Preview
Filing # 108429800 E-Filed 06/05/2020 09:03:59 AM
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
CHARLOTTE COUNTY. FLORIOA CIVIL ACTION
HARRY BIEBERSTEIN,
Plaintiff
v. Case No. 17-917CA
GABRIEL KIRCHBERGER, CAROL
DEVILLE, SOUTHERN SHORE
ENTERPRISES, LLC, a Florida limited
liability company, and MOONSTONE
HOLDINGS, LLC, a Nevada limited
ability company,
Defendants.
seven vs
DEFENDANTS DEVILLE/SOUTHERN SHORE ENTERPRISES LLC NOTICE OF FILING
DOCUMENTS
AND SUMMARY
COMES NOW SOUTHERN SHORE ENTERPRISES, LLC and CAROL DEVILLE
Defendants, by and through their undersigned attorney and provides Notice of Filing Documents
and Summary relative to Tax Assessed Values of the listed properties awned by Defendants in the
total amount of $1,815.058.00.
THEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing has been furnished court
e@ poral service to RYAN W. OWEN. Esq. Attomey for Plant?! Adams & Reese, LLP 1515
Ringing Biva., Suite 700, Sarasota, FL ryan.owen@arlaw.com: ROBERT W. SEGUR, Esq
Attorney for Moonstone, 2828 S, McCall Road PMe 56, Englewood. FL 34224
legal@sequriaw.nst; GLENN SIEGEL, Esq.; Attomey for Kirchoerger, 17825 Murdock Circle, Suite
A, Port Crarotte, FL 33948 gsiegel@glennsiegellaw.com kim@glennsiegellaw.com 5
CHRISTOPHER KLEIN, Esq. Baur & Klein, P.A. 1007 Brickell Bay Drive, Suite 1200, Miami, FL
33134 Ckiein@worldwidelaw com this 6" day of June, 2020
ete con
DAVID AKS, ESQ.
40/7 East Marion Avenue, Suite 104
Punta Gorda, FL 33950
(841) 649-7627
doaksesa@comcast
net
Florida Bar No. 0301817
Atterney for Defendants SOUTHERN SHORE
ENTERPRISES LLC & DEVILLE
SSE Property Taxes Assessment Forms
Production of
Decument # Property Address 2020 Assessment
2276 Yancy Street $105,620.00
13035 Tamiami Trait 5622,408).00
13075 Tamiamt Trail $54,500.00
4868 England Ave $128,226.00)
368 Bonsell Orive $3,570.00
12038 Green Gulf Blvd Punta Gorda $2,210.00
1810 £l lobean $369,208.00
31435 Collingswood Unit G $371,246.00
4369 Flectric Way $276, 563.00
10508 Gulfstream BLVD $78,505.00
27209 Sandrata De. Punta Gorda $2,216.00
2814 69th St. W. Lehigh Acres $3,800,00
.
s re
® a! a ee oi filee ty ‘ee
oe ES RPairte iar io ti) ata
i
a ee oe re
Yax Record
ast Cabo: ioe AMERY
Oetais
Yaw Bees d
Ag Valovem Taxes and Soouasl Valorem Assessments
ek Hebe ge Tae tax ¥
‘Se Poe
Acteteowe Pony Askioens
Sees ve
“0 a hee tat
te ty eee
Pome, me e cegise alia
te Punations com fon bolo
Pre somrky Taxes witiage Sale Eeveow Gots
Seempelon cas! a
we i
a i. Dawe gtgt ae |
et fi
oe ssn
frre
stein ss eso
om a ne Paes tsa
Rane Aeaunegs Saeagt ion Fanaziw Gaxag
Piekan cherity Su Aen ‘anit ect
thi Millage ar
fa $d Navinen! 4 fue a
Tides Tare png Beh = Rare
ke
fy
Ve
ses
Gr feta. fawmanm vee
2
Serengeti
Te a By agit Chon
fsa Senet pectin
rt
po
oe ites seen ae me aia,
fae
be sen sm
Florida Tax Collector NOTICE OF AD VALOREM TAXES AND NON-AD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS
Gates Gai caates — seeing Swascen Caety 2019 REAL, ESTATE
5A B Wematingiee Bud | Berane FL MZ36-POED
‘4.865 4300. eptan 2 rteGSaremctaT esZoiecter com Ship The Trp! www. Sarasota TaxCallector.com
sorrn SecwnstaTaa Selects xe ool me tee)
fe eGiere Lmiecnces pyre hem phat ohms tie Anoust
1 CHRR cams (2 Cm Mee wae ay i Kern! eeccmues
Account © VEBTORINT | Prist Your Recaipt Inasently:
ee SMa
Bg ENTERPRIGEELL oe Psieeen ss 18H ADE TO
OPE
ie
ees Beas 1207
EVACUATION ZONE a
ws
AD VALOREM TAXES: pas
as a rors a3 Cs) Er: tic
Pre
SucesoteGo, Genera! Rrwenum 2oTS a aot 19483
ae as Soon any 479,400. 1s
Sacnenie
Go La fas et Soe Dowty aa 427 a
3 Bet SO a2 ao waeid
fad Heth Bas BLT 7168 peat 3a at
ar SPY 33; 26 OIE) 2 eH
BAF, vee
BHATT OOO 130m
Habe
rt Pant se sag ane aA 6
cvosl Castel berg at azn Tt sah 180817
Ging ot eset:
Brat
TOTAL MLE a ow she AGTH, Sth VALOREM TAKES, 9a284,53
.
Pees HOSA VALOREM ABSEBEUENTS
YOUR EXEMPTIONS ae on at
Mo exemptions tee 2019 Detth Bart Fe 8 Reescoe Bat Gan Be ber pate ee tt
7 North Hert Mowe & Drange Bet 2b, te parce 12808
‘iach Fort MAD Cuesta ‘oars San 2a ee parcel ABBE
es trai ae
‘Questions
enoul eamptians? TOTAL NOMAD VALOREM SUGEASMENTS ~ Check dediathity wih tax Mesaionad
or
\get.ast nooo Page24. [COMBINED TARES AND ASSESSMENTS (qe below for amount to pay! ‘Sie
c
‘Bay ae etersae 98,608.82 304 wO19E 77 34,250.10 $842 w
| daecand atrmndy deduritedt| _ ee. 32. 31.2 an 31, 3020 Fab 29, 2059 Mar 34. 200!
Florida Tax Collector — 2018 REAL ESTATE hnpent Sue base oe} the datas paid in the office,
imeforkiomes ern casas Losey TaxCollseter.coen, or postmariad. |
S01 véwshengton
Geet j Sarmactn FL 34236-2003
ed BOT (4% dioound) $4,00882
28S B0Re 19025 TAMAR TRE
| Dees 2010 19% chazound) $092.34
SHORES ENTERPRISES Li. aan) RAED OM msceerly M0787
2810EL
Y GRAB, OTTE Fi, Sabet-12n7 Fok 20, 2920 (1% discount} erie 8
Hm 31), 2920 (ne diacourt) $54282
ariih a Lamsites Betarn Fo Sosa
US here onk Ne ogmitaned ners
GERGSOOLD QORTARVELE UGHOOOSLESSS0000 GOL b
Florida Tax Collector ROTICE DE AD VALOREM TAXES AMD NONAD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS
Tephara Fors Laaies — jerving Sacnuons Conary 2019 REAL ESTATE
ie Beconons, Fl, 4238-8985 www Saresot TaxCollector.com
943 MS 8302, apean 91 ito SacwnstaT ees otientor cam Skip The Trip?
wee cba jnbcares saunterpats nehing eauct th
re Mee
mere, Sowa earl 2.40% tng nee te IP pap preset
Ukecount # 0897093308 : Your Receipt Spstantiy!
aoccc
ennaermrepenmentiinmsnn
ce
Hib atateoisleet hehe lea 18 TaMmagTR
SHORES ENTERERISES Li, GOTUe Bue 9 18 He ack YOO PORT
BeeeTP GHARISUFE
OBEN FL A368
Ew TH BORNE
AG VALOREM TAXES:
r 43
i = out cL ft
Baravoga
Co, Senet teremnon ‘ay 881 S608 e ate 83
1 ae Oat $1200 ay
Go, LapaTH S41 Be) aoe 2okth 5s 80 at B18
a Se soe Br boo Sea)
sagt ee 58 Se Soo aap
get ae a ig HD aan a 85.b0p Hea
Coo tas
Merge Sat aa pone e208
Boao ake Sy BOS
‘Beate Psd Saaus 31.800 aoe ana
1 feo 61 sao 045
tity oF Nerds
Past aeRO sam GD 7868
FY
A
TOTAL WLLADE ABT TOT A, A) MAL AN TARE,
BS pees eT bt,
PER AENELS cam men aa
YOUR EXEMPTIONS mT im ie cin
Ne owernptions fre 2059 ‘hats Poet Fay & Raszun wat 2a AB pe ner ae
Norte Bor Rand & Granaige 247 ban 8063, BAC price rh 66
Nort: Poot RAG Capit imprizo at 2a ate Der Dara 14.00
Es nema
Dusatines apout ewermpionn?
Appraae
& HON AD VALOREM ASEESEMENTS - Capos det.citdity
wat lm ‘wont
Nga 88 PARDEG-Ea, [COMBINED
TAXES AND ASSESEMENTS [uae bolow
tor amourt to pay) nora |
[Rep ane arom
ws ieee alts encischad
51,082.07 ‘ataraee! 81 088.068 st a3 B.0aF 3
Nee Bes dan at oat Fob 29, 2020 | tee Re
Flarida tax Collector 2019 REAL ESTATE ‘Amount
due based on the dubs paid in the office,
Teil tidus won brea ciney at werw.fiermnota TanCollector.cam, or postmarked,
SO! S WengenBiva. : Sarrssta, FL 26708-6953
Anesunt #; 0887083319
| Nene 2019 4% sca) scene
Sansa aeos 2 A07E Tanne TH
| Deen 31, 2018 {3% decouni) S107 8
‘foarte. SHORES ENTERPRISES [sant (2020 (2% discount] 3168.8
{EE PL oman
STTE
PL ates | Feb 29. 2020 (1% discount) 81.095 19 t
Mar 23, BIRO gne ctacouney SY 107 ao
c8 paeanbaets Tau stam Awwara Fev
LOS Surge ony fo somtiohed chencta
HOGNANNTOO OoAoLared HOSQOIALIsbONN OOOL 0
Florida Tax Callector ROTICE OF AD VALOREM
TAKES AND NON.AD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS.
iach Ford Coates = serie Sormictn Loaty 2019 REAL ESTATE
LOE % Wimtiongton Hd. | Serenata FL STIG
Sos Be BODE psten 2 | ining Bacasone TanGobectar
sien argncen aatsteckin ci.
co Shir The Trt6: paysentwow.Rem poorSarasota
shack
TanCollector.com
ecaeed vate me Ane
eth,
Coat cnet A ne ated fey Be gerprens bro
(Accounts: Tiasonaszs
| Print Voor Recaipe [rimtaaty!
sett ent tbe ogo
seats ADAH ENGLAND ANE
In SHORES ENTERPRIBES Li Lot 6 abo1S
Non Poet
Son
gene Shee 0mm
Eeacuitocn ZUNE: O
AD VALOREM TAXES
ris cr eres ay:
fi Cucel
= ihe Can Gecerel Ravenwe: ‘bat pay game 12a 2a sas et a1 ae
Be oat eu 12828 a rae 18a
ascanCo. ety Tet Ba met 5 a8ao sea re e 128 sat
opm ae
Bat a7 S18 68nd epee. AME 133d
lage
BAW FL esta Meregenes Se 45 277 3732 eee ae
ania ae, $a8
Sacrarnte Setend Goare B41 SET BE IR ta aso
Fued pea sat N40 300 pee.
zt
ay soete|
Gihy wt ectsBont SAL ATE TE aan6 abe a8 ae8
Tor LACE San TOTAL Ae WAL OREN TAKES r 8209051,
co a xe
| ‘YOUR EXEMPTIONS: rare
+ No exemptions
for 2019 a Zan BES pot gant
4
aeceo
eici i‘ecth ant Boke nares
Sheth Patt Rows & Deainage
| Sean Pert RAD Canta erprees
we
0
pai20 08
pat
pat pepe
par parent
aS
re
8.00
Guestions spout exempears? TSTAL NOMAD VACOMEM ASSESIRAENTE - Chuck cncctiodty wi tar proigentonal ies72
\ga1 987 8200 | PABEG-FA
com, COMBINED TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS (ome Balow for smnnurdt to pay) szrmas |
onanism
Fay nem were ARTIS ee.e8 aa raRar ag fan. ag.774.29
‘encerseh siemasky shochecti Now 30. 2019 Dec 34, 2018 dan 34, 2020 Fete 25; 2020 MecMt 2oa0
ar
Florida Tax Coile:
lector 2078 REAL ESTATE Amaurt toe gared on the date paig im the office,
Dea tint Coes, ‘vr Sanna. at www. Baresota FaxCotlactor.com, of postmarked
$055. WwewringeenGe. | Sarmacte, FL 3AZINGBS
1348056823
iow 30, 2070 (4 eeer.10
pa so 4883 ENSLAND AVE
Bee21, 2009 (2% steno 828488,
suas ENTERPRISES UL din 31, 2020 12% danears) eae a
Bee ae
ARLOTTE2 138 Fee Ph BOBO ITH diasount, SE THO AB
ae, 20a tne Bi, ag.778 28
toca sustete Sate Riwitnin Sere Ceres
& foc
— fo peated
eer chai mi
gonsnoacne QCODS77AS3 OHONGHeSeHISSOOo GooL 7
aie i, TE ¥ 2°
Vickie L, Potts rumians featiae 2A
sg era: Grek ie EOE geih
CHARLOTTE COTY FAR COLLECTOR Oe
sae beng fa kage an
os 8G N Me Ce
cab Age
Sat Pot pasdesin,
ae
WALA i CLS TORMERS
semenBRINE
E reps a EMOTE
HER SES ENT ALORS DEVE sorrento
wy 3 9
vaaae, 8 SOLE i Parcet 4024 fp 4os008
sei
Tas Distre: 104
wee wncnotiot
re p mi
snes
2 ‘pe38, 2020
S303,7
= a$423.76Bch
000. shesntminan =|
iePlease Pay Si74.82 i wei
Ad Valorem Taxes
at = ee CS x co Lot " og eG
i Re 198: ne
Bika on pee ae
eet 158a "a
Hsien oe
\ i
2 ee
ee Bt aoe a5 bik
TOTAL WEAOR WATE TASES ora. tans, bag
oes @ Vabcirert
- cr cer S
— me
eaei A
AS SCTE 7h
ts or nero
VOMAL COMMORED TES AIM.
igen * Ena ifeuctiactariitbverctiocontetiges
‘Pos edidRionel \chicrettan sianee dee oeveran pide © Saye Tw. Po Crvlon af gutanestiorter ahenbitamnanyt
:A
CHARLOTTE COUNTY 1s
zaie Notice of Ad Valorern Taxes and Non-Ad Valarens Aqsessments
:
fie ees pasate8 _pocnerenrenrenneenrnnitcininnnia
a | Vath bring the tataning armaied inaicatent*
z ‘Rhald Pepin ate
OQ Mor See Bata 5o
a 5
mney. | C1)a Ape
Way 3,23 2020
2030 SMEG
ADL Te
zi
as |
eo || pce
Daewr eedsomation: SOL RE ear acet LE i
S98 14S by t
GLAPRE 1-80 2%!
ia
TERR,
Aicslon: Padara & say oe dy hse eet maou mn Adzereng
(Proverty eration
Adee a8 SEE HAR 5 anda tex Certtioals bal aati again tie prupdety.
_ —
[PLEASE
DO NO WATE peLOw THIS AREA*
:é #OSRQRECSEDE 2044.3
BEAL DST ATE Oeste
Vickie i. Potts doors aE REDON al Fath
CHARLOTTE COUNTY TAK COLAC TOR ‘aga Shewigtion ‘GP: DO OBOE PHOS Gs A UME BURT LT 6 GOMATTRA THN
Corte Acbinatration tsi PROTS18 PRS :
TRGOE Misrebocke Circle ‘cad
or: it Rsk
Ae Post Chartne 96 PIRERIOFE
WALKIN CUSTOMERS
SOUTHERN SHORES (NT MAGA Deve PLEASE BRING THIS ENTIRE NOTICE
IHN 19
TARABA Fh shore { Parceli: 4323631030045
| Tax District: 104 :
fovea
HE ae i, Mar 31, 2030, Apr
90, 3030, May 29, 2030.
Pisase Say $218.34 $224.68 $262,608
Ad Valorem Taxes
‘aa 7a tem ane a a
GRLATER CHRIS EUR TRNG: Wy ae a
Gam Ewponcutiy ea Ly Bae a8 on
uh
Eater
‘Signs O54 COM Scecee.
a8
MLM ene
thom ae ihe oR
tat
SR CMST TWO REET scott oe 2 Hane Lee ie
Ae ease a8 230 ie
o
TOTAL MLAS RATE 16 ERE ‘Pova rane; 0
Non-Ad Valorem Assessments
= a cs a ety
BM CHRSECTIE8) wae
TROP GARY ACRES
UA STAN
LT enw ioe
Thee potas,
or nett TOTHL GoeétoNen
satarmaton eiuae ose seen elt © ‘Sar Tite Fey Deine ot neeycMamnatasiar gnaetinco Hares AND ante Neat
untyfguee ~ Covad:
CHARLOTTE COUNTY A iomeentaae
2019 Notice of Ad Valorem Taxes and Non-Ad Valor
em Astessments
Make checks pupae om: Crarlctie County Tan Cotectie
ARSE & MORON CMS MT AF aad 28 NE i
BORA DRE REE Babee “DD RIEas Ca |. parrthe Inaweng ameunt dicate!
Mail PapeRERES Bie: ORS! Kivodiock Ciche
Sort Charge beta Mar 3", 2020
‘Tettghone: $4. 283-1195 Ape 30, 220,
21544
266
ParcelEe aIerowos May 28, 2020 $262,008
‘Gore Internation: SORTER SHORES TAT Liter DEAE
(GSH wT98T Oo
TAMPAFL 15812
Property Adcraas: «Joie CAPER CLAT BW ‘Watlen:
© nay
Fati
ihe anmuTts
es gos wl ck in
RUNTA GRCA and a Tax Cornice being freed euch penpery
“"' PLEASE DO NOT WRITE BELOW THIS AREA‘?
2b 48SSD93NI0GN FOG 2
Frat Sua NBME ES
Vickie L. Potts Sroptet Astin 810 EL AOREANAS
CHARLOTTE COUNTY TAR couLécTom — Lage! Denrieton PCH ca) O88 0078 PUNT CHARLOTTE BEAT BLNESS
Conesy Aateieertrabicn: Bite
Si wital
38900 Murdock tce th
Pret Chantome, Fi, 9Ve8-1S7S Ee
ogee
OA oa a egret ty
‘CHARLOTTE COUNTY pear a ba oye
2OUS Notice of Ad Veloturi Tases and Nom-Ad Valorer: Assessments nebo ee,
tities
SORTA SARE ENTERPRISES
5 GAN SAY ERTS
OB Scahan ( Parcel 1D: ao21 2357026
Ams
SORT CHARLOTTE, Fi | Tax District: 164
i
Aecsmeted tx] New 90, 2018. fac d 201 L Jon. 31, 2030. Feb 29, 20 | Mor