arrow left
arrow right
  • WILLIAMS, JOANNE,M. v. SARRA, AARON,W. AKAC90 - Contracts - All other document preview
  • WILLIAMS, JOANNE,M. v. SARRA, AARON,W. AKAC90 - Contracts - All other document preview
  • WILLIAMS, JOANNE,M. v. SARRA, AARON,W. AKAC90 - Contracts - All other document preview
  • WILLIAMS, JOANNE,M. v. SARRA, AARON,W. AKAC90 - Contracts - All other document preview
  • WILLIAMS, JOANNE,M. v. SARRA, AARON,W. AKAC90 - Contracts - All other document preview
  • WILLIAMS, JOANNE,M. v. SARRA, AARON,W. AKAC90 - Contracts - All other document preview
  • WILLIAMS, JOANNE,M. v. SARRA, AARON,W. AKAC90 - Contracts - All other document preview
  • WILLIAMS, JOANNE,M. v. SARRA, AARON,W. AKAC90 - Contracts - All other document preview
						
                                

Preview

D.N. HHB-CV2 l-5028822-S SUPERIOR COURT JOANNE WILLIAMS J.D. OF NEW BRITAIN v. AT NEW BRITAIN LAW OFFICES OF AARON W. SARRA, JANUARY 31, 2024 LLC, ETAL D.N. HHB-CV-20-5028224-S SUPERIOR COURT JOANNE WILLIAMS J.D. OF NEW BRITAIN v. AT NEW BRITAIN AARON W. SARRA AKA AARON W. JANUARY 31, 2024 SARRA, LLC, ET AL MOTION TO DISMISS Pursuant to § 10-30 of the Connecticut Rules of Court, the Defendants, Deanna Sarra, Executrix of Estate of Aaron Sarra and Law Offices of Aaron W. Sarra, LLC, hereby move to dismiss plaintiffs complaints due to a lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter. As set forth in the attached Memorandum of Law, the plaintiff filed three bankruptcy cases in the United States District Court, most recently in 2019 and failed to list the claims alleged in the two consolidated cases in her Schedules of assets. Because the claims in the captioned matters are unscheduled, pre-petition claims and they have not been abandoned, the plaintiff does not own those claims, and has no standing to assert them. In addition, plaintiffs failure to schedule the claims in her bankruptcy schedules judicially estops the plaintiff from pursuing the actions in Superior Court. WHEREFORE, the defendants move to dismiss the captioned lawsuits. DEFENDANTS, DEANNA SARRA EXECUTRIX OF ESTATE OF AARON SARA AND AARON W. SARRA A/KJA AARON SARRA, LLC By: ls/I 02228 Michael T. Ryan, Esq. Ryan Ryan Deluca LLP I 000 Lafayette Blvd., Suite 800 Bridgepmt, CT 06604 Juris No. 438500 Phone: 203-549-6650 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I certify that a copy of this document will immediately be mailed or delivered electronically on January 31, 2024, to all attorneys and self-represented parties of record and that written consent for electronic delive1y was received from all attorneys and self-represented parties receiving electronic delivery. Name and address of each patty and attorney receiving this document: Andre Cayo, Esq. via email: cayolaw@gmail.com P.O. Box 320297 Fairfield, CT 06825 Attorney for tlte Plt parcel oflwd situated in said Town of Plainville and known as lot No. 39 11$ shown on a 1n11p entitled ''Section 3, Clllllp Acic1, Plainville, Conn. Developed by D & ll Comtruction Co., Inc. Scale I"= 41>' Scptt:mber IS, 1962, Adrian M. Manhcws. Reg. Land Surveyor" which map is on file in said Plainville 'town Clerk'• Office, and being more partitularly bounded and desctibed SJ follows:. NORTHERLY: by Florence: Lane. as shown on 81lid map, Ei(lhty-two (82) fee~ more or lesi; EASTERLY: by land now or formerly of JCllllic T. Cowle$, cl al, One Hundred Sixteen md Sixty Ooe-hlllli1 t~''"'" FILED Debtor 2 101b JAN 1q AC\: 08 Uni\!':rl Stales Bankruptcy Court for the: District of Connoclicut CLERK. U.S. BANKRUPTCY COURT Case number 15-22095 Arnn DISTRICT OF CONNECTICUT HARTFORD 0 Check if this is an aniendod filing Official Form 106A/B Schedule A/B: Property 12115 In each category, separately list nnd describe ltc1ns. List an asset only once. If an asset fits in more than one category, list the asset in the category whore you think it fits best. Be as complete and accurate as possible. If two married people arc filing together, both arc equally responsible for supplying correct information. If more space Is needed, attach a separate sheet to this fortn. On the top of any addilionol pages, write your namo and case number (if known}. Answer every question. Describe Each Residence, Building, Land, or Other Real Estate You Own or Have an lntel'est In 1. Do you own or have any legal or equitable interest in any residence, building, land, or siinilar property? Ll No. Go to PDrt 2. tj° Yes. 1Nhcre is the property'' What is the property? Check le.-ofOihITTdes~rip1i0~1-- 0 0 Duplex or multi-urnt hu1ldm9 Cu11{lt11rnniurn {lf coonera1wu Current value of the Current value of the 0 M~11n1fac\urotl ur mropcrty? portion you own? 0 0 Land lnvcsl1nunt pro1lurly s---------- -- s_____ --- - ... -- Describe the nature of your ownership 0 Ti1nosl\11re interest (such as fee shnplo, tononcy by u 0111<11 -----------·· the entireties, or a life ostato}, lf known. Who has an interest in the property? Check om1. --------- 0 Debtor 1 O"lly 0 Debtor 2 only U Oeblor I Wld Debtor 2 only 0 Check if this is co1nmunity property 0 At funst one of ttu~ du!Jlors nnd ium\lu:!1 (see instructions) Other infonnation you wish to add about this Item, such as local property idcntificntion nu1nbcr: _ _ __ Official Farm 1OONB Schedule NB: Properly Case 15-22095 Doc 15 Filed 01/19/16 Entered 01/19/16 09:37:22 Page 4 of 39 Oabtot 1 ,,.._ Joanne M. Williams Caso numbart•.,_, 15-22095 Arnn What 11 the property? Check ell lhatepply. Do not deduct 1ecurad clatms or exempUona. Put 0 Slnglo·f8mlly home lhe amount of any secured ctalma on SChMJut. D: 1.3. ,,,...-.,....,.,..-~....,,.""""-~-,.-,..,,.- Credltore Who HaWI Clefml SetllfBd by Properly. . . .. Street 8ddr111, if avallabla, or other description 0 Duplex or mu\U·unll buI\ding ' - 0 Condominium or oooperallve current value of the Current value of Iha entire property? portion you own? 0 Manufactured or mobile home $_ _ _ _"-- $._ _ _ _ __ 0 Land 0 Investment property Clly Stale ZIP Codo 0 Timeshare Describe the nature of your ownerehlp Interest (such 11lea1lmple, tenancy by 0 Other ~~-------~- the entlretlee, or a Ille estate), II known. Who haa an Interest In the property? Check one. 0 Dobtor 1 only County 0 Debtor 2 only 0 Debtor 1 and Debtor 2 only Q Check II thl• 11 community property Q At least one of tha debtora and another (see lnelrucl\ons) Other Information you wish to add about thl• Item, auch H local property ldenttncallon n u m b e r : - - - - - - - - - - - - 2. Add the dollar value oltha portion you own for all of your entries from Part 1, Including any entries for pagea you have attached for Part 1. Write that number here....................................................................................... + ______ . $ 100,000.00_, Fifi Deacrlbe Your Vehicles Do you own, 11110, or have legal or equitable lntereat In any vehlcleo, whether they are reglatered or not? Include any vehlcles you own that someone else drives. If you teaae a vehicle, also report II on Schedule G: Execu/ory Contrac/s and Unexplrad Leases. 3. Care, vane, trucks, trectore, sport utility vehlclH, motorcycles 0 No IBYea 3.1. Make: Ford Who has an lntar..t In the property? Check one. Do not deduct ucurod claims or exemptlon1. Put the amount of any aecured claims on Schtdult a: Model: Ranger 121 Debtor 1 only Credllore Who HaWI Claim• Secured by P/Opony. 1997 0 Debtor 2 only Year: Current valua olthe Current value of the Cl Dabtor 1 end Debtor 2 only Approximate mileage: 210000 0 At lent one ol the debtors and another entire property? portion you own? Other lnformaUon: 500.00 $ 500.00 0 $ ------ ~-] Check II thl• lo community property (see lnstrucUons) If you own or have mora than one, describe hare: a.2. Make: Who ha• an lnter..t In the property? Check one. Do not doduct tecured delmt or exempUon1. Put 0 Debtor 1 only the emounl of any secured clalm1 on 8ch&du16 0: Model: CredHon Who H1v• Cl•lm• ll•cu19d by Praporly. 0 Dablor 2 only Year: Current value ol the Current value ol the 0 Debtor 1 and Debtor 2 only entire property? portion you own? Approximate mileage: CJ Al leeat one of the deblorl and enolher Other lnlormallon: $._ _ _ __ $._ _ _ __ 0 Check II lh\1 \1 community property (sea \nstrucUons) Official Fonm 106A/8 Schedule AIB: Property page 2 Case 15-22095 Doc 15 Filed 01/19/16 Entered 01/19/16 09:37:22 Page 5 of 39 Debtor 1 Joanne M. Williams Ceae number(,.....,, 15·22095 Arnn LMtHtm1 3.3. Make: Who h11 an Interest In the property? Cheol< one. Do not deduot secured d8tm1 or exempUone. Put the amount of any ncured clalma on Schedule D: Model: Q Debtor 1 only Ctedltort1 Who Have Clalma S.CUl&d by PiOpllrly. CJ Debtor 2 only Year: Current value or the Current value of the CJ Debtor 1 and Debtor 2 only portion you own? Approximate mileage: entire property? CJ Al leeal one of lhe deblors and enolher Olhar lnlonnaUon: Q Check If Ihle la community property (sea $ $ Instructions) 3.4. Make: Who ha• an lntera1t In the property? Cheol< one. Do not deduct 19CUl'ed claims or eKempUons. Put the amount of any secured clalmt on Schedufo D: Modal: 1J Debtor 1 only Cted#Oll Who Have Claim• &J<;ured by PtQP&~. CJ Debtor 2 only Year: Current value or the Currant value or the CJ Debtor 1 end Debtor 2 only entire property? Approximate mileage: portion you own? CJ At least one of lhe dablOll and anolher Olher lnfonnatlon: CJ Check If this I• community property (see $ $ Instructions) 4. Watercraft, aircraft, motor hornet, ATVe and other recreational vehlclaa, other vehlclea, and a.ceaaorlea Examples: Boele, trailers, motors, personal water<:reft, flehlng veasela, snowmobllaa, motorcycle acceasorles IZI No CJ Yea 4.1. Make: Who haa an Interest In Iha property? Check one. Do not deduct secured ciatm1 or exempUon1. Put the amount of any secured claims on Schedule D: Modal: CJ Debtor 1 only Credlloro Who H&va Claim• Secured by PiOpllrly. CJ Deblor 2 only Year: CJ Debtor 1 and Deblor 2 only Cunrant value or the Current value of Iha Olher lnfonnatlon: Q At leas! one of Iha debtors and anolhar entire property? portion you own? CJ Check If this la community property (see $._ _ _ __ lnetrucllons) '·------ If you own or have more than one, list here: 4.2. Make: Who ha1 en lntereat In the property? Check one. Do not deduct aecured ctalms or exempdone. Put Iha amount of any secured c\alms on Sr;hedute D; Model: 0 Debtor 1 only Crsdolora Who Hov• Cl•lm• Secur&d by Prop8rly. Q Debtor 2 only Year: Currant value of the Current value of the CJ Debtor 1 and Debtor 2 only entire property? portion you own? Olher lnfonnatlon: CJ At least one of lhe debtor11 and anolher $._ _ _ __ $,_ _ _ _ __ CJ Check II this 11 community property (see Instructions) Olflclal Form 108A/B Schedulo A/B: Property page 3 Case 15-22095 Doc 15 Filed 01119/16 Entered 01119/16 09:37:22 Page 6 of 39 Debtor 1 Joanne M. Williams ....... ca .. number"""""' 15-22095 Arnn Daacrlbe Your Personal and Household Items current value of the Do you own or have any legal or equllable lntereat In any of the followlng ltem1? portion you own? Oo not deduct 1ecured delmt or oxompllon1. 8. Hou1ehold good1 and furnlahlnga Examples: Major appllancee, lumllure, llnana, china. kttchanware g~:. oesc11ba......... ~Ho~siiho1. s the all over 10 years old. ·-····----- ·---~-- 2,500.00 7. Electronlaa Examples: Televlalona and radios; audio, video, stereo, and dlgllal equlpmant; computera, printers, scannera: music collactlons; electronic devlcaa lncludlng call phonea, cameraa, media players, game& CJ No 121 Yes. Describe.......... Computer, scanner, printer/fax/scanner, TV and Stereo. They are all over 10 $ 1,000.00 ears old. ·---~-- e. Collectibles of value Examples: Antiques and figurines: paintings, prints, or other artwork; books, plciures, or olher art objects: slamp, coin, or baaaball card collecUons; other collections, memorabilia, collacllblas 121 No CJ Yea. Describe......... . $._ _ _ _ __ 9. Equipment for sports and hobbles Examples: Sports, photogrsphlc, exercise, and olher hobby equipment: bicycles, pool tables, golf cluba, akla; canoes and kayaks; carpentry tools; musical inatruments ~ ~:•. Describe..........[ - .. ·-··----- ---··-·-1 $, _ _ _ _ _ __ 10.Flreanna Exomp/os: Pistols, rifles. shotguns. ammunition, and related equipment la No 0 Yes.Describe ......... . $,_ _ _ _ _ __ ·--------' l1.Clolhe1 Examples: Everyday ctolhes, furs, leather coals. designer wear, shoes, accessories Q No 121 Vas. Describe.........., Clothing and personal effects I $,_ _ _ _1:. :.,0:.;0:. ; 0.:. ;.0;. ; . 0 12.Jewelry Examplee: Everyday jewelry, costume Jewelry, engagement rings, wadding rings, heirloom jewelry, watches, gems, gold, silver [J No -----------------------·---~ 300.00 121 Yes.Oascribe.......... jCostume lewelry ~ 5'----...:.;== 13.Non·fann anfmal1 Examples: Dogs, cats, birds, horaes 121 No $, _ _ _ _ __ [J Yes. Oeocriba .......... 14.Any other peroonal and household Items you did not already Hot, Including any hoallh atda you did not !Isl la No [J Vas. Give spacmc $ Information. .............. L..._ __ Official Form 106AIB Schedule A/B: Property page4 Case 15-22095 Doc 15 Filed 01/19/16 Entered 01/19/16 09:37:22 Page 7 of 39 Debtor 1 Joanne M. Williams c... numbori1. _ 15-22095 Arnn f 6Ff Describe Your Financial Aasets Do you own or have any legal or equltablo lntaraat In any of the following? Currant value of tho portion you own? Do not deduct ffCU(td dalma or exempUon1. 18.Cath Exomplu· Money you have In your wallel, In your home, In e safe deposll box, end on hand when you file your petition Q No 121 Yea ................................................................................................................................................................ caah: ....................... s._____2_0_.o_o 17.Dopoalto of money Examples: Chaclramplos: Heatth, disability, or life Insurance; health savings account (HSA); credit, homeowner's, or rente(s Insurance B No CJ Yes. Name !he Insurance company Company name: Benenclery: surrender or refund value: of each policy end list Its value... New Brltlan Board of Education 3 Children 28,637.18 Mutual of Omaha 3 Children S ---""--- s'-----"2c:;2.; .<5,.;...00'-0'-o-'". "o $,___ _ _ __ 32. Any lntore1t In property that 11 due you from someone who haa died If you are the beneficiary of a llvlng trust, expect proceeds from a life Insurance policy, or are currenUy enUtled to receive property because someone hes died. la No 0 Yes. Give specific lnformalion .............. 33. Clalma against third partlat, whather or not you have filed a laweult or made a demand for payment Examples: Accidents, employment disputes, Insurance claims, or rights lo sue la No (J Yea. Oeaalbe each claim ................... .. 34. Other contingent and unllquldated clalm1 of every nature, Including counterclaims of the· debtor and right• to 111 off claims ia No (J Yes. Deaalbe each claim ................... .. 35.Any financial 11Hta you did not already Uet ~ ~: •. Give spaclflc lnfonmallon ............ L---·------ ] •. __ 36. Add the dollar value of all of your entrlea from Part 4, Including any antrlea for pagea you have attached for Part 4. Write that number here ....................................................................................................................................................~ I. 254,917.00 Deacrlbe Any Bualneea·Related Property You own or Have an Interest In. List any real estate In Part 1. 37.0o you own or have any legal or aqultabla lntarott In any bu1lneaa-reletad property? la No. Go to Part 6. (J Yea. Go to line 38. current value of the portion you own? Do not deduct secured cfalms or exempUont. 38.Accounts receivable or commission• you already earned iii No Cl Yea. Describe .......[ _ _ _ _ _ _ .. j._ _ 39. Office equipment, furnl1hlng1, and tuppllea E1tampl11.· Bullneawolated oomputera, aoRware, modem a, prlntet1, copler1, fax mactilnn, rug1, telephones, deak1, che\ra, e!ectronlc devfcea iii No CJ Yea. Describe ...... omc1a1Form108AIB Schedule A/B: Property paga a Case 15-22095 Doc 15 Filed 01/19/16 Entered 01/19/16 09:37:22 Page 11of39 Oel>lor 1 Cn:;u 11umtwr 1,11,, 1 "' 1) 15~22095 Am~1 40. Machinery, fixturcs 1 cquip1nent, supplies you usa In business, and tools of your trtidc itJ' No 0 Yes. Describe ...... . $ _______ - - - - · · - - 41. Inventory 1iiJ No 0 Yes. Describe ... $_ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ 42 Interests In partnerships or joint ventures la' No U Yes. Describe .. Name of enlity: % of ownership: _______ o/~ $._ _ _ _ __ $ --------~------ s________________ __ 43. Custo1nor lists, 1nailin9 lists. or other co1npilations Iii! No D Yes. Do your lists Include personally identifiable inforination (ns dAlined in 11ll.S.C.§101(41A))? D No 0 Yes. Describe .. s_____ -----·- 4•1.Any buslneSS•relatcd property you did not already list iii!' No 0 Yes. Give specific information ........ . ----·--------- ----- -----·---- --- ------------ s s________ _ --~- ----------------- --~-------~--- --- -----------· -·-···-- s_______ ---··-· s________ _ -------- - ----- -----------------------· ----- -·- s s '1f) Add the dollar value of all of your entries fronl Pnrt 5. including nny cntrios for pages you have attached for Port 5. Write that number here Is------~~1 Oescribo Any Farm .. and Commercial Fishing-Related Property You Own or Have an Interest In. If you own or have an Interest In fannla11d, list il l11 Part 1. '1G. Do you own or have any legnl or equitable interest in any farm· or comn1ercial fishing-related property? 10' No. Go lo Part 7. 0 Yes. Go to line 47. Curront value of the portion you own? Do no! deduct sc..:wcd diiull~ or exompllons. 47. Farin animals txcunpf,is; Uvestock, poultry. forin-raised fish ikf No 0 Yes .. s______ _ Official Form 106AJB Schedule AJB: Property pago 9 Case 15-22095 Doc 15 Filed 01/19/16 Entered 01/19116 09:37:22 Page 12 of 39 DtblO< I ""'"""' ....... Cato number(I_,,__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ 48.Crop-llhor growing or harvesled i!J No CJ Yes, Glva 1peclRo lnlonnallon............ . $._ _ _ _ __ 49. Fann and fl1hlng equip men~ lmplemanta, machinery, fixtures, end 10011 of trade i!J No CJ Yea .......................... .------------------------------~ $._ _ _ _ _ __ . 60. Fann ind flahlng 1uppllt1, chemlcal1, and foed 121 No CJ Yes .......................... .-----------------------------~ $._ _ _ _ _ __ 61.Any farm-and commercial fi1hlng-relatad property you did not already list 121 No CJ Yea. Give speclftc lnfonnallon............. $._ _ _ _ _ __ Describe All Property You Own or Have an Interest In That You Did Not Llet Above 53. Do you have olher property of any kind you did no! already llat? Examp/IJ.' Season UCketl, country dub memberwhlp 121 No s_____ CJ Y11. Give 1pecllic $_ _ _ __ lnlonnatlon ............ . $._ _ _ __ 114.Add tho dollar value of all of your entries from Port 7, Write that number here ................................................................. + $ 0.00 !if,¥ Llat the Totals of Each Part of this Form 55.Psrt 1: Total raal aalate, lino 2 .............................................................................................................................................................. + S 100.000.00 li8. Pert 2: Tolal vehlcla1, line 6 s 500.00 57.Part 3: Total personal and household ltemi, llne 15 $ 4,800.00 68.Part 4: Total flnanclel aa1e1a, line 38 ·$ 254,917.00 59. Part 6: Tola I bu1ln111-related property, line 45 $ o.oo 60.Part 5: Tolalfarm• and fl1hlng-reJ1ted property, lino 62 $ 0.00 81. Part 7: Total othar property not llated, llne 54 +s o.oo 82, Tolll pereon1J prop1rty. Add llnea 66 through 61 ..................... I $ 260,217·OOI Copy pe11onal property total + +$ 260,217.00 53. Total ol all property on Schedule NB. Add line 65 +line 82 ......................................................................................... . I s....__3_s_o_,2_11_.o_o Offlclal Fonn 106NB Schedule AIB: Property paga 10 EXHIBIT 3 Case 15-22095 Doc 32 Filed 03/23/16 Entered 03/23/16 16:29:39 Page 1of10 _Fill In this Information to idontlfy your case and this filing: Debtor 1 JoAnne M. Williams t~itthmo Debtor 2 (S!)Cuse, if f1liflg) f;u\ tlMM ---- lMlthme United Slates Bunkruptcy Court for the: Distdcl of Connecticut Case number 15-22095 amn -· -·-- ---~------~------ 1121 Check if this is an amended filing Official Form 106A/B Schedule A/B: Property 12/15 In each category, separately llst and describe lte1ns. List an asset only once. If an asset fits In n1ore than ono catogory, llst tho assot In tho category whoro you think It fits best. Be as complete and accurate as possible. If two married people are flllng together, both aro equally responsible for supplying correct Information. If more space Is needed, attach a separate sheet to this form. On the top of any additional pages, write your name and case nun1ber (if known}. Answer every question. Describe Each Residence, Building, Land, or Other Real Estate You Own or Have an Interest In Do you own or have any legal or equitable Interest In any residence, building, land, or similar property? 0 No. Go to Part 2. 0 Yes. Where is the property? What Is the property? Check an that apply. Do not deduct secured claims or exemptions. Put Ga' Single-family home lh1;1 amount of any secured claims on Schedule D: 11. 42 Florence Lar_1e________ Creditors Who Have Claims Secured by Property. Street -addrOss, if available, or other description 0 Duplex or multi-unit building D Condominium or cooperative Current value of the Current value of the D Manufactured or mobile home ontlro property? portion you own? lJ land s_E5,00Q:_D_!l_ $ 225,000.00 D Investment property Plainville CT 06062 Doscrlbo tho naturo of your ownership City Slate ZIP Code lJ Timeshore D Other _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ Interest (such as fee shnple, tenancy by the entireties, or a llfe estate), If known. Who has an Interest In the property? Check one. Hartford Ga Debtor I only County D Debtor 2 only 0 Debtor 1 and Debtor 2 only 0 Check If this Is community property (see instructions) 0 At least one of !he debtors and another Othor lnfonnatlon you wish to add about this ltom, such as local property Identification number: - - - - - - - - - - - - - If you own or have more than one, l!sl here: What Is tho property? Check all that apply. Do not deduct secured daims or exemptions. Put D Single-family home the amount ol any secured ciaims on Schadu/e D: Credi/ors Who Heve Claims Secured by Property 1.2. Street address, if ava!!ab!e, or other description D Duplex or multi-unit building D Condominium or cooperative Current value of the Curront value of tho 0 Manufaclured or mobile home entire property? portion you own? D Land $_ _ _ _ _ $_______ _