Preview
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 04/22/2024 10:56 AM
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NEW YORK
wee ee ee ee ee eee eee eee eee eee eee
EBONY MCGIRT, Index No.: 525895/2022
Plaintiff,
-against- EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE
ARCHBISHOP JOHN HUGHES KNIGHTS OF
COLUMBUS #481 INC. AND NEW YORK SMSA
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP D/B/A VERIZON
WIRELESS,
Defendants.
wee ee ee ee ee eee eee eee eee eee eee
ARCHBISHOP JOHN HUGHES KNIGHTS OF
COLUMBUS #481 INC. AND J OHN HUGHES
CLUB, INC. I/S/H/A ARCHBISHOP J OHN
HUGHES KNIGHTS OF COLUMBUS #481 INC.,
Third-P arty Plaintiffs,
-against-
THE GUILD FOR EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN,
INC.,
Third-P arty Defendant.
wee eee eee ee eee ee eee eee ee eee eee
Defendants/third-party plaintiffs Archbishop J ohn Hughes Knights of Columbus #481
Inc. and J ohn Hughes Club, Inc., by their attorneys, Gannon, Rosenfarb & Drossman, as and
for their response to plaintiff's request for disclosure for material relating to experts, sets forth
the following:
1 Identity of Expert:
Matthew S. Mendez-Zfass, M.D., 421 Ocean Parkway, Brooklyn, New York 11218.
2 Subject Matter of Testimony:
Dr. Mendez-Zfass’ testimony will relate to plaintiffs physical condition, nature of the
injuries complained of, his findings pursuant to his medical examination of plaintiff and his
review of plaintiff's medical records and films, the causal relation, or lack thereof, of the accident
to the injuries complained of, the need, if any, for further medical treatment or therapy, whether
1 of 16
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 04/22/2024 10:56 AM
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
or not there is any disability resulting from the alleged injury and other items relating to his
examination of plaintiff, his review of medical records and films, and the medical report annexed
hereto.
3 Substance of Facts and Opinions:
It is expected that Dr. Mendez-Zfass will testify, in accordance with his findings and
opinions set forth in the annexed report.
4 Qualifications:
For Dr. Mendez-Zfass’ qualifications, please see annexed curriculum vitae.
5 Grounds of Opinion:
The grounds of Dr. Mendez-Zfass’ opinions are the medical records and films supplied
by plaintiff, Dr. Mendez-Zfass’ examination of plaintiff, his expertise as an orthopedist, all other
grounds set forth in Dr. Mendez-Zfass’ medical report annexed hereto, and any evidence
admitted by the Court at the trial of this matter.
Defendants/third-party plaintiffs reserve the right to supplement any and all foregoing
responses up until the time of trial as further records and information becomes available.
Dated: New York, New York
April 22, 2024
4. Shia
By: J ohn H. Shin
Gannon, Rosenfarb & Drossman
Attorneys for Defendant
ArchbishopJ ohn Hughes Knights of
Columbus #481 Inc. andJ ohn Hughes Club,
Inc. i/s/hfa Archbishop J ohn Hughes Knights
of Columbus #481 Inc.
250 Broadway, 25th Floor
New York, New York 10038
(212) 655-5000
TO Service Via Efile
Shulman & Hill
Attorneys for Plaintiff
One State Street Plaza — 15th Floor
New York, New York 10004
2 of 16
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 04/22/2024 10:56 AM
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
New York SMSA Limited Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless — Discontinued
Third Party Action — Discontinued
3 of 16
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
Matthew S. Mendez-Zfass, M.D.
Diplomate of American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery
421 Ocean Parkway, Brooklyn, NY 11218
Examination Date: April 3, 2024
Report Date: April 12, 2024
Gannon, Rosenfarb & Drossman
250 Broadway
25th Floor
New York, NY 10007
Attn: Melisa Giles
Re: McGirt, Ebony
Claim #: 3622990-1
EW/GC Case #: 22266514
DOI: 6/23/22
Specialty Requested: :3 Orthopedic Surgery
Request Type: Liability IME
To Whom It May Concern:
I performed an independent orthopedic examination on the above claimant on 4/03/24 in my
Brooklyn, New York office. The claimant provided valid photo identification. The claimant
reported she took an Uber to the examination today. The findings of my examination are
noted below:
WORK HISTORY:
The claimant was employed full-time as a direct support professional when the 6/23/22
accident occurred. She states that she missed time from work following the accident. Ms.
McGirt is currently not working.
INJURY HISTORY:
Ms. McGirt states that she was involved in an accident on 6/23/22. She explains that she fell
inside a closet over a wooden block that was bolted in the floor. The claimant sustained
reported injuries to the neck, mid-back, lower back, right shoulder, and right hip. There were
no reported lacerations or a claimed loss of consciousness. Ms. McGirt went to the Woodhull
Hospital Emergency Room, on her own on 6/24/22, where she had radiology testing
performed of the left ankle, was provided with an Ace bandage and crutches and released the
same day.
PAST MEDICAL HISTORY:
The claimant did not report a history of serious illness.
The claimant denied being involved in any prior motor vehicle or workers’ compensation
accidents or sustaining any prior injuries.
4 of 16
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 04/22/2024 10:56 AM
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony
Examination Date: April 3, 2024
PRIOR/UNRELATED SURGICAL HISTORY:
The claimant did not report any prior/unrelated surgical history.
MEDICATION USE:
The claimant indicated she is currently using medication, which includes “muscle relaxers.”
TREATMENT HISTORY TO DATE:
The claimant was treated with medication, physical therapy, and injections. She is no longer
receiving physical therapy. Ms. McGirt was provided with medical supplies which included a
cane.
Ms. McGirt noted that she underwent lower back surgery in 2023, right shoulder surgery in
2022, and left ankle surgery in 2023.
MEDICAL RECORDS REVIEWED:
e Verified Bill of Particulars (Index No: 525895/2022) dated 4/14/23.
e EMG/Nerve conduction studies report from Health East Medical Alliance, dated
03/21/23. Impression: (1) The above electrodiagnostic study reveals evidence of a mild
bilateral sensory median nerve neuropathy at the wrist. This is consistent with the
clinical diagnosis of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. (2) The above electrodiagnostic study
reveals evidence of left C5 - C6 and right C6-C7 nerve root irritation.
Evaluation report from Brooklyn Premier Orthopedic Center for Musculoskeletal
Disorders, dated 12/01/22 to 01/10/23.
ED provider note report from Adrian Llewellyn, PA, dated 06/24/22.
ED notes report from Natasha Fontaine, Rn, dated 06/24/22.
Dc tibia fibula 2 view left from Adrian Llewellyn, PA, dated 06/24/22. Impression: No
acute fractures.
DX foot complete left from Adrian Llewellyn, PA, dated 06/24/22. Impression: No
acute fractures noted.
DX foot complete right from Adrian Llewellyn, PA, dated 06/24/22. Impression : No
acute fractures noted.
DX ankle comp right from Adrian Llewellyn, PA, dated 06/24/22. Impression: No
acute fractures noted.
DX tibia fibula 2 views right from Adrian Llewellyn, PA, dated 06/24/22. Impression:
No acute fractures.
MRI report of the left ankle from Stand-Up MRI of Manhattan, PC, dated 08/01/22.
Impression: Sprain of lateral ligaments. Contusion distal cuboid. - Tibialis anterior
tendinopathy with peritendinous edema. Extensor digitorum tendinopathy with
fraying at the myotendinous junction. Achilles tendinopathy.
MRI report of the right hip from Stand-Up MRI of Manhattan, PC, dated 08/01/22.
Impression: Arthrosis of the sacroiliac joints and pubic symphysis. Cam deformity
2|Page
5 of 16
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony
Examination Date: April 3, 2024
with moderate arthrosis, diffuse labral tear, and joint effusion. Gluteal tendinopathy
with low-grade tear at the greater trochanter with soft tissue edema. Hamstring
tendinopathy with moderate-grade tearing at the origin.
MRI report of the lumbar spine from Stand-Up MRI of Manhattan, PC, dated
07/28/22. Impression: L2-3 posterior broad based central and peripheral disc bulging.
L3-4 posterior broad based central disc bulge with peripheral increased bulging into
the bilateral left greater than right foramina. Facet hypertrophic change on the left
greater than right with trace facet fluid. L4-5 posterior broad based central disc
bulging with peripheral bulging extending into the left greater than right foramina.
Facet hypertrophic change. L5-S1 posterior broad based central disc bulging. Findings
consistent with inflammatory/noninfectious posterior paraspinal fasciitis.
MRI report of the right shoulder min 2 views from Lenox Hill Radiology, dated
07/19/22. Impression: No abnormality of the right shoulder.
MRI report of the cervical spine from Stand-Up MRI of Manhattan, PC, dated
03/02/23. Impression: (1) Straightening of the cervical lordosis. (2) C4/5: Posterior
disc bulge impinging on the anterior thecal sac. (3) C5/6: Broad-based 2-3 mm
posterior disc herniation impinging on the anterior thecal sac. Flattening of the
anterior cord. (4) C6/7: Posterior subligamentous disc bulge impinging on the anterior
thecal sac. (5) Bone marrow is hypointense likely related to residual red marrow but
clinical correlation is suggested for anemia or other hematopoietic abnormality which
may result in this appearance. Small lesion in the posterior C5 vertebra, nonspecific
but most compatible with a hemangioma. Periodic follow-up is suggested to assess
stability. (6) Findings compatible with pharyngeal and lingual tonsillar hypertrophy.
Findings compatible with adenoidal hyperplasia. (7) The thyroid is partly seen and
appears somewhat generous in size, nonspecific with no discrete lesion seen.
Correlation with clinical exam and history is suggested. (8) Multiple small and a few
top normal cervical lymph nodes, nonspecific, some of which may be
reactive/inflammatory. Correlation with clinical examination and history is suggested.
MRI report of the right shoulder from Stand-Up MRI of Manhattan, PC, dated
07/28/22. Impression: (1) Inhomogeneity of the supraspinatus tendon distally
representing tendinosis/tendinopathy. Peritendinous edema and inflammation that
obscures the peritendinous fat. (2) Fluid in the long head of biceps tendon sheath with
evidence for tenosynovitis. (3) Synovial effusion accumulating at the axillary recess of
the glenohumeral joint extending into the subscapularis recess. (4) Acromioclavicular
joint space narrowing with hypertrophic change. Subcortical reactive bone marrow
edema involving the inferior subarticular margin of the clavicle. Slightly anteriorly
downsloping type II acromial configuration.
Physical therapy initial evaluation report from Health East Medical Alliance, dated
07/11/22.
Physical therapy visit report from Health East Medical Alliance, dated 07/12/22 to
11/28/22.
3|Page
6 of 16
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony
Examination Date: April 3, 2024
PHYSICAL DESCRIPTION:
The claimant is a 34-year-old female who stands 5’ 6” tall and weighs 260 Ibs. She has brown
eyes and brown hair. The claimant stated being right-hand dominant.
SYMPTOMS DESCRIPTION:
This individual stated that she feels pain in the neck, mid-back, lower back, right shoulder,
and right hip. She started her treatments 7 days after the accident occurred. When asked if
she feels better now, compared to when she started treatments, she replied she does “not
really” feel better. Her relief lasted for “an hour or so” after her treatments. On a pain scale
from 1 to 10 (10 being the worst) her pain is a “7.5”. She indicated she took pain medication
today, which helped with the pain “a little”. She describes her pain as burning, sharp,
stabbing, and tingling. She has shooting pain down her leg and arm. She can walk 1 block
before being in too much pain. She has difficulty with stairs. She can sit for “2 minutes”
before being in too much pain. Bending, walking, and sleeping make the pain worse. She is
also experiencing locking, clicking, numbness, and tingling. She reported she is no longer
able to do “daily life activities”, clean, cook, or engage with her children due to this accident.
She reported she needs assistance with cooking and cleaning.
PHYSICAL EXAMINATION:
GENERAL OBSERVATIONS:
The claimant had a normal appearance and posture. The claimant was using a straight cane.
She was asked to inform me as to any pain or tenderness during the examination. All ROM
measurements were taken with the aid of a standard hand-held goniometer. ROM normal
values are in accordance with both the NYS WC guidelines and AMA guidelines.
EXAMINATION OF THE RIGHT SHOULDER: Examination of the right shoulder
revealed tenderness to palpation. There was no effusion. Muscle atrophy was negative. No
crepitus was noted. Impingement sign was positive. O’Brien’s test was negative. Crank test
was positive. Apprehension test was negative.
RIGHT SHOULDER
ACTIVE RANGE OF MOTION | NORMAL | CLAIMANT
ABDUCTION 180° 100°
ADDUCTION 30° 30°
FORWARD FLEXION 180° 90°
EXTENSION 60° 45°
INTERNAL ROTATION 80° 60°
EXTERNAL ROTATION go° 60°
There was suboptimal effort during the examination.
A|Page
7 of 16
UD OUN IK 04 AW INDEX NO. 525895/2022
NYSCEF BOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony
Examination Date: April 3, 2024
EXAMINATION OF THE LEFT SHOULDER: Examination of the left shoulder revealed
tenderness to palpation. There was no effusion. Muscle atrophy was negative. No crepitus
was noted. Impingement sign was negative. O’Brien’s test was negative. Crank test was
positive. Apprehension test was negative.
LEFT SHOULDER
ACTIVE RANGE OF MOTION | NORMAL | CLAIMANT
ABDUCTION 180° 105°
ADDUCTION 30° 30°
FORWARD FLEXION 180° 105°
EXTENSION 60° 45°
INTERNAL ROTATION 80° 60°
EXTERNAL ROTATION go° 55°
EXAMINATION OF THE RIGHT HIP: Examination of the right hip revealed tenderness
to palpation to the trochanteric aspect. FABER test was negative. FADDIR test was positive.
RIGHT HIP
RANGE OF MOTION NORMAL | CLAIMANT
FORWARD FLEXION 120° 75°
EXTENSION 30° 10°
ABDUCTION 45° 25°
ADDUCTION 35° 10°
EXTERNAL ROTATION 45° 25°
5°
INTERNAL ROTATION 45°
EXAMINATION OF THE LEFT HIP: Examination of the left hip revealed no tenderness
to palpation. FABER test was negative. FADDIR test was negative.
LEFT HIP
RANGE OF MOTION NORMAL | CLAIMANT
FORWARD FLEXION 120° 85°
EXTENSION 30° 15°
ABDUCTION 45° 25°
ADDUCTION 35° 10°
EXTERNAL ROTATION 45° 25°
INTERNAL ROTATION 45° 10°
EXAMINATION OF THE RIGHT ANKLE/FOOT: Examination of the right ankle/foot
revealed no soft tissue swelling. There was no tenderness to palpation. Sensation to light
touch was normal. Anterior drawer test was negative.
5|Page
8 of 16
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 04/22/2024 10:56 AM
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF 04/22/2024
Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony
Examination Date: April 3, 2024
RIGHT ANKLE/FOOT
RANGE OF MOTION NORMAL | CLAIMANT
DORSIFLEXION (ANKLE) 20° 10°
PLANTAR FLEXION (ANKLE) 40° 35°
INVERSION (FOOT) 30° 20°
EVERSION (FOOT) 20° 20°
EXAMINATION OF THE LEFT ANKLE/FOOT: Examination of the left ankle/foot
revealed no soft tissue swelling. There was no tenderness to palpation. Sensation to light
touch was normal. Anterior drawer test was negative.
LEFT ANKLE/FOOT
RANGE OF MOTION NORMAL | CLAIMANT
DORSIFLEXION (ANKLE) 20° 10°
PLANTAR FLEXION (ANKLE) 40° 35°
INVERSION (FOOT) 30° 20°
EVERSION (FOOT) 20° 20°
DIAGNOSES: The claimant presents with diagnoses of:
1 Right shoulder strain, status post surgery, recovered.
2. Right hip contusion, resolved.
3. Left ankle sprain, status post surgery, recovered.
DISCUSSION:
The claimant has the pre-existing condition of degenerative joint disease of the right hip.
TREATMENT:
No further physical therapy or orthopedic treatment would be reasonable or necessary for the
accident of record.
Tenderness is subjective. Upon examination, the claimant did exhibit decreased range of
motion. It should be noted that the findings of range of motion testing are subjective and
represent voluntary movements, which are fully under the control of the claimant being
examined. The end point of ROM measured is determined by the claimant, which is
subjective. These decreased range of motion findings are also not substantiated by any
objective abnormalities on neurologic examination and by observed behavior.
DISABILITY:
I find no orthopedic disability based on the physical examination at this time. This is also
based upon the available medical documentation, which was reviewed.
PERMANENCY:
There is no permanency in regard to the right shoulder, right hip, or left ankle.
PROGNOSIS: Good.
6|Page
9 of 16
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony
Examination Date: April 3, 2024
All opinions expressed are based upon a reasonable degree of medical certainty.
I do not have a physician/patient relationship with the claimant.
I, Matthew S. Mendez-Zfass, M.D., being a Diplomate of the American Board of Orthopaedic
Surgery, am duly licensed to practice medicine in the State of New York. I affirm, under the
penalties of perjury, that the information contained within this document was prepared and is
the work product of the undersigned, and is true to the best of my knowledge and
information.
My opinions and conclusions are based solely upon the review of the records submitted as
well as the results of my examination, if applicable. There is no conflict of interest known to
me regarding this specific case. I have received no financial incentive or compensation that is
dependent in any way on the opinion I have rendered.
It is understood that no doctor/patient relationship exists or is implied by this examination.
This individual was examined with reference to the specific complaints emanating from the
original injury. Any other medical conditions, which were either unreported or felt to be
unrelated to the original injury are considered to be beyond the scope of this examination.
I, Matthew S. Mendez-Zfass, M.D., hereby affirm pursuant to CPLR 2106 under the penalties
of perjury that I am a physician, duly licensed to practice medicine in the State of New York
and I am not a party to the action herein. I further affirm pursuant to CPLR 2106 and under
the penalties of perjury that the statements made in this report are true and accurate.
If any additional information is made available for my review, I will be happy to re-evaluate
my position at that time.
Sincerely,
Matthew S. Mendez-Zfass, M.D.
Diplomate of American Board
of Orthopaedic Surgery
License # 275271
MM:at
7|Page
10 of 16
= INDEX NO. 525895/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony
Examination Date: April 3, 2024
NEW YorK PERSTA TE™
NER MIT”
cassD
a NG,
FRONY.SADE 2
19
02/15/2024
topes 94/25/2028
NONE
a |
ps
GV o& ‘ge8!
8|Page
11 of 16
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
Curriculum Vitae
Matthew “Teo” S Mendez-Zfass, MD
ee
Work History
. Lenox Hill Hospital, New York, NY 9/2015-
Present
Attending Physician in Private Practice at NY Orthopedics
Postgraduate Training
. Lenox Hill Hospital, New York, NY 8/2014-7/2015
Orthopaedic Sports Medicine Fellowship
. University of Miami/Jackson Health System 7/2010-6/2014
Orthopaedic Surgery Residency (Chief Administrative Resident)
. University of Miami/Jackson Health System, Miami, Florida 6/2009-6/2010
Orthopaedic Surgery Internship
Education
. University of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia 8/2001-5/2005
Bachelor of Physics and Economics, Minor in Chemistry
. Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia 7/2005-5/2009
Doctor of Medicine
Areas of Interest
. All aspects of Sports Medicine including Arthroscopic Knee, Shoulder, Hip and ankle surgery.
Total and partial joint replacement surgery of the knee and hip as well as General
Orthopedic Trauma.
Professional Society Membership
. American Orthopedic Society for Sports Medicine 2014-present
oO Member
1
12 of 16
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons 2009-present
O Member
Society of Military Orthopaedic Surgeons 2012-2013
Arthroscopy Association of North America 2013-present
O Member
AOA Emerging Leader Program 2013-present
AOTrauma Member 2014-2015
Team Coverage
Miami Marlins Fall 2012-2013
University of Miami Men’s Basketball 2010-2012
University of Miami Men’s Football 2010-2013
Miami Country Day School Varsity Football Fall 2012-2013
World Baseball Classic Spring 2013
0 Miami, Florida
University of Miami Men’s Baseball Spring 2013
New York Jets Fall 2014
New York Islanders Fall 2014-Spring 2015
Rye (New York) High School Football Fall 2014
Scarsdale (New York) High School Football Fall 2014-Present
Manhattansville College Fall 2014-Present
Rye (New York) High School Rugby Spring 2015
Queens College Fall 2015-Present
York College Fall 2016-Fall 2019
Administrative Service
. Emory University School of Medicine Class of 2009 2006-2009
Social and Athletic Chair
University of Miami Orthopaedic Resident selection committee 2012-2013
Resident Member
University of Miami Orthopaedic curriculum committee 2012-2013
Resident Member
Jackson Memorial Hospital Graduate Medical Education committee 2012-2014
Resident Member
University of Miami Hospital Resident Leadership Council 2012-2014
Representative for the Department of Orthopaedics
University of Miami Department of Orthopaedics 2013-2014
Administrative Chief Resident
Publications
Peer Reviewed Publications
Oak N, Mendez-Zfass M, Lesniak B, Larson CM, Kelly BT, Bedi A “Complications in Hip Arthroscopy”
Sports Medicine and Arthroscopy Review 2013 June;21(2)97-105.
13 of 16
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
Kalogeropoulos A, Lerakis S, Mendez-Zfass M, et al., “Right Ventricular Function in Patients with
Eisenmenger Physiology: Insights from Two Dimensional Strain Echocardiography” J Am Coll Cardiol,
2007; 49:a254-a271
Patel A, Mendez-Zfass M, Lebwhol N, Wang M, Levi A, Green B, Vanni S, Williams S. "Minimally
Invasive Versus Open Lumbar Fusion: A Comparison of Blood Loss, Surgical Complications, and
Hospital Course." The lowa orthopaedic journal 35 (2015): 130.
Falakassa J, Mendez-Zfass M, Eismont F, et al. “Case reviews of infections of the spine in patients
with a history of solid organ transplantation.” Spine. 2014 Sep 1;39(19):E1154-8
Poster Publications
Kalogeropoulos A, Georgiopoulu V, Arita T, Mendez-Zfass M, “Evaluation and Clinical
Correlation of Right Intraventricular Dyssynchrony in Patients with Pulmonary
Hypertension: Insights from Two-Dimensional Strain Echocardiography” presented at the
American Society of Echocardiography 18 Annual Scientific Sessions, Seattle, Wa. June 16-20,
2007
Williams S, Mendez-Zfass M, “Evaluation of blood loss and operative time in single level PLIF, mis-
TLIF and PLF” Florida Orthopaedic Society 2014 Annual Meeting,
Book Chapters
Vilella F, Mendez-Zfass M, Ficco R. “Femoral Shaft Fractures” Contemporary Surgical
Management of Fractures and Complications. Ed. Asif Ilyas, Saqib Rehman. Jaypee Brothers
Medical Publishing, 2013.
Mendez-Zfass M, Owens P, Horschander A. “Carpal Tunnel Release B: Endoscopic “ Operative
Procedures
in Plastic, Aesthetic
and Reconstructive Surgery. Ed. Thaller, SR, Salgado CJ, Kasira W,
HoschanderAS. London: Informa Healthcare, 2014.
Mendez-Zfass M, Bedi A, Lesniak B. “Natural History of Anterior Shoulder Instability” Controversies in
Shoulder Instability. Ed. Dodson CC, Dines DM, Walch G, Williams G. Philidelphia, PA Lippincott
Williams & Wilkins, 2013.
Montgomery K, Mendez-Zfass M, Willis A. “Physical Examination of the Elbow” Musculoskeletal
Physical Examination: An Evidence-Based Approach. Ed MalangaG, Mautner K. Philidelphia PA Elsevier
2017.
Video Productions
Wong C, Mendez-Zfass M, Owens P, Horschander A. “Carpal Tunnel Release: Endoscopic Technique
“ Operative Procedures in Plastic, Aesthetic and Reconstructive Surgery. Ed. Thaller, SR, Salgado CJ,
Kasira W, Hoschander AS. London: Informa Healthcare, 2013. (Publication in Process)
Non-Peer Reviewed Publications
Mendez-Zfass, , “Is Ejection Fraction an Appropriate Measure of Left Ventricular Systolic Function
in Patients With Severe Pulmonary Hypertension?” Medical Research Review 2006, EUSOM
Mendez-Zfass, M “Comprehensive procedure for Radio guided Breast Lumpectomy”,
Department of Physics Undergraduate Research Symposium 2005, University of Virginia.
3
14 of 16
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
Presentations
Mendez-Zfass, M “Natural History of Anterior Shoulder Dislocation” University of Miami
Orthopedic Surgery Grand Rounds, January 2013
Mendez-Zfass, M “ICD-10: The Codes They are A-Changin’” University of Miamu Orthopedic
Surgery Grand Rounds, February 2014
Mendez-Zfass, M “Combined PCL and MCL Knee Injuries: Insights from Biomechanics to
Clinical Practice” Tri-County Orthopedics Lecture Series, December 2014
Mendez-Zfass, M “Meniscal Injuries and Repair: Back to the Future?” Tri-County
Orthopedics Lecture Series, February 2015
Mendez-Zfass, “Allograft Elbow Ulnar Collateral Ligament Reconstruction” Lenox Hill
Alumni Day, June 2015
Mendez-Zfass, M “Concussion and Return to Play” James A. Nicholas Sports Medicine
Symposium, Nov. 2016
CONFERENCES ATTENDED
AANA Resident Arthroscopy Course, Rosemont, Il, Oct 24-27, 2013
AANA Annual Meeting, Hollywood, Fl. May 1-3.
AOA 2013 Annual Meeting, Denver, CO, June 11-15, 2013
AOA Resident Leadership Forum, Denver, CO, June 11-13, 2013
Florida Orthopaedic Society Annual Meeting, Largo, FL, June 1-2, 2013
Medtronic Spine + Science + Management Program, Miami, FL, April 26-28, 2012
AAOS 2014 Annual Meeting, New Orleans, LA March 11-16, 2014
AO Basic Fracture Management for Residents, Atlanta, Ga Sept 14-18, 2011
AO Advanced Fracture Management for Residents, San Diego, CA. March 20-23, 2014
AO Solutions Course for Problem Fractures, Miami Beach, FL April 23-26
DePuy Residents Review Course, San Diego, CA, August 4-6, 2011
AO Spine Principles and Treatment of Spinal Disorders, Las Vegas, NV January 21-24,
2011
NuVasive Cadaveric & Educational Lab, Miami, FL, August 20-21, 2010
Stryker Foot and Ankle Reconstruction Fellows Course, Ft. Lauderdale, FL. Sept 19-20,
2009
Musculoskeletal Oncology Review, Islamorada, FL, June 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012,
2013,2014
Smith And Nephew Fellows Arthroscopy Course, Boston, MA September 7-9, 2014
Carlsbad Cartilage Course Carlsbad, CA, January 23-24, 2014
AAOS 2015 Annual Meeting, Las Vegas, NV, March 24-28, 2015.
Depuy Advanced Fellows Arthroscopy Course, Miami, FL, May 1-2, 2015.
AOSSM 2015 Annual Meeting
AAOS 2016 Annual Meeting
AAOS 2017 Annual Meeting
15 of 16
INDEX NO. 525895/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024
References
Residency Program Director: Sheila Conway, MD Associate Professor of Orthopedics at
University of Miami
Oo Phone: (305)689-7600 Email: sconway@med.miami.edu
Residency Chairman: Frank Eismont, MD Professor of Orthopedics at University of Miami
0 Ennil: feismont@med.miami.edu
Residency Vice-Chairman: H. Thomas Temple, MD Professor of Orthopedics at University
of Miami
O Email: htemple@med.miami.edu
Residency Sports Medicine Director: Lee Kaplan, MD Professor of Orthopedics at
University of Miami
0 Email: kaplan@med.miami.edu
Fellowship Program Director: Barton Nisonson, MD Director of Sports Medicine, Lenox
Hill Hospital
O Phone: (212)570-9120 Email: bnisonson@aol.com
16 of 16
Preview
INDEX NO. 525895/2022 FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 04/22/2024 10:56 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK wee ee ee ee ee eee eee eee eee eee eee EBONY MCGIRT, Index No.: 525895/2022 Plaintiff, -against- EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE ARCHBISHOP JOHN HUGHES KNIGHTS OF COLUMBUS #481 INC. AND NEW YORK SMSA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP D/B/A VERIZON WIRELESS, Defendants. wee ee ee ee ee eee eee eee eee eee eee ARCHBISHOP JOHN HUGHES KNIGHTS OF COLUMBUS #481 INC. AND J OHN HUGHES CLUB, INC. I/S/H/A ARCHBISHOP J OHN HUGHES KNIGHTS OF COLUMBUS #481 INC., Third-P arty Plaintiffs, -against- THE GUILD FOR EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN, INC., Third-P arty Defendant. wee eee eee ee eee ee eee eee ee eee eee Defendants/third-party plaintiffs Archbishop J ohn Hughes Knights of Columbus #481 Inc. and J ohn Hughes Club, Inc., by their attorneys, Gannon, Rosenfarb & Drossman, as and for their response to plaintiff's request for disclosure for material relating to experts, sets forth the following: 1 Identity of Expert: Matthew S. Mendez-Zfass, M.D., 421 Ocean Parkway, Brooklyn, New York 11218. 2 Subject Matter of Testimony: Dr. Mendez-Zfass’ testimony will relate to plaintiffs physical condition, nature of the injuries complained of, his findings pursuant to his medical examination of plaintiff and his review of plaintiff's medical records and films, the causal relation, or lack thereof, of the accident to the injuries complained of, the need, if any, for further medical treatment or therapy, whether 1 of 16 INDEX NO. 525895/2022 FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 04/22/2024 10:56 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 or not there is any disability resulting from the alleged injury and other items relating to his examination of plaintiff, his review of medical records and films, and the medical report annexed hereto. 3 Substance of Facts and Opinions: It is expected that Dr. Mendez-Zfass will testify, in accordance with his findings and opinions set forth in the annexed report. 4 Qualifications: For Dr. Mendez-Zfass’ qualifications, please see annexed curriculum vitae. 5 Grounds of Opinion: The grounds of Dr. Mendez-Zfass’ opinions are the medical records and films supplied by plaintiff, Dr. Mendez-Zfass’ examination of plaintiff, his expertise as an orthopedist, all other grounds set forth in Dr. Mendez-Zfass’ medical report annexed hereto, and any evidence admitted by the Court at the trial of this matter. Defendants/third-party plaintiffs reserve the right to supplement any and all foregoing responses up until the time of trial as further records and information becomes available. Dated: New York, New York April 22, 2024 4. Shia By: J ohn H. Shin Gannon, Rosenfarb & Drossman Attorneys for Defendant ArchbishopJ ohn Hughes Knights of Columbus #481 Inc. andJ ohn Hughes Club, Inc. i/s/hfa Archbishop J ohn Hughes Knights of Columbus #481 Inc. 250 Broadway, 25th Floor New York, New York 10038 (212) 655-5000 TO Service Via Efile Shulman & Hill Attorneys for Plaintiff One State Street Plaza — 15th Floor New York, New York 10004 2 of 16 INDEX NO. 525895/2022 FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 04/22/2024 10:56 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 New York SMSA Limited Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless — Discontinued Third Party Action — Discontinued 3 of 16 INDEX NO. 525895/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 Matthew S. Mendez-Zfass, M.D. Diplomate of American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery 421 Ocean Parkway, Brooklyn, NY 11218 Examination Date: April 3, 2024 Report Date: April 12, 2024 Gannon, Rosenfarb & Drossman 250 Broadway 25th Floor New York, NY 10007 Attn: Melisa Giles Re: McGirt, Ebony Claim #: 3622990-1 EW/GC Case #: 22266514 DOI: 6/23/22 Specialty Requested: :3 Orthopedic Surgery Request Type: Liability IME To Whom It May Concern: I performed an independent orthopedic examination on the above claimant on 4/03/24 in my Brooklyn, New York office. The claimant provided valid photo identification. The claimant reported she took an Uber to the examination today. The findings of my examination are noted below: WORK HISTORY: The claimant was employed full-time as a direct support professional when the 6/23/22 accident occurred. She states that she missed time from work following the accident. Ms. McGirt is currently not working. INJURY HISTORY: Ms. McGirt states that she was involved in an accident on 6/23/22. She explains that she fell inside a closet over a wooden block that was bolted in the floor. The claimant sustained reported injuries to the neck, mid-back, lower back, right shoulder, and right hip. There were no reported lacerations or a claimed loss of consciousness. Ms. McGirt went to the Woodhull Hospital Emergency Room, on her own on 6/24/22, where she had radiology testing performed of the left ankle, was provided with an Ace bandage and crutches and released the same day. PAST MEDICAL HISTORY: The claimant did not report a history of serious illness. The claimant denied being involved in any prior motor vehicle or workers’ compensation accidents or sustaining any prior injuries. 4 of 16 INDEX NO. 525895/2022 FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 04/22/2024 10:56 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony Examination Date: April 3, 2024 PRIOR/UNRELATED SURGICAL HISTORY: The claimant did not report any prior/unrelated surgical history. MEDICATION USE: The claimant indicated she is currently using medication, which includes “muscle relaxers.” TREATMENT HISTORY TO DATE: The claimant was treated with medication, physical therapy, and injections. She is no longer receiving physical therapy. Ms. McGirt was provided with medical supplies which included a cane. Ms. McGirt noted that she underwent lower back surgery in 2023, right shoulder surgery in 2022, and left ankle surgery in 2023. MEDICAL RECORDS REVIEWED: e Verified Bill of Particulars (Index No: 525895/2022) dated 4/14/23. e EMG/Nerve conduction studies report from Health East Medical Alliance, dated 03/21/23. Impression: (1) The above electrodiagnostic study reveals evidence of a mild bilateral sensory median nerve neuropathy at the wrist. This is consistent with the clinical diagnosis of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. (2) The above electrodiagnostic study reveals evidence of left C5 - C6 and right C6-C7 nerve root irritation. Evaluation report from Brooklyn Premier Orthopedic Center for Musculoskeletal Disorders, dated 12/01/22 to 01/10/23. ED provider note report from Adrian Llewellyn, PA, dated 06/24/22. ED notes report from Natasha Fontaine, Rn, dated 06/24/22. Dc tibia fibula 2 view left from Adrian Llewellyn, PA, dated 06/24/22. Impression: No acute fractures. DX foot complete left from Adrian Llewellyn, PA, dated 06/24/22. Impression: No acute fractures noted. DX foot complete right from Adrian Llewellyn, PA, dated 06/24/22. Impression : No acute fractures noted. DX ankle comp right from Adrian Llewellyn, PA, dated 06/24/22. Impression: No acute fractures noted. DX tibia fibula 2 views right from Adrian Llewellyn, PA, dated 06/24/22. Impression: No acute fractures. MRI report of the left ankle from Stand-Up MRI of Manhattan, PC, dated 08/01/22. Impression: Sprain of lateral ligaments. Contusion distal cuboid. - Tibialis anterior tendinopathy with peritendinous edema. Extensor digitorum tendinopathy with fraying at the myotendinous junction. Achilles tendinopathy. MRI report of the right hip from Stand-Up MRI of Manhattan, PC, dated 08/01/22. Impression: Arthrosis of the sacroiliac joints and pubic symphysis. Cam deformity 2|Page 5 of 16 INDEX NO. 525895/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony Examination Date: April 3, 2024 with moderate arthrosis, diffuse labral tear, and joint effusion. Gluteal tendinopathy with low-grade tear at the greater trochanter with soft tissue edema. Hamstring tendinopathy with moderate-grade tearing at the origin. MRI report of the lumbar spine from Stand-Up MRI of Manhattan, PC, dated 07/28/22. Impression: L2-3 posterior broad based central and peripheral disc bulging. L3-4 posterior broad based central disc bulge with peripheral increased bulging into the bilateral left greater than right foramina. Facet hypertrophic change on the left greater than right with trace facet fluid. L4-5 posterior broad based central disc bulging with peripheral bulging extending into the left greater than right foramina. Facet hypertrophic change. L5-S1 posterior broad based central disc bulging. Findings consistent with inflammatory/noninfectious posterior paraspinal fasciitis. MRI report of the right shoulder min 2 views from Lenox Hill Radiology, dated 07/19/22. Impression: No abnormality of the right shoulder. MRI report of the cervical spine from Stand-Up MRI of Manhattan, PC, dated 03/02/23. Impression: (1) Straightening of the cervical lordosis. (2) C4/5: Posterior disc bulge impinging on the anterior thecal sac. (3) C5/6: Broad-based 2-3 mm posterior disc herniation impinging on the anterior thecal sac. Flattening of the anterior cord. (4) C6/7: Posterior subligamentous disc bulge impinging on the anterior thecal sac. (5) Bone marrow is hypointense likely related to residual red marrow but clinical correlation is suggested for anemia or other hematopoietic abnormality which may result in this appearance. Small lesion in the posterior C5 vertebra, nonspecific but most compatible with a hemangioma. Periodic follow-up is suggested to assess stability. (6) Findings compatible with pharyngeal and lingual tonsillar hypertrophy. Findings compatible with adenoidal hyperplasia. (7) The thyroid is partly seen and appears somewhat generous in size, nonspecific with no discrete lesion seen. Correlation with clinical exam and history is suggested. (8) Multiple small and a few top normal cervical lymph nodes, nonspecific, some of which may be reactive/inflammatory. Correlation with clinical examination and history is suggested. MRI report of the right shoulder from Stand-Up MRI of Manhattan, PC, dated 07/28/22. Impression: (1) Inhomogeneity of the supraspinatus tendon distally representing tendinosis/tendinopathy. Peritendinous edema and inflammation that obscures the peritendinous fat. (2) Fluid in the long head of biceps tendon sheath with evidence for tenosynovitis. (3) Synovial effusion accumulating at the axillary recess of the glenohumeral joint extending into the subscapularis recess. (4) Acromioclavicular joint space narrowing with hypertrophic change. Subcortical reactive bone marrow edema involving the inferior subarticular margin of the clavicle. Slightly anteriorly downsloping type II acromial configuration. Physical therapy initial evaluation report from Health East Medical Alliance, dated 07/11/22. Physical therapy visit report from Health East Medical Alliance, dated 07/12/22 to 11/28/22. 3|Page 6 of 16 INDEX NO. 525895/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony Examination Date: April 3, 2024 PHYSICAL DESCRIPTION: The claimant is a 34-year-old female who stands 5’ 6” tall and weighs 260 Ibs. She has brown eyes and brown hair. The claimant stated being right-hand dominant. SYMPTOMS DESCRIPTION: This individual stated that she feels pain in the neck, mid-back, lower back, right shoulder, and right hip. She started her treatments 7 days after the accident occurred. When asked if she feels better now, compared to when she started treatments, she replied she does “not really” feel better. Her relief lasted for “an hour or so” after her treatments. On a pain scale from 1 to 10 (10 being the worst) her pain is a “7.5”. She indicated she took pain medication today, which helped with the pain “a little”. She describes her pain as burning, sharp, stabbing, and tingling. She has shooting pain down her leg and arm. She can walk 1 block before being in too much pain. She has difficulty with stairs. She can sit for “2 minutes” before being in too much pain. Bending, walking, and sleeping make the pain worse. She is also experiencing locking, clicking, numbness, and tingling. She reported she is no longer able to do “daily life activities”, clean, cook, or engage with her children due to this accident. She reported she needs assistance with cooking and cleaning. PHYSICAL EXAMINATION: GENERAL OBSERVATIONS: The claimant had a normal appearance and posture. The claimant was using a straight cane. She was asked to inform me as to any pain or tenderness during the examination. All ROM measurements were taken with the aid of a standard hand-held goniometer. ROM normal values are in accordance with both the NYS WC guidelines and AMA guidelines. EXAMINATION OF THE RIGHT SHOULDER: Examination of the right shoulder revealed tenderness to palpation. There was no effusion. Muscle atrophy was negative. No crepitus was noted. Impingement sign was positive. O’Brien’s test was negative. Crank test was positive. Apprehension test was negative. RIGHT SHOULDER ACTIVE RANGE OF MOTION | NORMAL | CLAIMANT ABDUCTION 180° 100° ADDUCTION 30° 30° FORWARD FLEXION 180° 90° EXTENSION 60° 45° INTERNAL ROTATION 80° 60° EXTERNAL ROTATION go° 60° There was suboptimal effort during the examination. A|Page 7 of 16 UD OUN IK 04 AW INDEX NO. 525895/2022 NYSCEF BOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony Examination Date: April 3, 2024 EXAMINATION OF THE LEFT SHOULDER: Examination of the left shoulder revealed tenderness to palpation. There was no effusion. Muscle atrophy was negative. No crepitus was noted. Impingement sign was negative. O’Brien’s test was negative. Crank test was positive. Apprehension test was negative. LEFT SHOULDER ACTIVE RANGE OF MOTION | NORMAL | CLAIMANT ABDUCTION 180° 105° ADDUCTION 30° 30° FORWARD FLEXION 180° 105° EXTENSION 60° 45° INTERNAL ROTATION 80° 60° EXTERNAL ROTATION go° 55° EXAMINATION OF THE RIGHT HIP: Examination of the right hip revealed tenderness to palpation to the trochanteric aspect. FABER test was negative. FADDIR test was positive. RIGHT HIP RANGE OF MOTION NORMAL | CLAIMANT FORWARD FLEXION 120° 75° EXTENSION 30° 10° ABDUCTION 45° 25° ADDUCTION 35° 10° EXTERNAL ROTATION 45° 25° 5° INTERNAL ROTATION 45° EXAMINATION OF THE LEFT HIP: Examination of the left hip revealed no tenderness to palpation. FABER test was negative. FADDIR test was negative. LEFT HIP RANGE OF MOTION NORMAL | CLAIMANT FORWARD FLEXION 120° 85° EXTENSION 30° 15° ABDUCTION 45° 25° ADDUCTION 35° 10° EXTERNAL ROTATION 45° 25° INTERNAL ROTATION 45° 10° EXAMINATION OF THE RIGHT ANKLE/FOOT: Examination of the right ankle/foot revealed no soft tissue swelling. There was no tenderness to palpation. Sensation to light touch was normal. Anterior drawer test was negative. 5|Page 8 of 16 INDEX NO. 525895/2022 FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 04/22/2024 10:56 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF 04/22/2024 Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony Examination Date: April 3, 2024 RIGHT ANKLE/FOOT RANGE OF MOTION NORMAL | CLAIMANT DORSIFLEXION (ANKLE) 20° 10° PLANTAR FLEXION (ANKLE) 40° 35° INVERSION (FOOT) 30° 20° EVERSION (FOOT) 20° 20° EXAMINATION OF THE LEFT ANKLE/FOOT: Examination of the left ankle/foot revealed no soft tissue swelling. There was no tenderness to palpation. Sensation to light touch was normal. Anterior drawer test was negative. LEFT ANKLE/FOOT RANGE OF MOTION NORMAL | CLAIMANT DORSIFLEXION (ANKLE) 20° 10° PLANTAR FLEXION (ANKLE) 40° 35° INVERSION (FOOT) 30° 20° EVERSION (FOOT) 20° 20° DIAGNOSES: The claimant presents with diagnoses of: 1 Right shoulder strain, status post surgery, recovered. 2. Right hip contusion, resolved. 3. Left ankle sprain, status post surgery, recovered. DISCUSSION: The claimant has the pre-existing condition of degenerative joint disease of the right hip. TREATMENT: No further physical therapy or orthopedic treatment would be reasonable or necessary for the accident of record. Tenderness is subjective. Upon examination, the claimant did exhibit decreased range of motion. It should be noted that the findings of range of motion testing are subjective and represent voluntary movements, which are fully under the control of the claimant being examined. The end point of ROM measured is determined by the claimant, which is subjective. These decreased range of motion findings are also not substantiated by any objective abnormalities on neurologic examination and by observed behavior. DISABILITY: I find no orthopedic disability based on the physical examination at this time. This is also based upon the available medical documentation, which was reviewed. PERMANENCY: There is no permanency in regard to the right shoulder, right hip, or left ankle. PROGNOSIS: Good. 6|Page 9 of 16 INDEX NO. 525895/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony Examination Date: April 3, 2024 All opinions expressed are based upon a reasonable degree of medical certainty. I do not have a physician/patient relationship with the claimant. I, Matthew S. Mendez-Zfass, M.D., being a Diplomate of the American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery, am duly licensed to practice medicine in the State of New York. I affirm, under the penalties of perjury, that the information contained within this document was prepared and is the work product of the undersigned, and is true to the best of my knowledge and information. My opinions and conclusions are based solely upon the review of the records submitted as well as the results of my examination, if applicable. There is no conflict of interest known to me regarding this specific case. I have received no financial incentive or compensation that is dependent in any way on the opinion I have rendered. It is understood that no doctor/patient relationship exists or is implied by this examination. This individual was examined with reference to the specific complaints emanating from the original injury. Any other medical conditions, which were either unreported or felt to be unrelated to the original injury are considered to be beyond the scope of this examination. I, Matthew S. Mendez-Zfass, M.D., hereby affirm pursuant to CPLR 2106 under the penalties of perjury that I am a physician, duly licensed to practice medicine in the State of New York and I am not a party to the action herein. I further affirm pursuant to CPLR 2106 and under the penalties of perjury that the statements made in this report are true and accurate. If any additional information is made available for my review, I will be happy to re-evaluate my position at that time. Sincerely, Matthew S. Mendez-Zfass, M.D. Diplomate of American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery License # 275271 MM:at 7|Page 10 of 16 = INDEX NO. 525895/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 Examinee Name: McGirt, Ebony Examination Date: April 3, 2024 NEW YorK PERSTA TE™ NER MIT” cassD a NG, FRONY.SADE 2 19 02/15/2024 topes 94/25/2028 NONE a | ps GV o& ‘ge8! 8|Page 11 of 16 INDEX NO. 525895/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 Curriculum Vitae Matthew “Teo” S Mendez-Zfass, MD ee Work History . Lenox Hill Hospital, New York, NY 9/2015- Present Attending Physician in Private Practice at NY Orthopedics Postgraduate Training . Lenox Hill Hospital, New York, NY 8/2014-7/2015 Orthopaedic Sports Medicine Fellowship . University of Miami/Jackson Health System 7/2010-6/2014 Orthopaedic Surgery Residency (Chief Administrative Resident) . University of Miami/Jackson Health System, Miami, Florida 6/2009-6/2010 Orthopaedic Surgery Internship Education . University of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia 8/2001-5/2005 Bachelor of Physics and Economics, Minor in Chemistry . Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia 7/2005-5/2009 Doctor of Medicine Areas of Interest . All aspects of Sports Medicine including Arthroscopic Knee, Shoulder, Hip and ankle surgery. Total and partial joint replacement surgery of the knee and hip as well as General Orthopedic Trauma. Professional Society Membership . American Orthopedic Society for Sports Medicine 2014-present oO Member 1 12 of 16 INDEX NO. 525895/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons 2009-present O Member Society of Military Orthopaedic Surgeons 2012-2013 Arthroscopy Association of North America 2013-present O Member AOA Emerging Leader Program 2013-present AOTrauma Member 2014-2015 Team Coverage Miami Marlins Fall 2012-2013 University of Miami Men’s Basketball 2010-2012 University of Miami Men’s Football 2010-2013 Miami Country Day School Varsity Football Fall 2012-2013 World Baseball Classic Spring 2013 0 Miami, Florida University of Miami Men’s Baseball Spring 2013 New York Jets Fall 2014 New York Islanders Fall 2014-Spring 2015 Rye (New York) High School Football Fall 2014 Scarsdale (New York) High School Football Fall 2014-Present Manhattansville College Fall 2014-Present Rye (New York) High School Rugby Spring 2015 Queens College Fall 2015-Present York College Fall 2016-Fall 2019 Administrative Service . Emory University School of Medicine Class of 2009 2006-2009 Social and Athletic Chair University of Miami Orthopaedic Resident selection committee 2012-2013 Resident Member University of Miami Orthopaedic curriculum committee 2012-2013 Resident Member Jackson Memorial Hospital Graduate Medical Education committee 2012-2014 Resident Member University of Miami Hospital Resident Leadership Council 2012-2014 Representative for the Department of Orthopaedics University of Miami Department of Orthopaedics 2013-2014 Administrative Chief Resident Publications Peer Reviewed Publications Oak N, Mendez-Zfass M, Lesniak B, Larson CM, Kelly BT, Bedi A “Complications in Hip Arthroscopy” Sports Medicine and Arthroscopy Review 2013 June;21(2)97-105. 13 of 16 INDEX NO. 525895/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 Kalogeropoulos A, Lerakis S, Mendez-Zfass M, et al., “Right Ventricular Function in Patients with Eisenmenger Physiology: Insights from Two Dimensional Strain Echocardiography” J Am Coll Cardiol, 2007; 49:a254-a271 Patel A, Mendez-Zfass M, Lebwhol N, Wang M, Levi A, Green B, Vanni S, Williams S. "Minimally Invasive Versus Open Lumbar Fusion: A Comparison of Blood Loss, Surgical Complications, and Hospital Course." The lowa orthopaedic journal 35 (2015): 130. Falakassa J, Mendez-Zfass M, Eismont F, et al. “Case reviews of infections of the spine in patients with a history of solid organ transplantation.” Spine. 2014 Sep 1;39(19):E1154-8 Poster Publications Kalogeropoulos A, Georgiopoulu V, Arita T, Mendez-Zfass M, “Evaluation and Clinical Correlation of Right Intraventricular Dyssynchrony in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension: Insights from Two-Dimensional Strain Echocardiography” presented at the American Society of Echocardiography 18 Annual Scientific Sessions, Seattle, Wa. June 16-20, 2007 Williams S, Mendez-Zfass M, “Evaluation of blood loss and operative time in single level PLIF, mis- TLIF and PLF” Florida Orthopaedic Society 2014 Annual Meeting, Book Chapters Vilella F, Mendez-Zfass M, Ficco R. “Femoral Shaft Fractures” Contemporary Surgical Management of Fractures and Complications. Ed. Asif Ilyas, Saqib Rehman. Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishing, 2013. Mendez-Zfass M, Owens P, Horschander A. “Carpal Tunnel Release B: Endoscopic “ Operative Procedures in Plastic, Aesthetic and Reconstructive Surgery. Ed. Thaller, SR, Salgado CJ, Kasira W, HoschanderAS. London: Informa Healthcare, 2014. Mendez-Zfass M, Bedi A, Lesniak B. “Natural History of Anterior Shoulder Instability” Controversies in Shoulder Instability. Ed. Dodson CC, Dines DM, Walch G, Williams G. Philidelphia, PA Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, 2013. Montgomery K, Mendez-Zfass M, Willis A. “Physical Examination of the Elbow” Musculoskeletal Physical Examination: An Evidence-Based Approach. Ed MalangaG, Mautner K. Philidelphia PA Elsevier 2017. Video Productions Wong C, Mendez-Zfass M, Owens P, Horschander A. “Carpal Tunnel Release: Endoscopic Technique “ Operative Procedures in Plastic, Aesthetic and Reconstructive Surgery. Ed. Thaller, SR, Salgado CJ, Kasira W, Hoschander AS. London: Informa Healthcare, 2013. (Publication in Process) Non-Peer Reviewed Publications Mendez-Zfass, , “Is Ejection Fraction an Appropriate Measure of Left Ventricular Systolic Function in Patients With Severe Pulmonary Hypertension?” Medical Research Review 2006, EUSOM Mendez-Zfass, M “Comprehensive procedure for Radio guided Breast Lumpectomy”, Department of Physics Undergraduate Research Symposium 2005, University of Virginia. 3 14 of 16 INDEX NO. 525895/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 Presentations Mendez-Zfass, M “Natural History of Anterior Shoulder Dislocation” University of Miami Orthopedic Surgery Grand Rounds, January 2013 Mendez-Zfass, M “ICD-10: The Codes They are A-Changin’” University of Miamu Orthopedic Surgery Grand Rounds, February 2014 Mendez-Zfass, M “Combined PCL and MCL Knee Injuries: Insights from Biomechanics to Clinical Practice” Tri-County Orthopedics Lecture Series, December 2014 Mendez-Zfass, M “Meniscal Injuries and Repair: Back to the Future?” Tri-County Orthopedics Lecture Series, February 2015 Mendez-Zfass, “Allograft Elbow Ulnar Collateral Ligament Reconstruction” Lenox Hill Alumni Day, June 2015 Mendez-Zfass, M “Concussion and Return to Play” James A. Nicholas Sports Medicine Symposium, Nov. 2016 CONFERENCES ATTENDED AANA Resident Arthroscopy Course, Rosemont, Il, Oct 24-27, 2013 AANA Annual Meeting, Hollywood, Fl. May 1-3. AOA 2013 Annual Meeting, Denver, CO, June 11-15, 2013 AOA Resident Leadership Forum, Denver, CO, June 11-13, 2013 Florida Orthopaedic Society Annual Meeting, Largo, FL, June 1-2, 2013 Medtronic Spine + Science + Management Program, Miami, FL, April 26-28, 2012 AAOS 2014 Annual Meeting, New Orleans, LA March 11-16, 2014 AO Basic Fracture Management for Residents, Atlanta, Ga Sept 14-18, 2011 AO Advanced Fracture Management for Residents, San Diego, CA. March 20-23, 2014 AO Solutions Course for Problem Fractures, Miami Beach, FL April 23-26 DePuy Residents Review Course, San Diego, CA, August 4-6, 2011 AO Spine Principles and Treatment of Spinal Disorders, Las Vegas, NV January 21-24, 2011 NuVasive Cadaveric & Educational Lab, Miami, FL, August 20-21, 2010 Stryker Foot and Ankle Reconstruction Fellows Course, Ft. Lauderdale, FL. Sept 19-20, 2009 Musculoskeletal Oncology Review, Islamorada, FL, June 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013,2014 Smith And Nephew Fellows Arthroscopy Course, Boston, MA September 7-9, 2014 Carlsbad Cartilage Course Carlsbad, CA, January 23-24, 2014 AAOS 2015 Annual Meeting, Las Vegas, NV, March 24-28, 2015. Depuy Advanced Fellows Arthroscopy Course, Miami, FL, May 1-2, 2015. AOSSM 2015 Annual Meeting AAOS 2016 Annual Meeting AAOS 2017 Annual Meeting 15 of 16 INDEX NO. 525895/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 41 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/22/2024 References Residency Program Director: Sheila Conway, MD Associate Professor of Orthopedics at University of Miami Oo Phone: (305)689-7600 Email: sconway@med.miami.edu Residency Chairman: Frank Eismont, MD Professor of Orthopedics at University of Miami 0 Ennil: feismont@med.miami.edu Residency Vice-Chairman: H. Thomas Temple, MD Professor of Orthopedics at University of Miami O Email: htemple@med.miami.edu Residency Sports Medicine Director: Lee Kaplan, MD Professor of Orthopedics at University of Miami 0 Email: kaplan@med.miami.edu Fellowship Program Director: Barton Nisonson, MD Director of Sports Medicine, Lenox Hill Hospital O Phone: (212)570-9120 Email: bnisonson@aol.com 16 of 16