On January 05, 2023 a
Exhibit,Appendix
was filed
involving a dispute between
Dan Albasry
As Trustee Of The Estate Of Newal Al Saad,
Firas Mohammad,
and
Barretts Minerals Inc.,
Beacon Cmp Corp.,
Brenntag Specialties Llc,
Charles B. Chrystal Company Inc.;,
Colgate Palmolive Co.;,
Conopco Inc.,
Glaxosmithkline Consumer Healthcare Holdings,
Glaxosmithkline Llc,
Gsk Consumer Health Inc.,
Lornamead Inc.,
Pfizer Inc.,
Port Jervis Laboratories Inc.,
The Procter & Gamble Co.,
Whittaker, Clark & Daniels Inc.,
Yardley Of London Inc.,
Yardley Of London Ltd.,,
for Torts - Asbestos
in the District Court of New York County.
Preview
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 07/10/2023 10:29 PM INDEX NO. 190002/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 99 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/10/2023
EXHIBIT 14
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 07/10/2023 10:29 PM INDEX NO. 190002/2023
03/19/2002 19:04 9088741209 CPWW SKIN RESEARCH PAGE 04
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 99 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/10/2023
i
~aterial Specification
Company:
i\
o Johnson & Johnson Consumer Pro{~ucts Co. Johnson & Johnson Products Inc.
o Personal Products Company (
§ Consumer Produces Worldwide
Personal ProduCts Worldwide
Location: ROYSTON, KOLMAR,
Document No.: RM08006 Franchise:Adult/Kids/Baby SILLIKER (N])
Document Type: Pennanent Expiration Date: None
Subject: LUZENAC AMElUCA. IN¢.• WINDSOR GRADE 66 and 96 TALC
i
I
I
REVISION AUlHORIZATION ; DESCRIPTION
03/09/00 CR217132 Sec. 5.0, removed Hammondsville Mine as an: approved mine.
(M. Underwood) (706-245.2078)
11/15/01 C1U35713 Entire document revised to reflect the addition of a new grade from same
source ore body, a new trade name and reflect current industry standards for
the analysis of talc. Sec. 1.0 reworded. Sec. 2.1, changed from CIFA to TM.
Sec. 2.2 deleted asbestos, added micro. Sec. 3.0, itemized Certificates of
Analysis. Former Sec. 3.1 now Sec. 3.1.6. Sec. 3.2, Solubility by Acid,
TM7165 deleted, replaced with Sec. 3.1.5, Acid Soluble Substances, USP.
Former Sec. 3.3, Magnesite deleted. Sec. 3.4 now 3.1.1. Sec. 3.5 now 3.1.3.
Sec. 3.6 now Sec. 3.1.2. Sec. 3.7 now 3.1.10. Sec.3.8 now 3.1.9. Sec. 3.9
nOW 3.1.8. Sec. 3.10 now 3.1.11. Sec. 3.1.1, from TM to Luzenac method;
lower limit from 20.5 to 24.5 .. Sec. 3.1.3, deleted TM numbers; limit from
84.5% to 82%. Sec 3.1.4, added Loss on Ignition USP. Sec. 3.1.5 added
USP test. Sec. 3.1.6, from TM7164 to STM04. Sec 3.1.7, new test from
USP. Sec. 3.1.8, added JP. Sec. 3.1.9. deleted TM's, added USP; limit from
2.5 to 3ppm. Sec. 3.1.10, from TM's to USP; limit from lOppm to 0.04%.
Sec. 3.1.11, added USP. Former Sec. 3.12, rearranged order. Section 3.2,
new section. Sec. 3.2.land 3.2.2 formerly Sec. 2.2. Sec. 3.3 formerly
Sec.7.0 part LB. Sec. 3. 4 is a new section. Section 3.5 is a new section.
Sec. 4.0, new fonnat. Sec. 5.0 was formerly 6.0. Sect. 7.0, new section.
Former Sec. 7.0 is now Sec. 9. Sec. 9.1, new format; added "lA". Sec. 9.2
added a new trade name. Sec. 9.3.1, rearranged order. Sec. 9.4 , rearranged
order, Sec. 9.4.2 from CTFA to TM726 1. Sec. 9.4.3 was Sec. 7.0. Sec.
9.4.3, most methodS and frequencies changed. Sec. "Composite
Identification" is ncW. Added notes to Old Lot, Retest and STP. (1. Payeur)
(908-874-1441)
Header updated to reflect current format. (Spec. Dept.)
Issue Date: November 15, 2001 Released by: R. Bacorn Page 1 ofll
Protected Document--Subject to Protective Order
J NJ MX68_000000860
FILED:~3/19/2002
NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 07/10/2023 10:29 PM INDEX NO. 190002/2023
19:04 9088741209 CPWW SKIN RESEARCH PAGE 05
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 99 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/10/2023
Material Specification
I
Company: !
D Johnson. & Johnson Consumer Prodtlccs Co.
D Personal Products Company § Johnson & Johnson Products Inc,
Consumer Products Worldwide
Personal Products Worldwide
Location: ROYSTON, KOLMAR,
Document No.: RM08006 i Franchise:AdultiKidslBaby SILLIKER (NJ)
Document Type: Pennanent Expiration Date: None
Subject: LUZENAC AMERICA, INC., WINDSOR GRADE 66 and 96 TALC
1.0 DESCRIPTION
Hydrous magnesium silicate; alsi> called magnesium acid metasilicate, Mg 3 Si4 0,o(OH)2' A flne white
lustrous powder, slippery, adher~s to skin, with no foreign odor or grittiness.
2.0 PROPERTIES & REOUIREMENIS
2.1 Infrared Identification (IM7261)
The infrared spectrum of the sample should exhibit absorption bands of the same pattern and
placement as those exwbited by the standard, with no extraneous bands present, as determined by
a qualified analyst. '
2.2 Microbial Limits (TM7807 and Current USP)
Samples s11all contain no detectable objectionable microorganisms and the total count shall be no
greater than 50 microorganisms per gram of product.
3.0 CERTIFICATE OF ANALYSIS
3.1 A Certificate of Analysis labeled "~" (IA) will accompany each batch and provide
numerical analytical results for items 3.1.1 through 3.1.7 below; Sec's. 3.1.8 through 3.1.11 below
will be reported as pasS, or fail. The certificate shall include silo number, batch number, date
assayed, date silo cleared, and the railcar or trailer number (if a trailer is used to ship directly to
Royston) or lot numbe~ of bags. Receipt of Certificate of Analysis is an accepth:eject criterion.
3.1.1 Bulk Densiey (Luzenac Method STM12)
24.5 to 25.5 Ib..lcu. ft. for silo composite.
3.1.2 Fineness (Luzjmac Method STM03)
Through 60 n1esh (250 micron), 100%.
Tluough 100 mesh (150 micron), 99.7% minimum.
Through 200 mesh (75 micron), 98.5% minimum.
3.1.3 Color, Minolta 'Y' (Luzenac Method STM76)
A minimum of 82 % reflectance
3.1.4 Loss on Ignition (Current USP)
Not more thal'l 6.5%
Issue Date: November 15, 2001 Released by: R. Bacom Page 2 of 11
Protected Document··Subject to Protective Order J NJ MX68_000000861
F
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 07/10/2023 10:29 PM INDEX NO. 190002/2023
NYSCEF 03/19/2002
DOC. NO. 9919:04 9088741209 CPWW SKIN RESEARCH PAGE 0607/10/2023
RECEIVED NYSCEF:
Material Specification
Company:
D Johnsoll & Johnson Consumer Produ~ts Co. Johnson & Johnson Produces Inc.
D Personal Products Company :
§ Consumer Products Worldwide
Personal Products Worldwide
Location: ROYSTON, KOLMAR,
Document No.: RM08006 franchise:AdulrJKidslBaby SILLIKER (NJ)
Document Type: Pennanent E3:pjration Date: None
Subject: LUZENAC AMERICA, INC., WINDSOR
I
GRADE 66 and 96 TALC
i
3.1,5 Acid-soluble suhstances (Purity) (Current USP or JP)
I
i
Not more than 2l0%
;
3.1.6 Moisture (STMQ4)
;
NMTO.15% i
!
3.1.7 Reaction and Soluble Substances (Current USP or JP)
Not more than 0:.1 %
i
3.1.8 Water-soluble J~en (Current USP or JP)
Pass Test
3.1.9 Arsenic (Cune~t USP)
Limit is 3 ppm :
I
3.1.1 0 Heavy Metals (
Preview
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 07/10/2023 10:29 PM INDEX NO. 190002/2023 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 99 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/10/2023 EXHIBIT 14 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 07/10/2023 10:29 PM INDEX NO. 190002/2023 03/19/2002 19:04 9088741209 CPWW SKIN RESEARCH PAGE 04 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 99 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/10/2023 i ~aterial Specification Company: i\ o Johnson & Johnson Consumer Pro{~ucts Co. Johnson & Johnson Products Inc. o Personal Products Company ( § Consumer Produces Worldwide Personal ProduCts Worldwide Location: ROYSTON, KOLMAR, Document No.: RM08006 Franchise:Adult/Kids/Baby SILLIKER (N]) Document Type: Pennanent Expiration Date: None Subject: LUZENAC AMElUCA. IN¢.• WINDSOR GRADE 66 and 96 TALC i I I REVISION AUlHORIZATION ; DESCRIPTION 03/09/00 CR217132 Sec. 5.0, removed Hammondsville Mine as an: approved mine. (M. Underwood) (706-245.2078) 11/15/01 C1U35713 Entire document revised to reflect the addition of a new grade from same source ore body, a new trade name and reflect current industry standards for the analysis of talc. Sec. 1.0 reworded. Sec. 2.1, changed from CIFA to TM. Sec. 2.2 deleted asbestos, added micro. Sec. 3.0, itemized Certificates of Analysis. Former Sec. 3.1 now Sec. 3.1.6. Sec. 3.2, Solubility by Acid, TM7165 deleted, replaced with Sec. 3.1.5, Acid Soluble Substances, USP. Former Sec. 3.3, Magnesite deleted. Sec. 3.4 now 3.1.1. Sec. 3.5 now 3.1.3. Sec. 3.6 now Sec. 3.1.2. Sec. 3.7 now 3.1.10. Sec.3.8 now 3.1.9. Sec. 3.9 nOW 3.1.8. Sec. 3.10 now 3.1.11. Sec. 3.1.1, from TM to Luzenac method; lower limit from 20.5 to 24.5 .. Sec. 3.1.3, deleted TM numbers; limit from 84.5% to 82%. Sec 3.1.4, added Loss on Ignition USP. Sec. 3.1.5 added USP test. Sec. 3.1.6, from TM7164 to STM04. Sec 3.1.7, new test from USP. Sec. 3.1.8, added JP. Sec. 3.1.9. deleted TM's, added USP; limit from 2.5 to 3ppm. Sec. 3.1.10, from TM's to USP; limit from lOppm to 0.04%. Sec. 3.1.11, added USP. Former Sec. 3.12, rearranged order. Section 3.2, new section. Sec. 3.2.land 3.2.2 formerly Sec. 2.2. Sec. 3.3 formerly Sec.7.0 part LB. Sec. 3. 4 is a new section. Section 3.5 is a new section. Sec. 4.0, new fonnat. Sec. 5.0 was formerly 6.0. Sect. 7.0, new section. Former Sec. 7.0 is now Sec. 9. Sec. 9.1, new format; added "lA". Sec. 9.2 added a new trade name. Sec. 9.3.1, rearranged order. Sec. 9.4 , rearranged order, Sec. 9.4.2 from CTFA to TM726 1. Sec. 9.4.3 was Sec. 7.0. Sec. 9.4.3, most methodS and frequencies changed. Sec. "Composite Identification" is ncW. Added notes to Old Lot, Retest and STP. (1. Payeur) (908-874-1441) Header updated to reflect current format. (Spec. Dept.) Issue Date: November 15, 2001 Released by: R. Bacorn Page 1 ofll Protected Document--Subject to Protective Order J NJ MX68_000000860 FILED:~3/19/2002 NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 07/10/2023 10:29 PM INDEX NO. 190002/2023 19:04 9088741209 CPWW SKIN RESEARCH PAGE 05 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 99 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/10/2023 Material Specification I Company: ! D Johnson. & Johnson Consumer Prodtlccs Co. D Personal Products Company § Johnson & Johnson Products Inc, Consumer Products Worldwide Personal Products Worldwide Location: ROYSTON, KOLMAR, Document No.: RM08006 i Franchise:AdultiKidslBaby SILLIKER (NJ) Document Type: Pennanent Expiration Date: None Subject: LUZENAC AMERICA, INC., WINDSOR GRADE 66 and 96 TALC 1.0 DESCRIPTION Hydrous magnesium silicate; alsi> called magnesium acid metasilicate, Mg 3 Si4 0,o(OH)2' A flne white lustrous powder, slippery, adher~s to skin, with no foreign odor or grittiness. 2.0 PROPERTIES & REOUIREMENIS 2.1 Infrared Identification (IM7261) The infrared spectrum of the sample should exhibit absorption bands of the same pattern and placement as those exwbited by the standard, with no extraneous bands present, as determined by a qualified analyst. ' 2.2 Microbial Limits (TM7807 and Current USP) Samples s11all contain no detectable objectionable microorganisms and the total count shall be no greater than 50 microorganisms per gram of product. 3.0 CERTIFICATE OF ANALYSIS 3.1 A Certificate of Analysis labeled "~" (IA) will accompany each batch and provide numerical analytical results for items 3.1.1 through 3.1.7 below; Sec's. 3.1.8 through 3.1.11 below will be reported as pasS, or fail. The certificate shall include silo number, batch number, date assayed, date silo cleared, and the railcar or trailer number (if a trailer is used to ship directly to Royston) or lot numbe~ of bags. Receipt of Certificate of Analysis is an accepth:eject criterion. 3.1.1 Bulk Densiey (Luzenac Method STM12) 24.5 to 25.5 Ib..lcu. ft. for silo composite. 3.1.2 Fineness (Luzjmac Method STM03) Through 60 n1esh (250 micron), 100%. Tluough 100 mesh (150 micron), 99.7% minimum. Through 200 mesh (75 micron), 98.5% minimum. 3.1.3 Color, Minolta 'Y' (Luzenac Method STM76) A minimum of 82 % reflectance 3.1.4 Loss on Ignition (Current USP) Not more thal'l 6.5% Issue Date: November 15, 2001 Released by: R. Bacom Page 2 of 11 Protected Document··Subject to Protective Order J NJ MX68_000000861 F FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 07/10/2023 10:29 PM INDEX NO. 190002/2023 NYSCEF 03/19/2002 DOC. NO. 9919:04 9088741209 CPWW SKIN RESEARCH PAGE 0607/10/2023 RECEIVED NYSCEF: Material Specification Company: D Johnsoll & Johnson Consumer Produ~ts Co. Johnson & Johnson Produces Inc. D Personal Products Company : § Consumer Products Worldwide Personal Products Worldwide Location: ROYSTON, KOLMAR, Document No.: RM08006 franchise:AdulrJKidslBaby SILLIKER (NJ) Document Type: Pennanent E3:pjration Date: None Subject: LUZENAC AMERICA, INC., WINDSOR I GRADE 66 and 96 TALC i 3.1,5 Acid-soluble suhstances (Purity) (Current USP or JP) I i Not more than 2l0% ; 3.1.6 Moisture (STMQ4) ; NMTO.15% i ! 3.1.7 Reaction and Soluble Substances (Current USP or JP) Not more than 0:.1 % i 3.1.8 Water-soluble J~en (Current USP or JP) Pass Test 3.1.9 Arsenic (Cune~t USP) Limit is 3 ppm : I 3.1.1 0 Heavy Metals (