On March 11, 2020 a
Geske Earl - MSJ_Exh D thru Q to the Decl EAM_20240418
was filed
involving a dispute between
Estate Of Earl Geske By Decedent'S Heirs Caroline Ann Geske,
Geske, Deborah Ann,
Geske, Elizabeth Marie,
Geske, Erline Susan,
Geski, Melinda Kristine,
and
Bina, Ioana Anca,
Farrag, Yasser,
Gazi, Tawhid,
Hayatdavoudi, Saman,
Queen Of The Valley Medical Center St. Joseph Health,
Schoeder, Bradley,
St. Joseph Health,
Yee, Alan,
for Medical Malpractice Unlimited (45)
in the District Court of Napa County.
Preview
1 Elisabeth A. Madden (SBN 131172)
emadden@maddenlynch.com
2 Philip T. Emmons (SBN 124902)
pemmons@maddenlynch.com
3 LAW OFFICES OF MADDEN & LYNCH PC
45 Belden Place, Suite 301
4 San Francisco, CA 94104
Telephone: (415) 851-5900
5 Facsimile: (415) 795-2332
6 Attorneys for Defendant
TAWHID GAZI, M.D.
7
8 IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
9 IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF NAPA
10 UNLIMITED JURISDICTION
11 ESTATE OF EARL GESKE BY DECEDENT’S HEIRS Case No.: 20CV000322
CAROLINE ANN GESKE; ELIZABETH MARIE
12 GESKE; DEBORAH ANN GESKE; ERLINE SUSAN EXHIBITS D THROUGH Q: DECLARATION
GESKE; and MELINDA KRISTINE GESKE, OF ELISABETH A. MADDEN IN SUPPORT
13 OF DEFENDANT TAWHID GAZI, M.D.’S
Plaintiffs, MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR,
14 IN THE ALTERNATIVE, SUMMARY
vs. ADJUDICATION
15
QUEEN OF THE VALLEY MEDICAL CENTER-ST. Date: July 12, 2024
16 JOSEPH HEALTH; IOANA ANCA BINA, M.D.; Time: 9:30 a.m.
TAWHID GAZI, M.D.; YASSER FARRAG, M.D.; Dept.: A, Hon. Cynthia P. Smith
17 ALLEN YEE, M.D.; BRADLEY SCHROEDER,
M.D.; SAMAN·HAYATDAVOUDI, M.D.; and FAC Filed: July 27, 2022
18 DOES 1-20, Complaint Filed: March 11, 2020
Trial Date: August 19, 2024
19 Defendants.
20
21 Exhibits D through Q submitted as Part 3 of 3 to the Declaration of Elisabeth A. Madden in
22 support of Defendant Tawhid Gazi, M.D.’s Motion for Summary Judgment or, in the Alternative,
23 Summary Adjudication previously uploaded in Odyssey Envelope #15068442.
24
25
Elisabeth A. Madden
Law Offices of 26
Madden & Lynch
45 Belden Place,
Suite 301
San Francisco, CA 27
94104
Ph (415) 851-5900
28
1
EXHS D THRU Q TO THE DECLARATION OF ELISABETH A. MADDEN
Exhibit D
Providence
Queen of the Valley
I, CHRISTINE COOLEY, declare as follows: Medical Center
1. Iam the duly authorized custodian of records of QUEEN OF THE VALLEY MEDICAL
CENTER, and I have authority to certify such records.
2. The copy attached to this declaration is a true copy of all of the records described in the
Subpoena/Authorization which are kept by or in possession of the witness.
3. The records were prepared by the personnel of the business named above in the ordinary
course of business at or near the time of the act, condition, or event.
4. Any records which are not furnished and which are described in the
Subpoena/Authorization are not within the possession, custody, or control of the witness.
5. The records enclosed pertain to:
EARL GESKE, MACRO PRO, 698780-1
6. The records were prepared in the following manner:
M Photocopy
H Computer generation
â–¡ Other:_________________________________________________________ .
I declare under penalty of perjury pursuant to the laws
of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed on this 14th day of APRIL________ ,, 20^, in Napa, California.
Christine Cooley
Senior Manager
Health Information Management
Northern California Region
Providence
0010
PROVIDENCE QUEEN OF THE VALLEY MEDICAL CENTER Geske, Earl F
1000 TRANCAS ST MRN: 20014431313, DOB: 6/ 11 /1942, Sex: M
NAPA CA 94558-2906 Adm: 11/9/2018, D/C: 12/14/2018
11/09/2018 -Admission (Discharged) in PROVIDENCE QUEEN OF THE VALLEY ICU (continued)
Hardcopy Scans (group 1 of 3) (continued)
Ag•/hK: 76 K
uni t t : OM022766S4
Attending: Schro• d•r. B ndl♦y Ill
Account • : av0087S4 H3S
I GESKE, BARL r Status : Disch â– r~d
lniti at•d: 11/09/18
Pag•
Print•d
12
Loe.tiQn: NQMIClJS. Maitt•d : ll/O!J/19 flt 1849 OO■pht•n 11/10/1& RD 11/10/18 0953 ""''
H¢ , Hc:t
lllh4tn placi ng POiat Transfusi o n Hgb , H= :
11/10/18 81118
""''
lJ Us• S.conda ry • • th• Orde r 8our,ce
2) let the or-dar'• pno r ity to 'l'i-d,
en-:1 enter ti.. e>eact de.t• lll'ld t i •• th•
11/10/18 R II
U/10/1!1 RN
11/10/18 MAN 11/10/18 II A 11/10/18 1'.3SO AS DIRECTED
11/10/18 MAN 11/10/18 1'.350 All DIRECTED
11/10/1!1 ~ 11/11/18 Ii: 8 11/10/18 1350 AS DlREC'TiD
11/10/18 MA.~ 11/11/18 E I 1 1/10/18 13SO DAI LY
• • In&♦ rt MSI\Ag• NG 00 Tut . U/10/18 MAN ll/ 10/18 tl A 11/10/18 1'.34S
• !IC N•bl KDI Vent/ 8 .i. PAP Pt Npr 11/10/lll ~ 12/03/18 PAR 11/10/18 13!,0 ""''
. Par RT ■♦di.c•uon
• RC N•b/ MOl V•nt./ RiPAP Pt. tlptc 11/10/18 MAN 11/13/18 SNV 11/1 0/18 1'.350 . P<>tc RT ••dicat:1.on
11/10/18 R D 11/ 10/18 R D 11/10/18 l'.348
llhen pl..:ing ~•t Ttcans fu • i on C!IC: ""''
1) use seconda r y H t.h• Order lourc•
2) let. th♦ order'• priority t.o Ti Md,
end • nter ti.. • x•ct dolt• ;rnd ti•• t h •
• • vent All. . . .... nt Adult / PIW 11/10/18 R D 11/10/18 1352 Q◄ IIR
• * VIU' Pr••• ntion Order ■11/10/18 J! D 11/ 16/18 l'l 8 1 1/ 10/ 18 lJSS 07, 19
11/13/18 224S 08,2 0
11/10/18 R 0 11/16/18 M B 11/10/18 13~5 07,1'
11/1'.3/18 2245 013, 20
11/10/18 R 0 11/ 16/18 J C 11/10/18 1'.3S5 00, 12
1 1/U/18 0 000 Oâ—„IIR
• * VIU' B..:I Chair PO■it ion 11/10/18 J! D 11/10/18 1'.355 OS, 12, 20
11/10/18 ll A 11/11/18 E B 11/10/18 U 27 oz,,,
• • Richaond Agitation B•dation IC'ale RAIS
11/10/18
11/10/18
NLR
S 8 11/ 16/11 l'l I
11/10/18
1 1/10/18
U Sll!i
lb37 ·"""
ou,,
11/10/18 Y • 11/17/18 AG 11/10/18 1S38 AB DIRECTED
• RC tt.b/ NDl V•ot/ 8.i. PAP Pt Npr 11/10/18 Y II 11/ 17/18 AG 11/10/18 1538 AS DlR.ECT! D
" RC I ntubate/ Extubat•/ De,cann 11/10/18 Y • 11/10/te Y w 1 1/10/18 1S38
• RC Veot Adult/HO Npr 11/10/18 Y II 11/17/18 AG 11/10/18 1602 ""''
AS DIRECTID
• C.re Plan Proble• Reatra1nts Non Violent 11/10/18 J! D 111 10/18 l'l B 1 1/10/18 1801 om
• • T ran■fu■• C riteria P R!IC 11/10/ 18 l'l I 11/ 11/18 " Z 11/10/18 19'.38
11/11/18 .mH ""''
• * D1aly■1 ■RH or- Labs 11/11/18 I 8 11/ 11/18 NJC 11/11/18 1122 AS DlRECTSD
• • Dialysis Treat-nt 11/11/18 I 8 11/ 11/ 18 UJC 11/11/18 1122 Al DIRECTED
ll/lâ—„ /16 8 T
• RC MD/ DD to RC ~--unication
11/lZ/lll
11/lZ/18
LG
l\ C 11/ 18/18 J "
11/12/18
11/12/18
0 031
""''
101115 AS 0111.EC'tl!O
• RD tlutrlt i onal Ass•■-• nt ADULT 11/12/18 J! 8
• Car• Plan RD Adult 11/lZ/18 J! 8
• * Inâ–
Preview
1 Elisabeth A. Madden (SBN 131172) emadden@maddenlynch.com 2 Philip T. Emmons (SBN 124902) pemmons@maddenlynch.com 3 LAW OFFICES OF MADDEN & LYNCH PC 45 Belden Place, Suite 301 4 San Francisco, CA 94104 Telephone: (415) 851-5900 5 Facsimile: (415) 795-2332 6 Attorneys for Defendant TAWHID GAZI, M.D. 7 8 IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 9 IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF NAPA 10 UNLIMITED JURISDICTION 11 ESTATE OF EARL GESKE BY DECEDENT’S HEIRS Case No.: 20CV000322 CAROLINE ANN GESKE; ELIZABETH MARIE 12 GESKE; DEBORAH ANN GESKE; ERLINE SUSAN EXHIBITS D THROUGH Q: DECLARATION GESKE; and MELINDA KRISTINE GESKE, OF ELISABETH A. MADDEN IN SUPPORT 13 OF DEFENDANT TAWHID GAZI, M.D.’S Plaintiffs, MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR, 14 IN THE ALTERNATIVE, SUMMARY vs. ADJUDICATION 15 QUEEN OF THE VALLEY MEDICAL CENTER-ST. Date: July 12, 2024 16 JOSEPH HEALTH; IOANA ANCA BINA, M.D.; Time: 9:30 a.m. TAWHID GAZI, M.D.; YASSER FARRAG, M.D.; Dept.: A, Hon. Cynthia P. Smith 17 ALLEN YEE, M.D.; BRADLEY SCHROEDER, M.D.; SAMAN·HAYATDAVOUDI, M.D.; and FAC Filed: July 27, 2022 18 DOES 1-20, Complaint Filed: March 11, 2020 Trial Date: August 19, 2024 19 Defendants. 20 21 Exhibits D through Q submitted as Part 3 of 3 to the Declaration of Elisabeth A. Madden in 22 support of Defendant Tawhid Gazi, M.D.’s Motion for Summary Judgment or, in the Alternative, 23 Summary Adjudication previously uploaded in Odyssey Envelope #15068442. 24 25 Elisabeth A. Madden Law Offices of 26 Madden & Lynch 45 Belden Place, Suite 301 San Francisco, CA 27 94104 Ph (415) 851-5900 28 1 EXHS D THRU Q TO THE DECLARATION OF ELISABETH A. MADDEN Exhibit D Providence Queen of the Valley I, CHRISTINE COOLEY, declare as follows: Medical Center 1. Iam the duly authorized custodian of records of QUEEN OF THE VALLEY MEDICAL CENTER, and I have authority to certify such records. 2. The copy attached to this declaration is a true copy of all of the records described in the Subpoena/Authorization which are kept by or in possession of the witness. 3. The records were prepared by the personnel of the business named above in the ordinary course of business at or near the time of the act, condition, or event. 4. Any records which are not furnished and which are described in the Subpoena/Authorization are not within the possession, custody, or control of the witness. 5. The records enclosed pertain to: EARL GESKE, MACRO PRO, 698780-1 6. The records were prepared in the following manner: M Photocopy H Computer generation â–¡ Other:_________________________________________________________ . I declare under penalty of perjury pursuant to the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on this 14th day of APRIL________ ,, 20^, in Napa, California. Christine Cooley Senior Manager Health Information Management Northern California Region Providence 0010 PROVIDENCE QUEEN OF THE VALLEY MEDICAL CENTER Geske, Earl F 1000 TRANCAS ST MRN: 20014431313, DOB: 6/ 11 /1942, Sex: M NAPA CA 94558-2906 Adm: 11/9/2018, D/C: 12/14/2018 11/09/2018 -Admission (Discharged) in PROVIDENCE QUEEN OF THE VALLEY ICU (continued) Hardcopy Scans (group 1 of 3) (continued) Ag•/hK: 76 K uni t t : OM022766S4 Attending: Schro• d•r. B ndl♦y Ill Account • : av0087S4 H3S I GESKE, BARL r Status : Disch â– r~d lniti at•d: 11/09/18 Pag• Print•d 12 Loe.tiQn: NQMIClJS. Maitt•d : ll/O!J/19 flt 1849 OOâ– pht•n 11/10/1& RD 11/10/18 0953 ""'' H¢ , Hc:t lllh4tn placi ng POiat Transfusi o n Hgb , H= : 11/10/18 81118 ""'' lJ Us• S.conda ry • • th• Orde r 8our,ce 2) let the or-dar'• pno r ity to 'l'i-d, en-:1 enter ti.. e>eact de.t• lll'ld t i •• th• 11/10/18 R II U/10/1!1 RN 11/10/18 MAN 11/10/18 II A 11/10/18 1'.3SO AS DIRECTED 11/10/18 MAN 11/10/18 1'.350 All DIRECTED 11/10/1!1 ~ 11/11/18 Ii: 8 11/10/18 1350 AS DlREC'TiD 11/10/18 MA.~ 11/11/18 E I 1 1/10/18 13SO DAI LY • • In&♦ rt MSI\Ag• NG 00 Tut . U/10/18 MAN ll/ 10/18 tl A 11/10/18 1'.34S • !IC N•bl KDI Vent/ 8 .i. PAP Pt Npr 11/10/lll ~ 12/03/18 PAR 11/10/18 13!,0 ""'' . Par RT ■♦di.c•uon • RC N•b/ MOl V•nt./ RiPAP Pt. tlptc 11/10/18 MAN 11/13/18 SNV 11/1 0/18 1'.350 . P<>tc RT ••dicat:1.on 11/10/18 R D 11/ 10/18 R D 11/10/18 l'.348 llhen pl..:ing ~•t Ttcans fu • i on C!IC: ""'' 1) use seconda r y H t.h• Order lourc• 2) let. th♦ order'• priority t.o Ti Md, end • nter ti.. • x•ct dolt• ;rnd ti•• t h • • • vent All. . . .... nt Adult / PIW 11/10/18 R D 11/10/18 1352 Qâ—„ IIR • * VIU' Pr••• ntion Order â– 11/10/18 J! D 11/ 16/18 l'l 8 1 1/ 10/ 18 lJSS 07, 19 11/13/18 224S 08,2 0 11/10/18 R 0 11/16/18 M B 11/10/18 13~5 07,1' 11/1'.3/18 2245 013, 20 11/10/18 R 0 11/ 16/18 J C 11/10/18 1'.3S5 00, 12 1 1/U/18 0 000 Oâ—„IIR • * VIU' B..:I Chair POâ– it ion 11/10/18 J! D 11/10/18 1'.355 OS, 12, 20 11/10/18 ll A 11/11/18 E B 11/10/18 U 27 oz,,, • • Richaond Agitation B•dation IC'ale RAIS 11/10/18 11/10/18 NLR S 8 11/ 16/11 l'l I 11/10/18 1 1/10/18 U Sll!i lb37 ·""" ou,, 11/10/18 Y • 11/17/18 AG 11/10/18 1S38 AB DIRECTED • RC tt.b/ NDl V•ot/ 8.i. PAP Pt Npr 11/10/18 Y II 11/ 17/18 AG 11/10/18 1538 AS DlR.ECT! D " RC I ntubate/ Extubat•/ De,cann 11/10/18 Y • 11/10/te Y w 1 1/10/18 1S38 • RC Veot Adult/HO Npr 11/10/18 Y II 11/17/18 AG 11/10/18 1602 ""'' AS DIRECTID • C.re Plan Proble• Reatra1nts Non Violent 11/10/18 J! D 111 10/18 l'l B 1 1/10/18 1801 om • • T ranâ– fu■• C riteria P R!IC 11/10/ 18 l'l I 11/ 11/18 " Z 11/10/18 19'.38 11/11/18 .mH ""'' • * D1alyâ– 1 â– RH or- Labs 11/11/18 I 8 11/ 11/18 NJC 11/11/18 1122 AS DlRECTSD • • Dialysis Treat-nt 11/11/18 I 8 11/ 11/ 18 UJC 11/11/18 1122 Al DIRECTED ll/lâ—„ /16 8 T • RC MD/ DD to RC ~--unication 11/lZ/lll 11/lZ/18 LG l\ C 11/ 18/18 J " 11/12/18 11/12/18 0 031 ""'' 101115 AS 0111.EC'tl!O • RD tlutrlt i onal Ass•■-• nt ADULT 11/12/18 J! 8 • Car• Plan RD Adult 11/lZ/18 J! 8 • * Inâ–