Preview
GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP
Palo Alto, California 94301
Attorneys for Plaintiffs FIRST STREET
HOLDINGS LLC; S.J. BAYSHORE
HOLDINGS LLC; and BRIAN BUMB
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA
BAYSHORE DEVELOPMENT LLC; S.J.
DECLARATION OF LINDSEY YOUNG
BUMB, IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ EX
PARTE APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER
PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO COMPEL
THE DEPOSITION OF TIMOTHY BUMB
TIMOTHY BUMB; RONALD WERNER; and
Date: April 18, 2024
Time: 8:15 a.m.
Judge: The Hon. Socrates P. Manoukian
Action Filed: January 11, 2022
FAC Filed: March 22, 2022
Cross-Complainant, Trial Date: July 1, 2024
ally, and ROES 1
Gibson, Dunn &
r LLP DECLARATION OF LINDSEY YOUNG IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR AN
ORDER SHORTENING TIME TO HEAR PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO COMPEL THE DEPOSITION OF
TIMOTHY BUMB
I, Lindsey Young, declare as follows:
I am an attorney licensed to practice before this Court and all courts of the State of
California and am an associate with the law firm of Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP (“Gibson Dunn”).
I am one of the attorneys of record for Plaintiffs First Street Holdings LLC (“First Street”), S.J.
Bayshore Development LLC (“S.J. Bayshore”), S.J. Sweetwater Holdings LLC (“S.J. Sweetwater”),
and Brian Bumb (“Brian”) (together, “Plaintiffs”) in the above-captioned action. I submit this
declaration in support of Plaintiffs’ Ex Parte Application for an Order Shortening Time to Hear
Plaintiffs’ Motion to Compel the Deposition of Timothy Bumb. I have personal knowledge of the facts
set forth herein, except as to those stated on information and belief and, as to those, I am informed and
believe them to be true.
Plaintiffs served a notice of deposition on Tim on February 16, 2024. Tim has not
served any objections to that notice of deposition. Attached hereto as is a true and correct
copy of the Notice of Deposition for Personal Appearance to Timothy Bumb, dated February 16, 2024.
Over the subsequent weeks, the parties met and conferred in good faith via email to
agree upon a date for Tim’s deposition. Both parties offered proposed dates but did not ultimately
reach agreement on a date when all relevant parties were available. During those discussions, Tim’s
counsel never indicated that Tim would be unavailable for over a month right before the Sutter’s Place
trial. If Tim’s counsel had indicated that Tim would be unavailable that entire month, Plaintiffs would
have acted differently. Attached hereto as is a true and correct copy of the email
correspondence between myself and Ben Pulliam and Abraham Andrade (both of Coblentz Patch Duffy
& Bass LLP) “RE: First Street Holdings v. Timothy Bumb; Sutter’s Place Inc. v. Gregory Bumb -
At that point, with a mediation scheduled for April 9, 2024, Plaintiffs determined it
would be reasonable to wait until after the mediation to continue discussions, given the possibility that
the mediation might obviate the need for the deposition in the first place. After the failed mediation,
Plaintiffs followed up with Tim’s counsel the very next day, April 10, 2024, to schedule Tim’s
Gibson, Dunn &
r LLP DECLARATION OF LINDSEY YOUNG IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR AN
ORDER SHORTENING TIME TO HEAR PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO COMPEL THE DEPOSITION OF
TIMOTHY BUMB
deposition. Tim’s counsel responded that Tim was “unavailable for deposition before the May 6, 2024
trial in Sutter’s Place,” and that Tim is only available “the last two weeks of May” because he is “out-
of-state.”
Plaintiffs had previously offered to stay the litigation pending the parties’
6. Plaintiffs’ opposition to Tim’s third motion for summary adjudication is due on May 9,
2024, and the hearing on that motion is set for May 23, 2024. The close of fact discovery is June 3,
7. On April 17, 2024, Plaintiffs filed a Motion to Compel the Deposition of Timothy
8. Plaintiffs provided notice of this application via electronic mail on April 17,
2024 before 10:00 a.m. pursuant to Local Rule 8F.
9. The earliest a motion to compel Timothy Bumb’s deposition may be heard is June 20,
2024, according to the Court’s online reservation system.
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is
Executed on April 17, 2024 at Palo Alto, California.
Gibson, Dunn &
r LLP DECLARATION OF LINDSEY YOUNG IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR AN
ORDER SHORTENING TIME TO HEAR PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO COMPEL THE DEPOSITION OF
TIMOTHY BUMB
GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP
MICHAEL D. CELIO, SBN 197998
mcelio@gibsondunn.com
JESSICA VALENZUELA, SBN 220934
jvalenzuela@gibsondunn.com
LINDSEY YOUNG, SBN 300080
lsyoung@gibsondunn.com
310 University Avenue
Palo Alto, California 94301
Telephone:
Facsimile:
Attorneys for Plaintiffs FIRST STREET
HOLDINGS LLC; S.J. BAYSHORE
DEVELOPMENT LLC; S.J. SWEETWATER
HOLDINGS LLC; and BRIAN BUMB
SUPERIOR COURT OF THSTATE OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SANTA CLAR
FIRST STREET HOLDINGS LLC; S.J. CASE NO. 22CV39322
BAYSHORE DEVELOPMENT LLC; S.J.
SWEETWATER HOLDINGS LLC; and BRIAN NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONFOR
BUMB, PERSONAL APPEARANCETO
TIMOTHY BUMB
Plaintiffs,
Date: March
TIMOTHY BUMB; RONALD WERNER; and Time: 9:30a.m.
DOES 1 through 25, inclusive, Place: Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP
310 University Ave.,
Defendants. Palo Alto, California 94301
TIMOTHY BUMB, individually,
Action Filed: January 11, 2022
Cross Complainant, FAC Filed: March 22, 2022
Trial Date: May 6, 2024
BRIAN BUMB, individually, and ROES 1
through 25, inclusive,
Cross Defendants.
Gibson, Dunn &
Crutcher LLP
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION FOR PERSONAL APPEARANCE TO TIMOTHY BUMB
TO ALL PARTIES AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD:
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that, pursuant to California Code of Civil Procedure §§ 2025.010
and 2025.210 2025.280, Plaintiffs Brian Bumb, First Street Holdings LLC, S.J. Bayshore
Development LLC, and S.J. Sweetwater Holdings LLC, by and through its counsel, will take the
depositio of Timothy Bumb on March , 2024 at 9:30 a.m. (PST), and continuing from day to day,
Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays excluded, until completed. Said deposition will be taken upon oral
examination before an officer duly qualified in the State of California to administer oaths, and shall
take place at the offices of Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP, located at 310 University Ave., Palo Alto,
California 94301. Plaintiffs reserve the right to record the deposition testimony by videotape for use
at trial, pursuant to California Code of Civil Procedure section 2025.220(a)(6).
PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE THAT, pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure §§ 2025.220
and 2025.330, said deposition will be recorded by stenographic means as well as audio and visual
means, including videotape and interactive “real time” software (i.e., software, such as LiveNote or
similar software, that provides a simultaneous display of transcribed testimony on a laptop). Plaintiffs
reserve the right to use these audio and video recordings at evidentiary hearings and at trial, as provided
by Code of Civil Procedure § 2025.620(d).
A list of the attorneys for the party on whom this Notice of Deposition is being served is shown
on the accompanying proof of service.
DATED: February 16, 2024 GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER
By:
Michael D. Celio
Jessica Valenzuela
Lindsey Young
Attorneys for Plaintiffs FIRST STREET
HOLDINGS LLC; S.J. BAYSHORE
DEVELOPMENT LLC; S.J. SWEETWATER
HOLDINGS LLC; and BRIAN BUMB
Gibson, Dunn &
Crutcher LLP
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION FOR PERSONAL APPEARANCE TO TIMOTHY BUMB
PROOF OF SERVICE
First Street Holdings LLC, et al., vs. Timothy Bumb, et al., Case No. 22CV393229
I, Sean McCroskey, declare as follows:
I am employed in the County of San Francisco, State of California. I am over the age of
eighteen years and am not a party to this action; my business address is One Embarcadero Center,
Suite 2600, San Francisco, CA 94111, in said County and State. On February 16, 2024 I served the
following document(s):
NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONFOR PERSONAL APPEARANCE TO TIMOTHY BUMB
on the parties stated below, by the following means of service:
Please see attached Service List.
BY ELECTRONIC SERVICE: On the above mentioned date, based on a court order or an
agreement of the parties to accept service by electronic transmission, I caused the documents to
be sent to the persons at the electronic notification addresses as shown below.
BY ELECTRONIC SERVICE THROUGH AN EFSP: On the above mentioned date, I
caused the documents to be sent to a court approved Electronic Filing Service Provider
(“EFSP”), for electronic service and filing. Electronic service will be accomplished by the
EFSP’s case filing system at the electronic notification addresses as shown below.
BY MESSENGER SERVICE: I placed a true copy in a sealed envelope or package addressed
to the persons at the addresses listed above and providing them to a professional messenger
service for service for delivery before 5:00 p.m. on the above mentioned date.
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Stateof California that the foregoing
is true and correct.
Executed on February 16, 2024.
/s/ Sean McCroskey
Sean McCroskey
Gibson, Dunn &
Crutcher LLP
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION FOR PERSONAL APPEARANCE TO TIMOTHY BUMB
SERVICE LIST
For Defendant Timothy Bumb:
Richard R. Patch (ef rrp@cpdb.com)
Jonathan R. Bass (ef jrb@cpdb.com)
Scott C. Hall (ef sch@cpdb.com)
Ben Pulliam (ef bcp@cpdb.com)
Clifford E. Yin (ef cey@cpdb.com)
Abraham M. Andrade III (aandrade@coblentzlaw.com)
For Defendant, Ron Werner:
McManis Faulkner
Matthew Schechter (mschechter@mcmanislaw.com), attorney
Elise Dresser (edresser@mcmanislaw.com), legal assistant
Gibson, Dunn &
Crutcher LLP
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION FOR PERSONAL APPEARANCE TO TIMOTHY BUMB
Pulliam, Ben
Valenzuela, Jessica; Verdin, Hazel
EfilingRRP; EfilingJRB; EfilingSCH; EfilingBCP; EfilingCey; Andrade, Abraham; EfilingSEP; Wiener,
[WARNING: External Email]
As we have indicated repeatedly, Timothy and his counsel are unavailable for a deposi on at this late date, mere weeks
before the er’s Place trial. Your demand to depose him now—a er years of delay and over a month of radio
silence—is unfair and will materially and prejudicially interfere with our and his ability to prepare for trial in that case.
As you point out, the Court may hear a summary judgment mo on less than 30 days before trial. Code of Civil
Procedure § 437c(a)(3) (“The mo on shall be heard no later than 30 days before the date of trial, unless the court for
good cause orders otherwise.”). In other words, there is no jurisdic onal bar to having this mo on heard on June
Beroiz v. Wahl (2000) 84 Cal.App.4th 485, 493, n.4. We believe good cause exists here.
If you want to depose Timothy, you can do so in May, a er the er’s Place trial.
Thanks,
Coblentz Patch Duffy & Bass LLP
415-772-5778 | O ce 415-391-4800
al is intended solely for use by its addressee, and may contain con den al or legally privileged informa on. If you receive this transmi
please email a reply to the sender and delete the transmi achments.
Young, Lindsey
Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2024 8:53 AM
Pulliam, Ben ; Krbechek, Franklin ; Celio, Michael D.
; Dooley, Elizabeth Aislinn ; McCroskey, Sean
; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB ; EfilingSCH ;
EfilingBCP ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation
[EXTERNAL] RE: First Street Holdings v. Timothy Bumb; Sutter's Place Inc. v. Gregory Bumb - deposition notices
Thank you for the email and the e ort to compromise. Based on the July 1 trial date in , we understand that
on before May 30. (See Code of Civil Procedure § 437c(a)(3)
on shall be heard no later than 30 days before the date of trial, unless the court for good cause orders
otherwise.”].) Thus, June 13 would be too late for a hearing on MSA 3, and the necessity of deposing Tim before the
er’s Place trial remains.
Thanks,
Associate Attorney
T: +1 650.849.5387 | M: +1 650.575.2664
LSYoung@gibsondunn.com
Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP
310 University Avenue, Palo Alto, CA 94301-1744
Pulliam, Ben ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Celio, Michael D.
MCelio@gibsondunn.com EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com Term_Acc_CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Celio, Michael D.
MCelio@gibsondunn.com EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com Term_Acc_CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Celio, Michael D.
MCelio@gibsondunn.com EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Dooley, Elizabeth
EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean ; Valenzuela, Jessica
JValenzuela@gibsondunn.com>; Verdin, Hazel ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Dooley, Elizabeth Aislinn ; McCroskey,
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com>; Young, Lindsey ; Beauclair, Chase
CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation
Valenzuela, Jessica; Verdin, Hazel
EfilingRRP; EfilingJRB; EfilingSCH; EfilingBCP; EfilingCey; Andrade, Abraham; EfilingSEP; Wiener,
[WARNING: External Email]
As we have indicated repeatedly, Timothy and his counsel are unavailable for a deposi on at this late date, mere weeks
before the er’s Place trial. Your demand to depose him now—a er years of delay and over a month of radio
silence—is unfair and will materially and prejudicially interfere with our and his ability to prepare for trial in that case.
As you point out, the Court may hear a summary judgment mo on less than 30 days before trial. Code of Civil
Procedure § 437c(a)(3) (“The mo on shall be heard no later than 30 days before the date of trial, unless the court for
good cause orders otherwise.”). In other words, there is no jurisdic onal bar to having this mo on heard on June
Beroiz v. Wahl (2000) 84 Cal.App.4th 485, 493, n.4. We believe good cause exists here.
If you want to depose Timothy, you can do so in May, a er the er’s Place trial.
Thanks,
Coblentz Patch Duffy & Bass LLP
415-772-5778 | O ce 415-391-4800
al is intended solely for use by its addressee, and may contain con den al or legally privileged informa on. If you receive this transmi
please email a reply to the sender and delete the transmi achments.
Young, Lindsey
Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2024 8:53 AM
Pulliam, Ben ; Krbechek, Franklin ; Celio, Michael D.
; Dooley, Elizabeth Aislinn ; McCroskey, Sean
; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB ; EfilingSCH ;
EfilingBCP ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation
[EXTERNAL] RE: First Street Holdings v. Timothy Bumb; Sutter's Place Inc. v. Gregory Bumb - deposition notices
Thank you for the email and the e ort to compromise. Based on the July 1 trial date in , we understand that
on before May 30. (See Code of Civil Procedure § 437c(a)(3)
on shall be heard no later than 30 days before the date of trial, unless the court for good cause orders
otherwise.”].) Thus, June 13 would be too late for a hearing on MSA 3, and the necessity of deposing Tim before the
er’s Place trial remains.
Thanks,
Associate Attorney
T: +1 650.849.5387 | M: +1 650.575.2664
LSYoung@gibsondunn.com
Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP
310 University Avenue, Palo Alto, CA 94301-1744
Pulliam, Ben ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Celio, Michael D.
MCelio@gibsondunn.com EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com Term_Acc_CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Celio, Michael D.
MCelio@gibsondunn.com EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com Term_Acc_CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Celio, Michael D.
MCelio@gibsondunn.com EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Dooley, Elizabeth
EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean ; Valenzuela, Jessica
JValenzuela@gibsondunn.com>; Verdin, Hazel ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation ; Dooley, Elizabeth Aislinn ; McCroskey,
SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel
HVerdin@gibsondunn.com>; Young, Lindsey ; Beauclair, Chase
CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com
EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham
aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ;
Bumb Litigation
Preview
GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP Palo Alto, California 94301 Attorneys for Plaintiffs FIRST STREET HOLDINGS LLC; S.J. BAYSHORE HOLDINGS LLC; and BRIAN BUMB STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA BAYSHORE DEVELOPMENT LLC; S.J. DECLARATION OF LINDSEY YOUNG BUMB, IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO COMPEL THE DEPOSITION OF TIMOTHY BUMB TIMOTHY BUMB; RONALD WERNER; and Date: April 18, 2024 Time: 8:15 a.m. Judge: The Hon. Socrates P. Manoukian Action Filed: January 11, 2022 FAC Filed: March 22, 2022 Cross-Complainant, Trial Date: July 1, 2024 ally, and ROES 1 Gibson, Dunn & r LLP DECLARATION OF LINDSEY YOUNG IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER SHORTENING TIME TO HEAR PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO COMPEL THE DEPOSITION OF TIMOTHY BUMB I, Lindsey Young, declare as follows: I am an attorney licensed to practice before this Court and all courts of the State of California and am an associate with the law firm of Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP (“Gibson Dunn”). I am one of the attorneys of record for Plaintiffs First Street Holdings LLC (“First Street”), S.J. Bayshore Development LLC (“S.J. Bayshore”), S.J. Sweetwater Holdings LLC (“S.J. Sweetwater”), and Brian Bumb (“Brian”) (together, “Plaintiffs”) in the above-captioned action. I submit this declaration in support of Plaintiffs’ Ex Parte Application for an Order Shortening Time to Hear Plaintiffs’ Motion to Compel the Deposition of Timothy Bumb. I have personal knowledge of the facts set forth herein, except as to those stated on information and belief and, as to those, I am informed and believe them to be true. Plaintiffs served a notice of deposition on Tim on February 16, 2024. Tim has not served any objections to that notice of deposition. Attached hereto as is a true and correct copy of the Notice of Deposition for Personal Appearance to Timothy Bumb, dated February 16, 2024. Over the subsequent weeks, the parties met and conferred in good faith via email to agree upon a date for Tim’s deposition. Both parties offered proposed dates but did not ultimately reach agreement on a date when all relevant parties were available. During those discussions, Tim’s counsel never indicated that Tim would be unavailable for over a month right before the Sutter’s Place trial. If Tim’s counsel had indicated that Tim would be unavailable that entire month, Plaintiffs would have acted differently. Attached hereto as is a true and correct copy of the email correspondence between myself and Ben Pulliam and Abraham Andrade (both of Coblentz Patch Duffy & Bass LLP) “RE: First Street Holdings v. Timothy Bumb; Sutter’s Place Inc. v. Gregory Bumb - At that point, with a mediation scheduled for April 9, 2024, Plaintiffs determined it would be reasonable to wait until after the mediation to continue discussions, given the possibility that the mediation might obviate the need for the deposition in the first place. After the failed mediation, Plaintiffs followed up with Tim’s counsel the very next day, April 10, 2024, to schedule Tim’s Gibson, Dunn & r LLP DECLARATION OF LINDSEY YOUNG IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER SHORTENING TIME TO HEAR PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO COMPEL THE DEPOSITION OF TIMOTHY BUMB deposition. Tim’s counsel responded that Tim was “unavailable for deposition before the May 6, 2024 trial in Sutter’s Place,” and that Tim is only available “the last two weeks of May” because he is “out- of-state.” Plaintiffs had previously offered to stay the litigation pending the parties’ 6. Plaintiffs’ opposition to Tim’s third motion for summary adjudication is due on May 9, 2024, and the hearing on that motion is set for May 23, 2024. The close of fact discovery is June 3, 7. On April 17, 2024, Plaintiffs filed a Motion to Compel the Deposition of Timothy 8. Plaintiffs provided notice of this application via electronic mail on April 17, 2024 before 10:00 a.m. pursuant to Local Rule 8F. 9. The earliest a motion to compel Timothy Bumb’s deposition may be heard is June 20, 2024, according to the Court’s online reservation system. I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is Executed on April 17, 2024 at Palo Alto, California. Gibson, Dunn & r LLP DECLARATION OF LINDSEY YOUNG IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER SHORTENING TIME TO HEAR PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO COMPEL THE DEPOSITION OF TIMOTHY BUMB GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP MICHAEL D. CELIO, SBN 197998 mcelio@gibsondunn.com JESSICA VALENZUELA, SBN 220934 jvalenzuela@gibsondunn.com LINDSEY YOUNG, SBN 300080 lsyoung@gibsondunn.com 310 University Avenue Palo Alto, California 94301 Telephone: Facsimile: Attorneys for Plaintiffs FIRST STREET HOLDINGS LLC; S.J. BAYSHORE DEVELOPMENT LLC; S.J. SWEETWATER HOLDINGS LLC; and BRIAN BUMB SUPERIOR COURT OF THSTATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SANTA CLAR FIRST STREET HOLDINGS LLC; S.J. CASE NO. 22CV39322 BAYSHORE DEVELOPMENT LLC; S.J. SWEETWATER HOLDINGS LLC; and BRIAN NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONFOR BUMB, PERSONAL APPEARANCETO TIMOTHY BUMB Plaintiffs, Date: March TIMOTHY BUMB; RONALD WERNER; and Time: 9:30a.m. DOES 1 through 25, inclusive, Place: Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP 310 University Ave., Defendants. Palo Alto, California 94301 TIMOTHY BUMB, individually, Action Filed: January 11, 2022 Cross Complainant, FAC Filed: March 22, 2022 Trial Date: May 6, 2024 BRIAN BUMB, individually, and ROES 1 through 25, inclusive, Cross Defendants. Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP NOTICE OF DEPOSITION FOR PERSONAL APPEARANCE TO TIMOTHY BUMB TO ALL PARTIES AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD: PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that, pursuant to California Code of Civil Procedure §§ 2025.010 and 2025.210 2025.280, Plaintiffs Brian Bumb, First Street Holdings LLC, S.J. Bayshore Development LLC, and S.J. Sweetwater Holdings LLC, by and through its counsel, will take the depositio of Timothy Bumb on March , 2024 at 9:30 a.m. (PST), and continuing from day to day, Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays excluded, until completed. Said deposition will be taken upon oral examination before an officer duly qualified in the State of California to administer oaths, and shall take place at the offices of Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP, located at 310 University Ave., Palo Alto, California 94301. Plaintiffs reserve the right to record the deposition testimony by videotape for use at trial, pursuant to California Code of Civil Procedure section 2025.220(a)(6). PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE THAT, pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure §§ 2025.220 and 2025.330, said deposition will be recorded by stenographic means as well as audio and visual means, including videotape and interactive “real time” software (i.e., software, such as LiveNote or similar software, that provides a simultaneous display of transcribed testimony on a laptop). Plaintiffs reserve the right to use these audio and video recordings at evidentiary hearings and at trial, as provided by Code of Civil Procedure § 2025.620(d). A list of the attorneys for the party on whom this Notice of Deposition is being served is shown on the accompanying proof of service. DATED: February 16, 2024 GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER By: Michael D. Celio Jessica Valenzuela Lindsey Young Attorneys for Plaintiffs FIRST STREET HOLDINGS LLC; S.J. BAYSHORE DEVELOPMENT LLC; S.J. SWEETWATER HOLDINGS LLC; and BRIAN BUMB Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP NOTICE OF DEPOSITION FOR PERSONAL APPEARANCE TO TIMOTHY BUMB PROOF OF SERVICE First Street Holdings LLC, et al., vs. Timothy Bumb, et al., Case No. 22CV393229 I, Sean McCroskey, declare as follows: I am employed in the County of San Francisco, State of California. I am over the age of eighteen years and am not a party to this action; my business address is One Embarcadero Center, Suite 2600, San Francisco, CA 94111, in said County and State. On February 16, 2024 I served the following document(s): NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONFOR PERSONAL APPEARANCE TO TIMOTHY BUMB on the parties stated below, by the following means of service: Please see attached Service List. BY ELECTRONIC SERVICE: On the above mentioned date, based on a court order or an agreement of the parties to accept service by electronic transmission, I caused the documents to be sent to the persons at the electronic notification addresses as shown below. BY ELECTRONIC SERVICE THROUGH AN EFSP: On the above mentioned date, I caused the documents to be sent to a court approved Electronic Filing Service Provider (“EFSP”), for electronic service and filing. Electronic service will be accomplished by the EFSP’s case filing system at the electronic notification addresses as shown below. BY MESSENGER SERVICE: I placed a true copy in a sealed envelope or package addressed to the persons at the addresses listed above and providing them to a professional messenger service for service for delivery before 5:00 p.m. on the above mentioned date. I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the Stateof California that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on February 16, 2024. /s/ Sean McCroskey Sean McCroskey Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP NOTICE OF DEPOSITION FOR PERSONAL APPEARANCE TO TIMOTHY BUMB SERVICE LIST For Defendant Timothy Bumb: Richard R. Patch (ef rrp@cpdb.com) Jonathan R. Bass (ef jrb@cpdb.com) Scott C. Hall (ef sch@cpdb.com) Ben Pulliam (ef bcp@cpdb.com) Clifford E. Yin (ef cey@cpdb.com) Abraham M. Andrade III (aandrade@coblentzlaw.com) For Defendant, Ron Werner: McManis Faulkner Matthew Schechter (mschechter@mcmanislaw.com), attorney Elise Dresser (edresser@mcmanislaw.com), legal assistant Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP NOTICE OF DEPOSITION FOR PERSONAL APPEARANCE TO TIMOTHY BUMB Pulliam, Ben Valenzuela, Jessica; Verdin, Hazel EfilingRRP; EfilingJRB; EfilingSCH; EfilingBCP; EfilingCey; Andrade, Abraham; EfilingSEP; Wiener, [WARNING: External Email] As we have indicated repeatedly, Timothy and his counsel are unavailable for a deposi on at this late date, mere weeks before the er’s Place trial. Your demand to depose him now—a er years of delay and over a month of radio silence—is unfair and will materially and prejudicially interfere with our and his ability to prepare for trial in that case. As you point out, the Court may hear a summary judgment mo on less than 30 days before trial. Code of Civil Procedure § 437c(a)(3) (“The mo on shall be heard no later than 30 days before the date of trial, unless the court for good cause orders otherwise.”). In other words, there is no jurisdic onal bar to having this mo on heard on June Beroiz v. Wahl (2000) 84 Cal.App.4th 485, 493, n.4. We believe good cause exists here. If you want to depose Timothy, you can do so in May, a er the er’s Place trial. Thanks, Coblentz Patch Duffy & Bass LLP 415-772-5778 | O ce 415-391-4800 al is intended solely for use by its addressee, and may contain con den al or legally privileged informa on. If you receive this transmi please email a reply to the sender and delete the transmi achments. Young, Lindsey Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2024 8:53 AM Pulliam, Ben ; Krbechek, Franklin ; Celio, Michael D. ; Dooley, Elizabeth Aislinn ; McCroskey, Sean ; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB ; EfilingSCH ; EfilingBCP ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham ; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation [EXTERNAL] RE: First Street Holdings v. Timothy Bumb; Sutter's Place Inc. v. Gregory Bumb - deposition notices Thank you for the email and the e ort to compromise. Based on the July 1 trial date in , we understand that on before May 30. (See Code of Civil Procedure § 437c(a)(3) on shall be heard no later than 30 days before the date of trial, unless the court for good cause orders otherwise.”].) Thus, June 13 would be too late for a hearing on MSA 3, and the necessity of deposing Tim before the er’s Place trial remains. Thanks, Associate Attorney T: +1 650.849.5387 | M: +1 650.575.2664 LSYoung@gibsondunn.com Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP 310 University Avenue, Palo Alto, CA 94301-1744 Pulliam, Ben ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Celio, Michael D. MCelio@gibsondunn.com EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com Term_Acc_CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Celio, Michael D. MCelio@gibsondunn.com EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com Term_Acc_CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Celio, Michael D. MCelio@gibsondunn.com EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Dooley, Elizabeth EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean ; Valenzuela, Jessica JValenzuela@gibsondunn.com>; Verdin, Hazel ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Dooley, Elizabeth Aislinn ; McCroskey, SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com>; Young, Lindsey ; Beauclair, Chase CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation Valenzuela, Jessica; Verdin, Hazel EfilingRRP; EfilingJRB; EfilingSCH; EfilingBCP; EfilingCey; Andrade, Abraham; EfilingSEP; Wiener, [WARNING: External Email] As we have indicated repeatedly, Timothy and his counsel are unavailable for a deposi on at this late date, mere weeks before the er’s Place trial. Your demand to depose him now—a er years of delay and over a month of radio silence—is unfair and will materially and prejudicially interfere with our and his ability to prepare for trial in that case. As you point out, the Court may hear a summary judgment mo on less than 30 days before trial. Code of Civil Procedure § 437c(a)(3) (“The mo on shall be heard no later than 30 days before the date of trial, unless the court for good cause orders otherwise.”). In other words, there is no jurisdic onal bar to having this mo on heard on June Beroiz v. Wahl (2000) 84 Cal.App.4th 485, 493, n.4. We believe good cause exists here. If you want to depose Timothy, you can do so in May, a er the er’s Place trial. Thanks, Coblentz Patch Duffy & Bass LLP 415-772-5778 | O ce 415-391-4800 al is intended solely for use by its addressee, and may contain con den al or legally privileged informa on. If you receive this transmi please email a reply to the sender and delete the transmi achments. Young, Lindsey Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2024 8:53 AM Pulliam, Ben ; Krbechek, Franklin ; Celio, Michael D. ; Dooley, Elizabeth Aislinn ; McCroskey, Sean ; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB ; EfilingSCH ; EfilingBCP ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham ; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation [EXTERNAL] RE: First Street Holdings v. Timothy Bumb; Sutter's Place Inc. v. Gregory Bumb - deposition notices Thank you for the email and the e ort to compromise. Based on the July 1 trial date in , we understand that on before May 30. (See Code of Civil Procedure § 437c(a)(3) on shall be heard no later than 30 days before the date of trial, unless the court for good cause orders otherwise.”].) Thus, June 13 would be too late for a hearing on MSA 3, and the necessity of deposing Tim before the er’s Place trial remains. Thanks, Associate Attorney T: +1 650.849.5387 | M: +1 650.575.2664 LSYoung@gibsondunn.com Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP 310 University Avenue, Palo Alto, CA 94301-1744 Pulliam, Ben ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Celio, Michael D. MCelio@gibsondunn.com EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com Term_Acc_CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Celio, Michael D. MCelio@gibsondunn.com EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com Term_Acc_CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Celio, Michael D. MCelio@gibsondunn.com EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Krbechek, Franklin ; McCroskey, Sean SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Dooley, Elizabeth EDooley@gibsondunn.com>; McCroskey, Sean ; Valenzuela, Jessica JValenzuela@gibsondunn.com>; Verdin, Hazel ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation ; Dooley, Elizabeth Aislinn ; McCroskey, SMcCroskey@gibsondunn.com>; Valenzuela, Jessica ; Verdin, Hazel HVerdin@gibsondunn.com>; Young, Lindsey ; Beauclair, Chase CBeauclair@gibsondunn.com EfilingRRP ; EfilingJRB < >; EfilingSCH ; EfilingCey ; Andrade, Abraham aandrade@coblentzlaw.com>; EfilingSEP ; Wiener, Christopher ; Bumb Litigation