result: Result. Review ~------------------ Review Completed Completed ee wo eee nee ee eee 03/01/2024 Event Resultes Status Review (CV) scheduled on: Farrell 03/01/2024 07:00 AM Has been: Review Completed we eee ee eee Hon. ON, William lam GG Farrell, ~~~ Farrell, Presiding Frestalr We eee 22 --- = 03/08/2024 22 Motion to Add Facts, Correct Damages, Correct Party Names and Roles filed by Commerce Insurance Company As Assignee of North Roofing, LLC subject to opposition procedure (Joint Standing Order 1-04 or Dist. Ct. ween eee eee ------ Standing Sanain Order 1-98).7 eae e ee ee eee 2 ee 03/18/2024 23 Opposition filed by The Manitowoc Company, Inc /Grove US, LLC/National Crane to Motion Defendant Crane's Opposition to plaintiff's motion for leave to file an amended complaint. that was filed on 03/19/2024 subject to opposition procedure (Joint Standing Order 1-04 or District Court Standing -------------~~~ Order 1-98). MIGORT99). woe eee ne ee eee ee ee = 5 + 03/20/2024 Event Scheduled Event: Motion Hearing (CV) Date: 04/05/2024 Time: 09:00 AM ~~ - Result: ---------------- Held RESUME TENG ee wane ee 2-3-2 -- 2-2-2 - = -- 03/20/2024 Form generated: Notice of Next Event(Event Notice) CV we ee eee - -- Sent On: 03/20/2024 DEM OM Voleeyes 08:29:57 MOeI IE ee eee ween eee === eee 03/25/2024 Event Resulted: Motion Hearing (CV) scheduled on: Farrell 04/05/2024 09:00 AM Has been: Held Hon. William G Farrell, Presiding Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 6 CRTR2709-CR e7e MASSACHUSETTS oY, BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT 2 zh Public Docket Report i iz} We? & oo ———_---- ———__----——_— 03/25/2024 Motion to dismiss (Mass.R.Civ.P. 12[b]) denied. Farrell wee eee eee ee 8 Judge:je. Farrell, Sue Farrell, Hon. Fon. William Wiliam GS one en eee eee eee eee 03/25/2024 24 Order: Order on the Defendant's Rule 12 B 6 motion to dismiss; parties Farrell Notified. ~~~ Judge: --------------- Farrell, Hon. SUE e_Parrel, Mon. William G VWillam eee 03/25/2024 Event Scheduled Event: Case Management Conference Date: 04/29/2024 Time: 02:00 PM -- Result: Event CancelledGe -- wee oe ice afil oye -s OO as -- 03/27/2024 Event Scheduled Event: Motion Hearing (CV) Date: 04/19/2024 Time: 09:00 AM Result: esulk Held ~------------------Mela ee ae _- oo ee eee eee ee eee eee eee 03/27/2024 Form generated: Notice of Next Event(Event Notice) CV ene ene ene ee - Sent BOM On: Vole 03/27/2024 le0eG 12:05:28 NEN CO ee = --- = -- -- 04/01/2024 Motion for order admitting Atty Richard C Moreno Pro Hac Vice allowed Farrell Attorney Richard C Moreno counsel for Defendant's PACCR, Inc and Peterbilt Motors Company. Murchison & Cummings , LLP 801 Grand Ave 9th Floor LOs wees ee eee --------- Angeles EYSAN eles California California 90017 YUN Ee woe eee eee 04/01/2024 Form generated: Notice of Next Event(Event Notice) CV wwe enn Sent BEM On: OM 04/01/2024 CAINE ee 08:56:58 MOO8 eee one ene ee eee ee 04/03/2024 Form generated: Notice of Next Event(Event Notice) CV ooo - == Sent - BEM MMOn: 04/03/2024 UANVOI NEG 11:29:25 NN Ee9 - ween ee wee a 04/03/2024 eee et 26 Opposition fileda! filed. _ £0 AREAS aoe oe ------- we eee eee -- ee-e - 04/19/2024 Event Resulted: Motion Hearing (CV) scheduled on: Farrell 04/19/2024 09:00 AM Has been: Held wee eee ------ ~~~ - Hon. ON, William Mllam &G Farret, Farrell, Presiding rresialt 1 oo 2 ee 2 ee - e = 04/25/2024 Motion to amend complaint (Mass.R.Civ.P. 4[g] & 15) allowed . Farrell - Judge: Farrell, en, Hon. Fi William mam G ~ oo ene eee ne oon ee eee nee eee eee eee 04/25/2024 Motion to dismiss (Mass.R.Civ.P. 12[b]) for exceeding the amount in Farrell controversy of the District Court allowed . Judge: Farrell, Hon. William G Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 7 CRTR2709-CR aang MASSACHUSETTS oo BROCKTON DISTRICT COURT a Public Docket Report Bi & oS —— ——----- ——_ 04/26/2024 Judgment Entered:: Judgment of Dismissal , upon motion for dismissal Presiding: Hon. William G Farrell Judgment For: PACCAR, INC. Peterbilt Motors Company Hunter Services, Inc. The Manitowoc Company, Inc /Grove US, LLC/National Crane CRW CORP Hunter Keystone Peterbilt The Manitowoc Company Inc. Grove US, LLC CRW Corp Judgment Against: Commerce Insurance Company Mostafa Masomi Terms of Judgment: Jdgmnt Date: 04/26/2024 Further Orders: . Dismissed for exceeding the amount in controversy of the District Piswmiet Court. ------------------- Gout, oo eeeeee -- 04/26/2024 Event Resulted: Case Management Conference scheduled on: Farrell 04/29/2024 02:00 PM Has been: Event Cancelled For the following reason: Brought forward Hon. William G Farrell, Presiding Printed: 05/07/2024 11:25 am Case No: 2315CV001032 Page: 8