Order: Opera House Lofts Llc v. Christopher Carnahan, Stephen Meyers, Julie Covello, Ryan Shollenberger, Alexander Azzure, Celina Vicioso, Michael Chesbro, Tatiana Reid, Ahmed Almahdi, Howida Tarabzooni, Piya Malik, Samantha Cunningham, Laura Newman, Diana Osorio, Andres Rincon, Kelsey Fairhurst, Bryant Wells, Shannon Lumpkin, Anthony Christie, Aurora Halal, Jason Halal, Christoph Krey, Casey Halter, Evan Batson, Andrew Wehnke, Jessica Muller AKA JESSICA MILLER, Peter Carlovich, Sarah Beilenson, Gavin Koepke, Sarah Labriola, Paula Smith, Jordan Smith, Hellen Smith, Hector Macel aka Hector Malacaria, Daniel Mcinerney, Richard Einhorn, Ari Finkel, Michael Ralston, Molly Wypyski, Ryan Schweitzer, Slyvie Wise, Andrew Fassel, Gia Kourlas, Sonja Einem, Jack Ford, Joon Lee, Kendall Payne, Mutaurwa Mapondera, Yohay Ben-Itzhak, Subantita Suwan, Casssandra Emmett, Hector Guerra, Cassandra Fernandes, Martin Argueta, Alex Regan aka ALEX REGEN, Guho Kevin Kim, Anastasia Vlasova, Sebastian Rodas Medeiros, Mie Vedel Joergensen, Kevin Urvalek, Katrina Wilson, Michael Sauder, Margarita Cardenas, Sarah Witham, Joseph Tyman, Jaka Vinsek, Caroline Silverman, Willaim Klimbert, Beth Morgan, David Richter, Seth Lopez, David Call, Richard Maguire, Emily Zech, Tristan Hughes-Freeland, Jeremy Hawkins, Dana Cataldo, Tyler Harris, Jeffrey Arthur, Chelsea Spencer, Johannes Staudt, Amber Renaye a/k/a Amber Thomas, Josh Reames, Zachary Pless, Jordan Sutherland, Bethany Reeves, Gerrard Deasy, The New York City Department Of Buildings

On March 22, 2020 a Order was filed involving a dispute between Opera House Lofts Llc, and Ahmed Almahdi, Alexander Azzure, Alexandra Harrington, Alex Regan, Alex Regan Aka Alex Regen, Alicia French, Amber Renaye A K A Amber Thomas, Amber Thomas, Anastasia Vlasova, Andres Rincon, Andrew Fassel, Andrew Wehnke, Anthony Christie, Ari Finkel, Aurora Halal, Bethany Reeves, Beth Morgan, Brandon Smith, Brooke Davies, Bryant Wells, Carly Forgach, Caroline Silverman, Casey Halter, Cassandra Fernandes, Casssandra Emmett, Celina Vicioso, Chelsea Spencer, Christopher Carnahan, Christoph Krey, Dana Cataldo, Daniel Mcinerney, David Call, David Richter, Diana Osorio, Edras Maldonado, Elanor Barnes, Emily Zech, Evan Batson, Evander Batson, Gavin Koepke, Gerrard Deasy, Gia Kourlas, Giancarlo Roca, Grant Gulla, Guho Kevin Kim, Hector Guerra, Hector Macel Aka Hector Malacaria, Hector Malacaria, Hellen Smith, Henry Gordon-Smith, Howida Tarabzooni, Jack Ford, Jaka Vinsek, Jason Halal, Jeffrey Arthur, Jenzo Duque, Jeremy Hawkins, Jessica Muller, Jessica Muller Aka Jessica Miller, Joanna Whicker, Johannes Staudt, Joon Lee, Jordan Smith, Jordan Sutherland, Joseph Lewis, Joseph Simons, Joseph Tyman, Josh Reames, Julie Covello, Katrina Wilson, Kelsey Fairhurst, Kendall Payne, Kevin Kim, Kevin Urvalek, Laura Newman, Laurence Beilenson, Luisel Pena, Madalyn Drew, Madeline Arnoldy, Marcella Lentz-Pope, Margarita Cardenas, Martin Argueta, Michael Chesbro, Michael Ralston, Michael Sauder, Mie Vedel Joergensen, Molly Wypyski, Mutaurwa Mapondera, Nicholas Cortezi, Noah Goldberg, Pablo Smith, Paula Smith, Peter Carlovich, Piya Malik, Quinn Mcgovern, Radhika Basu, Richard Einhorn, Richard Maguire, Rocco Mancinelli, Roque Silva, Ryan Schweitzer, Ryan Shollenberger, Samantha Cunningham, Samantha Giovinco, Sarah Beilenson, Sarah Labriola, Sarah Witham, Sebastian Medeiros, Sebastian Rodas Medeiros, Seth Lopez, Shannon Lumpkin, Slyvie Wise, Sonja Einem, Stephanie Deangelis, Stephen Meyers, Subantita Suwan, Tatiana Reid, The New York City Department Of Buildings, Thomas Parker, Tony Christie, Tristan Hughes-Freeland, Tyler Harris, Willaim Klimbert, Winston Adeyemo, Yohay Ben-Itzhak, Zachary Pless, for Real Property - Other (Declaratory Judgment) in the District Court of Kings County.

						
                                Preview
                                INDEX   NO.        507079/2020
(FILED:     KINGS COUNTY CLERK                             1270572023                 12:28 PM
NYSCEF   DOC.        NO.   488                                                                                    RECEIVED     NYSCEF:          12/05/2023
                                                                                               At IAS Part 9 of the Supreme Court of
                                                                                               the State of New Y ork, Kings County,
                                                                                               on the 5th day of December, 2022

                PRESENT: Hon. LAWRENCE KNIPEL,                          JSC
                              Administrative J udge
                weee nen                         een      en een nenneenneennee
                OPERA HOUSE LOFTS, LLC,                                                            AMENDED
                                                       Plaintiff(s)                                SPECIAL REFEREE ORDER

                                   - against -                                                     Index No. 507079/2020

                CARNAHAN, etal,
                                                     Defendant(s)
                wen eeceeeeeeenenn eeeeenneenneeneenee eee en ee neenneeeeeenee

                        At the request of Justice DEBRA SILBER, and pursuant to Article 22, of the Judiciary Law, in
                accordance with the provisions of Part 122 of the Rules of the Chief A dministrator of the Courts
                (NYCRR Part 122), the issues referred below are assigned to a:

                Mw         Special Referee

                The date will be fixed by the Clerk of the Part. This reference shall be to:

                a          Hear and Determine pursuant to the stipulation of the parties with respect to the issue(s) of

                           Attorneys’ fees, costs and disbursements the plaintiff is entitled to, as well as the amount
                           of the damages, consisting of rent and additional rent, that plaintiff is entitled to, from the
                           occupants of the apartments specified in the decision/order of the court dated October 24,
                           2022, on motion seq. #7, as amended by the Decision/Order dated December 5, 2023,                              on
                           motions 11 & 16 to reargue, issued simultaneously herewith. Plaintiff is entitled to
                           judgment upon the referee’s determination.

                         ORDERED, that if the trial of the issue or action hereby referred is not begun within 60 days
                from the date of this order, or before such later date as the Referee or Judicial Hearing Officer may fix
                upon good cause shown, this Order shall be canceled and revoked, and this matter shall be remitted by the
                Referee or the Judicial Hearing Officer back to the assigning Part from which it was issued, and the
                matter shall immediately be returned to the Court for hearing and/or trial.


                                                                                               aan
                                                                                                     Hon. Lawrence Knipel

                On matters to Hear and Determine: Consent of Attorneys:

                Plaintiff: Windels Marx Lane & Mittendorf                             Defendant: Ween & Kozek PLLC
                Address: ane nn                                                       Address: aaa nn
                Phone:       aan  ann nn                                              Phone: aaa                                     aa
                Signature:   aan.                                                     Signature:                aan.                      a.




                                                                                               a
                                                                                                     Hon. Debra Silber, J SC
                                                                              lof 1

Case Info

Judge

Kerry J. Ward Track Judge’s New Case

Case No.

(Subscribe to View)

Document Filed Date

December 05, 2023

Case Filing Date

March 22, 2020

County

Parties

(2021-023677) Attorney for the Defendant
Ahmed Almahdi Defendant
Alexander Azzure Defendant
Alexandra Harrington Defendant
Alex Regan Defendant
Alex Regan aka ALEX REGEN Defendant
Alicia French Defendant
Amber Renaye a/k/a Amber Thomas Defendant
Amber Thomas Defendant
Anastasia Vlasova Defendant
Andres Rincon Defendant
Andrew Fassel Defendant
Andrew Wehnke Defendant
Anthony Christie Defendant
Ari Finkel Defendant
Aurora Halal Defendant
Bethany Reeves Defendant
Beth Morgan Defendant
Brandon Smith Defendant
Brooke Davies Defendant
Bryant Wells Defendant
Carly Forgach Defendant
Caroline Silverman Defendant
Casey Halter Defendant
CASSADY, ANDREW DAVID Attorney for the Defendant
Cassandra Fernandes Defendant
Casssandra Emmett Defendant
Celina Vicioso Defendant
Chelsea Spencer Defendant
Christopher Carnahan Defendant
Christoph Krey Defendant
CURRAN, MICHAEL ROLAND Attorney for the Defendant
Dana Cataldo Defendant
Daniel Mcinerney Defendant
David Call Defendant
David Richter Defendant
Diana Osorio Defendant
Edras Maldonado Defendant
Elanor Barnes Defendant
Emily Zech Defendant
Evan Batson Defendant
Evander Batson Defendant
FROSCH, JASON MICHAEL Attorney for the Plaintiff
Gavin Koepke Defendant
Gerrard Deasy Defendant
Gia Kourlas Defendant
Giancarlo Roca Defendant
Grant Gulla Defendant
Guho kevin Kim Defendant
Hector Guerra Defendant
Hector Macel aka Hector Malacaria Defendant
Hector Malacaria Defendant
Hellen Smith Defendant
Henry Gordon-smith Defendant
Howida Tarabzooni Defendant
Jack Ford Defendant
Jaka Vinsek Defendant
Jason Halal Defendant
Jeffrey Arthur Defendant
Jenzo Duque Defendant
Jeremy Hawkins Defendant
Jessica Muller Defendant
Jessica Muller AKA JESSICA MILLER Defendant
Joanna Whicker Defendant
Johannes Staudt Defendant
Joon Lee Defendant
Jordan Smith Defendant
Jordan Sutherland Defendant
Joseph Lewis Defendant
Joseph Simons Defendant
Joseph Tyman Defendant
Josh Reames Defendant
Julie Covello Defendant
Katrina Wilson Defendant
KELLIHER, KATHLEEN BRIDGET Attorney for the Plaintiff
Kelsey Fairhurst Defendant
Kendall Payne Defendant
Kevin Kim Defendant
Kevin Urvalek Defendant
KOZEK-PERKINS, MICHAEL PARIS Attorney for the Defendant
Laura Newman Defendant
Laurence Beilenson Defendant
Luisel Pena Defendant
Madalyn Drew Defendant
Madeline Arnoldy Defendant
Marcella Lentz-pope Defendant
Margarita Cardenas Defendant
Martin Argueta Defendant
Michael Chesbro Defendant
Michael Ralston Defendant
Michael Sauder Defendant
Mie Vedel joergensen Defendant
Molly Wypyski Defendant
Mutaurwa Mapondera Defendant
Nicholas Cortezi Defendant
Noah Goldberg Defendant
Opera House Lofts LLC Plaintiff
Pablo Smith Defendant
Paula Smith Defendant
Peter Carlovich Defendant
Piya Malik Defendant
Quinn Mcgovern Defendant
Radhika Basu Defendant
Richard Einhorn Defendant
Richard Maguire Defendant
Rocco Mancinelli Defendant
Roque Silva Defendant
Ryan Schweitzer Defendant
Ryan Shollenberger Defendant
Samantha Cunningham Defendant
Samantha Giovinco Defendant
Sarah Beilenson Defendant
Sarah Labriola Defendant
Sarah Witham Defendant
Sebastian Medeiros Defendant
Sebastian rodas Medeiros Defendant
Seth Lopez Defendant
Shannon Lumpkin Defendant
Slyvie Wise Defendant
Sonja Einem Defendant
SOU, KACEY HOI-LAM Attorney for the Plaintiff
Stephanie Deangelis Defendant
Stephen Meyers Defendant
Subantita Suwan Defendant
Tatiana Reid Defendant
THE NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF BUILDINGS Defendant
Thomas Parker Defendant
Tony Christie Defendant
Tristan Hughes-freeland Defendant
Tyler Harris Defendant
Willaim Klimbert Defendant
Winston Adeyemo Defendant
Yohay Ben-itzhak Defendant
Zachary Pless Defendant
FERNANDO CARABALLO Attorney
ADAM ZUCKER Attorney
JASON FROSCH Attorneys for Plaintiffs
KELECHI ACHOLONU Attorney
JASON MILLER Attorneys for Plaintiffs
MICHAEL FROSCH Attorneys for Plaintiffs
CARL MURACO Attorneys for Plaintiffs
JASON MINTZ Attorneys for Plaintiffs
MARY O'SULLIVAN Attorney
STEPHAN CLARKE Attorney
KACEY SOU Attorneys for Plaintiffs
BERNARD SHAFRAN Attorney

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.

Preview

Related Topics

Case Info

Parties