arrow left
arrow right
  • Community Coalition To Save Beth Israel Hospital And The New York Eye And Ear Infirmary by Its Co-Chair Penny Mintz, The 504 Democratic Club, Center For Independence Of The Disabled, Save Nyee, Inc., Fulton Houses Tenants Association, Elliot-Chelsea Houses Tenants Association, Michael Schweinsburg, Arthur Z. Schwartz, Pca Doe, Richard Cruz, Andrea Gordillo, Sarah Batchu, Rhoda Lyman v. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital, New York Eye And Ear Infirmary Of Mount Sinai, Mount Sinai Hospital System, New York State Department Of Health, James V. Mcdonald as Commissioner of the New York State Department of HealthSpecial Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 document preview
  • Community Coalition To Save Beth Israel Hospital And The New York Eye And Ear Infirmary by Its Co-Chair Penny Mintz, The 504 Democratic Club, Center For Independence Of The Disabled, Save Nyee, Inc., Fulton Houses Tenants Association, Elliot-Chelsea Houses Tenants Association, Michael Schweinsburg, Arthur Z. Schwartz, Pca Doe, Richard Cruz, Andrea Gordillo, Sarah Batchu, Rhoda Lyman v. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital, New York Eye And Ear Infirmary Of Mount Sinai, Mount Sinai Hospital System, New York State Department Of Health, James V. Mcdonald as Commissioner of the New York State Department of HealthSpecial Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 document preview
  • Community Coalition To Save Beth Israel Hospital And The New York Eye And Ear Infirmary by Its Co-Chair Penny Mintz, The 504 Democratic Club, Center For Independence Of The Disabled, Save Nyee, Inc., Fulton Houses Tenants Association, Elliot-Chelsea Houses Tenants Association, Michael Schweinsburg, Arthur Z. Schwartz, Pca Doe, Richard Cruz, Andrea Gordillo, Sarah Batchu, Rhoda Lyman v. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital, New York Eye And Ear Infirmary Of Mount Sinai, Mount Sinai Hospital System, New York State Department Of Health, James V. Mcdonald as Commissioner of the New York State Department of HealthSpecial Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 document preview
  • Community Coalition To Save Beth Israel Hospital And The New York Eye And Ear Infirmary by Its Co-Chair Penny Mintz, The 504 Democratic Club, Center For Independence Of The Disabled, Save Nyee, Inc., Fulton Houses Tenants Association, Elliot-Chelsea Houses Tenants Association, Michael Schweinsburg, Arthur Z. Schwartz, Pca Doe, Richard Cruz, Andrea Gordillo, Sarah Batchu, Rhoda Lyman v. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital, New York Eye And Ear Infirmary Of Mount Sinai, Mount Sinai Hospital System, New York State Department Of Health, James V. Mcdonald as Commissioner of the New York State Department of HealthSpecial Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 document preview
  • Community Coalition To Save Beth Israel Hospital And The New York Eye And Ear Infirmary by Its Co-Chair Penny Mintz, The 504 Democratic Club, Center For Independence Of The Disabled, Save Nyee, Inc., Fulton Houses Tenants Association, Elliot-Chelsea Houses Tenants Association, Michael Schweinsburg, Arthur Z. Schwartz, Pca Doe, Richard Cruz, Andrea Gordillo, Sarah Batchu, Rhoda Lyman v. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital, New York Eye And Ear Infirmary Of Mount Sinai, Mount Sinai Hospital System, New York State Department Of Health, James V. Mcdonald as Commissioner of the New York State Department of HealthSpecial Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 document preview
  • Community Coalition To Save Beth Israel Hospital And The New York Eye And Ear Infirmary by Its Co-Chair Penny Mintz, The 504 Democratic Club, Center For Independence Of The Disabled, Save Nyee, Inc., Fulton Houses Tenants Association, Elliot-Chelsea Houses Tenants Association, Michael Schweinsburg, Arthur Z. Schwartz, Pca Doe, Richard Cruz, Andrea Gordillo, Sarah Batchu, Rhoda Lyman v. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital, New York Eye And Ear Infirmary Of Mount Sinai, Mount Sinai Hospital System, New York State Department Of Health, James V. Mcdonald as Commissioner of the New York State Department of HealthSpecial Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 document preview
  • Community Coalition To Save Beth Israel Hospital And The New York Eye And Ear Infirmary by Its Co-Chair Penny Mintz, The 504 Democratic Club, Center For Independence Of The Disabled, Save Nyee, Inc., Fulton Houses Tenants Association, Elliot-Chelsea Houses Tenants Association, Michael Schweinsburg, Arthur Z. Schwartz, Pca Doe, Richard Cruz, Andrea Gordillo, Sarah Batchu, Rhoda Lyman v. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital, New York Eye And Ear Infirmary Of Mount Sinai, Mount Sinai Hospital System, New York State Department Of Health, James V. Mcdonald as Commissioner of the New York State Department of HealthSpecial Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 document preview
  • Community Coalition To Save Beth Israel Hospital And The New York Eye And Ear Infirmary by Its Co-Chair Penny Mintz, The 504 Democratic Club, Center For Independence Of The Disabled, Save Nyee, Inc., Fulton Houses Tenants Association, Elliot-Chelsea Houses Tenants Association, Michael Schweinsburg, Arthur Z. Schwartz, Pca Doe, Richard Cruz, Andrea Gordillo, Sarah Batchu, Rhoda Lyman v. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital, New York Eye And Ear Infirmary Of Mount Sinai, Mount Sinai Hospital System, New York State Department Of Health, James V. Mcdonald as Commissioner of the New York State Department of HealthSpecial Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 document preview
						
                                

Preview

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 02:07 PM INDEX NO. 151136/2024 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 38 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 EXHIBIT MM FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 02:07 PM INDEX NO. 151136/2024 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 38 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 skip to main content Department of Health Information for a Healthy New York " Home " Help " Contact " A-Z En español " A-Z Index Certificate of Need (CON) " CON Homepage " NYSE-CON Homepage To go back, pleaseuse the "Start Over" button Start Over Refine Search instead of your browser's back button. Project Search Results Please be mindful that while the Department believes the following to be accurate, the information provided reflects that as submitted by the applicant and may or may not be confirmed by the Department. Further, while the Department believes the following to be current, changes to this information can occur at any given time. Results are listed by Project Number and Facility Name, in ascending order. To sort by another column, select the column in the 'Sort By' drop down list and click submit. To view the project site address, click on the Show Project Address link. To view project details, click on the project number. 1 Results from Search Criteria: Project Number: 162046; Facility ID: 1439; Facility Type: Hospital; County: NEW YORK; Region: New York City Sort By fl‚oject Numbel SubrWI Show Project Address Operating Project Facility Certificate Submission . ®.r ame ro ct esc on m e y e Sta s C nty 162046 Mount Decertify 26 Physical 7002002H Application - Project NEW Sinai Beth Medicine and Limited Review - Complete YORK Israel Rehabilitation beds Service Delivery Questions or comments: cons@health.state.ny.us Revised: November 2014 " Disclaimer " Privacy Policy " Accessibility FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 02:07 PM INDEX NO. 151136/2024 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 38 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 skip to main content Department of Health Information for a Healthy New York " Home " Help " Contact " A-Z En español " A-Z Index Certificate of Need (CON) " CON Homepage " NYSE-CON Homepage To go back, pleaseuse the "Return to Results" button Return To Results Start Over or Over" button instead of your browser's backbutton. .. .. the . .."start .. . .. . . . .. . . .. .. .. . ... . .. General Inforrnation Project Number: 162046 Facility Name: Mount Sinai Beth Israel Project Description: Decertify 26 Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation beds General Executive Summary Sites Decision Post Approval Summary Status: Project Complete Submission Type: Application - Limited Review - Service Delivery Status Date: 08/11/2016 Application Received Date: 07/19/2016 Review Level: Limited Initial Review Date: 07/22/2016 County: NEW YORK Acknowledgement Date: 07/25/2016 Region: New York City Total Project Cost: $500.00 Impact on Operating Certificate Bed/Service Action Count Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Beds Decertify 26 Notice Publicaccessto NYSE-CON is Intendedsolelyto allowthe publicconvenientandimmediateaccessto publicinformation.Muchof theinformationcontained withinNYSE-CON is providedby applicants,andmuchof it is historicinformationthat mayno longerbeaccurateor complete.Whileall attemptsaremadeto provideaccurate,current,andreliableinformation,the Departmentof Healthrecognizes the possibilityof humanand/ormechanical errorandthat infomTation capturedat a pointin time oftenbecomesobsolete.Therefore,the Departmentof Health,its employees, officersandagentsmakeno representation, warranty or guaranteeasto the accuracy,completeness, currency,or suitabilityof theinformationprovidedhere, Questions or comments: cons@health.state.ny.us Revised: November 2014 " Disclaimer " Privacy Policy " Accessibility FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 02:07 PM INDEX NO. 151136/2024 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 38 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 skip to main content Department of Health Information for a Healthy New York " Home " Help " Contact " A-Z En español " A-Z Index Certificate of Need (CON) " CON Homepage " NYSE-CON Homepage To go back, pleaseuse the "Return to Results" button Return To Results Start Over or the "Start Over" button instead of your browser's back button. Executive Summary Project Number: 162046 Facility Name: Mount Sinai Beth Israel Project Description: Decertify 26 Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation beds General Executive summary Sites Decision Post Approval Summary xecutive Summary: Last Modified: 07/19/2016 02:23:29 PM In accordance with Section 710.1(c)(5) of 10 New York Codes, Rules and Regulations (10 NYCRR), Mount Sinai Beth Israel (MSBI) is submitting this Service Delivery Limited Review Application that seeks approval for the decertification of the 26 inpatient Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation (PM&R) beds at the Hospital. MSBI is currently certified for 26 PM&R beds, among other certified bed classifications, for a total of 825 certified inpatient beds. Upon implementation of this project, all 26 PM&R beds will be decertified, resulting in a total inpatient bed count of 799 at MSBI. MSBI is located at First Avenue at 16th Street, New York (New York County), New York 10003. This project is part of a larger effort of Mount Sinai to create a more integrated healthcare system, and to more effectively use system resources. In the first six (6) months of 2016, MSBI experienced 290 discharges (with 3,396 patient days) for its 26 PM&R beds, representing an occupancy rate of 71.6% and a decrease from its 88.6% occupancy in 2012. Currently, the Hospital is providing inpatient care for only 13 PM&R patients. Through this project, patients who would typically be seen at MSBI will now be seen at other Mount Sinai facilities within Manhattan. At the other three (3) Mount Sinai facilities with inpatient PM&R beds (Mount Sinai Hospital (88 beds), Mount Sinai West (25 beds) and Mount Sinai St. Luke's (15 beds)), the overall occupancy rate in the first six (6) months of 2016 was 52.8%, so there is sufficient capacity at these three (3) facilities in Manhattan to be able to serve MSBUs patients once the PM&R unit at MSBI is closed. Although MSBI understands that some individuals may choose to seek care outside of the Mount Sinai system, the Hospital believes that this project is in the best interest of patients from a clinical perspective, given its plans for the transformation of the MSBI campus. Lastly, the planned decertification of the 26 inpatient PM&R beds is the result of an industry-wide transition from an inpatient rehabilitation model to one increasingly focused on an outpatient therapy model, resulting in the need for fewer inpatient beds for these services. At no point will access to Mount Sinai physicians be interrupted, Additionally, Mount Sinai does not anticipate any job losses as a result of the closure of the inpatient rehabilitation unit at MSBI, and it has already begun meeting and working with its union partners to ensure that the affected union employees are retrained, if necessary, and offered other union opportunities with equal pay within the Mount Sinai Health System. The Total Project Cost for this project is $500, which is comprised solely of the Limited Review Application fee, and is being submitted as part of initial submission of the Application. Notice Publicaccessto NYsE-CON is intendedsolelyto allowthe publicconvenientandimmediateaccessto publicinformation.Muchof theinformationcontained withinNYSE-CON is providedby applicants,andmuchof it is historicinformationthat maynolongerbeaccurateor complete.Whileallattemptsaremadeto provideaccurate,current,andreliableinformation,the Departmentof Healthrecognizes the possibilityof humanand/orrnechanical errorandthatinformation capturedat a pointin time oftenbecomesobsolete.Therefore,theDepartmentof Flealth,its employees, officersandagentsmakenorepresentation, warranty or guaranteeasto the accuracy,completeness, currency,or suitabilityof theinformationprovidedhere. Questions or comments: cons@health.state.ny.us Revised: November 2014 " Disclaimer " Privacy Policy " Accessibility FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 02:07 PM INDEX NO. 151136/2024 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 38 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 skip to main content Department of Health Information for a Healthy New York " Home " Help " Contact " A-Z En español " A-Z Index Certificate of Need (CON) " CON Homepage " NYSE-CON Homepage To go back, pleaseusethe "Return to Results" button Return To Results Start Over or the astart over" button instead of your browser's back button. Sites Project Number: 162046 Facility Name: Mount Sinai Beth Israel Project Description: Decertify 26 Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation beds General Executive Summary sites Decision Post Approval Summary Main Site Information Facility Name: Mount Sinai Beth Israel Facility Type: Hospital Physical Address: First Ave at 16th Street Facility ID: 1439 New York, NY 10003 County: NEW YORK Current Operator: Mount Sinai Hospitals Group, Inc. One Gustave L. Levy Place New York, NY 10029 Operator County: operating Certificate: 7002002H Project Site Information Name: Mount Sinai Beth Israel Physical Address: First Ave at 16th Street New York, NY 10003 County: NEW YORK Proposed Operator: Operator County: ..........................................................,-............................................................................................................-.......................................,-.............................. Notice Publicaccessto NYSE-CON is intendedsolelyto allowthe publicconvenientandimmediateaccessto publicinformation.Muchof theinformationcontained withinNYSE-CON is providedby applicants,andmuchof it is historicinformationthat may nolongerbeaccurateor complete.Whileall attemptsaremadeto provideaccurate,current,andreliableinformation,the Departmentof Healthrecognizes the possibilityof humanand/ormechanical errorandthat information capturedat a pointin time oftenbecomesobsolete.Therefore,theDepartme nt of Health,its employees,officersandagentsmakenorepresentation,warranty or guaranteeasto the accuracy,completeness, currency,or suitabilityof theinformationprovidedhere, Questions or comments: cons@health.state.ny.us Revised: November 2014 " Disclaimer " Privacy Policy " Accessibility FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 02:07 PM INDEX NO. 151136/2024 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 38 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 skip to main content Department of Health Information for a Healthy New York " Home " Help " Contact " A-Z En español " A-Z Index Certificate of Need (CON) " CON Homepage " NYSE-CON Homepage To go back, pleaseuse the "Return to Results" button Return To Results Start Over or the "Start Over" button instead of your browser's back button. Decision Inforrnation Project Number: 162046 Facility Name: Mount Sinai Beth Israel Project Description: Decertify 26 Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation beds General Executive Sites Decision Post Approval p-----.------------...--------------- Summary Summary i- Decision Action Date Director Action: Approval Date: 08/02/2016 ACS Letter Sent: PHC Final Approval Letter Sent: L___________________________________---------___________ Notice Publicaccessto NYSE-CON is intendedsolelyto allowthe publicconvenientandimmediateaccessto publicinformation.Muchof theinformationcontained withinNYSE-CON is providedbyapplicants,andmuchof it is historicinformationthat maynolongerbeaccurateor complete.Whileall attemptsaremadeto provideaccurate,current,andreliableinformation,the Departmentof Healthrecognizes the possibilityof humanand/ormechanical errorandthat information capturedat a pointin timeoftenbecomes obsolete.Therefore,the Departmentof Health,its employees, officersandagentsmakeno representation, warranty or guaranteeasto the accuracy,completeness, currency,or suitabilityof theinformationprovidedhere, Questions or comments: cons@health.state.ny.us Revised: November 2014 " Disclaimer " Privacy Policy " Accessibility FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 02:07 PM INDEX NO. 151136/2024 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 38 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 skip to main content Department of Health Information for a Healthy New York " Home " Help " Contact " A-Z En español " A-Z Index Certificate of Need (CON) " CON Homepage " NYSE-CON Homepage To go back, pleaseuse the "Return to Results" button Return To Results Start Over or the "start over" button instead of your browser's backbutton Post Approval Information Project Number: 162046 Facility Name: Mount Sinai Beth Israel Project Description: Decertify 26 Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation beds General Executive Summary Sites Decision Post Approval Summary Assigned Start Date: Actual Start Date: Assigned Completion Date: Actual Completion Date: 09/01/2016 Notice Publicaccessto NYSE-CON is intendedsolelyto allowthepublicconvenientandimmediateaccessto publicinformation,Muchof theinformationcontained withinNYSE-CON is providedbyapplicants,andmuchof it is historicinformationthat may nolongerbeaccurateor complete.Whileallattemptsaremadeto provideaccurate,current,andreliableinformation,the Departmentof Healthrecognizes the possibilityof humanand/ormechanical errorandthat information capturedat a pointin time oftenbecomesobsolete.Therefore,the Departmentof Health,its employees, officersandagentsmakeno representation, warranty or guaranteeasto the accuracy, completeness,currency,or suitabilityof theinformationprovidedhere. Questions or comments: cons@health.state.ny.us Revised: November 2014 " Disclaimer " Privacy Policy " Accessibility FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 02:07 PM INDEX NO. 151136/2024 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 38 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 skip to main content Department of Health Information for a Healthy New York " Home " Help " Contact " A-Z En español " A-Z Index Certificate of Need (CON) " CON Homepage " NYSE-CON Homepage To go back, pleaseuse the "Return to Results" button Return To Results Start Over or the "Start Over" button instead of your browser's back button.. Summary Information Project Number: 162046 Facility Name: Mount Sinai Beth Israel Project Description: Decertify 26 Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation beds General Executive Sites Decision Post Approval ___________________---------------- Summary summary General Information Status: Project Complete Submission Type: Application - Limited Review - Service Delivery Status Date: 08/11/2016 Application Received Date: 07/19/2016 Co nt : NE YORK c wiedg ment ate: 0 i Region: New York City Total Project Cost: $500.00 Impact on Operating Certificate Bed/Service Action Count Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Beds Decertify 26 Sites Main Site Information Physical Address: First Ave at 16th Street Facility ID: 1439 New York, NY 10003 County: NEW YORK Current Operator: Mount Sinai Hospitals Group, Inc. One Gustave L. Levy Place New York, NY 10029 Operator County: Operating Certificate: 7002002H Project Site Information Name: Mount Sinai Beth Israel Physical Address: First Ave at 16th Street New York, NY 10003 County: NEW YORK Proposed Operator: Operator County: Decision FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 02:07 PM INDEX NO. 151136/2024 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 38 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 i Decision Action Date Director Action: Approval Date: 08/02/2016 ACS Letter Sent: PHC Final Approval Letter Sent: Post Approval Assigned Start Date: Actual Start Date: Assigned Completion Date: Actual Completion Date: 09/01/2016 Notice Publicaccessto NYSE-CON is intendedsolelyto allowthe publicconvenientandimmediateaccessto publicinformation.Muchof theinformationcontained withinNYSE-CON is providedby applicants,andmuchof it is historicinformationthat maynolongerbeaccurateor complete.Whileall attemptsaremadeto provideaccurate,current,andreliableinformation,the Departmentof Healthrecognizes the possibdityof humanand/ormechanical errorandthat information capturedat a pointin time oftenbecomesobsolete.Therefore,the Departmentof Health,its employees, officersandagentsmakeno representation, warranty or guaranteeasto the accuracy, completeness,currency,or suitabilityof theInformation providedhere. Questions or comments: cons@health.state.ny.us Revised: November 2014 " Disclaimer " Privacy Policy " Accessibility