Preview
INDEX NO. 516379/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF 11/16/2023
THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF KINGS
ne eee
YITZCHOK ELIMELECH TEITELBAUM a/k/a Index No. 516379/2022
ISAAC TEITELBAUM and YAACOV —_LEIB
DAVIDSON a/k/a YAKOV LEIB DAVIDSOHMN, JUDGMENT
Petitioners,
-against-
YOEL PERL, YOSEF RUBIN a/k/a JOSEPH RUBIN,
and PR BROOKLYN, LLC,
Respondents.
wen nen n enn nnn nnn nnn,
The Petition and Notice of Petition having been filed on June 7, 2022, in this action and,
thereafter, the parties and their attorneys having stipulated fo certain terms and conditions (the
“Stipulation of Settlement’) and Respondents having defaulted in payment under the Stipulation
of Settlement, and Petitioners having moved the Court for judgment pursuant to the terms of the
Supulation of Settlernent, and the Hon Leon Ruchelsman having granted Petitioners’ motion in
an Oder dated August 24, 2023 and entered on September 8. 2023 Ghe “Order”),
Now, upon the Petition and Notice of Petition, the Affirmation of Dov Medinets, Esq.
dated May 18, 2023. the exhibits attached thereto. including the Notices of Default both dated
January 9, 2023, the Stipulation of Settlement, and the Order,
ADJUDGED, that Petitioners YITZCHOK ELIMELECH TEITELBAUM a/k/a ISAAC
TEITELBAUM, whose address is 237 Hooper Street, Brooklyn, N.Y. 11211, and YAACOV
LEIB DAVIDSON a/k/a YAKOV LEIB DAVIDSOMN, whose address is 99 Wilson Street, #4-
D, Brooklyn, N.Y. 11249 have judgment against and shall recover of Respondents YOEL
PERL, whose address is 40 Skillman Street, Unit 4, Brooklyn, N.Y. 11205, YOSEF RUBIN
a/k/a JOSEPH RUBIN, whose address is 281 Bry Avenue, Howell, N.J. 07731, and PR
1 of 61
INDEX NO. 516379/2022
(FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2023 11:04 AM
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2023
BROOKLYN, LLC, whose address is 40 Skillman Street, Unit 4, Brooklyn, N.Y. 11205, jointly
and severally in the sum of SIX HUNDRED FORTY THOUSAND and 00/100 ($640,000.00)
DOLLARS, and that Petitioners have execution therefor.
Judgment signed and entered this 16th day of Nov. in the year 2023.
2023
Newey 2 Ahram.
Clerk
FILED
2023 NOV 16 AM 10:12
KINGS COUNTY CLERK
FEE
2 of 61
ik INDEX NO. 516379/2022
LI OUI
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/06/2023
= seg ees my ge ngage Rx
SUPEESE F EE, ye & y
sy a8 y N i
GUND i Ss
x =e oe heaven a
& hh
Se aise sey 4 a
A f AS he
ee, yy aoe pees:
38 AWD RPA See PE
Oh ge Se
Leer se ey 2 Ss
v Us
Sey pe sf4G ayN ee
1
ay ky
AMS PR Be TEs 5 Asks
Aw 2g
on eee on oe wv ow eo seiae
e nei mem oe som
gs ay see As oNai &
x
SaeARt we gx. 8
ve sep &
aOre Lar sibs gS Se at se 2 wea er Ss fe as
i PED Ve fii rt
Aye a ELD ant se i s 8
e 38 lage
WEPe sor a aid 8 Pe LES arc ea us id & ae
sy Seyf yeeME fa
8 & f BO
x kbs
LS
- gar & 8 4
eh &
tie me ef
wh ps a tr Se 8 EO p Ay
8 & a ss Sis ag
# ~. eee es sy 3 kar oP
ve Pay 3 Ww ts
LS LE ey ha
ee aft Hyat lef ds
As
= a S ie se a ©. s% a
& eb
et FQg ae wew tet 3
3. offGL
sc ik io Dp ENDEX NO. 516379/2022
OUI 3 ft
NYSCEF_ DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/06/2023
Fer oe: Sek ix rare! ey
YS S yes ATR Als ane & et y Be
\ &oar 4¥6
Sb ae 8 & & y
as ReAG te RS oH Jer ed Ley 6S & Ss
he gO se ee as
ye
eae ae ya) PR Brooklyn LLC nwa vran nwa pan gop "1 diya BRP
S278 23 poprya Va popna
2 oA wad TPos NY TIMI DATTA MVNA RIW VW INR
Tyo Dowd OwR JOIRA AN) TAI THA (PR Brooklyn LLC 1 pan qov ,21v9 Oxy) The 99 DDN 2 TY G
-$740,000.00 7W TID
1051 New York piana mbya nw ‘paynd we maw TY by pe 72 TAT RMIIWA DW RN "2 TY IY PR (2
1 py bw inn 92 Dw NW nt 92 Ave.
pra PR Brooklyn LLC (gemini 925) vain wan ’R TE wAwNa PTY 1 —pyD FW INA 92 BIW NIV Nt 72 GB
-York Ave, 1051 New
SMRDIVA ATT’PDD TROT NINY JOIN YDB ITN Mad KT ORY RI WMI II DMP? NI ‘ATE oN (4
AIT N12 TD TM? M9 Mayor My7aN TY AN Ww) DR
> lead TN! pr
44 of 61
LED WG OUN INDEX NO. 516379/2022
NYSCEF BOE. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/06/2023
Translation from the H E BRE W_ language
Givas Hamorah
Rabbinical Court
6222 23" Ave
Brooklyn, New York 11204
Tel: 718-930-4923
Fax: 718-301-1771
JUDGMENT
Mr Yitzchok Elimelech Teitelbaum and Mr Yaacov Leib Davidson of Brooklyn NY,
Party A
and Mr Yoel Perl and Mr Yosef Rubin, on their own behalf and on that of PR Brooklyn,
LLC (owner of the building at 1051 New York Ave, Brooklyn, NY), Party B
litigated before us, having [accepted our jurisdiction by] performing a full Kinyan Agav
Sudar and by signing an arbitration agreement.
After much deliberation on the facts of the matter and on the law, we have issued a
judgment as follows
1) Party B must each (Yoel Perl, Yosef Rubin, and PR Brooklyn, LLC), jointly or
severally (even personally), pay Party A the amount of $740,000.00.
2) Party B is not to take out any mortgage, and likewise Party B is not to alter or to
convey any ownership, on the building at 1051 New York Ave, so long as it has
not paid the debt from section 1
3) So long as [Party B] has not paid the entire debt from section 1, Party A is still
considered a partner (for all profits) in the asset PR Brooklyn, LLC, and in the
building at 1051 New York Ave
4) Should Party B not carry out everything written here then Party A is permitted to
collect its debt in any manner whatsoever, and to have this judgment confirmed in
the civil courts
Should either party have further claims or arguments, they shall return to litigate before
our court.
In the event that doubt arises in understanding the judgment, it shall be interpreted
according to the judges’ understanding.
To which we affix our signatures on J Adar 15, 5782, which is Feb-16-2022 on the civil
calendar.
Thus saith Mordechai Meir Tzvi Berger judge
Thus saith _Yuda Gutman judge
Thus saith _Yaacov Markowitz , judge
45 of 61
INDEX NO. 516379/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2023
EXHIBIT B
46 of 61
EIEED: KINGS
Sani CLE G/DOLs FZ ENDEX NO,d. ShO379V/2022
atk [D6]
y
NNSCEF DOC ary eC SLY ED ¥y BE/16/2023
a
i
Of
Givas Hamorah
6222.23" Ave,
Brooklyn, New York 11204
Tel: 718.930.4923
Fax: 718.301.1771 Px MII ct.
AGREEMENT TO SUBMIT TO ARBITRATION
We the undersigned hereby agree to submit to binding arbitration (individually, and on behalf of corporations,
LLCs, and all other entities involving this matter) all the controversies (claims and counter claims) between the
undersigned parties including but not limited to the following controversy:
We further agree that
the controversy be heard and determined by the three following Arbitrators,
Rabbi _ GuTwan » Rabbi EXCEL. and Rabbi ROAR OS ORT (the “Arbitrators”).
The Arbitrators may reader their award based upon Din Torah (Jewish Law), compromise, settlement, or any other
way the Arbitrators wish to reach a decision; that no transcript of the proceeding shall be made unless the Arbitrators
decides to, hire 2 stenographer or minute taker whose cost shall be paid equally by the parties; that the Arbitrators may
follow any procedure as they decide; the hearing may be held on Sundays and other legal holidays; that the award of the
Arbitrators shall be in writing and shall be signed by a majority of the Arbitrators and need not be acknowledged or
notarized to be confirmed or enforced; that the award may be served via regular mail; that in the event that one Arbitrator
resigns, or is in¢apacitated or can’t continue for any other reason, the remaining two Arbitratots may elect to continue the
proceeding and they shall have the same powers and authority
The undersigned waive all waivable rights provided under CPLR Article 74, including but not limited to formal
notice of the time and place the arbitration proceeding and consent that the Arbitrators shall have jurisdiction to render an
award based on the testimony and/or evidence presented, even without the presence of a party if the party does not attend
a scheduled hearing. In the event the undersigned or any party’ seeks-to reargue due to a claim of judicial error ot new
evidence ete, the undersigned agree that the Arbitrators shall have continuous jurisdiction over the matter, including the
authority to ‘render’s clarification or supplemental award, The Arbitrators shall not be required to explain to the
undersignéd or to anyone alse the reason for their award, and shall not be subpoenaed to testify, explain or furnish
documents relating to the award, and the award is not subject to appeal in court or any other tribunal
The undersigned agree to faithfully abide and perform any interim or final award or oral directives given by the
Arbitrators, including oral instructions to appear at adjourned or additional hearings or for production of documents. The
undersigned agree that the Arbitrators shall have ‘continuous jurisdiction over the implementation, enforcement or over
any matter arising out of or relating to an interim or final award, -incliding the Arbitrators’ authority to modify.
supplement or revise such award. In the event one party does not obey by the award and the other party seeks court
intervention or enforcement, the undersigned agree.that the disobeying party shall pay reasonable attorney fees incurred
hy such proceeding. The undersigned consent to the entry of judgment on the award. The award of the Arbitrators shall be
enforceable in the courts in the State of New York and/or New Jersey. The Arbitrators shall not be required to take an oath
or to administer an oath to any: witness or party at the hearing. The parties submit themselves to the personal jurisdiction
of the courts of the State of New York and/or New Jersey for any action or proceeding to.confirm or enforce the award of
the Arbitrators. The Parties waive personal service of process for sich confinmation or enforcement proceedings, service
thereof shall be sufficient if mailed via regular and via certified mail to the undersigned at the address set forth below.
Oa ane Dated: Vs LO 20th 44
Fsaqe “Retell bs
“pave
alee? Tak!
23 7. Hooper st HIG WiLsot STA
eg Par)
Pre Drovkly i
$f 7 fe
Hope:wy BRIG HyNy YO sky nan se #4
ME 7s
5 AB prays: vh G12 4G ESV B41 6 ahd
www. givashamprab.org
LED OU [067 ob INDEX NO. 516379/2022
NYSCEF DOC. N. as RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/06/2023
Iginica/ as \'TD-
os
hen Sy
\\ —,
OF
ov
rr s&WAG
Ey eewn! SS“\ 1
GK WH, N CT xX
FAL KA& \\ NM
\
. ( TeA \ .
\ a“ \ . . \ ©
/ . X
|\
Givas Hamorah
.Xs ws
\\\ \wsy
N \
y\ . | | .
i/ . :\
\\ \c
\N Se
\
\
XN
\\
&
LOSS a sh . .
S
ww \
\
6222-23" Ave. i/ .. \
\
\
\\
\\
<<
<<
x
\
\
:\ .
.
. o. .
<© &
i/ . \
N
Brooklyn, New York 11204 \q :.
&
.. \N .
WC .
Pel: 718.930.4923 i. sf.
<
ml \|
% / .
Fax: 718.301.1771 iMAACO
“6 QA
AWN
=
=
WW 7’
SHHMAMAGAG
AEwie
kf
AGREEMENT TO SUBMIT TO ARBITRATION
We the undersigned hereby agree to submit to binding arbitration Gndividually, and on behalf of corporations
LLCs, and all other entities involving this matter) all the controversies (claims and counter claims) between the
undersigned parties including but not limited to the following controversy:
We further agree that
the controversy be heard and determined by the three following Arbitrators
Rabbi Rabbi , and Rabbi (the “Arbitrators”)
The Arbitrators may render their a ard based upon Din Torah Jewish Law). compromise, settlement. or any other
way the Arbitrators wish to reacha decision; that no transcript of the proceeding shall be made unless the Arbitrators
decides to hire a stenographer or minute taker whose cost shall be paid equally by the parties; that the Arbitrators may
follow any procedure as they decide; the hearing may be held on Sundays and other legal holidays; that the award of the
Arbitrators shall be in writing and shall be signed by a majority of the Arbitrators and need not be acknowledged or
notarized to be confirmed or enforced: that the award may be served via regular mail; that in the event that one Arbitrator
resigns, or is incapacitated or can’t continue for any other reason, the remaining two Arbitrators may elect to continue the
proceeding and they shall have the same powers and authority
The undersigned waive all waivable rights provided under CPLR Article 75, including but not limited to formal
notice of the time and place the arbitration proceeding and consent that the Arbitrators shall have jurisdiction to render an
wward based on the testimony and/or evidence presented, even without the presence of a party if the party does not attend
a scheduled hearing. In the event the undersigned or any party secks to reargue due to a claim of judicial error or new
evidence etc., the undersigned agree that the Arbitrators shall have continuous jurisdiction over the matter, including the
authority to render a clarification or supplemental award. The Arbitrators shall not be required to explain to the
undersigned or to anyone else the reason for their award, and shall not be subpoenaed to testify, explain or furnish
documents relating to the award, and the award is not subject to appeal in court or any other tribunal
The undersigned agree to faithfully abide and perform any interim or final award or oral directives given by the
Arbitrators, including oral instructions to appear at adjourned or additional hearings or for production of documents. The
undersigned agree that the Arbitrators shall have continuous jurisdiction over the implementation, enforcement or over
any matter arising out of or relating to an interim or final award, including the Arbitrators’ authority to modify
supplement or revise such award. In the event one party does not obey by the award and the other party seeks court
intervention or enforcement, the undersigned agree that the disobeying party shall pay reasonable attorney fees incurred
by such proceeding. The undersigned consent to the entry of judgment on the award. The award of the Arbitrators shall be
enforceable in the courts in the State of New York and/or New Jersey. The Arbitrators shall not be required to take an oath
or to administer an oath to any witness or party at the hearing. The parties submit themselves to the personal jurisdiction
of the courts of the State of New York and/or New Jersey for: any action or proceeding to confirm or enforce the award of
the Arbitrators. The Parties waive personal service of process for such confirmation or enforcement proceedings, service
thereof shall be sufficient if mailed via reeular and via certified mail to the undersigned at the address set forth below
Dated 20
January 30, 2022
www.givashamorah.org
48 of 61 Scanned with CamScanner
WG INDEX NO. 516379/2022
O. a5 mail - (noSi jec RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/06/2023
7
or YS i Givas Hamorah
(no subject)
3 messages
Beth Din Sun, Jan 30, 2022 at 2:39 PM
To: yyrrealty@gmail.com, Ahron Gluck
Please respond that you authorize Ahron Gluck to represent you and your company PR Brooklyn LLC in Din Torah with
Mr Davidson and Mr Teitelbaum
Also sign and return the attachment
Thank you
8 41_(3) pn". Now.pdf
523K
Yossi Rubin Sun, Jan 30, 2022 at 2:43 PM
To: Beth Din
Cc: Ahron Gluck
Confirmed
Sent from my iPhone
On Jan 30, 2022, at 2:39 PM, Beth Din wrote:
Please respond ihai you authorize Ahron Gluck io represent you and your company PR Brooklyn LLC in
Din Torah with Mr Davicison and Mr Teitelbaum
Also sign and return the attachment
Thank you
<1_(3) jana Nwow.pdf>
Yoss Rubin Sun, Jan 30, 2022 at 2:45 PM
To: Beth Din
Cc: Ahron Gluck
See attached
Sent from my iPhone
https://mail. google. com/mail/u/1/2ik-0af9445c7d&view=pt&search=all&parnthid=thraad-a%3Ar36282500047375074398simpl=msg-a%3Ar6 20889857... 1/2
WG INDEX NO. 516379/2022
O. a5 mal nos jec RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/06/2023
in Jan 30, 2022, at 2:43 PM, Yossi Rubin wrote:
Confirmed
Sent from my iPhone
On Jan 30, 2022, at 2:39 PM, Beth Din
1051 1:2 10u.pdf
540K
https://mail. google. com/mail/u/1 /2ik-0af9445c7d&view=pt&search=all&pgrnthid=thraad-a%3Ar36282500047375074398simpl=msg-a%3Ar6 20889857... 2/2
INDEX NO. 516379/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2023
EXHIBIT C
51 of 61
TAP
rz FY CLERK
0d /06/ 23 a7 SINDEX NO. 516379/2022
RYSGEF DOE. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 14/16/2023
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
STATE OF NEW YORK )
)ss.:
COUNTY OF KINGS )
Samantha Walters, affirms the following under the penalties of perjury:
Iam over 18 years of age and am not a party to this action. J reside in the State of New York.
On May 17, 2022, I served the within
Arbitration Award
via first class mail, upon the party at the addresses set forth below:
Yoel Perl
40 Skillman Street, # 4
Brooklyn, NY 11205
PR Brooklyn, LLC
40 Skillman Street, #4
Brooklyn, NY 11205
PR Brooklyn, LLC
4019 14th Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11218
Joseph Rubin a/k/a Yosef Rubin
281 Bry Ave
Howell NJ 07731
by depositing a true copy of same to said party at the address designated by them for such
service, enclosed in a post-paid properly addressed wrapper in an official depository under the
exclusive care and custody of the United States Pgstal Service within the State of New York.
Samantha Walters
Affirmed before me this
(2 day May, 2022
DOV BER MEDINETS
Notary’Public Notary Public, State of New York
No, 02ME6220615
Qualified in Richmond County ")
Commission Expires July 09, 20 Ef
52 of 61
INDEX NO. 516379/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2023
EXHIBIT D
53 of 61
INDEX NO. 516379/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF 11/16/2023
Preview
INDEX NO. 516379/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF 11/16/2023 THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF KINGS ne eee YITZCHOK ELIMELECH TEITELBAUM a/k/a Index No. 516379/2022 ISAAC TEITELBAUM and YAACOV —_LEIB DAVIDSON a/k/a YAKOV LEIB DAVIDSOHMN, JUDGMENT Petitioners, -against- YOEL PERL, YOSEF RUBIN a/k/a JOSEPH RUBIN, and PR BROOKLYN, LLC, Respondents. wen nen n enn nnn nnn nnn, The Petition and Notice of Petition having been filed on June 7, 2022, in this action and, thereafter, the parties and their attorneys having stipulated fo certain terms and conditions (the “Stipulation of Settlement’) and Respondents having defaulted in payment under the Stipulation of Settlement, and Petitioners having moved the Court for judgment pursuant to the terms of the Supulation of Settlernent, and the Hon Leon Ruchelsman having granted Petitioners’ motion in an Oder dated August 24, 2023 and entered on September 8. 2023 Ghe “Order”), Now, upon the Petition and Notice of Petition, the Affirmation of Dov Medinets, Esq. dated May 18, 2023. the exhibits attached thereto. including the Notices of Default both dated January 9, 2023, the Stipulation of Settlement, and the Order, ADJUDGED, that Petitioners YITZCHOK ELIMELECH TEITELBAUM a/k/a ISAAC TEITELBAUM, whose address is 237 Hooper Street, Brooklyn, N.Y. 11211, and YAACOV LEIB DAVIDSON a/k/a YAKOV LEIB DAVIDSOMN, whose address is 99 Wilson Street, #4- D, Brooklyn, N.Y. 11249 have judgment against and shall recover of Respondents YOEL PERL, whose address is 40 Skillman Street, Unit 4, Brooklyn, N.Y. 11205, YOSEF RUBIN a/k/a JOSEPH RUBIN, whose address is 281 Bry Avenue, Howell, N.J. 07731, and PR 1 of 61 INDEX NO. 516379/2022 (FILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2023 11:04 AM NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2023 BROOKLYN, LLC, whose address is 40 Skillman Street, Unit 4, Brooklyn, N.Y. 11205, jointly and severally in the sum of SIX HUNDRED FORTY THOUSAND and 00/100 ($640,000.00) DOLLARS, and that Petitioners have execution therefor. Judgment signed and entered this 16th day of Nov. in the year 2023. 2023 Newey 2 Ahram. Clerk FILED 2023 NOV 16 AM 10:12 KINGS COUNTY CLERK FEE 2 of 61 ik INDEX NO. 516379/2022 LI OUI NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/06/2023 = seg ees my ge ngage Rx SUPEESE F EE, ye & y sy a8 y N i GUND i Ss x =e oe heaven a & hh Se aise sey 4 a A f AS he ee, yy aoe pees: 38 AWD RPA See PE Oh ge Se Leer se ey 2 Ss v Us Sey pe sf4G ayN ee 1 ay ky AMS PR Be TEs 5 Asks Aw 2g on eee on oe wv ow eo seiae e nei mem oe som gs ay see As oNai & x SaeARt we gx. 8 ve sep & aOre Lar sibs gS Se at se 2 wea er Ss fe as i PED Ve fii rt Aye a ELD ant se i s 8 e 38 lage WEPe sor a aid 8 Pe LES arc ea us id & ae sy Seyf yeeME fa 8 & f BO x kbs LS - gar & 8 4 eh & tie me ef wh ps a tr Se 8 EO p Ay 8 & a ss Sis ag # ~. eee es sy 3 kar oP ve Pay 3 Ww ts LS LE ey ha ee aft Hyat lef ds As = a S ie se a ©. s% a & eb et FQg ae wew tet 3 3. offGL sc ik io Dp ENDEX NO. 516379/2022 OUI 3 ft NYSCEF_ DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/06/2023 Fer oe: Sek ix rare! ey YS S yes ATR Als ane & et y Be \ &oar 4¥6 Sb ae 8 & & y as ReAG te RS oH Jer ed Ley 6S & Ss he gO se ee as ye eae ae ya) PR Brooklyn LLC nwa vran nwa pan gop "1 diya BRP S278 23 poprya Va popna 2 oA wad TPos NY TIMI DATTA MVNA RIW VW INR Tyo Dowd OwR JOIRA AN) TAI THA (PR Brooklyn LLC 1 pan qov ,21v9 Oxy) The 99 DDN 2 TY G -$740,000.00 7W TID 1051 New York piana mbya nw ‘paynd we maw TY by pe 72 TAT RMIIWA DW RN "2 TY IY PR (2 1 py bw inn 92 Dw NW nt 92 Ave. pra PR Brooklyn LLC (gemini 925) vain wan ’R TE wAwNa PTY 1 —pyD FW INA 92 BIW NIV Nt 72 GB -York Ave, 1051 New SMRDIVA ATT’PDD TROT NINY JOIN YDB ITN Mad KT ORY RI WMI II DMP? NI ‘ATE oN (4 AIT N12 TD TM? M9 Mayor My7aN TY AN Ww) DR > lead TN! pr 44 of 61 LED WG OUN INDEX NO. 516379/2022 NYSCEF BOE. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/06/2023 Translation from the H E BRE W_ language Givas Hamorah Rabbinical Court 6222 23" Ave Brooklyn, New York 11204 Tel: 718-930-4923 Fax: 718-301-1771 JUDGMENT Mr Yitzchok Elimelech Teitelbaum and Mr Yaacov Leib Davidson of Brooklyn NY, Party A and Mr Yoel Perl and Mr Yosef Rubin, on their own behalf and on that of PR Brooklyn, LLC (owner of the building at 1051 New York Ave, Brooklyn, NY), Party B litigated before us, having [accepted our jurisdiction by] performing a full Kinyan Agav Sudar and by signing an arbitration agreement. After much deliberation on the facts of the matter and on the law, we have issued a judgment as follows 1) Party B must each (Yoel Perl, Yosef Rubin, and PR Brooklyn, LLC), jointly or severally (even personally), pay Party A the amount of $740,000.00. 2) Party B is not to take out any mortgage, and likewise Party B is not to alter or to convey any ownership, on the building at 1051 New York Ave, so long as it has not paid the debt from section 1 3) So long as [Party B] has not paid the entire debt from section 1, Party A is still considered a partner (for all profits) in the asset PR Brooklyn, LLC, and in the building at 1051 New York Ave 4) Should Party B not carry out everything written here then Party A is permitted to collect its debt in any manner whatsoever, and to have this judgment confirmed in the civil courts Should either party have further claims or arguments, they shall return to litigate before our court. In the event that doubt arises in understanding the judgment, it shall be interpreted according to the judges’ understanding. To which we affix our signatures on J Adar 15, 5782, which is Feb-16-2022 on the civil calendar. Thus saith Mordechai Meir Tzvi Berger judge Thus saith _Yuda Gutman judge Thus saith _Yaacov Markowitz , judge 45 of 61 INDEX NO. 516379/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2023 EXHIBIT B 46 of 61 EIEED: KINGS Sani CLE G/DOLs FZ ENDEX NO,d. ShO379V/2022 atk [D6] y NNSCEF DOC ary eC SLY ED ¥y BE/16/2023 a i Of Givas Hamorah 6222.23" Ave, Brooklyn, New York 11204 Tel: 718.930.4923 Fax: 718.301.1771 Px MII ct. AGREEMENT TO SUBMIT TO ARBITRATION We the undersigned hereby agree to submit to binding arbitration (individually, and on behalf of corporations, LLCs, and all other entities involving this matter) all the controversies (claims and counter claims) between the undersigned parties including but not limited to the following controversy: We further agree that the controversy be heard and determined by the three following Arbitrators, Rabbi _ GuTwan » Rabbi EXCEL. and Rabbi ROAR OS ORT (the “Arbitrators”). The Arbitrators may reader their award based upon Din Torah (Jewish Law), compromise, settlement, or any other way the Arbitrators wish to reach a decision; that no transcript of the proceeding shall be made unless the Arbitrators decides to, hire 2 stenographer or minute taker whose cost shall be paid equally by the parties; that the Arbitrators may follow any procedure as they decide; the hearing may be held on Sundays and other legal holidays; that the award of the Arbitrators shall be in writing and shall be signed by a majority of the Arbitrators and need not be acknowledged or notarized to be confirmed or enforced; that the award may be served via regular mail; that in the event that one Arbitrator resigns, or is in¢apacitated or can’t continue for any other reason, the remaining two Arbitratots may elect to continue the proceeding and they shall have the same powers and authority The undersigned waive all waivable rights provided under CPLR Article 74, including but not limited to formal notice of the time and place the arbitration proceeding and consent that the Arbitrators shall have jurisdiction to render an award based on the testimony and/or evidence presented, even without the presence of a party if the party does not attend a scheduled hearing. In the event the undersigned or any party’ seeks-to reargue due to a claim of judicial error ot new evidence ete, the undersigned agree that the Arbitrators shall have continuous jurisdiction over the matter, including the authority to ‘render’s clarification or supplemental award, The Arbitrators shall not be required to explain to the undersignéd or to anyone alse the reason for their award, and shall not be subpoenaed to testify, explain or furnish documents relating to the award, and the award is not subject to appeal in court or any other tribunal The undersigned agree to faithfully abide and perform any interim or final award or oral directives given by the Arbitrators, including oral instructions to appear at adjourned or additional hearings or for production of documents. The undersigned agree that the Arbitrators shall have ‘continuous jurisdiction over the implementation, enforcement or over any matter arising out of or relating to an interim or final award, -incliding the Arbitrators’ authority to modify. supplement or revise such award. In the event one party does not obey by the award and the other party seeks court intervention or enforcement, the undersigned agree.that the disobeying party shall pay reasonable attorney fees incurred hy such proceeding. The undersigned consent to the entry of judgment on the award. The award of the Arbitrators shall be enforceable in the courts in the State of New York and/or New Jersey. The Arbitrators shall not be required to take an oath or to administer an oath to any: witness or party at the hearing. The parties submit themselves to the personal jurisdiction of the courts of the State of New York and/or New Jersey for any action or proceeding to.confirm or enforce the award of the Arbitrators. The Parties waive personal service of process for sich confinmation or enforcement proceedings, service thereof shall be sufficient if mailed via regular and via certified mail to the undersigned at the address set forth below. Oa ane Dated: Vs LO 20th 44 Fsaqe “Retell bs “pave alee? Tak! 23 7. Hooper st HIG WiLsot STA eg Par) Pre Drovkly i $f 7 fe Hope:wy BRIG HyNy YO sky nan se #4 ME 7s 5 AB prays: vh G12 4G ESV B41 6 ahd www. givashamprab.org LED OU [067 ob INDEX NO. 516379/2022 NYSCEF DOC. N. as RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/06/2023 Iginica/ as \'TD- os hen Sy \\ —, OF ov rr s&WAG Ey eewn! SS“\ 1 GK WH, N CT xX FAL KA& \\ NM \ . ( TeA \ . \ a“ \ . . \ © / . X |\ Givas Hamorah .Xs ws \\\ \wsy N \ y\ . | | . i/ . :\ \\ \c \N Se \ \ XN \\ & LOSS a sh . . S ww \ \ 6222-23" Ave. i/ .. \ \ \ \\ \\ << << x \ \ :\ . . . o. . <© & i/ . \ N Brooklyn, New York 11204 \q :. & .. \N . WC . Pel: 718.930.4923 i. sf. < ml \| % / . Fax: 718.301.1771 iMAACO “6 QA AWN = = WW 7’ SHHMAMAGAG AEwie kf AGREEMENT TO SUBMIT TO ARBITRATION We the undersigned hereby agree to submit to binding arbitration Gndividually, and on behalf of corporations LLCs, and all other entities involving this matter) all the controversies (claims and counter claims) between the undersigned parties including but not limited to the following controversy: We further agree that the controversy be heard and determined by the three following Arbitrators Rabbi Rabbi , and Rabbi (the “Arbitrators”) The Arbitrators may render their a ard based upon Din Torah Jewish Law). compromise, settlement. or any other way the Arbitrators wish to reacha decision; that no transcript of the proceeding shall be made unless the Arbitrators decides to hire a stenographer or minute taker whose cost shall be paid equally by the parties; that the Arbitrators may follow any procedure as they decide; the hearing may be held on Sundays and other legal holidays; that the award of the Arbitrators shall be in writing and shall be signed by a majority of the Arbitrators and need not be acknowledged or notarized to be confirmed or enforced: that the award may be served via regular mail; that in the event that one Arbitrator resigns, or is incapacitated or can’t continue for any other reason, the remaining two Arbitrators may elect to continue the proceeding and they shall have the same powers and authority The undersigned waive all waivable rights provided under CPLR Article 75, including but not limited to formal notice of the time and place the arbitration proceeding and consent that the Arbitrators shall have jurisdiction to render an wward based on the testimony and/or evidence presented, even without the presence of a party if the party does not attend a scheduled hearing. In the event the undersigned or any party secks to reargue due to a claim of judicial error or new evidence etc., the undersigned agree that the Arbitrators shall have continuous jurisdiction over the matter, including the authority to render a clarification or supplemental award. The Arbitrators shall not be required to explain to the undersigned or to anyone else the reason for their award, and shall not be subpoenaed to testify, explain or furnish documents relating to the award, and the award is not subject to appeal in court or any other tribunal The undersigned agree to faithfully abide and perform any interim or final award or oral directives given by the Arbitrators, including oral instructions to appear at adjourned or additional hearings or for production of documents. The undersigned agree that the Arbitrators shall have continuous jurisdiction over the implementation, enforcement or over any matter arising out of or relating to an interim or final award, including the Arbitrators’ authority to modify supplement or revise such award. In the event one party does not obey by the award and the other party seeks court intervention or enforcement, the undersigned agree that the disobeying party shall pay reasonable attorney fees incurred by such proceeding. The undersigned consent to the entry of judgment on the award. The award of the Arbitrators shall be enforceable in the courts in the State of New York and/or New Jersey. The Arbitrators shall not be required to take an oath or to administer an oath to any witness or party at the hearing. The parties submit themselves to the personal jurisdiction of the courts of the State of New York and/or New Jersey for: any action or proceeding to confirm or enforce the award of the Arbitrators. The Parties waive personal service of process for such confirmation or enforcement proceedings, service thereof shall be sufficient if mailed via reeular and via certified mail to the undersigned at the address set forth below Dated 20 January 30, 2022 www.givashamorah.org 48 of 61 Scanned with CamScanner WG INDEX NO. 516379/2022 O. a5 mail - (noSi jec RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/06/2023 7 or YS i Givas Hamorah (no subject) 3 messages Beth Din Sun, Jan 30, 2022 at 2:39 PM To: yyrrealty@gmail.com, Ahron Gluck Please respond that you authorize Ahron Gluck to represent you and your company PR Brooklyn LLC in Din Torah with Mr Davidson and Mr Teitelbaum Also sign and return the attachment Thank you 8 41_(3) pn". Now.pdf 523K Yossi Rubin Sun, Jan 30, 2022 at 2:43 PM To: Beth Din Cc: Ahron Gluck Confirmed Sent from my iPhone On Jan 30, 2022, at 2:39 PM, Beth Din wrote: Please respond ihai you authorize Ahron Gluck io represent you and your company PR Brooklyn LLC in Din Torah with Mr Davicison and Mr Teitelbaum Also sign and return the attachment Thank you <1_(3) jana Nwow.pdf> Yoss Rubin Sun, Jan 30, 2022 at 2:45 PM To: Beth Din Cc: Ahron Gluck See attached Sent from my iPhone https://mail. google. com/mail/u/1/2ik-0af9445c7d&view=pt&search=all&parnthid=thraad-a%3Ar36282500047375074398simpl=msg-a%3Ar6 20889857... 1/2 WG INDEX NO. 516379/2022 O. a5 mal nos jec RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/06/2023 in Jan 30, 2022, at 2:43 PM, Yossi Rubin wrote: Confirmed Sent from my iPhone On Jan 30, 2022, at 2:39 PM, Beth Din 1051 1:2 10u.pdf 540K https://mail. google. com/mail/u/1 /2ik-0af9445c7d&view=pt&search=all&pgrnthid=thraad-a%3Ar36282500047375074398simpl=msg-a%3Ar6 20889857... 2/2 INDEX NO. 516379/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2023 EXHIBIT C 51 of 61 TAP rz FY CLERK 0d /06/ 23 a7 SINDEX NO. 516379/2022 RYSGEF DOE. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 14/16/2023 AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE STATE OF NEW YORK ) )ss.: COUNTY OF KINGS ) Samantha Walters, affirms the following under the penalties of perjury: Iam over 18 years of age and am not a party to this action. J reside in the State of New York. On May 17, 2022, I served the within Arbitration Award via first class mail, upon the party at the addresses set forth below: Yoel Perl 40 Skillman Street, # 4 Brooklyn, NY 11205 PR Brooklyn, LLC 40 Skillman Street, #4 Brooklyn, NY 11205 PR Brooklyn, LLC 4019 14th Avenue Brooklyn, NY 11218 Joseph Rubin a/k/a Yosef Rubin 281 Bry Ave Howell NJ 07731 by depositing a true copy of same to said party at the address designated by them for such service, enclosed in a post-paid properly addressed wrapper in an official depository under the exclusive care and custody of the United States Pgstal Service within the State of New York. Samantha Walters Affirmed before me this (2 day May, 2022 DOV BER MEDINETS Notary’Public Notary Public, State of New York No, 02ME6220615 Qualified in Richmond County ") Commission Expires July 09, 20 Ef 52 of 61 INDEX NO. 516379/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2023 EXHIBIT D 53 of 61 INDEX NO. 516379/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 25 RECEIVED NYSCEF 11/16/2023