Preview
FILED
11/21/2023 5:04 PM
FELICIA PITRE
DISTRICT CLERK
DALLAS CO., TEXAS
Jenifer Trujillo DEPUTY
CAUSE NO. DC-20-1 1 175
MICHAEL WILLIAMS, § IN THE DISTRICT COURT
§
Plaintzffi §
§
§
v. §
§ DALLAS, COUNTY, TEXAS
TXI OPERATIONS, L.P., §
TEXAS INDUSTRIES, INC., §
MARTIN MARIETTA, §
MARTIN MARIETTA MATERIALS, INC.,§
AND MARTIN MARIETTA MATERIALS §
SOUTHWEST, L.L.C. §
§
Defendants. § 134th JUDICIAL DISTRICT
DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS
Defendants TXI Operations, L.P., Texas Industries, Inc., Martin Marietta, Martin Marietta
Materials, Inc., and Martin Marietta Materials Southwest, L.L.C. serve their objections to
Plaintiff’ s Deposition Designations. Defendants reserve the right to amend or supplement these
objections.
I. OBJECTION KEY
Code Objection
AF Assumes facts not in evidence (TRE 104(b))
402 Not relevant (TRE 402)
403 Confusing and unduly prejudicial; cumulative (TRE 403)
PRIV Pertains to issues protected by the attorney-client privilege (TRE 503)
LPK Lack of personal knowledge (TRE 602)
LF Lack of foundation (TRE 602)
SPEC Calls for speculation (TRE 602)
NR Non-responsive (TRE 61 1(a))
ARGUE Argumentative (TRE (611(3))
701 Lay opinion testimony that is (i) not reasonably based on perception, (ii)
not helpful to a clear understanding of the witness’s testimony, and/or
(iii) the determination of a fact in dispute (TRE 701)
DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS T0 PLAINTIFF’s DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 1
Code Objection
H Hearsay - Statement made by one other than the declarant While
testifying at trial, offered into evidence to prove the truth of the matter
asserted (TRE 802)
901 Not authenticated (TRE 901)
INCH Incomplete hypothetical
IMPH Improper hypothetical
NG Expert opinion not timely designated by the propounding party.
LC Calls for or constitutes a legal conclusion
V Vague, ambiguous, and/or misleading
MIS Misstates the witness’s prior testimony or evidence in the case
II. OBJECTIONS
Deposition of Jayson Aydelotte, M.D.
May 8th, 2023
Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection
4:20 5:4
5:14 8:4
9:21 10:18
11:10 11:21
12:8 13:1
13:23 14:14
15:24 18:5
19:20 20:2
24:21 26:16
28:13 28:17 901, 402,
403, AF, LF
29:13 29:20 901, 402,
403, AF, LF
29:23 30:3 901, 402,
403, AF, LF
30:12 30:20 901, 402,
403, AF, LF
31:7 31:19 901,402, 403, AF, LF
32:1 36:15
37:2 38:7 NR in part, 901, 402,
403, AF, LF
39:3 41:4 901, 402, 403, AF, LF
41:10 43:4 901,402, 403,AF, LF
43:14 45:23 901, 402, 403, AF, LF
46:5 46:9 901, 402, 403, AF, LF
48:14 50:13 NR, 901, 402, 403, AF,
LF
50:24 51:6
51:18 51:22
52:4 52:12
53:6 53:14
DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS T0 PLAINTIFF’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 2
Deposition of Jayson Aydelotte, M.D.
May 8th, 2023
Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection
65:14 67:4
Deposition of Larry Hill
August 12‘“, 2022
Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection
4:25 5:22
13:1 13:8
13:24 14:22
16:3 16:8
16:17 17:5
18:25 19:20
20:11 20:19
25:1 25:12
27:14 27:25
29:2 30:18
40:11 40:19
41:1 41:18
42:2 42:11
44:18 45:20
53:13 53:25
Deposition of Jimmy Nance
November 9th, 2022
Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection
6:9 6:18
1 1:18 11:23
14:5 17:16
17:23 17:25
21 :2 21 :6
21:23 22: 14 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
22:17 22:25 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
24:13 24:25 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
29:22 30: 14 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
30:22 31:7 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
36:4 36:11
36:25 37:8
37:21 38:6
DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS T0 PLAINTIFF’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 3
Deposition of Jimmy Nance
November 9th, 2022
Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection
38: 18 38:21
39:6 39:22
40:22 41 :2 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
44:7 47:1 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
47:18 47:24 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
54:21 55:12 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
56:9 56:17 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
57:25 58:20 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
64:12 65:1 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
65:21 67: 14 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
68: 13 69:9 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
69: 15 69:17 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
69:21 70: 16 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
72:19 72:22
Deposition of Freddie Patterson
Feb 11‘“, 2022
Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection
4:24 5:1
5:21 6:9
10:22 11:4
13:5 13:16
14:4 14:21
15:20 15:24
16:14 16:24
17:17 17:20
18:3 18:15
19:4 19:5
19:22 20:2
20:10 21:1
34:24 35:13
35:21 36:1
57:12 58:23
62:20 65:3
67:4 68:20
72:22 73:14
75:23 76:14
77:1 77:15 LF, 402, 403, 701
77:17 77:23 LF, 402, 403, 701
DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS T0 PLAINTIFF’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 4
Deposition of Freddie Patterson
Feb 11‘“, 2022
Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection
78:1 78:7
88:21 89:13
94:21 94:25
98:9 98:12
105:14 106:14
12225 125:21
Deposition of Bobby Romero
July 21“, 2022
Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection
5:11 5:14
6:7 6:10
13:17 15:6
17:7 17:15
17:22 18:8
20:21 21:7
22:13 22:23 AF, LF, 403
22:25 22:25 AF, LF, 403
25:11 26:7
27:25 28:12
28:18 29:25
33:19 34:14
38:11 39:11
47:16 48:2
48:16 50:11
52:8 55:25
59:6 62:8 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
62:10 62:10 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
62:23 63:8 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
63:10 63:15 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
64:5 64:22 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
65:9 66: 19 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
66:21 66:21 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE
66:25 67:5
DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS T0 PLAINTIFF’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 5
Deposition of Richard Smith
August 9‘“, 2022
Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection
4:21 5:5
5:14 6:1
12:17 13:7
15:3 15:8
16:12 16:24
19:4 19:11
19:21 20:4
21:9 22:10
23:10 24:3
26:20 27:22
28:12 29:19
31:17 33:8
35:17 36:15
39:11 40:17
44:14 48:2
49:18 49:21
50:21 51:2
56:4 56:19
Deposition of Blake Sutton
February 22nd, 2023
Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection
4:21 16:22
17:13 20:3
20:23 26:14
27:22 28:18
29:7 34:2
35:12 37:1
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Mark Stradlev
Mark E. Stradley
State Bar No. 19352500
THE STRADLEY LAW FIRM
9330 LBJ Freeway, Suite 1185
Dallas, Texas 75243
DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONs T0 PLAINTIFF’s DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 6
(972) 231-6001
(972) 231-7004 (FAX)
Mark@Stradleylawfirm.com
Parker Graham
State Bar No. 24087612
CARRINGTON, COLEMAN,
SLOMAN & BLUMENTHAL, L.L.P.
901 Main Street, Suite 5500
Dallas, TX 75202
Telephone: 214-855-3000
Fax: 214-580-2641
pgraham@ccsb.com
Attorneys for Defendants
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
This is to certify that a true and correct copy of the above and foregoing instrument has
been sent to Plaintiff’s counsel of record Via electronic service and Via E-mail today
November 21, 2023.
/S/ Parker Graham
DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS T0 PLAINTIFF’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 7
i_11423317v.1
Automated Certificate of eService
This automated certificate of service was created by the efiling system.
The filer served this document via email generated by the efiling system
on the date and to the persons listed below. The rules governing
certificates of service have not changed. Filers must still provide a
certificate of service that complies with all applicable rules.
Parker Graham
Bar No. 24087612
pgraham@ccsb.com
Envelope ID: 81886727
Filing Code Description: Objection
Filing Description: DEFENDANTS/ TO PLAINTIFFS 1ST AMENDED
EXHIBIT LIST
Status as of 11/22/2023 8:55 AM CST
Associated Case Party: MICHAEL WILLIAMS
Name BarNumber Email TimestampSubmitted Status
Karla Rodriguez KRodriguez@carlsonattorneys.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT
Luke Porche LPorche@carlsonattorneys.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT
William Rossick BillRossickEfile@carlsonattorneys.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT
Case Contacts
Name BarNumber Email TimestampSubmitted Status
Carlos Rodriguez crodriguez@car|sonattorneys.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT
Schmitz Christy christy@stradleylawfirm.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT
Mark Stradley Mark@Stradleylawfirm.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT
Francine Ly fly@dallascourts.org 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT
William Rossick WRossick@carlsonattorneys.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT
Rachael Rubio rrubio@carlsonattorneys.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT
Parker LGraham pgraham@ccsb.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT
Patti Littrell plittrell@ccsb.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT
Carolyn Taylor ctaylor@ccsb.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT
Preview
FILED 11/21/2023 5:04 PM FELICIA PITRE DISTRICT CLERK DALLAS CO., TEXAS Jenifer Trujillo DEPUTY CAUSE NO. DC-20-1 1 175 MICHAEL WILLIAMS, § IN THE DISTRICT COURT § Plaintzffi § § § v. § § DALLAS, COUNTY, TEXAS TXI OPERATIONS, L.P., § TEXAS INDUSTRIES, INC., § MARTIN MARIETTA, § MARTIN MARIETTA MATERIALS, INC.,§ AND MARTIN MARIETTA MATERIALS § SOUTHWEST, L.L.C. § § Defendants. § 134th JUDICIAL DISTRICT DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS Defendants TXI Operations, L.P., Texas Industries, Inc., Martin Marietta, Martin Marietta Materials, Inc., and Martin Marietta Materials Southwest, L.L.C. serve their objections to Plaintiff’ s Deposition Designations. Defendants reserve the right to amend or supplement these objections. I. OBJECTION KEY Code Objection AF Assumes facts not in evidence (TRE 104(b)) 402 Not relevant (TRE 402) 403 Confusing and unduly prejudicial; cumulative (TRE 403) PRIV Pertains to issues protected by the attorney-client privilege (TRE 503) LPK Lack of personal knowledge (TRE 602) LF Lack of foundation (TRE 602) SPEC Calls for speculation (TRE 602) NR Non-responsive (TRE 61 1(a)) ARGUE Argumentative (TRE (611(3)) 701 Lay opinion testimony that is (i) not reasonably based on perception, (ii) not helpful to a clear understanding of the witness’s testimony, and/or (iii) the determination of a fact in dispute (TRE 701) DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS T0 PLAINTIFF’s DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 1 Code Objection H Hearsay - Statement made by one other than the declarant While testifying at trial, offered into evidence to prove the truth of the matter asserted (TRE 802) 901 Not authenticated (TRE 901) INCH Incomplete hypothetical IMPH Improper hypothetical NG Expert opinion not timely designated by the propounding party. LC Calls for or constitutes a legal conclusion V Vague, ambiguous, and/or misleading MIS Misstates the witness’s prior testimony or evidence in the case II. OBJECTIONS Deposition of Jayson Aydelotte, M.D. May 8th, 2023 Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection 4:20 5:4 5:14 8:4 9:21 10:18 11:10 11:21 12:8 13:1 13:23 14:14 15:24 18:5 19:20 20:2 24:21 26:16 28:13 28:17 901, 402, 403, AF, LF 29:13 29:20 901, 402, 403, AF, LF 29:23 30:3 901, 402, 403, AF, LF 30:12 30:20 901, 402, 403, AF, LF 31:7 31:19 901,402, 403, AF, LF 32:1 36:15 37:2 38:7 NR in part, 901, 402, 403, AF, LF 39:3 41:4 901, 402, 403, AF, LF 41:10 43:4 901,402, 403,AF, LF 43:14 45:23 901, 402, 403, AF, LF 46:5 46:9 901, 402, 403, AF, LF 48:14 50:13 NR, 901, 402, 403, AF, LF 50:24 51:6 51:18 51:22 52:4 52:12 53:6 53:14 DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS T0 PLAINTIFF’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 2 Deposition of Jayson Aydelotte, M.D. May 8th, 2023 Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection 65:14 67:4 Deposition of Larry Hill August 12‘“, 2022 Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection 4:25 5:22 13:1 13:8 13:24 14:22 16:3 16:8 16:17 17:5 18:25 19:20 20:11 20:19 25:1 25:12 27:14 27:25 29:2 30:18 40:11 40:19 41:1 41:18 42:2 42:11 44:18 45:20 53:13 53:25 Deposition of Jimmy Nance November 9th, 2022 Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection 6:9 6:18 1 1:18 11:23 14:5 17:16 17:23 17:25 21 :2 21 :6 21:23 22: 14 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 22:17 22:25 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 24:13 24:25 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 29:22 30: 14 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 30:22 31:7 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 36:4 36:11 36:25 37:8 37:21 38:6 DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS T0 PLAINTIFF’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 3 Deposition of Jimmy Nance November 9th, 2022 Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection 38: 18 38:21 39:6 39:22 40:22 41 :2 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 44:7 47:1 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 47:18 47:24 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 54:21 55:12 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 56:9 56:17 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 57:25 58:20 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 64:12 65:1 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 65:21 67: 14 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 68: 13 69:9 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 69: 15 69:17 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 69:21 70: 16 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 72:19 72:22 Deposition of Freddie Patterson Feb 11‘“, 2022 Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection 4:24 5:1 5:21 6:9 10:22 11:4 13:5 13:16 14:4 14:21 15:20 15:24 16:14 16:24 17:17 17:20 18:3 18:15 19:4 19:5 19:22 20:2 20:10 21:1 34:24 35:13 35:21 36:1 57:12 58:23 62:20 65:3 67:4 68:20 72:22 73:14 75:23 76:14 77:1 77:15 LF, 402, 403, 701 77:17 77:23 LF, 402, 403, 701 DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS T0 PLAINTIFF’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 4 Deposition of Freddie Patterson Feb 11‘“, 2022 Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection 78:1 78:7 88:21 89:13 94:21 94:25 98:9 98:12 105:14 106:14 12225 125:21 Deposition of Bobby Romero July 21“, 2022 Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection 5:11 5:14 6:7 6:10 13:17 15:6 17:7 17:15 17:22 18:8 20:21 21:7 22:13 22:23 AF, LF, 403 22:25 22:25 AF, LF, 403 25:11 26:7 27:25 28:12 28:18 29:25 33:19 34:14 38:11 39:11 47:16 48:2 48:16 50:11 52:8 55:25 59:6 62:8 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 62:10 62:10 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 62:23 63:8 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 63:10 63:15 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 64:5 64:22 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 65:9 66: 19 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 66:21 66:21 402, 403, IMPH, ARGUE 66:25 67:5 DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS T0 PLAINTIFF’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 5 Deposition of Richard Smith August 9‘“, 2022 Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection 4:21 5:5 5:14 6:1 12:17 13:7 15:3 15:8 16:12 16:24 19:4 19:11 19:21 20:4 21:9 22:10 23:10 24:3 26:20 27:22 28:12 29:19 31:17 33:8 35:17 36:15 39:11 40:17 44:14 48:2 49:18 49:21 50:21 51:2 56:4 56:19 Deposition of Blake Sutton February 22nd, 2023 Beg. Page: Line End Page: Line Objection 4:21 16:22 17:13 20:3 20:23 26:14 27:22 28:18 29:7 34:2 35:12 37:1 Respectfully submitted, /s/ Mark Stradlev Mark E. Stradley State Bar No. 19352500 THE STRADLEY LAW FIRM 9330 LBJ Freeway, Suite 1185 Dallas, Texas 75243 DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONs T0 PLAINTIFF’s DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 6 (972) 231-6001 (972) 231-7004 (FAX) Mark@Stradleylawfirm.com Parker Graham State Bar No. 24087612 CARRINGTON, COLEMAN, SLOMAN & BLUMENTHAL, L.L.P. 901 Main Street, Suite 5500 Dallas, TX 75202 Telephone: 214-855-3000 Fax: 214-580-2641 pgraham@ccsb.com Attorneys for Defendants CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE This is to certify that a true and correct copy of the above and foregoing instrument has been sent to Plaintiff’s counsel of record Via electronic service and Via E-mail today November 21, 2023. /S/ Parker Graham DEFENDANTS’ OBJECTIONS T0 PLAINTIFF’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS PAGE 7 i_11423317v.1 Automated Certificate of eService This automated certificate of service was created by the efiling system. The filer served this document via email generated by the efiling system on the date and to the persons listed below. The rules governing certificates of service have not changed. Filers must still provide a certificate of service that complies with all applicable rules. Parker Graham Bar No. 24087612 pgraham@ccsb.com Envelope ID: 81886727 Filing Code Description: Objection Filing Description: DEFENDANTS/ TO PLAINTIFFS 1ST AMENDED EXHIBIT LIST Status as of 11/22/2023 8:55 AM CST Associated Case Party: MICHAEL WILLIAMS Name BarNumber Email TimestampSubmitted Status Karla Rodriguez KRodriguez@carlsonattorneys.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT Luke Porche LPorche@carlsonattorneys.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT William Rossick BillRossickEfile@carlsonattorneys.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT Case Contacts Name BarNumber Email TimestampSubmitted Status Carlos Rodriguez crodriguez@car|sonattorneys.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT Schmitz Christy christy@stradleylawfirm.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT Mark Stradley Mark@Stradleylawfirm.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT Francine Ly fly@dallascourts.org 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT William Rossick WRossick@carlsonattorneys.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT Rachael Rubio rrubio@carlsonattorneys.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT Parker LGraham pgraham@ccsb.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT Patti Littrell plittrell@ccsb.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT Carolyn Taylor ctaylor@ccsb.com 11/21/2023 5:04:48 PM SENT